hp-20-08-10_s_main_st_city.pdf
City of Sumter · Sumter County · Other
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
This document is no longer listed on City of Sumter's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Historic Preservation Design Review
June 25, 2020
HP-20-08, 10 S. Main St. (City)
I. THE REQUEST
Applicant: R. Scott Bell
Status of the Applicant: Project Architect
Request: Design Review approval for rear elevation renovations.
Location: 10 S. Main St.
Present Use/Zoning: Commercial / CBD
Tax Map Reference: 228-13-07-015
Adjacent Property
Land Use and
Zoning:
North – Sumter Original Brewery / CBD
South – Vacant Building / CBD
East – S. Main St. / CBD
West – Pedestrian Alley & Liberty Center / CBD
II. BACKGROUND
10 S. Main St., (front elevation shown in the
photograph to the right ), was most recently used
by Standard Music and as storage space. Long
term plans for the building include use of the
rear of the facility as storage sp ace for p roduct
from the adjacent brewery . The storefront and
second floor uses are undetermined at this time.
The A pplicant is requesting design review
approval to make alterations to the rear (alley -
facing) elevation of the building in order to
provide improved a ccess to the space for large
items, and to make cosmetic changes inclu ding
new paint and removal of abandoned u tility
conduits.
2
Historic Context
Based upon the Sumter County Assessor’s
Record, the building was constructed in
1910, however a s tructure existed on this
site as early as 1889 based upon Sanborn
maps. The earliest photo of the building,
shown to the r ight was from the 1900s.
Based upon archival photos, by 1959, the
upper façade had been altered to include
covering of the six (6) se cond story windows
and brickwork. By 1985 when the first
Downtown historic resources survey was
undertaken, all historic character had been
removed or covered over and the structure
was deemed to not be contributing to the
National Register Historic District.
In t he early 1900s, prior to façade
alterations, the building was a good
architectural example of the Main Street
Commercial Form. This architectural style
was popular from 1875 to around 1940.
Main Street Commercial Buildings feature ground level stor efronts with large display
windows to showcase goods to consumers. Upper stories usually functioned as living space
for th e shop owner or as storage. The building plan is generally rectangular with a
symmetrical façade. Roofs are typically fla t with a par apet. Ent rances are commonly
glazed doors with transoms flanked by large storefront windows to display goods
surmounted by transoms. Windows on upper floors are typically double -hung sash
windows. Const ruction materials are commonly brick, wood, stucco, an d cast me tal.
Decorative wood, brick or metal cornices, patterned or corbelled brickwork and sign bands
are not uncommon,
In 2018, following design review approval, the site’s previous owner conducted some
facade restorations which included removal of an awning and demolition of portions of the
previous facade that were not considered historic.
3
Site Photos:
Rear building (alley) elevation
North side door (proposed for replacement with 8x10
ft coil-up door and new 3x7 ft metal door)
View of pedestrian and service alley
from south
South side door (proposed for replacement
with new 3x7 ft metal door.
4
Scope of Work:
It is the A pplicant’s intent to complete r ear elevation renovations to the building , which
faces an existing alley. Renovations include adjustments to doors, removal of abandoned
utility conduit, and repainting.
Based upon the submitted architectural elevation/rendering, the following is proposed:
1) Install new 8x10’ coil-up door
2) Replace existing north side door with new painted 3x7’ hollow metal door and shift
door location to accommodate new coil-up door;
3) Replace existing south side door with new painted 3x7’ hollow metal door;
4) Remove existing abandoned sprinkler lines;
5) Remove existing abandoned downspout;
6) Remove existing exposed electrical conduit;
7) Repaint existing windows, trim, bars, and sills;
8) Paint brick walls;
Below, a building elevation shows the scope of proposed renovations.
5
The proposed colors are shown below. Renwick Beige will be the wall color. Fairfax Brown
will be the door color, and Classical White will be the window, trim, bar, and sill color.
Design review approval is required prior to the proposed work.
The Design Review Guidelines Manual states:
4.3 Exterior Walls: Masonry
Exterior masonry walls exist in both the commercial and residential historic district.
