_01162019-418
Town of Mount Pleasant · Charleston County · meeting of Jan 16, 2019 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Mount Pleasant
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
TOWN OF MOUNT PLEASANT, SOUTH CAROLINA
SHEM CREEK STUDY ADVISORY COMMITTEE
Wednesday, January 16, 2019
Mount Pleasant Town Hall, Police Training Room
100 Ann Edwards Lane, Mount Pleasant, SC 29464
Minutes
Present: Bubba Simmons; Grace Edwards; Brett Bennett; Miles
Martschink; Olivia Flynn; Elizabeth Anderegg; Billy Barnwell;
Cheryll Woods-Flowers arrived at 9:05 a.m.
Absent: Randy Friedman
Consultants: Tom Robertson; Matt Randall; Jim Hartling; Jonathan Lane
Staff: Lauren Sims; Michele Canon
Ms. Sims called the meeting to order at 9:03 a.m. and thanked everyone for
attending. She said the consulting team sent a report to everyone, and they
would be giving a condensed version of the report at the meeting today.
1. Public Comments
There were no public comments.
2. Review of Study Schedule & Progress
Mr. Robertson thanked everyone for attending and reviewed the process.
They are in the baseline data and inventory phase, and that will be
followed by brainstorming opportunities for the future, and that will fold
into alternatives which will occur in the March/April timeframe. The
alternatives phase will be distilled into a plan that will be in draft form by
May or June, with the completed plan presented to Council in July. (Ms.
Woods-Flowers entered at 9:05 a.m.)
Page 2 of 45
A) Review Approach
Mr. Robertson said the report is entitled Inventory and Baseline Data,
which is a summary of findings up until the week prior to this meeting.
He asked the committee to please bring to their attention any errors
they found, and input on opportunities for the next phase will be
requested at the end of the meeting.
Page 3 of 45
3. Update of Mission, Study Elements & Draft Goals
Mr. Robertson reviewed the mission which is to “Preserve, promote, and
protect the unique history, nature, and economy of the Shem Creek
Study Area and maintain the character of its working creek.”
Mr. Bennett suggested changing the wording to read “character of it as a
working creek.” Mr. Robertson agreed.
A) Consultant Team Suggested updates
Page 4 of 45
Mr. Robertson said Mr. Lane would review the changes to the study
elements.
Mr. Lane said there were initially six study elements and as he was
focusing on two of them, it occurred to him that it may be simpler to
combine them. One addressed pedestrian and amenities and one
addressed visual character. Mr. Lane said those were combined to a
single element, and he would explain in more detail later in the
presentation. Mr. Lane said that as Mr. Hartling was working on the
Private Use and Development aspect, he made a slight modification of
that goal.
Mr. Lane said that for each element, the baseline data, issues,
opportunities, choices, and recommendations would be reviewed.
Mr. Lane encouraged the Committee Members to delve into the
report and give feedback. He said in the first phase, baseline data and
issues were evaluated. Opportunities were looked at but not dealt
with. He said their team’s thoughts and the issues about each of the
study elements would be reviewed. Opportunities would be discussed
at the end of the presentation. Mr. Lane said that Mr. Hartling would
start with Private Use and Development.
Mr. Hartling said that when he looked at the goal with Economic
Development in mind, it was a little too restricting and not quite as
pro-business as he liked to find, so he suggested modifying the goal to
what is listed in the slide below.
Page 5 of 45
Mr. Hartling said the words in italics are the suggested modification.
Mr. Hartling said he spent time trying to figure out what the
businesses are and reaching out for conversations. In the report that
was sent, on page 5, the team made an effort to tally what we see.
Mr. Hartling said the hardest part was trying to figure out how many
shrimp and fishing boats are working the Creek. He said there are at
least 11 or 12 working boats, maybe more. Clearly some of them have
related retail or wholesale seafood operations on the dock. Mr.
Hartling found four water related recreation businesses that had a
physical location, but heard reports of people showing up in vehicles
and leasing kayaks to people in the parking lot. He said there are
three boat landings, storage operations that are private, and sixteen
restaurants that generate a significant amount of the parking. There is
one lodging facility, a retail shopping center, a mixed use complex, ten
freestanding retailers, six multi-tenant office centers of various scales,
thirteen freestanding offices mostly in converted houses, and six other
miscellaneous businesses. Mr. Hartling said there is a broad array of
uses, and that does not include residential. Mr. Hartling said with
respect to the seafood operation, there was a particular study done
Page 6 of 45
about Mount Pleasant about a decade ago, and we tried to see how
things have changed. He said the conclusions are that the seafood
industry is under a tremendous amount of regulatory, international
competition, capital investment and infrastructure issues, but the
residual fleet that is maintained here by and large have figured out
how to bypass those problems. One way is branding local seafood and
selling that concept in restaurants and markets. Second is developing
distribution mechanisms such as selling at markets and distribution at
restaurants. The smaller people use cell phones to text to develop
individual distribution of the shrimp. The shrimping and fishing
industry has almost developed into a boutique industry, and is
sustainable for those that have managed to maneuver the mechanism.
Mr. Hartling said for the next 10-15 years you can still have a fleet of
the same size.
Page 7 of 45
There are some key issues here, and the three big ones were dock
space, ice and fuel. He said the fuel has been resolved, so the real
issues are dock space and ice. Mr. Hartling said he suspects as we
continue through this process a lot of what we will be dealing with is
where do we maintain dock space for the fleet, and how do we do
that. He said the ice issue seems to be getting resolved by groups of
anywhere from 1-3 working together on one dock, two-ton ice
machines. We may need to find a place to put four to six ice machines
to meet the needs.
