RecordWell Data

Minutes

Town of Awendaw · Charleston County · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Awendaw

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Town of Awendaw | August 31st, 2026, Planning Commission and Town Council Joint Workshop Meeting Minutes | Page 1 Town Council & Planning Commission Joint Workshop APPROVED Minutes August 31, 2026 | 6:00 PM | Town Hall, Awendaw, South Carolina 1 . Call to Order Mayor Chris Crolley called the Joint Workshop of the Town Council and Planning Commission to order at 6:00 PM on Monday, August 31, 2026. 2. Roll Call Present (Town Council): Mayor Chris Crolley; Councilman Paul Brown; Councilwoman Wendy Helms; Councilman John Timmons; Councilman Kent Prause; Councilwoman Grace Gasper (arrived at 6:02pm) Absent (Town Council): Councilman Rodney Porcher Present (Planning Commission): Chairman John Osguthorpe; Vice-Chairman Kelly Cousino; Commissioner James Gardner; Commissioner Jeff Hardee; Commissioner Jay Reigart (arrived at 6:02pm) Staff Present: Town Administrator Katharine Watkins; Town Clerk Takeya White; Planning Manager Daniel O'Hara; Town Attorney Mac McQuillin 3. I nvocation The invocation was led by Mayor Chris Crolley. 4. P ledge of Allegiance T he Pledge of Allegiance was recited by all. 5. C ivility Pledge The Civility Pledge was read by Councilman Paul Brown. 6. A pproval of the Joint Workshop Agenda Motion: To approve the August Agenda. 1st: Chairman Osguthorpe 2nd: Commissioner Cousino APPROVED Town of Awendaw | August 31st, 2026, Planning Commission and Town Council Joint Workshop Meeting Minutes | Page 2 Discussion: None. Vote: Approved unanimously (Aye). 7. D iscussion, Consideration and Recommendation of Planning Commission Strategies, Goals and Priorities [Time Stamp: 04:10/2:52:39] Planning Commission Chair John Osguthorpe provided an overview of the Planning Commission's priorities, tracing them back to a January 2025 joint session facilitated by former interim administrator Rebecca Vance. At that time, both the Planning Commission and Town Council aligned on a shared set of priorities, which have since guided the Commission's work. Completed items included vesting, open space and tree preservation, surfaces, wetlands, stormwater management, and lighting. Outstanding items identified at that time—commercial building size, infrastructure requirements, and heritage property—have not yet been addressed. Chairman Osguthorpe noted that the Commission had been operating with limited administrative support and without an active, updated town zoning plan, which he described as a significant obstacle to effective planning. Comprehensive Plan and Zoning Crosswalk Chairman Osguthorpe presented a crosswalk document comparing the Town's existing 2004- era zoning code with the newly adopted Comprehensive Plan (formally adopted in 2025). He emphasized that state law requires all zoning decisions to align with the officially adopted Comprehensive Plan, and that the Town's current zoning is significantly out of alignment. He noted that the average small South Carolina town (under 5,000 population) operates with 5–12 zoning districts and outlined the Commission's proposed restructuring of zoning districts to mirror the Comprehensive Plan's future land use designations. Key proposed zoning district changes presented included: ● Conservation – Minimum 3-acre lot; permanent restriction language adopted from state standards. ● Parks – Labeled per the Comprehensive Plan; the Town has one large town park. ● Conservation Residential (formerly Agricultural General) – Minimum 3-acre lot; 10% open space requirement. ● Rural Residential (formerly Area Residential) – Minimum 1.5-acre lot; 20% open space; described as the town's primary residential district. ● Village Residential (VR1) – New district added per the Comprehensive Plan; serves as a transition zone; minimum acreage with 25% open space. ● Village Residential (formerly Office Residential; VR2) – Most dense residential designation; minimum 21,500 sq. ft. with public water; 30% open space. ● Village Commercial (formerly General Commercial) – No open space requirement; minimum lot size updated per recent council action. ● Town Center – Present on the map but not in the Comprehensive Plan text; minimum 1- acre lot; pedestrian-oriented design standards proposed. Chairman Osguthorpe further noted that 22 of the Town's 24 currently approved or built planned developments (PDs) appear to be legally nonconforming under a 1994 state statute