Minutes
City of Sumter · Sumter County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
Minutes of the Meeting
May 8, 2024
ATTENDANCE
A regular meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals was held on
Wednesday, May 8, 2024, in the Fourth Floor City Chambers of
the Sumter Opera House, 21 N. Main Street. Seven board
members –Mr. Jason Reddick, Mr. Claude Wheeler, Mr. Steven
Schumpert, Mr. Louis Tisdale , Mr. Leslie Alessandro, Mr.
William Bailey, and Mr. Todd Champion were present. Mr. Frank
Shuler and Mr. Clay Smith were absent.
Planning staff in attendance : Mr. Jeff Derwort , Mr. Quint
Klopfleisch, Ms. Helen Roodman and Ms. Kellie Chapman.
The meeting was called to order at 3:00 p.m. by Mr. Leslie
Alessandro, Chairman.
MINUTES
Mr. Louis Tisdale made a motion to approve t he minutes of the
April 10, 2024, meeting as written. The motion was seconded by
Mr. Steven Schumpert and carried a unanimous vote.
NEW BUSINESS
Mr. Louis Tisdale recused himself from BOA-24-11.
BOA-24-11, 420 S. Pike West (City) was presented by Mr. Kyle
Kelly. The Board reviewed the request for a variance to the
public road frontage requirements outlined in Article 8.d.14.a
(Lots) and Article 8.d.14.c (Lots) of the City of Sumter Zoning
& Development Standards Ordinance in order to permit the
establishment of a new 1.97-acre lot that does not front on either
a public road or other permissible road type. The City of Sumter
Zoning & Development Standards Ordinance requires that new
lots (that are not exempt as outlined in Article 10) shall have at
least 60 ft. of frontage on either a public or other permissible
road type. The property is located at 420 S Pike West, is zoned
Residential-6 (R-6), and is represented by TMS# 229-02-02-001.
Mr. Kelly stated the applicant is requesting a variance to the
public road frontage requirements of the Ordinance to permit
the establishment of a new 1.97-acre lot.
Mr. Kelly added the Ordinance requires that new lots have at
least 60 ft. of frontage on either a public or other permissible
road type.
2
Mr. Kelly mentioned proposed subdivision is being pursued by
the City as part of a project to provide pedestrian connection to
the City’s Shot Pouch Greenway for residents, businesses, and
healthcare providers east of Shot Pouch Creek around Wall
Street.
Mr. John Macloskie was present to speak on behalf of the
request.
After a brief discussion, Mr. Steven Schumpert made a motion
to approve this request subject to the following:
1. The subject property is +/- 13.05-acres in size, with +/- 424
ft. of frontage on S. Pike West. The property is currently
used as a church and private school, with the buildings for
the uses located close to S. Pike West and recreational fields
located at the rear of the site.
The proposed 1.97-acres to be subdivided is at the rear of the
property, approximately 1,400 feet from the road. Th e
proposed lot is currently an undeveloped forested area that is
approximately 80% floodplain and jurisdictional wetlands.
2. This area of the City of Sumter contains primarily residential
lots, with some commercial and multi-family development as
well.
Due in part to the floodplain and floodway around Shot
Pouch Creek, there are irregularly shaped parcels of land,
including several existing parcels that do not meet the
Ordinance requirement in Article 8.d.14.
These lots were established prior to adoption of the current
Ordinance.
3. The application of the Ordinance in this case prevents the
applicant from subdividing the property as intended in order
to facilitate development of a public connection to the City’s
Shot Pouch Greenway for the Wall Street neighborhood.
4. Article 8.d.14. requires that newly subdivided lots be
established with public road frontage to minimize
“landlocked” lots.
In this case, while the proposed lot would be landlocked, it is
adjacent to property owned by Sumter County, and will be
accessible from Wall Street via a recreational trail and utility
easement.
3
The City’s objective is to construct a paved greenway
segment on the property, which will benefit the public good,
and enhance the character of the district.
The motion was seconded by Mr. William Bailey and carried by
a unanimous vote.
BOA-24-12, 4672 Broad St. (County) was presented by Mr.
