hp_20-02_100_w-liberty_st-city.pdf
City of Sumter · Sumter County · Other
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
This document is no longer listed on City of Sumter's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Historic Preservation Design Review
February 27, 2020
HP-20-02, 100 W. Liberty St. (City)
I. THE REQUEST
Applicant: Chris Hawkins
Status of the Applicant: Authorized Agent for property owner
Request: Design Review approval for installation of an
emergency exit door.
Location: 100 W. Liberty St.
Present Use/Zoning: Vacant/ CBD
Tax Map Reference: 228-13-03-003
Adjacent Property Land Use and
Zoning:
North – Commercial/ GC
South – Vacant /GC
East – Commercial/CBD
West – Commercial/ GC
II. BACKGROUND
The subject prop erty, sh own in the
photo to the right, is a vacant
commercial property located at 100 W.
Liberty St., at the intersection of W.
Liberty St. and S. Sumter St.
The a pplicant is requesting historic
district design review approval to install
an emergency exit door on th e eastern
portion of the structure along S. Sumter
St., which will accompany new interior
renovations to accommodate two new
tenants.
This work is required in order to comply
with required building and lif e s afety
code.
Additional photos of the subject property are shown below.
Above: View of the eastern elevation of the structure from S. Sumter St.;
Below: View of the rear elevation of the structure from S. Sumter St.
Historic Context
According to the Sumter County Tax Assessor Property Cards, the structure on the site
was constructed in 1960. It is a single-story commercial structure, with mid-century
modern architectural style. It is not from the peri od of signifi cance for th e Sumter
Downtown Historic District . The site was last used as a realtor’s office. T he proposed
renovations are in order to accommodate an incoming medical office use.
Scope of Work
The proposed project will include the following exterior al terations to the S. Sumter
frontage of the subject property.
Installation of Emergency Fire Door:
• Installation of door unit on the eastern portion of the building façade , along the S.
Sumter St. frontage
Plans for the proposed door location are shown below.
The Design Review Guidelines Manual states:
3.2 Visibility and Level of Review
In addition to the identification of character defining -building components, it is important
to understand the role that visibility plays in determining the app lication of the design
guidelines. As the goal of the design review process is to preserve the visual qualities that
give a district its historic character , the areas of a buil ding that are highly visible from the
public right-of-way are the most important . The highest level of preservation with the least
amount of change is the best approach for these areas. In the Downtown Historic District,
where adjacent buildings for solid “street walls,” this highly sensitive area may be limited
to the front of the bu ilding. In the cases of corner buildings or freestanding buildings, such
as larger institutional buildings or residences, this area may extend to the sides and rear of
a building, as we ll. Areas along the sides and rear of a building, depending on their
location and surrounding buildings, may not be as highly visible as the front and are,
therefore, secondary in their importance. These less visible, secondary areas allow for
greater flexibility in their treatment. The level of sensitivity will also depend o n the
building’s overall significance, architectural style, and level of detailing.
Staff Analysis:
The property at 100 W. Liberty St. is a
corner lot, with frontage along W. Liberty
St., and S. Sumter St. Due to the pattern of
development for the site, both frontages are
highly visible from the adjacent right of way.
Due to the proposed interior configuration of
the building, the emergency access door is
required o n the eas tern faç ade. It is not
possible to install landscaping to shield view
of the door since the building in constructed
up to the S. Sumter St. property line ,
abutting a public sidewalk.
4.8 Doors
Doors provide attractive, welcoming entrances to interior spaces. Like windows, they reflect
the architectural style of a building and are important elements of architectural character.
Residential doors are characterized by wood panels and in some cases, glass panes. The
arrangement of panels and panes will differ depending on the style of the door. Main
entrances tend to feature decorative elements, such as sidelights, transoms, fanlights, and
milled surrounds. It is common for commercial doors to have more glazing, often with a
single glass pane and sometimes raised wood panels.
C. Add new door openings in a manner that minimizes impact on historic features and
subtly distinguishes them from historic doors.
➢ Select and inconspicuous location for new door openings, such as the rear or side
elevations not visible from the street.
➢ Use clear glass for doors on the primary and readily visible secondary facades.
Tinted glass may only be uses on rear or side elevations not visible from the street.
➢ Decorative or stained glass is only appropriate if there is evidence that this feature
existed historically.
➢ Modern wood, fiberglass, or steel doors may be appropriate on rear or side elevations
not visible from the street.
Staff Analysis:
Historic Preservation guidelines
typically advocate the utiliz ation of
more traditional materials for doors
on highly visible portions of a
structure.
The submitted design for the door is a
standard metal emergency exit door,
painted dark bronze, as shown in the
images to the right.
Due to the lack of screening or
landscaping, the proposed door
location will be highly visible from
right of way along S. Sumter St . For
such a location, HP guidelines would
normally call for a higher quality of
design. However, this minimalist approach
is in keeping the with the modern
architecture of the building.
In this instance, a storefront style approach is not
appropriate. Additionally, t he material and
design of this emergency side door are dictated by
safety and building code.
The door’s installation will no t result in the
removal of any architecturally or historically
significant features.
III. STAFF RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends approval of this request . The work is required by emergency code, and
the structure itself is not architecturally or historically significant.
IV. DRAFT MOTION
1.) I move that the Sumter Historic Preservation Design Review Committee ap prove
HP-20-02 in accordance with the specifications and photographs submitted as a part
of this request and based on compliance with Design Review Guidelines.
2.) I move that the Sumter Historic Preservation Design Review Committe e deny HP -
20-02
Above: Proposed door design
Below: Proposed “Dark Bronze” aluminum finish
3.) I move that the Sumter Historic Preservation Design Review Committee enter an
alternative motion.
V. HISTORIC PRESERVATION – FEBRUARY 27, 2020
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.