RecordWell Data

County Council Regular Meeting — Minutes

Georgetown County · Georgetown County · County Council · meeting of Feb 9, 2016 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Georgetown County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Georgetown County Council Meeting Minutes February 9, 2016 1 Georgetown County Council held a Regular Council Session on Tuesday, February 9, 2016, at 5:30 PM in County Council Chambers located in the old Georgetown County Courthouse, 129 Screven Street, Georgetown, South Carolina. Present: Austin Beard Leona Miller Ron L. Charlton Johnny Morant Steve Goggans John Thomas Lillie Jean Johnson Staff: Sel Hemingway Theresa E. Floyd Wesley P. Bryant Jackie Broach Other staff members, members of the public, and representatives of the media were also present. In accordance with the Freedom of Information Act, a copy of the agenda was sent to newspapers, television, and radio stations, citizens of the County, Department Heads, and posted on the bulletin board located in the lobby of the historic Courthouse. Chairman Johnny Morant called the meeting to order. Vice Chairman Ron Charlton gave an invocation, followed by the pledge of allegiance. APPROVAL OF AGENDA: A request was made to move reports 15a and 15b recognizing volunteers forward on the agenda to immediately follow the agenda’s approval. Councilman Ron Charlton moved for approval of the meeting agenda, as amended. Councilwoman Leona Miller seconded the motion. Chairman Morant called for discussion on the motion, and no discussion occurred. In favor: Austin Beard Leona Miller Ron L. Charlton Johnny Morant Steve Goggans John Thomas Lillie Jean Johnson PUBLIC COMMENTS: Robert Plowden General Robert Plowden stated that as the former Chairman of Georgetown County’s Visions Strategic Planning effort, he had seen firsthand a fitting example of how constituents can work together with a governing body for the betterment of all. He spoke in opposition of efforts to change the existing setback for Highway 17, and encouraged County Council to reject changes to something that has worked for over 30 years. He also encouraged the following speakers to be respectful in stating their position on this issue without making it personal. Bob Mimms Mr. Mimms spoke in favor of amending the current setback guidelines for the Highway 17 commercial corridor. As the owner of a business located within the commercial corridor he has a stake in this issue, which affects the Pawleys/Litchfield area, not Murrell Inlet. Property owners are concerned that if their building burned they could not build back within the existing setback. People who are well meaning should have use of their own property. Vida Miller Ms. Miller spoke in favor of amending the current Highway 17 commercial corridor setback requirements. She distributed copies of a petition, signed by 150 residents, who have an Georgetown County Council Meeting Minutes February 9, 2016 2 interest in this issue but could not attend this meeting tonight. She said the existing setbacks were established over 40 years ago, and since that time golf courses have been built on roads that were still dirt back then. As the former Chairperson of the Grand Strand Area Transportation Study (GSATS) Committee, she asked County Council to favorably consider the proposed setback amendments. Wyndell Peacock Mr. Peacock spoke in favor of amending the current setback regulations for the Highway 17 commercial corridor. As a land planner, he said the setbacks only affect where a building may be constructed within the buildable area of a lot. This does not have an impact on density. The size of the building is what determines the density, and building size is restricted within other areas of the County’s zoning ordinance. Tom Leis Mr. Leis, a member of the Litchfield Beach Beautician Committee, stated that he was one of the overwhelming number of people opposed to amending the Highway 17 setback requirements. He urged Council members to listen to their constituents, and oppose the setback amendment. Jan Devereaux Ms. Devereaux stated that she owns several buildings within the Highway 17 commercial corridor, and has spent decades working to keep the area looking like “Pawleys Island”. She expressed concern that if her properties were destroyed by fire or natural disaster, she would be restricted from rebuilding within the existing setback regulations, and lose use of the properties. She asked County Council to support amending the current setback guidelines. John Henry Whitmire Mr. Whitmire spoke in support of amending the current 90 ft. setback requirement for the Highway 17 commercial corridor. He said buildings constructed closer to Highway 17 are more aesthetically appealing, as anything further back from Highway 