RecordWell Data

hp-20-01_428_w_hampton_ave_city_6-25-20.pdf

City of Sumter · Sumter County · Other

Open the original document More from City of Sumter

This document is no longer listed on City of Sumter's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Historic Preservation Design Review February 27, 2020 HP-20-01, 428 W. Hampton Ave. (City) I. THE REQUEST Applicant: Christopher Green; G & G Mortgage Services Status of the Applicant: Property Owner Request: Request for Historic Preservation Design Review approval for renovations to include partial demolition and reconstruction/repair of the roof, repair or replacement of windows, siding, chimney, balusters and the addition of two rear entrances in order to convert the existing structure into a duplex. Location: 428 W. Hampton Ave. Present Use/Zoning: Residential / R-6 (Residential-6) Tax Map Reference: 228-11-03-038 Adjacent Property Land Use and Zoning: North – W. Hampton Ave. South – Commercial Offices & Single-family / GC East – Single-family & multi-tenant senior housing/ R-6 West – Duplex / R-6 II. BACKGROUND 428 W. Hampton Ave., shown in the photograph to the right, is a residential structure located on the southern edge of the Hampton Park Hi storic District. Prior to acquisition of the property by the current owners, the structure had been subject to a continuous pattern of severe neglect, which has left the structure in an advanced state of disrepair. Historic Context Based upon the Sumte r County Assessor’s Record Property Card, the dwelling was constructed in 1881. The October 1980 Historic Resources Survey Card identifies the structure as a single-story classical revival cottage. The building is a rectangular plan with cross gable roof. There is one exterior end chimney on the left side of the façade. The house has three bays with 4 over 4 double hung windows with louvered shutters flanking the porch. There is a single door entrance with sidelights and a transom with wide gabled portico across the central portion of the façade. The portico is supported by four posts with decorative saw work brackets and valence. The porch has a balustrade, pent roof of wooden shingles above the porch and below the gable. The gable has a pedimented area with two long arched louvered vents. The house has had several additions to the rear, one with board and batten siding with scalloped cornice. Based upon the age of the structure, it is contributing to the overall fabric of the Hampton Park District. The Applicant acquired the property in July 2017 along with the neighboring property at 434 W. Hampton Ave. The applicant has proceeded with cleaning up portions of the property, determining structural stability and completing rehabilitation plans . Based on plans submitted with this app lication, the applicant intends to convert the existing structure at 428 W. Hampton Ave. into a duplex. The current request is for restoration work; renovations to include partial demolition and reconstruction/repair of the roof ; replacement and addition of windows ; rep air of siding and chimney; and repair /replacement of balusters. The following photographs show the exterior of the structure in its current condition. As shown in the preceding photographs, the front of the structure gives the appearance of a modest sized single -story dwelling. As the rear and sides of the structure come into view, it is apparent that over the last 137 years, multiple additions with oddly connecting rooflines have been constru cted. This has c reated areas of pooli ng for water, and in some instances, leaking between the walls due to how the additions were added to the original structure. Scope of Work: The following elevations and floor plan show the proposed repairs and changes to the structure. Front Elevation Rear Elevation West Elevation East Elevation REAR FRONT Floor Plan The multiple additions to the rear of the bu ilding have created a series of rooflines that poorly intersect and have resulted in leaks over t ime. As shown in the elevations and floor plan above, changes to the roofline are proposed to create a single, cohesive roofline allowing interior renovations to create two duplex unit s, with each unit being 1468 sq. ft. with 3 bedrooms, two bathrooms, kitchen area, dining area, living room, and laundry room. Adhoc additions made to the original house overtime will be demolished with this project, as shown below. As submitted, the following exterior changes are proposed: Front Façade – 1) Repair existing paired 4 over 4 windows 2) Repair roof with black architectural shingle. 3) Replace metal roof with similar metal roof. 4) Repair louvered shutters and paint. 5) Pressure w ash brick foundation and repair/repaint where necessary. Add foundation vents—this applies to entire structure. 6) Repair and replace missing baluster pieces on front porch. 7) Build new brick stairs to front porch. 8) Clean, repair and repaint wood siding. Color to be SW 9135 Whirlpool. West Elevation – 1) Repair existing paired 4 over 4 windows 2) In areas of new construction/rehabilitation, a. New windows as shown – 4 over 4 b. Wooden siding profile and color to match front façade. c. New roofline – hipped roof with 6:12 pitch. Black architectural shingles Rear Elevation – 1) New windows as shown – 4 over 4 2) Wooden siding profile and color to match front façade. 3) Two new entry rear doors. One for each dwelling unit. 4) New roofline – hipped roof with 6:12 pitch. Black architectural shingles East Elevation – 1) Repair existing paired 4 over 4 windows 2) Chimney to be cleaned, repaired and repointed. 