BOA-25-14, Borden Rd. (County) - Staff Report
City of Sumter · Sumter County · Other
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Sumter City-County
Board of Zoning Appeals
May 14, 2025
BOA-25-14, Black River Rd., Borden Rd.,
Cimmaron Rd., Log Cabin Rd., & New Hope
Church Rd. (County)
The applicant (TOCE SC Solar 1, LLC) is requesting that the Sumter City-
County Board of Zoning Appeals grant special exception approval for the
establishment of a utility scale (+/- 170 MWac) primary photovoltaic solar
energy system on multiple parcels of land with frontage along or near Black
River Rd., Borden Rd., Cimmaron Rd., Log Cabin Rd., & New Hope Church Rd.
pursuant to Article 3, Exhibit 5: Permitted Uses in All Zoning Districts; Article
5.b.2: Enumeration of Certain Hazardous and/or Potential Disruptive Land
Development Activities, and Article 5.b.3.f: Primary Photovoltaic Solar Energy
Systems of the Sumter County Zoning & Development Standards Ordinance
(the “Ordinance”). The applicant is also requesting consideration for setback
area reductions pursuant to Article 5.b.3.f. of the Ordinance. The property is
within the Agricultural Conservation (AC) zoning district. The property consists
of multiple Sumter County tax map parcels, as follows: TMS# 139-00-01-038,
139-00-01-043, 139-00-02-001, 139-00-02-002, 140-00-02-009, 140-00-02-
033, 147-00-01-016, 148-00-03-001, 139-00-01-004, 148-00-02-038, 148-00-
02-009, & 147-00-02-042 (part).
2
Sumter City-County
Zoning Board of Appeals
May 14, 2025
BOA-25-14, Pinewood Rd, Starks Ferry Rd, S. St. Paul’s Church Rd, & Gwyndale Rd.
(County)
I. THE REQUEST
Applicant: TOCE SC Solar 1, LLC
Status of the Applicant: Authorized Agent
Request: Request for Special Exception approval for the establishment of a
utility scale 170 MWac photovoltaic solar energy system on
multiple parcels of land with frontage along or near Black River
Rd., Borden Rd., Cimmaron Rd., Log Cabin Rd., & New Hope
Church Rd., and a request for 50% project setback reductions
along Black River Rd. frontage.
County Council District: District 1
Location: Black River Rd., Borden Rd., Cimmaron Rd., Log Cabin Rd., &
New Hope Church Rd.
Present Use/Zoning: Agricultural/Undeveloped / Agriculture Conservation (AC)
Tax Map Reference: 139-00-01-038, 139-00-01-043, 139-00-02-001, 139-00-02-002,
140-00-02-009, 140-00-02-033, 147-00-01-016, 148-00-03-001,
139-00-01-004, 148-00-02-038, 148-00-02-009, & 147-00-02-
042 (part)
II. B ACKGROUND
The applicant (TOCE SC Solar 1, LLC) is seeking
approval to establish a Primary Photovoltaic Solar
Energy System along or near Black River Rd., Borden
Rd., Cimmaron Rd., Log Cabin Rd., & New Hope
Church Rd. The project will be located on an
assemblage of land that is +/- 1,763-acres in total size.
The fenced development area for the project will be
+/- 1,158-acres in total. The facility is being designed
to be a 170- megawatt alternating current (MWac),
3
2277-megawatt direct current (MWdc) single- axis tracker utility scale solar facility. Support
facilities will include an interconnection point, substation, transformers, inverters, etc.
The project is located in the north central area of Sumter County, southeast of the Rembert area
and north of the Dalzell area. The project area generally extends from New Hope Church Rd. in
the north to Borden Rd. in the south and Mayrant Rd. in the west to Black River Rd. and
Settlement Rd. in the east. The full limits of the project parcel boundaries, as well the fenced
development area boundaries are shown on the project boundary map graphic below.
Above: Project Boundary Map
In accordance with Article 3, Exhibit 5 of the Sumter County Zoning & Development Standards
Ordinance (the “Ordinance), Primary Photovoltaic Energy Systems (NAICS 221114) require
special exception approval in all districts where they can be established. The Sumter City-County
Zoning Board of Appeals (BOA) reviews all special exception requests for adherence to the
applicable criteria outlined in the Ordinance, holds a public hearing, and ultimately decides on
whether the request meets all the criteria for approval.
