Minutes
City of Sumter · Sumter County · meeting of Jun 25, 2020 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
This document is no longer listed on City of Sumter's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
HISTORIC PRESERVATION
DESIGN REVIEW
Minutes of the Meeting
June 25, 2020
ATTENDANCE
A regular meeting of the Historic Preservation Design
Review Committee was held on Thursday, June 25, 2020,
in the Sumter Opera House Theater located on the F irst
Floor of the Sumter Opera House. Four board members –
Ms. Vivian Sharp ; Mr. William Buxton ; Ms. Julie Her long
and Ms. Jean Whitaker were present and two board
members – Ms.Heidi Burkett and Mr. Jerome Robinson
were absent.
Staff members present were: Ms. Helen Roodman , Mr.
Kyle Kelly, Mr. Preston McClun and Ms. Kellie Chapman
The meeting was called to order at 4:30 p.m. by Ms. Julie
Herlong.
MINUTES
Mr. Bill Buxton made a motion to approve the minutes of
the February 27 , 20 20 meeting as written. The m otion
was seconded by Ms. Jean Whitaker and c arried a
unanimous vote.
NEW BUSINESS
HP-20-05, 508 W. Hampton Ave . (City) was presented
by Mr. Preston McClun The Committee reviewed this
request for Historic Preservation Design Review app roval
for the construction of a 144 sq. ft. accessory storage
building with wooden siding.
Mr. McClun stated the dwelling was constructed in 1890.
According to the 1980 Historic Resources S urvey. T he
structure is identified as a Ve rnacular Victorian style, with
Tuscan columns, double gable, and wrap around porch.
Mr. McClun added that the proposed pro ject will include
construction of a 144 sq. ft. wood en accessory shed with
wood siding and one over sash configuration vinyl
windows on an existi ng concrete pad . The applicant
plans to choose a color from the Historic Preservation
approved color pallet book.
2
Mr. Wilber Jeffcoat was present to speak on behalf o f this
request.
After some discussion, Mr. Bill Bu xton made a motion to
approve this request in accor dance with the materials,
photographs, and construction details submitted based on
compliance with Design Review Guidelines. The motion
was seconded by Ms. Vivian Sharp and carried a
unanimous vote.
HP-20-06, 521 W. H ampton Ave . (City) was presented
by Mr. Preston McClun . The Commi ttee reviewed the
request for Historic Preservation Design Review approval
for construction of a 960 sq. ft. accessory structure, gate
installation, enclosure of a rear screen po rch, and
construction of a new rear deck.
Mr. McClun stated that the existing si ngle-family
residence was construct ed circa 1925. The reside nce is
in the California Bungalow style, and is characterized by a
pedimented projecting porch, shipla p siding, and double
porch piers.
Mr. McClun added that the proposed scope of work to be
performed is:
1. Enclosure of existing rear screen porch.
2. Construction of a new 336 sq. ft. floating rear de ck
immediately adjacent to the residence.
3. Construction of a 960 sq. f t. rear acce ssory
structure with black architectur al shingles, vinyl window s
and siding.
4. Installation of a 5 ft. tall wooden gate.
After some discussion, M s. Vivian Sharp made a motion
to approve this request in accordance with the materials,
photographs, and construction details submitted based on
compliance with Design Review Guidelines. The motion
was seconded by Mr. Bill Buxton and carried a unanimous
vote.
HP-20-07, 100 W. Liberty St. (City) was presented by
Mr. Kyle Kelly . The Committee reviewed the request for
Historic Preservation Design Review a pproval for the
removal o f existing canopy and installation of new metal
sloped canopy.
3
Mr. Kelly stated that the site was last used as a real tor’s
office. The proposed renovations are in order to
accommodate an incoming medical office.
Mr. Kelly stated the existing canopy element fea tured on
the front of the façade is a flat, minimalisti c, geometric
design. Currently, this canopy is in a st ate of disrep air.
The applicant is prop osing to remove the canopy and
install a new dark bronze sloped metal c anopy with metal
fascia and a new 8 X 8-inch columns.
Mr. Mack Ko lb was pres ent to speak on be half of the
request.