17 simply looks like a parking lot. Julius Blake Mr. Blake stated that he has been a resident of Pawleys Island for 85 years. He said he supports amending the existing ordinance to allow for a 50 ft. setback on Highway 17. Russ Campbell Mr. Campbell spoke in favor of amending the Highway 17 commercial corridor setback requirements. He said the corridor already contains a substantial mixture of setbacks and uses, and the proposed amendment would work toward correcting that over time. Mr. Campbell stated that he has known Councilman Goggans since the 80’s and worked with him on initial drafts of the standards for the original overlay. Resistance to changing the status of the current 90 ft. setback requirement will not result in the attractive community County Council envisions. Mary Erickson Ms. Erickson stated that she has lived in the area for 8 years, although she has been vacationing here for over 30 years. She spoke in opposition of amending the current setback regulations for Highway 17, and urged County Council to keep the setback requirements as they are. Leon Rice Mr. Rice spoke in opposition of changing the existing setback requirements for the Highway 17 commercial corridor. He suggested that County Council “grandfather” in the currently non- Georgetown County Council Meeting Minutes February 9, 2016 3 conforming property owners so they would not be restricted from rebuilding in the unlikely event that their business was destroyed by fire. He said larger setback areas allow for more beautiful landscapes, and urged Council members to heed the letters and emails they have received from their constituents on this issue. Tom Stickler Mr. Stickler stated that he is currently the President of the Waccamaw Neck Council of POA’s, which represents 45 Property Owner Associations and Home Owner Associations. During their last annual meeting the membership overwhelmingly opposed amending the current setback regulations for Highway 17. He encouraged County Council to take the advice of previous speakers and reject the proposal to amend the setbacks. According to calculations he has done, there will be a change in density if the amendments are approved. Karen Yaniga Ms. Yaniga said she was dismayed when she learned of County Council’s reversal of a decision it made just one week earlier to include the issue of Highway 17 setback regulations in a larger corridor study. Although the local community opposes the setback amendments, there may still be merit in including this issue in a bigger study. She added that the owners of homes and businesses that do not meet the existing setback requirements should have their property rights protected, but County Council should address that concern as a separate issue. Dana Arneman Mr. Arnaman said he was in support of amending the current 90 ft. setback regulations to 50 ft. He said the number of businesses that could not rebuild if destroyed because they do not meet the existing setback requirements all have a tremendous impact of Georgetown County’s tax base. Although it is important to promote an aesthetically pleasing corridor, it is more important to support Georgetown County’s local economy. Henry Jobe Mr. Jobe, a resident of Litchfield by the Sea, said people in the room overwhelmingly oppose any proposed amendment to the current setback requirements for Highway 17. He encouraged the Council Chairman to ask any members of County Council who are professionally involved in development, or a related field such as real estate or building, to allow only the board members who do not have a have a conflict of interest to decide this issue. John Kramer Mr. Kramer said he has been a resident of the Waccamaw Neck for over 25 years. He stated that 90% of residents agree that the current setback requirements should stay as they are, and any proposed amendments should be decided by a referendum of the voters, not by just a few. Dick Baughman Mr. Baughman stated the definition of “constituents” as having the voting power to elect. He said the constituents have clearly voiced their opposition to changing the existing 90 ft. setback regulations, and they expect Council members to act accordingly. Mike Redmond Mr. Redmond stated that as a consulting engineer and resident of Pawleys Island for 35 years he was in favor of reducing the 90 ft. setback requirement, not because it would be advantageous to his business, but because changing the current setback requirement would enhance the streetscape. He said buildings located closer to the street are preferable to looking at pavement or a large parking lot. Georgetown County Council Meeting Minutes February 9, 2016 4 Frank Demato Mr. Demato, President of the Tradition Property Owners Association, said he represented 405 single family homes. He said he