RecordWell Data

Board of Zoning Appeals — Agenda Packet

Lancaster County · Lancaster County · Board of Zoning Appeals · meeting of Jun 3, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Lancaster County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Board of Zoning Appeals Members Gary Alden Mark Boland Charles Deese James Faulkenberry Aaron Fender County Attorney Ginny L. Merck-Dupont Secretary to BZA Aimee Sholar Planning Director April Williams June 3, 2025 6:00 PM BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS County Council Chambers, County Administration Building, 101 North Main Street, Lancaster, SC 29720 AGENDA 1. Call to Order Regular Meeting 2. Approval of the Agenda 3. Approval of Minutes a. Minutes of 5/5/2025 Training Meeting 4. Public Hearing Items a. VAR-2025-0914 Milhorn/Old Lynwood Circle Application by Jim Crumpler/Iseley Surveying on behalf of owner Karla Sistare Milhorn for a Variance from UDO Sec. 2.4 Lot Standards: Setback requirements, for eight lots on Old Lynwood Circle at TM# 0087G-0D-011.00 (Numbers 1655, 1657, 1663, 1667, 1671, 1675, 1679 and 1683 Old Lynwood Circle), to resolve existing nonconformities. 5. Other 6. Adjournment Anyone requiring special services to attend this meeting should contact 285-1565 at least 24 hours in advance of this meeting. Lancaster County Board of Zoning Appeals agendas are posted at the Lancaster County Administration Building and are available on the Website: https://mylancastersc.org/ Meetings are livestreamed and can be found by using the following link: https://www.youtube.com/@LancasterCoSCGov/streams Page 1 of 65 Agenda Item Summary Ordinance # / Resolution # : N/A Contact Person / Sponsor: Department: Date Requested to Be on Agenda: 6/3/2025 Information to Show on Agenda Below Title: Proposal: Property Details: Statutory Notices: Proposed Action Advances the Following Comprehensive Plan Guiding Principles: Points to Consider: Recommendation: Attachments: 1. 2025-05-05 BZA minutes 2. BZA 5-5-2025 Handouts 3. BZA - Rules of Procedure Training 5-5-2025 Page 2 of 65 MEMBERS OF LANCASTER COUNTY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS CHARLES DEESE , CHAIR JAMES FAULKENBERRY , VICE -CHAIR GARY ALDEN MARK BOLAND AARON FENDER Lancaster County Board Of Zoning Appeals 1 May 5, 2025 MINUTES OF THE LANCASTER COUNTY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS REGULAR MEETING May 5, 2025 at 6:00 PM 1. Roll Call/Call to Order Board Members present: Quorum is present (5 Board Members) Charles Deese Mark Boland (arrived 6:08 PM) Aaron Fender Gary Alden James Faulkenberry Absent: Staff: April Williams, Planning Director Allison Hardin, Development Services Director Jennifer Bryan, Planning Technician Ginny Merck-Dupont, County Attorney Corey Barnes, Planner Members of the press were notified in advance but were not present. A notice of public hearing was published in the Lancaster News at least 15 days prior to the meeting. The agenda was posted on the County website, and posted in the lobby of the administration Building one week prior to the meeting. A copy of the agenda is on file. THE FOLLOWING IS A SUMMARY ONLY; IT IS NOT A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT. Chairman Deese called the meeting to order at 6:00 p.m. 2. Approval of Agenda J. Faulkenberry moved to Approve the Agenda; 2nd by G. Alden. The motion was approved by unanimous consent. 3. Approval of Minutes a. Minutes of 3/4/2025 Regular Meeting Call for a motion. Motion to approve by A.Fender; 2nd by G. Alden Vote: 3:0 (Faulkenberry abstained as absent. M. Boland arrived after vote.) Page 3 of 65 4. Other Business: a. TRAINING: RULES OF PROCEDURE Presentation by Ginny Merck DuPont See attached powerpoint slide presentation, and handouts re: Roberts Rules of Order 5. Adjournment: With there being no further business, Aaron Fender moved to adjourn; The motion was approved by unanimous consent. Adjourned at 7:00 PM_. Page 4 of 65 Page 5 of 65 Page 6 of 65 Page 7 of 65 Page 8 of 65 Page 9 of 65 Page 10 of 65 Page 11 of 65 Page 12 of 65 Page 13 of 65 Page 14 of 65 Page 15 of 65 Page 16 of 65 Page 17 of 65 LANCASTER COUNTY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS Rules of Procedure Training GINNY MERCK-DUPONT County Attorney May 5, 2025 Page 18 of 65 Development Services Responsibilities of the County Attorney (Diverse and Include Matters Such As): Advising county officials on the application of various county ordinances, state and federal laws Serving as parliamentarian Drafting legislation – ordinances and resolutions Providing legal advice and representation to the county government on a wide range of legal issues, including contracts, employment law, civil rights, environmental law, and land use Drafting, reviewing, and negotiating contracts, agreements, and other legal documents on behalf of the county government Defending the county government in court, administrative proceedings, and other legal disputes Advising county officials, departments, and