RecordWell Data

hp_22-13-210_church_st.pdf

City of Sumter · Sumter County · Other

Open the original document More from City of Sumter

This document is no longer listed on City of Sumter's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

City of Sumter Design Review Board October 27, 2022 HP-22-13, 210 Church St. I. THE REQUEST Applicant: Robert Burleson Status of the Applicant: Authorized Agent for Property Owner Request: Request for Design Review approval for construction of a new second floor access stair at the rear of the residence. District Hampton Park Historic District Location: 210 Church St. Present Use/Zoning: Residential / R-6 Tax Map Reference: 228-05-05-023 Adjacent Property Land Use and Zoning: North – Single-Family Residential / R-9 South – Single-Family Residential / R-6 East – Vacant / R-6 West – Single-Family Residence / R-6 II. BACKGROUND 210 Church St ., shown in the photograph to the right, is a two-story frame house . The home is located on Church St. between W. Calhoun St. and Haynsworth St. The applicant is proposing to construct a new 2 nd floor access staircase at the rear of the residence . Sto p-Work orders were issued by both the Sumter City-County Building Official and Sumter City -County Zoning Enforcement Officer on July 11, 2022, terminating construction, as the property owner had not obtained proper Historic Design Review approvals or building permits to conduct work. The applicant has submitted this request as a 2 remediation step. The current configu ration of the s taircase constructed prior to the sto p-work order appears to conflict with required building setback requirements . As a result, the applicant has submitted a proposed conf iguration that would preserve the alr eady- constructed second story la nding but reconfigure the staircase to exi t directly to the rear of the residence and turn at a l ower landing 90 degrees before meeting the ground level in the center of the property’s rear yard. ARCHITECTURAL/HISTORIC CONTEXT: 210 Church St. is a 2-story frame house. The house was constructed around 1906 and is 4,863 sq. ft. in size. The property is identified as s ite # 176 in the 1985 Historic Resources Survey that catalogued the s tructures in the Hampton Park historic Dis trict. The resid ence is a 2-story f rame house with shiplap sid ing, a hip roof with cros s gable to the front, decorative brackets beneath the eaves, and a 2-story wing at the left with a pair of 6/6 windows on the 1 st floor and a flat roof porch supported by plain colum ns and a turned balustrade on the 2nd floor. While it was constructed as a single-family home, at some point the historic structure was converted to a duplex. The applicant has renovated the structure under previous Design Review approval (HP-19-13) in order to re-establish the duplex use. Based on the age of the building and archit ectural design and features, 210 Church St. is considered a contributing structur e to the N ational Register District-eligible Hampton Park Historic District. The property also contributes to the City-designated Hampton Park Historic Overlay District. SITE PHOTOS: Front Façade Rear Façade, as viewed from southwest corner of lot, showing area of proposed alteration. 3 Above: Partially constructed staircase (built without permits), proposed to be removed to the upper landing and reconstructed in configuration as proposed by this application Above: Partially constructed staircase as viewed from rear. Above: rear view of residence prior to alterations approved via HP-19-13 showing previous 1st floor rear access stair configuration and covered 2nd floor addition that has been modified. 4 SCOPE OF WORK: The following information describes the proposed changes and new construction. • Construct new exterior access stair Proposed 2nd Floor Access Stair Configuration and details (submitted by applicant) Colors The applicant is proposing to use pressure treated exterior- grade natural lumber, with no paint or stain applied. 5 DESIGN REVIEW: Design review approval is required prior to the proposed work. The Design Review Guidelines Manual states: 4.9 Porches A. Retain and Repair Original Porch Elements and Materials.  Preserve and maintain original porch elements including f loors, beadb oard ceilings, columns and supports, pilasters, railings, steps, lattice, and decorative trim.  Remove inappropriate materials such as open -riser stairs, metal porch s upports, decki ng used as porch flooring, and inappropriately installed lattice panels.  Repair the deteriorated portions of an element rather than replacing an entire structure.  Consider epoxy consolidants to rebuild deteriorated elements. B. Replace Deteriorated or Missing Porch Elements and Materials In-Kind.  Replace deteriorated or mi ssing features with materia ls compatible with the original in size and shape, detail and dimension, color, and texture.  Choose proper replacement columns or supports for the style of the h ouse, based on existing evidence or historical information.  Replace deteriorated wood co lumns with new wood columns or composite c olumns that resemble wood. Metal or aluminum columns are not appropriate for elevations visible from the public right-of-way.  Replace missing porch railings and balusters with traditional d esigns wi th appropriate dimensions.  Replace deteriorated wood porch floors with traditional tongue an d groove floors if possible. Composite tongue and groove flooring may be an appropriate alternative.  Replace deteriorated or missing porch stairs with closed-riser stairs of materials matching the original. Use simple handrails made of wood in a simple design. C. Preserve and Retain Original Porch Configuration  Retain the open quality of porches, especially those on the front or on a prominent elevation  Design porch enclosures in a manner that will not obscure, damage, or destroy character- defining features. D. Preserve and retain original porch locations.  Reconstruct missing porches based on photographic or physical evidence that supports the prior existence of a porch. Match the features of the original, or if no photographic evidence exists, design a new porch t hat is compatible with the scale, design, dimensions, and detail of the house.  Locate new porches and decks with no historical basis in an inco nspicuous location on the rear or side elevations of a building that are not visible from the street. Staff Analysis: The applicant’s proposed scope of work involves construction of a new 2nd floor exterior access staircase . Under the Design Guidelines, this is evaluated under the porch guidelines. While the project’s proposed location directly on the rear elevation of the residence is the most minimally visible portion of the site visible from the public right-of- way, the stair 6 will be visible from both Church St. and W. Calhoun St. Specifically, due to the presence of an open parking lot behind the lot, visibility into the rear yard is fairly unobstructed. The location of the proposed 2nd floor exterior s taircase was previously occupied by a 1 st floor exterior staircase and landing. In addition, prior to renovations completed under HP-19-13, an internal 2nd floor access stair was located inside the 2-story addition. Due to structural deficiencies identified in the addition, the renovations under HP-19-13 included removal of that access staircase and conversion of the addition to open porch space. While the residence contains at least 1 internal access staircase to the 2nd floor, the floor plan of the resi dence and need for emergency egress do es warra nt c onstruction of a 2 nd floor access stair. Though construction of the 2 nd floor access stair is warranted, the pro posed materials do not match the existing structure, and no attempt has been made via the proposed designs and course of action submitted to integrate the exterior access stair into the residence as a whole . As a result, the proposed design is generally in consistent with the Design Guidelines. III. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends de nial of this request. While construction of a 2 nd floor access stair is a valid improvement for the residence, the proposed changes are in consistent with the City of S umter Historic Preservation Design Guidelines an d are incompatible with the existin g b uilding design. An alternative design that is integrated with the building would be more consistent with the intent of the Design Guidelines. IV. DRAFT MOTION 1) I move that the City of Sumter D esign R eview Board approve HP-22-13 in accordance wi th the materials, photographs, a nd construct ion details submitted and referenced in the Staff Report based o n compliance with Design Review Guidelines. 2) I move th at the City of Sumter Design Review Board deny HP-22-13 3) I move t hat the Cit y of Sumter Design Review Board enter an alternative motion. V. DESIGN REVIEW BOARD – OCTOBER 27, 2022

Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.