requiring PDs to be mixed-use. He referenced the 2000 South Carolina Supreme Court decision affirming that agricultural zones cannot be converted to dense residential development without a mixed-use component and called it. He stated he had no further explanation for the record. Future Land Use Map Discussion APPROVED Town of Awendaw | August 31st, 2026, Planning Commission and Town Council Joint Workshop Meeting Minutes | Page 3 Planning Manager Daniel O'Hara and Town Administrator Katharine Watkins clarified that the future land use map in the Comprehensive Plan represents the Town's vision for what land uses should be going forward, not a current zoning map. Town Administrator Watkins noted that the future land use map colors and designations are intended to serve as the basis for new zoning district classifications, effectuated through a formal rezoning process. Town Council and the Commission engaged in extended discussion on how PDs are represented on the map, with staff confirming that at least one referenced parcel (Seewee Landing, 67 lots) is shown on the future land use map as Village Residential. Nonconforming Lots Analysis Chairman Osguthorpe presented a preliminary analysis of nonconforming lots based on the Planning Commission's proposed zoning crosswalk. Using parcel data and lot size as the sole parameter, the following nonconforming lot counts were identified under the proposed standards: ● Conservation Residential: 112 lots ● Rural Residential: 520 lots ● Village Residential: 273 lots ● Village Center: 72 lots ● Town Center: 4 lots ● Total: approximately 927 lots Town Attorney Mac McQuillin and Town Administrator Watkins cautioned that this analysis was preliminary—based only on lot size—and did not account for lot width, setbacks, or other dimensional standards. They also noted that some nonconformities predate the Town's incorporation and were created by county zoning standards applied at the time the Town was formed. Action Item Assigned: Town Administrator Watkins directed staff to conduct an additional analysis of the current number of nonconforming lots under existing zoning standards (without any proposed changes), using lot size as the parameter, to establish a baseline for comparison. Chairman Osguthorpe addressed the legal framework governing nonconforming lots, emphasizing that: ● Any property conforming to zoning rules prior to rezoning is automatically grandfathered and may continue its current use with no required structural changes. ● Property owners may apply for a zoning variance through the Board of Zoning Appeals. ● Businesses rendered nonconforming may petition for a conditional use permit. ● Boundary adjustments through adjacent property transactions are available. Town Attorney McQuillen confirmed that local jurisdictions have broad discretion to designate nonconformities and utilize legally established techniques—including amortization—to phase them out over time. He noted that such determinations are fact-specific, and that legal challenges, while possible, do not guarantee adverse outcomes for the Town. Pending Lot Size Ordinances (Ordinance Nos. 2026-17 and 2026-18) Town Administrator Watkins provided procedural context for Ordinances 2026-17 and 2026-18, which propose increased minimum lot sizes for residential and agricultural general zoning districts. These ordinances received a first reading at the May 2026 Town Council meeting, a public hearing was held, and the Planning Commission reviewed them at the July meeting. Staff APPROVED Town of Awendaw | August 31st, 2026, Planning Commission and Town Council Joint Workshop Meeting Minutes | Page 4 identified Section 153.011(j) of the zoning code—the nonconforming lot merger (combination) clause—as a significant concern, noting that contiguous lots in common ownership that do not individually meet new minimum lot size requirements would be considered an undivided parcel and could not be separately sold or developed. Councilman Paul Brown expressed concern that the ordinances, though legally sound, could adversely affect small property owners and individuals who had already subdivided lots in reliance on prior town-approved standards. He called for minimizing harm to the maximum extent possible consistent with the Town's fiduciary responsibility to property owners. Commissioner James Gardner expressed frustration that the ordinances appeared to duplicate or conflict with the Planning Commission's comprehensive rezoning effort and noted that not having