RecordWell Data

Agenda

Town of Awendaw · Charleston County · Agendas

Open the original document More from Town of Awendaw

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

TOWN OF AWENDAW 6971 Doar Road | P.O. Box 520 | Awendaw, SC 29429 843.928.3100 | www.townofawendawsc.org townadministrator@townofawendawsc.org Rebecca Vance | Interim Town Administrator Takeya White | Clerk & Vivienne Haven | Treasurer Chris Crolley | Mayor Town Council Paul Brown | Wendy Helms Grace Gasper | Rodney Porcher Kent Prause | John Timmons Town of Awendaw Tree Preservation Sub-Committee Meeting Monday, November 16th, 2026 1:00 PM A. Call to Order and Roll Call B. Prayer, Pledge of Allegiance & Reading of the Civility Pledge C. Approval of November 16 th, 2026, Tree Preservation Sub-Committee Agenda D. Approval of October 12th, 2026, Meeting Minutes E. Public Comments – The public comment period will be limited to a total of 25 minutes. Each speaker will have up to 2 minutes. No individual may speak more than once until all others wishing to comment have had an opportunity. F. Old Business – a. Ordinance 2026-04 - AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND CHAPTER 153, ZONING CODE, TREE PRESERVATION REQUIREMENTS DIVISION, SUBSECTION 153.195 AND 153.198, TO RESTRUCTURE THE REVIEW, MITIGATION, AND SITE RENTION PROCESS FOR THE REMOVAL OF PROTECTED TREES. G. Confirmation of Next Meeting Date - H. Closing Remarks – I. Adjournment IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT, THE PRINT MEDIA WERE DULY NOTIFIED, ALONG WITH A HARD COPY POSTED AT CITY HALL. ● SHOULD YOU HAVE QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS, PLEASE CONTACT PLANNING AT (843) 931 -8125. SETTLED 1696 DRAFT TOWN OF AWEN DAW 6971 Doar Road | P.O. Box 520 | Awendaw, SC 29429 843.928.3100 | www.townofawendawsc.org townadministrator@townofawendawsc.org Rebecca Vance | Interim Town Administrator Takeya White | Clerk & Vivienne Haven | Treasurer Chris Crolley | Mayor Town Council Paul Brown | Wendy Helms Grace Gasper | Rodney Porcher Kent Prause | John Timmons Town of Awendaw Tree Preservation Sub-Committee Meeting DRAFT Minutes Monday, October 12th, 2026 2:00 PM A. Ca ll to Order and Roll Call Chair Brubaker called the meeting to order and went into roll call. Present: Chairman John-Brubaker, Vice-chairman Grace Gasper (arrived at 2:02 pm), Planning Manager Dan O’Hara and Town Clerk Takeya White were all present. B. Prayer, Pledge of Allegiance & Reading of the Civility Pledge Chair J ohn Brubaker opened the meeting and led the assembly with the prayer. The Pledge of Allegiance was recited by all assembled, followed by a reading of the Civility Pledge. C. Approval of October 12th, 2026, Tree Preservation Sub-Committee Agenda A mo tion to accept the October 12th, 2026, Tree Preservation Sub-Committee Agenda was made by Chair Brubaker and seconded by Planning Manager O’Hara. The motion carried unanimously, 3-0. D. App roval of July 22nd, 2026, Meeting Minutes Chair Brubaker asked whether members had reviewed the minutes of the July 22nd meeting. Planning ManagerO'Hara noted that he had attended that meeting virtually and asked that the minutes reflect this. He said the change was not substantial enough to revisit at the next meeting. No other corrections were offered. A motion to approve the minutes of the July 22nd meeting, with the noted correction regarding virtual attendance, was made by Planning Manager O’Hara, and seconded by Vice-Chair Gasper. The motion carried unanimously, 3-0. E. Pub lic Comments – [Time Stamp: 0:4:56/2:02:20] The public comment period will be limited to a total of 25 minutes. Each speaker will have up to 2 minutes. No individual may speak more than once until all others wishing to comment have had an opportunity. Lyn n Vicary of 8470 Doar Road asked how the draft ordinance would apply in an emergency, such as a hanging limb or a leaning tree. She asked whether a property owner could document the condition with photographs rather than go before the Zoning Administrator for a special exception. She said that the process could be burdensome and that time is often critical. She added that she had been unable to read the full draft. SETTLED 1696 Page 1 of 5 DRAFT Planning Manager O'Hara responded that the draft includes hardship