After some discussion, Mr. Bill Buxton made a motion to
approve this request in accordance with the materials,
photographs, and construction details submitted based on
compliance with Design Review Guidelines. The motion
was seconded by Ms. Jean Whitaker and carried a
unanimous vote.
HP-20-08, 10 S. Main St. (City) was presented by Mr.
Kyle Kelly . The Committee reviewed the request for
Historic Preservation Design Review approval for the
removal of existing alley doors, in stallation of two (2) new
alley servi ce doors , 8 ft. 10 ft. co il-up door, and rear
façade paint.
Mr. Kelly stated the applicant is requesting design review
approval to make alterations to the rea r (alley -facing)
elevation of the building in order to provide i mproved
access to the space for large items, and to make cosmetic
changes including new paint and re moval of a bandoned
utility conduits.
Based upon the submitted archit ectural
elevation/rendering, the following is proposed:
1. Install new 8X10’ coil-up door;
2. Replacing existing north side door with new painted
3X7’ hollow metal door and shift door location to
accommodate new coil-up door;
3. Replace existing south side door with new painted
3X7’ hollow metal door;
4. Remove existing abandoned sprinkler lines;
5. Remove existing abandoned downspout;
6. Remove existing exposed electrical conduit;
7. Repaint existing windows, trim, bard and sills;
8. Paint brick walls
4
Mr. Kelly added that Renwick Beige will be the wall color.
Fairfax Brown will be the door color, and Classical White
will be the window, trim, bar, and sill color.
Mr. Scott Bell was pres ent to speak on be half of th e
request.
After some discussion, Mr. Bill Buxton made a motion t o
approve this request in accordance with the materials,
photographs, and construction details submitted based on
compliance with Design Review Guidelines. The motion
was seconded by Ms. Vivian Sharp and carried a
unanimous vote.
HP-20-09, 129 N. Washingt on St. (City) was presented
by Mr. Kyle Kelly . The Committee reviewed the request
for Histo ric Preservation Design Review approval for a
30,000 sq. ft. renovation and e xpansion of the existing
emergency room department and parking lot on the N .
Main St. frontage.
Mr. Kelly added the site had been used as a ho spital
since at least 1940. N o portions of the original st ructure
remain due to piecemeal demolition and redevelopment of
the site.
Mr. Kelly stated the proposed sco pe of work is the
construction of a 30,000 sq. ft. emergenc y room addition
with red bri ck masonry, aluminum windows, and
aluminum accents and roofing.
Mr. Scott Bell spoke in favor of this request.
After some discussion, Mr. Bill Buxton made a motion to
approve this request in accordance with the materials,
photographs, and construction details submitted based on
compliance wi th Design Review Guidelines. The motion
was seconded by Ms. Jean Whitaker and carried a
unanimous vote.
HP-20-10, 234 Church St. (City) was presented by Mr.
Preston McClun. The Committee reviewed the request for
Historic Preservation Design Review approva l for
installation of a new front porch railing and a 6 ft. tall chain
link fence on a portion of the property line.
Mr. McClun stated the home was constructed circ a 1900
and was re novated around 1980. The house is mul ti-
5
storied with elements of Vernacul ar V ictorian style. The
home is characterized by its wooden si ding, cross gable
roof, pedimented entrances, and molded windows.
Mr. McClun added the proposed scope of work is the
installation of painted woo den porch railings on the front
elevation and construction of a 6ft. tall b lack coated chain
link fence along the front portion of the southern property
line.
Mr. Charles Clark was present to speak on behalf of t he
request.
After some discussion, Mr. Bill Buxton made a motion to
approve the request fo r the installation of a new por ch
railing in accordance with the materials, photographs, and
construction details submitted based on compliance with
Design Review Gu idelines. The motion was seconded by
Ms. Jean Whitaker and carried a unanimous vote.
Mr. B ill Buxton made a motion to den y the req uest to
install a 6ft. tall b lack chain link fence in accordance with
the material, photographs, and construction details
submitted based on co mpliance with Design R eview
Guidelines. The motion was seconded by Ms. J ean
Whiter and carried a unanimous vote.
HP-20-11, 311 W. Calhoun St. (City) was presented by
Mr. Preston McClun . The Committee reviewed the
request for Historic Preservation Design Review approval
for construction of a 288 sq. ft. accessory storage build ing
with vinyl siding.
