hp_20-26-27_park.pdf
City of Sumter · Sumter County · Other
Open the original document More from City of Sumter
This document is no longer listed on City of Sumter's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
City of Sumter Historic Preservation
Design Review
November 19, 2020
HP-20-26, 27 Park Ave.
I. THE REQUEST
Applicant: Stephen Barwick
Status of the Applicant: Property Owner
Request: Design Review approval for replacement of
existing front gutter and installation of new side
gutters, paint front door, and replacement of
existing steps with a new deck and steps on the
south side of the residence
District Hampton Park Historic District
Location: 27 Park Ave.
Present Use/Zoning: Single-Family Residential / R-9
Tax Map Reference: 228-11-02-003
Adjacent Property Land Use
and Zoning:
North – Single-Family Residential / R-9
South – City Park / R-9
East – Single-Family Residential / R-9
West – Single-Family Residential / R-9
II. BACKGROUND
27 Park Ave. , sh own in the
photograph to the right, is a two -story
home in the Dutch Colonial Revival
style. Dutch Colonial Revival is a
style of domestic architecture,
primarily characterized by gambrel
roofs having curved eaves along the
length of the house.
This property is located on Par k Ave.,
immediately adjacent to the City of
Sumter’s Memorial Park.
2
The applicant is proposin g to install new white gutters on the sides of the house and
replace the existing front porch gutter, paint the front door, and install a so uth-facing
deck and exterior stair re-alignment on that side of the house , which faces Memorial
Park.
Installation of the south -facing deck and exterior stair re -alignment is subject to
approval of a variance by the Sumter City-County Board of Zoning Appe als (BZA) to
the City of Sumter Zoning and Development Standards, Article 4.f.7 – Structures
Projecting into Required Yards. The variance request has been filed ( BOA 20-23) and
will be considered by the BZA in December 2020.
ARCHITECTURAL/HISTORIC CONTEXT:
According to the Sumter County Assessor’s Office, the house was constructed in 1939,
and is in the Dutch Coloni al Revival style of architecture, primarily characterized by
gambrel roofs having curved eaves along the length of the house. It is the only
residential structure in the Hampton Park Historic District in this style. T he
property was not evaluated during the 1985 Historic Resources Survey because at the
time of the Survey, the str ucture did not meet the age requirement (50 years) for a
structure to be considered a contributing structure to the historic district.
Based on the current age of the structure , location within the district, and unique
architectural features , 27 Park Ave. should be c onsidered on e of the contributing
properties in the Hi storic District. The following photographs show the current
exterior conditions.
SITE PHOTOS:
Front Façade (pre-renovation) South face of building (site of proposed deck
and stair reorientation)
3
South-facing East Exterior Steps South-facing West Exterior Steps
North-facing Exterior (proposed for
gutter installation)
South-facing Exterior (proposed for gutter
installation)
4
Front Door (proposed for painting) Front Porch Gutter (proposed for
replacement)
SCOPE OF WORK:
The proposed project includes renovations to the exterior of 27 Park Ave., as follows:
1. Paint front door.
2. Install new white gutters on sides of house and replace existing front porch
gutter to match new side gutters.
3. Install a new 5 x 12 ft deck and re -orient stai rs on south side of house , with
balusters and railings to match front porch.
4. Paint steps and deck on south side of house to match front porch.
The following descriptions and illustrations show the proposed changes and new
construction.
5
Existing Exterior Steps
Proposed 5 x 12 ft Side Deck
The proposed paint color for the front door is s hown below. The proposed door paint
color is Wild Daisy (#3007-4A), which is included in the Sumter Historic Preservation
Color Palette. The applicant proposes to ma tch the white paint color of the existing
front porch railing for the proposed steps and deck on the south side of the house.
Replace existing
steps with new
deck and st eps
and paint to
match front
porch.
Paint existing
steps to match
porch.
6
DESIGN REVIEW:
Design review approval is required prior to the proposed work. The Design Review
Guidelines Manual states:
4.5 Architectural Detail and Ornamentation
A. Preserve and Maintain Architectural Ornamentation.
Retain architectural ornamentation, including but not limited to corniced, eave
brackets, spindles, bargebo ard, frieze boards, knee braces, and e xposed rafter
tails.
Do not remove or obscure architectural ornamentation.
Staff Analysis:
The applicant proposes to replace the front porch PVC gutters and to install new
white gutters on ea ch side of the house. The existing gutter is not original to the
house, and the installation of these new gutters will not obscure or negatively impact
the existing architectural detail of the house . All gutters will be matching material
and color.
4.11 Paint
B. Select a Compatible Color Scheme.
Choose colors that are appropriate to the architectural style and compliment the
building and its surroundings. Overl y brig ht a nd ob trusive colors are not
appropriate.
Consider an original color scheme based on paint analysis or research.
C. Use Paint Color to Accentuate Exterior Details.
Use lighter colors to highlight trim and architectural ornamentation.
Limit the paint scheme to three or four colors: one roof color, one wall co lor, one
trim color, and one accent color.
Staff Analysis:
The proposed paint color for the door is Wild Daisy (#3007-4A) and is one of the colors
included in the Sumter Historic Preservation Color Palette. This color is compatible
7
with the Design Guidelines. The balusters and railings for the deck and stair rail on
the south-facing side of the house will be paint ed white to match the existing front
porch style. No other paint is proposed for this project.
6.2 Residential Additions
P. Distinguish a New Addition f rom the H istoric Building with a Simple and
Unobtrusive Design.
Design an addition to be subordinate to t he existing building in size, design,
and detailing.
Locate a new addition on t he rear el evation where not highly visible from the
public right -of-way. S ide additions subo rdinate to the original house may be
appropriate in some situation s, depen ding on the lot configuration and
architectural style of the house.
Keep the addition height lower and the width narrower than that of the original
house. Set back side additions at least two feet from the front plane of the house.
Ensure the design is distinct from the original house but still compatible. Avoid
exact duplication of the original house
Include simplified architectural features derived from similar features on the
historic building.
Ensure that colors and materials are harmonious with the materials of t he
historic building.
Q. Avoid Obscuring or Destroying Important Features or Materials of the Existing
Building When Constructing an Addition.
R. Design and Construct an Addition so if Removed in the Future the Basic Form and
Character of the Original Building Remain Intact.
Staff Analysis:
The deck addition and reorientation of exterior access stairs on the south -facing side
of the house are consistent with the Design Review Guidelines and will have a square
baluster railing type to match the existing front porch.
III. STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends approval of this request.
All proposed changes are consistent with the City of Sumter Historic Preservation
Design Review guidelines and are compatible with the existing building design.
IV. DRAFT MOTION
1) I move that the City of Sumter Design R eview Board approve HP-20-26 in
accordance wi th the materials, ph otographs, and construct ion details
8
submitted and referenced in the Staff Report based on compliance with Design
Review Guidelines.
2) I move that the City of Sumter Design Review Board deny HP-20-26
3) I move that the City of Sumter Design Review Board enter an alternative
motion.
V. DESIGN REVIEW BOARD – NOVEMBER 19, 2020
Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.