boa_24-08_941_clay_st_county_deferred_may_8.docx.pdf
City of Sumter · Sumter County · Other
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Sumter City-County
Zoning Board of Appeals
May 8, 2024
BOA- 24- 08, 941 Clay St. (County)
The applicant is requesting a variance from the residential accessory
structure maximum size requirements outlined in Article 4.g.2.b.6: Maximum
Size and Article 4, Exhibit 8A: Maximum Square Footage of Residential
Accessory Structures Based on Gross Acreage of the Sumter County Zoning
& Development Standards Ordinance (the “Ordinance”) and any other
Ordinance requirements as may be applicable in order to establish a +/-
1,200 sq. ft. residential accessory structure where the maximum total area of
residential accessory structures permitted based on the size of the property
is 1,150 sq. ft. The property is located at 941 Clay St., is zoned Residential-
15 (R-15), and is represented by TMS# 207-10-02-009
2
Sumter City-County
Zoning Board of Appeals
May 8, 2024
BOA- 24-08, 941 Clay St. (Coun ty)
I. THE REQUEST
Applicant: Richard W. Irick, II
Status of the Applicant: Property Owner
Request: Variance from the residential accessory structure maximum size
requirements and any other Ordinance requirements as may be
applicable in order to establish a +/ - 1,200 sq. ft. residential
accessory structure where the maximum total area of residential
accessory structures permitted based on the size of the property is
1,150 sq. ft.
County Council District: District 4
Location: 941 Clay St.
Present Use/Zoning: Single Family Residence / Residential-15 (R-15)
Tax Map Reference: 207-10-02-009
II. B ACKGROUND
The applicant is requesting variance approval to
permit the construction of a 1 ,200 sq. ft.
residential accessory structure on the property,
combined with an existing +/ - 400 sq. ft.
accessory structure, for a total of +/- 1,600 sq. ft.
Based on the lot size (0.61 acres), the maximum
amount of residential accessory structure area
permitted is 1,150 sq. ft.
The property is located in the Hilldale
Subdivision along Clay St. and is shown in red
on the location to the right. A 1,200 sq. ft.
3
accessory structure was erected sometime between January and March 202 4 without required
building permits. Variance approval is being sought in order to legally permit the building .
There is an existing +/- 400 sq. ft. carport structure located adjacent to the residence.
Sumter County Assessor’s property records indicate that there are two accessory structures
associated with the property, one being a carport and the other being a utility/storage shed.
Aerial imagery from 2023 indicates 3 total accessory structures, 1 being the existing carport in
the property’s side yard, and 2 located in the rear yard. The 2 rear yard accessory structures were
removed between August 2023 and March 2024. However, because no demolition permits were
filed, those structures remain associated with the tax records. Based on rough measurements, the
two structures removed between 2023 and 2024 were 500 sq. ft. (utility/storage building) and
600 sq. ft. (carport).
Furthermore, the 2 rear yard accessory structures (that have been removed) appear to have been
nonconforming with regard to total accessory structures (maximum 2) building setbacks
(minimum 5 ft. from property lines) and combined structure size (1,500 sq. ft. total size of all 3
structures, compared with 1,150 sq. ft. maximum for the lot.
Above (left): 2023 Aerial imagery depicting previous accesory structures; Above (right): Image depicting previous
accesory structures in rear yard (imagery dated August 2023, captured via Google Streetview)
A further factor of relevance to this case is the presence of an overhead electrical transmission
line easement along the property’s northeast (side) property line.
The easement, which is identified on the plat prepared by H.S. Willston and recorded in 1994
(PB 94, Pg 805), is shown as being 70 ft. in width (35 ft. on the property at 945 Clay St.), and
held by Carolina Power & Light, now Duke Energy Progress.
4
Staff has attempted to contact Duke Energy Progress to obtain details on the company’s
easement status and legal requirements , but as of the time of this report, no response has been
received.
5
Above: Site Diagram showing location of proposed accessory structure and existing overhead utility easement
Above: Image depicting unpermitted 1,200 sq. ft. accessory structure in rear yard
at time of variance application (image dated March 22, 2024)
6
Ordinance Requirements:
Article 4.g.2.b.6.
6. Maximum Size – The maximum size of residential accessory structures shall be
governed by Exhibit 8A and shall be based on the gross acreage of the parcel of land on
which it is located.
Exhibit 8A
Maximum square footage of residential accessory structures based on gross acreage
The Request:
The applicant is requesting a variance from the requirements outlined in Article 4.g.2.b.6: Maximum
Size (Residential Accessory Structures) and Article 4, Exhibit 8A: Maximum Square Footage of
Residential Accessory Structures Based on Gross Acreage of the Sumter County Zoning &
Development Standards Ordinance in order to establish a +/ - 1,200 sq. ft. residential accessory
building on the property, combined with an existing +/- 400 sq. ft. accessory structure, for a total of
+/- 1,600 sq. ft. The gross acreage of the property is 0.61 acres and the maximum total area allowed
for residential accessory structures based on this land area is 1,150 sq. ft.