Page 8 of 45
Mr. Hartling said he wanted to discuss the commercial space which is
packed and valuable and the one area that is clearly in transition is the
northeast triangle. He said he observed that a number of lots in the
last few years that have sold, and the price of those is now in the
range of $2M an acre. A house sold there, with a half acre lot, for
$900,000. The house is not worth that, it is the lot that is driving up
the price. Restaurant properties are extremely valuable, residential
large homes with a view are extremely valuable and the general
conclusion is that there is a lot of strong office market. There is strong
economic position with the restaurants, offices, residential and
parking right now. With regard to residential, there were 34 sales of
28 different homes in the last two years, out of the 71 homes that are
in this area. Prices have gone up to over $500 a square foot in the last
four years, for both homes with water and marsh views and homes
that don’t. Mr. Hartling said that the main difference is that if you
have a marsh view, you build a bigger home, and some prices are over
$2M. The residential values are quite high.
Page 9 of 45
Mr. Hartling said there are three possible futures. One is survival. Two
is modified stability which is you are able to maintain all the dock
space that is there now, including the ones that are being repaired,
and slightly increase the fleet. The third is diversification and growth.
Right now the fish has to be sold wholesale because there are no
processing facilities on the dock, so add some processing facilities, and
one suggestion was to find the equivalent of a farmers market for
seafood only for the fleet. And possibly a retail presence of product
coming from the fleet plus some storage facilities and processing
facilities.
Page 10 of 45
Mr. Hartling said there is a group called the Association of Working
Waterfronts, and they looked through that and found three
waterfronts that had some relationship to Shem Creek. One is Port
Solerno in Florida, another is Portland, Maine, and the other is
Gloucester, Massachusetts. The things that came out of their lessons
are: One is to provide dock space for the fleet at economical
sustainable rates. The second is to provide industry specific
infrastructure. Mr. Hartling said others are to celebrate the maritime
history, to make sure there is public access to the waterfront and have
zoning that maintains the waterfront character and minimizes
incompatible development. He stated those are the lessons learned
from other places and they seem very similar to the issues Shem Creek
is facing.
Page 11 of 45
Mr. Hartling reviewed the issues and directions from the Community
Development side as opposed to the maritime side. He said it is not
necessary to stimulate the market as there is plenty of demand, but
there are two places that are really susceptible to change right now.
One is the Wando Dock, and the other is the Northeast Triangle
sector. There needs to be more intense focus on how that should
evolve and what kind of controls there are. He stated Mr. Lane would
review that further.
Mr. Barnwell asked about the canal picture. Mr. Hartling said that is
downtown Portland Maine, and they have big seafood operations
running the docks downtown. Mr. Lane said there is a difference in
Portland and Gloucester, there are intensive harbors with many ins
and outs.
Mr. Hartling said the crucial issue with this is where they allowed that
development did not impact the operation. They restricted it, and they
figured out how they were going to park those people so they would
not impact the water and seafood restaurants.
Page 12 of 45
Mr. Robertson said that although those are condominiums, the key is
they are set right on the edge of the water, similar to what Shem
Creek has with the commercial restaurants.
Ms. Sims said if the Committee wants to read about these specific
areas, she gave everyone a packet when they were working as the
Shem Creek Task Force with several case studies of working
waterfronts. She said Port Solerno and Portland, Maine were both in
there.
Ms. Anderegg asked if those areas had to address FEMA and OCRM
codes as they look like they are right up on the water and are on
ground level.
Mr. Hartling said he was not sure at this location, but a lot of it has to
do with the nature of the flood plains in this business and if you have
short cliffs and the flood plain does not run very far – there are no
marshes in Portland.
Mr. Hartling said yes, but they are dealing with different physical
attributes. Mr. Randall said FEMA is federal so everyone must deal
with it.
Mr. Robertson said the coastal zone management is a blanket that is
then carried out by the states in different ways.
Mr. Hartling said there are huge differences if you are on a sharp
embankment versus marsh.
Page 13 of 45
Mr. Robertson said he would be speaking about the creek itself and
reviewed the goal (see slide above).
Page 14 of 45
Mr. Robertson said the above map shows the study area and shows
the buildings along either side. The Creek is lined with waterfront
uses, and they can be classified in two ways. Ones that are water-
dependent, and ones that may be water-related uses. The red is
residential, the blue represents the commercial. There is an activity
zone cluster which does attract a lot of traffic for various reasons. The
Creek functions as a harbor, and that mainly occurs on the commercial
areas, but it does to some degree spill over to the other types of docks
there. You can think of it as a road with many origins and destinations
where people come and go. Mr. Robertson said he was surprised to
find that upstream of the study area there are 59 docks, and those
people have to have a way to get their boats in and out. They likely
launch at the Harry Hallman boat ramp which is quite a busy spot, and
is probably self-limiting because of the queues of boats getting out on
the land side as well as water during the busy times. There is also the
issue of limited parking. Mr. Robertson said there are people that
come to Shem Creek by water to the entertainment district, there are
also people that go out to fish or just out for a boat ride. It is a very
busy spot and that creates traffic. Mr. Robertson said the heavy
stippling on the map was a heavily concentrated area of boats, which
is a major point of conflict. Mr. Robertson also pointed out the fuel
dock, and the shrimping fleet is mostly on the other side, and they
must cross over the boat traffic to get their fuel. Mr. Robertson said
there is also the recreational use of the Creek where people use non-
motorized boats of their own, and also rental facilities. He said those
folks are not typically as experienced with maneuvering boats, or
maritime rules. Mr. Robertson said the Police Department says they
have control of the traffic there and they pretty much do not have any
problems.
Mr. Martschink asked about the portion of the map that was not filled
in and Mr. Robertson said that is a restaurant, and the others are
water-dependent uses. There are the remnants of a commercial dock
there and that is a possibility for expansion in case the Wando Docks
would go away.