provisions, including a provision allowing removal where it is the only reasonable means of meeting building, zoning, subdivision, health, or public safety requirements. He said he would address the question further during the ordinance discussion. Ms. Vicary thanked the committee for its work. F. Old Business – [Time Stamp: 0:7:11/2:02:20] a. O rdinance 2026-04 - AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND CHAPTER 153, ZONING CODE, TREE PRESERVATION REQUIREMENTS DIVISION, SUBSECTION 153.195 AND 153.198, TO RESTRUCTURE THE REVIEW, MITIGATION, AND SITE RENTION PROCESS FOR THE REMOVAL OF PROTECTED TREES. Chair Brubaker explained that the committee was tasked with developing a more effective Tree Preservation Ordinance for the Town of Awendaw. Following his review of comparable municipalities, he recommended using Hilton Head Island’s ordinance as a framework, citing its established protections, legal history, and administrative clarity. He submitted the ordinance as Supplemental Document #1 for consideration. Vice-Chair Gasper expressed concerns about using Hilton Head as a model given the differences between the two communities. Chair Brubaker emphasized that the proposed ordinance would be tailored to Awendaw’s rural character, natural resources, and environmental priorities. Planning Manager O’Hara clarified that the Town’s First Reading version of Ordinance 2026-04 remained the legislative starting point and cautioned against unintentionally weakening existing protections. Tree Classifications, Species, and Protection Standards The committee reviewed tree classifications based on diameter at breast height (DBH), including Hilton Head’s 24-inch threshold for certain live oaks, compared with Awendaw’s existing 12-inch hardwood standard and the Planning Commission’s proposed 18-inch grand tree threshold. Members discussed locally appropriate species, including southern red cedar, loblolly pine, and Hercules club. The committee also examined Hilton Head’s tree equivalency system, which assigns species value factors of 1.0, 0.75, 0.5, or 0.25 and establishes a requirement of 900 adjusted caliper inches (ACI) per acre of pervious surface. Members questioned the scientific basis for the 900 ACI standard and agreed that additional research and adjustments to local species classifications were necessary. Tree Removal, Pruning, and Exemptions Members discussed emergency tree removal provisions, including allowing the Planning Manager or designee to review removals after the fact and require restitution when exemptions are improperly used. The committee also considered pruning restrictions, particularly the proposed 10% leaf surface removal limitation. Planning Manager O’Hara expressed concerns regarding enforcement and Page 2 of 5 DRAFT staffing capacity, while Vice-Chair Gasper supported retaining measurable standards. No final determination was made. The committee reviewed forestry exemptions under S.C. Code §48-23-205 and discussed maintaining restrictions preventing property owners from clearing land under a forestry exemption and immediately pursuing development. The First Reading draft proposed an eight- year waiting period, compared with Hilton Head’s six-year provision. Tree Surveys, Development Standards, and Staffing Planning Manager O’Hara raised concerns about the cost of professional tree surveys, particularly for residential property owners. Chair Brubaker suggested exploring lower-cost survey options, including qualified students or interns. Vice-Chair Gasper recommended considering financial assistance or grant opportunities for residents. Members discussed establishing different requirements based on parcel size and development type, including a possible five-acre subdivision threshold, protections within setbacks and buffers, and limitations on land disturbance surrounding residential construction. The committee also reviewed tree protection zones, including drip-line protection versus DBH- based formulas. Planning Manager O’Hara recommended incorporating fencing, marking, and signage requirements into the ordinance. Mitigation, Enforcement, and Public Education The committee discussed establishing a dedicated tree mitigation or natural resources fund. Potential uses included tree replacement, living shoreline restoration, and