Quint Klopfleisch. The Board reviewed the request for a
variance from the minimum off -street parking requirements
outlined in Article 8, Exhibit 23: Off -Street Parking
Requirements for Non- Residential Uses of the Sumter County
Zoning & Development Standards Ordinance and any other
variances required to establish a hookah lounge (with no on- site
consumption of alcoholic beverages) within an existing tenant
space of the multi -tenant commercial building on the property.
The property is located at 4672 Broad St., is zoned General
Commercial (GC), and is represented by TMS# 155-08-02-003.
Mr. Klopfleisch stated the applicant is requesting a variance to
minimum off-street parking requirements in order to allow for
the establishment of a hookah lounge (with no on- site
consumption of alcoholic beverages) within a +/- 1,200 sq. ft.
tenant space of a larger multi-tenant commercial building.
Mr. Klopfleisch added the property currently does not conform
to minimum off-street parking requirements, and the requested
use of this specific space will increase the degree of
nonconformity. As such, an approval of a variance to minimum
off-street parking requirements is required.
Mr. Klopfleisch mentioned the space proposed for the hookah
lounge is currently licensed for a use requiring 1 space per 250
sq. ft. of GFA.
Ms. Sunny Wise was present to speak on behalf of the request.
After a brief discussion, Mr. Louis Tisdale made a motion to
approve this request subject to the following:
1. The commercial building was constructed circa 1986, prior
to the adoption of the current Ordinance.
Based on the layout of the building establishing additional
parking at the rear of the building is not practical.
The property falls within two separate zoning districts.
If demolition of a portion of the building was carried out to
allow for access to the rear, rezoning the back portion of the
property to a commercial district would be required.
4
2. Multi-tenant commercial sites that do not conform with
current minimum off -street parking requirements are fairly
common in this area of Sumter County. However, most sites
do have available land to construct some additional parking
areas.
3. The application of the Ordinance prohibits the applicant
from locating a hookah lounge in their desired location.
4. Based on available street imagery and preliminary site
research, there is not typically a high demand for parking on
this property. The parking area typically functions at around
½ capacity during normal operating hours.
Subject to the following conditions:
• No more than 3,900 sq. ft. of space within the
multitenant building on the property may be used for
uses that require more off-street parking than 1 space per
250 sq. ft. of gross floor area (GFA) under applicable
requirements in place now or in the future.
• Previous BOA conditions pertaining as applied under
BOA-23-29 are null and void.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Steven Schumpert and carried
by a unanimous vote.
BOA-24-13, 1619/1625 Panola Rd. (County) was presented by
Mr. Kyle Kelly. The Board reviewed the request for a variance
from requirements outlined in Article 3.n.5.a: AC District
Minimum Lot Requirements, Article 8.e.13.a: Lots, Article
8.e.13.c: Lots, and any other applicable provisions of the Sumter
County Zoning & Development Standards Ordinance (the
“Ordinance”) required to subdivide the property in a manner that
will result in 1 new lot being 0.43 acres in size and will result in 1
new lot (non-exempt) being established without required publ ic
road frontage. The property is subject to a 1.0-acre minimum lot
size requirement and all new lots are required to have at least 60
ft. of frontage on a public road (unless exempted elsewhere in
the Ordinance). The property is located at 6919 & 6925 Pan ola
Rd., is zoned Agricultural Conservation (AC), and is represented
by TMS# 172-00-02-005.
Mr. K elly stated the applicant is requesting variance to the
subdivision development standards outlined in Article 3.n.5.a:
(AC District) Minimum Lot Requirements, Article 8.e.13.a: Lots,
of the Sumter County Zoning and Development Standards
Ordinance in order to permit di vision of a 4.89-acre tract into 4
5
separate lots, 2 of which would not meet the Ordinance
minimum development standards.
Mr. Kelly added the Ordinance requires that new lots in the AC
zoning district have at least 60 ft. of lot width throughout the
entire lot and at least 60 ft. of frontage on a public road.
Furthermore, lots must be at least 1.0-acre in size.