staff on legal and policy matters and representing the county in legal negotiations Providing training and guidance to county officials, departments, and staff on legal and ethical issues Keeping informed of changes in the law and developments in legal practice that may affect the county government Overseeing cases or other matters/issues handled by outside attorneys Board of Zoning Appeals - (Role of County Attorney) Page 19 of 65 Development Services What Can the County Attorney Do For the Board of Zoning Appeals The County Attorney can assume the role of another person staffed to the Board, with the County Attorney’s role to address procedural issues (i.e. what to do if a motion ends in a tie) Zoning or Planning Official(s) should answer operational questions about what the zoning code requires and do the staff work on the merits of a given case The Board may or may not want a staff recommendation, if so, that recommendation comes from the planning or zoning official(s) and not the lawyer (i.e. whether or not a variance or special exception meets the criteria is something for the zoning or planning staff to address) The County Attorney cannot advise the Board and simultaneously advise the planning or zoning staff on specific cases; given the quasi-judicial nature of the proceeding, the County Attorney cannot simultaneously represent the fact-finder and one of the parties (even if not a named party) Once a case starts the County Attorney takes on a general “officer of the court” orientation toward keeping the case on track procedurally Board of Zoning Appeals - (Role of County Attorney) Page 20 of 65 Development Services • The Lancaster County Board of Zoning Appeals is governed by a number of applicable rules of procedure: • The South Carolina Comprehensive Planning Act provides for the Board of Zoning Appeals to adopt rules of organizational procedure. • The Board of Zoning Appeals is additionally governed by procedural provisions which may be included in the Lancaster County Unified Development Ordinance as well as Lancaster County’s Code of Ordinances. • Where the Board of Zoning Appeals own rules of organizational procedure and the Unified Development Ordinance and Lancaster County’s Code of Ordinances do not apply, Roberts Rules of Order fills in the gaps. • The Lancaster County Board of Zoning Appeals is additionally governed by a number of applicable provisions which address, essentially, the structure and organization of the Board: • The South Carolina Comprehensive Planning Act provides for the membership and organization of the Board of Zoning Appeals. • The Board of Zoning Appeals is additionally governed by structure and organization provisions included in the Unified Development Ordinance as well as the Lancaster County Code of Ordinances. • Where the South Carolina Planning Act and Lancaster County Unified Development Ordinance and other Lancaster County Code of Ordinance provisions do not address structure and organization, the general provisions ordinance adopted by County Council in Fall of 2024 applies. Board of Zoning Appeals - (Applicable Rules and Provisions) Page 21 of 65 Development Services • The South Carolina Comprehensive Planning Act provides for the number of members (3-9); no dual office holding; election of a chairman who shall serve for one year or until re-elected or successor is elected and qualified; appointment of a secretary who may be an officer of the County or the Board; meetings at the call of the chairman or other times as determined by the Board; public notice of meetings; conspicuous notice posted on property or adjacent to property affected; administration of oaths; power to compel attendance of witnesses by subpoena; keeping of minutes showing vote of each member on each question; keeping of records of examination or other official action. • The Lancaster County Code of Ordinances and the Unified Development Ordinance provides for the number of members (5); power of the Board; members representing areas of the County and others having background and/or experience in a development related profession; 4 year terms with 2 consecutive terms allowed (additional needing a 2/3 vote of County Council); staggered membership; officers elected in accordance with adopted rules of procedure; equal rights, privileges and duties for all members; standards of review by the Board. • Lancaster County recently adopted general provisions which would fill any in any gaps which include: • General Powers and Duties • Residency • Length of Terms • Attendance • Conduct • Service and Removal • Training • Filings with Clerk to Council • Disestablishment Board of Zoning Appeals - (General/Structural/Organizational Provisions) Page 22 of 65 Development Services • The South Carolina Comprehensive Planning Act provides that the Board shall adopt its own Rules of Procedure. • The Lancaster County Unified Development Ordinance provides additional provisions which could be considered Rules of Procedure. • At present, the