RecordWell Data

Minutes

Oconee County · Oconee County · meeting of Apr 7, 2025 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Oconee County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

OCONEE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION 415 S. Pine St. Room 212 | Walhalla, SC 29691 864.638.4218 OconeeSC.com Ms. Serena Richardson voiced her opposition to eliminating the 50’ right-of-way requirement on private roads and drives. b. Discussion / Vote: Open discussion among members, Oconee County Fire Marshal, Clint Livingston, Oconee County Fire Chief, Chris Smith, and Roads and Bridges Director, Kyle Reid. 6:40 – Mr. Haney made a motion to allow Mr. Kyle Reid, Mr. Clint Livingston, and Mr. Chris Smith to speak; Seconded by Mr. Fravel. Approved Unanimously. 7:30 – Mr. Haney made a motion to allow Mr. Tom Markovich to speak. Second by Mr. Johnson. Approved unanimously. Mr. Tom Markovich voiced his opinion regarding private roads and private drives. 7:38 – Mr. Nix made a motion to allow anybody else to speak on the topic. Seconded by Mr. Johnson. Approved Unanimously. Mr. Perry Smith voiced his opinion regarding private roads and private drives. Mr. John Richardson voiced his opinion regarding private roads and private drives. Mr. Doug Cooper voiced his opinion regarding private roads and private drives. 8:00 – Mr. Nix made a motion to allow Mr. Kyle Reid, Mr. Clint Livingston, and Mr. Chris Smith to return to the podium and speak; Seconded by Mr. Haney. Approved unanimously. 8:22 – Ms. Spicer made a motion to delay the conversation until the next meeting; Seconded by Mr. Nix. Approved unanimously. 9. Adjourn – The meeting was adjourned at 8:23 PM. Youtube Transcript 22:36 minutes into the meeƟng. Good evening chair, commissioners and fellow ciƟzens. My name is LucreƟa Morgan and I stand before you today to voice my strong opposiƟon to the Planning commission proposal to eliminate the 50 foot right away requirement on Private Roads and Drives. This proposal is not only unnecessary, it’s misleading, poorly substanƟated and potenƟally self serving. Let’s start with the basics, a 50’ ROW isn’t an arbitrary number. It exists for good reason. Public safety, access for emergency services uƟlity placement, long-term infrastructure and proper traffic flow. Removing this requirement invites future complicaƟons for property owners, local services and the broader community. It undermines standards that have been in place to protect everyone not just a few who stand to benefit from the change. Back in July 2022. This exact proposal was introduced by the Planning Commission chairman Mike Johnson. Today, it’s being reintroduced by Commissioner Mickey Haney. But let’s be honest. This is the same idea recycled and jusƟficaƟon remains as weak now as it was then. We are told this is for Farmer Joe who wants to divide his property, into more than three parcels for his family because 50’ ROW requirement. That narraƟve might tug at some heart strings but let’s look at the facts. The parcels presented to support this proposal are decepƟve. The parcels that were just shown I’ve researched every one of them. I’ve pulled plats. There’s either the owner as adjacent property or when I pull the plat there’s 50’ on the actual plat or greater. In most cases the land owner already control adjacent parcels that do provide the required access. In some examples, (inaudible) told the access is under 50’ the actual plats and in mulƟple instances the access points are more than 50 feet wide. Feel free to conduct your own research. I’ve already done mine. The handouts I provided include the findings I came across and I have more but I didn’t wanna make a 40 page handout. So I ask, was this an oversight or intenƟonal misinformaƟon to dissuade decision makers? If it’s the former, then someone failed to do their due diligence. If it’s the laƩer then it’s blatant aƩempt to mislead this commission and the public. Either way, we deserve beƩer, we deserve transparency. 25:10 Let’s talk about potenƟal conflict of interest. The chairman of this commission works for realtor and developer. The commissioner who promoƟng this proposal owns considerable property. That’s not inherently wrong but it does raise quesƟons. Who really benefits from this change. Is this truly about Farmer Joe or is he just a convenient cover story? 5IJTUSBOTDSJQUXBTQSPWJEFECZ.S+PIOTPO 25:26 Because when you look at the records from 2022 to present how many variances actually been submiƩed because of a 50 right away requirement? Just one. One single case. You may have heard of it, Arrowhead Point. the same contenƟous subdivision that Mr. Johnson’s employer has been trying to access for over three years. Convenient, isn’t it? 25:48 If this proposal goes through and Private Roads Standards are relaxed, that project could automaƟcally get the green light. 19 homes and a 20 foot wide road. Is that in the community‘s best interest? Or is it someone’s personal interest? 26:02 And the plot thickens through a FOIA request I obtain documentaƟon showing that back in 2019 Mr. Johnson submiƩed a subdivision development request for 3 to 4 Ɵny homes. The planning Commissioner at the Ɵme responded “ONLY THREE HOMES ALLOWED WITHOUT A 50” ROW.” That’s not about Farmer Joe, and not about a struggling family and not about a struggling family trying to divide land for their kids. Doesn’t that seem like someone trying to bend the rules for personal development again. This isn’t about simplifying things for rural families. It’s about paving the way literally, for developers to bypass long-standing protecƟons under the guise of helping the average landowner. If Farmer Joe has a legiƟmate case let him take it to the board of appeals and ask for a variance. 