Page 15 of 45
There was discussion about the owner of The Wreck recently passing
away and who owned the property.
Mr. Hartling said presumably the people who are operating the
restaurant are operating under a lease, the question is how long is
that lease. Mr. Robertson said the team could look into that a little
further.
Mr. Robertson said looking forward the issues for the fleet would be
commercial dock space. The reason the channel remains dredged is
because of the commercial fleet, so if the fleet goes away, the benefit
of the dredging would go away as well.
Ms. Anderegg said going back to the previous slide, where The
Boatyard is, there is outlined private dock land, but some of that
private dock space is on Town of Mount Pleasant property, and asked
if that had been addressed. Mr. Robertson said they know that it is,
because there is a little strip of land that belongs to the Town, and it is
uncertain how those people have docks going across that piece of
Page 16 of 45
land. Ms. Anderegg said it could be that the dock space is not
legitimately private.
Mr. Randall said he believes the only area in question may be a small
piece that extends beyond the right of way in between the waterway
and (inaudible).
Ms. Woods-Flowers said that was granted when the residential
development was granted zoning where it was maritime uses, and
that was something the Town required that right of way to remain, for
that zoning change, back in the 1980s.
Mr. Robertson said the importance of the fleet had just begun. The
visual idea of the fleet being there and the business that it brings to
the creek and it also makes it eligible for dredging and it is a lot easier
to permit that with funding. If the fleet goes away it will be difficult to
keep that channel dredged. Mr. Robertson said keeping it dredged
keeps it available as a harbor. Boat traffic conflicts need to be looked
at because some of the four and five deep rafting that occurs along
the restaurants do impinge on the dredged area and the width of the
channel, which puts the boats going through in a smaller area. Mr.
Robertson said future boat access is a concern as well because the
Hallman Boat Landing is very convenient and there is not another
nearby public landing. Perhaps a new boat landing could be
considered, not in the study area, but it might help with the
congestion.
Mr. Martschink asked if the consultants, when thinking about adding
another boat ramp somewhere, had considered the creek full. On the
weekends it is hard to get through there. That may be something that
needs to be addressed – how many boats can you handle at Shem
Creek Landing, and should they be able to raft up five boats across.
Mr. Robertson said that is something that needs to be looked at, and it
is a major issue. If you have the impinging of the area by parking on
the side, maybe there needs to be some regulations about how deep
you can park and how much narrowing can actually occur.
Page 17 of 45
Ms. Anderegg said the Shem Creek Boat Landing is self-limiting
because of parking and because people have to wait. She said people
are putting in at Remley’s Point, Folly Beach, James Island and coming
across the harbor to be in Shem Creek, and then you think of all of the
boat slips up the creek, they all come to the Creek to party, to go out
and fish. Limiting that little space at Shem Creek Boat Landing may
sound like a great idea, but you may not actually be limiting anything.
You may be limiting what is already self-limiting. We need to look at
the bigger picture when talking about boat traffic because it is a
destination for every watercraft. She said the only thing that we do
not have are jet skis.
Mr. Robertson said there are quite a population of dry stacks as well.
Mr. Barnwell said DNR calls for a private dock not to extend more than
25% into the creek because it is a navigational hazard, so from both
sides that would be 50%. He asked if there is any way the Town of
Mount Pleasant has the ability to regulate that or would it have to go
through DNR.
Mr. Randall said when he spoke to the Police Department they said
they have jurisdiction and it has to be navigable, but no specific
dimensions.
Mr. Barnwell said they are fighting oyster cages in a different creek
and it is a navigational hazard as you run up on them and cannot get
through, then the shrimp boats come through, along with
paddleboarders, kayaking and throw in a jet ski and all of a sudden
someone gets hurt.
Mr. Randall said he thinks the majority of the shrimp boat maneuvers
are at off-peak hours.
Mr. Randall said he had an interview with the Deputy Chief and one of
his Lieutenants and they gave him a straight “PR” answer that through
education there are no more problems with anything on the creek.
They have educated the restaurants and bars so there is no
overdrinking, and no parking issues because of enforcement.
Page 18 of 45
Mr. Robertson said ultimately it may be delegated to the Town, but
the Coast Guard has jurisdiction as well.
Ms. Anderegg said she has been guiding for almost fifteen years, and
they have had a permanent location for the past 8 or 9 years, but
before that she worked out of the public boat landing. She said in all
those years she could recall one incident where someone was
endangered by the turning of a shrimp boat. As far as the other boats,
there is a lot of interaction with drunk boaters, and that is a huge
hazard. An improperly educated boater can do more damage than an
improperly educated paddleboarder or kayaker.
Ms. Edwards said she wanted to clarify that the fleet goes out
between 2:30 – 3:30 every morning but they come in between 2:30 –
4:30 p.m., peak dining time.
Ms. Woods-Flowers said to maintain that Creek, the fleet needs to
stay there or it will cost millions to keep the channel dredged. She
said perhaps the Police Department does not know what the rules say
about how wide that channel needs to be in order for it to function
efficiently. She said they may not have full enforcement and maybe
we need to go back to DNR for more enforcement.
Ms. Anderegg said she wondered how much jurisdiction Mount
Pleasant actually has to ticket on the Creek because recently there
was an individual that was reported for operating a paddleboard in an
unsafe manner and the police came out and said they needed to get
out of the water. The individual laughed at the police and the police
did nothing because they said they had no jurisdiction. This person
brought their board from elsewhere, put in at the public boat ramp
with their infant in a bucket seat on the bough of the boat. There
were many reports called in and the police said they could do nothing.
She said she would like to know if there is something they actually can
do.
Mr. Robertson said this whole issue is something that we obviously
have to address, and this input is good.
Page 19 of 45
Ms. Flynn asked to add to the list a better understanding of
jurisdiction, and Mr. Robertson responded in the affirmative.