had listened to the “ridiculous” argument from business owners worried if a catastrophe destroyed their business that they could not rebuild it. He said the customers of these business are the same residents who oppose changing the current 90 ft. setback requirements. He reminded Council members that this was an election year, and the residents have stood in front of them tonight clearly stating “we do not want to change the 90 ft. setback” on Highway 17. Bill Renault Mr. Renault said as a resident of the Tradition for 19 years he had watched the urbanization of the Waccamaw Neck, and it is frightening. He urged County Council to consider grandfathering properties that are currently non-conforming. He asked County Council to listen to the people, and reject proposals to amend the 90 ft. setback requirement. Norman Reid Mr. Reid, President of the Pawleys Island Civic Club, stated that a great local community leader, Mr. Bill Murray recently passed away. Mr. Murray was very instrumental in obtaining donated property and other substantial contributions, and the Parkersville Community Recreation Center was a result of his efforts. Mr. Reid stated that local residents are grateful for all that Mr. Murray had done for the community, and he asked Council’s consideration in placing a plaque and photo of Mr. Murray in the Parkersville Community Recreation Center to honor his memory. Mr. Reid also urged County Council to protect the rights of those homeowners on Highway 17 whose property does not conform to current setback regulations, either by grandfathering them in, or some other solution. David Gundling Mr. Gundling stated that he has resided on the Waccamaw Neck for 40 years, and has owned a business there since 1993. Mr. Gundling read portions of a letter that he had previously emailed to members of County Council from Mr. Goff. Mr. Goff owns property on Highway 17, which does not conform to the current 90 ft. setback requirement. Mr. Gundling stated that Mr. Goff is one of many property owners in this situation. Many of these property owners and property heirs have owned their property on Highway 17 for generations well before the Highway 17 setback requirements were put in place. He said the proposed setback reduction could eliminate some situations where current setback requirements have prohibited property owners from building on their property, which could be viewed as a government “taking”. Rhea Carter Ms. Carter stated that she bought a house at Litchfield Beach and has lived there since 1984. She said she was speaking on behalf of herself and several neighbors in opposition to amending the current 90ft. setback requirement. She said that the Brookgreen property was one of the reasons the local area was beautifully unique, and there were not many green spaces left. She asked County Council to maintain the current setback requirements for Highway 17. Thomas Bevins Mr. Bevins said he has lived and worked as an engineer in Georgetown County and on the Waccamaw Neck for 21 years. He spoke in favor of changing the existing setback requirements. He said there has been discussion that a reduction in the current setback regulations would increase storm water runoff, and this is not accurate information. Georgetown County Council Meeting Minutes February 9, 2016 5 Robert M. Seward Mr. Seward spoke in favor of maintaining the existing setback requirements. He urged County Council to leave the Highway 17 setback at 90 ft., as the issue needs more study. MINUTES: Regular Council Session – January 26, 2016 A motion was made by Councilman Ron Charlton, and seconded by Councilwoman Lillie Jean Johnson for approval of the minutes of the January 26, 2016 council meeting. The Chairman called for discussion on the motion, and there was none. In favor: Austin Beard Leona Miller Ron L. Charlton Johnny Morant Steve Goggans John Thomas Lillie Jean Johnson CONSENT AGENDA: The following reports were included on the Consent Agenda, and therefore approved previously during the meeting: Procurement #15-081, Exterior Architectural Cladding System for Howard Center Renovation- County Council awarded a purchase order to Rainville Carlson Inc. of Annandale, MN for $56,410 (with the Facility Services Division of Public Services performing the installation). Procurement 15-001a, 4-Plane Box Hangar at Swinnie Airport in Andrews, SC – County Council authorized award of a change order to an existing contract with Sellers General Construction for construction of a four plane box hangar at Robert F. Swinnie Airport in Andrews for a total project cost of $250,872 (including base bid and both add/alternative items). Procurement 16-017, Fleet Maintenance Service Truck (Pre-Owned) – County Council authorized the procurement of a pre-owned 2007 Ford F750 Fleet