hp_20-20_1_w_liberty_st.pdf
City of Sumter · Sumter County · Other
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
This document is no longer listed on City of Sumter's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
City of Sumter Design Review Board
October 22, 2020
HP-20-20, 1 W. Liberty St.
I. THE REQUEST
Applicant: Jay Davis
Status of the Applicant: Authorized Agent for Property Owner
Request: Design Review approval for interior and exterior
renovations for existing building for use as a
retail space.
District Downtown Design District
Location: 1 W. Liberty St.
Present Use/Zoning: Residential / CBD
Tax Map Reference: 228-12-04-072
Adjacent Property Land Use
and Zoning:
North – Hyatt Place Hotel / CBD
South – Sumter Original Brewery / CBD
East – Coldwell Banker Commercial / CBD
West – Vacant Lot / CBD
II. BACKGROUND
1 W. Libert y St. , shown in the
photograph to the right, consists of a
commercial structure. This store front is
located on north side of Lib erty St.
directly to the west of Coldwell Bank er
Commercial Cornerstone. 1 W. Liberty
St.is a two -story building th at has
remained vacant/under- utilized for an
extended period of time.
The applicant is proposin g extensive
work to renovate the structure at 1 W .
Liberty St. At completion the building
will house retail space.
2
ARCHITECTURAL/HISTORIC CONTEXT:
The property is identified as site #111 in the 1985 Historic Resources Survey that
catalogued the structures in the downtown. Bas ed upon Sanborn Maps, there has
been some sort of structure(s) on the property since at least 1894. At the time of the
survey, the building gave the appearance of two (2) structures , but may have been
one (1) structure built for two tenants.
1 W. Liberty St. has a glass and a luminum storefront on the first leve l that is not
original to the building. It has three window openings on the second story . There is
also a fir st floor access door to a stairwell leading to the second floor of the building
from the Liberty St. frontage. The building has a pressed metal par apet and
decorative window surrounds. The two vertical halves of the building are divided by
quoined pilasters on the second level. The exterior wall material is masonry, however;
the façade wall for 1 W. Liberty St. ha s parging covering the brickwork to j ust below
the second story windows. The original brick work on the f ront façade has been
previously painted.
As per the 1985 s urvey, 1 W. Liberty St. is historically significant because of its age
and architecturally s ignificant because of the quality of the design. The building
merits restoration and should be considered on e of the contributing properties in the
Historic Distric t. The following photographs show the pre -renovation exterior
conditions.
SITE PHOTOS:
Front Façade (pre-renovation) Front Façade (after partial renovation)
3
Rear elevation (pre-renovation) Rear elevation (after partial renovation)
SCOPE OF WORK:
The proposed project include s restoration of and additions to 1 W . Liberty St . The
following renderings, elevations and plan s show the proposed changes and new
construction.
4
5
The proposed exterior paint colors are shown below . The proposed paint colors are
Repose Grey (SW 7 015) for the existing fr ont brick wall and Polished Concrete ( SW
9167) for the existing cornice and window trim.
DESIGN REVIEW:
Design review approval is required prior to the proposed work. The Design Review
Guidelines Manual states:
4.3 Exterior Walls: Masonry
Exterior masonry walls exist in both the commercial and residential historic districts.
Masonry materials include brick , stone, concrete, stucco , and terracotta. Brick is the
most common masonry material used in Sumter and is used primarily for exterior
walls, foundations, and chimneys. Some exterior masonry walls are solid brick, while
others are prick veneer, consisting of a single brick course over a wood frame
6
structural system. In both cases, the brick exterior wall surface, and their associated
bond patter ns and textures, define the appearance and character of the building.
Masonry elements can also be used to create decorative details and textures, such as
corbelled brick patterns and inlays of belt courses.
The color and texture of masonry is an importan t defining feature, as is the mortar
that bonds the masonry units. Mortar for most historic buildings is composed of a
mixture of line and sand, which allows fo r expansion and contraction of the mortar
joints in hot and cold weather. In most cases, the use of modern Portland cement is not
appropriate for historic buildings, as it is stronger than traditional historic mortars
and does not allow for joint expansion or contraction. It is common for houses and
commercial buildings in the historic districts to feature flush or concave mortar joints.
A. Preserve Original Masonry and its Visual Qualities.
Retain masonry features that are important in defining the overall character of
the building.
Do not remove or obscure masonry elements.
Do not paint unpainted masonry. Exceptions to this include masonry walls that
have a patchwork appearance from extensive replacement or rebuilding.