Per submitted application documents, the applicant is a subsidiary of Treat Oak Clean Energy,
LLC. According to information on the Treaty Oak Clean Energy, LLC website
(www.treatyoakcleanenergy.com), the company develops, builds, and operates utility- scale solar
and battery storage project in select U.S. markets. Website information shows the company
recently broke ground on a 100- megawatt project in Arkansas, and that the company recently
acquired 2 existing facilities with a combined total of 465 -megawatts of solar production and
4
storage. It is the staff’s understanding that the applicant plans to develop, own, and directly
oversee the operations in the long term for this proposed project.
A key component of the applicant’s decision to site this project at this proposed location is the
combination of available large acreage holdings in close proximity to a Santee Cooper
transmission line. This transmission line traverses the project area boundary.
Major components of the project are anticipated to include separate clusters of fenced solar panel
arrays, a substation, a switchyard, an operation and maintenance yard, and an interconnection
point.
The above referenced components are to be located within the project boundary as shown on the
site plan graphic below. Note that the site plan submitted is high level plan , with more detailed
area plans included within Exhibit 4.
Above: General Site Development Plan Graphic
5
Multiple documents have been submitted to support this request. A table outlining all exhibits is
included below. References to these exhibits are made throughout the report.
Exhibit Table
Exhibit 1 Staff Recommended Conditions of Approval
Exhibit 2 Applicant Letter of Intent & Executive Summary
Exhibit 3 BOA Application Form & Additional Request Narrative
Exhibit 4 Overall Site Layout & 10% Design Plans
Exhibit 5 Interconnection Study Agreement & Generation Queue Report
Exhibit 6 Property Control Agreement Memos
Exhibit 7 Applicant Community Outreach
Exhibit 8 Landscape Buffer Plan
Exhibit 9 Viewshed Analysis
Exhibit 10 Glare Analysis
Exhibit 11 Draft Decommissioning Plan
Exhibit 12 Wetlands & Waterbodies Field Delineation Memo
Exhibit 13 Protected Species Habitat Suitability Report
Exhibit 14 Airfield Buffer Map
Exhibit 15 SCDAH ArchSite Map
Exhibit 16 Project Wildlife Corridor Map
Ordinance Amendment (OA-23-01 & OA-24-06)
Sumter County Council adopted Ordinance Amendment OA -23-01 on December 12, 2023. This
amendment put in established c omprehensive primary solar facility development requirements.
Sumter County Council amended these requirements via Ordinance Amendment OA -24-06 on
December 10, 2024. The OA -24-06 revisions primarily refined setback requirements to account
for situations not previously anticipated.
III. LAND USE, ZONING, AND CONDITIONS
The project area is located in the north- central portion of Sumter County on or around Black
River Rd., Borden Rd., Cimmaron Rd., Log Cabin Rd., & New Hope Church Rd. The land
proposed for this project is owned by various individuals and entities, with the applicant entering
into lease agreements with these various individuals and entities.
The land in vicinity of the project area is characterized as rural, with a mixture of agricultural
land uses, low -density residential land uses, and property that is not developed or used for any
man-made purpose. The project area is directly adjacent to both residential uses and undeveloped
or non- residentially used parcels. The project area completely bounds a small low density
residential enclave or around Cimmaron Rd., Hines Rd., and Malcolm Ln.
6
Above: Adjacent Land Use Map
The subject property is completely located
within the Agricultural Conservation (AC)
zoning district. The intent of this district is
to protect and preserve areas of the county
which are presently rural or agricultural in
character and use and are uniquely suited
to agricultural use. Where urban
development is permitted within the
district, strict quality standards should be
required.
As stated previously in this
report, Primary Photovoltaic Solar Energy
Systems (NAICS 221114) can be
established in the AC zoning district via
the special exception approval process.
Above: Zoning Map
All development shown on submitted plans will occur within FEMA FIRM Panel:
45085C0105F. Land designated as special flood hazard area (SFHA) exists within the project
7
area to the south of Borden Rd. However, per submitted plans no development is proposed in the
SFHA.