Services Truck with a 5,000 lb. crane, hydraulic air compressor, and Lincoln welder for $62,300 (tax inclusive) from 4M Iron of St. George, SC. PUBLIC HEARINGS: Ordinance No. 2016-03 County Council held a public hearing on Ordinance No. 2016-03, an ordinance to amend Ordinance 2012-47 pertaining to the lease of hangars and other storage facilities at the Georgetown County Airport. There were no public comments, and Chairman Johnny Morant ordered the public hearing closed. Ordinance No. 2016-04 A public hearing was held on Ordinance No. 2016-04, an ordinance to amend the FY2016 Budget Ordinance. There were no public comments pertaining to Ordinance No. 2016-04, and the Chairman closed the public hearing. RESOLUTIONS: Resolution No. 2016-02 Councilman Steve Goggans moved for the adoption of Resolution No. 2016-02 supporting an endeavor by the Georgetown County Economic Development Alliance for the development of a technology park on Pettigru Road in the Waccamaw Neck region of the County. Councilman John Thomas seconded the motion. No discussion followed the motion. Georgetown County Council Meeting Minutes February 9, 2016 6 In favor: Austin Beard Leona Miller Ron L. Charlton Johnny Morant Steve Goggans John Thomas Lillie Jean Johnson ORDINANCES- Third Reading Ordinance No. 2016-03 Councilman Austin Beard moved for third reading approval of Ordinance No. 2016-03, an ordinance to amend Ordinance 2014-27 pertaining to the lease of hangars and other storage facilities at the Georgetown County Airport. Councilwoman Leona Miller seconded the motion. Chairman Morant called for discussion on the motion, and there was none. In favor: Austin Beard Leona Miller Ron L. Charlton Johnny Morant Steve Goggans John Thomas Lillie Jean Johnson Ordinance No. 2016-04 Councilwoman Lillie Jean Johnson moved for third reading approval of Ordinance No. 2016-04, an ordinance to amend the FY2016 Budget Ordinance adopted by Georgetown County. Councilman Austin Beard seconded the motion. Upon a call for discussion on the motion from Chairman Morant, no discussion occurred. In favor: Austin Beard Leona Miller Ron L. Charlton Johnny Morant Steve Goggans John Thomas Lillie Jean Johnson ORDINANCES-Second Reading: Ordinance No. 2015-49 Councilman Steve Goggans moved for second reading approval of Ordinance No. 2015-49, an Ordinance to amend the Georgetown County Zoning Ordinance Article IV, VI, VII and XXI of the Zoning Ordinance to reduce the currently required ninety (90) foot setback on Highways 17 and 701 to fifty (50) feet. Councilwoman Leona Miller seconded the motion. Chairman Morant called for discussion on the motion. Councilman Steve Goggans asked for clarification on related issues prior to moving forward with the vote. Councilman Goggans asked Georgetown County Planning & Code Enforcement Director, Boyd Johnson, if reducing the current setback would change density and what bearing there would be on storm water runoff, light pollution, or other environmental impacts. Mr. Johnson responded that a reduction in the required setback area would change the size of the buildable area, however, when factoring in the County’s other regulations that govern open space requirements and parking regulations, the reduced setback would not cause an increase in density. Additionally, Mr. Johnson said that bigger setbacks contribute to urban sprawl. Councilman Goggans asked if the current right-of-way on Highway 17 was adequate to meet future improvements. Mr. Johnson responded that the current right-of-way would not support a frontage road on Highway 17; however, the road could be widened to support six lanes of traffic within the existing right of way. If the current setback requirements were to be reduced to 50 ft. there would also be an extra 100 ft. of property that could be acquired if necessary. Georgetown County Council Meeting Minutes February 9, 2016 7 Councilman Goggans noted that the current 90 ft. setback requirement has been in place for many years. He asked Mr. Johnson to elaborate on how many variances or exceptions to this requirement have been granted over the years. Mr. Johnson stated that in previous years, if a 50 ft. setback was requested by a property owner, it was typically granted without exception. This was the standard practice, and was not controversial. Later, the County’s Zoning Ordinance was amended to prohibit granting variances to Planned Developments. Councilman Goggans asked if there are currently any planned developments, previously approved, that could receive more buildings within the 50 ft. setback. Mr. Johnson responded that there are opportunities for building within the 50 ft. setback on Highway 17, and named various Planned Developments that have previously authorized commercial components (within a 50 ft. setback). Councilman