RecordWell Data

hp_20-03_438_w-hampton_ave-city.pdf

City of Sumter · Sumter County · Other

Open the original document More from City of Sumter

This document is no longer listed on City of Sumter's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Historic Preservation Design Review February 27, 2020 HP-20-03, 438 W. Hampton St. (City) I. THE REQUEST Applicant: Patrick Enzor Status of the Applicant: Authorized Agent for property owner Request: Design Review approval for the construction of a new single family dwelling with attached rear garage Location: 438 W. Hampton Ave. Present Use/Zoning: Vacant/ R-6 (Residential-6) Tax Map Reference: 228-11-03-035 Adjacent Property Land Use and Zoning: North – Residential/Residential-6 (R-6) South – Residential/Residential-6 (R-6) East – Residential/Residential-6 (R-6) West – Residential- R-6 II. BACKGROUND This request seeks Historic Preservation Design Approval for the construction of a new single - family residential dwelling at 438 W. Hampton Ave., shown in red on the location map to the right. The property is a narrow, 0.28 acre vacant lot located between two existing single family residential lots. Photos of the property are shown on the following page. Historic Context The site is currently vacant, and aerial photography indicates that the property has been without a structure since at least 1989. Above: View of the subject property from W. Hampton Ave. The property was not included in the 1984 Historical Resources Survey due to the lack of a structure on the site. The applicant intends to utilize this property to construct a new single-family dwelling. Scope of Work: The scope of this project is the constructi on of a new single -family dwelling , with an attached rear garage. A rough plot plan of the proposed structure is shown to the right. The structure will be clad in vinyl siding and windows, black architectural shingles , with wooden porch columns and fixtures. Renderings of t he structure are sho wn on the following page, however, note that the color shown on the renderings doe s not accurately portray the proposed color chosen by the applicant , which is detailed later in the report. Above: Angled rendering of the structure; Below: Front elevation of the structure Above: Rear building elevation Above: Western building elevation; Below: Eastern building elevation Above: Proposed floorplan of the structure Design review approval is required prior to undertaking the proposed changes. The Design Review Guidelines Manual states: 6.2 Residential Properties High quality infill construction on vacant or underutilized lots has the potential to strengthen the vitality of t he Hampton park design review district, and over time, contribute to i ts evolving architectural character. Existing buildings in the residential historic district represent a variety of architectural styles. While these buildings differ in their detailing and level of ornament, certain patterns area consistent among them in terms of their siting and appearance. The intent of these guidelines is to encourage new buildings that reinforce and respond to the principal design elements of historic houses in the district, while reflecting their own time in the development of the city. A. Design buildings to reflect their own time  Avoid the direct imitation of the historic style that would blur the distinction between old and new.  Avoid any reference to historic styles that precede the grow th and development of the district. Staff Analysis: The proposed structure is a simple, straightforward design that draws inspiration from elements of shotgun-style houses. While it lacks the shotgun -style floor plan, the entire structure, including the attached garage , is perpendicu lar to the s treet, and follows the slim profile characteristic of the style. By altering the floorplan, and incorporating more modern materials, the st ructure avoids conveying a false historic character, and w ill be easily id entifiable as a non- historic structure. B. Incorporate the principal elements of the traditional residential structures into the design of new house Staff Analysis The principal design element that the newly proposed structure bo rrows from traditional residential design is the inclusi on of a covere d front porch. This serves to concentrate visual in terest to the front of the structure and ensures that the d esign keeps a human scale. The proposed design also modi fies a traditional design element of residential structures in the area through the i nclusion of a side loading attached garage. Garages in the Hampton Park area are ty pically detached, or not present on the site at all. In this design, the garage is built flush with the s tructure, and is designed to appear to b e a continuation of the resi dential dwelling. By not including a secondary structure, this design seeks to preserve the dwelling as the primary visual focal point. C. Relate the setback, orientation, and spacing of new construction to that of existing buildings.  Align new constructio n with the setback established by adjacent houses, while conforming to zoning requirements.  Establish an average setback if the standards of adjacent houses are inconsistent  Maintain average side yard setbacks based on adjacent houses and adhering to applicable zoning regulations  Orient the primary façade to the major street onto which the lot faces. Staff Analysis Due to the varied time of development for the homes on W. Hampton Ave ., setbacks for other homes in the surrounding area are inconsistent , with several of the neighboring dwellings encroaching into setback areas, or over property lines. Front setbacks in this area vary from as little as approximately eight (8) ft. at 437 W. Hampton Ave., to nearly 60 ft. at 443 W. Hampton Ave. T he proposed 25 ft. setback is smaller t han the 40 -45 ft. setbacks for the adjacent structures at 436 and 442 W. Hampton, Ave. The proposed 25 Ft. setback is consistent with zoning requirements. The proposed structure will be l ocated eight (8) ft. from the eastern property line and will be located 25 ft. from the western property line to accommodate the driveway for the use. This site configuration is consistent with development along Hampton Ave. D. Develop respectful relationships in terms of size, scale and ma ssing t o adjacent historic buildings  Use an appropriate form and massing for new construction that relates to the majority of the surrounding buildings  Reflect the widths of adjacent buildings in new construction., Generally, new construction should not differ in width by more than 10 percent from typical buildings on the street  Reflect the heights of adjacent houses in new construction. Generally, new construction should not differ in height by more than 10 percent from typical buildings on the street.  