Mr. Kelly mentioned the parent parcel in question, TMS# 172 -
00-02-005, was created in 1961 via survey and filed in Judgement
Roll 19566 of the Office of the Clerk of Court. The applicant is
attempting to subdivide the tract into 4 separate portions as part
of a division of land for different family members. Tract A and
D, as shown on the map below, require variances prior to plat
approval. Tract B and C, as proposed family transfers in
accordance with the exempt subdivision regulations found in
Article 10 of the Ordinance, do not require variances.
Ms. Connie Smiling was present to speak on behalf of the
request.
After a brief discussion, Mr. William Bailey made a motion to
approve this request subject to the following:
1. The property is +/- 4.89-acres, with +/- 131 LF of frontage
on Panola Rd. in 2 separate locations. The site is a non-
conforming lot of record because it has less than 60 ft. of
width throughout. The lot is also a nonconforming use not
subject to discontinuance, as it has 2 separate principal
residences on a single lot. The proposed division would
retain the existing nonconforming site condition, but would
resolve the nonconforming use.
While there are numerous uniquely shaped parcels of record
in the area of this site, none share the same conditions as the
subject parcel, particularly the narrow width of the lot,
combined with the 0.15-acre remnant of land on the east side
of Panola Rd. that is the result of development of the road,
which blocks the tract from having a greater width at the
roadway (218 LF vs. 36 FL).
2. Lots in this area of Sumter County are generally a
combination of large agricultural tracts and smaller
residential lots. Several lots in the vicinity do not meet the
Article 8.e.13. standard, though these were created prior to
adoption of the Ordinance.
The condition of the 0.15-acre strip of land between the site
and Panola Rd. is a unique condition, as is the placement of
both dwellings and configuration of the area of Lot C & D.
6
All properties in Sumter County are required to abide by
Article 8.e.13. standards, save those defined as exempt
subdivisions under Article 10, limited to agricultural
restricted uses and family exempt subdivisions.
3. The application of the ordinance to the property restricts the
ability of the applicant to divide the tract as desired by the
family.
4. Tract A – Article 3.n.5.a. requires that new lots have a least
1.0-acre of land in the AC District as part of the County-wide
policy intended to discourage dense development in rural
areas to preserve the agricultural and rural character of these
areas. However, in this situation, the existence of 2
residential structures (manufactured homes) is an existing
condition, and application of the Ordinance in restricting a
subdivision that would separate the 2 residences would not
result in an actual change to the pattern of the development.
Tract D – Article 8.e.13. requires that newly subdivided lots
be established with public road frontage to minimize
presence of “landlocked” lots, meaning tracts that cannot be
reached but by crossing another’s land. While easements are
employed to establish lega l access to property, application
and enforceability is left to individual property owners,
leaving situations in which property becomes difficult to
access for its owners. Article 8.e.13. ensures that lots are
created with the necessary width to allow ac cess without
requiring easements. In this case, while the parcel would be
landlocked, the applicant does have some direct access to the
public road, and has obtained easement access across the
adjoining lot to legally access Panola Rd.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Jason Reddick and carried by
a unanimous vote.
BOA-24-14, 3908/3910 Camden Hwy. (County) was
presented by Mr. Jeff Derwort. The Board reviewed the request
for a variance from the non- residential building setback
requirements outlined in Article 3.b.5.b: (R-9 District) Minimum
Yard and Building Setback Requirements and Article 4.g.4.a:
(Agricultural Accessory Structures) Conditions & Exceptions of
the Sumter County Zoning & Development Standards
Ordinance in order reuse existing discontinued non-residential
structures that do not comply with applicable non- residential
building setback requirements for agricultural purposes. The
building setback requirement for non- residential uses applicable
to this property is 50 ft. The property is located at 3908/3910
Camden Hwy., is zoned Residential -9 (R-9), and is represented
by TMS# 189-00-02-005.
7
Mr. Derwort stated the property is the location of a former
cotton oil mill and contains multiple structures pertaining to this
business and any other later businesses on the property.
Mr. Derwort added the applicant desires to reuse two (2) of the
warehouse buildings at the rear of the property for agricultural
storage purposes. Agricultural storage uses are permitted in the
R-9 zoning district, like they are in all county zoning districts, but
must mee t required non-
residential building setback
requirements.