the background on the ordinances' intent made it difficult to evaluate them when they came before the Commission. He acknowledged, upon hearing the full explanation, that the ordinances were intended as an interim stopgap measure rather than a replacement for the Commission's comprehensive work. Town Administrator Watkins clarified the intent of the ordinances: they are interim measures designed to prevent the subdivision of small lots under the existing 5-lot moratorium carve-out while the Planning Commission completes its comprehensive zoning overhaul. She stated that the ordinances would not interfere with the Commission's ongoing work and are not intended to be permanent substitutes for a full zoning revision. Planning Manager O'Hara provided updated development activity data. Since adoption of the subdivision moratorium in 2024, the Town has seen a net gain of 15 parcels in 2024, 19 in 2025, and 9 in 2026, for a total net gain of approximately 52 lots under the moratorium. He noted that between 2024 and mid-2026, the Town approved 403 zoning permits total, of which 176 were for single-family residences. O'Hara identified several active and forthcoming large-scale development projects, including Preserve at Seewee Sound, Romain Bay Reserve Phase 1, Reserve at Bulls Bay (24 lots), Seewee Landing (67 lots), and the White Tract (Phase 1: 71 homes; Phase 2: 108 homes), with an anticipated net addition of approximately 174 single- family residences within the next two years from Seewee Sound Phase 1 and 2 and Romaine Bay Reserve Phase 1. Chairman Osguthorpe and Mayor Crolley each noted that community feedback gathered during door-to-door outreach and public workshops strongly favored larger lot sizes and expressed opposition to large-scale subdivision development—though Mayor Crolley emphasized that residents' stated concern was specifically with large developments, not with small-scale or family-based subdivisions. The body reached general consensus on two points: (1) the nonconforming lot merger clause in Section 153.011(j) should be removed or substantially amended; and (2) the comprehensive rewrite of subdivision standards is urgently needed regardless of the outcome of the pending ordinances. Action Item Assigned: Planning Manager O'Hara confirmed that a model ordinance to strike or amend Section 153.011(j) would be included in the September Town Council meeting agenda, with an additional version striking the merger clause entirely to be prepared based on the evening's discussion. Subdivision Standards and Comprehensive Zoning Revision Extended discussion occurred regarding the broader need to rewrite the Town's subdivision standards and bring zoning into alignment with the Comprehensive Plan. Planning Manager O'Hara, Town Administrator Watkins, Town Attorney McQuillen, and Chairman Osguthorpe all agreed that the existing subdivision standards are suburban in character and wholly APPROVED Town of Awendaw | August 31st, 2026, Planning Commission and Town Council Joint Workshop Meeting Minutes | Page 5 inappropriate for a rural development pattern. Chairman Osguthorpe noted that Planning Commissioner Kelly Cousino and Planning Manager O'Hara are working toward delivery of revised land use and development standards by December 2026. Planning Commissioner Jeff Hardee offered an illustrative analysis comparing impervious surface outcomes for conventional one-acre lot subdivision (approximately 21 acres of impervious surface per 50 acres developed) versus clustered development with gravel roads and smaller lots (approximately 7 acres of impervious surface per 50 acres developed). He emphasized that preserving the rural character of Awendaw—its tree canopy, unpaved roads, and natural drainage—should drive subdivision regulation design more than lot size alone. Town Administrator Watkins proposed that the revision of subdivision standards be pursued through a joint subcommittee structure, with council and planning commission liaisons collaborating with staff, noting that any such committee would need to comply with FOIA requirements for meetings, agendas, and minutes. Town Attorney McQuillen indicated the appropriate meeting structure would depend on the type of committee formed. Action Item Assigned: Staff directed to work with Planning Commission to deliver a comprehensive revision of subdivision standards for consideration at the December 2026 joint workshop, incorporating rural development standards, low-impact development principles, septic/sewer