RecordWell Data

Zoning Board of Appeals — Agenda Packet

City of Beaufort · Beaufort County · Zoning Board of Appeals · meeting of Nov 18, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Beaufort

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

MEETING AGENDA The City of Beaufort ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS Wednesday, November 18, 2026, 5:30 P.M. City Hall, Council Chambers, 2nd Floor – 1911 Boundary Street, Beaufort, SC Please click the link below to access the webinar: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/82683873197?pwd=46wLZRH7CFYeeaAhVd8MUkzcLwoywB.1 Passcode: 338255 Meeting ID: 826 8387 3197 Call in Phone #: 1+929 205 6099 STATEMENT OF MEDIA NOTIFICATION: “In accordance with South Carolina Code of Laws, 1976, Section 30-4-80(d), as amended, all local media were duly notified of the time, date, place, and agenda of this meeting.” Please note, this meeting will be broadcast via zoom and live-streamed on YouTube. You can view the meeting at the City's page; City of Beaufort Government ____________________________________________________________________________________ I. Call to Order II. Pledge of Allegiance III. FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT COMPLIANCE Public Notification of the Zoning Board of Appeals meeting has been published in compliance with the Freedom of Information Act requirements. IV. Review of Minutes: A. Minutes of the April 27, 2026 Meeting B. Minutes of the June 22, 2026 Meeting V. Review of Projects: A. 807 Bladen Street identified as R120 004 000 329A 0000, Variance Applicant: Mark Sutton The agent, Mark Sutton, for the owner, Jessica Mittel, is requesting a variance from Section 2.4.1.B.3 for 807 Bladen Street in order to add a new screened -in porch to the rear of the existing home. The property is further identified as R120 004 000 329A 0000. VI. Adjournment Zoning Board of Appeals Meeting Minutes – April 27, 2026 CALL TO ORDER 2:08 A meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals was held in-person on April 27, 2026 at 5:30 p.m. ATTENDEES Members in attendance: Kenneth Hoffman, Chairman, Marc Sviland, Vice-Chairman, and Zach Graber. Me mbers absent: Patrick McMichael, and Parker Moore. St aff in attendance: Curt Freese, City of Beaufort Community Development Director, and Nick Navia, City of Beaufort Community Development Planner I. REVIEW OF MINUTES – MARCH 23, 2026 3:34 Motion: Mr. Sviland made a motion, seconded by Mr. Graber, to approve the March 23, 2026 as submitted. The motion passed unanimously. All Zoning Board of Appeals meeting minutes are recorded and can be found on the City’s website at http://www.cityofbeaufort.org/AgendaCenter. APPLICATIONS 3:58 A. 110 Factory Creek Court, identified as R123 015 00A 0782 0000, Appeal Applicant: James Mead Th e applicant is requesting an Appeal from an order of Section 3.6.2.C.2.j for 110 Factory Creek Landing in order to continue to operate a Short-Term Rental. The property is further identified as R123 029 015 0782 0000. Curt Freese presented the staff report. Public Comment Co oter Ramsey resides at 112 Factory Creek Court, next door to the applicant. He sated he is in favor of the applicant having a short-term rental. Mr. Ramsey built the first house back in the development back in 2002 and his house is the only one without a ground level unit. DRAFT Michelle Hipp resides at 104 Factory Creek Court and owns the lot next to her at 106 Factory Creek Court. She referred to the Affidavit that was sent to the Zoning Board of Appeal (ZBOA) Members that was signed by her and the other Board Members that were duly elected on November 18, 2025. There was a special meeting held for the first time in 8 years with all of the homeowners and the property owners to put together a true Homeowner’s Property Association. This meeting was held at her home with some members who attended in-person and some members attended via Zoom. At that time, some of the members had resigned including Michael Spaulding had been volunteering as the president since 2017-2018. Mr. Spaulding designated Ms. Hipp as his proxy for any election to take place. We had no bylaws at this point to rely on. Roberta DeLoach drafted some bylaws but they never went anywhere. Since then, our Bylaws have been adopted and recorded with the help of an attorney from Bluffton SC. Zaven Yourelian 102 Factory Creek Court, said he has managed HOAs and POAs throughout the country. Mr. Spaulding was previously elected President, but Mr. Yourelian became President as of this February. He stated the board has been active and overseeing the community. During that time, the association has consistently collected dues, paid taxes, and engaged professional management through Bundy Management to support the operations. When this was started, there were only four homes. In the beginning, Mr. Mead did not have a permit for his rental. There are not any short-term rentals in any of the single family residences. The majority of the Board is against it. Tom Danniels resides at 121 South Hermitage Road. He owns the Lady’s Island Marina and the largest portions of the lots within the development. He was not present for the interim board election since he