B. Maintain Historic Masonry Materials.
C. Repair and Replace Historic Masonry with In-Kind Materials.
Repair or replace a masonry featu re using masonry units that respect the size,
texture, color, and patterns of this historic material, as well as the mortar join
size and tooling.
Repair and repoint only areas where mortar has deteriorated, leaving sound
mortar intact.
Repair cracks and u nsound mortar with new mortar that match ed the original
in composition and appearance, including color.
Rake new mortar joints to match the originals.
Staff Analysis:
Existing masonry is being retained on the front facades and rear facades, to include
the pilasters. Due to the condition of the existing brickwork on the front façade, the
surface will be painted to compliment the metal materials being used on t he building.
All brick work is to be repointed to ensure structural cohesiveness.
4.5 Architectural Detail and Ornamentation
Architectural ornamentation helps to convey that historic significance and style of
moth commercial and residential properties. Commercial buildings often feature
7
elaborate cornices at their rooflines of metal, wood, or corbelled brick. These decorative
elements are essential to the architectural character of a building.
A. Preserve and Maintain Architectural Ornamentation.
Retain architectural ornamentation, including but not limited to corniced, eave
brackets, spindles, bargebo ard, frieze boards, knee braces, and exposed rafter
tails.
Do not remove or obscure architectural ornamentation.
B. Replace Ornamentation with Designs and Materials to Match the Original.
Replace architectural ornamentation only when damaged or deteriorated
beyond reasonable repair.
Match the profile, dimensions and materials of the original feature as closely as
possible.
C. Restore Missing Ornamentation Based on Photographic or Physical Evidence.
Do not apply ornamentation that has no historical basis, as i t would create and
appearance not in accordance with the building’s original design or style.
Consider a simple cornice of wood or metal on commercia l buildings that have
lost their cornice. Materials such as fiberglass reinforced concrete may also be
appropriate.
Staff Analysis:
All existing ornamentation is being repaired , restored and retained as part of this
project.
4.6 Windows
Windows, and the architectural details surrounding windows, reflect the architectural
style and date of a building and are i mportant aspects of architectural cha racter.
Basic window functions include allowing light into the interior, providing fresh air
and ventilation, serving as a visual link to outside, and enhancing the appearance of a
building. The location, size, and st yle of windows can also suggest the interior plan or
function of spaces. Historic wood windows can last for over one hundred years with
periodic maintenance to prevent deterioration and maintain thermal efficiency. The
addition of a storm window can provid e thermal efficiency equal to a replacement
window with insulated glass.
A. Preserve and Repair Historic Windows.
8
Retain historic windows that contribute to the historic character of a building,
including functional and decorative features, such as frames, sa sh, muntins,
mullions, decorative glass, sills, trim, surrounds, and shutters.
Repair original windows by patch ing, splicing, consolidatin g, weather
stripping, caulking, and replacing missing glass.
Replace only those features that are beyond repair rath er than replacing the
entire window uni t. For example, sash replacement may be a less costly
alternative to a full window replacement. Match the original feature in design,
dimension, and material.
Improve the thermal efficiency by securely locking windows, adding weather
stripping, and installing interior or exterior storm windows.
Preserve original window locations, sizes, and types and restore altered window
openings to their historic configurations.
B. Replace Historic Windows with Compatible New Windows.
Replace historic windows only when damaged or deteriorated beyond
reasonable repair or missing.
Match the original windows in design, dime nsion, muntin profile, pane
configuration, finish and, where possible, material. If all of the original
windows are missing, replacement windows should reflect a design appropriate
for the building form and architectural style.
Avoid the use of false muntins, either internal or applied exterior grilles, which
do not resemble the profile and depth of historic muntins.
Avoid reducing or increasing the size of a historic opening to accommodate a
smaller or larger window. Where necessary, limit this treatment to the rear or
side elevations not visible from the street.
Avoid elaborate stained glass or other decorative glass o n the primary or visible
secondary elev ations unless there is evidence that these features existed
historically.
C. Maintain the Pattern and Rhythm of Original Window Openings.
Select an inconspicuous location for new window openings, such as the rear or
side elevations not visible from the street.
Add new window openings in a manner that minimizes impact on historic
features and subtly distinguishes them from historic windows.
Match the general size and alignment of original window openings when
adding a new window opening.
Do not enclose or obscure original window openings with added materials.