Mr. Randall said Mount Pleasant was very clear that they do have
jurisdiction and they do ticket, now whether they can say having a
child on a paddleboard is legal, he does not know. He also stated that
every creek is a different width, so he does not think you will find a
specific dimension for a creek. It will be subjective, especially if there
is a dredged, navigable waterway.
Mr. Robertson said that would make it very different from the regular
rules because the width of a dredged channel is presumably the area
that you are supposed to be able to use for navigation purposes.
Mr. Barnwell asked if they could find out the cost of the dredging to
the Creek. If we have twelve boats and they are connected to the
financial sustainability of acquiring the dollars to do the dredge, they
must be protected at virtually any cost, unless you want to assess
every restaurant and landowner over there to dredge the Creek.
Mr. Robertson asked how often the Creek is dredged and Ms.
Anderegg said every ten years is what the Corps of Engineers told
them at the Crab Bank meeting. As a commercial channel they assess
it and dredge every ten years, but if it needs to be dredged sooner or
later, they have discretion.
Ms. Sims said the last dredging was done earlier than that ten-year
time-frame, and the Town had to foot the bill to piggy-back onto
another project they were mobilized for in the area, and it was still a
hefty bill.
Mr. Simmons said the problem was the mouth of the Creek which
would have choked off everything.
Page 20 of 45
Mr. Lane reviewed the recrafted goal in the slide above. He stated this
shows a pretty good picture of the core of the Creek, and as these
buildings have evolved, there is quite a lot of variation among them in
terms of height. Some built to the bulkhead line, some were set back,
and probably the one that is set back the furthest is the Shem Creek
Inn because it is one of the more recent. Mr. Lane said in thinking
about the character, the way we thought about it was first of all to
define the Creek as having three different segments. The first
segment Mr. Lane said he calls the Urban Creek, and that is the
corridor of buildings that nestle right up against the Creek, and is
typically almost all the Inns and the restaurants and they have very
defined edges, and the reason it feels very active is it is almost like a
canyon, and the density of boats and the activity in the water create a
real sense of bustle and interest. A place where people want to be.
Mr. Lane said he thought that would want to be maintained, but there
are some challenges in that. The edge of the new office building
looms over the others. Generally speaking the working creek is the
area beyond this. It is a little more open because of the marsh and
most of the docks for the fishing fleet are in this area. There is some
Page 21 of 45
overlap because of the fuel station in front of Vickery’s. It is a very
different character as it is opening up to the mouth of the harbor. On
the other side of Coleman, it is kind of a natural creek, and farther up
there is a tree line along the marsh which hide some of the houses.
This area is a very different character because of the environment and
because of the bridge and what is allowed to pass under it. Mr. Lane
said the public access is predominately on the northern side of the
creek, and the park and boardwalk. The boardwalk is in front of the
structures, and eventually will continue across the creek. Mr. Lane
said the way the public can experience the south side of the creek is
by coming into private uses as there is no common connection,
particularly at the extension of Church Street. Mr. Lane said there is
no access on the other side of the creek and that is a major character
defining aspect.
Page 22 of 45
He said they have looked at the land use. There are restaurants,
offices, and a series of water dependent uses.
Page 23 of 45
Mr. Lane said the directions the team sees are to retain and enhance
marine activities; increase public access and connections to the creek.
He said a very nice job has been done on the northern side of the
creek, but not so much on the south. The next is to expand public
activities and facilities in Shem Creek Park. Right now there is simply
the covered station, and if there is any opportunity to tell a story
about the maritime heritage of Shem Creek. There is some on the
wayside exhibits on the boardwalk but maybe something more
ambitious can be done. We certainly want to protect the view sheds
and architectural character, and the team heard loud and clear that if
there was a hurricane or some catastrophe, what could be put back in
this area. He said they are concerned as there will be pressure to
build up to the limits. This variation is very characteristic. If things
have to be rebuilt, it would be a good idea to include public access.
Mr. Lane said with Coleman Boulevard being modified but also with
the Boulevard Overlay District, the team thinks there is going to be a
lot of change along Coleman Boulevard and we need to anticipate this.
Ms. Woods-Flowers asked, as hurricanes were mentioned, if there is a
way through a historic designation or something, that we would be
able to maintain what we have there if we did have to rebuild. She
said it is not just the elevation, it is the push back from the creek. Mr.
Lane said the team is in the process of trying to identify the
possibilities.
Mr. Barnwell said about a year ago this was discussed and the rentable
number of square feet that are there now, which by property rights
you should be able to put back, in his opinion. Mr. Barnwell said there
are new guidelines, FEMA guidelines, setbacks, sideline setbacks,
parking regulations, and now city regulations and the forty-five foot
height rule which goes to the top of the roof which is going to
encourage everyone to have flat roofs. Under the new construction
rules, we would not be able to put back what we have now, and that is
a big concern.
Page 24 of 45
Mr. Lane said that regarding the regulations one of the things that
strikes him as being important is the Shem Creek Waterfront Overlay
District. It prohibits jet skis, encourages pervious surfaces, and allows
any use permitted in the marine district, but it says nothing about any
of the physical characteristics of what is developed, and he thinks that
is an omission. Mr. Lane believes we should be looking at what other
possible modifications could be added to the overlay district. Much
has been done with the Boulevard Overlay District where it has been
thought through carefully as to what is trying to be accomplished.
Ms. Anderegg said she thinks the building codes are more limiting.
The new codes put limitations on the buildings. Mr. Lane said the
Boulevard Overlay District has modified heights and specified certain
relationships to the street and has dealt with certain use relationships
that were not specified before, he thinks if that was done for the
Boulevard District, it opens the door to think a little more carefully
about the waterfront district, particularly given its importance. Mr.