Create visual interest at the ground level to emphasize the human scale of the building by incorporating functional elements like traditional front porches Staff Analysis As proposed, the s ingle-family dwelling will be 23 ft. wide a t the front porch area , expanding to a uniform 27 ft. wide throughout the rest of the structure. Neighbo ring structures a re similar in width at their front setback , b ut typically expand to larger widths of 40-50 ft. The result of th e applicant ’s proposed layout is a substantially thinner building tha n is typical in the a rea, and that lacks the visual intere st generated by the modulation of the façade into larger sections. However, due to the smaller lot size (60 f t. i n width ), and de cision to u tilize a side loading attached garage, site development is constrained to the thinner, less conventional shape and design in order to accommodate the side driveway. E. Choose roof forms for new construction that are similar to adja cent historic examples  Use a minimum roof pitch of 6:12 and a maxi mum roof pitch of 12:12 to facilitate drainage. Staff Analysis The applicant intends to uti lize a roof pitch of 6:12, which is consistent with Design Review Guidelines, and is similar in pitch to the home at 436 W. Hampton Ave. F. Respect the height and c ontrast of materials of foundations on adjacent historic buildings  Align foundation height of new construction with adjacent houses  Ensure foundation heights is within 10 percent of the average foundation height of adjacent houses  Build a new foundation at least one foot above grade on the primary elevation  Differentiate the foundation level fr om the main wall plane through a change in material or texture Staff Analysis This request details a brick foundation, which is consistent with adjacent development, and will be built to a similar height as adjacent development. The brick foundation will then transition into vinyl siding, which will d ifferentiate the foundation level from the rest of the home. H. Incorporate a porch on the primary elevation of new residential construction  Ensure that the design, placement, and height of a porch is in accordance with those of adjacent buildings on the block  Design a porch to have a depth of at least 6 feet, although 8 to 10 ft. is recommended to create a usable space.  Use simple, round or square columns of a uniform shape and style, with a base and a cap. Aim for a minimum diameter of 6 inches and a maximum diameter of 10 inches for cornices and frieze boards, soffits, eaves, trim and moldings.  Use simple square balusters with appropriate proportions and spacing.  Design the porch roof with a pitch equal to or less than that of the main roof Staff Analysis The porch as submitted is 23 ft. wide, an d eight (8) ft . in depth , with 8-inch stained wooden columns, wooden balusters, and matching wood railing. The roof is consistent in mater ial with the roofing on the rest of the structure but is at a significantly lower pitch than the dwelling’s primary roof. The porch is lacki ng some finer design detail f ound elsewhere in the district, such as bases a nd caps fo r the support columns, but overall is consistent with design review guidelines. I. Arrange Windows and Doors to r eflect the traditional size and proportion of those on adjacent houses  Keep new doors and window openings within 10 percent of the height and width of those on adjacent historic houses  Proportion windows to be approximately twice as tall as they are wide Staff Analysis The proposed doo r for the structure is consistent in siz e and location as adjacent structures and meets design review guidelines. The width of the window s for the proposed structure are a larger departure from the surrounding pattern of development. The applicant is proposing two (2) squa re windows on the front elevation, with a two over two sash configurat ion, with an identical window included on the western elevation. The home also will utilize si x vertically oriented one over one rectangular windows on the side elevations that are more consistent with the pattern of development for the area. While guidelines generally advocate for rectangular, vertical ly arranged windows , in this instance the larger windows on the front elevation serve to create a more visually interesting space due to the small width of the building. J. Arrange windows and doors to reflect t he spacing, rhythm and alignment of others in the district Staff Analysis While the arrangement of t he windows and doors on the front elevation is consistent with the rhy thm and s pacing found elsewhere in the district , the place ment of windows elsewhere on the structure is less conventional. The window openings for the structure are configured t o match the unconventional floor plan , and a s a result are not uni form in locat ion a nd spacing like other homes in the d istrict. This results in concentrations of windows near the front of the home, and large stretches of buildi ng without any windo ws at all. The rear elevation in particular does not have any exterior windows. Surrounding homes have their window s more even ly dist ributed throughout the length of the structure. K. Relate the ratio of solid walls to voids (window s and doors) of new houses to that of adjacent historic houses.  Avoid blank walls by covering a minimum of 20 percent of wall surface between the eaves and foundation with window and door openings.  