RecordWell Data

boa-24-24_23_haynsworth_st_city.pdf

City of Sumter · Sumter County · Other

Open the original document More from City of Sumter

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Sumter City-County Board of Zoning Appeals July 10, 2024 BOA-24-24, 23 Haynsworth St. (City) The applicants (Raymond & Carolyn Hodge) are requesting variances from the accessory structure setback requirements and fence placement requirements outlined in Article 4.g.2.b.4: (Residential Accessory Structures) Setbacks and Article 4.f.8: Height, Fencing Materials, and Proximity Regulations for Fences Allowed in Required Yards of the City of Sumter Zoning & Development Standards Ordinance (the “Ordinance”), and any additional variances as may be required, in order to (1) establish a residential accessory structure closer to a side property line than otherwise permitted and (2) establish an 8 ft. tall solid fence closer to an existing structure on an adjacent property than otherwise permitted. The property is located 23 Haynsworth St., is zoned Residential-6 (R-6), and is represented by TMS# 228-05-01-023. 2 Sumter City-County Zoning Board of Appeals July 10, 2024 BOA-24-24, 23 Haynsworth St. (City) I. THE REQUEST Applicant: Raymond & Carolyn Hodge Status of the Applicant: Property Owners Request: Variances from residential accessory structure setback requirements and from fence placement requirements City Council Ward: Ward 4 Location: 23 Haynsworth St. Present Use/Zoning: Residential / Residential-6 (R-6) Tax Map Reference: 228-05-01-023 II. BACKGROUND The applicant is requesting variances from residential accessory structure setback requirements and fence placement requirements in order to establish a +/ - 900 sq. ft. storage building and a wood privacy fence on the property. A recent plat of the property and a plot plan showing the location of the prop osed privacy fence is attached to this report as Exhibit 1 and Exhibit 2, respectively. The property is located is located on the north side of Haynsworth St., at the mid - point between Chestnut St. and Folsom St. The property is shown in red on the location map to the right. 3 The applicant is in the process of constructing a residential storage building in the rear yard of the property. Building permits were issued for this project earlier this year based on variance approvals obtained in 2018 under Case# BOA -18-05 that provided 3.5 ft. of relief from side accessory structure setback requirements and 3 ft. of relief from rear accessory structure setback requirements. This previous variance approval was based on the understanding that the proposed accessory structure would be established within the limits of an existing concrete slab in the rear yard that once served as the foundation for a n accessory structure. During the building inspection process, it was discovered that vertical building support columns had been established just outside of the edge of the concrete slab, instead of completely within the boundary. As such, the structure is not in compliance with the setback requirements previously granted by the Zoning Board of Appeals under BOA -18-05. The applicant is requesting additional variance relief to reduce the side setback to +/- 1 ft. and the rear setback to +/- 1.5 ft.1 The applicant has indicated that the current condition of the slab is not suitable to act as the foundation of the proposed structure. As such, the applicants are constructing the building as a pole barn. Above: Accessory Structure Graphic 1 Staff notes that the setback variance requested does not include the eave overhang of the accessory. Per Article 4.f.7. – eaves, cornices, gutters, fireplaces, and other minor architectural features may extend up to 2 ft. into required yards (setbacks). This requirement does not allow for such features to encroach over property lines, unless such encroachment would be allowed elsewhere by the Ordinance. 4 Above: Pictures of accessory structure under construction The applicant has completed an 8 ft. tall wooden privacy fence along the western property line in the side and front yards . The applicant was permitted (Permit #2024-01647) for this work and it has been completed in accordance with City of Sumter Zoning & Development Standards Ordinance (the “Ordinance”) requirements. The applicant desires to extend the privacy further into the rear, with a termination point at the front of the accessory structure under construction. T he Ordinance requires separation between solid fences over 5 ft. in height and existing structures on adjacent property . Specifically, if a solid fence is 5 ft. in height or more, than at least 6ft. of separation between the fence and the existing structure on adjacent property is required . Any fence over 6ft. in height must be separated by an additional 1 ft. for every 1 ft. in height. As such, the required separation from the existing structures on the adjacent property in the specific instance is approximately 7 to 8ft. (the exact distance of the structure on adjacent property from the property line is not known, but it appears to be approximately 