Lane said there is a Design Review Board capacity in the Town for any
non-residential development and there are some guidelines to that,
but they are not particular to the waterfront. He said there are ways
that could be particularized and made more specific to the waterfront.
Page 25 of 45
Mr. Randall said he would discuss access and parking and reviewed
the goal stated in the slide above.
Mr. Randall said the Town contracted with Kimley Horn to do a
parking study for Coleman Boulevard in 2016, and that did include
Shem Creek. He said they have that report and have received some
additional supplemental information from Kimley Horn that has to do
with building uses and square footages at the end of last week, so they
are still reviewing the data. Mr. Randall said they had done parking
counts themselves by looking at every individual parcel and counting
the parking spaces in each parcel. He said they broke the information
up into four different zones, and there is a lot of shared parking. The
team went to the Town to see if there were any recorded shared
parking agreements, and they found one that was the office parking
garage. He stated there are a lot of private agreements that are not
recorded. Many of the restaurants have approached other business
owners and parcels and are using their facilities for parking during
peak hours. Mr. Randall said the study said there is a surplus of
parking spaces in the Shem Creek area, however they adjusted that to
Page 26 of 45
say there is a latent demand which is an unmet demand and there
were maybe 30 spaces short currently, as of 2016. He said in 2020
they projected to be about 300 spaces short, but that was before the
parking garage was built. Mr. Randall said they are using that for
information purposes, but they are forming their own opinions and
looking in other areas and more specifically directly toward Shem
Creek. The study identified some possible areas for surface parking, as
well as some potential locations for surface parking, which are
identified in yellow on the slide above, as well as some potential
locations for garages. Mr. Randall said looking at this area that we
talked about with potentially adding some more delineated on-street
parking, whether it be parallel spaces, or possibly making the streets
one-way with angled spaces to increase some surface parking. In the
different zones there is shared parking. In Zone 1 there is the public
parking and on-street parking with shared parking between the
restaurants and the Inn. In Zone 2, there is shared parking between
the businesses on the parcel with the office space. Saltwater Cowboys
is almost segregated from the other parking - even from a pedestrian
standpoint as you must walk all the way around the fenced parking
area to get to it. There is some possibility to improve access and
connectivity. Mr. Randall said a huge issue is The Shelter and their
lack of parking which affects all the businesses in the area. People will
post parking for Red’s Ice House or Tavern and Table and in this area
there are signs that read “No Shelter Parking.” Mr. Randall said we
have heard a lot that the parking garage is somewhat underutilized,
and there is typically a fair amount of parking that is available. The
team is somewhat limited in that they have not been looking at it
during peak season, but from what we have heard there is a potential
opportunity to increase the use of the parking garage. Mr. Randall
said from an access standpoint, public access on the south side of the
creek was discussed. Shem Creek is accessed from Coleman
Boulevard, from Downtown, the barrier islands and the rest of Mount
Pleasant, and the waterway as well.
Page 27 of 45
There is parking of vehicles and boat trailers. Also discussed was the
new lot that provides 22 spaces for boat trailer parking, and in
Moultrie Plaza there is another 22 spaces designated for boat trailer
parking, but that is an agreement that could potentially go away at any
time. That is obviously a significant issue. Mr. Randall said the current
Mount Pleasant Code is 1-2 parking spaces per 100 square feet of
seating area. They can have a minimum of 1 space per 100 square
feet or up to 2 spaces per 100 square feet. Anything over 2 would
have to be impervious pavement so these businesses try to fit as much
building on a spot as possible, and limit the parking, which becomes an
issue. Identifying whether the regulations fit the demand for the area
and how does that get resolved.
Mr. Randall said they looked at a case study in Rockport, MA where
there was remote parking and the transit authority shuttles people.
Approximately 30,000 people per year use it and it is very low cost.
He believes the cost is $.50 per ride and they break even. That is a
little different in that it is a peninsula, so everyone drives past that
parking lot and they know that is where they park. He said these are
things we are going to look at under opportunities.
Page 28 of 45
Mr. Randall said overflow into residential neighborhoods was
discussed and they met with Mr. Brad Morrison, Transportation
Director, and currently they are looking at a residential parking permit
program, but there is a public listening session later this week, so they
are early on in the process. He said limiting parking is not going to
solve any problems, additional parking options need to be provided.
Mr. Randall said another issue that has been brought up is the poor
parking surface of the Shem Creek Overlay as it requires pervious
surface, which is environmentally friendly, but how it has been
implemented is a lot of base coarse material which really is not that
pervious once it is compacted and it does not provide a safe or desired
surface to walk or drive on.
Mr. Lane said it is a little different than this place because there is one
dominant way in, and they were fortunate enough to have a piece of
public land that was on that route, but it is an interesting collaboration
between the town and the transit authority, which runs the modest-
sized shuttle. The town provides the staff so it is supervised during
the hours of operation, and it is only a mile, and only operates during
the peak season and weekends.
Mr. Barnwell said he wanted to make sure he understood what Mr.
Randall said. The study from Kimley Horn stated that this area is
underparked by 30 spaces, is that correct. Mr. Randall said that was in
2016. They said initially that there was actually a surplus but then
realized that was not the case, and said there was a latent demand
during peak hours.
Mr. Barnwell asked if anyone looked specifically at each piece of
property and what it requires for parking. Mr. Randall said that is
what they are working toward but it is a little easier said than done
because of all the different shared parking agreements.
Mr. Barnwell said Mr. Randall stated there was only one enforceable
and the rest of them are private and can be terminated so he did not
Page 29 of 45
think that information could be used and assume that they would
remain in place.
Mr. Robertson said he believes what Mr. Randall is trying to say is if
you consider the zone as a whole, then the private parking
agreements do not matter as much to figure out what the total
demand is against the total supply.