Mr. Derwort mentioned the locations of the warehouse buildings
are nonconforming to setback requirements and the site is
considered discontinued in accordance with Article 6 provisions.
Mr. Derwort added reuse of the buildings is subject to the
“Projects at Nonconforming Sites” provisions in Article 6.c.4 of
the Ordinance. The applicant is proposing electrical work in
order for building reuse. Based on the cost of work submitted
with an electrical permit application, it appears that substantial
compliance with all current standards is required.
Mr. Derwort stated the major non- conforming site feature
applicable are the distances the building are setback from side
and rear property lines, with both building being located +/- 11
ft. from the side property line and 1 building being located +/-
25 ft. from the rear property line.
Mr. William Moore was present to speak on behalf of the request.
After a brief discussion, Mr. Steven Schumpert made a motion
to approve this request subject to the following:
1. The property, and the improvements thereon, were in place
long before current zoning requirements.
The layout of the buildings on the property were done so to
support a past cotton oil mill land use. The property has a
narrow width in relation to the number of structures placed
on it.
2. The conditions described above, as they pertain to the subject
property, are not generally applicable to most other property
in the vicinity.
3. The application of the Ordinance to this property would not
allow most of the structures on the property to be reused for
any nonresidential use otherwise permitted in the R-9 zoning
district.
8
4. Approval of this request is not anticipated to be of substantial
detriment to adjacent property or to the public good.
Further, the request is not expected to harm the character of
the district.
The property is adjacent to property that is either currently
undeveloped or used for agricultural purposes.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Jason Reddick and carried by
a unanimous vote.
BOA-24-15, 3413 US Highway 15 S. (County) was presented
by Mr. Quint Klopfleisch. The Board reviewed the request for a
variance from the front and rear building setback requirements
in the Agricultural Conservation (AC) zoning district outlined in
Article 3.n.5.b: (AC District) Minimum Yard and Building
Setback Requirements of the Sumter County Zoning &
Development Standards Ordinance ( the “Ordinance”) in order
to establish a new dwelling that will be located +/ - 34 ft. from
the front property line and located +/- 14 ft. from the rear
property line. The property is located at 3413 US Hwy. 15 S., is
zoned Agricultural Con servation (AC), and is represented by
TMS# 222-00-02-025.
Mr. Klopfleisch stated the subject property is located on the east
side of US Hwy. 15 S. The proposed new construction will result
in the building’s proposed front being +/- 34 ft. from the front
property line and +/- 14 ft. from the rear of the property.
Mr. Klopfleisch added the subject property is approximately
0.23-acres in size, and falls under the Agricultural Conservation
(AC) zoning. In the AC District, any road classified higher than
a collector street necessitates a 45 -
foot front setback. At the
location of the subject property, US Hwy. 15 S. is classified as an
arterial road. Arterial roads primarily facilitate traffic movement
and typically permit higher vehicular speeds compared to
collector or local roads.
Ms. Antionette Boykin and Mr. David Johnson were present to
speak on behalf of the request.
After a brief discussion, Mr. Louis Tisdale made a motion to
approve this request subject to the following:
1. The subject property is 0.23 -acres in size with primary road
frontage on US Hwy. 15 S. The property is located in an area
of unincorporated Sumter County to the south of the city
jurisdiction. The lot is an irregular shape with depths ranging
from 106 ft. at its deepest to 77 ft. at the shallowest, making
the lot unbuildable without setback variance approvals.
9
2. Several neighboring houses sit as close or closer US Hwy. 15
S. The house on the abutting parcel to the southeast lies
approximately 15 ft. from the front property line and as close
as approximately 25 ft. from the rear property line, while the
house on the parcel abutting to the northwest of the property
stands approximately 22 ft. f rom the front property line.
Additionally, the house across the road is approximately 34
ft. from the front property line. All the neighboring houses
mentioned were built bef
ore the current ordinance. The
conditions of the subject property, and the existing
residentially used lots in the immediate vicinity, are somewhat
unique for property within the AC zoning district along US
Hwy. 15 S.