1ft.) The applicant is requesting a variance to allow for +/- 2.5ft. of separation, not to include eave overhangs on the existing buildings. Staff notes that a portion of the property line already has an existing privacy fence installed by the adjacent owner , and that the separation requirements outlined in Article 4.f.8 have historically been interpreted to only include buildings. The proposed new 8 ft. tall privacy fence is not included in the scope of the side and front yard fence installation permit previously approved, and work has not begun. Above: Pictures of existing buildings on adjacent property along the western property boundary line Above: Picture of western boundary line from end of newly constructed privacy fence facing north 5 Above: Privacy Fence Graphic Ordinance Requirements: Article 4.g.2.b.4: (Residential Accessory Structures) Setbacks 4. Setbacks - Note: accessory structure over 1,200 sq. ft. must be a minimum of 10 ft. from all side and rear property lines. i. Interior Lots – Front – N/A Side – 5 ft. Rear – 5 ft. Article 4.f.8: Height, Fencing Materials, and Proximity Regulations for Fences Allowed in Required Yards: A solid fence or wall not over 5 ft. in height is permitted outright in any side or rear yard provided; that a said fence is no closer than 12 inches from a street right -of-way line. Where a fence is in fact over 5 ft. in height, said fence may not be permitted within 6 ft. of a structure on an adjacent property. In addition, a solid fence which is over 6 ft. in 6 height must be an additional 1 ft. from the adjacent structure for every foot in height. No fence may exceed 8 ft. in height. Hurricane, cyclone and wire fences are permitted along any side or rear property line. All solid fences in the front yard setback area will have an exterior finish facing outward. The Request: The applicants (Raymond & Carolyn Hodge) are requesting variances from the accessory structure setback requirements and fence placement requirements outlined in Article 4.g.2.b.4: (Residential Accessory Structures) Setbacks and Article 4.f.8: Height, Fencing Materials, and Proximity Regulations for Fences Allowed in Required Yards of the City of Sumter Zoning & Development Standards Ordinance (the “Ordinance”), and any additional variances as maybe required, in order to (1) establish a residential accessory structure closer to a side property line than otherwise permitted and (2) establish an 8 ft. tall solid fence closer to an existing structure on an adjacent property than otherwise permitted. III. FOUR PART TEST In order to grant the requested variance, the request must meet all parts of a State-mandated four- part test. When reviewing a variance request, the Board may not grant a variance that would do the following: • Allow the establishment of a use not otherwise permitted in a zoning district; • Extend physically a nonconforming use of land; • Change zoning district boundaries shown on the Sumter City -County Official Zoning Map. The fact a property may be utilized more profitably should a variance be granted shall not be considered grounds for approving a variance request. In granting a variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the Board may consider advisable to promote public health, safety, or general welfare. Staff Review: 1) There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property. Accessory Structure – According to the applicant, the condition of the existing slab is not suitable to serve as the supporting foundation for an accessory structure , a condition that arose after the original variance approval (BOA -18-05). Based on this condition, the applicant has elected to construct a pole barn style structure with support columns installed directly adjacent to the outer limits of the concrete slab. The rear yard of the property is influenced by the presence of 3 mature canopy tree s classified as ‘significant’ trees per Article 9 of the Ordinance . In order to construct the 7 proposed building to meet required setback requirements, impacts to the critical root zone s resulting in long term impacts to th ese mature tree s are anticipated for the structure to comply with minimum accessory structure setback requirements. This reasoning was cit ed in the original BOA -18-05 approval that allowed for the 3.5 ft. reduction in the minimum side setback and the 3 ft. reduction to the required minimum rear setback. While single-family detached dwellings are exempted from the tree preservation and tree protection requirements outlined in Article 9 of the Ordinance, preserving these trees is consistent with the overall intent and purpose of the Ordinance. Fence Separation – The applicant is attempting to provide additional s creening from the adjacent property to the west , where documented disputes with the adjacent property owner have occurred in the recent past. An existing accessory structure, with a window facing into the applicant’s backyard, is located within less than 1 ft. of the western property boundary . The applicant is requesting a variance to install a privacy fence closer to existing structures on the adjacent property than is otherwise permit ted to resolve their safety and privacy concerns. 