assistance with tree survey costs. Vice-Chair Gasper recommended stronger enforcement measures beyond monetary fines, including potential restrictions on future building permits for violations. Planning Manager O’Hara emphasized maintaining setback and buffer protections without encroachment exceptions. To improve public understanding, Vice-Chair Gasper requested a one-page, plain-language summary explaining the ordinance’s requirements and limitations. Planning Manager O’Hara agreed this could be developed. Additional Considerations and Next Steps The committee also discussed preserving understory vegetation through pre-construction underbrushing regulations and reviewed Hilton Head’s Natural Resource Request application as a possible administrative tool. Planning Manager O’Hara indicated that the First Reading version would serve as the foundation for incorporating proposed revisions, with the resulting ordinance anticipated to be introduced as a full repeal and replacement under a new ordinance number. Page 3 of 5 DRAFT Additional research and consideration were identified regarding tree classifications, the 900 ACI standard, applicability thresholds, pruning restrictions, mitigation requirements, enforcement provisions, and implementation resources. Requested Action: The committee agreed that Planning Manager O'Hara would prepare a one-page document identifying, section by section, how the framework would be reorganized and where Hilton Head elements and committee recommendations would be placed. The working draft will be in Word format, sent to Town Clerk Takeya White, who will distribute it to members. Members will make tracked changes and return comments before the next meeting. Open items for follow-up included: • research on the 900 ACI standard; • adjustment of tree categories to local conditions; • sample-project analysis of replacement methods; • assistance for property owners who need tree surveys; • uses of a tree replacement fund; • strengthened penalties; • the pruning standard; • the forestry waiting period; • applicability tiers. No formal action was taken on the ordinance. G. Confirmation of Next Meeting Date – [Time Stamp: 1:57:41/2:02:20] Planning Manager O'Hara noted scheduling conflicts in the coming weeks, including Planning Commission meetings, the Board of Zoning Appeals, a Town Council meeting, and staff work on the land development regulations. He asked that the next meeting be scheduled in November. After reviewing several dates, the committee agreed to meet on Monday, November 16, 2026, at 1:00 PM, and Chair Brubaker confirmed the date. Town Clerk White was to coordinate notice. H. Closing Remarks – [Time Stamp: 2:00:46/2:02:20] Chair Brubaker stated that he was pleased with the committee's progress. He observed that the Hilton Head ordinance did not deviate greatly from the Town's current ordinance but provided far more specificity and clarity, which he believed would reduce questions from the public. He said the ordinance must serve the community without placing unreasonable demands on staff, though he anticipated that doing the right thing might require additional staffing. Vice-Chair Gasper and Planning Manager O'Hara concurred. I. Adjournment - [Time Stamp: 2:01:20/2:02:20] Motion: To adjourn Page 4 of 5 DRAFT 1st: Vice Chair Gasper, 2nd Chairman Brubaker Discussion: None Vote: Unanimous approval The meeting adjourned at 4:03 pm DRAFT Minutes Respectfully Submitted on Tuesday, November 10th, 2026, by Takeya White Final Approval Date: _____________ Electronic Signature: ____________________________ Note: These meeting minutes are not verbatim. To watch the full meeting video, please visit the town’s YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/@TownOfAwendaw IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT, THE PRINT MEDIA WERE DULY NOTIFIED, ALONG WITH A HARD COPY POSTED AT CITY HALL. ● SHOULD YOU HAVE QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS, PLEASE CONTACT PLANNING AT (843) 931-8125. Page 5 of 5 ORDINANCE NO. 2026-XX AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND CHAPTER 153, ZONING CODE, TREE PRESERVATION REQUIREMENTS DIVISION, SUBSECTIONS 153.195 AND 153.196 , TO RESTRUCTURE THE REVIEW, MITIGATION, AND SITE RETAINMENT PROCESS FOR THE REMOVAL OF PROTECTED