11-14-16 Council Meeting Minutes
Town of Pawleys Island · Georgetown County · meeting of Dec 11, 2014 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Pawleys Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MINUTES CALLED MEETING PAWLEYS ISLAND TOWN COUNCIL DATE/PLACE: November 14, 2016 Pawleys Island Chapel PRESENT: Mayor Bill Otis, Mike Adams, Ashley Carter, Rocky Holliday & Sarah Zimmerman ABSENT: None EXECUTIVE SESSION 30-4-70(A) (2) LEGAL ADVICE PROPERTY ACQUISITION FOR TOWN HALL Sarah Zimmerman made a motion to stand down in to Executive Session under 30-4-70(a)(2) to discuss legal advice on property or easement acquisition Town Hall. Mike Adams seconded. All in favor. Sarah Zimmerman made a motion to stand down from Executive Session. Mike Adams seconded. All in favor. Mayor Otis stated that there were no decisions made. PUBLIC COMMENT No one signed up for Public Comment. MOMENT OF SILENCE FOR THE PASSING OF WORTH JOHNSON Mayor Otis stated that Worth was a valued member of our community and a valued member of our Board of Appeals for many years. After some very significant and serious health issues Worth passed away and The Mayor asked for a moment of silence for him. APPROVAL OF MINUTES - SEPTEMBER 12, 26, OCTOBER 6, 10, 13, 18, 27, 2016 Sarah Zimmerman made a motion to approve the September 12, 26, October 6, 10, 13, 18, 27, 2016 meeting minutes. Mike Adams seconded. All in favor. APPEAL OF THE GEORGETOWN COUNTY GROIN PERMIT AS AN INTERVENER – 3 YEAR ANNIVERSARY The Town attorney stated that there has been no response. BEACH COMMITTEE – ROCKY HOLLIDAY Rocky Holliday stated that because of Hurricane Matthew the Beach Committee did not meet during the month of October. The next meeting will focus on the impact of Matthew and what that has added to their subject matter to work on. Engineers from CSE will be at their next meeting and they will be looking at alternatives identified by the CSE engineers for renourishing Pawleys beach and at what cost. There will be discussions of potential State, Federal and other sources of funding. They will also discuss the agreement by the US Corps of Engineers to reactivate our long-term study. DISCUSSION OF A TOWN HALL PERMANENT LOCATION Mayor Otis stated that this has been under discussion since the existing historic Town Hall has been deemed uninhabitable after Hurricane Matthew. He read the following; “On October the 8th, 2016, Hurricane Matthew drove over 3 feet of water into the Town of Pawleys Island Town Hall. ______________________ Page 1 of 7 November 14, 2016
The result of the destruction by this salt water intrusion was that the structure is unusable with the Town granting itself an exemption from its own ordinances. This has been discussed by Council which has decided that this is not an appropriate path to take considering that there are other property owners in the Town that currently face or could face the same problem in the future. In addition, the structure would not be insurable for federal flood insurance in the future. Council has looked at options for the relocation of Town Hall under the following parameters: 1) The Town Hall should be within the Town limits potentially utilize existing property owned by the Town at the corner of the North Causeway and Myrtle Avenue which is currently landscaped as part of the Pawleys Park. 2) Spend funds very carefully for any new property. 3) Determine if there are any low-cost alternatives. 4) Have direct access to and visibility from a major street. 5) Keep governance around and near its current location and maintain its relationship to the park as the “center” of the island. 6) Maintain or improve the “sense of arrival” on Pawleys Island North Causeway. 7) Be considerate to existing residential property owners when evaluating new locations. 8) Consider if improved beach access should be integrated into a Town Hall location given the other parameters. There have been several properties considered for acquisition or for use as a temporary Town Hall. The cost to the Town to purchase those sites has been in excess of $400,000 each without a building on them and greater if structures exist. Not all had access and visibility from a major street. All would separate the Town Hall from the North Causeway area. All could cause existing neighboring property owners consternation. The property owned by the Town on the southwest corner of Myrtle Avenue and the North Causeway met most of the parameters but there has been some concern from the Pawleys Island Beautification Foundation regarding the loss of that property from the park and the fact that most of its beautification and integration into the park was donated by island families. A long-time property owner, Glen Cox, brought an out of the box solution to Council which has been considered by