hp_21-19-45_n_main_st.pdf
City of Sumter · Sumter County · Other
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
This document is no longer listed on City of Sumter's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
City of Sumter Historic Preservation
Design Review
A
ugust 26, 2021
HP-21-19, 45 N. Main St.
I. T
HE REQUEST
Applicant:
Status of the Applicant:
Request:
District
Location:
Present Use/Zoning:
Tax Map Reference:
Adjacent Property Land Use
and Zoning:
Scott Bell
Project Designer
Design Review approval for exterior alterations
to include replacement of the storefront wind ow
system, new horizontal alum inum awning
system, removal of window shutters and
shingle/framing section at rear , installation of
new windows, replacement of side access door ,
painting of trim , d oors, and previous ly painted
masonry, and new business signage
Downtown Design District
45 N. Main St.
Commercial Storefront / CBD
228-12-05-001
North – Commercial Storefront / CBD
South – Commercial Storefront / CBD
East – Commercial Storefront / CBD
West – Commercial Storefront / CBD
II. B
ACKGROUND
45
N. Main St ., shown in the photograph
to the right, is a rectangular two -story
Vernacular Brick building that was
constructed around 1909. It has
previously served a variety of retail uses .
The building is on the east side of N. Main
St. at the intersection of N. Main St. and
Hampton Ave.
2
The applicant is proposing to complete exterior renovations including replacement of
the storefront wind ow system, installation of a new horizontal alum inum awning
system, removal of window shutters and shingle/framing section at rear, installation
of new windows, replacement of side access door, painting of trim , doors, an d
previously painted masonry, and new business signage
ARCHITECTURAL/HISTORIC CONTEXT:
45 N. M ain St. is a rectangular two -story Vernacular Brick building, co nstructed
around 1909, according to the Sanborn Fire Maps. The building originally served as
home of Antler’s Pharmacy, whose name was adopted because the Moose Club met on
the second floor. The building later housed Mit chell’s, the “ Twin-E” Fountain, and
Landmark Finance.
The property is identified as site # 25 in the 1985 Historic Resources Survey that
catalogued the structures in the downtown area. The front façade on the first level
consists of a main double glass recessed entrance door with storefront glass on either
side. There is an exterior entrance to the second floor facing N. Main St. next to the
storefront glass. On the second level there are three simple glass windows and seven
similar unevenly spaced windows on the E. Hampton Ave. façade . Also , on the side
façade toward the rear of the building on the lower level, a stucco finish has been
applied to the masonry with a false mansard wood shingled fa cia. The roof shape i s
flat and the exterior wall material is a combination of brick and masonry, the latter of
which has been painted.
Based on th e age of the building and architectural design and features, 45 N. Main
St. is considered a contributing structu re to the Downtown Sumter National Register
District and contributes to the City -designated Downtown Design Review D istrict.
The corners of Hampton Ave. and N. Main S t. – one of which this bui lding occupies -
are important as anchors of the historic downtown streetscape.
Previous design review approvals granted for this site include HP -04-24, to install an
awning (work never completed), and HP-00-21.
3
SITE PHOTOS:
Above: Current building exterior conditions, viewed from corner of Hampton Ave. and N. Main St.
Below: Current Building Exterior Conditions, as viewed from E. Hampton Ave.
4
SCOPE OF WORK:
The proposed project include s renovations to the exterior of 119 N. Mai n St. , as
follows:
1. Replacement of the storefront window system on N. Main St. façade.
2. Installation of a new horizontal aluminum awning system on both N. Main
St. and E. Hampton Ave. facades.
3. Removal of window shutters and shingle/framing section at rear o f E.
Hampton Ave. façade.
4. Installation of three (3) new windows on E. Hampton Ave. façade.
5. Replacement of entry door on E. Hampton Ave façade.
6. Painting of trim, doors, and previously painted masonry
7. New business signage.
The r enderings, eleva tions and pla ns displayed on pg . 5 & 6 s how the proposed
changes and new construction.