National Wetland Inventory (NWI) data identifies potential areas of wetland within the project
boundary. Staff notes that NWI data is used as a guide only and is not a substitute for a wetland’s
delineation prepared by a qualified professional. The applicant has completed a wetland’s
delineation, and these boundaries are shown on the site plan submitted for this request and
supporting wetland delineation documentation. The applicant is not proposing to disturb
delineated wetland areas or disturb land within 50 ft. of such areas.
Above: Floodplain Map Above: NWI Map
IV. SPECIAL EXCEPTION REVIEW CRITERIA
In the AC zoning district under Article 3, Exhibit 5, Primary Solar Electric Power G eneration
uses under NAICS 221114 are considered special exception uses requiring the review and
approval of the BOA. Such requests are evaluated in accordance with Article 1.h.4.c., and Article
5.b.3.f. of the Ordinance.
Article 1.h.4.c.2: Special Exceptions:
Permits for Special Exceptions shall be evaluated by the B oard on the basis of the following
criteria:
a. That the Special Exception complies with all applicable development standards contained
elsewhere in this Ordinance, including landscaping and bufferyards, off -street parking,
and dimensional requirements.
Staff Review: A full review of the special design criteria outlined in Article 5.b.3.f of the
Ordinance is provided elsewhere in this report. Outside of Article 5.b.3.f items, the project is
in general compliance with Ordinance requirements in as much as can be determined from
the 10% design plans submitted with this request.
8
b. That the special exception will be in substantial harmony with the area in which it is
located.
Staff Review: The applicant has submitted site and landscape buffering plans, as well as
numerous documents and studies to support the ir position that the project will be in
substantial harmony with the area in which it is located. All such plans, documents , and
studies submitted are attached as exhibits to this report and include a Site L ayout & 10%
Design Plans (See Exhibit 4), Landscape Buffer Plans ( See Exhibit 8), a Viewshed Analysis
(See Exhibit 9) , a Glare Analysis ( See Exhibit 10), a Wetlands & Waterbodies Field
Delineation Memo (See Exhibit 12), and a Protected Species Habitat Suitability Report ( See
Exhibit 13).
c. That the special exception will not discourage or negate the use of surrounding property
use(s) permitted by right.
Staff Review: The project area is located in a area of the county characterized as rural and is
bounded by land used for either agricultural, residential, or institutional purposes or by land
that is otherwise undeveloped. The applicant intends (and must) comply with applicable
setback and landscaping requirements. The applicant is proposing to install landscaping
buffers in identified areas where existing vegetation will not meet the required standards. As
referenced above, the applicant has submitted site and landscape buffering plans, as well as
numerous documents and studies to support their position that the project will not discourage
or negate the use of surrounding property for uses(s) permitted by right . See referenced
exhibits noted above under point b.
Article 5.b.3.f. Primary Photovoltaic Solar Energy Systems (NAICS 221114)
1. All ground-mounted photovoltaic solar energy system projects shall observe the
following minimum setbacks:
a. From Roadways:
i. All Public Roads with a Functional Classification of Principal Arterial or
Minor Arterial – 300 ft. from property line.
ii. All Other Public roads – 200 ft. from property line.
iii. Private Roads – 50 ft. from the platted right-of-way line.
Staff Review: The project area does not have frontage on a public road that is classified as a
principal or minor arterial. Proposed setbacks from other public roads, with the exception of
Black River Rd., meet the required setback standard. Setbacks shown along all private roads
meet the required standard. Pursuant to Article 5.b.3.f.1.f ., the BOA may consider up to a
50% setback reduction along non- arterial roadways if the BOA finds that certain conditions
can be demonstrated . Further analysis of the setback reduction request is provided below.
Setback requirements are restated in the proposed conditions of approval, and the applicant
must comply. This will be reviewed again at the time of formal site plan submission.
9
b. When abutting adjacent residentially used parcels regardless of zoning district: 200 ft.
from property line.
Staff Review: Proposed setbacks from abutting adjacent residential used parcels meet the
required standard. Setback requirements are restated in the proposed conditions of approval,
and the applicant must comply. This will be reviewed again at the time of formal site plan
submission.
c. When abutting adjacent undeveloped parcels in Residential Zoning Districts: 200 ft.
from property line.