Council to be an excellent alternative. That is to ask the South Carolina Department of Transportation to turn over the 66 foot right of way of Pavilion Road to the Town. The Town would then design and construct a new Town Hall on the right of way of Pavilion Road at the intersection facing Myrtle Avenue with Town Hall parking on the current Pavilion Avenue paving at the Myrtle Avenue intersection. The street would be a dead end from the North Causeway but will be left open for part traffic and parking as well as retaining the staging area for trash pick-up and temporary equipment uses such as for the underground wire construction. The creek access area would remain open accessible and there could be additional areas on the east side of the Pavilion Road right of way made available for additional landscaping as the paving only takes up less than 30 of the 66 foot right of way. An example might be where the Pawleys Park signage is now located improving the sense of arrival on Pawleys. The Town would request that a right turn lane be added at the intersection of the North Causeway and Myrtle Avenue so traffic turning right won’t be backed up by traffic turning left at the intersection. The Town has discussed this with the President and immediate past President of the Pawleys Island Pavilion Company which owns both sides of Pavilion Road including the park and believe that their board would be supportive of the idea. SCDOT is willing to turn over Pavilion Road to the Town subject to approval in Columbia. The Town attorney, David DuRant, has discussed the proposal with the SCDOT and sees no issues with it. The only acquisition cost would be some legal cost involved with the plat and filling out several pages of documentation. ______________________ Page 2 of 7 November 14, 2016
All other parameters discussed so far will be met by the proposal with exception of approved beach access. However, creek access at the park would be maintained and could be improved if Council wished.” Sarah Zimmerman made a motion for Ryan Fabbri and David DuRant to secure the Pavilion Road right of way for the location of the new Town Hall. Mike Adams seconded. All in favor. Mayor Otis stated that he thought the property owners should have some open input. Once we have the SCDOT’s approval we will schedule an open Town Hall meeting. BOARD OF APPEALS VACANCIES – WORTH JOHNSON – ROBERT MOSER PROPOSED BY ASHLEY CARTER Mayor Otis stated that Ashley Carter has proposed Robert Moser to fill Worth Johnson’s position on the Board of Appeals. Ashley Carter made a motion to approve Robert Moser to complete Worth Johnson’s term on the Board of Appeals. Sarah Zimmerman seconded. All in favor. ACCOMMODATIONS TAX COMMITTEE VACANCY – ROBERT MOSER RESIGNED Mayor Otis stated that Robert Moser resigned from his position on the Accommodations Tax Committee to enable him to fill Worth Johnson’s position on the Board of Appeals. Council will consider replacement for this position for the next Town Council meeting. A-TAX COMMITTEE EXPIRING TERMS – DECEMBER 9, 2016 – WENDELL CANTRELL, DAVID TEEMS, CORRINE TAYLOR Mayor Otis stated that all three individuals, Wendell Cantrell, David Teems and Corinne Taylor, have been very active members to the A-tax Committee and recommends that they be approved to serve another term. Sarah Zimmerman made a motion to approve Wendell Cantrell, David Teems and Corinne Taylor to another term on the A-tax Committee pending their willingness to serve. Ashley Carter seconded. All in favor. PLANNING COMMISSION EXPIRING TERMS – DECEMBER 9, 2016 – ED FOX Mayor Otis stated that Ed Fox has been a very active member on the Planning Commission and recommends that he be approved to serve another term. Sarah Zimmerman made a motion to approve Ed Fox to another term on the Planning Commission pending his willingness to serve. Rocky Holliday seconded. All in favor. ACCOMMODATIONS TAX COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS Pawleys Island Beautification Foundation $12,104 (Parks Maintenance) The Accommodations Tax Committee received a request from the P.I. Beautification Foundation for $12,104 for maintaining all the parks on the island. Town of Pawleys Island $157,135.04 (Tourism Related Expenses) The Accommodations Tax Committee received a request from the Town for $157,135.04 which is the balance of the funds available. This goes to the Town for tourism related expenses. Sarah Zimmerman made a motion to approve the Accommodations Tax Committees recommendations to give the Pawleys Island Beautification Foundation $12,104 for parks maintenance and $157,135.04 to the Town of Pawleys Island for its tourism related expenses. Mike Adams seconded. All in favor. POLICE REPORT Chief Fanning reviewed the October 2016 police report – See attached. ______________________ Page 3 of 7 November 14, 2016