Goggans questioned if there are many non-conforming residential lots, deemed unbuildable because they do not meet setback requirements. Mr. Johnson said there are properties in this category near the Coachman area of Highway 17. Councilman Goggans questioned how these individuals would seek a variance if a building permit was denied for non- compliance with setback requirements? Mr. Johnson said it was less likely that a standard size lot would be granted a variance, however, smaller lots would have to be allowed some reasonable use of their property, or it could be considered a government “taking”. Councilman Goggans asked Mr. Johnson’s opinion on the potential adoption of an ordinance to grandfather in the non-conforming properties. Mr. Johnson said it was his opinion that an ordinance permitting all properties to rebuild in a non-conforming manner would defeat the purpose of having a 90 ft. setback requirement. Councilman Goggans asked if any other coastal communities currently have a 90 ft. setback requirement in place. Mr. Johnson stated that he was not aware of any. Councilman Goggans said the most admired parts of the Highway 17 corridor are areas with a 50 ft. setback currently in place such as the Oak Lea PUD, Pawleys Business Center PUD, and First Citizens Bank PUD, among others. The reduced setback requirement forces parking to the side and rear or the property, which is much more aesthetically appealing. Councilman John Thomas said that the notion that a reduction in the current setback requirements would not result in an increase in density defies credulity. He said a study of this issue indicated differently, and he provided specific examples: a 3.6-acre parcel next to Crooked Oak Drive would add 50,000 sq. ft. of potential buildable area (a 30% increase in the buildable area); a 2.1-acre parcel next to Martin Luther King Road would add 12,300 sq. ft. of buildable area (15% increase); a 2.7-acre parcel south of Moe’s Barbeque would add 17,800 sq. ft. of buildable area (15% increase); a parcel north of Professional Lane in Pawleys Island would add 11,200 sq. ft. of buildable area (a 10% increase); and 15,300 sq. ft., or 3.35 acres of buildable area, would be added to a 2.5-acre parcel near The Founders Club (a 15% increase in the buildable area). Councilman Thomas said these were only a few examples, and others exist. Councilman Thomas said the property on Highway 17 owned by Mr. Goff, referred to earlier by Mr. Gundling, is a 5,000 sq. ft. parcel that would not be buildable even if the existing setback regulations were amended. He said there has not been enough study on how reducing the setback requirement will affect adjacent neighborhoods, traffic volumes/congestion, storm water runoff, or impacts overall infrastructure. The Grand Strand Area Transportation Study Committee has initiated a study, funded at $100,000, with taxpayer money. The study will provide information regarding transportation and land use planning, as well as pedestrian and transit planning, that Council and staff need before making a policy decision on setbacks. Along Georgetown County Council Meeting Minutes February 9, 2016 8 with providing this necessary information the study will also provide an opportunity for public input. Councilman Steve Goggans moved to amend the motion to refer the issue regarding setback amendments to staff for further study, to include public input, and additional study of landscaping elements. The motion died for lack of a second. Chairman Morant called for the vote on the original motion granting second reading approval of Ordinance No. 2015-49. The vote was as follows: In favor: Steve Goggans Leona Miller Opposed: Austin Beard Johnny Morant Ron L. Charlton John Thomas Lillie Jean Johnson In regards to comments pertaining to non-conforming properties, Chairman Morant assigned staff with the task of researching this issue with the purpose of bringing a recommendation back to County Council (within the next 90 days) on options to best protect non-conforming property owners along the Highway 17 commercial corridor and Highway 17 south. ORDINANCES- First Reading: Ordinance No. 2016-05 – An amendment to the Future Land Use map to redesignate a parcel located on the south side of Grape Drive approximately 145 feet southeast of Reds Landing Road from Low Density Residential to Medium Density Residential. Ordinance No. 2016-06 – To rezone one parcel located on the south side of Grape Drive approximately 145 feet southeast of Reds Landing Road from One-Half Acre Residential (R1/2) to 10,000 Square Feet Residential (MR-10). BIDS: Procurement 16-016 - Murrells Inlet Dredging Project under US Army Corps of Engineers Councilman Austin Beard moved for approval of a Memorandum of Agreement with US Army Corps of Engineers