hp_20-10_234_church_st_city.pdf
City of Sumter · Sumter County · Other
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
This document is no longer listed on City of Sumter's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Historic Preservation Design Review
June 25, 2020
HP-20-10, 234 Church St. (City)
I. THE REQUEST
Applicant: Joan Lease-Clark
Status of the Applicant: Property Owner
Request: Design Review for installation of a new porch railing and
construction of a section of 6 ft. tall chain link fencing
Location: 234 Church St..
Present Use/Zoning: Residential / PO
Tax Map Reference: 228-05-01-043
Adjacent Property Land
Use and Zoning:
North –Doctors Office/ Professional Office (PO)
South – Residential / Professional Office (PO)
East – Residential / Professional Office (PO)
West – Residential / R-6
II. BACKGROUND
234 Church St., shown in the photograph
to the right, is a single -family residential
structure with frontage on Church Street.
The applicant is requesting design
approval for the installation of a new
wooden front porch railing and the
construction of a segment of 6 ft. tall chain
link fencing in the front yard.
Architectural/Historic Context:
Based upon the Sumter County
Assessor’s Record Property Card, the
home was constructed circa 1900 and was
subsequently renovated around 1980. The
2
home has elements of Vernacular Victorian style, and is characterized by its wooden
siding, cross gable roof, pedimented entrance, and molded windows. It is a
contributing structure to the fabric of the Hampton Park Historic district based on
age and architectural detail.
Scope of Work:
The applicant intends to perform the following work on the subject property:
1. Installation of painted wooden porch railings on the front elevation.
2. Construction of 6 ft. tall black coated chain link fence along the front portion
of the southern property line.
Design review approval is required prior to making these proposed alterations.
Design Review:
The Design Review Guidelines Manual states:
4.9 Porches
B. Replace Deteriorated or Missing Porch Elements and Materials In-Kind
Replace deteriorated or missing features with materials compatible with the
original in size and shape, detail and dimension, color and texture.
Replace missing porch railings and balusters with traditional designs with
traditional dimensions
Staff Analysis:
Archival photographic evidence from the
1985 Historical Resources Survey indicates
that the subject property’s front porch was
previously enclosed, and featured a front
metal awning, and wooden railing on its flat
roof to create the appearance of a second
story balcony. These features were not
original to the home and were added during
the 1980 remodel of the structure. At some
point after the Historical resource survey,
the screening, awning, and porch roof
railings were removed , resulting in the
current porch configuration.
Currently, due to the height of the front porch, the lack of railing or enclosure is a
safety concern. The applicant intends to install white wooden porch railing on the
3
front porch in order to safely enclose it. The design of the balusters will match those
found on the second story rear balcony, shown in the photo to the right , and will be
painted white to match the existing balusters.
Historic preservation guidelines for porch balusters and
railings call for traditional designs and materials that
are compatible with the character of the house. As the
proposed element recreates an element already present
in the home, the guidelines support its inclusion.
5.2 Fences and Walls
Fences and walls delineate property boundaries, as well
as distinguish private from public outdoor space. In
Hampton Park, front yards are traditionally open to the
street, with a fence enclosing the backyard for privacy.
B. Choose New Fencing that Enhances the
Architecture of the Building.
Select a fence design that relates to the style
and character of the building.
Use traditional materials to build new fences or use appropriate
contemporary materials with a traditional appearance.
Limit front yard fencing to open designs, such as painted wood picket or
simple wrought iron fencing that will not obscure views of the building from
the street.
Avoid incompatible fencing - such as wood plank, split rail, vinyl, solid
brick, or chain link fences – along prominent, visible property lines.
Use ivy, vines, or other plant materials to cover or screen chain link fences.
Do not exceed fence heights of 4 feet on the front property line and 6 feet on
side and rear yards.
Staff Analysis
The applicant’s proposed fencing design is a 6 ft. tall black chain link fence that will
run along the southern property line from the front plane of the house to the sidewalk,
in the area shown in the photo and aerial graphic on the following page.
The fencing will run parallel to the sections of wooden fencing on the adjacent
property at 232 Church St. and will terminate at the existing 6 ft. tall wooden privacy
fence that encloses the subject property’s rear yard.
Above: Archival photo of the property’s
rear porch railing
4
Above: Image depicting location of proposed fence;
Below: Aerial graphic detailing the proposed chain link fencing location
Fences within the Hampton Park Historic District are traditionally constructed of
wood, stone, or masonry. The proposed black chain link fencing material is not in
keeping with the character of the house, and is designated as incompatible in front
yards by the Historic Preservation Design Review Guidelines . In addition, the
proposed height of the fencing exceeds the four -foot recommended height guideline
for fencing located in the front yard area.
5
In the alternative, a 4 ft. tall black extruded aluminum simulated wrought iron fence,
4 ft. tall wooden picket fence or 4 ft tall white vinyl picket fence would be appropriate
for achieving delineation between the two properties.
III. STAFF RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommendation is as follows:
1) Staff recommends approval of the porch railing.
The proposed front porch rail addition replicates an element found elsewhere
on the dwelling and is in keeping with the style of the dwelling and historic
preservation guidelines,
2) Staff recommends denial of the proposed 6 ft. tall black vinyl dipped chain
link fencing.
The proposed fencing fails to meet location, material and height guidelines for
fencing within the Hampton Park Design Review District. In the alternative,
a 4 ft. tall black extruded aluminum simulated wrought iron fence, 4 ft. tall
wooden picket fence, or 4 ft tall white vinyl picket fence would be appropriate
for achieving delineation between the two properties.
IV. DRAFT MOTION
1) I move that the Sumter Historic Preservation Design Review Committee
approve the proposed Porch Railing portion of HP -20-06, but deny the chain
link fencing portion of the request in accordance with the materials,
photographs, construction details submitted and staff recommendation
referenced in the Staff Report . Additionally, I m ove that the Committee
approves of either a 4 ft. tall black extruded aluminum simulated wrought iron
fence, 4 ft. tall wooden picket fence or 4 ft tall white vinyl picket fence in place
of the proposed 6 ft. tall chain -link fence, based on compliance wit h Design
Review Guidelines
2) I move that the Sumter Historic Preservation Design Review Committee deny
HP-20-05
3) I move that the Sumter Historic Preservation Design Review Committee enter
an alternative motion.
V. HISTORIC PRESERVATION – JUNE 25, 2020
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.