FINANCIAL REPORT – RECAP OF HURRICANE MATTHEW EXPENSES – DISCUSS INSURANCE, FEMA AND SCDOT REIMBURSEMENT ELIGIBILITY Mayor Otis stated that the total income through October 2017 is $1,028,783 and the budget for the same period is $1,028,210. Total expenses for the month were $62,332 and budget was $63,454. Here was nothing out of the ordinary to comment on. 2016 BUDGET AMENDENTS Town Hall Storm Damage ($11,000) – Ryan Fabbri stated that we created a separate line item for Town Hall related expenses due to the Hurricane to enable us to better track these expenses. We should be reimbursed 100% through our flood insurance and FEMA. Sarah Zimmerman made a motion to approve amending the 2016 Budget to include the new line item Town Hall/Storm Damage for $11,000. Rocky Holliday seconded. All in favor. Street Maintenance ($50,500) - Ryan Fabbri stated that this was the cost for Goodson to remove the sand and debris from Springs Avenue, with some James Snow debris removal as well. We should be reimbursed 100% from SCDOT. Sarah Zimmerman made a motion to approve amending the 2016 Budget by increasing Street Maintenance by $50,500. Mike Adams seconded. All in favor. Beach Management ($78,000) – Ryan Fabbri reported that this is Goodson’s billing for moving debris from the beach which has already been paid. It also includes labor for James Snow for removing beach debris. The quote from SDR for removing beach debris was $350,000 and Goodson did it for $20,000. The amount also includes the cost of rebuilding beach access walkways. We rebuilt the First Street walkover the same way as it was, but on Davis Drive we did a walkover that went over the large dune. We still have to rebuild the Hazard Street and Pritchard Street walkovers. We would like to keep Pritchard Street the way it was to enable the 4-wheeler to have access to the beach, but he would like to do a walkover similar to Davis Drive for the Hazard Street access. Council agreed. We should be reimbursed approximately 75% from FEMA. Sarah Zimmerman made a motion to approve amending the 2016 Budget by increasing the Beach Management line item by $78,000. Mike Adams seconded. All in favor. Beach Renourishment ($325,000) – This is for the 3 invoices for Goodson that have already been paid. This also includes our agreement with Coastal Science & Engineering for a total not-to-exceed amount of $17,600 that Council previously agreed to, however, once we got started things happened that we did not plan on such as the Corps of Engineers halting the cleanup work being done on the south end as they said we needed another permit. CSE went above and beyond what they needed to do to get us moving by the next day. We should be reimbursed approximately 75% from FEMA. Sarah Zimmerman made a motion to approve amending the 2016 Budget by increasing the Beach Renourishment line item by $325,000. Mike Adams seconded. All in favor. 2017 BUDGET – FIRST READING Ryan Fabbri stated that the revenue section is pretty much the same as 2016 but included in the grant section is reimbursement for storm damage from Juaquin. In the expense section computer-administration includes the cost for I-pads for all council members if Council will use them instead of paper. This will eliminate excess paperwork as all the information for each council meeting will be on the I-pads, which will be property of the Town. Election expense will be needed for 2017. Professional Accounting has increased – there is a new contract from Harper, Poston and Moree for the next 3 years auditing. Professional FEMA has gone up to cover hiring
Lisa Jones as a consultant to help us with reimbursement from FEMA for the cost of replacing our Town Hall. ______________________ Page 4 of 7 November 14, 2016 Ordinance Review & Revision increased as we will have the new flood maps and will have to revise and adopt our flood ordinance’s with the help of WRCOG. Rent increased because of the mobile trailer that we will be using in 2017. Capital Outlay – PD will be for purchasing body cameras and a mobile generator with an attached light tower. Estimated cost for Underground Wire is $8,000, we have paid Santee completely and this is for miscellaneous costs. Rocky Holliday discussed that one of the best things we could do for our property owners is to fix drainage problems as we did on the north-end of Myrtle Avenue. Mayor Otis stated that once you fix something that the Highway Department is responsible for it becomes yours, but when Ryan hired an engineer to look at the problem, and Ryan has something from an engineer to show the Highway Department what needs to be done, they seem to be more responsive to correcting the problem. A program to do that with our drainage system would be a good thing to have. Council agreed. Ryan created a new