5
North Main St. Façade Existing Elevation
North Main St. Façade Proposed Elevation
6
E. Hampton Ave. Façade Existing Elevation
E. Hampton Ave. Façade Proposed Elevation
Proposed exterior paint colors are as f ollows: Secession Blue (DCR064) for the
masonry wall sections , Caribbean Waters ( DCR060) for t he door s, and Shoji White
(SW-7042) for the building trim.
Secession Blue
Duron DCR064
Caribbean Waters
Duron DCR060
Shoji White
Sherwin Williams 7042
7
DESIGN REVIEW:
Design review approval is required prior to the proposed work. The Design Review
Guidelines Manual states:
4.3 Exterior Walls: Masonry
A. Preserve Original Masonry and its Visual Qualities.
Retain masonry features that are important in defining the overall character of the building.
Do not remove or obscure masonry elements.
Do not paint unpainted masonry. Exceptions to this include masonry walls that have a
patchwork appearance from extensive replacement or rebuilding.
Staff Analysis:
The applicant is proposing to paint only masonry elements on the façades of the building
that have been previously painted. No unpainted masonry elem ents are proposed to be
disturbed by construction.
4.6 Windows
A. Preserve and Repair Historic Windows.
Retain historic windows that contribut e to the historic ch aracter of a building, including
functional and decorative features, such as frames, sash, muntins, mullions, decorative glass,
sills, trim, surrounds, and shutters.
Repair original windows by patch ing, splicing, consolidating, weather stripping, caulking, and
replacing missing glass.
Replace only those features that are beyond repair rather than replacing the entire window unit.
For example, sash replacement may be a less costly al ternative to a full window replacement.
Match the original feature in design, dimension, and material.
Improve the thermal efficiency by securely locking windows, adding weather stripping, and
installing interior or exterior storm windows.
Preserve origina l window locations , sizes, and types and restore altered window openings to
their historic configurations.
B. Replace Historic Windows with Compatible New Windows.
Replace historic windows only when damaged or deteriorated beyond reasonable repair or
missing.
Match the original windows in design, dimension, muntin profile, pane conf iguration, finish
and, where possible, material. If all of the original windows are missing, replacement windows
should reflect a design appropriate for the building form and architectural style.
Avoid the use of false muntins, either interna l or applied e xterior grilles, which do not resemble
the profile and depth of historic muntins.
Avoid reducing or increasing the size of a historic opening to accommodate a smaller or larger
window. Where necessary, limit this treatment to the rear or side elevations not visible from the
street.
Avoid elaborate stained glass or other decorative glass on the primary or visible secondary
elevations unless there is evidence that these features existed historically.
C. Maintain the Pattern and Rhythm of Original Window Openings.
Select an inconspicuous location for new window openings, such as the rear or side elevations
not visible from the street.
8
Add new window openings in a manner that minimizes impact on historic features and subtly
distinguishes them from historic windows.
Match the general size and alignment of original window openings when adding a new window
opening.
Do not enclose or obscure original window openings with added materials.
Staff Analysis:
The applicant is not proposing to replace any of the existing windows, which meets design
guidelines. The applicant is proposing to install three (3) new windows matching the
style of the existing 1 st floor windows on the E. Hampton Ave. façade. The addition of
these new windows also meets the design guidelines, as th e new windows will improve
the rhythm of window openings on the façade , with an irregular window pattern already
in place.
4.8 Doors
A. Preserve and Repair Historic Doors that Contribute to the Character of a Building .
Retain and rep air his toric doors, including dec orative features such as tri m, sidelights,
transoms, fanlights, and surrounds. Where possible, retain original hardware.
Preserve original door openings, sizes, and types and restore altered door openings to th eir
historic configurations.
Avoid painting previously unpainted doors unless extremely weathered.
Staff Analysis:
While replacement of the existing door on the E. Hampton Ave. façade would result in a
new door installation, the existing door in that location is not part of the original historic
building, and the proposed new door will carry the style of the storefront , particularly
that of the 2nd floor access door , to the secondary façade of the building, resulting in a
more cohesive visual appearance in keeping with the commercial nature of the district.