3. The lot is unbuildable without building setback variance
approvals.
4. Approval of this request is not anticipated to be of substantial
detriment to adjacent property or to the public good.
Further, the request is not expected to harm the character of
the district.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Steven Schumpert and carried
by a unanimous vote.
BOA-24-16, 5725 Hugh Ryan Rd. (County) was presented by
Mr. Jeff Derwort. The Board reviewed the request for a variance
from the accessory building placement requirements outlined
Article 4.g.2.b.4 (Residential Accessory Structures) Location
Requirements of the Sumter County Zoning & Development
Standards Ordinance (the “Ordinance”) in order to construct a
detached carport in the front yard. The property is located at
5725 Hugh Ryan Rd., is zoned Agricultural Conservation (AC),
and is represented by TMS# 091-00-01-046.
Mr. Derwort stated Article 4.g.2.b.4 of the Sumter County
Zoning & Development Standards Ordinance (the “Ordinance”)
requires that detached garages and carports be placed in either
the rear yard of the property or the side yard of the property no
further forward than the front of the principal dwelling.
Mr. Derwort added the applicant is requesting this variance due
to existing topographic conditions, the location of the existing
fence, and the location of the septic drain field on the property.
Ms. Pamela Kirvin was present to speak on behalf of the request.
After a brief discussion, Mr. Steven Schumpert made a motion
to approve this request subject to the following:
10
1. The subject property is +/- 2.1-acres in size and is located in
a rural area in the northwest section of unincorporated
Sumter County. There is an approximately 16 ft. change in
grade from the front of the property to the rear of the house.
The area to the right of the dwelling, as viewed from Hugh
Ryan Rd., is fenced in and has step s installed to access the
area from the front yard due to the change in grade. The area
to the left of the dwelling, as viewed from Hugh Ryan Rd., is
the location of the septic tank drain field and repair area. The
dwelling only has front and rear entry doors.
2. The subject property has unique challenges pertaining to the
placement of a detached carport in compliance with
Ordinance requirements. While other property in the
immediate vicinity may also encounter similar challenges, the
topography and other existing site conditions related to the
placement of a detached carport on this property are
somewhat unique within the larger context of this area of
Sumter County.
3. If the requested variance is not approved, the applicant must
install the proposed detached carport in compliance with
Ordinance requirements. Doing so would either require the
structure to be located further away from the house and/or
would require the applicant to drive around/through existing
site features to access it. The area immediately behind the
dwelling is fenced in.
4. Approval of this request is not anticipated to be of substantial
detriment to adjacent property or to the public good.
Further, the request is not expected to harm the character of
the district.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Claude Wheeler and carried by
a unanimous vote.
Mr. Jason Reddick recused himself from BOA-24-17.
BOA-24-17, 520 Wilson Hall Rd. (City) was presented by Mr.
Jeff Derwort. The Board reviewed the request for a variance
from the required 12” setback for fences along street frontages
as outlined in Article 4.f.8 of the City of Sumter Zoning &
Development Standards Ordinance in order to construct a new
brick fence in a manner that allows the applicant to retain existing
automatic security gates and avoid underground infrastructure.
The property is located at 520 W ilson Hall Rd., is zoned
Residential-15 (R-15), and is represented by TMS# 185 -00-02-
012.
11
Mr. Derwort stated the applicant is proposing to replace an
existing chain link fence that runs parallel to S. Wise Dr. ROW
with sections of screen wall fence and knee wall fence.
Mr. Derwort added the existing chain link fence ties into brick
columns at 2 site ingress/egress points along this street frontage.
These brick columns provide anchoring for automatic security
gates at these 2 access points.
Mr. Derwort mentioned the backs of these existing brick
columns are closer than 12” from the S. Wise Dr. ROW line.
Mr. Ben McIver was present to speak on behalf of the request.
After a brief discussion, Mr. Louis Tisdale made a motion to
approve this request subject to the following:
1. The property is the location of an established school campus.
New brick fencing is being proposed to screen the school
playground and parking areas from public view. A portion
of the proposed fence line, primarily between 2 site access
points along S. Wise Dr., will be +/- 8’ from the street ROW
line in order to 1) tie into existing brick columns that anchor
access security gates and 2) to avoid the location of an
existing underground water vault.