section called “Town Hall” with line items for design, construction and miscellaneous. Beach Renourishment was increased for an aggressive program to establish an engineered beach depending on the recommendations of the Beach Committee. Everything else is pretty much the same as 2016. Mayor Otis stated that this is a “best guess” budget as there are so many things that are not certain as a result of Matthew, including possible FEMA reimbursements, so there will probably be more amendments by December, and Council will also probably need to amend it in 2017 as things become clearer. Sarah Zimmerman made a motion to approve 1st reading of the 2017 budget. Rocky Holliday seconded. All in favor. BUILDING REPORT Mayor Otis stated that there was nothing unusual in the building report. SIGN ORDINANCE REVISION, PLANNING COMMISSION – SUPREME COURT DECISION Mayor Otis asked for a motion to turn the Sign Ordinance revision over to the Planning Commission for analysis under the recent Supreme Court decision and revision as necessary. Sarah Zimmerman made a motion to turn the Sign Ordinance revision over to the Planning Commission for analysis under the recent Supreme Court decision and revision as necessary. Mike Adams seconded. All in favor. Mayor Otis stated that it would be good to let the Planning Commission know what Council has decided about the new Town Hall and get their thoughts and input as we go forward. ADMINISTRATORS REPORT Status of Post Hurricane Debris Cleanup – Ryan Fabbri reported that there is one truck that is dedicated to the island by the DOT Contractor. There are 7 trucks now working the entire county to pick up debris on the roadsides. We are having James Snow supplement the contractor to do debris cleanup. They have both been working everyday cleaning up. The debris in the creek will be the last priority unless it is a hazard. The remaining sand that is on private property is up to the individual property owners to get it cleared out. Mayor Otis stated that this subject is addressed in the last Tides and it’s on the website. Springs Street property owners should push the sand to the beach side of their property onto the backside of the dune. We no longer have equipment to move sand off the road sides. It was agreed that the Creekside property owners should move their excess sand to the beachside of the public accesses. The Town’s insurance
company has said that we are not insured for anything that our contractor does on private property. Status of Temporary Town Hall – Ryan Fabbri reported that the temporary Town Hall trailer will be delivered this Thursday. At that time we will return the U-haul trailer which has cost the Town $25 a day. ______________________ Page 5 of 7 November 14, 2016 Status of Underground Wire Project – Ryan Fabbri reported that Santee Cooper wants to do a south end walk through tomorrow, and that their contractor will not have the ability to use the south lot for their staging until it is opened. The north end contractor will resume work in approximately 2 weeks. Community Outreach – “Reducing Flood Insurance Premium:” – Wednesday December 16, 6-8 pm at Georgetown VFW – Ryan Fabbri stated that there is a group that was formed in the City of Georgetown to develop a program for public information and we will get CRS points for it. It will be a public outreach event at the VFW in Georgetown hosted by a company called Smart Vent. Something will be mailed out to property owners to let them know when they can attend. COMMENTS BY COUNCIL MEMBERS Mayor Otis stated that he received two letters commending the Pawleys Island Police Department. One letter by Louise Reeve commended Officer Tracie Milligan for her professionalism, kindness and sensitivity during their recent visit to Pawleys Island when her husband had a serious stroke. Tracie drove this woman to the hospital as she had difficulty driving. This woman stated that what Tracie did was above and beyond what was expected. The next letter was from Dr. Inscore that talked about his daughter and grandchildren’s visit to Pawleys south-end beach. While parked in the parking lot someone struck his daughter’s vehicle causing several hundred dollars worth of damage. She reported it to the Pawleys Island Police Department and she said that Chief Fanning and Officer Fairfield had identified the culprit and got the culprit to finally confess. Mayor Otis stated that in the last Tides we once again asked our property owners to supply their email addresses to the Town. Our inability to contact owners after Hurricane Juaquin for permission to build their dunes almost resulted in the town not being granted permits for beach scraping and dune rebuilding. We have not had many replies to that continued request. Also, all council members email addresses are on the Town website and