Mr. Barnwell asked if each is considered on a standalone basis, what is
required for parking.
Mr. Robertson said he did not think they were going to do that
because it is so complicated with the agreements, but if you draw a
line around a group, you can get a handle on whether it is good or
bad.
Mr. Lane said you can look at the requirement but it is hard to
correlate with what is on the ground.
Mr. Randall said it would be hard to compile the square footage of
each building, so they will go through the Kimley Horn data and talk to
the Town, but most of these buildings were done prior to digital
submittals so they may not have those records. It is laborious and
challenging.
Mr. Barnwell said that was the response every time we brought this
up, that it is too expensive, too complicated and could not be done.
Mr. Randall asked what it would tell us, that there are not enough
parking spaces? We already know there are not enough.
Mr. Barnwell said it would tell you how many parking spaces it is
underparked by and he believes it is over thirty.
Mr. Robertson said he would say it is more than thirty but remember,
when the Kimley Horn study was done, the demand for the parking in
the building was not there, and the supply of parking was not there,
and it was built over an existing parking lot that was included in the
count, so it is not applicable any more, except for the data we get
from them which is the square footage. Mr. Robertson said he hopes
they can give the Committee a better answer when they come back.
Page 30 of 45
Mr. Martschink said as this is a management plan we are trying to
develop, he hopes the team will consider that all of these surface
parking areas that are there now, the parking use is just a holding
pattern. With the price of land as high as it is, they will be developed.
He said in this management plan we need to anticipate that, and these
private agreements are all short term, so a hard look needs to be
taken as to how many private agreements are in place and how many
of those places will likely go away in the short term.
Mr. Lane said the question we need to think about is if there is the
ability to build further on some of these places and we need to
consider that.
Mr. Randall said that is why they went out and did a parking count, so
now we have the parking spaces that are out there. So now we need
to find out what parking is required for each building according to the
Code. It is a challenge just getting that information. He said we can
get the surface area of the building footprint but many of these places
have bars on the first floor where it is not heated square footage.
Mr. Barnwell said they know how many seats are in these restaurants,
and sometimes it is regulated by seats. Mr. Randall said a lot of these
were from the older standards and grandfathered in.
Ms. Anderegg said the Fire Marshall will regulate what the building
capacity is, and most people go there with one person in a car.
Mr. Robertson said they will look into that further as we go along.
Mr. Barnwell said there is one yellow spot that is hatched directly
across the street from the Bank. Mr. Randall said this is from the
traffic study from 2016. Mr. Barnwell asked if it was there because it
was included in the parking and Mr. Randall said they identified that
as a potential area to add surface parking. It is hatched because it was
identified as a potential garage, but he did not know how feasible it
would be. There are opportunities and we are going to move into that
phase of the study.
Page 31 of 45
Ms. Woods-Flowers said we need to remember that people will do
whatever is easiest. She said a lot of times that parking garage is not
full and it is because it is not as convenient for people to park and
walk. They are going to look for someplace in the neighborhood or
someplace they do not have to pay to park.
Mr. Lane said there are many places that provide validation for
parking, and in the garage almost all of the spaces are accessible after
6:00 p.m., and on the weekends. Many of the spaces are posted for
certain usage, but only from 6:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. during weekdays.
Mr. Randall said the study states that accessible parking spaces are
within 800 feet of your destination and anything over that is not used
and that is how they calculate the latent demands. Although there are
parking spaces, some of them are not desirable.
Mr. Hartling said he would like to talk about an economic concept
which he has seen work in other cases, where you create a mechanism
in which you charge for every parking space so price goes away as a
determinant to where people park. There is a community in
Philadelphia, Chestnut Hill, where almost all of the private parking
spaces were amalgamated into a foundation and were operating
continuously as one single integrated parking system. They charged
the same rate for everything, so therefore you went to the most
convenient parking lot, and you modify the people’s behavior like that.
He said he spoke with many of the property owners here and he
thinks that is an unlikely solution, but those are ways to tackle it,
where you create a centralized collective approach and move price out
of the system.
Page 32 of 45
Mr. Lane said the goal is enacting regulations to support the mission.
He said in the picture above, which was taken from the boardwalk,
you can see the buildings along the creek with the office building in
the rear, and this is the paradigm of what everyone is worried about,
the idea that if you have a height limit there will be a constant height
along the creek and a monolithic sense instead of the organic feel that
it has currently.
He said the team has done their own evaluation of the existing zoning
which has much of the area in the Marine District which does allow
Page 33 of 45
restaurants. Mr. Lane said a lot of the area is Areawide Business and
that applies to the parking lots on the north side of the creek. The
residential is around the perimeter, and in fact the Areawide Business
does not encourage residential, though some has been allowed in the
Boulevard Overlay District.
Mr. Lane said the overlay districts are quite important. The striped is
probably the least important which is a national registration district,
and it may apply if federal money comes into play along the creek.
The Old Village Historic Overlay District protecting the perimeter, the
Shem Creek Waterfront Overlay District in blue, which included all the
buildings at the very western edge and all of the land along the edge
as well as the north side of the creek. The Boulevard Overlay District
in red, which includes several sub-areas that have different
requirements for each one. Looking at the Boulevard Overlay District,
his strong sense is that the Waterfront Overlay District does not say
very much, and yet it is the most critical piece of the puzzle, so we
need to think through what requirements can be brought forth to be
added. When we look at the very careful thinking in the Boulevard
Page 34 of 45
Overlay District, certainly Shem Creek deserves the same level of
careful thinking, particularly where the underlying zoning is Areawide
Business, there are clearly incentives to develop. He said these
parking lots, although they are the active problem today they are the
future problem of Shem Creek.