Staff Review: The project area is not adjacent to any undeveloped parcels in a residential
zoning district. Setback requirements are restated in the proposed conditions of approval, and
the applicant must comply. This will be reviewed again at the time of formal site plan
submission.
d. When abutting adjacent non- residentially used parcels in the Agricultural,
Conservation, Commercial, and Industrial Zoning Districts: 100 ft. from property
line.
Staff Review: Proposed setbacks from abutting adjacent non- residentially used parcels meet
the required standard. Setback requirements are restated in the proposed conditions of
approval, and the applicant must comply. This will be reviewed again at the time of formal
site plan submission.
e. When a project area is comprised of multiple abutting tax parcels, there shall be no
setback required between parcels that are part of the internal project area.
Staff Review: The project consists of multiple parcels of land that will be leased for the
purposes of developing this project area. No setbacks are proposed along internal project area
parcel lines.
f. Reductions to project setbacks:
i. The Board of Zoning Appeals may reduce the setback along Public Roads
that are not classified as principal arterial or minor arterial by up to 50%
when it can be demonstrated that specific project site topography and/or
environmental conditions on a site necessitate placement closer to a roadway
to maintain appropriate separation from environmentally sensitive site
features and steep slopes.
ii. Individual residential property owners may waive the 200 ft. setback
requirement to reduce the setback to 100 ft. It shall be the responsibility of
the developer/applicant to acquire the necessary approvals from adjacent
residential property owners. Said waiver shall be in the form of a legally
10
binding notarized agreement. A copy of the executed agreement shall be
provided with the formal application for use approval.
Staff Review: The applicant is requesting a 50% setback reduction along Black River Rd.,
which is functionally classified as a major collector road. The applicant has cited the
existence of wetland areas and steep topography associated with a stream and wetland
drainage system. The applicant’s detailed justification for this reduction request is included
in the additional request narrative provided in Exhibit 3.
No setback waivers from adjacent residentially used property are being proposed by the
applicant.
g. The above -referenced setbacks shall be interpreted to apply to all improved areas
associated with the project(s). This provision excludes any internal access roads,
security fencing, and permanent stormwater facilities, however; internal access roads,
fences, and stormwater facilities shall be located behind the buffers required in
Article 5.b.3.f.10. The established setback shall apply to all arrays, storage areas,
battery storage, inverters, and transformers. The poles and aerial lines necessary to
deliver electricity to the power grid may be located in the setback so l ong as all
necessary buffering is maintained as required in Article 5.b.3.f.10.
Staff Review: Submitted plans indicate substantial compliance with this requirement.
Setback requirements are restated in the proposed conditions of approval, and the applicant
must comply. This will be reviewed again at the time of formal site plan submission.
2. All access roads and storage areas shall be established on a fire code compliant 2 0-foot
minimum easement to a public right-of-way.
Staff Review: Access roads shown on site plan s are described as being 12 ft. wide. No
easement area is shown. Additional information is required, as staff cannot determine if the
proposal meets this standard. Staff has included this requirement as a recommended
conditional of approval. See Exhibit 4.
3. All ground ground- mounted photovoltaic solar energy systems shall be enclosed by a
perimeter security fence that is wildlife friendly and of a height that meets the National
Electric Code (NEC) without the use of barbed wire. Said fencing shall be installed
behind required buffers and shall not be visible from public rights of way. In addition to
the use of wildlife friendly fencing, solar developments shall be designed to provide
unfenced wildlife passageways of a size, scale, and number appropriate for a given
development size in order to allow large mammals such as deer, coyotes, and bears to
traverse the area.
Staff Review: Based on information submitted by the applicant, the facility will be enclosed
by a wildlife friendly security fence that is ( 8) feet in height. A drawing detail of the
proposed wildlife fence is included in the 10% design plan documents (See Exhibit 4). The
11
applicant has submitted a graphic demonstrating proposed wildlife passages through the
project area (See Exhibit 16).
4. All ground-mounted photovoltaic solar collectors shall be limited to a maximum height
of 15 feet above the ground when oriented at maximum tilt. The provision shall not
include the interconnection poles, substation equipment, or other devices necessary for
the electricity to be delivered to the public utility station.
Staff Review: The applicant acknowledges in their BOA application form that this provision,
and all other provisions of Article 5.b.3.f. (except for the stated setback exemption request)
will be complied within. This requirement is being restated in the proposed conditions of
approval document. See Exhibit 3.