Staff Analysis:
The window openings on the second floor on the front facade will have 2 over 2 double
hung windows to match the windows on the rear of 1 W. Liberty S t. that have
survived. Two (2) window openings on the rear are proposed for enclosure . One of
9
these windows is to be convert ed to a door, and the other is inconsistent with the
rhythm of th e other windows of the building in terms of size and location. The
window opening to be removed will be en closed using matching brick . Th e three (3)
front façade windows will also hold permanent flowerboxes affixed to the wall.
4.10 Storefronts
The storefront is the most visible and noticeable part of a commercial b uilding. An
original storefront reflects the architectural character and period of a building’s
construction. Storefronts are differentiated from the upper façade by larg e display
windows that flank the main entr ance. The large expanse of glass allows for th e
display of goods and merchandise. The display windows rest on low bulkheads
typically constructed of masonry or wood. Storefronts with recessed entrances often
incorporate decorative floor tiles leading from the sidewalk. Historic storefronts are
character-defining features of a building’s façade and should be preserved.
Commercial storefronts are often altered and remodeled to reflect current retail trends
or the needs of new tenants. Sometimes, these changes have intrinsic architectural and
historic value and should be retained, as they have become part of the history of the
building. If the entire storefront has been insensitively altered or replaced with a
modern storefront, consideration should be given to a new, compatible storefront.
When designi ng a new storefront, historic photographs or physical evidence can
provide clues for an appropriate reconstruction. If no evidence of the original storefront
exists, the new design should incorporate traditional storefront elements that reflect
the scale, pr oportions, materials, and colors of other commercial buildings in the
district. A new storefront should not imitate another building or give a false historical
appearance.
D. Consider a Simplified or Contemporary Interpretation of a Traditional Storefront
where the Historic Storefront is Missing or no Evidence of it Exists.
Base the new design on traditional storefront elements that reflect the scale,
proportions, materials, and colors of other commercial buildings in the district.
Use compatible materials that are in keeping with the style of the building.
Avoid creating a false historical appearance by introducing architectural
elements where they never previously existed.
Staff Analysis:
The original storefront design no longer exists, and the photo record doesn’t show the
original storefronts. The new storefront is of a simple cont emporary design that
respects the scale and design of the historic district.
10
4.11 Paint
The right combination of paint colors can accentuate important architectural feature s
and unify the façade. In addition to its aesthetic benefits, paint also provides
protection to certain building surfaces, particularly wood. Due to these protective
qualities, building components that were historically painted should remain painted.
Alternatively, surfaces that were not historically painted, such as brick and stone,
should remain unpainted to retain their historic texture and appearance. Appropriate
paint schemes differ depending on the architectural style and era of a building.
Historically appropriate color schemes for a particular style can be determined based
on paint analysis or research.
A. Maintain and Repair Historically Painted Surfaces.
Remove paint from masonry only when the paint is not historic, will not reveal
aesthetic issues, and will not damage the masonry.
Do not paint unpainted masonry walls unless insensitive past repairs have
negatively affected the visual qualities of the masonry.
Do not strip paint or other coatings to reveal bare wood or apply stain if the
material did not historically have a natural finish.
B. Select a Compatible Color Scheme.
Choose colors that are appropriate to the architectural style and compliment the
building and its surroundings. Overly bright and obtrusive c olors are not
appropriate.
Consider an original color scheme based on paint analysis or research.
C. Use Paint Color to Accentuate Exterior Details.
Use muted or dark colors for the walls of a building
Use lighter colors to highlight trim and architectural ornamentation.
Paint window sash and f rames contrasting colors than the walls to provide
contrast and depth to window openings.
Limit the paint scheme to three or four colors: one roof color, one wall color, one
trim color, and one accent color.
D. Remove Deteriorated Paint Using the Gentlest Means Possible.
Do not use abrasive methods, such as sandblasting, high pressure water, or
butane torches to remove paint from masonry, wood, or metal.
Staff Analysis:
The proposed paint colors are Repose Grey (SW 7 015) for the existing front brick wall
and Polished Concrete (SW 9167) for the existing cornice and window trim.
11
III. STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends approval of this request.
All proposed changes are consistent with the City of Sumter Historic Preservation
Design Rev iew guidelines and are compatible with the existing b uilding design
without attempting to convey a false historic character.
IV. DRAFT MOTION
1) I move that the City of Sumter Design R eview Board approve HP-20-20 in
accordance wi th the materials, photographs, a nd construct ion details
submitted and referenced in the Staff Report based o n compliance with Design
Review Guidelines.
2) I move that the City of Sumter Design Review Board deny HP-20-20
3) I move that the City of Sumter Design Review Board enter an alternative
motion.
V. DESIGN REVIEW BOARD – OCTOBER 22, 2020
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.