did not know about it. He understands that a change cannot be made to the existing bylaws or covenants without a majority vote of which is 75%. He holds the most number of votes. Mr. Daniels stated he’s not against the idea of somebody wanting to generate money out of their property, but it’s against the rules based upon what he thought when he purchased his property in 2018. He referred to the comment that Cooter Ramsey stated about the homes having ground floors units for renting and said the language was drafter after these were built to prevent this sort of activity. Ben Coppage, City Attorney, stated we all agree that these properties the cottages at Battery Creek are affected by some covenants that were recorded in 2008. It’s been discussed that those covenants require that the residential lots only be used for single-family purpose. Single- family is defined as people who are related or that have a household together. Mr. Coppage referred to the application that applicant, Mr. Mead, signed for the short-term rent and that he did check “no” in the box on the application that read, Pursuant to 6-29-1445 of the South Carolina Code of Laws, is this tract or parcel restricted by any recorded covenants that is contrary to conflict with or prohibits the activity described in this application. Mr. Spaulding contacted Mr. Rose, the City Business License Administrator, letting him know those covenants were in place. Mr. Coppage reviewed the covenants and he found the portion of the covenants that restricted the use of the residential lots for single-family uses. This is why the license has been revoked not because a board or committee said so. Mr. Coppage stated back in 2008 it was Battery Creek Marina Village and the signatory for Battery Creek Marina Village was the was Matt Trumps, member of the LLC. He handed out to the board members and the applicant an Affidavit signed by Matt Trumps. The Affidavit gives Mr. Trumps testimony saying that “the simultaneous use of one of the residential lots as both the primary residence and a short-term- rental would be incompatible with the restriction imposed by the single-family covenant. Individuals who pay for a short-term-rental are not related to the primary residence by blood, DRAFT do not maintain a common household with the primary residence, and because they’re paying for their accommodations, cannot be considered transient guest”. Mr. Coppage request that the Board uphold the decision of the administrator in revoking Mr. Mead’s license. Public comment closed. Motion: Mr. Sviland made a motion, seconded by Mr. Moore, to deny the request and uphold the decision of the City’s administrator. The motion passed unanimously. ADJOURNMENT 1:23:05 Mr. Sviland made a motion to adjourn the meeting. Mr. Moore seconded the motion. The meeting ended at 6:53 pm. DRAFT Zoning Board of Appeals Meeting Minutes – June 22, 2026 CALL TO ORDER 1:14 A meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals was held in-person on June 22, 2026 at 5:30 p.m. ATTENDEES Members in attendance: Marc Sviland, Vice-Chairman, Zach Graber, Patrick McMichael, and Parker Moore. Member absent: Kenneth Hoffman, Chairman. Staff in attendance: Nick Navia, City of Beaufort Community Development Planner II and Christopher Klement, City of Beaufort Community Development Planner III. WELCOME NEW MEMBER 1:14 Mr. Sviland introduced the new Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBOA) board member, Zach Graber, who filled the expired term of Kevin Blank. REVIEW OF MINUTES – APRIL 27, 2026 2:13 Mr. Moore noted under Members in attendance, to replace Kevin Blank with Zach Graber. Also, under Review of Minutes, the motion was made by Mr. Sviland, not Mr. Suter. Mr. Sviland stated the minutes will be corrected by staff and presented at the next ZBOA meeting for approval. All Zoning Board of Appeals meeting minutes are recorded and can be found on the City’s website at http://www.cityofbeaufort.org/AgendaCenter. ELECTION OF VICE-CHAIRMAN 3:04 Mr. Sviland stated his term is expiring and the Board needs to elect a new Vice-Chairman. Motion: Mr. McMichael made a motion to nominate Parker Moore for Vice-Chairman. Mr. Graber seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. APPLICATIONS 3:46 A. 2945 Marshfront Drive, identified as R120 032 000 0613 0000, Appeal Applicant: Jack McSweeney, K. Hovnanian Homes The applicant is requesting an Appeal from an order of 5.2.2.B (2) c for denial of an application for a permit to remove three (3) landmark live oak trees on a platted building lot within the Overlook at Battery Creek subdivision rendering it undevelopable. The property is further identified as R120 032 000 0613 0000. Nick Navia presented the staff report. Public Comment Michael Short, 2037 Satilla Boulevard, lives directly across from the property at 2945 Marshfront Drive. He likes to look at the trees through the window in his study. He asked the Board to deny the request for a waiver to Section 5.2.2.B (2) c of the Municipal Code. He is opposed to the destruction and removal of the live oaks. He also asked the Board to enforce the applicable state, county and city policies, legislation, statutes, regulations, rules, and ordinances