3) In areas of new construction/rehabilitation, a. New windows as shown in elevation – 4 over 4 b. Wooden siding profile and color to match front façade. c. New roofline – hipped roof with 6:12 pitch. Black architectural shingles. Paint Colors: Pictured on the next page – Venetian Yellow is proposed for all trim work and railings for the dwelling with Whirlpool as the primary paint color for the siding. Design review approval is required prior to undertaking the proposed changes. The Design Review Guidelines Manual states: 3.1. Steps to Consider for a Successful Preservation Project Assess Conditions and Select and Appropriate Treatment Carefully assess the c urrent condition of a building in order to develop an appropriate scope of work and treatment approach. Pay particular attention to the “ch aracter-defining” building components and materials identified as significant to determine the best treatment. The treatment that requires the least amount of intervention is preferred. Where significant historic building compo nents and materials are intac t, retain them. Where deterioration occurs, identify and correct the cause of the condition through sensitive repairs. Where such building components or materials are either missing or deteriorated beyond repair, replace them i n-kind to match the visual qu alities of the historic based on physical evidence, original drawings, or historic photographs. If not such documenta tion or evidence exists, the replacement component or material should be simple in design so not to add a leve l of detailing that cannot be justified. Alterations should respect the historic character of a building and should not attempt to make it looks o lder, newer, or more ornate. If a new feature of an addition is necessary, its design should be compatible wit h the historic character of the building and have a minimal impact on historic features. Staff Analysis The proposed scope of work was developed after removing extensive vegetative overgrowth and debris from the property . The proposed scope does not remove any architectural detailing unique to the structure such as the millwork on the front porch. Additionally, all structurally sound components ar e being r etained and repaired/refinished. Where material s do need to be replaced (i.e. siding) the existing wood siding is to be matched in dimension and style with new wood materials. 3.2 Visibility and Level of Review In addition to the identification of character defining-building components, it is imp ortant to understand the role that visibility plays in determining the application of the design guidelines. As the goal of th e design review process is to preserve the visual qualities that give a district its historic character, the areas of a building t hat are highly visible from the public right-of-way are the most important. The highest level of preser vation with the least amount of change is the best approach for these areas. In the Downtown Historic District, where adjacent buildings for solid “stree t walls,” this highly sensitive area may be limited to the front of the building. In the cases of corne r buildings or freestanding buildings, such as larger institutional buildings or residences, this are may extend to the sides and rear of a building, as well. Areas along the sides and rear of a building, depending on their location and surrounding buildin gs, may not be as highl y visible as the front and are, therefore, secondary in their importance. Thes e less visible, secondary areas allow for greater flexibility in their treatment. The level of sensitivity will also depend on the building’s overall significance, architectural style, and level of detailing. Staff Analysis The most significant and visib le change to the structure will be the roof demolition to the rear of the structure that is required in order to square up the back portion of the building under one cohesive roofing plan. When completed, the rea r roofline will be lower and subservient to the front façade. All other proposed work that is highly visible respects the character of the building and is an in-kind replacement where deterioration has occurred. 4.1. Roofs Roofs are significant charact er-defining features for most buildings. The refore, the preservation of their original forms, materials, and elements is important. In Hampton Park, most roofs are gable, hipped, or a composite of bo th forms. These residential roods can feature chimneys, d ormers and decorative elements, including fi nials and cresting. Original roofing materi als found in the neighborhood, such as standing -seam metal, slate and tile, also impart historic character. B. Preserve Original Roof Materials. ➢ Retain original roof mat erials, such as standing -seam metal, slate, or clay tile whenever possible. ➢ Repair deteriorated sections of roofs with in-kind materials to match the original. Staff Analysis The metal roof on the structure has failed, extensive changes to the rear of the building to alter the roofline will result in removal of the metal roof in place. C. Retain Original Roof Elements and Ornamentation. ➢ Preserve chimneys, dormers, exposed rafter tails, finals, and cresting. ➢ Repair brick chimneys with brick and mortar to match the original. ➢ Do not remove chimneys above the roofline, especially those on prominent elevations. Staff Analysis The only visible chimney on the structure is to be retained and preserved/repaired. D. Replace Original Roof Materials with Compatible New Materials. ➢ Replace historic r oofing mater ials only when damaged or deteriorated beyond reasonable repair. ➢ Replace original roof materials in-kind with traditional materials whenever feasible. ➢ Use substitute materials that convey the same visual appearance of the original roof when replacement with the traditional material is not feasible. ➢ Use substitute materials that r esemble the original in size, shape, color, texture, pattern, and where possible, material composition. ➢ Replacement of asphalt, asbestos, or composition shingle roofs wi th new aspha lt or fiberglass shingles is appropriate. Use dark colored shingles, such a s black, brown, dark green or dark red rather than lighter shades. ➢ Avoid materials that do not convey the same visual qualities as the original roof. ➢ Reinstall roof ornamentation such as finials, cresting, and ridge caps. Staff Analysis The proposed replacement roof is to be black architectural shingles. The existing roof is a Terne tin roof that h as failed. Due to the extensive changes to the rear of the structure and cost of meta l roofing materials that give the appearance of the historic tin roof, the applicants have requested to use architectural shingle for a bulk of the structure. As proposed, pent roof above the porch and below the gable is proposed to be replaced with a meta l roof. It s hould be required that this replacement metal roof be a silver/gray standing seam metal roof. This type of roof was approved for this structure in 2018 and is reminiscent of the original Terne tin. 4.2. Foundations Foundations are structural elements above or below grade that support a building. Masonry buildings often show no delineation between the foundation and wall plane, whi le brick foundations tend to contrast with the wall surface or frame construction. Most residences in Hampton Park stand on raised brick foundations that are either continuous walls or piers. A. Maintain the Visual and Structural Qualities of Historic Foundations. ➢ Repair and replace deteriorated foundation materials matching the original materials as closely as possible. Staff Analysis The proposed plan is to clean and repoint the existing brick foundation and to install foundation vents to properly vent the crawlspace of the structure. 4.4 Exterior Walls: Siding Many houses in Hampton Park are clad in wo od siding. Horizontal lap siding, such as weatherboard or clapboard, is most common. Most exterior walls are sided from the frieze board just beneath the rood to the sill board at the foundation. Wood shingles are also found in the residential historic dis trict, most commonly on Queen Anne and Craftsman style houses. These shingles are generally of square, elliptical, hexagonal or saw tooth designs. This exterior cladding usually a dorns gables, dormers, or the second story of a house. Houses also feature ot her wood elements, including frieze boards, sill boards, corner boards, window and door trim, soffits, eaves, and decorative moldings. C. Preserve and Maintain Original Wood Siding and Other Wood Features. ➢ Retain original wood siding and other wood features , such as d ecorative shingles, cornices and frieze boards, soffits, eaves, trim and moldings. ➢ Protect wood elements from water damage by repairing leaking roofs, gutters, downspouts and flashing. ➢ Keep wood surfaces painted and primed. D. Repair Original Wood Siding and Wood Features, Where Feasible. ➢ Restore deteriorated or missing sections rather than replacing or covering the entire feature. ➢ Consider an epoxy consolidate to patch missing or deteriorated elements. ➢ Splice new materials of the same material, d esign, color, texture, and other visual qualities of the original material, while retaining as much of the original material as possible. E. Replace Original Wood Siding and Wood Features In-Kind. ➢ Replace original wood siding and wood features only if beyond reasonable repair. ➢ Match the original material in design, color, texture, and other visual qualities and, where possible, material. F. Preserve the Visibility of Exterior Wood Siding and Wood Features. ➢ Consider removing non -historic materials that conceal original w ood siding and features and repair the underlying materials. ➢ Do not cover wood siding with aluminum, steel, vinyl, brick and stone veneers, and other artificial materials. ➢ Do not cover soffits, eaves and porch ceilings with aluminum, steel, or vinyl siding. Staff Analysis All proposed restoration/addition work to the exterior of the building complies with the above referenced guidelines. 4.6 Windows Windows, and the architectural details surrounding windows, reflect the architectural style and date of a building and are important aspects of architectural character. Basic window functions include allowing light into the interior, providing fresh air and ventilation, s erving as a visual link to outside, and enhancing the appearance of a building. The loca tion, size, and style of windows can also suggest the interior plan or function of spaces. Historic wood windows can last for over one hundred years with periodic maint enance to prevent deterioration and maintain thermal efficiency. The addition of a storm window can provide thermal efficiency equal to a replacement window with insulated glass. A. Preserve and Repair Historic Windows. ➢ Preserve original window locations, s izes, a nd types and restore altered window openings to their historic configurations. B. Replace Historic Windows with Compatible New Windows. ➢ Match the original windows in design, dimension, muntin