RecordWell Data

Planning Commission Meeting — Minutes

Lancaster County · Lancaster County · Planning Commission · meeting of Jul 15, 2025 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Lancaster County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

MEMBERS OF LANCASTER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION JASON CAVALIER , DISTRICT 1 T. YOKIMA CURETON , DISTRICT 2 LYNETTE HINSON , DISTRICT 3 JUDIANNA TINKLENBERG , DISTRICT 4 MICHELLE RICHARDS , DISTRICT 5 SHEILA HINSON , DISTRICT 6 FRANCES LIU, DISTRICT 7 SECRETARY : VACANT MINUTES Lancaster County Planning Commission July 15, 2025, 6:00 p.m. Amended 9/16/2025 The meeting was delayed due to malfunctioning AV equipment. As no Livestream was available, the meeting has backup audio recording only. Chairman Cavalier called the meeting to order at 6:10 p.m. 1. Roll Call: Quorum is present (6 Commissioners) Commissioners Present: Jason Cavalier, Dist. 1 Judianna Tinklenberg, Dist. 4 T. Yokima Cureton, District 2 Michelle Richards, Dist. 5 Lynette Hinson, District 3 Sheila Hinson, Dist. 6 Frances Liu, Dist. 7 Absent: __Frances Liu__________________ Staff Present: Allison Hardin, Development Services Dir. Corey Barnes, Planner Matthew Blaszyk, Planner Kirsten Willis, Planner Jennifer Bryan, Planning Technician (Acting secretary) The following press were notified of the meeting by email in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act: The Lancaster News, Kershaw News Era, The Rock Hill Herald, The Fort Mill Times, Cable News 2, Channel 9, and the local Government Channel. The agenda was also posted in the lobby of the County Administration Building for the required length of time and was published on the County website. THE FOLLOWING IS A SUMMARY OF PROCEEDINGS. IT IS NOT A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT. Prayer and Pledge of Allegiance…………………………..T. Yokima Cureton 2. APPROVE AGENDA: See Attached Statement By Commissioner Tinklenberg Chairman Cavalier called for a motion to approve the Agenda. Commissioner Tinklenberg moved to add officer Elections to the agenda, seconded by T. Yokima Cureton. Chairman Cavalier stated that Elections could not be added to an agenda without 24 hours notice. 2 Development Services Director Allison Hardin concurred, and stated that they could be added to the August agenda. She noted that the County Attorney had been consulted on the matter, and that the February elections were adequate. Commissioner Tinklenberg objected: she had asked at the previous meeting if the February elections were interim terms, and was told they were, which would mean that technically those terms would be over. Director Hardin stated that staff would research the matter and provide a full response to address the question at the next meeting. Commissioner Tinklenberg asked that the record indicate that the future election should be limited to those in attendance tonight. Director Hardin stated that staff would review Roberts Rules of Order to determine if that restriction was possible. Commissioner Cureton stated that she had researched SC State Code 6.29.30 through 6.29.380 and 34.80, and since we didn’t talk about any changes or omissions [stet] she doesn’t understand why we are not voting tonight. She has been on the Board for two years and elections have always been held in July. Director Hardin responded that during the history of the Planning Commission, the time for elections has varied in practice from January to July. She noted that matters concerning elections of officers were not in the state code section 6.29.30 or 6.29.80, but in the section that covers Freedom of Information Act [“FOIA”], which states what can and cannot be added to an agenda and when. The County Attorney can provide a workshop on Freedom of Information Act requirements. Commissioner Cureton stated that she would welcome a workshop on FOIA. When she started she was given information about code requirements but nothing about FOIA. Commissioner Tinklenberg stated that she wanted to note that she felt really uncomfortable with the proceedings as they created the appearance that we look incompetent, and she is embarrassed to be sitting here because we are “setting the illusion of mistrust and not being transparent, it doesn’t sit right.” She has been on the Board longer than everyone present except Miss Hinson, and it [the elections] have always been in July. She finds it “interesting” that the recordings of July meetings are not on the website. 