Historic Preservation Commission Meeting — Minutes
Town of Bluffton · Beaufort County · Historic Preservation Commission · meeting of Dec 3, 2025 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Bluffton
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Historic Preservation Commission Meeting
Theodore D. Washington Municipal Building, Henry “Emmett” McCracken Jr. Council Chambers, 20
Bridge Street, Bluffton, SC
December 03, 2025
I. CALL TO ORDER
Chairman Goodwin called the meeting to order at 6pm.
II. ROLL CALL
PRESENT
Chairman Evan Goodwin
Vice Chairman Joe DePauw
Commissioner Carletha Frazier
Commissioner Jim Hess
Commissioner Tim Probst
Commissioner Debbie Wunder
Commissioner Lisa Sulka
III. ADOPTION OF MINUTES
1. November 5, 2025 Minutes
Commissioner Sulka made a motion to approve the minutes as written.
Seconded by Commissioner Frazier.
Voting Yea: Chairman Goodwin, Vice Chairman DePauw, Commissioner Frazier, Commissioner
Hess, Commissioner Probst, Commissioner Wunder, Commissioner Sulka
All were in favor and the motion passed.
IV. PUBLIC COMMENT
Norma Cooley, 15 Wharf St, Bluffton - Ms. Cooley owns property abutting 5 Garfields Way. She
shared that a fence was encroaching into her rear yard and was seeking assistance for its removal.
V. OLD BUSINESS
VI. NEW BUSINESS
1. 5 Garfields Way: A request by Scott Middleton of Southern Coastal Homes (Applicant) on
behalf of 5 Garfields LLC (Owner), for review of a Certificate of Appropriateness-Historic
District to allow the construction of a new 2-story 2,621 SF main house (an Additional Building
Type) and a 1-story 264 SF carriage house at 5 Garfields Way. The property is located in the
Old Town Historic District and zoned Neighborhood General-Historic District (NG-HD). (COFA-
10-25-019966) (Staff - Charlotte Moore)
Staff presented. The applicant was present. There was discussion regarding the rear property
line, the location of an existing fence in relation to the property, and the opacity of the
proposed fence. The Commission had questions regarding the main structure foundation and
the proposed foundation recesses, including whether infill material was necessary for the
recesses. The Commission asked for clarification on the materials to be used for the stairs and
Town of Bluffton, SC Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Minutes December 03, 2025
sofa. The side yard porch of the main structure was discussed in relation to the rear yard
setback line. There were concerns regarding the length of the diagonal for the brackets on the
rear elevation. There was discussion regarding the size of the lot and the footprint of what is
being proposed.
Commissioner Sulka made a motion to approve the application with the following conditions:
1. Update the wall section to show required UDO details, including soffit material and
configuration, frieze board and fascia material, corner boards with a beaded or ¼ round
inset trim mold, and provide details for the foundation sill and porch columns.
2. Add a top board to the wood hog-wire infill fence (UDO Sec. 5.15.6.K.3.g.).
3. Obtain an approved Tree Removal Permit from the Town before removing any tree
that is 14 or more inches in diameter at breast height (Applications Manual).
4. For the main house foundation, remove the recesses to create a flat, solid surface.
5. For the rear elevation brackets, increase the length of the diagonal.
6. For the foundation sill, place the band at the bottom of the sill or remove it.
7. The property owners of 15 Wharf Street and 5 Garfield's Way are to meet with Town
Staff to agree that their individual surveys align with the property lines.
And determinations:
1. The 6’-0” dog-ear fence along the rear property line complies with the Unified
Development Ordinance (UDO).
2. The creation of a rear porch elevation that is asymmetrical is appropriate to avoid
encroachment into the rear yard setback.
Seconded by Commissioner Hess.
Voting Yea: Chairman Goodwin, Vice Chairman DePauw, Commissioner Frazier, Commissioner
Hess, Commissioner Probst, Commissioner Wunder, Commissioner Sulka
All were in favor and the motion passed.
VII. DISCUSSION
1. Historic District Monthly Update. (Staff)
Staff presented. The Commission did not have any questions about the report submitted.
VIII. ADJOURNMENT
Commissioner Frazier made a motion to adjourn.
Seconded by Vice Chairman DePauw.
Voting Yea: Chairman Goodwin, Vice Chairman DePauw, Commissioner Frazier, Commissioner
Hess, Commissioner Probst, Commissioner Wunder, Commissioner Sulka
All were in favor and the motion passed. The meeting adjourned at 7:13pm.
Source: Town of Bluffton website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.