Avoid large expanses of glass or solid wall that convey a contemporary appearance. Staff Analysis As mentioned previously, there are large sections of th e side and rear of the structure that are solid walls lacking adornment or windows to generate visual interest. Design Review Guidelines in this instance wou ld advocate for a more even distr ibution of windows in order to maintain a more consistent appearance throughout the structure. L. Use traditional styles found in the district as the basis for new doors and windows  Incorporate glazing, sidelights, and a transom into the designs of new entrances  Use a pane configuration for windows that is compatible with ot her houses in the district and that is consistent with the style of the house.  Scale shutters to fit the window opening and only use them when they are in keeping with the style of the house. Staff Analysis The applicant intends to utilize a simple wooden shaker style door with glass glazing, in a white color. While the door design does incorporate glazing, it lacks some of the more decorative fea tures of doors typically found in the historic district, such as sidelights and transoms The windows will b e a vinyl material consistent with many of the newer replacement windows in the Hampton Park area. The fro nt windows will be accented by inoperable wooden shutters. The shutters as proposed are not sized appropriately to the windows the y accompany. Design r eview guidelines would advocate for installing proportionately appropriate shutters or removing them from the design. M. Reinterpret traditional architectural design elements in a contemporary manner  Incorporate simplified architectural features that reflect but do not duplicate similar features found on existing historic buildings in the district  Concentrate architectural detail in areas that traditionally feature detail , such as floor transitions, window surrounds, and cornices or pediments  Use detail that is three dimensional to add visual interest and texture to the façade Staff Analysis The bulk of the architectural detail of the house is concentrated in the front elevation, particularly in the porch design . However, due to the orientation of the structure, the western elevation of the structure will also be highly visible. The historic guidelines in this instance would advocate for additional architectural detail in elements along the side of the structure such as using cornices, friezes, or utilizing other forms of architectural detailing to create visual interest. N. Choose high quality and durable materials that are visually compatible with and complimentary to the architectural character of the district and surrounding buildings  Use brick or concrete for the foundation material. If concrete block is used, it should be painted or covered with stucoo  Use wood or brick for exterior wall cladding of new construction or additions  Employ a uniform primary wall material on all sides of the building  Use horizontally oriented weatherb oard, clapboard , or shiplap siding for frame buildings  Use traditional materials for trim, windows, doors, porches, and other decorative features. Contemporary materials that are compatible with historic materials may be acceptable if the material conveys the visual qualities of traditional materials.  Consider traditional standing seam metal or asphalt shingles. Staff Analysis Like many homes in the historic district, the proposed structure u tilizes a traditional brick foundation material, but eschews traditional wooden or brick cladding in favor of vinyl siding. The guid elines strongly advocate for new construction to utilize traditional materials for the siding of a building , however within the Hampton Park district, a general certificate of appropriat eness has been issue d for vinyl siding , allowing the Historic Preservation Board to approve its use. O. Select from a coordinated color palette informed by historic precedent and compatible with adjacent buildings and the district as a whole. Staff Analysis Much of the struc ture’s color will be the result of the color of the prefabricated vinyl siding , which in this i nstance is Tuscan Olive. A photo of the proposed material and color is shown in the imag e to the right and on the image on the proceeding page. Other than the vinyl siding, the only other colors present on the structure wi ll be the black architectural shingles , and the white windows and doors. The proposed color palate is neutral in nature and is consistent with the c haracter of the Hampton Park area. III. STAFF RECOMMENDATION This request is a basic design t hat is relatively sim ple in terms of ornamentation and architectural detail in comparison to the majority of the homes in the Hampton Park area. Several of the design choices for the structure, such as the window placement, are unconventional, however many of these design features are dictated by constraints resulting from the small size of the site. Overall, the structure i s generally consistent with the design re view guidelines. Sta ff recommends approval of the request , with consideration that the structure be moved further back on the site to match the se tback lines of the adjacent properties to the east and west consistent with the City of Sumter Historic District Guidelines. IV. DRAFT MOTION 1.) I move that the Su mter Historic Preservation Design Review Committee approve HP-20-03 in accordance with the materials, photographs, and construction details submitted and referenced in the Staff Report based on compl iance with Design Review Guidelines. 2.) I move that the Sum ter Historic P reservation Design Review Committee deny HP - 20-03 3.) I move that the Sumter Historic Preservation Design Review Committee enter an alternative motion. V. HISTORIC PRESERVATION – February 27, 2020 The Sumter Historic Preservation Design Review Committee at its meeting on Thursday, February 27, 2020, deferred the request for the construction of a new si ngle family dwelling with attached rear garage. The Board has requested that the bui lding plans be modified to add additional architectural detailing and address window placement on the side facades to make structure more compatible with the District as a whole. VI. HISTORIC PRESERVATION – MARCH 26, 2020

Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.