for the Murrells Inlet Dredging Project, and to authorize the issuance of a purchase order to encumber funds for future payments to the US Army Corps – Charleston, in an amount not to exceed the contracted $6,000,000. Councilman John Thomas seconded the motion. Upon a call for discussion from Chairman Morant, no discussion occurred. In favor: Austin Beard Leona Miller Ron L. Charlton Johnny Morant Steve Goggans John Thomas Lillie Jean Johnson REPORTS TO COUNCIL: Recognition – Volunteers of the Year (These reports were presented earlier during the meeting) With the understanding that volunteers are imperative to the operation of certain programs and functions in Georgetown County, and in appreciation of those who give their time and talents to make these programs possible, Georgetown County recognizes both a Volunteer of the Year and an Employee Volunteer of the Year at the end of each calendar year. Georgetown County Council Meeting Minutes February 9, 2016 9 2015 Volunteer of the Year Wil Keith was recognized for being named Georgetown County's Volunteer of the Year for 2015. He has served as Chaplain at Midway Fire Rescue for the past year and a half, and his service has been invaluable. Wil makes every effort to meet with anyone seeking his advice or needing someone to talk to. He arrives on fire/emergency scenes when requested and has proven himself instrumental in helping to calm victims. He goes the extra mile by leaving his card, so victims can contact him again later if needed, and makes sure they know that help is still available, even after the fire trucks and ambulances are gone. Wil also provides counsel and emotional support to first responders, making himself available anytime a crew member needs to talk. When Midway crews answer a call that might take more of an emotional toll than usual on responders, Wil can usually be found standing in the firehouse bay when they return if he was unable to get to the scene. 2015 Employee of the Year Chief Mack Reed was recognized as Georgetown County’s Employee Volunteer of the Year for 2015. Chief Mack Reed has been an employee of Georgetown County since January 1989. Prior to being hired he worked as a volunteer coaching youth football for Georgetown County Parks and Recreation, and served as a youth mentor for over 27 years. Mack Reed is also the founder of the Browns Ferry Booster Club, an organization founded to see that youth in his community could play ball even if their families couldn't afford the registration fee and other associated costs. Mack also transports players who do not have another ride to and from games and practices. In 2015, Mack was head coach of the County's All Stars team for 9-10 year olds and brought his team to victory. Under his leadership, several youths have gone on to play college and even professional ball. Mack's efforts stand out above others because of his passion for the sport, and his love for helping people. Request for Site Plan Review – Multi-family Development located in Murrells Inlet A motion was made by Councilman John Thomas, and seconded by Councilman Steve Goggans, to approve a request from Tim Harris of ASI Engineers, as agent for Coastal Ventures of Murrells Inlet for site plan review of a 25-unit multi-family development located at the corner of Melton Avenue and Highway 17 business in Murrells Inlet (TMS #41-0105-030-01-00). In favor: Austin Beard Leona Miller Ron L. Charlton Johnny Morant Steve Goggans John Thomas Lillie Jean Johnson DEFERRED OR PREVIOUSLY SUSPENDED ISSUES: County Council deferred action on Ordinance No. 2015-30, an amendment to Article VI, Section 631, and Flexible Design District to address density issues (This issue was previously referred by County Council to the Planning Commission for further review) EXECUTIVE SESSION: Councilman Ron Charlton made a motion to move into Executive Session to discuss an economic development matter. Councilman John Thomas seconded the motion. There was no discussion on the motion. Georgetown County Council Meeting Minutes February 9, 2016 10 In favor: Austin Beard Leona Miller Ron L. Charlton Johnny Morant Steve Goggans John Thomas Lillie Jean Johnson County Council moved into Executive Session at 7:37 PM. OPEN SESSION: As Open Session resumed at 8:08 PM, Chairman Morant stated that County Council received a legal briefing related to economic development during Executive Session. No decisions were made, and no votes were taken by County Council during execution session. As there was no further business to come before County Council, Chairman Morant moved to adjourn the meeting at 8:09 PM. _________________________________ Date __________________________________ Clerk to Council

Source: Georgetown County website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.