TREES. WHEREAS, the Town Council wishes to strengthen the preservation of trees within the Town of Awendaw. NOW, THEREFORE, be it Ordered and Ordained by the Council of the Town of Awendaw, S. C., that Article 7.1, Tree Preservation Requirements of the Code of the Town of Awendaw, South Carolina, shall be repealed and replaced as follows: Section 153.190 Purpose (A) To protect existing forests adjacent to federally protected environments and habitats. (B) To preserve the Town’s existing tree canopy and to maintain at least a tree canopy of 60%. Section 153.191 Applicability (A) Any Land Disturbance or Construction activity that may result in any protected trees being damaged, destroyed, or removed. (B) Any request proposing the removal or encroachment of any protected trees. If the conditions of this section present a hardship , a person must submit a zoning permit application to the Zoning Administrator. The Zoning Administrator or their designee may grant a zoning permit based on the following factors: a. Trees are diseased, dead or dying; b. Trees pose a safety hazard to nearby buildings, or pedestrian or vehicular traffic; c. Trees prevent essential grade changes or all reasonable utility installations; d. Trees prevent all reasonable site configurations; e. Trees are within the footprint of a proposed residential structure or septic field, as shown on a site plan; f. Removal of trees is the only reasonable means by which building, zoning, subdivision, health, public safety, or other Town requirements can be met. Section 153.192 Exemptions (A) Exceptions to this include trees grown for farming activities. (B) Others as suggested. Section 153.194 Significant and Grand Tree Classification (A) Significant Tree Classification. Hardwood trees (excluding gums and water oaks) twelve (12) inches DBH (DBH = diameter at breast height) or greater s. (B) Grand Tree Classification. Grand Trees are recognized as providing exceptional ecological, environmental, scenic, and cultural value and shall receive enhanced protection under this ordinance. (C) Species Hierarchy? Tree Preservation Ordinance as Presented on November 16, 2026 Section 153.195 Tree Protection Standards. (A) Tree Protection Zone (TPZ). Grand Trees as required, shall have a mandatory Tree Protection Zone (TPZ). The TPZ shall encompass the critical root zone (CRZ), and a tree barricade fence must be installed around the CRZ to prevent any activity in this area . Within the TPZ, the following activities are prohibited unless approved through the procedures outlined herein: a. grading or fill placement b. trenching or utility installation c. compaction by vehicles or equipment d. storage of materials e. alteration of natural drainage patterns Section 153.193 Tree Surveys and Development Standards (A) Design Priority Standard. Development shall be designed using the following hierarchy: a. Preserve Grand Trees; b. Preserve existing Significant Trees; c. Preserve 75% of the existing Tree Canopy onsite; d. Adjust site layout where feasible; e. Utilize mitigation planting only as a last resort. (B) Tree Surveys. a. Residential Sites i. Land Disturbance or Construction Projects less than 10% of the total lot but not to exceed 5,000 square feet: 1. Grand Trees or Significant trees must be identified within the proposed limits of disturbance. 2. Any grand tree within 25 feet of activities shall show a Tree Protection Zone ii. All other projects: 1. Any project proposing 10% to 30% land disturbance a. A partial tree survey shall be required within the limits of disturbance, and b. Tree Protection Zone (TPZ) sur veyed on all grand trees within the limits of disturbance (LOD), and c. All trees within a 15-foot buffer of the LOD shall be protected. 