4.10 Storefronts
A. Preserve and Maintain Original Storefronts and their Character-Defining Features and Materials.
Retain the historic storefront configuration, including the original location and size of the
entrance doors, display windows, and transoms.
Retain storefront features that are not original, but have gained architectural and historical
value.
Retain and repair historic structural components, such as decorative cast iron elements and
stone or brick piers.
Retain and repair historic entrance doors and any distinctive hardware.
Retain and repair historic transoms, especially those with prism or leaded glass.
Retain and repair original wood or brick bulkheads. Also, retain elements such as Carrara
glass or glazed tile that have gained historic significance in their own right.
Retain and repair the historic cornice or sign band, which delineates the storefront from the
upper facade.
Protect historic features and material s by maintaining their historic protective finishes, such as
paint or stucco.
D. Consider a simplified or contemporary interpretation of a traditional storefront where the historic
storefront is missing or no evidence of it exists.
9
Base the new design on traditional storefront elements that reflect the scale, proportions,
materials, and colors of other commercial buildings in the district.
Use compatible materials that are in keeping with the style of the building.
Avoid creating a false historical appearance by introducing architectural elements where they
never previously existed.
Staff Analysis:
The applicant is proposing minor changes overall to the storefront, primarily replacement
of elements such as windows and doors without altering the dimensions, style, or nature
of the storefront configuration. Sta ff finds the proposed alterations to be consistent with
the design guidelines.
4.11 Paint
A. Maintain and repaint historically painted surfaces.
Remove paint from masonry only when the paint is not historic, will not reveal aesthetic issues,
and will not damage the masonry.
Do not paint unpainted masonry walls unless insensitive past repairs have negatively affected
the visual qualities of the masonry.
Do not strip paint or other coatings to reveal bare wood or apply a stain if the material did not
historically have a natural finish.
B. Select a Compatible Color Scheme.
Choose colors that are appropriate to the architectural style and complement the building and
its surroundings. Overly bright and obtrusive colors are not appropriate.
Consider an original color scheme based on paint analysis or research.
C. Use Paint Color to Accentuate Exterior Details.
Paint window and door sash and frames a contrasting color from t he walls to provide contrast
and depth.
Limit the paint scheme to three or four colors, one roof color, one wall color, one trim color, an d
one accent color.
Staff Analysis:
Surfaces proposed for pai nting con sist of all previously painted surfaces, including
masonry and window and door trim. The color scheme proposed consists of three colors, a
wall color (Secession Blue), a door color (Caribbean Waters), and a trim color ( Shoji
White). The colors proposed are consistent with the City of Sumter Historic Preservation
Color Palette, and the color scheme is compatible with the design guidelines.
4.12 Signs and Awnings
A. Place signs in a manner that is complementary, or subordinate to, the architecture of the building.
Locate signs on flat, unadorned areas, such as horizontal sign bands, existing signboards, or
vertical piers.
Place signs at or below the storefront cornice for a ground level business.
Position permissible portable signs so that they do not interfere with pedestrians or traffic sight
lines at intersections.
Pylon, monument, and other freestanding signs are generally not appro priate in the Downtown
Historic District. Where determined appropriate, freestanding signs shall be monument style.
B. Attach signs in a manner that will not damage or obscure architectural features.
10
Minimize the number of sign attachments to a building.
Avoid obstructing or damaging character- defining features, which include, but are not limited
to: a storefront or building cornice, decorative or patterned masonry, or window and door trim.
Attach signs in mortar joints rather than drilling holes in brick, stone, or concrete walls.
Use attractive hardware and supports of finished metal or wood to mount signs, particularly
projecting signs.
Take advantage of the locations of former signs to minimize additional impact on the building
by attaching new signs, where appropriate.
C. Limit the size and number of signs per building.
Limit sign area to less than 25 percent of the building front wall.
