RecordWell Data

Minutes

Town of Awendaw · Charleston County · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Awendaw

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Page 1 of 5 TOWN OF AW ENDAW 6971 Doar Road | P.O. Box 520 | Awendaw, SC 29429 843.928.3100 | www.townofawendawsc.org townadministrator@townofawendawsc.org Katharine Watkins | Town Administrator Takeya White | Clerk Chris Crolley | Mayor Town Council Paul Brown | Wendy Helms Grace Gasper | Rodney Porcher Kent Prause | John Timmons Town of Awendaw Tree Preservation Sub-Committee APPROVED Minutes Wednesday, July 22nd, 2026 3:00 PM Awendaw Town Hall A . Prayer, Pledge of Allegiance & Reading of the Civility Pledge Town Clerk Takeya White opened the meeting and led the assembly with the “The Lord’s Prayer.” The Pledge of Allegiance was recited by all assembled, followed by a reading of the Civility Pledge. B. C all to Order and Roll Call Town Clerk Takeya White called the meeting to order and conducted roll call. Present: Planning Manager Dan O’Hara (Virtual), Mr. John Brubaker, Councilwoman Grace Gasper along with staff, Town Administrator Ms. Katharine Watkins and Town Clerk Takeya White C. Appointment of Chair The floor was opened for nominations for committee chair. [Time Stamp: 2:08/1:09:20] Motion: To open the floor for nominations for committee chair posed by Committee member John Brubaker and seconded by Committee member Gasper. Discussion: None Vote: The motion passed unanimously (Aye) In discussion, Committee member gasper asked if any member was interested in taking on the role. Committee Member John Brubaker volunteered to serve in the role, and the nomination was accepted. Motion: T o appoint John Brubaker as Chair of the Tree Preservation Sub-Committee was made by Committee Member Grace Gasper and seconded by Planning Manager O’Hara. Discussion: None Vote: The motion passed unanimously (Aye) D . Appointment of Vice-Chair T he floor was opened for nominations for Vice-Chair. Motion: To appoint Grace Gasper as Vice-Chair of the Tree Preservation Sub- Committee was made by Planning Manager O’Hara and seconded by Chairman John Brubaker. Discussion: None SETTLED 1696 APPROVED Page 2 of 5 Vote: The motion passed unanimously (Aye) E. Adoption of Rules of Procedures The committee discussed the adoption of a standard procedural framework. It was agreed that the most current edition of Robert's Rules of Order would serve as the guiding framework for committee business. Motion: To adopt the most current version of Robert's Rules of Order to guide all Tree Preservation Sub-committee proceedings was made by Vice-Chairman Gasper and seconded by Planning Manager O’Hara. Discussion: None Vote: The motion passed unanimously. (Aye) F. Public Comments – The public comment period will be limited to a total of 25 minutes. Each speaker will have up to 2 minutes. No individual may speak more than once until all others wishing to comment have had an opportunity. 1. Lynn Vicary of 8470 Doar Road Ms. Vicary addressed the committee regarding tree preservation challenges on smaller vested lots, specifically referencing development occurring along South Doar Road. She noted that some of those vested lots are as small as 9,068 square feet, with a maximum home coverage of 25 percent. She described consulting a Clemson-trained landscape architect, who concluded that, given the constraints of the lot footprint, hardpan surfaces, septic systems, and foundation clearance requirements, there were effectively no native trees suitable for planting on such a lot. Ms. Vicary urged the committee to consider not just tree mitigation in isolation, but the integral role of the tree canopy in defining the character and livability of Lowcountry communities—particularly as smaller, nonconforming lots are developed. Chair John Brubaker responded directly to Ms. Vicary's concerns, affirming that her point was well taken. He noted that many tree species indigenous to the area possess deep root systems that do not pose a threat to septic drain fields and indicated his intention to ensure the ordinance identifies and promotes those species. He also expressed concern about the practice of designing structures for lots without first determining whether the infrastructure—septic, foundation, and landscaping—could be adequately accommodated, emphasizing the need for more front-end responsibility placed on purchasers and developers. APPROVED Page 3 of 5 G. New Business – [Time Stamp: 13:25/1:09:20] a. An Ordinance to Amend Chapter 153, Zoning Code, Tree Preservation Requirements Division, Subsections 153.195 and 153.196, to Restructure the Review, Mitigation, and Site Retention Process for the Removal of Protected Trees. Chair John Brubaker and Vice-Chair Grace Gasper opened a substantive working discussion on the current state of the draft tree preservation ordinance. The committee had before it two primary versions: the First Reading version (Appendix 2026-04-01), which incorporated staff and Town Council edits, and the Planning Commission recommendations, which further developed the draft and drew significantly from Mount Pleasant's tree ordinance, including a mitigation table recommended by an arborist. Planning Manager O’Hara provided context for both versions. He explained that staff edits were originally proposed after recognizing deficiencies in the current ordinance that were not preserving trees as intended, and that the Planning Commission subsequently built upon that work in a direction more aligned with Charleston County's ordinance. He noted that the mitigation table, borrowed from Mount Pleasant, had generated some confusion, and acknowledged that moving toward a defined list of preferred native species—rather than leaving replacement tree selection entirely open—was a direction he could support. Vice-Chair Grace Gasper stressed the importance of simplicity and clarity, expressing concern that the ordinance could become unnecessarily cumbersome for residents without the resources to hire specialized professionals. She emphasized that the goal should be to protect Awendaw's native canopy and rural character, using a "right plant, right place" philosophy rather than framing the issue strictly as urban versus rural development