hp_21-10-multiple_downtown_mural_sites.pdf
City of Sumter · Sumter County · Other
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
This document is no longer listed on City of Sumter's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
City of Sumter Historic Preservation
Design Review
April 22, 2021
HP-21-10, Downtown Mural Sites (Multiple Locations).
I. THE REQUEST
Applicant: Leigh Newman
Status of the Applicant: Authorized Agent for Property Owner
Request: Design Review approval for installation of large-
scale murals painted directly on exterior building
walls.
District Downtown Design District
Location: 16, 26, 30, and 36 W. Liberty St.
34 S. Main St.
9 N. Main St.
Present Use/Zoning: Commercial / CBD
Tax Map Reference: 228-13-07-001; -002; -003; -006; -046; -049; -065
228-12-05-012
Adjacent Property Land Use
and Zoning:
North – Commercial / CBD
South – Commercial / CBD
East – Commercial / CBD
West – Commercial / CBD
II. BACKGROUND
16, 26, 30, and 36 W. Liberty St., 34 S.
Main St., and 9 N. Main St. , shown on
the map to th e right, are downtown
commercial properties with large
unadorned walls in the Downtown
Design Review District which are
being evaluated for installation of
large format murals throug h the
Sumter Mural Projec t sponsored by
the City of Sumter and the Sumter
County Cultural Center.
2
The applicant is proposin g to install full wall artistic murals on exterior walls in the
alley between 16 and 36 W. Liberty St ., on the south- facing wall of 3 4 S. Main St.,
and on the south-facing second-story wall of 9 N. Main St.
***Note: due to an admini strative error, additional proposed mural sites were
advertised incorrectly. 17 and 25 S . Main St. are not proposed for mural placement .
The correct intended site for the final mural location s (37 and 43 S. Main St ., also
known as Mosaic Alley ) will be brought for Board review as a revision to this request
at a future meeting.***
The Sumter Mural Project will be funded by a variety of sources, in cluding private
donations and grants, and will also include sites outsid e the Downtown Design
Review District. The pro ject is awaiting decision regarding grant funding, but does
already have the funds required to implement the first mural, which will be located
in the alley between 16 and 36 W. Liberty St.
A committee comprised of representatives from the applicable property owners,
Sumter County Cultural Center, and City of Sumter will review the art ists’ proposed
designs and make final decisions regarding the content and style of each mural. Once
approved, each mural will take 2-4 weeks to complete.
ARCHITECTURAL/HISTORIC CONTEXT:
16 & 26 W. Liberty St. (Berenyi/F45/City of Sumter Liberty Center)
26 W. Li berty St. is a City -owned courtyard which previously served as the site of a
small commercial building constructed c.1915. While the building has since been
demolished, a section of the building ’s fire wall does still exist adjacent to 2 4 W.
Liberty S t. This section of wall has bee n previously stuccoed and painted many
times.
According to the Sumter County Assessor, t he 8,710 sq. ft. building at 16 W. Liberty
St was constructed in 1970 and is part of the larger site #100 referenced as 12 W.
Liberty St (also known today as the Libe rty Center) on the 1985 Main Street Sumter
Preservation Plan. The building is an irregular s hape and 1 story in height . The
exterior walls are brick, which has been previously painted. At the time of the 1985
Survey, the building had little historical significance.
The Liberty Center’s exterior was redesigned and renovated in 2015, having received
design review approval via HP 14-10. Changes made to the building complemented
the midcentury lines of the structure and improve d its aesthetic s without
compromising the architecture.
3
Based on the current age of the structure , location within the district, and
architectural features , neither 1 6 or 26 W. Liberty St . are considered co ntributing
structures to the Historic District.
30 & 36 W. Liberty St. (Osteen Publishing Co./Sumter Item)
According to the Sumter County Assessor, the 779 sq. ft. building at 30 W. Liberty St
was constructed in 1945 and is site #104 o n the 1 985 Main Street Su mter
Preservation Plan. The building is rectangular in shape and 1 story in height. The
exterior walls are brick, which has been previously stuccoed and painted.
Also a ccording to the Sumter County Assessor, the 2, 757 sq. ft. bui lding at 36 W.
Liberty St was constructed in 1 970 and is site # 105 on the 1985 Main Street Sumter
Preservation Plan. The building is rectangular in sha pe and 1 story in height at the
street front, increasing to 2 stories at the rear . The exterior walls are brick masonry,
which has been previously painted.
Both the 30 and 36 W. Liberty St buildings are currently home to the Osteen
Publishing Co., which operates the Sumter Item newspaper. Osteen Publishing was
the original occupan t of 36 W . Liberty St , though for several decades, both buildings
were home to the headquarters of the Santee- Lynches Regional Council of
Governments, prior to Osteen Publishing Co. re-purchasing the property.
Based on the current age of the structure , location within the district, and
architectural features , 30 W. Liberty St . is a contributing structure to the Historic
District, while 36 W. Liberty St. is not a contributing str ucture to the Historic
District.
