hp-20-13-419_w-calhoun_st.pdf
City of Sumter · Sumter County · Other
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
This document is no longer listed on City of Sumter's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Historic Preservation Design Review
June 25, 2020
HP-20-13, 419 W. Calhoun St. (City)
I. THE REQUEST
Applicant: Robert S. McCreight
Status of the Applicant: Property Owner
Request: Design Review for proposed 420 sq. ft. breakfast room/covered
patio addition to the rear of the existing structure
Location: 419 W. Calhoun St.
Present Use/Zoning: Residential (R-9)
Tax Map Reference: 228-06-01-026
Adjacent Property
Land Use and
Zoning:
North – Residential / R-9
South – W. Calhoun St. and Residential / R-9
East – Residential / R-9
West – Residential / R-9
II. BACKGROUND
The applicant is requesting design
review approval for a +/- 350 sq. ft.
addition to the rear of the existing
structure to serve as a covered
patio. Based on submitted plan s,
the a ddition is intended to be of
the similar materials and colors as
the existing structure as shown in
the photographs to the right.
Architectural/Historic Context
Constructed in 1928, 419 W.
Calhoun St. is a 4,038 sq. ft. Colonial Revival influenc ed dwelli ng s ituated at the
westernmost edge of the Hampton Park Historic District Overlay. Although the structure
was not included in the 1980 Historic Resources Survey I nventory for the Hampton Park
Neighborhood, based on its age, condition, and minimal changes to t he exterior of the
structure that could compromise its historic character and defining architectural
2
characteristics, this structure could be considered to be a contributing structure within the
fabric of the Hampton Park Historic District. T he front of th e structure gives the
appearance of being wood sided, however as shown in the photographs below, a majority of
the building exterior is brick with wood sided gabled ends, soffits and trim work.
In 2011, the applicant received approval to construct a 420 sq. ft. addition to the east side
of the existing structure to serve as an extension to the existing kitchen as a breakfast
area and outdoor covered patio dining area.
Site Photos:
Existing rear of structure (side view) Existing rear of structure (facing view)
Existing entry door from side porch.
(Proposed entry doors on rear porch
will match this style.)
Existing side porch.
(Proposed rear porch will match this style.)
3
Scope of Work:
It is the Applicant’s proposal is to complete a rear elevation addition of +/- 350 sq. ft. to the
residence to serve as a covered patio, tied into the existing roofline. The addition will
match the sty le of the existing covered porch that was added in 2011 . In addition, an in-
ground pool is to be constructed in the rear yard immediately behind the addition . Design
review of the swimming pool is not required and is outside the scope of this request.
Following are concept drawings showing the scope of proposed addition:
4
A white paint color matching the existing exterior paint on the structure will be used for
the columns and tri m, and the existing rear elevation brick will serve as the rear wal l of
the covered porch , this area of brick will also be painted white. New brick to be used for
the addition will be the “Rittenburg” style, also matching existing materials in use on the
structure.
Design review approval is required prior to the proposed work.
The Design Review Guidelines Manual states:
4.9 Porches
Porches are often the focal points of historic homes, espec ially when positioned on primary
elevations. They provide an area for people to gather and socialize, as well as serving as an
important transition space between the interior and exterior of a residence. Porches can
define the overall character and style of a building, with their distinctive columns, railings,
steps, and decorative detailing. In Hampton P ark, almost all houses have some type of
porch on the primary or street elevation. Side and rear porches are less com mon, but
examples do exist in the dist rict. Some porches extend across the entire width of the façade
while others only shelter the entranc e. Most are one story in height, with two -story porches
being rare. While the overall p lan and form of porches are si milar, their detailing and
ornamentation varies depending on the architectural style of the house.
D. Preserve and Retain Original Porch Locations Masonry and its Visual Qualities.
Locate new porches and decks with no histo rical significance in an incon spicuous
location on the rear or side elevations of a building that a re not visible from the
street.
Staff Analysis:
The proposed project meets the above standards.
4.11 Paint
The right combination of paint colors can accen tuate important architectural features and
unify the façade. In addi tion to its aesthetic benefit s, paint also provides protection to
certain building surfaces, particularly wood. Due to these protective qualities, building
components that were hi storically pa inted should remain pain ted. Alternatively, surfaces
that were n ot historically painted, such as brick and stone, should remain unpainted to
retain their historic texture and appearance. Appropriate paint schemes differ depending
on the architectural style and era of a building. Historically appropriate color schemes for a
particular style can be determined based on paint analysis or research.
B. Select a Compatible Color Scheme.
5
Choose colors that are appropriate to the architectural sty le and compl iment the
building and its s urroundings. Overly bright and obtrusiv e colors are not
appropriate.
Staff Analysis:
The proposed paint color meets the above standards.
III. STAFF RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends approval of this request. The proposed pro ject meets the requirements
set forth in the design review guidelines and the colors and materials proposed are already
in use on the existing dwelling.
IV. DRAFT MOTION
1.) I move that the Sumter Historic Preservation Design Review Committee approve
HP-20-13 in accordance with the materials, photographs, and co nstruction details
submitted an d referenced in the Staff Report based on compliance with Design
Review Guidelines.
2.) I move that the Sumter Historic Preservation Design Review Committee deny HP -
20-13.
3.) I move that the Sumter Historic Preservation Design Rev iew Committee enter an
alternative motion.
VI. HISTORIC PRESERVATION – JUNE 25, 2020
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.