Lancaster County Board of Zoning Appeals has adopted a set of Rules of Procedure which include: Officers (Chairperson; Vice-Chairperson; Secretary) Meetings (Time and Place; Quorum; Rules of Order as Roberts Rules; Cancellation; Open to the Public) Application Prehearing Procedure (Form; Calendar and Docket; Time of Hearing; Withdrawal; Continuances/Deferrals; Notice) Hearing Procedures (Appearances; Equal Consideration; Witnesses; Cross Examination Not Allowed; Evidence Allowed Which Is Not Hearsay or Cumulative; Conduct of Hearing; Voting and Disposition; Adjournments; Form of Order; Service of Order; Appeals to Circuit Court; Rehearing) Conduct and Communications (Conduct – Avoidance of Situations, Communications and Circumstances Which Lead to Bias or Prejudice; Contact – Applicants or Other Parties Reported to Chair) Records (Minutes; Orders and Documents) Amendment and Adoption (Adoption – June 8, 2017 Currently; Amendment – Any Regular or Special Meeting by Majority Vote of Members of Board Script of Meeting Amendments to the above Rules are being proposed which include the addition of items such as agendas and voting requirements. Other amendments are being proposed within the existing Rules of Procedure. Board of Zoning Appeals - (Current Rules of Procedure) Page 23 of 65 Board of Zoning Appeals – Rules of Procedure (Relevant Robert’s Rules of Procedure) • If the Board of Zoning Appeals Rules of Procedure do not address a matter that arises during the course and scope of a meeting, Robert’s Rules of Procedure would fill in. • The following are potentially relevant rules from Robert’s Rules of Procedure which may be utilized to conduct the business of the Board:  Procedural Motions (may occur during course of debate – include privileged; subsidiary; incidental; recall)  Privileged Motions (do not require seconds – adjourn; recede; raise a question of privilege; convene executive session; follow agenda)  Subsidiary Motions (applied to pending motions – lay on table; call for question; limit/extend debate; postpone/to time certain; commit; amend)  Incidental Motions (point of order; appeal chair; suspend rules; divide question; consider by section/paragraph; requests and inquiries)  Recall Motions (brings a matter back – reconsider; recall from the table or committee) Page 24 of 65 Board of Zoning Appeals – Rules of Procedure (Witnesses and Exhibits) Pointers When Dealing with Witnesses and Exhibits Do questions and answers stick to the request? - Relevant to Matter - Not cumulative (i.e. tending to prove the same point) - Not hearsay (i.e. testimony based on what a witness has heard from another person rather than on direct personal knowledge or experience) Purpose of questions? - Are we addressing the criteria for special exceptions or variance? Value of discussion, openness of debate - Different from jury/judge deliberations as this is done in open session Page 25 of 65 Board of Zoning Appeals – Rules of Procedure (Bias/Prejudice – Ex Parte Communications) Pointers To Avoid Bias or Prejudice NO EX PARTE COMMUNICATIONS (communications between a party and the body when opposing party is not present) “In view of the quasi-judicial nature of service on the Board of Zoning Appeals, Board members shall not discuss any case pending before the Board with parties of record or other interested persons, except as part of a public hearing concerning that case. If a member is contacted by a party of record or other interested person, the member shall decline to discuss the case and inform the contacting person of the opportunity to appear before the Board at a public hearing to present his or her views on the record…” “If contact or a relationship between an interested party and a member is such that it compromises, or appears to compromise, the ability of the member or the Board to render a fair and unbiased decision in a case, it shall be the duty of the member to disclose the contact on the record at the start of the meeting where the case is to be heard, and to recuse himself or herself from participation in the discussion and any vote concerning the case wherein the contact or relationship exists.” Page 26 of 65 Board of Zoning Appeals – Rules of Procedure (Executive Session) Use of an Executive Session – S.C. Code Ann. §30-4-70 A public body may hold a meeting closed to the public for one or more of the following reasons: Discussion of negotiations incident to proposed contractual arrangements and proposed sale or purchase of property, the receipt of legal advice where the legal advice relates to a pending, threatened, or potential claim or other matters covered by the attorney-client privilege, settlement of legal claims, or the position of the public agency in other adversary situations involving the assertion against the agency of a claim. Before going into executive session the public agency shall vote in public on the question and when the vote is favorable, the presiding officer shall announce the specific purpose of