2. Any project proposing land disturbance activities over more than 30% of the total lot area: a. A full site tree survey shall be required, and b. Tree Protection Zone (TPZ) sur veyed on all grand trees within the limits of disturbance (LOD), and c. All trees within a 35-foot buffer of the LOD shall be protected, and d. No more than 30% of the existing protected trees identified on the survey can be removed. Tree Preservation Ordinance as Presented on November 16, 2026 Section 153.193 Tree Surveys and Development Standards - contiued b. Commercial Properties. All commercial properties shall prepare a full site tree survey showing all existing significant and grand trees. i. Any trees within a 3-to-4-inch DBH deviation of each category shall also be marked (i.e., an 8-inch DBH live oak must be shown on commercial tree surveys). Tree Protection Zone (TPZ) surveyed on all grand trees in the limits of disturbance (LOD) and protected, and ii. All trees within a 50-foot buffer of the LOD shall be protected, and iii. No more than 25% of the existing protected trees identified on the survey can be removed. (C) Tree Protection Zone Maintenance a. Tree protection barricades must have a layer of organic mulch 3 to 4 inches thick. b. Routine tree protection inspection by a certified arborist shall be required preconstruction, during construction, and post-construction to ensure no encroachment occurs or disturbance occurs within the protection barricade. Section 153.196 Mitigation and Enforcement. A) Tree mitigation count shall be 15% greater than the total inches of significant and grand trees removed (I.e., if 150 inches of significant trees are removed from the property, 170 inches must be replaced). B) A tree mitigation plan shall include the following: a. A table showing the: i. Replacement species, ii. Number of trees, and iii. Caliper inch. b. Show the location of trees to be mitigated, C) No less than one-for-one inch replacement shall be permitted. D) Where difficulty in replacing the additional 15% DBH of inches lost a. If approved by the Board of Zoning Appeals or its designee, the applicant shall pay a tree replacement fee of $100 per DBH inch of hardwoods and $50 per DBH inch of softwoods. b. If trees are removed without an approved permit and mitigation plan, the cost of tree replacement will be increased to $200 per DBH inch of hardwoods and softwoods. c. Additionally, if the Board finds that the trees were removed with knowledge of the Town’s tree ordinance, any development permits or proposals may be held in abeyance for a total of 36 months after the required restoration has occurred or fees have been paid. E) Replacement Trees shall be a minimum of 2.5-inch caliper. The following species are required to be utilized as replacement mitigation trees. The list is subject to staff approval & town administrator. a. Live Oak (Quercus virginiana) b. Southern Magnolia (Magnolia grandiflora) c. Bald Cypress (Taxodium distichum) d. Willow Oak (Quercus phellos) e. White Oak (Quercus alba) f. Blackgum / Tupelo (Nyssa sylvatica) g. American Holly (Ilex opaca) h. Red Maple (Acer rubrum) Tree Preservation Ordinance as Presented on November 16, 2026 Section 153.197 Required Tree Canopy Retention (A) A minimum of 60% of the Pr otected Tree Canopy is required to be retained or planted, with the minimum tree size being two and one-half caliper inches. (B) The owner or developer is required to retain existing trees on the site to the maximum extent possible, as determined during the development approval process, in lieu of replanting. (C) If the required amount of caliper inches per tree to be retained does not exist, or for extraordinary circumstances cannot be retained, an equivalent amount of caliper inches may be planted to satisfy this requirement, with replacement determined during the applicable approval process. (D) Tree removal is only allowed with an approved development plan; lots may not be cleared without a purpose stated in an approved development plan. Severability The provisions of this ordinance are intended to be severable, and if a court of competent jurisdiction should hold any part of this ordinance invalid, unconstitutional, or otherwise unlawful, such ruling shall not affect the remainder of the ordinance, which shall remain in full force and effect. Be it further ordained that the Town Council declares its intention that the “Pending Ordinance Doctrine” be effective upon first reading of this ordinance. THIS ORDINANCE SHALL BE EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY UPON FINAL READING _____________________________ Chris Crolley, Mayor Town of Awendaw First reading: January 8, 2026 Public Hearing: Planning Commission Recommendation: Second and Final Reading: Donna F. Steed, Clerk of Council

Source: Town of Awendaw website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.