1 She stated that “she knows from oftentimes having to correct our records that looking back at the records might not be the most accurate place to look for that information.” 1 All July recordings were on the County website at the time of this meeting. Link to Audio/Video of 7/16/2024 Planning Commission Meeting Part 1. Link to Audio/Video of 7/16/2024 Planning Commission Meeting Part 2. The July 2024 meeting was held at the Sheriff’s Department due to elevator maintenance at the County Administration Building. Link to Livestream recording of 7/18/2023 Planning Commission meeting. Link to Livestream recording of 7/19/2022 Planning Commission meeting. Link to Livestream recording of 7/20/2021 Planning Commission meeting. Link to Livestream recording of 7/21/2020 Planning Commission meeting. Livestream recordings began in April 2020. Audio recording of this meeting (July 15, 2025) was posted on July 16, 2025. 3 She states that “it is disrespectful for us [Commissioners] to volunteer our time, often weekly, for Planning Commission stuff and to not be given the common courtesy of a phone call, of a text message, of an email from anyone on the staff or even our sitting chairman to let us know this isn’t happening tonight. It feels very blindsided, and it’s embarrassing to be a part of this Commission.” Director Hardin apologized for any “uncomfortableness” felt, and indicated that since . the packet is distributed a week before the meetings, Commissioners have eight days notice of agenda items. She indicated that information is pulled from the minutes, which is the official record of the Planning Commission meetings. She thanked Commissioner Tinklenberg for her comments and pledged to take them into consideration. “It’s never our intention to be anything other than transparent, I hate that you don’t feel that we are, and I’ll be happy to talk with you offline about ways that I can make you more comfortable with this process.” Commissioner Tinklenberg: Thank you for your kind words. Chairman Cavalier: Ms. Hardin, before you take your seat could you please give us some guidance on how to withdraw the motion that was made. Director Hardin: I don’t think it was a motion, it was a question -I would ask Commissioner Tinklenberg to restate as a motion. If there was a motion and a second, then vote up or down. Commissioner Cureton asked to amend the June 16 minutes. The Chair deferred the question to the minutes discussion. Director Hardin recommended that the Chair start over with a request for a motion for the agenda. Motion to Approve by Sheila Hinson; 2 nd by Shelly Richards. Called vote: 6:0. Motion approved unanimously. Frances Liu absent. 3. APPROVE MINUTES a. June 17, 2025 Regular Minutes Chairman Cavalier called for a motion to approve June 17, 2025 Regular Minutes as written. Motion to amend page 12 of the minutes, to add context for her discussion of mobile homes by T. Yokima Cureton. She will submit the amendment in writing. 2 nd by Judianna Tinklenberg. After procedural discussion, Ms. Cureton withdraws her motion, and makes a motion to deny the minutes. 2 nd by Judianna Tinklenberg. Called vote: 5:1. (J. Cavalier dissents.) Motion approved, minutes denied. Commissioner Cureton will provide written amendment to statements in the minutes, and the amended minutes will be placed on the August 19, 2025 agenda for approval. Amendment should be submitted by August 5th. 4 b. Workshop Minutes No Workshop was held for the month of July 4. CITIZEN’S COMMENTS [see Sign-In sheet attached] None signed in. Chairman Cavalier opened the floor to comments from the public. As none had signed in for general comments, the Chairman closed the floor. 5. PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS FOR RECOMMENDATIONS TO COUNCIL a. TA-2025-1306 MUSC/Lowes Application by Keith Corp./MUSC Health and MDI Management LLC/Lowes Foods for amendments to Unified Development Ordinance Sec. 10.3 Definitions and Sec. 7.4.5 Signage Standards. Staff Presentation: Allison Hardin, Development Services Director, (in the absence of the Planning Director) presented the application consistent with the staff report [amended copy of the report and the application attached hereto]. This amendment is similar to the Costco amendment made in 2023. Staff Recommendations: Concern about addition to MX district, as that can include Neighborhood Business. No issue with definitions supplied by