profile, pane configuration, finish and where possible, ma terial. If all the original windows are missing, replacement windows should reflect a de sign appropriate for the building form and architectural style. ➢ Avoid reducing or increasing the size of a historic opening to accommodate a smaller or larger window. Where necessary, limit this treatment to the rear or side elevations where not visible from the street. ➢ Use clear glass on the primary elevation and secondary elevations visible from the street. Tinted glass may only be installed on rear or secondary elevat ions not visible from the street. C. Maintain the Pattern and Rhythm of Original Window Openings. ➢ Select an inconspicuous location for new window openings, such as the rear or side elevations not visible from the street. ➢ Add new window openings in a manner that minimizes impact on historic features and subtly distinguishes them from historic windows. ➢ Match the general size and alignment of original window openings when adding a new window opening. ➢ Do not enclose or obscure original window openings with added materials. Staff Analysis The 4 over 4 windows on the oldest portion of the dwelling are to remain and be repaired. All other window openings are proposed to be 4 over 4 windows and similar to the historic windows . Consideration should be given to installing a different widow profile to differentiate them from the original structure. The only openings that are to be altered are located on the side and rear façade and not visible from the public way. 4.8 Doors Doors provide attractive, welcoming entrances to interior spac es. Like windows, they reflect the architectural style of a building and are important elements of architectural character. Residential doors are characterized by wood panels and in some cases, glass panes. The arrangement of panels and panes will differ d epending on the style of the door. Main entrances tent to feature dec orative elements, such as sidelights, tr ansoms, fanlights, and milled surrounds. A. Preserve and Repair Historic Doors that Contribute to the Character of a Building. ➢ Retain and repair his toric doors, including decorative features such as trim, sidelights, transoms, fanligh ts, and surrounds. Wher e possible, retain original hardware. ➢ Preserve original door locations, sizes, and types and restore altered door openings to their historic configurations. ➢ Avoid painting previously unpainted doors unless extremely weathered. C. Add N ew Door Openings in a M anner that Minimizes Impact on Historic Features and Subtly Distinguishes them from Historic Doors. ➢ Select an inconspicuous location for new door openings, such as the rear or side elevations not visible from the street. ➢ Modern wood, fiberglass, or steel doors may be appropriate on rear or side elevations that are not visible from the street. Staff Analysis The existing front door is to be retained, repaired and repainted. All new proposed doors are on the side and rear façade and are placed in such a manner as not to b e visible from the street. 4.9 Porches Porches are often the focal points of historic homes, especially when positioned on primary elevations. They provide an area for people to gather and socialize , as well as serving as an important transition space be tween the interior and exterior of a residence. Porches can define the overall character and style of a building, with their distinctive columns, r ailings, steps, and decorative detailing. In Hampton Park, almost all houses have some type of porch on the p rimary or street elevation. Side and rear porches are less common, but examples do exist in the district. Some porches extend across the entire wid th of the façade while others only shelter the entran ce. Most are one story in height, with two -story porches being rare. While the overall plan and form of porches are similar, their detailing and ornamentation varies depending on the architectural style of the house. A. Retain and Repair Original Porch Elements and Materials. ➢ Preserve and maintain original porch elements including floors, beadboard ceiling, columns and supports, pilasters, railings, steps, lattice, and decorative trim. Staff Analysis All proposed porch restoration work complies with this guideline. 4.11 Paint The right combination of paint colors can accentu ate important architectural features and unify the façade. In addition to its aesthetic benefits, paint also provides protection to certain buildin g su rfaces, particularly wood. Due to these protective qualities, building components that were historically painted should remain painted. Alternatively, surfaces that were not historically painted, such as brick and stone, should remain unpainted to retain their historic texture and appeara nce. Appropriate paint schemes differ depending on the architectural style and era of a building. Historically appropriate color schemes for a particular style can be determined based on paint analysis or research. B. Select a Compatible Color Scheme. ➢ Choose colors that are appropriate to the architectural style and compliment the building and its surroundings. Overly bright and obtrusive colors are not appropriate. C. Use Paint Color to Accentuate Exterior Details. ➢ Use muted or dark colors for the walls of a building ➢ Use lighter colors to highlight trim and architectural ornamentation. ➢ Paint window sash and frames contrasting colors than the walls to provide contrast and depth to window openings. ➢ Limit the paint scheme to three or four colors: one roof color , one wall color, one trim color, and one accent color. D. Remove Deteriorated Paint Using the Gentlest Means Possible. ➢ Do not use abrasive methods, such as sandblasting, high pressure water, or butane torches to remove paint from masonry, wood, or metal. Staff Analysis The proposed color scheme respects the above outlined criteria. All surfaces proposed to be painted historically have been painted on this structure. 