Masonry materials include brick, stone, concrete, stucco, and terraco tta. Brick i s the most
common m asonry material used in Sumter and is used primarily for exterior walls,
foundations, and chimneys. Some exterior masonry walls are solid brick, while others are
brick veneer, consisting of a single brick course over a wood frame structu ral system. In
both cases, the brick exterior wall surface, and their associated bond patterns and textures,
define the appearance and character of the building. Masonry elements can also be used to
create decorative details and textures, such as corbelled brick patterns and inlays or bel t
courses.
The color and texture of masonry is an important defining feature, as is the mortar that
bonds the masonry units. Mortar for mo st historic buildings is composed of a mixture of
lime and sand, which a llows for ex pansion and co ntraction of the mortar joint in hot and
cold weather. In most cases, the use of modern Portland cement is not appropriate for
historic buildings, as it is stronger than traditional historic mortars and does not allow for
joint expansion or co ntraction. It is common for houses and commercial buildings in the
historic districts to feature a flush or concave mortar joints.
A. Preserve Original Masonry and its Visual Qualities.
Retain masonry features that are important in defining the overall character of the
building.
Do not remove or obscure masonry elements.
Do not paint unpainted masonry. Exceptions to this include masonry walls that have
a patchwork appearance from extensive replacement or rebuilding.
6
Staff Analysis:
The proposed project meets the above s tandards. The brickwork on the rear elevation
of the site has been pr eviously painted, and removal of aban doned non-historic utility
elements, including abandoned electrical and sprinkler conduit s and downspouts will
result in better visibility of the masonry itself.
4.8 Doors
Doors provide attractive, welcoming entrances to interior spaces. Like windows, they reflect
the architectural style of a building and are important elements of architectural character.
C. Add New Door Openings in a Man ner that Minimizes Impact on Historic Features and
Subtly Distinguishes Them from Historic Doors.
Select an inconspicuous location for new door openings, such as the rear or side
elevations not visible from the street.
Use clear glass for doors on the pri mary and read ily visible seconda ry facades.
Tinted glass may only be used on rear or side elevations not visible from the street
Decorative or stained glass is only appropriate if there is evidence that this feature
existed historically
Modern wood, fiberglass, or steel doors may be appropriate on rear or side elevations
that are not visible from the street.
Staff Analysis:
The proposed adjustments to the door configuration meet the ab ove standard. The
proposed work is in the rear alle y of the building, an inconspicuous area not
immediately visible from the street . The alley is, by nature, intended to support non-
public building access and use for bringing deliveries into the building.
4.11 Paint
B. Select a Compatible Color Scheme.
Choose col ors that a re appropriate to the architectural style and complement the
building and i ts surroundings. Overly bright and obtrusive colors are not
appropriate.
Consider an original color scheme based on paint analysis or research.
C. Use Paint Color to Accentuate Exterior Details.
Use muted or dark colors for the walls of a building.
Use lighter colors to highlight trim and architectural ornamentation.
Paint window sash and frames a contrasting color than the walls to provide contrast
and depth to window openings.
7
Limit the paint scheme to three or four colors: one roof color, one wall color, on trim
color, and one accent color.
Staff Analysis:
The proposed color scheme meets the above standard s. The colors selected are in
keeping with the o verall architectural style of the area and the paint select ed is
limited to one (1) wall color, one (1) trim color, and one (1) door color.
III. STAFF RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends approval of this request. The overall proposal is compatible with
established guidelines and is based upon photographic record from the structure’s period
of significance.
IV. DRAFT MOTION
1.) I move that the Sumter Historic Preservation Design Review Committee approve
HP-20-08 in accordance with the materials, photographs, and co nstruction details
submitted an d referenced in the Sta ff Report based on compliance with Design
Review Guidelines.
2.) I move that the Sumter Historic Preservation Design Review Committee deny HP -
20-08.
3.) I move that the Sumter Historic Preservation Design Rev iew Committee enter a n
alternative motion.
V. HISTORIC PRESERVATION – MARCH 26, 2020
The scheduled March 26, 2020 Historic Preserva tion Design Review Committee meeting
was postponed by order of City Counc il, in the keeping with Center f or Disease Control
(CDC) guidelines related to the COVID-19 virus.
VI. HISTORIC PRESERVATION – JUNE 25, 2020
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.