applicant. Comment from applicant(s): Sam Walker (MUSC, Charlotte NC); Grant Wiley (architects, Charleston SC) Dave Kopenay (Lowes Foods, Tega Cay SC) Mr. Walker: Recommending proportional signage for the size of the building; the key difference is, we are trying to guard against future misuse of the new definition by carefully defining Regional Hospital Facility (minimum 25 inpatient hospital rooms, 50,000 sf of gross area). [see attached slide presentation]. Request that signage totals exclude federally required signs. Mr. Kopenay: We are also asking for proportional signage; not only for size of building, but also distance from highway. This site sits down below grade, with 4 out-lots in front of us, making it difficult to develop visible signage. The MX district where we are located has a stricter signage policy. [see attached slide presentation]. They use the 198-sq foot sign for all of their stores. The additional footage is to allow for secondary signs. Questions from Commissioners: Jason Cavalier: My information says 400 square feet for the hospital, and 250 for the shopping center. Are any of those lit? Mr. Kopenay: Ours are internally illuminated channel letters. 5 Jason Cavalier: I thought I read in here somewhere that they were asking for 400 sf for the grocery, and 250 sf for the hospital. Director Hardin: What’s happened is a section was copied and pasted from GB section that applies to hospital and inserted in the MX section. MX zones allow 50 sf because they are walkable neighborhoods, so they added MX to the list. Staff would not support the whole hospital package for MX. If you decide you want more information, we can bring that back. Mr. Walker: We are willing to strike the hospital provisions from MX, if that makes a difference for approval. Jason Cavalier: If you’re going to have lit signs, how does that impact our current lighting standards? Director Hardin: It will be [reviewed] under the current lighting standards until such time as the new UDO is done, anything after that would meet the new standards- dark sky provisions, down-angle lighting, warm vs. cool lighting. Current standards do require down-angle lighting. Jason Cavalier: Is there currently a restriction on the height of lighted signage? Director Hardin: We do not have a restriction on lit signage in particular; we do restrict location in that it can’t go above the parapet or the top of the building. Jason Cavalier: Do we have a count of how many stores that would fit into this description, that could go out and change their sign? Director Hardin: We can get you that information. Shelly Richards: In some places you refer to “Large Scale Grocery” and others “Large Scale Retailer.” That’s two different things. Mr. Kopenay: “Large Scale Retailer” is what you approved in 2023. That’s the existing policy, carved out for 100,000 sf designation. Lynette Hinson: So this will apply to neighborhood business- how will that apply? Please clarify. Director Hardin: The way it’s written, it would apply to all the MX districts, and Institutional which is church and school zones, civic uses; and Neighborhood Business is the smallest form of business use. We include it in MX because they are sometimes neighborhoods. NB includes uses like salons, utilities, event and banquet halls, recreation facilities, day care, studios. But it would have to meet the definition of 50,000 sf. Mr. Walker: That is why we are asking for proportional signage, the large sign only applies to businesses that meet the size definition. 6 Mr. Kopenay: That 50,000 sf definition is a very small group. Public Hearing: (See attachments: Sign-in Sheets) None signed in. Chairman Cavalier closed Public hearing and called for a motion on item TA-2025- 1306. Commissioner Cureton: I would like to have more information; a list of Neighborhood Businesses that will be affected, so that we don’t make a decision on the fly. Chairman Cavalier: So, a Motion to Continue? Motion to continue to August 19, 2025 by Y. Cureton; 2 nd by J. Tinklenberg. Discussion: Jason Cavalier: I would also be interested in what Federal requirements for hospital signage; how the square footage requirement is applied; the height of lighted signs; and how roadside placards and signage figure in. Called vote: 6:0. Motion is approved unanimously. The item is continued to August 19, 2025. b. RZ-2025-1514 Kershaw Zoning Corrections Group of properties sponsored by the Town of Kershaw Administration: properties did not receive zoning designation at time of incorporation into the Town of Kershaw. • TM # 0156O-0J-003.00: 0.966 acres at Hamel St, owned by Joan Clyburn per Db 1135/p183, from unzoned “City” to B3 General Commercial. • TM #0159A-0J-004.00: 1.8 acres at 167 Shop Rd owned by Kershaw Hardware & Supply LLC per Db 1878/p. 334, from unzoned “City” to B3 General Commercial. • TM #0156O-0J-006.00: 0.66 acres as 111 Jones St, owned by Robert Adcock per Db 1234/p 89, from unzoned “City” to R15 moderate density residential. • TM # 0156P-0C-001.00: 0.76 acres at 202 S. Hampton St owned by Norfolk Southern RR Corporation per Db I-G/p. 38, from unzoned “City” to B1 Central Business. • TM #0156I-0F-007.00: 0.96 acres at 305 E. Church St., owned by Willard & Patricia Dennis per Db 802/p. 167, from unzoned “City” to R6 high density residential Staff Presentation: Jennifer Bryan, Planning Technician, presented the applications consistent with the staff report. Staff Recommendation: Approval of administrative action by Kershaw Town Council Questions from Commissioners: none. Yokima Cureton: Does our Kershaw representative have [a comment]? Sheila Hinson: The Town just wants to get it right, I’m sure the County is jumping up and down. 7 J. Bryan: Kershaw is getting ready to update their UDO and Comprehensive Plan, as we are doing, and they’re paving the way by taking care of these errors. Lynette Hinson: To make sure I understand: all of them are smaller parcels, everything that is being written in is consistent with what is already zoned. J Bryan: Yes. None of the uses have changed, and all of the requested base zoning is to conform to the current use and what is around it. Public Hearing: (See attachments: Sign-in Sheets) None signed in. Chairman Cavalier closed Public hearing and called for a motion on item RZ-2025-1514 Motion to approve by Y. Cureton; 2 nd by S. Hinson. Discussion: No further discussion. Called vote: 6:0. Motion is approved unanimously. France Liu absent. The item will go to Kershaw Town Council for consideration, and applicant will be notified of time and date. 6. PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS FOR PLANNING COMMISSION DECISION a. SD-2024-1442 Shadow Moss Application by Prestige Development & Site Works LLC and Michael McCarter for a Preliminary Plat for 52.235 acres located off Hilldale Drive (TM-0080-00- 033.00) to develop a 100-lot single family residential community (aka Shadow Moss) Matthew Blaszyk, Planner: Applicant requests to defer to the September Planning Commission meeting. Director Hardin: They are asking for time to correct the items identified in the Technical Review. Judianna Tinklenberg: I don’t have a problem with the deferral, but if there are citizens who have come to speak tonight, if there are things they want us to know about it, then I think we should listen to them. Director Hardin: You can take their input today, and defer it; but if you intend to take an action today it would have to be yes or no, not conditional. Jason Cavalier: So if we take public comments, we have to vote today? Director Hardin: No; you can hear public comment, but if you are going to take action rather than allow the deferral request, the decision has to be made tonight based on the existing plan, not proposed revisions, and staff would recommend denial based on technical review comments. Comment from applicant(s): We would like to defer to the September meeting. 8 Public Hearing: (See attachments: Sign-in Sheets) 1. Sandra Sikorski: (Emma Circle, Lancaster) near Hilldale. The information I have was given to me by another citizen. The new development will distress all the resources in the area. As a neighbor I do not want to see 100 new units there. Trees and wildlife will be destroyed. I purchased my home in an area that is not in the city. I do not want to see that, and my neighbors don’t either. 2. Barbara Scannell: [Ms. Scannell had to leave for another meeting. Her comments have been provided for the record]. 3. Toronca Johnson (Hilldale Drive, Lancaster) I have submitted a letter which you have in your packet. This is our 3 rd time around with this project. We heard it in 2002 for 130 homes, and in 2006 with 130 homes. The plan calls for future connections, which means this is not the end of development. I purchased my home because it’s a quiet street with not a lot of homes. I’m concerned about traffic. 