Mr. McCl un stated the si ngle-family dwelling was
constructed in 1979 and renovated in 2012. This property
is not a contributing structure to the Hampton Park
Historic District. In 2012 the Design R eview Board
approved a request to convert the structure from a duplex
to a single-family residence.
Mr. McClun added the applicant is requesting to construct
a 288 sq. ft. accessory structure. The accessory structure
will be sided with vinyl siding that mimic s exi sting vinyl
siding on the pr incipal structure ’s second floor. The
roofing material used will mimic the existing dwelling ’s
roof.
6
Mr. John Dicks was present to speak on behalf of the
request.
After some discussion, Mr. Bill Buxton made a motion to
approve this request in accordance with the materials,
photographs, and construction details submitted based on
compliance with Design Review Guidelines. The motion
was seconded by Ms. Jean Whi taker and carried a
unanimous vote.
HP-20-13, 149 W. Calhoun St. (City) was presented by
Mr. Kyle Kelly . The Committee reviewed the request for
Historic Preservation Design Review approval for
construction of +/- 350 sq. ft. covered patio addition.
Mr. Kelly stated the si ngle-family dwelling was
constructed in 1928 and is Colonial Revival influenced.
The property is at the westernmost edge of the Historic
District Overlay.
Mr. Kelly added the applicant is requesting approval for a
+/- 350 sq. ft. addition to the rear of the existing structure
to serve as a cover ed patio. Based on the submitted
plans, the a ddition is intended to be of the simi lar
materials and colors as the existing structure.
After some discussion, Mr. Bill Buxton made a motion to
approve this request in accordance with the materials,
photographs, and construction details submitted based on
compliance with Design Review Guidelines. The motion
was seconded by Ms. Jean Whitaker and carried a
unanimous vote.
Reconsideration of HP-20-10, 234 Church St. (City)
Ms. Julie Herlong entertained a motion to recon sider HP-
20-10, 234 Church St. to consider approval of one of the
three alternative fence material and height options for the
6 ft. tall black chain link fence that was denied earlier in
the meeting.
Mr. Bill B uxton made a motion to recon sider HP -20-10,
234 Church St and the motion was seconded by Ms. Jean
Whitaker and carried a unanimous vote.
Mr. Bill Buxton made a motion to deny the request to
install a 6-ft. tall black chain link f ence. As an alternative,
Mr. Buxton mo ved that the committee approve th ree
alternative materials opt ions that would be acceptable in
7
the location proposed. The three options are:
1. 4-ft tall white vinyl picket-style fence
2. 4-ft tall white painted wood picket fence
3. 4-ft tall black extruded aluminum fence
The motion was seconded by Ms. Jean Whit aker and
carried a unanimous vote.
Planning Staff will work with the applicant to permit
installation of one of the three 4 ft. tall options.
OLD BUSINESS
HP-20-01, 4 28 W. Hampton Ave. (City) was presented
by Mr. Kyle Kelly . The Committee reviewed the request
for Historic Preservation Des ign Review ap proval for
exterior color palette.
Mr. Kelly mentioned this request was heard at the
meeting on February 27, 2020. The applicant is
submitting for color palette approval for the exterior of the
structure. Whirlpool is the color for the siding. The
proposed colors for the trim are Classic Light Buff or
Classical White. The applicant is also proposing to retain
the pink color of the gingerbread detail on the front porch.
After some discussion, Mr. Bill Buxton made a motion to
approve this request in acc ordance with the materials,
photographs, and construction details submitted based on
compliance with Design Review Guide lines. The motion
was seconded by Ms. Vivian Sharp and carried a
unanimous vote.
OTHER BUSINESS
Ms. Helen Roodman introduced Jerome Robinson as a
new member of the Historic Preservation Design Review
Committee. Ms. Roodman also introduce Kyle Kelly,
Senior Planner, to the Committee.
ADJOURNMENT
With no further business, Mr. William Buxton made a
motion to adjourn the meeting at 5:15 p.m. The motion
was seconded by Ms. Vivian Sharp and carried a
unanimous vote.
Respectfully submitted,
Kellie K. Chapman
Kellie K. Chapman, Board Secretary
8
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.