9 N. Main St. (Imports Ltd.)
According to the 1985 Main Street Sumter Preservation Plan , the 8,172 sq. ft.
building was constructed c.1890 and is site #33. The building is rectangular in shape
and 2 stories in height . T he building material is brick, which has been painted
multiple times over the years.
Prior to occupation by the current retail use, the building was t he original site of
Bultman Bros. Shoes & Boots. It has also housed a jewelry store, finance company,
Army-Navy Store, and a general merchant and cotton buyer.
Based on the current age of the structure , location within the district, and
architectural features, 9 N. Main St . is considered one of t he contributing properties
to the Historic District.
4
34 S. Main St. (Cut-Rate Drug Co.)
According to the 1985 Main Street Sumter Preservation Plan, the 6,290 sq. ft.
building was constructed c.1910 and is site #93. The building is rectangular in shape
and 1 story in height. The building material is masonry, which has been painted.
The site also contains a state historical marker indicating the nearby site of the home
of native Sumterite Clara Louise Kellogg, word famous opera sing er who performed
abroad and in America.
The building may be historically signific ant, because of early appearance on Sanborn
maps, but alterations , including new facades, have negated parts of the building’s
significance to the Historic District.
SITE PHOTOS:
16 W. Liberty St. (Berenyi/F45/Liberty
Center west-facing wall)
36 W. Liberty St. (Osteen Publishing
Co./Sumter Item east-facing wall)
34 S. Main St. (Cut Rate Drug Store south-
facing wall)
9 N. Main St. (Imports Ltd second floor
south-facing wall.)
5
SCOPE OF WORK:
The proposed project is as follows:
1. Painting of large -format artistic murals on selected building walls in the
downtown, including:
a. Alley between 16 and 36 W. Liberty St.
b. South-facing wall of 34 S. Main St.
c. South-facing second-story wall of 9 N. Main St.
DESIGN REVIEW:
Design review approval is required prior to the proposed work. The Design Review
Guidelines Manual states:
4.3 Exterior Walls: Masonry
A. Preserve Original Masonry and its Visual Qualities.
Retain masonry features that are important in defining the overall character of the building.
Do not remove or obscure masonry elements.
Do not paint unpainted masonry. Exceptions to this include masonry walls that have a
patchwork appearance from extensive replacement or rebuilding.
Staff Analysis:
Painting of previously unpainted masonry is not con sistent with the City of Sumter
Historic Preservation Design Rev iew guidelines, unless there is a patchwork appearance
from extensive replacement or rebuilding, which are exceptions cited in th e Design
Guidelines.
Most brick is never intended to be painted , and painting of brick creates a lo ng-term
maintenance need that does not exist with unpainted brick. Moisture trapped within
walls and the associated damage it can do , as well as degradation of the paint itself over
time both suggest that painting of brick is not an ideal course of action.
The br ick and other masonry e lements of the buildings under consideration for this
project have been previously painted, and application of new paint to these surfaces would
not cause further harm to the surface s or otherwise be in conflict with the Design
Guidelines.
4.11 Paint
A. Maintain and Repair Historically Painted Surfaces.
Do not paint unpainted masonry walls unless insensitive past repairs have negatively affect ed
the visual qualities of the masonry.
B. Select a Compatible Color Scheme.
Choose colors that are appropriate to the architectural style and compliment the building and
its surroundings. Overly bright and obtrusive colors are not appropriate.
Consider an original color scheme based on paint analysis or research.
6
C. Use Paint Color to Accentuate Exterior Details.
Use muted or dark colors for the walls of a building.
Use lighter colors to highlight trim and architectural ornamentation.
Paint window sash and frames a contrasting color than the walls to provid e contrast and depth
to window openings.
Limit the paint scheme to three or four colors: one roof color, o ne wall color, one trim color, and
one accent color.
Staff Analysis:
While the applicant has not proposed specific paint colors or designs a t this t ime due to
the natur e and process of large format mural project s, the location and size of the
proposed murals and their intent as artistic and cultural enhancements for the downtown
area are consistent with the intent of the Design Review Guidelines. Prior to installation
of an y mural, the content and design of each mural will u ndergo a r igorous vetting
process by staff, City and C ounty elected leadership, property owners, and project
sponsors to ensure that the designs are consistent with Sumter’s vision.
III. STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends approval of this request.
The proposed mural locations are consistent with the City of Sumter Historic
Preservation Design Review guidelines.
Painting of previously unpainted masonry in this case is not con sistent with the City
of Sumter Historic Preservation Design Rev iew guidelines. Painting of brick creates
a long-term maintenance need that does not exist with unpainted brick. With that
said, the surfaces of the building s under consideration for this project are either
previously painted brick, or are other materials, s uch as stucc o w hich can support
paint without damaging the structural quality or historical character of the surfaces.
IV. DRAFT MOTION
1) I move that the City of Sumter Design R eview Board approve HP- 21-10 in
accordance wi th the materials, photographs, a nd con struction details
submitted and referenced in the Staff Report based o n compliance with Design
Review Guidelines.
2) I move that the City of Sumter Design Review Board deny HP-21-10
3) I move that the City of Sumter Design Review Board enter an alterna tive
motion.
V. DESIGN REVIEW BOARD – APRIL 22, 2021
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.