5. On-site electrical interconnections and power lines shall be installed underground
wherever reasonably practical.
Staff Review: The applicant acknowledges in their BOA application form that this provision,
and all other provisions of Article 5.b.3.f. (except for state setback exemption request) will be
complied with. This requirement is being restated in the proposed conditions of approval
document. See Exhibit 3.
6. The applicant has the burden of proving that glare produced from a primary photovoltaic
solar energy system will not have a significant adverse impact on aviation interests,
motor vehicle traffic, or neighboring properties. Submission of a glare assessment
prepared by a qualified professional is required.
Staff Review: A glare analysis prepared by HDR and dated April 18, 2025 has been
submitted. The analysis indicates that no glare was shown along the approach paths to the
runways at Shaw Air Force Base or at its Air Traffic Control Tower; no glare was shown
along roadway routes surrounding the Project; and no glare was shown at eight of nine single
observation points nearby the Project. One observation point was modeled to have
insignificant glare without adverse effects. See Exhibit 10.
7. For all locations within 5 nautical miles of the center point of the runway for Shaw
Airforce Base, Poinsett Electronic Combat Range (ECR) and the Sumter County Airport:
a. The applicant shall provide documented proof of having notified the Shaw
Airforce Base/Poinsett ECR Military Base Commander, or the Commander’s
representative and/or the Sumter County Airport Director of a Photovoltaic Solar
Energy System proposal.
b. The applicant shall allow 21 days for written comments to be provided from these
agencies. Any written comments received shall be submitted with the Special
Exception use application.
12
Staff Review: No part of the project area is within 5 nautical miles of the center point of the
runway for Shaw Airforce Base or the Sumter County Airport, nor is the project area within
5 nautical miles of the center point for Poinsett Electronic Combat Range. See Exhibit 14.
8. It shall be demonstrated that the Photovoltaic Solar Energy System will not unreasonably
interfere with the view of, or from, significant sites of public interest such as public parks
and historic sites and resources.
Staff Review: The South Carolina Department of Archives and History (SCDAH) ArchS ite
Application Database does not indicate that a historic site or resource is within the project
area or within a distance to the project area that would cause interference to such a site. There
are not any public parks within the general vicinity of the project area. See Exhibit 15.
9. Written documentation of an agreement with an electric utility provider for
interconnection of the completed facility shall be submitted at time of Special Exception
application. In lieu of a final executed interconnection agreement, documentation from
the electric utility provider that such a request is in process and under consideration may
be accepted at the discretion of the Sumter City -County Zoning Board of Appeals. Once
constructed, the project shall provide a copy of the signed certification of completion
from the electric utility prior to issuance of the certificate of occupancy for the system.
Staff Review: The applicant has provided a copy of the interconnection study agreement
with Santee Cooper, as documentation supporting the interconnection of the project to the
Santee Cooper Dalzell-Camden 230 Kv line. See Exhibit 5.
It is noted that in a typical solar facility project life cycle, permit and use approvals are
usually obtained prior to final interconnection approval from an electrical utility.
10. Landscape Buffering: A minimum 50 ft. wide landscape buffer containing evergreen
vegetation screening is required to obscure solar energy system s from public rights of
way and residential uses on adjacent parcels. Buffers shall meet the following minimum
criteria:
a. Existing Vegetation: Existing mature trees and shrubs shall be retained in the
required setback areas . Dead trees and shrubs may be removed in the setback
area. Said vegetation shall be supplemented to ensure a year -round evergreen
vegetative visual screen of at least 6 ft. in height over 3 growing seasons and not
less than 20 ft. in height at maturity.
b. Additional Plantings: Where existing vegetation is insufficient for required
screening, a planting plan shall be developed and submitted that creates a year -
round evergreen vegetative visual screen of at least 6 ft. in height over 3 growing
seasons and not less than 20 ft. in height at maturity. The planting plan shall
utilize a variety of evergreen species to avoid the creation of a monoculture
vegetative buffer.
13
c. Maintenance: All new plantings must include an irrigation system that shall be
maintained until all plant materials are fully established and thriving; dead or
diseased plant materials shall be replaced within 60 days of notification by the
County. It shall be the developer’s responsibility to ensure all buffer plants remain
healthy and thriving. Failure to replace dying, diseased or plants failing to thrive
constitutes a violation of the Ordinance and may result in enforcement action in
accordance with Article 1 of the Ordinance.