5.3 Driveways, Walkways, and Ramps A. Maintain Traditional Driveway Configurations ➢ Retain and repair historic driveways and their materials. ➢ Locate new driveways to the side or rear of a building. ➢ Maintain narrow driveway widths to reduce their visual impact. ➢ Use paving materials that complement the architectural style of the house. Staff Analysis The applicant has an existing curb cut to the east of the structure that can be utilized for a driveway. Either this curb cut or a shared driveway with the property located at 434 W. Hampton Ave. (under same ownership) will be used. Parking is anticipated to be located at the back on the renovated structure, where separate entrances to each unit are located. Historic driveway surface materials, per available aerial photography, appear to be dirt or gravel. ADDITIONS While older homes are admired for their character and charm, potential buyers often opt for new construction with the modern amenities they have come to expect. A sensitive addition to a historic home can often provide needed extra space and modern amen ities. However, insensitively design additions can radically alter the historic appearance of the building and destroy important features. Careful design and location of new additions can complement rather than detract from the character of a historic building and the district as a whole. P. Distinguish a New Addition from the Historic Building with a Simple and Unobtrusive Design. ➢ Design an addition to be subordinate to the existing building in size, design, and detailing. ➢ Locate a new addition on the rear elevation where not highly visible f rom the public right-of-way. Side additions subordinate to the original house may be appropriate in some situat ions, depending on the lot configuration and architectural style of the house. ➢ Keep the addition height lower and the width narrower than that of the original house. Set back side additions at least two feet from the front place of the house. ➢ Ensure the design is distinct from the original house but still compatible. Avoid exact replication of the original house. ➢ Include simplified architectural fe atures derived from similar features on the historic building. ➢ Chose a roof form that complements that of the o riginal building. Keep the roof pitch similar to the original building, but proportional to the size of the addition. ➢ Base the size, rhythm, and alignment of the window and door openings on those of the historic building. ➢ Ensure that colors and materials a re harmonious with the materials of the historic building. Q. Avoid Obscuring or Destroying Important Features or Materials of the Existing Building with Constructing an Addition. R. Design and Construct an Addition so if Removed in the Future the Basic form and Character of the Original building remain intact. Staff Analysis Redesign of the rear portions of the b uilding effectively makes the propos ed project more of an addition to the structure as opposed to an interior renovation. The work will have a smaller footprint th an the additions onto the original struct ure. The original footprint of the house is being retained. III. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends approval for the request , with consideration that the Historic Preservation Commission requires the following: • New windows on all facades of the addition should be 6 over 6 double hung windows or similar to differentiate from the historic portion of the house being retained. • Replacement metal roof on front porch shall be silver/gray standing seam metal roofing material reminiscent of the original Terne tin. • Off-street parking for the units must be in the rea r, with driveway that utilizes historic district compatible driveway materials. IV. DRAFT MOTION 1.) I move that the Sumter H istoric Preservation Design Review Committee approve HP-20-01 in accordance with the submitted materials, photographs, construction details referenced in t his Staff Report , s taff’s recommendation, and based on findings of compliance with the Design Review Guidelines. 2.) I move that the Sumter Historic Preservation Design Review Committee deny HP- 20-01. 3.) I move that the Sumter Historic Preservation Design Review Committee enter an alternative motion. V. HISTORIC PRESERVATION – FEBRUARY 27, 2020 The Sumter Historic Preservation Design Review Committee at its meeting on T hursday, February 27, 2020 app roved the partial demolition and re construction/repair of the roof, repair or replacement of windows, siding, chimney, balusters and the addition of two rear entrances in order to convert the existing st ructure in to a duplex. The Design Review Committee deferred color palette approval pending physical samples. VI. HISTORIC PRESERVATION – MARCH 26, 2020 The scheduled March 26, 2020 Historic Preservation Design Review Committee meeting has been postponed until further notice by order of C ity Council, in keeping with Centers of Disease Control (CDC) guidelines related to the COVID-19 virus. VII. HISTORIC PRESERVATION – JUNE 25, 2020

Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.