standards. She also raised the need for significantly stronger violation penalties, noting that monetary fines alone are unlikely to deter developers, and referencing language from another jurisdiction that suspends building permits upon violation as a more effective deterrent. Chair John Brubaker expressed a strong preference for replacing the current mitigation calculation table entirely, claiming it was counterproductive, and proposed instead a system that awards credit for on-site retention of appropriate native species—verified against established ecological criteria. He referenced The Natural Communities of South Carolina by John Nelson as a practical, accessible framework for identifying the natural community type present on a given site and selecting ecologically appropriate plantings. He noted that this text is designed to be used by laypersons and could be meaningfully incorporated into the ordinance as a reference standard. He expressed his intent to redraft the ordinance language section by section and bring it to the committee for review at the next meeting. Planning Manager O’Hara highlighted several additional priorities: ensuring tree protection barriers for root systems are codified (a standard present in Charleston County and Mount Pleasant but absent from Awendaw's current code); addressing tree removal within designated setbacks and buffers, which he proposed should be prohibited outright; and differentiating between the two development patterns actively occurring in town—suburban-style subdivision development and rural residential—to ensure that appropriate standards are applied in each context. He noted that Georgetown County's ordinance includes distinct rural and urban standards with identified boundaries, and that a similar approach could be considered for Awendaw. Town Clerk Takeya White weighed in from a regulatory and compliance perspective, emphasizing APPROVED Page 4 of 5 the need for the final ordinance to be specific enough to provide clear enforcement authority, while not becoming so complex as to be unworkable in practice. She expressed a preference for building on the First Reading version rather than the Planning Commission version, finding the latter's detail level more prone to implementation confusion. She strongly advocated for community education as a precondition for successful enforcement, suggesting that a public workshop—potentially a "tree preservation day" or "species day"—could build community buy-in before the ordinance takes effect and draw on the knowledge of long-term residents familiar with the local landscape. Planning Manager O’Hara also noted that a tree canopy study had been conducted in town in recent years and is referenced in the Comprehensive Plan (Tree Canopy Study was done in 2022 - TW); he indicated the hard copy may be available in the Town office and agreed to locate and share it with the committee. He additionally raised the concept of developing separate subdivision standards in the land development regulations to address tree preservation requirements specific to subdivision activity, complementing the broader zoning code provisions that would apply to all property owners. Vice-Chair Grace Gasper noted that Sullivan's Island operates a tree mitigation fund in which removal of invasive species earns mitigation credit and suggested a similar incentive structure could encourage proactive stewardship in Awendaw. She also mentioned that the Sullivan's Island resilience coordinator had shared a list of preferred native species and offered to make that available to the committee. She and Town Clerk Takeya White both highlighted the potential value of resources from Clemson Extension, Audubon, and the Lowcountry Land Trust in producing accessible, locally relevant planting guides. The committee agreed on the following path forward: Chair John Brubaker will prepare a section-by-section redraft of the First Reading version (Appendix 2026-04-01), proposing edits where he finds the existing language insufficient or in need of replacement. That draft will be circulated to committee members and staff prior to the next meeting for review and discussion. H. Confirmation of Next Meeting Date - [Time Stamp: 1:05:59/1:09:20] T he committee discussed scheduling the next meeting during the week of August 17th. Vice-Chair Grace Gasper indicated she would confirm her availability upon reviewing her calendar and would communicate available dates to Town Clerk Takeya White, who would then notify all members and ensure the meeting is properly publicized. No conflicts were identified by Chair John Brubaker or Planning Manager O’Hara for that week. Assigned Action Items: (No formal motions were made) Action Item: Vice-Chair Grace Gasper to email available dates for the week of August 17th to Town Clerk Takeya White, who will coordinate and publicize the next meeting date. Action Item: Chair John Brubaker to prepare a section-by-section redraft of the First Reading version (Appendix 2026-04-01) for committee review prior to the next meeting. Action Item: Planning Manager O’Hara to locate the town's tree canopy study and share it with committee members, and to reach out to Audubon, Clemson Extension, and Lowcountry Land Trust for relevant native species maps and planting guides. I. C losing Remarks – APPROVED Page 5 of 5 There were none. J. Adjournment – [Time Stamp: 1:08:53/1:09:20] M otion: To adjourn 1st: Vice Chair Gasper, 2nd Chairman Brubaker Discussion: None Vote: Unanimous approval The meeting adjourned at 4:10 pm DRAFT Minutes Respectfully Submitted on Thursday, August 27th, 2026, by Takeya White Minutes approved as amended Final Approval Date: 10.12.2026 Electronic Signature: Takeya White, CMC Note: These meeting minutes are not verbatim. To watch the full meeting video, please visit the town’s YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/@TownOfAwendaw Notice of Meeting: In accordance with the SC Code of Laws, 1976, Section 30-4-80(d), as amended, the following have been notified of the time, date, place, and agenda of this meeting. The agenda was posted on the bulletin board at Town Hall prior to the meeting. APPROVED

Source: Town of Awendaw website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.