Mr. Lane read the issues and directions from the above slide. He said
one thing he thought is that there is no requirement for public access
in the Waterfront Overlay District, and he thinks he would encourage
a requirement and ways of expanding public access along the creek,
particularly if big changes occur. He said it might be worth
reconsidering the height limitations along the creek, with an eye
toward the ability to go somewhat higher but with a subject to
variation. You do not want to build a height that requires you to
maximize, but to produce something with character down the road.
Page 35 of 45
Mr. Lane said the team put together a summary, and they have a large
sheet available with the map on it, and on the back side there is a
summary of all the issues and directions mentioned so far for each of
the study elements. He said we have actually touched on most of
them, but this will be a launch pad for where we are moving in the
next stage of the study. It is not total but gives ideas that are worth
thinking about.
Mr. Randall said from a regulations standpoint to update the
committee on where the team is currently, he interviewed a
gentleman who works with Terracon Environmental, but for the
previous ten years he was with OCRM, and he was the direct planning
assistant in the South Carolina State lead for a lot of these waterfront
issues, mainly on beaches, but worked for a lot of municipalities. He
was on many of the disaster resiliency boards and he has identified a
few different people from OCRM that the team will meet with, as well
as a DNR representative who is the state flood plain manager and she
advises how the state comes into conformance with federal standards
because the town can do a lot of things, but in the end it is an
economic situation because if you are not going to be able to get
Page 36 of 45
insurance, no one is going to develop on that, and even more so if the
Town allows development that goes against the national flood plain
standard, and they will not be able to get federal funding for disaster
relief.
Page 37 of 45
Mr. Robertson said clearly at the core is the existing restaurants in the
urban waterfront and the question is how to rebuild if they are
damaged and what standard to apply if individuals decide to rebuild
on their own. It dovetails with regulation but it is also central to the
character of Shem Creek and its most iconic section.
Mr. Lane said the next issue is parking lots that extend north and
south of the restaurants; can and might they be developed in the
Page 38 of 45
future. If things are going to be proposed for them, we might want to
think more carefully about what we are trying to achieve.
Mr. Lane asked if we could think of ways to increase use to the entry
of the Town park, and beneficial ways to use the park land. The major
water dependent uses, the boat ramp and its relationship to the
surrounding neighborhood, and what are the pressures on this whole
eastern part of the Shem Creek Area. Mr. Lane said the Wando Dock
and the area of The Wreck, are areas that are water dependent now if
it moves out of that kind of use, it is never going to move back. If the
dock space disappears as a resource for the commercial fleet, it will
put a constraint on the commercial fleet. Mr. Lane said a thought they
had was whether it might be possible to have some of the non-
motorized boat rentals closer to the mouth of the creek to possibly
reduce some of that congestion. Another aspect is public use and
public access, not as they exist but perhaps as they will or might in the
future, and where might that public access extend to. Could it connect
to Church Street, or in some way to GeeChee dock for seafood market,
and are there ways to connect to some of the other uses in the natural
Page 39 of 45
part of Shem Creek where there is no public access. He said clearly
there are some pressures along Coleman Boulevard for
redevelopment. For example the Moultrie Plaza that has now a height
limit of 55 feet, not directly on the street, but setback away from the
street. It is conceivable that if things change the trailer parking that is
there now may not be so conceivable to accommodate. Mr. Lane said
some of these lots that are positioned on the creek such as the law
office that is now vacant, we do not know what the future is for that,
but with the Boulevard District there may be some potential as well as
the combination of a site that the town is using as a laydown site and
the landscape business, is clearly a site that has potential for more
intensive development. He said the whole issue of overflow parking is
not only toward the Old Village but in the neighborhood on the other
side of Coleman, not just from the boat ramp. He said these are all
questions that come to the floor in our thinking as to what choices
there might be, and what we are trying to do is focus on opportunities.
On the back of the map, they tried to list all of the issues and
possibilities for all of the study elements. Mr. Lane said if the
Committee looks at them carefully and in the context of what was
presented you can see that they are leading us toward opportunities.
The opportunities are not mutually exclusive nor are they global.
Some conflict with one another and he thinks the important thing we
want to do in our next session is identify the full range of
opportunities and figure out which are in conflict and how they might
be assembled into sensible ways to think about the Shem Creek Study
Area.
Ms. Flynn said she was thinking the same thing, that we will identify
opportunities that conflict with each other and asked if anyone had
put any thought into, here are the issues, and ranking the ones that
are most critical. For example, the importance of keeping the fleet for
the dredging aspect and that may be more important to this group
than any other item. She said maybe that comes later, but she does
see value in ranking the issues.
Page 40 of 45
Mr. Lane said that is one way to do it, but their proposed method is to
assemble those opportunities into a couple of different scenarios. He
said he did not think the group has gotten to the stage of assembling
those, nor of crystalizing the opportunities. Mr. Lane said they are
trying to come to an understanding of what is tolerable, and a lot of
times people will not tell you and you have to make a judgement call
based on what you hear. We know the parking is a big issue and we
have a platform of data that they have generated, along with others,
and it will be deployed in the right way.
Mr. Robertson said at the moment we would like to get all
opportunities out on the table.
Mr. Robertson said he would like to take five minutes for the
Committee to write down some of the things they have thought
about. Ms. Woods-Flowers said it would be better if they could think
about it and send the ideas in. Ms. Sims asked for a deadline for
receiving the comments and a week was decided. Mr. Lane said he
knows the Committee just received the report and a week might give
them a chance to look at it. Today we have just touched on the
surface of what is in the report.
Mr. Hartling said if there is some issue that the Committee thinks was
missed to add that to the list.
Mr. Bennett asked the team to guide the Committee with respect to
what their expectations as to how the opportunities are crafted or
captured, and maybe even some examples.
Mr. Robertson said just an example of something the team thought of
is that there is some vacant land just to the southeast of the boat
landing for parking that the County has there. It makes sense in the
short term to acquire some land and put in more boat parking.