Staff Review: Submitted site and landscape plans indicate that a 50 ft. buffer is provided
along public rights of way and residential uses on adjacent parcels. It is noted that existing
vegetation within setback area s must be retained as required. The applicant is proposing to
primarily use existing vegetation to meet landscape buffering requirements, with buffer yard
planting installations in areas not completely screened by existing vegetation. Buffer yard
plantings will be installed as shown on plans and supporting information provided by the
applicant. See Exhibit 4, Exhibit 8, & Exhibit 9.
11. For primary photovoltaic energy systems developed in the Agricultural Conservation
(AC) and Conservation (CP) zoning districts – sites sh all be designed and developed
using native ground cover/vegetation and other best practices as outlined in the Technical
Guidance for the Development of Wildlife & Pollinator Habitat at Solar Farms (South
Carolina Solar Habitat Act – March 2021) document or similar best practices documents.
Staff Review: The applicant acknowledges in their BOA application form that this provision,
and all other provisions of Article 5.b.3.f. (except for stated setback exemption request) will
be complied within. This requirement is being restated in the proposed conditions of approval
document. See Exhibit 3.
12. Decommissioning Plan
a. Satisfactory completion of a Decommissioning Plan, per Appendix D. The
Decommissioning Plan shall be recorded at the Sumter County Register of Deeds
and be included with any leasing documents/agreements with the property owner.
Staff Review: A draft decommissioning plan has been submitted with this request. The plan
outlines many of the components addressed in Appendix D but includes additional
information and commentary. It is a recommended condition of approval that a
decommissioning plan addressing all items outlined in Appendix D be recorded at the Sumter
County Registers of Deeds prior to building permit approval for the project. See Exhibit 16
13. Decommissioning Surety:
a. A form of surety equal to 125% of the entire cost to decommission the primary
photovoltaic solar energy facility, as approved, is required. Decommissioning
costs shall be estimated by an engineer licensed to practice in the State of South
Carolina and approved by the Sumter County Administrator and Sumter County
Attorney.
14
Note: Salvage/recycling value of system elements/components may be taken into
account as part of the decommissioning cost estimates.
b. The surety is required to cover the costs of decommissioning the primary
photovoltaic solar energy facility. Decommissioning costs shall include all work
as described in the recorded Decommissioning Plan.
c. The surety can be in the from of cash, cashier’s check, certified check, certificate
of deposit, negotiable U.S. Treasury securities, performance bond, irrevocable
letter of credit, or other instrument readily convertible into cash at face value. If
utilizing a bond to cover the required surety, the bond shall have a rating of AAA.
d. The surety can be made directly to Sumter County or be placed in escrow within a
financial institution designated as an official depository of Sumter County.
e. Following initial submittal of the surety, the cost calculation shall be reviewed
every (5) years and adjusted accordingly based upon an updated estimate
provided by an engineer licensed to practice in the State of South Carolina.
Update estimates must be reviewed and approved by the Sumter County
Administrator and Sumter County Attorney. In the case of cost increase, the
surety instrument used must be updated to reflect 125% of the entire cost to
decommission the primary photovoltaic energy facility.
f. Failure to comply with any of the requirements outlined in Article 5.b.3.f.13 shall
result in the immediate termination and revocation of all prior approvals and
permits; further, Sumter County shall be entitled to make immediate demand
upon, and/or retain any proceeds of the surety, which shall be used for
decommissioning and/or removal of the primary photovoltaic solar energy
facility, even if such facility is operational.
Staff Review: The applicant has submitted preliminary cost estimates for decommissioning
as part of their decommissioning plan. Such estimates are considered preliminary at this time
and must be updated as required if the project is formally approved. All Article 5.b.3.f. 13
items are required and have been included in the recommended conditions of approval. See
Exhibit 11.
V. STAFF RECOMMENDATION
Staff has developed recommended conditions of approval for the project that are outlined in
Exhibit 1 of this report. If the BOA makes the findings necessary to approve this request, then it
is recommended that such approval be made contingent upon compliance with Exhibit 1
approval conditions.