and utility requirements, and road and infrastructure standards consistent with the Comprehensive Plan's implementation goals. Action Item Assigned: Mayor Crolley and the body agreed to schedule a subsequent joint workshop in December 2026, prior to the Christmas holiday. Planning Manager O'Hara confirmed that a Doodle poll would be circulated by the town clerk to identify an available date. Planning Commission September 17 Public Input Session Commissioner Gardner raised the question of whether the Planning Commission's scheduled September 17, 2026 public input session on proposed zoning districts should proceed in light of the evening's discussion. Chairman Osguthorpe indicated the session would go forward. The body did not take formal action on this item but acknowledged that the September session would be an early step in the broader public education process on zoning changes. Public Comments Mayor Crolley opened the floor to public commentary to several members of the public during the workshop: ● Andrea Frazier gave a history of the make-up of the Comprehensive Plan Steering Committee, as she was a sitting member, and told how it made it to Town Council. [Time Stamp: 1:30:20/2:52:39] ● Chris Cullum, a longtime resident, thanked both bodies for their work and urged that any ordinance amendments address the unintended consequence of drawing small existing property owners into the nonconformity target zone, while still pursuing the primary goal of curtailing large-scale subdivisions. [Time Stamp: 1:31:29/2:52:39] ● Former Councilman Frank Frazier spoke to his history of the Comprehensive Plan when he was on Town Council and expressed support for larger lot sizes and citing concerns about density, septic capacity, flooding, drainage, and preserving Awendaw’s rural character [Time Stamp: 1:32:50/2:52:39] ● John Popelka expressed concern that interim lot size changes would disproportionately harm local property owners with undeveloped "paper lots" representing a significant APPROVED portion of their net worth, rather than targeting large developers. [Time Stamp: 1:35:34/2:52:39] ● Kay Minson, a 27-year resident, thanked the bodies for their commitment to the community and emphasized residents' desire for safe, livable neighborhoods with reliable infrastructure. [Time Stamp: 2:38:34/2:52:39] 8. Closing Remarks Mayor Chris Crolley offered closing remarks, affirming the importance of the joint workshop format and the value of open communication between the two bodies. He expressed confidence in the expertise of the Planning Commission and staff, and expressed support for a more collaborative, less siloed approach going forward. Mayor Crolley committed to quarterly or triannual joint workshops and encouraged the Planning Commission to proceed with its work, bringing items requiring formal approval through the standard process. Town Administrator Katharine Watkins summarized staff's marching orders from the evening: ● Conduct a nonconforming lot analysis under current zoning standards using lot size as the parameter to establish a baseline. ● Work with Planning Commission on revised subdivision standards for the Decembe r j oint workshop. ● Prepare an amendment to remove the merger clause from Section 153.011(j) for the September Town Council agenda. ● Circulate a Doodle poll for a December joint workshop date. ● Continue work with COG on an updated, official zoning map for formal adoption, leading toward a repeal-and-replace of the current zoning framework. 9. Adjournment There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Motion: To adjourn 1 st: Chairman Osguthorpe 2nd: Councilman Timmons Discussion: None Vote: The motion passed unanimously. The meeting adjourned at 8:52 pm DRAFT Minutes Respectfully Submitted on Thursday, September 24th, 2026, by Takeya White Final Approval Date: 10.01.2026 Signature:Takeya White, CMC Note: These meeting minutes are not verbatim. To watch the full meeting video, please visit the town’s YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/@TownOfAwendaw Notice of Meeting: In accordance with S.C. Code of Laws, 1976, Section 30-4-80(d), as amended, notice of the time, date, place, and agenda of this meeting was provided, and the agenda was posted on the bulletin board at Town Hall prior to the meeting. Town of Awendaw | August 31st, 2026, Planning Commission and Town Council Joint Workshop Meeting Minutes | Page 6 APPROVED

Source: Town of Awendaw website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.