Mr. Hartling said if one of these issues is really important, highlight it
and say, resolving this is my key opportunity.
Mr. Robertson said what we hope is when we meet again to discuss
the opportunities, then we will craft those into alternative futures, and
it is good to put them together in a way that if you go with this
Page 41 of 45
approach, this is what it would look like. It is easier to see if you can
look at what the consequences of your actions might be.
Ms. Sims said the sheets would be returned in a week. She said she
would collect them and get them to the team.
Ms. Sims said the report was sent out yesterday and she will re-send
it. Mr. Randall has a condensed version that may not take as long to
load.
Ms. Pat Sullivan – 1002 Plantation Court – said there is some property
at the entrance to the creek that currently has a contract on it by a
private individual and no one knows what will happen. If we lose that
area, who knows what will happen to the shrimping business. She said
the Town is trying to buy that but she has no idea where that is, and
she wanted the team to be aware of it.
Mr. Robertson said they are aware of it, but do not know the details.
Mr. Lane said one of the things we need to consider in the scenarios is
for example, there has been some back and forth about people
wanting to put residential back there, but it is not permitted in the
current zoning, but there are commercial uses that would be
permitted.
Ms. Edwards asked if Mr. Lane had spoken to the new owner, the
person that has an offer on the property. Mr. Lane said they have
spoken with someone who has talked with him. Mr. Robertson said
he spoke with Jimmy Bagwell and has spoken with about 60% of the
Council Members. He said he received some pretty good information
to the extent that they could say given that there had been some legal
sessions on it.
Ms. Edwards said she just wanted to make sure someone was feeding
the team that information.
Mr. Barnwell asked if the Town has access to other spaces if Wando
does not work out. He asked if there was space on the other side of
the creek that could be used for the fleet.
Page 42 of 45
Mr. Lane said he thought what Mr. Barnwell is getting to is what we
will have to think through in these scenarios. So if the Wando Dock
went away, what could be done. That gets to issues not just of can
you tie up there, but how do you run your business, deliver your
product, operate wholesale or retail.
Mr. Barnwell said if $3.5-$4M is spent to purchase it and it needs to be
repaired, it will be $6M. Do we have a more effective cost of linear
space across the creek.
Mr. Hartling said it is how one operates the on land activities after the
catch is brought in. Mr. Robertson said he noticed there is a section of
floating dock. He said there are no boats there, but all of the
shrimpers tie up at the fixed dock and not at the floating dock. That is
probably an operational issue.
Ms. Woods-Flowers asked if it was because of ownership and Mr.
Simmons responded that the docks at the mouth of the creek – the
concrete floating docks – are designated recreational and part of the
issue there is no boat wants to have to carry their catch from that
point farther down. The shrimp dock supports six shrimp boats and
they have the option of unloading quickly at the fuel dock, but most of
them choose to tie up and roll their catch to that same area where the
fuel dock comes out. He said he did not know any of them that want
to walk that distance and that is why that farther section is
recreational. Mr. Simmons said there is a section where the
recreational concrete docks stop and there is a big gap between there
and the shrimp dock. He said potentially for later that could support
more boats to dock there but not necessarily unload there. He said
years back there were three shrimp docks on the creek and on two of
them, the boats would pull in and unload, then they would be on a
holding dock after they unloaded. It may be in the future that if
something happens with Wando, you still have to have a place for
them to unload and you do not want to bottleneck that section. Mr.
Simmons said supporting several different areas, as with the ice,
makes more sense, but he does not think the floating dock area would
work because of the distance they would have to walk.
Page 43 of 45
Mr. Robertson said the only way that would work is if that is where
they tied up after they unloaded. Mr. Hartling said the owner of the
GeeChee dock is reconstructing it now. He used to tie up nine boats
there, but only four now while reconstruction is going on. He intends
on doing up to eight or nine once the construction is finished, so there
will be some capacity added there.
Ms. Woods-Flowers said while that one section is recreational it is
being used for charter boats, picking up people all day. Mr. Simmons
said that is a problem because a small center console fishing boat that
carries people out, they pull into Vickery’s or Water’s Edge parking lot
and park their car, which stays in that spot all day long with no benefit
to the area. Mr. Robertson clarified that it is parking for people that
are being picked up and taken away by water. Ms. Woods-Flowers
said it is a moving target as you would have to sit there for a couple of
weeks and survey people that are picking up people to see who is
doing it.
Mr. Barnwell said on a fishing boat like that you have a captain, one
mate, six passengers who all drive their own cars, so that is eight
parking spaces taken by one boat.
Mr. Hartling said they could start charging for parking.
Mr. Bennett said there may be some larger charter boats, but most of
them are center console, inshore fishing and touring.
Ms. Anderegg said as far as charging for parking a lot of the businesses
that have their own parking do not want to charge their customers.
Mr. Hartling said that goes back to integrating it with the validation
system. It has worked, but whether it will work here is another whole
question.
Ms. Anderegg said we are fortunate that the younger generation likes
Uber because her business has offered incentives for customers that
use the service.
Page 44 of 45
Mr. Randall said if you think about it from a parking standpoint, there
have been case studies in Europe where the towns and municipalities
have reduced the parking requirement and the apartment
communities will give them $100 off a month in rent if they do not
have a car there, so the incentives work.
Page 45 of 45
Mr. Robertson said the next meeting is a Public Input Meeting which is
on March 19, 2019 at 5:00 p.m. and the next Shem Creek Study
Advisory Committee Meeting #3 will be the next morning on March
20, 2019 at 9:00 a.m. here in the Police Training Room.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 11:08
a.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Christine Barrett
Clerk of Council
Source: Town of Mount Pleasant website. First collected Nov 13, 2026.