hp_20-06_521_w-hampton_ave_city.pdf
City of Sumter · Sumter County · Other
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
This document is no longer listed on City of Sumter's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Historic Preservation Design Review
June 25, 2020
HP-20-06, 521 W. Hampton Ave. (City)
I. THE REQUEST
Applicant: Judy Burket
Status of the Applicant: Property Owner
Request: Design Review for the construction of a 960 sq. f t. accessory
structure, gate installation, enclosure of a rear screen porch ,
and construction of a new rear deck.
Location: 521 W. Hampton Ave.
Present Use/Zoning: Single-Family Residential / Residential-9 (R-9)
Tax Map Reference: 228-11-01-015
Adjacent Property Land
Use and Zoning:
North –Residential / Residential-9 (R-9)
South – W. Hampton Ave. & Residential / Residential-9 (R-9)
East – Residential / Residential-9 (R-9)
West – Residential / Residential-9 (R-9)
II. BACKGROUND
521 W. Hampton Ave., shown in the
photo t o the right, was a cquired in
2019 by the owners of the adjacent
property at 519 W. Hampton Ave.
The subject property contains a
single-family residential dwelling
that has been vacant for a
significant amount of time . This
property was the subject of
extensive codes enforcement ac tion
prior to purchase by the applicant.
The applicant intends to restore the
structure.
In late 2019, the applicant received
2
design review approval via HP-19-21 to make su bstantial renovations to the
structure, including replacement of the metal standing seam roof with architectural
shingles, repair of rotten beams and supports, and install ation of vinyl siding . As
shown in the photos below, this work is still ongoing.
Above: Side view of the home; Below: Rear view of the home
3
Architectural/Historic Context:
Based on the Sumter County Tax Assessor’s records, the site’s existing single-family
residence was constructed circa 1925. The residence is in the California Bungalow
style, and is characterized by a pedimented projecting po rch, shi plap siding, an d
double porch piers. It is a contributing structure to the fabric of the Hampton Park
Historic District based on its age and architectural details.
Scope of Work:
The applicant proposes to perform the following work:
1. Enclosure of existing rear screen porch.
2. Construction of a new 336 sq. ft. (16 x 21 ft. ) floating rear deck immediately
adjacent to the residence.
3. Construction of a 960 s q. ft. ( 30 x 32 ft.) rear accessory structure with black
architectural shingles, vinyl windows and siding.
4. Installation of a 5 ft. tall wooden side gate.
Images submitted b y the applicant detailing the proposed desi gn of the accessory
structure and gate are shown below.
Above: Proposed accessory structure design
4
Above: Proposed fence material and finish
Design Review:
The Design Review Guidelines Manual states:
4.9 Porches
A. Retain Original Porch Elements
Preserve and maintain original porch elements including floors, beadboard
ceilings, column s, supports, pilasters, railings, steps, lattice, and
decorative trim.
C. Preserve and retain original porch configuration
Porch enclosures may be appropriate on the rear or side elevations that are
less prominent.
Use screen panels with the minimum numbe r of vertical and horizontal
framing members necessary to enclose the porch. Recess panels behind
porch columns and railings. Wood frames are more appropriate than
metal.
D. Preserve and Retain Original Porch Locations
Locate new porches and decks with no historical basis in an inconspicuous
location on the rear or side elevations of a building that are not visible
from the street.
5
Staff Analysis:
Much of th e existing rear screen porch element had to be r eplaced during t he
previous renovations due to sig nificant water damage. At thi s time, t he screen
material and door has been removed, and all beams on the porch have been replaced
with new wood.
The applicant intends to enclose this rear porch with the same vinyl siding that was
approved for the rest of th e home via HP-19-21, and replace the screen door with a
solid wooden door that was previously used in one of the home’s interior hallways.
Design review guidelines typically do not support enclosing porches that historically
were open , but a s the p orch is located to the rear of th e property the guidelines
afford it additional leeway with enclosure.
The applicant also proposes to construct a new 336 sq . ft. (16 x 21 ft. ) floating rear
deck immediately adjacent to the residence. The proposed deck will not be attached
to the structure, and not affect the existing foundation. It will be located at the rear
elevation of the structure not visible from the street.