designed and enacted to protect our maritime forests, the live oak ecosystems and the grand old legendary trees. He stated three reasons why he is opposed to the request. (1) When the petitioner purchased the land, he knew the State of South Carolina’s policies, legislative intent, laws, and statutes governing this matter. He was also aware of the regulations and rules defining terms of procedures protecting the environment and the tree cover. Lastly, he was cognizant of the city’s ordinance regarding protection of the trees under consideration. (2) After the Petitioner bought the land with the existing trees, he divided the land into 14 lots to build on. He could have drawn the lines to protect the trees by putting them on a lot line or leaving a protected space between two lots as other developers have done in our subdivision. (3) After the designer bought the lot, he started building on the outside and built into the center where this lot is. He feels the petitioner created the problem himself by saying, “this lot is unbuildable the way it is”. Granting this will hurt the adjacent properties and will harm the community’s public good. Donald Thatcher lives a 2927 Marshfront Drive, agreed with Mr. Short. Mr. Thatcher moved to the Overlook because of the trees. Legally, they are protected landmarks and he doesn’t understand why there’s any discussion of ignoring the laws of the protected landmarks. Tom Walsh, 2958 Marshfront Drive, stated he was one of the first persons to purchase a lot in the Overlook. His setbacks were the standards setbacks of 10 feet. We did have beautiful oak trees on the one side of our property. To accommodate building a house, we were allow a 3 foot setback on the side of the property nearest to my home. He feels the opportunity existed for K. Hovnanian Homes to assess whether or not they could change some of these lot lines. Public comment closed. Motion: Mr. Moore made a motion to deny the application for an Appeal. Mr. Moore stated the City of Beaufort is tree City USA and said the standards are clearly defined and this is a situation where proper planning and preparation and assessment could have avoided this problem. Mr. Graber seconded the motion. The motion passed with a vote of 3:1 (Mr. McMichael opposed). ADJOURNMENT 29:36 Mr. Sviland made a motion to adjourn the meeting. Mr. Graber seconded the motion. The meeting ended at 6:59 pm. 807 Bladen Street Variance Request Beaufort Code Section 2.4.1.B.3 STAFF REPORT: ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS (ZBOA) Variance Request DATE: November 18, 2026 1 GENERAL INFORMATION Applicant: Mark W. Sutton (Architect) Site Address / Tax PIN: 807 Bladen Street / PIN: R120 004 000 329A 0000 Applicant's Request: The applicant requests a variance from Beaufort Development Code Section 2.4.1.B.3 to allow a proposed screened-in rear porch to encroach 3 feet into the required 5-foot southern side setback at 807 Bladen Street. The proposed addition would be located approximately 2 feet from the southern property line. Current Zoning: T4-NEIGHBORHOOD DISTRICT (T4-N) Neighborhood Northwest Quadrant Flood Zone/Elevations Flood Zone “X”, Lot Elevation: 23’; [Base Flood Elevation in Beaufort, SC: 13’] Lot size N/A ZONING DISTRICT INFORMATION T4-NEIGHBORHOOD DISTRICT (T4-N) Lot Width at Setback: N/A Max. Lot Coverage: 70% of lot area (area under roof) / 80% total impervious lot coverage Front Setback Primary Buildings: 0 ft min – 15 ft max Accessory Buildings: 5 ft min Side Setback Primary Buildings: Interior: 5 ft min Accessory Buildings : 5 ft min Rear Setback Primary Buildings: 10 ft min Accessory Buildings: 5 ft min SURROUNDING ZONING, LAND USE AND REQUIRED BUFFERS Adjacent Zoning Adjacent Land Uses Setbacks for Adjacent Zoning /Buffer required if rezoned North: T4-N 809 Bladen Street (Residential) N/A South: T4-N 801 Bladen Street (Commercial) N/A East: T4-N 1507 Duke Street (Commercial) N/A West: T4-N 806 Bladen Street (Residential) N/A 2 Background: The applicant requests a variance from Beaufort Development Code Section 2.4.1.B.3 to allow a proposed screened-in rear porch to encroach 3 feet into the required 5-foot southern side setback at 807 Bladen Street. The proposed addition would be located approximately 2 feet from the southern property line. Under Section 2.5.6.D: Encroachments, covered porches are permitted to encroach into required setbacks but must remain at least 5 feet from an interior side or rear property line. The existing residence, known as the Robert Proctor House, was constructed circa 1895 and is a contributing historic structure within the Beaufort Historic District. The residence predates the City's current zoning standards and already encroaches approximately 3 feet into the northern side setback. Under Section 11.1.3.A, contributing historic structures are exempt from the Code's nonconformity provisions. Due to the historic placement of the residence and the existing configuration of the property, the available space for a rear addition that complies with current setback requirements is limited. The applicant therefore requests a variance to accommodate a screened-in rear porch extending into the southern side setback, as illustrated in the