III. FOUR PART TEST
In order to grant the requested variance, the request must meet all parts of a State-mandated four-
part test. When reviewing a variance request, the Board may not grant a variance that would do
the following:
• Allow the establishment of a use not otherwise permitted in a zoning district.
• Extend physically a non-conforming use of land.
• Change zoning district boundaries shown on the Sumter City- County Official Zoning
Map.
The fact that a property may be utilized more profitably should a variance be granted shall not be
considered grounds for approving a variance request. In granting a variance, the Board may
attach to it such conditions regarding location, character, or other features of the proposed
building, structure, or use as the Board may consider advisable to promote the public health,
safety, or general welfare.
7
Staff Review:
1) There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of
property.
The subject property is 0.61 acres in size and is located within the Hilldale Subdivision in
unincorporated Sumter County. The property is in the R-15 zoning district, which allows for
a minimum lot size of 15,000 sq. ft. (0.34 acres). Most lots in the subdivision are between
0.34 and 0.40 acres in size. However, the lots which abut the existing overhead utility
transmission line and associated easement are significantly larger than the average lots in the
subdivision, at between 0.46 and 0.76 acres.
Additionally, while the lot is not technically a corner lot, it functions as a corner parcel, as
there is a private portion of Hilldale Dr. located adjacent to the property which provides
unpaved driveway access to 3 lots.
Furthermore, while the presence of the overhead electric utility line easement is an
extraordinary condition that affects a relatively small number of lots within the overall
subdivision, the lot sizes for these lots appear to have been established with this factor in
mind to offset the impact of the easement’s effect.
2) These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity.
The subject parcel’s location within the subdivision and impact caused by the utility
easement applies to a relatively small number of lots in the overall subdivision . However,
the accessory building standards found in Article 4.g. of the Ordinance apply countywide,
and the specific dimensional constraints to which this request is seeking a variance are
intended to account for differently sized parcels of land.
The maximum accessory structure size thresholds in Exhibit 8A were established based on a
standard increment, with each 0.10- acre increase in lot size corresponding to additional
accessory structure size allowance between 25 and 100 sq. ft. This methodology does not
account for standard dimensioning in the building construction industry, which can make
constructing an 1,150 sq. ft. building significantly more difficult than a 1,200 sq. ft. building.
This is particularly acutely felt with modular construction, and metal buildings, in which the
materials used may be prefabricated at specific dimensions.
3) Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of
property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property.
The applicant can construct up to 2 accessory buildings with a combined size of 1,150 sq. ft.
without a variance. The applicant has an existing +/ - 400 sq. ft. accessory structure (carport)
and could build an additional +/ - 750 sq. ft. structure without a variance . The ordinance
prevents the applicant from exceeding this limit.
8
The existing +/- 400 sq. ft. carport located to the side of the residence is located close enough
to the dwelling that it could be connected to the dwelling such that it would be treated as a
part of the principal structure and not as an accessory structure. In this scenario, the
applicant’s need for a variance would be reduced from 450 sq. ft. to 50 sq. ft.
4) The authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or
to the public good, and the granting of the variance will not harm the character of the
district.
The purpose of regulating the size of residential accessory buildings is to ensure
compatibility, preserve the primary residence as the focal point of the property, and avoid
negatively impacting surrounding properties.
The authorization of this specific variance is not likely to result in substantial detriment to
adjacent property and the public good, as it represents only a small increase in residential
accessory structure above the maximum requirement. However, on a broader scale,
exceeding the established maximum accessory structure size limits without demonstrating a
true hardship could impact district character over time as it hinders the effectiveness of the
Ordinance requirements and undermines the expressed intent of the ordinance countywide.
IV. STAFF RECOMMENDATION
Should the Board make the necessary findings to approve this request, s taff recommends t he
following conditions of approval be attached:
1. The
applicant must obtain written consent or other legal documentation that verifies that
construction of an accessory structure is permitted under the terms of the easement
currently held on the property by Duke Energy Progress prior to building permit
approval.
A
dditional conditions may need to be considered regarding the 400 ft. prefabricated car port in
the side yard should the Board elect to not include this structure in any approval provided.
V. DRAFT MOTIONS FOR BOA-24-08
1. I
move the Zoning Board of Appeals approve BOA-24-08, subject to the findings of fact
and conclusions developed by the BZA and so stated:
2. I move the Zoning Board of Appeals deny BOA-24-08, subject to the following findings
of fact and conclusions:
3.
I move the Zoning Board of Appeals enter an alternative motion for BOA-24-08.
9
VI. BOARD OF APPEALS – APRIL 10, 2024
The Sumter City -County Board of Appeals at its meeting on Wednesday, April 10, 2024,
deferred action on this request until the next Board of Appeals meeting on Wednesday, May 8,
2024. The Board has asked that the applicant obtain written consent or other legal
documentation that verifies that construction of an accessory structure is permitted under the
terms of the easement currently held on the property by Duke Energy Progress. The meeting will
begin at 3:00 p.m. and will be held in City Council Chambers located on the Fourth Floor of the
Sumter Opera House (21 North Main Street, Sumter, South Carolina).
VII. BOARD OF APPEALS – MAY 8, 2024
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.