5.2 Fences and Walls
Fences and walls delineate property boundaries, as well as distingu ish private from
public outdoo r space. In Hampton Park, front yards are traditionally open to th e
street, with a fence enclosing the backyard for privacy.
B. Choose New Fencing that Enhances the Architecture of the Building.
Use traditional materials to b uild new f ences or use appropriate
contemporary materials with a traditional appearance.
Do not exceed fence heights of 4 feet on the front property line and 6 feet on
side and rear yards.
Staff Analysis
The applicant’s proposed fencing design is a
simple 5 ft. tall wooden privacy fence with a
gate running across the side property li ne
between the two structur es, as sh own in red
in the graphic to the right. The proposed
design’s height , material, and location are
consistent with design guidelines.
6
5.7 Outbuildings and Accessory Structures
When designing a new garage or accessory structure it is important to remember its
design and placement affect the overall appearance of the property
A. Place, maintain, and preserve historic outbuildings
B. Construct new outbuildings to compliment the primary building
a. Design new buildings to be subordinate to the primary structure in size,
scale, and location.
b. Locate new outbuildings in inconspicuous locations, set behind the
primary building or in the rear of the lot.
c. Ensure the new buildings are compatible in size, scale, materials, and
roof slope.
d. Limit the visibility of pre -fabricated accessory structures a s much as
possible.
Staff Analysis:
As shown in the plot plan below, the applicant proposes to construct a 960 sq. ft. (30
x 32 ft.) accessory building in the rear portion of the property.
The 960 sq. ft. structure is comprised of a 600 sq . ft. enclos ure with a 360 sq. ft.
open covered porch area. The proposed structure will feature viny l sid ing, vinyl
windows, and a porch overhang supported on square columns.
While 960 sq. ft. may appear to be large for a n accessory structure, the propose size
conforms to ordinance size limitations and will remain subordinate to the 1800 sq.
ft. primary dwelling on the site.
The proposed location at the rear of the property will not be visible from the right of
way, and is partially screen ed from view from adjacent pro perty by exis ting
vegetation along the side and rear property lines, as shown below in the photograph
on the following page.
Floating
Deck
(prop.)
16 x 21’
7
Above: View of rear yard (white posts indicate approximate location of proposed accessory structure)
The applicant has indicated that the color of the
accessory structure will match the c olor of the
primary dwelling, (“Bountiful Blue” (4007-6B), shown
to the rig ht). Because this color is from the appro ved
Valspar color palette, approval by the Sumter Historic
Preservation Design Review Committee is not
required.
Overall, the accessory structure meets design review
guidelines. It is in a compatible, screened area,
features more design detail than typica l accessory
buildings, and is compatible in appe arance with the
primary dwelling.
III. STAFF RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends approval of this request.
The proposed accessory structure meets location and material guidelines and will
still be sub ordinate t o the singl e-family residential dwelling on the parcel. The
proposed fencing design is simple and consistent with the location and appearances
of other f ences within the district . The floating rear deck will no t be visible from
the public right of way. Ad ditionally, the enclosed porch, while differing from the
historical configuration of the home, will not be visible from the rig ht of way and
will match the material of the rest of the home’s siding.
8
IV. DRAFT MOTION
1. I move that the Sumter Historic Preservation Design Review Committee
approve HP-20-06 in accordance with the materials, photographs,
construction details submitted and staff recommendation referenced in the
Staff Report based on compliance with Design Review Guidelines.
2. I move that the Sumter Historic Preservation Design Review Committee
deny HP-20-06.
3. I move that the Sumter Historic Preservation Design Review Committee
enter an alternative motion.
V. HISTORIC PRESERVATION – MARCH 26, 2020
The scheduled March 26, 2020 Historic Preserv ation Design Review Committee
meeting was postponed by order of City Council, in keeping with Centers for
Disease Control (CDC) guidelines related to the COVID-19 virus.
VI. HISTORIC PRESERVATION – JUNE 25, 2020
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.