Minutes
City of Sumter · Sumter County · meeting of Feb 27, 2020 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
This document is no longer listed on City of Sumter's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
HISTORIC PRESERVATION
DESIGN REVIEW
Minutes of the Meeting
February 27, 2020
ATTENDANCE
A regular meeting of the Historic Preservation Design
Review Committee was held on Thursday, February 27,
2020, in the City Council Chambers located on the Four th
Floor of the Sumter Opera House. Five board members –
Ms. Vivian Sharp; Mr. William Buxton ; Ms. Heidi Burkett ;
Ms. Julie Herlong and Ms. Jean Whitaker were present.
Staff members present were: Ms. Helen Roodman , Mr.
Daniel Crum, Mr. Jeff Derwort and Ms. Kellie Chapman
The meeting was called to order at 4:30 p.m. by Ms. Julie
Herlong.
MINUTES
Ms. Julie Herlong asked the Board to accept the revi sed
agenda to move the Election of Officers to the end of the
meeting. Mr . William Buxton mad e a motion to approve
the revised agen da. The motion was seconded by Ms.
Vivian Sharp and carried a unanimous vote.
Ms. Vivian Sharp made a motion to approve the minutes of
the November 21, 2019 meeting as written. The motion
was seconded by Ms. Heidi Burkett and c arried a
unanimous vote.
NEW BUSINESS
Mr. William Buxton recused himself from this request.
HP-20-01, 428 W. Hampton St. (City) was presented by
Mr. Jeff Derwort. The Committee reviewed this request for
Historic Preservation Design Review appr oval for
renovations to include partial demolition and
reconstruction/repair of the roof, repair or replacem ent of
windows, siding, chimney, balusters and the addition of
two rear entr ances in order to convert the existing
structure into a duplex.
Mr. Derwort stated the dwelling was constructed in 188 1.
The building is a rectangular plan with cross gable roof.
2
The hous e has three bays with 4 over 4 do uble hung
windows with louvered shutters flanking the por ch. There
is a dingle do or ent rance with sid elights and a transom
with wide ga bled portico across the central portion of the
façade.
Mr. De rwort added the f ollowing exterior changes are
proposed:
Front Façade –
1. Repair existing paired 4 over 4 windows.
2. Repair roof with black architectural shingle.
3. Replace metal roof with similar metal roof.
4. Repair louvered shutters and paint.
5. Pressure w ash bri ck foundation and repair/repaint
where necessary. Add foundation vents – this
applies to entire structure.
6. Repair and replace missing baluster pieces on fron t
porch.
7. Build new brick stairs to front porch.
8. Clean, repair and repaint wood siding. Co lor to be
SW 9135 Whirlpool.
West Elevation
1. Repair existing paired 4 over 4 windows
2. In arear of new construction/rehabilitation,
3. New windows as shown – 4 over 4
a. Wooden siding profile and color to match
front façade.
b. New roofline – hipped roof with 6:12 pitch.
Black architectural shingles.
Rear Elevation
1. New windows as shown 4 over 4
2. Wooden siding profile and color to match front
façade.
3. Two new entry rear doors. One for each dwelling
unit.
4. New roofline – hipped roof with 6:12 pitch. Black
architectural shingles.
East Elevation
1. Repair existing paired 4 over 4 windows
2. Chimney to be cleaned, repaired and repointed.
3. In areas of new construction/rehabilitation,
a. New windows as shown in elevation – 4 over
4
b. Wooden siding profile and color to match
3
front façade.
c. New roofline – hipped roof with 6:12 pitch.
Black architectural shingles.
Mr. Chris Green, Mr. Lee Chapman , and Mr. Ernest
Green were present to speak on behalf of this request.
After some discussion, Ms. Vivian Sharp made a motion
to approve the partial demolition and reconstruction/repair
of the roof, repair or replacement of windows, siding,
chimney, balusters and the addition of two rear entrances
in order to convert the existing structure into a duplex in
accordance with the materials, photographs, and
construction details submitted based on compliance with
Design Review Guidelines. The Design Review
Committee deferred color palett e approv al pending
physical samples. The motion was seconded by Ms. Heidi
Burkett and carried a unanimous vote.