15
V. DRAFT MOTIONS FOR BOA-25-14
1. I move that the Zoning Board of Appeals approve BOA-25-14, subject to the following
findings of fact and conclusions:
2. I move that the Zoning Board of Appeals deny BOA-25-14, subject to the following
findings of fact and conclusions:
3. I move that the Zoning Board of Appeals enter an alternative motion for BOA-25-14.
NOTE: STATE DEFINITIVIE REASONING FOR ANY MOTION MADE
VI. BOARD OF APPEALS – May 14, 2025
Exhibit 1
BOA-25-14 – Black River Rd., Borden Rd., Cimmaron Rd., Log Cabin Rd., & New Hope
Church Rd. (County
Proposed Conditions of Approval
1. The project shall be developed in substantial conformance with site layout plan titled
“White Palmetto Site Layout Plan”, prepared by Treaty Oak Clean Energy and site design
plans titled, “10% Solar Photovoltaic Civil Design of White Palmetto for TOCE SC Solar
1, prepared by KWRE and presented to the Zoning Board of Appeals on May 14, 2025,
after necessary adjustments and revisions are made to bring the project into conformity
with all other approval conditions listed below, as applicable.
The project shall be developed in substantial conformance with the landscape buffering
plan titled “White Palmetto Landscape Buffer Plan” prepared by Treaty Oak Clean Energy
and the landscape buffer plan enlargements and planting details prepared by Treaty Oak
Clean Energy and presented to the Zoning Board of Appeals on May 14, 2025.
2. The applicant shall submit to the Sumter City -County Planning Department a complete
General Development Plan application or Major Site Plan application for the project no
later than 6 months after to the date of special exception approval. The applicant shall make
continued good faith efforts in completing the General Development Plan or Major Site
Plan process after submission.
Note: Refer to Article 1.i.8. of the Sumter County Zoning & Development Standards
Ordinance.
3. Documentation of correspondence with and responses from the US Fish & Wildlife Service
(UFWS) and the South Carolina Department of Natural Resources concerning the project
shall be submitted to the Planning Department prior to major site plan approval for any
aspect of this project. Site plans must incorporate and/or address any mitigation measures
identified by these agencies.
4. Documentation of correspondence with and responses from the South Carolina Department
of Archives and History (SCDAH) or State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO)
concerning the project shall be submitted to the Planning Department prior to major site
plan approval for any aspect of this project. If a Memorandum of Agreement with this
agency or with the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation (ACHP) is required, then an
executed copy of this agreement shall be submitted to the Planning Department prior to
major site plan approval . Site plans must incorporate and/or address any mitigation
measures identified by these agencies.
5. All ground- mounted photovoltaic solar energy systems shall observe the minimum
setbacks outlined in Article 5.b.3.f.1.
2
6. All access roads and project storage areas shall be established on a fire code compliant 20-
foot minimum easement to a public right-of-way.
7. All ground-mounted photovoltaic solar energy systems shall be enclosed by a perimeter
security fence that is wildlife friendly and of a height that meets the National Electric Code
(NEC) without the use of barbed wire. Said fencing shall be installed behind required
buffers and shall not be visible from public rights of way.
In addition to the use of wildlife friendly fencing, solar developments shall be designed to
provide unfenced wildlife passageways of a size, scale, and number appropriate for a given
development size in order to allow large mammals such as deer, coyotes, and bears to
traverse the area. At the discretion of the Zoning Board of Appeals, additional passageways
from those provided may be required.
8. On-site electrical interconnections and power lines associated with this project shall be
installed underground wherever reasonably practical.
9. A final executed copy of the interconnection agreement with the utility provider shall be
submitted to the Sumter City-County Planning Department prior to land disturbance permit
approval.