26:45 That’s the process. That’s the transparent and accountable way to handle it. But don’t blow up a policy that affects our whole community to benefit a select few. I urge this commission, do not let personal interest override public good. Do not use Farmer Joe as a smoke screen to pass something that only serve a handful of people. Some of whom sit on this very board. Let’s preserve the integrity of our planning process and reject this proposal. I also request that my presentaƟon with my research along with a copy of my verbal transcript be included in the meeƟng minutes and backup materials. Thank you for your Ɵme. 5IJTUSBOTDSJQUXBTQSPWJEFECZ.S+PIOTPO Good evening Chair, Commissioners, and fellow citizens, My name is Lucretia Morgan and I stand before you today to voice my strong opposition to the Planning Commission's proposal to eliminate the 50-foot right- of-way (ROW) requirement on private roads and drives. This proposal is not only unnecessary—it’s misleading, poorly substantiated, and potentially self-serving. Let’s start with the basics: A 50-foot ROW isn’t an arbitrary number. It exists for good reasons—public safety, access for emergency services, utility placement, long-term infrastructure planning, and proper traffic flow. Removing this requirement invites future complications for property owners, local services, and the broader community. It undermines standards that have been in place to protect everyone, not just the few who stand to benefit from the change. Back in July 2022, this exact proposal was introduced by the Planning Commission Chairman, Mike Johnson. Today, it's being reintroduced by Commissioner Mickey Haney. But let’s be honest—this is just the same idea recycled, and the justification remains as weak now as it was then. We’re told this is for “Farmer Joe,” who wants to divide his property into more than three parcels for his family but can’t because of the 50-foot ROW requirement. That narrative might tug at some heartstrings, but let’s look at the facts. The parcels being presented to support this proposal are deceptive. In most cases, the landowners already control adjacent parcels that do provide the required access. In some examples, we’re told the access is under 50 feet, but I reviewed the actual plats—and in multiple instances, the access points are more than 50 feet wide. Feel free to conduct your own research—I’ve already done mine. The handouts I provided include the findings I came across. So I ask: was this an oversight, or is it intentional misinformation meant to sway decision-makers? If it's the former, then someone failed to do their due diligence. If it’s the latter, then it’s a blatant attempt to mislead this Commission and the public. Either way, we deserve better. We deserve transparency. Let’s also talk about potential conflicts of interest. The Chairman of this Commission works for a realtor and developer. The commissioner who’s promoting this proposal owns considerable property. That’s not inherently wrong—but it does raise questions. Who really benefits from this change? Is this truly about "Farmer Joe," or is he just a convenient cover story? 5IJTNBUFSJBMXBTQSPWJEFEUPUIFDPNNJTTJPOCZ.T.PSHBO Because when you look at the records from 2022 to the present, how many variances have actually been submitted because of a 50-foot ROW requirement? Just one. One single case. You may have heard of it—Arrowhead Point. The same contentious subdivision that Mr. Johnson’s employer has been trying to access for over three years. Convenient, isn’t it? If this proposal goes through and private road standards are relaxed, that project could automatically get the green light—19 homes on a 20-foot-wide road. Is that in the community’s best interest? Or is it in someone's personal interest? And the plot thickens. Through a FOIA request, I obtained documentation showing that back in 2019, Mr. Johnson submitted a subdivision development request for 3–4 tiny homes. The planning commissioner at the time responded clearly: only three homes are allowed without a 50-foot ROW. That’s not about "Farmer Joe." That’s not about a struggling family trying to divide land for their kids. Doesn’t that seem like someone trying to bend the rules for personal development—again? This isn’t about simplifying things for rural families. It's about paving the way— literally—for developers to bypass longstanding protections under the guise of helping the average landowner. If “Farmer Joe” has a legitimate case, let him take it to the Board of Zoning Appeals and ask for a variance. That’s the process. That’s the transparent and accountable way to handle it. But don’t blow up a policy that affects our whole community just to benefit a select few. I urge this Commission: do not let personal interests override public good. Do not use “Farmer Joe” as a smokescreen to pass something that only serves a handful of people—some of whom sit on this very board. Let’s preserve the integrity of our planning process and reject this proposal. I also request that the presentation with my research, along with a copy of my verbal transcript, be included in the meeting minutes and backup materials. Thank you. Lucretia Morgan 5IJTNBUFSJBMXBTQSPWJEFEUPUIFDPNNJTTJPOCZ.T.PSHBO 2025-04-07 Backup Material Planning Commission Meeting Research on parcels being presented by Planning Commission Meeting as “potential” issues for subdividing with a 50’ROW on private roads/drive. 4/7/2025 L. Morgan Backup material research 1 5IJTNBUFSJBMXBTQSPWJEFEUPUIFDPNNJTTJPOCZ.T.PSHBO

Source: Oconee County website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.