every issue of the Pawleys Tides includes the home telephone number of council members. Property owners have been directed to the Town website and to the Town Facebook page for town information. These sites also refer to Twitter for information. Since October 6th to last week there have been over 125 Town posts on the Town website, face-book and twitter sites referring to Hurricane Matthew. During this period there were a number of interactions with property owners and others, particularly on Twitter, and photos and videos of the storm and the aftermath. After Joaquin, and the repairs to the beach, we again asked for email addresses. In August the Town hired an individual to help the administrator select an appropriate data base program to program it and input all the existing owners’ information. Part of this process is to establish an email blast system so the Town can provide up to date information to owners; particularly in emergency situations. The data base has been completed as of last Friday and is cloud based. It will need to be proofed to be sure it works correctly. To date the Town has only about 50% of homeowner email addresses due to the lack of response from our homeowners. When the data base is proofed and ready to go we will send a test message to our email list as it now stands to identify out of date or bad addresses.
The entire history of the Town has been based on the premise included in the Mission Statement adopted by Council in 2003, “to deliver basic service levels in law enforcement, including the protection of lives and property, building and zoning including basic public works, and the efficient, courteous and simple administration of Town Government.” The town has followed this mission, and through 2016 the Town of Pawleys Island has not levied a property tax on its property owners. This contrasts with 9 other ocean-front municipalities in South Carolina and the 21 ocean-front municipalities in North Carolina. All of which have property taxes. ______________________ Page 6 of 7 November 14, 2016 The Town does have a state accommodations tax paid by renters, which helps finance some of the Town’s tourism related expenses, and a local accommodations tax which has built a $5 million dollar fund for beach protection and maintenance. If the Town had not quickly passed our ordinance a number of years ago, those accommodations tax dollars would have gone to Georgetown County when they passed one for the County. We are now faced with 4 basic challenges that the Town is going to have to address going forward: The loss of our historic Town Hall and the need to replace it. The Council will need to study its size, taking into consideration the long range planning and staffing needs of the town, while continuing to be true to the Mission Statement. The damages to our beach from Hurricanes Juaquin and Matthew, and decisions on repair and renourishment, including the financing of the results of those decisions, The ability of the Town to continue and improve the FEMA CRS rating, which saved 420 property owners $388,000 in federal flood insurance premiums this past year, or an average of $923 per property owner The apparent desire of some property owners to increase the service levels of the Town. Mayor Otis again gave credit to Administrator, Ryan Fabbri, Town Clerk, Diane Allen and Chief Michael Fanning who are the entire staff of the Town, there are no other departments. Thanks again to each of our full time and part time police officers who went on 12 hour shifts before the storm, and continued these shifts until October 17th. All of these folks put in many extra hours to pull the Town back together, under difficult circumstances and in cramped space without facilities or direct phone or internet service for much of the time. The Town has come a long way since October 8th. The Town is in business, Police protection has been maintained, Springs Avenue has been cleared of sand and debris and is open, the beach has been cleaned of storm debris, 17,000 lineal feet of dune protection has been pushed up protecting our houses and infrastructure, and road right of way debris clearing, first pass, has progressed from Springs Avenue toward the north end of the island. We members of Town Council fully appreciate the progress that has been made, with the hard work and dedication of the staff and officers, and their continued efforts on behalf of Pawleys Island and our property owners.
Sarah Zimmerman made a motion to adjourn. Mike Adams seconded. All in favor. ___________________________________ ____________________ APPROVED DATE ____________________________________ ____________________ ATTEST DATE ______________________ Page 7 of 7 November 14, 2016
Source: Town of Pawleys Island website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.