Based on GIS analysis, there is between +/ - 20’ to +/- 25’
ft. of space between the S. Wise Dr. edge of asphalt and the
ROW line.
2. These conditions are somewhat unique within the vicinity
due to use characteristics of the property and the proximity
of existing site infrastructure.
3. Without variance approval, the applicant would have to
relocate established brick columns and underground site
infrastructure to construct the proposed fence.
4. Approval of this request is not anticipated to be of substantial
detriment to adjacent property or to the public good.
Further, the request is not expected to harm the character of
the district.
Based on GIS analysis, there is between +/- 20’ to 25’ ft. of
space between the S. Wise Dr. edge of asphalt and the ROW
line. The fence, as proposed, is not anticipated to impact
transportation operations or the operations of other
infrastructure located within the ROW.
12
The motion was seconded by Mr. Claude Wheeler and carried by
a unanimous vote.
OTHER BUSINESS
BOA-24-07, 1740 Hwy. 521 S. (C ity) The Board reviewed the
request for variances from the lot development standards
outlined in Article 3.b.5.a: (R -9 District) Minimum Lot
Requirements and Article 8.e.13.c: Lots of the Sumter County
Zoning & Development Standards Ordinance and any other
Ordinance requirements as may be applicable in order in
establish a new lot that will have +/- 21 ft. of frontage on a public
street and will have +/ - 21 ft. of lot width at the front building
setback line. The Ordinance requirements applic able to the
subdivision of this property require that new lots have at least 60
ft. of frontage on a public street and have at least 75 ft. of lot
width at the front building setback line. The property is located
at 1740 US Hwy 521 S., is zoned Residential- 9 (R -9), and is
represented by TMS# 252-00-02-022. This request was deferred
to the May 8, 2024 BOA at the April 10, 2024 BOA meeting.
Mr. Derwort stated that this request was deferred due to the
applicant not being present at the meeting and due to questions
that could not be resolved at that time. Mr. Derwort stated that
the applicant is present at the meeting and the staff is
recommending an addition approval conditions, should the BOA
find that all necessary criteria have been met. Mr. Derwort stated
that this additional recommended approval conditions is that the
applicant provide a access easement to property from the
driveway of the church property.
Mr. Thomas Anderson and Mr. Ricky McLeod was present to
speak on behalf of the request. Mr. Ricky McLeod indicated that
they were comfortable with providing an access easement.
After a brief discussion, Mr. Louis Tisdale made a motion to
approve this request subject to the following:
1. The subject property is +/- 6.17-acres in size, with public
frontage on US 521 S. The lot is currently home to a religious
organization. The proposed lot will have +/- 270 ft. of road
frontage along a private road (Brunswick Rd.) on the eastern
edge of the property which will give it access to US 521 S.
The narrow width stem is being proposed to US 521 S. in
order to provide some level of frontage on a public road and
to preserve the existing driveway location for the church.
2. The lot size and dimensions of the property are not
uncharacteristic for a non-residential institutional use along a
major arterial roadway. However, having secondary frontage
on private road that provides access to multiple lots under
13
different ownership is somewhat unique to this particular
property.
3. The application of the ordinance to the particular property
restricts the ability of the applicant to subdivide the property
as proposed. The proposed lot has significant frontage on a
private road that is the only access point for multiple
different property owners.
4. Based on the proposed subdivision sketch, it is not
anticipated that the area of lot width and road frontage non-
conformity will be substantial detriment to adjacent property
or the public good. However, it is important to consider the
impact that a varia
nce approval creates with regard to
precedent for future, potentially more impactful, requests.
Subject to the following condition:
• An Easement is shown on the plat from Frasier
Memorial Church to all future owners of the new lot
giving the owners right to use the present ingress/egress
onto US Highway 521.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Steven Schumpert and carried
by a unanimous vote.