10. Landscape buffering for the project shall be required as follows:
A minimum 50 ft. wide landscaping buffer containing evergreen vegetation screening
obscuring solar energy system perimeters from public rights of way and residential uses on
adjacent parcels. Buffer shall meet the following minimum criteria:
a. Existing Vegetation: Existing mature trees and shrubs shall be retained in the required
setback areas . Dead trees and shrubs may be removed in the setbacks area. Said
vegetation shall be supplemented to ensure a year-round evergreen vegetative visual
screen of at least 6 ft. in height over three growing seasons and not less than 20 ft. in
height at maturity.
b. Additional Plantings: Where existing vegetation is insufficient for required screening,
a planting plan shall be developed and submitted that creates a year -round evergreen
vegetative visual screen of at least 6 ft. in height over three growing seasons and not
less than 20 ft, in height at maturity. The planting plan shall utilize a variety of
evergreen species to avoid the creation of a monoculture vegetative buffer.
c. Maintenance: All new plantings must include an irrigation system that shall be
maintained until all plant materials are fully established and thriving; dead or diseased
plant materials shall be replaced within 60 days of notification by the County. It shall
be the developer’s responsibility to ensure all buffer plants remain healthy and thriving.
Failure to replace dying, diseased or plants failing to thrive constitutes a violation of
the Ordinance and may result in enforcement action in accordance with Article 1 of the
Ordinance.
11. Developed areas shall be designed and developed using native ground/cover vegetation as
outlined in the Technical Guidance for the Development of Wildlife & Pollinator Habitat
3
at Solar Farms (South Carolina Solar Habitat Act – March 2021) document or similar best
practices document.
12. A Decommissioning Plan addressing all items required per Appendix D of the Sumter
County Zoning & Development Standards Ordinance must be recorded at the Sumter
County Register of Deeds prior to land disturbance permit approval.
13. The project must comply with the following Decommissioning Surety requirements prior
to building/electric permit approval:
a. A form of surety equal to 125% of the entire cost to decommission the primary
photovoltaic solar energy facility, as approved, is required. Decommissioning costs
shall be estimated by an engineer licensed to practice in the State of South Carolina
and approved by the Sumter County Administrator and Sumter County Attorney.
Note: Salvage/recycling value of system elements/components may be taken into
account as part of decommissioning cost estimates.
b. The surety is required to cover the full costs of decommissioning the primary
photovoltaic solar energy facility. Decommissioning costs shall include all work as
described in the recorded Decommissioning Plan.
c. The surety shall be in the form of cash, cashier’s check, certified check, certificate of
deposit, negotiable U.S. Treasury securities, performance bond, irrevocable letter of
credit, or other instrument readily convertible into cash at face value. If utilizing a bond
to cover the required surety, the bond shall have a rating of AAA.
d. The surety may be made directly to Sumter County or be placed in escrow within a
financial institution designated as an official depository of Sumter County.
e. Following initial submittal of the surety, the cost calculation shall be reviewed every
five (5) years and adjusted accordingly based upon an updated estimate provided by an
engineer licensed to practice in the State of South Carolina. Updated estimates must be
reviewed and approved by the Sumter County Administrator and Sumter County
Attorney. In the case of cost increase, the surety instrument used must be updated to
reflect 125% of the entire cost to decommission the primary photovoltaic solar energy
facility.
f. Failure to comply with any of the requirements outlined in Article 5.b.3.f.13 shall
result in the immediate termination and revocation of all prior approvals and permits;
further, Sumter County shall be entitled to make immediate demand upon, and/or retain
any proceeds of, the surety, which shall be used for decommissioning and/or removal
of the primary photovoltaic solar energy facility, even if such facility is operational.
16
LIST OF EXHIBITS
Multiple documents have been submitted to support this request. A table outlining all exhibits is
included below, with hyperlinks to copies of each exhibit available via web. References to these
exhibits are made throughout the report.
Exhibit 1 Staff Recommended Conditions of Approval
Exhibit 2 Applicant Letter of Intent & Executive Summary
Exhibit 3 BOA Application Form & Additional Request Narrative
Exhibit 4 Overall Site Layout & 10% Design Plans
Exhibit 5 Interconnection Study Agreement & Generation Queue Report
Exhibit 6 Property Control Agreement Memos
Exhibit 7 Applicant Community Outreach
Exhibit 8 Landscape Buffer Plan
Exhibit 9 Viewshed Analysis
Exhibit 10 Glare Analysis
Exhibit 11 Draft Decommissioning Plan
Exhibit 12 Wetlands & Waterbodies Field Delineation Memo
Exhibit 13 Protected Species Habitat Suitability Report
Exhibit 14 Airfield Buffer Map
Exhibit 15 SCDAH ArchSite Map
Exhibit 16 Project Wildlife Corridor Map
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.