site plan below. Variance Requested: The applicant is requesting the following variance: • Section 2.4.1 – Transect-based District Standards – B. Primary Building Placement – 3. Side Setback-Interior – 5 ft min. 3 VARIANCE REVIEW & APPROVAL CRITERIA (IN ACCORDANCE WITH SEC. 9.14.2.F) Required Findings: A variance may be granted by the ZBOA if it concludes that the strict enforcement of any design and performance standard set forth in this Code would result in unnecessary hardship to the applicant, and that by granting the variance, the spirit of this Code will be observed, public welfare and safety will not be diminished, and substantial justice will be done. A variance may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship only when the ZBOA makes, and explains in writing, all of the following findings: 9.14.2.F.1 - Finding of Fact Rationale Present (yes/no) Staff Analysis of Rationale a. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property. For example, the variance is justified because of topographic or other special conditions unique to the property and development involved, in contradistinction to the mere inconvenience or financial disadvantage. Yes  807 Bladen Street, known as the Robert Proctor House, is a contributing historic structure constructed circa 1895. The residence predates the City's current zoning standards and already encroaches approximately 3 feet into the northern side setback. The historic placement of the residence, combined with the property's existing site constraints, limits the available space for a rear addition and creates conditions that are not typical of modern residential development. b. These conditions do not generally apply to other properties in the vicinity. Yes  Although many historic properties have nonstandard setbacks, the combination of building placement, available rear yard space, and site constraints at 807 Bladen Street is not generally applicable to other surrounding properties. c. The conditions are not the result of the applicant's own actions. Yes  The residence was constructed circa 1895, well before the adoption of the City's current zoning standards. The existing building placement and associated setback limitations were established prior to the applicant's ownership and are not the result of the applicant's actions. 4 d. Granting of the variance would not substantially conflict with the Comprehensive Plan, the Civic Master Plan and the purposes and intent of this Code. Yes  The proposed screened-in rear porch represents a modest residential addition to an existing contributing historic structure. The addition would not change the property's residential use or increase its density. Allowing reasonable improvements to existing historic residences, while maintaining their historic character, is consistent with the City's preservation objectives and the general intent of the Beaufort Development Code. e. Because of these conditions, the application of this Code to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property. Yes  The existing residence already encroaches into the northern side setback; however, the property's current configuration prevents the proposed porch from being accommodated on that side. Strict application of the southern side setback would further restrict the limited space available for a rear addition. The requested variance would allow a modest screened-in porch while accommodating the existing historic structure and its established placement on the property. f. The authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or the public good, and the character of the zone will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. Yes  The proposed variance would allow a limited 3-foot encroachment into the required southern side setback for a screened-in rear porch. The addition would maintain the property's existing residential use and would not increase the number of dwelling units. Given the limited scope of the proposal and the established development patterns of the Historic District, Staff does not anticipate a substantial adverse impact on adjacent properties or the character of the district. Limitations: The ZBOA may not grant a variance if it would do any of the following: a. Allow the establishment of a use not otherwise permitted in the applicable district. b. Increase the density of a use above which is permitted in the applicable district. c. Physically extend a nonconforming use of land. d. Change the zone boundaries shown on the Official Zoning Map. 5 Profitability Not to Be Considered: Profitability shall not be considered grounds for a variance! PUBLIC NOTICE AND COMMENT Notice of the Zoning Board of Appeals hearing has been mailed to property owners within 500 feet of the subject property, a legal ad published, and the property was posted as required by the Development Code. FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS Staff Recommendation: Staff recommends APPROVAL of a variance from Section 2.4.1.B.3, to allow a limited encroachment into the south side setback for 807 Bladen Street, due to meeting all of the Findings of Fact requirements.

Source: City of Beaufort website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.