BOA-24-08, 941 Clay St. (County) The Board reviewed the
request for a variance from the residential accessory structure
maximum size requirements outlined in Article 4.g.2.b.6:
Maximum Size and Article 4, Exhibit 8A: Maximum Square
Footage of Residential Accessory Structures Based on Gross
Acreage of the Sumter County Zoning & Development
Standards Ordinance (the “Ordinance) and any other Ordinance
requirements as may be applicable in order to establish a +/ -
1,200 sq. ft. residential accessory structure w here the maximum
total area of residential accessory structures permitted based on
the size of the property is 1,150 sq. ft. The property is located at
941 Clay St., is zoned Residential- 15 (R-15), and is represented
by TMS# 207-10-02-009. This request was deferred to the May
8, 2024 BOA at the April 10, 2024 BOA meeting.
Ms. Helen Roodman provided an update concerning the Duke
Energy/Progress easement, and stated that no final answer from
Duke Energy/Progress is available at this time concerning
whether or not the structure will be allowed to remain within the
easement area.
Mr. Richard Irick was present to speak on behalf of the request.
After a brief discussion, Mr. William Bailey made a motion to
approve this request subject to the following:
14
1. The property is in the R -15 zoning district, which allows a
minimum lot size of 15,000 sq. ft. (0.34- acres). Most lots in
the subdivision are between 0.34 and 0.40-acres in size.
While the overhead electric utility line easement is an
extraordinary condition that affects a relatively small number
of lots within the overall subdivision, the lot size for these
lots appear to have been established with this factor in mind
of offset the impact of the easement’s effect.
Additionally, while the lot is not technically a corner lot, it
functions as a corner parcel, as there is a private portion of
Hilldale Dr. located adjacent to the property which provides
unpaved driveway access to 3 lots.
2. The subject parcel’s location with the subdivision and impact
caused by the utility easement applies to a relatively small
number of lots in the overall subdivision. However, the
accessory building standards found in Article 4.g. of the
Ordinance apply co untywide, and the specific dimensional
constraints to which this request is seeking a variance are
intended to account for differently sized parcels of land.
The maximum accessory structure size thresholds in Exhibit
8A were established based on a standard increment, with
each 0.10-acre increase in lot size corresponding to additional
accessory structure size allowance between 25 and 100 sq. ft.
This methodology does not account for standard
dimensioning in the building construction industry, which
can make constructing a 1,150 sq. ft. building significantly
more difficult than a 1,200 sq. ft. building.
3. The applicant can construct up to 2 accessory buildings with
a combined size of 1,150 sq. ft. without a variance. The
applicant has an existing +/ - 400 sq. ft. accessory structure
(carport) and could build an additional +/- 750 sq. ft.
structure without a variance. The ordinance prevents the
applicant from exceeding this limit.
The existing +/- 400 sq. ft. carport located to the side of the
residence is close enough to the dwelling that it could be
connected and treated as part of the principal structure and
not as an accessory structure.
In this scenario, the applicant’s need for a variance would be
reduced from 450 sq. ft. to 50 sq. ft.
4. The purpose of regulating the size of residential accessory
buildings is to ensure compatibility, preserve the primary
15
residence as the focal point of the property, and avoid
negatively impacting surrounding properties.
Authorization of this specific variance is not likely to result
in substantial detriment to adjacent property and the public
good, as it represents only a small increase in residential
accessory structure above the maximum requirement.
However, exceeding the established maximum accessory
structure size limits without demonstrating a true hardship
could impact district character over time as it hinders the
effectiveness of the Ordinance requirements and undermines
the expressed intent of the ordinance countywide.
Subject to the following condition:
• The applicant must obtain written consent or other legal
documentation within 90 days (Tuesday, August 6, 2024)
that verifies that construction of an accessory structure is
permitted under the terms of the easement currently held
on the property by Duke En ergy Progress prior to
building permit approval.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Jason Reddick and carried by
a unanimous vote.
There being no further business, Mr. Louis Tisdale made a
motion to adjourn the meeting at 4:54 p.m. The motion was
seconded by Mr. William Bailey and carried by a unanimous vote.
The next regularly scheduled meeting is scheduled for May 8 ,
2024.
Respectfully submitted,
Kellie K. Chapman
Kellie K. Chapman, Board Secretary
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.