2) These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity. Accessory Structure – The utilization of an existing concrete slab (the location of a previous accessory structure) to protect mature trees in close proximity could be considered a condition that is not generally applicable to all property in the immediate vicinity. Fence Separation – The current need for additional screening, security, and privacy (for both the applicants and the representatives of the adjacent property ) could be considered a condition that is not generally applicable to all property in the immediate vicinity. 3) Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property. Accessory Structure – The Ordinance prevents the applicant from constructing the accessory structure in the manner desired due to required setback encroachments. The applicant has provided information indicating that the condition of the existing slab is not suitable to provide foundational support for an accessory structure . Further, construction in full compliance with the minimum 5 ft. setback applicable to residential accessory structures of this size could endanger the health of existing ‘significant’ canopy trees. Fence Separation – The Ordinance prevents the applicant from constructing the privacy fence in the location desired. The fence separation standard does still apply even if a structure on an adjacent property does not conform to required setback requirements , which is the case in this situation. If the closest residential accessory structure on the adjacent property met the 5 ft. minimum setback requirement, the proposed privacy fence would have to be installed +/- 3 ft. from the property line. Based on the actual location of the neighboring buildings, the proposed privacy fence would need to be placed +/- 8 ft. from the property line to maintain the required separation outlined in Article 4.f.8. 8 4) The authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the granting of the variance will not harm the character of the district. Accessory Structure – The purpose of regulating setbacks for residential and accessory structures is to ensure compatibility , ensure minimum open space around a structure, facilitate safe access, a nd avoid negatively impacting surrounding properties. It is noted that this area is within the historic core of the City of Sumter where it is common for both homes and their accessory structures to have been constructed prior to 1999 and to conform to current setback requirements. Further, the proposed structure would not be readily visible from public right-of-way and any potential impacts to adjacent property would be limited to the rear yard areas of the property to the west and the property to the north where boundary fences already exist on the property lines. Fence Separation – The purpose of requiring separation between solid fences and existing accessory structures on adjacent property is to ensure compatibility, to ensure minimum open space around a structure, to facilitate safe access, to avoid negatively impacting surrounding properties, and to prevent damage to adjacent structures in the event a fence were to fall. It is noted that there are extenuating c ircumstances pertaining to the subject property and the abutting property to the west. Additionally, the existing accessory structure on the adjacent property appears to be approximately 1 ft. from the property boundary line, thus requiring an 8 ft. tall privacy fence to be significantly setback on the subject property. Any potential impacts to adjacent property would be limited to the rear yard of the property to the west. IV. STAFF RECOMMENDATION The purpose of regulating structure setbacks and fence separation requirements is to ensure compatibility, ensure minimum open space around a structure, facilitate safe access, a nd avoid negatively impacting surrounding properties. Further, fence separation requirements prevent damage to adjacent structure s in the event a fence were to fall. Deviations from the Ordinance specified requirements should be carefully weighed. Staff recommends the following approval conditions if the Zoning Board of Appeals makes all the findings necessary to approve this request: 1. The eave overhang and roof drip line for the accessory structure shall not encroach over any boundary line of the subject property. V. DRAFT MOTIONS for BOA-24-24 1. I move the Zoning Board of Appeals approve BOA-24-24 based on the following findings of fact and conclusions : State Definitive Findings for each part of the four -part test for the record. 2. I move the Zoning Board of Appeals deny BOA-24-24 based on the following findings of fact and conclusions: State Definitive Findings for each part of the four -part test for the record. 9 3. I move the Zoning Board of Appeals enter an alternative motion for BOA-24-24. VI. ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS – July 10, 2024 Exhibit 1 Exhibit 2

Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.