HP-20-02, 100 W. Liberty St. (City) was presented by
Mr. Daniel Crum . The Committee reviewed the request
for Historic Preservation Design Review approval for
installation of an emergency exit door.
Mr. Crum stated the applicant is requesting historic district
design review approval to install an emergency e xit door
on the eastern portion of the structure along S. Sumter
St., which will accompany new interior renovati ons t o
accommodate two new tenants.
Mr. Crum added this work is req uired in order to compl y
with required building and life safety codes.
Mr. Mack Ko lb was present to speak on behalf of the
request.
After some discussion, Mr. William Buxton made a motion
to approve this request in accordance w ith the materials,
photographs, and construction details submitted based on
compliance with Design Review Guidelines. The motion
was seconded by Ms. Vivian Sharp and carried a
unanimous vote.
HP-20-03, 438 W. Hampton St . (City) was presented by
Mr. Daniel Crum. The Committee reviewed the request for
Historic Preservation Design Review approval
for the
construction of a new si ngle-family dwelling with attached
rear garage.
4
Mr. Crum stated the applicant intends to utilize this
property to const ruct a new si ngle-family dwelling. The
structure will be clad in vinyl siding and windows, black
architectural shingles, with wooden porch columns and
fixtures. The proposed structure is a simple,
straightforward design that draws ins piration fro m
elements of shotgun style houses.
Mr. Crum added due to the varied time of development for
the homes on W. Hampton Ave., setbacks for other homes
in the surrounding area are inconsistent, with several of
the neighboring dwellings encroac hing into setbacks
areas, or over property lines. Front setbacks in this area
vary from as little as approximately eight (8) ft. to nearly
sixty (60) ft. The proposed 25 f t. setback is smaller than
the 40- 45 ft. setbacks f or the adjacent structures. T he
proposed structure will be located eight (8) ft. from the
eastern property line and will be located 25 ft. from the
western property line to accommodate the driveway.
Mr. Crum mentioned the porch is lacking some finer
design details found elsewhere in the district, such as
bases and caps for the support columns . While the
arrangement of the windows and doors on the front
elevation are consistent with the rhythm and spacing found
elsewhere in the district, the placement of windows
elsewhere on the struc ture is less conventional . T he
window openings for the structure are configured to match
the unconventional floor plan, and as a result are not
uniform in location and spac ing lik e other homes in the
district. Surrounding homes have their windows more
evenly distributed throughout the length of the structure.
Mr. Patrick En zor was pres ent to speak in favor of the
request.
Mr. Jim Crawley, Ms. Marla Talley, Ms. Colleen Yates, and
Mr. Paul Shivar were present to speak in opposition of the
request.
After some discussion, M s. Vivian Sharp made a motion
to defer this request so that building plans could be
modified to add addit ional architec tural detailing and
address window placement on the si de facades to make
sure the structure is more compatible with the District as a
whole. The motion was secon ded by Ms. Heidi Burkett
and carried a unanimous vote.
5
OLD BUSINESS
None
ELECTION OF
OFFICERS
Ms. Julie Herlong accepted nominations for Chair for
2020.
Mr. William Buxton nominated Ms. Julie Herlong, the
nomination was seconded by Ms. Heidi Burkett and
carried a unanimous vote.
Ms. Julie Herlong accepted nominations for Co-Chair for
2020.
Ms. Jean Whitaker nominated Mr. William Buxton, the
nomination was seconded by Ms. Heidi Burkett and
carried a unanimous vote.
OTHER BUSINESS
Ms. Helen Roodman mentioned that once we are notified
of the Historic Preservation training date and times we will
pass along the information to each board member.
ADJOURNMENT
With no further business, Mr. William Buxton made a
motion to adjourn the meeting at 5:55 p.m. The motion
was seconded by Ms. Jean Whitaker and carried a
unanimous vote.
Respectfully submitted,
Kellie K. Chapman
Kellie K. Chapman, Board Secretary
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.