Relate sign proportions to the element on which it is placed.
Size the lettering and graphics of wind ow signs to be clearly legible, but not block views into or
from display windows.
Limit the size of transom signs to avoid blocking light to the interior or obscuring the transom
glazing.
Use signs that are pedestrian oriented and of a scale comfortable for a walking customer.
D. Use appropriate materials that complement the style and materials of the building.
Use traditional sign materials (finished wood, glass, metal, brass letters) or contemporary
products that have the same visual characteristics.
Finish sign edges to provide character and durability.
Limit the use of neon signs to the interior of buildings. Neon signs on building exteriors are not
appropriate.
Shiny plastic products, including internally-illuminated, plastic box signs are not appropriate.
Avoid painting signs directly on unpainted masonry walls.
E. Use colors that complement the building, including accent and trim colors.
A maximum of three colors is recommended per sign, although more may be appropriate in some
cases.
Use colors that relate to the overall color scheme of the building.
Use light or neutral colors on window signs—such as white or gold leaf—that are easy to read.
Minimize solid painted background behind window lettering, as it reduces transparency
F. Design signs to be simple and legible.
Keep sign message simple, easy to read, and in scale with the building and elements on which it
is placed.
Avoid lettering that is difficult to read or overly intricate.
Use no greater than two or three distinct typefaces.
Consider the use of a symbol and logo rather than words.
K. Preserve and Maintain Historic Awnings and Canopies.
L. Preserve and Maintain Historic Awnings and Canopies.
Size awnings to adequately fit commercial storefronts and window, door or porch op enings of
residential buildings.
Locate awnings on the transom bar or below the storefront cornice, above the transom, for
commercial buildings.
Proportion the awning to allow for ample sidewalk cle arance and projection over the sidewalk
in downtown.
Choose an appropriate awning shape . Standard sloped awnings are appropriate in most cases,
but circular or accordion designs can also be acceptable.
Choose appropriate awning fabrics, such as canvas, vinyl -coated canvas, and acrylic as awning
materials. Metal and vinyl awnings are not appropriate.
11
Ensure the materials and colors are compatible with the design and color scheme of the
building.
Consider using the awning valance as a sign panel for commercial buildings.
Consider retractable canvas awnings.
Staff Analysis:
The e xisting shallow aluminum awnings are not original to the building . Because the
awnings are not original t o the building and are in a style that is not conside red
appropriate to the district, removal is not considered detrimental to the property’s historic
value.
While the new awning proposed for both the N. Main St. and Law Range faca des of the
building is metal (aluminum), the style (flat) di stinguishes it from the style of metal
awning that the design guidelines seek to discourage in the Downtown District, a nd is
consistent with several other recent building rehabilitations on N. Main St . The size o f
the awning is appropriate to the building , and the placement location will provide
exposure to the previously covered transom windows that are one of the defining
characteristics of this historic building.
Proposed signage is c onsistent wi th the Design Review G uidelines, consisting of two
38x30 inch interlocking letter signs on the N. Main St. and E. Hampton Ave. façades
mounted on the corner s of the building above the p roposed awning. A smaller version
(approximately ¼ size) of the same icon will be mounted at eye level at the door on the E.
Hampton Ave. façade . The final signage element on the building will be 6- inch height
text spelling “Nicole Norris Design Studio” which will be mounted to the front of the flat
awning.
III. STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends approval of this request.
The Proposed changes are consistent with the City of Sumter Historic Preservation
Design Review Guidelines and are compatible with the existing building design.
IV. DRAFT MOTION
1) I move that the City of Sumter Design R eview Board approve HP-21-19 in
accordance wi th the materials, photographs, a nd construct ion details
submitted and referenced in the Staff Report based on compliance with Design
Review Guidelines.
2) I move that the City of Sumter Design Review Board deny HP-21-19
3) I move that the Cit y of Sumter Design Review Board enter an alterna tive
motion.
V. DESIGN REVIEW BOARD – AUGUST 26, 2021
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.