100 homes means 200 cars. Between Hwy 903 and Hwy 9 there’s only about 100 homes altogether, and you’re talking about adding another 100 in 53 acres. I request that you deny this development in my neighborhood. 4. Ruby Rucker (Hilldale Drive, Lancaster). She has lived there 60 years; we already have too much traffic. Too many sirens, too many trucks, speeding cars near where children ride their bikes. We don’t need 100 homes there. I have refused to sell my 100 acres to anyone building that many homes. I just found out about this yesterday. We don’t need that. I don’t want that in my neighborhood, its not right. We’re going to fight it. 5. Jerry Witherspoon (Hilldale Drive) I’ve lived there 41 years, I helped build some of these homes. A lot of our neighbors are widows. There are too many homes in a small area. We’ve fought this two times already; we will keep on fighting. We don’t want it. You know it’s serious to get Ms. Rucker out here. We’re standing up. It’s going to be like a project, as close as these houses are. I’ve been a deputy Administrator for the County, and I’ve been the Administrator of the Housing Authority. You put this many people together, you’re going to have problems. Imagine how you would feel if this was in your neighborhood. We don’t need this many homes in this area. TIME CALLED Chairman Cavalier closed Public hearing and called for a motion on item SD-2024-1442 Motion to grant deferral by J. Tinklenberg; 2 nd by S. Richards. Yokima Cureton: Can I ask when Shadow Moss first came to us? J. Bryan: This is the fourth time we will have postponed it. [Scrivener’s correction: July 15 was the third time the item appeared on the agenda; September will be the fourth time it goes to agenda, not the fourth time it is postponed.] Called vote: 6:0. Motion is approved unanimously. The item will go to September 16, 2025 Planning Commission meeting. b. SD-2023-0677 Edgewater Phase 9 9 Application by True Homes LLC and B&C Landholdings LLC for a Preliminary Plat for30.26 acres (p/o TM # 0106-00-003.02 and 0106-00-003.00) for a neighborhood of 155 townhome lots. (Phase 9 of Edgewater development). Matthew Blaszyk, Planner: Applicant requests deferral to the August Planning Agenda. Comment from applicant(s): Joel Madden (Glen Eden Court, Mint Hill NC) We would like to defer. Public Hearing: (See attachments: Sign-in Sheets) 1. Barbara Scannell (absent). Her handout has been provided to the Clerk for inclusion in the minutes. Chairman Cavalier closed Public hearing and called for a motion on item SD-2023-0677 Motion to defer to August 19, 2025 by L. Hinson; 2 nd by J. Tinklenberg. Called vote: 6:0. Motion is approved unanimously. Frances Liu absent. Planning Commission makes the final decision regarding Preliminary Plats. 7. OTHER a. Distribution of UDO revision Module 4. UDO Stakeholder Meeting on Wednesday, July 16, 2025 from 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM. The Commissioners are invited. Please provide comments to Director Hardin for inclusion in the materials forwarded to the consultants. b. Review of Next Month’s Agenda • SD Silver Run aka Silverton • SD Riverside SF • SD Howard Property • SD Edgewater Phase 9 • RZ Fenchel • NRN Stonebrook Dr • Kershaw Annex 439 KCC Rd • Others have been submitted but are working on requirements and may go to September 8. ADJOURN Motion to adjourn by Y. Cureton; Motion approved by unanimous consent. Meeting adjourned at 7:34 PM. ATTACHMENT: Addendum dated 9/16/2025 Statement by Commissioner Judianna Tinklenberg Tuesday, September 16, 2025 July meeting documentation-by Judianna Tinklenberg Full Context to July meeting Thank you Madam Chair. I have something to say about our July meeting that has not been publicly addressed and is important. Please allow me to complete this without interruption. I listened to our recording of the July meeting again, and while the minutes are conclusive to the most part, they are by no means a full representation of that meeting. For these reasons I felt that I needed to substantiate the context. I have said it before sitting up here and I will say it again, ‘to be unclear is to be unkind’. I will take it a step further to also say that I think everyone that sits around me on this commission knows that I will search for the truth in all we do. It is easy to take one part of a whole and run with it, but it misses the context. Context is defined as the circumstances that form the setting for an event, statement, or idea, and in terms of which it can fully be understood. These minutes leave out all of the context. I recently heard a fitting quote that unfortunately rings loud as I prepared this statement, it reads ‘text without context is only a con.’ A con, per definition, is to persuade to do or believe something by use of deception or tricking. So in this case I would hope that staff would want all context included for full transparency and accountability so there is no question in the details of these July minutes. I will always be fully transparent and not leave out the context that is often proven to be the most important part of the whole and often times is the hardest to say out loud. Accountability is uncomfortable, but it is admirable. I motioned last month to amend these minutes because it lacked any context. The irony is staff included footnotes to the meeting minutes, but not to provide clarity, to point fingers. If they want to be technical with footnotes, lets get technical and include all of the detailed context. The details are that the County attorney did find that we should have had our election in July. I was merely trying to keep us as a commission legal and make sure we had a legitimate meeting that evening. The fact is we should have had the election and voted on officers to run that meeting, unfortunately for reasons I don’t know the staff removed the election from our agenda without proper communication, nor did our prior chair, communicate this change with his fellow commissioners. I believe we should not have to worry about staff meddling in our administrative duties as a commission, so no we were not checking our agenda a week 1 before to see if the election was included or not. We discussed the election previously in our June public meeting so it should have been on the agenda. The removal of the election suggests some form of outside control and conspiring to mislead us. In that moment when I asked during the meeting to hold the elections staff, nor our previous chair, lead us into doing the right and legal thing. Thus the entire meeting was in error and it ultimately lead to more confusion moving forward with our commission elections. It is important we get things right, simply because it is the right and noble thing to do. Doing what is right, leads me to my last part. I mentioned that I was uncomfortable in that July meeting because I knew we were being forced to carry on when it was not right or legal and the County attorney even later found this to be accurate. Instead, I was mocked by staff responding to me in a condescending way trying to make me look incompetent and incorrect for stating I was uncomfortable. I will always be uncomfortable doing something that I know is wrong. This will not be tolerated. Let the recored indicate that they were incorrect and completely out of line and unprofessional. The July meeting was in error and thankfully for staff everything that evening was deferred and no major decisions were made. Since then, staff has had 2 months to publicly take accountability and responsibility and has not done so, so let this memo and the full context be the record. I do not need a public apology, knowing that I was merely trying to do what is right and the law on my side gives me the peace I need. However, it would have gone far in making positive amends and gaining trust again among the staff and commission. I wish to move forward with the expectation of mutual respect and professional conduct as we are only trying to do what is best for all of Lancaster County and as a reminder we are all volunteers on this commission and unpaid. It is always my goal to keep this commission fully transparent in all our affairs, with full context of our meetings being documented. Thank you for listening and giving me the opportunity for correct representation of the meeting and what transpired within our commission, lets move on. Footnotes: In response to the footnotes on July meeting minutes, myself, nor multiple other people, could locate the past years July meeting videos. Obviously staff who posts these videos can quickly navigate the links. At least 2 of the past years July videos are voice only and in different folders. It has since been requested by myself that the videos/voice recordings be grouped per Commission and Board so all Planning Commission videos/recordings are together under one tab. 2

Source: Lancaster County website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.