the executive session No action may be taken in executive session except to adjourn or return to public session The members of a public body may not commit the public body to a course of action by a polling of members in executive session. Page 27 of 65 Board of Zoning Appeals – Rules of Procedure (Executive Session) When can Board hold an Executive Session? - When Executive Session is noticed on the agenda or when one is not noticed on the agenda but is requested and approved via 2/3 vote of the Board provided no “final action” is taken coming out of Executive Session For what purpose(s)? -For purposes of a quasi-judicial entity, for receipt of legal advice requiring a specific legal issue/concept related to the matter before the Board Legal advice vs. substantive decision - Legal advice can be provided to the Board regarding a specific legal issue/concept related to the matter before the Board but cannot be provided as to how the legal issue, relevant law, criteria, etc. should be/can be applied to the matter before the Board - Legal advice cannot be provided to the Board as to how to rule on a matter before it Not to be used to avoid public discussion/deliberation No action taken in executive session - No “polling” Page 28 of 65 Board of Zoning Appeals – Rules of Procedure (Appeals from Board of Zoning Appeals) Appeals from the Board – S.C. Code Ann §6-29-790 A person who may have a substantial interest in any decision of the board of appeals or an officer or agent of the appropriate governing authority may appeal from a decision of the board to the circuit court in and for the county, by filing with the clerk of the court a petition in writing setting forth plainly, fully, and distinctly why the decision is contrary to law. The appeal must be filed within thirty days after the decision of the board is mailed. An appeal from the Board would be handled by an attorney either retained by the County or provided under the Lancaster County Errors and Omissions Policy Coverage provided by the County’s Insurer, the South Carolina Association of Counties, depending upon the claims asserted on appeal. Claims for individual/personal liability for any decision rendered by the Board Members themselves would be argued against and requested to be dismissed, provided the Board Member was acting in their official capacity - official capacity claims against a Board Member would be handled by an attorney either retained by the County or provided under the Lancaster County Errors and Omissions Policy Coverage. Only in the instance where a Board Member is personally sued and not sued in their official capacity due to actions outside of the scope of their appointed duties would the County not provide legal representation. Page 29 of 65 Board of Zoning Appeals – (Appeals to Circuit Court) Pre-Litigation Mediation – S.C. Code Ann. §6-29-825 Property owner can file an appeal with a request for pre-litigation mediation and that request must be granted Notice of the opportunity to attend mediation must be provided to the property owner or representative, any other person claiming an ownership interest or a person granted leave to intervene If mediation is successful, the written mediation agreement must be provided within 5 working days Before the mediation settlement takes effect it must be approved by the local governing body in public session and the Circuit Court Any land use or change agreed to in mediation which affects existing law if effective only to the real property subject to the mediation and the settlement sets no precedent If mediation not successful or settlement agreement not approved by local governing body, a property owner may appeal by filing a petition with the Circuit Court within 30 days of the report of no mediation agreement or the failure to approve the settlement by the local governing body Circuit Court must approve settlement if it has a rational basis; if settlement is not approved by the Court, the Judge must schedule a hearing for the parties to present evidence and then issue a written opinion A party may appeal from the Circuit Court decision in the same manner as other appeals of judgement from the Circuit Court Page 30 of 65 Board of Zoning Appeals - (Appeals to Circuit Court) Board Decision Appeal – S.C. Code Ann. §6-29-840 Upon ten days' notice to the parties, the presiding judge of the circuit court of the county must proceed to hear the appeal on the certified record of the Board proceedings The Court may not take additional evidence In the event the judge determines that the certified record is insufficient for review, the matter may be remanded to the Board for rehearing The Court must determine only whether the decision of the Board is correct as a matter of law In the event that the decision of the Board is reversed by the Court, the Board is charged with the costs, and the costs must be paid by the governing authority which established the Board Nothing prohibits a property owner from subsequently electing to assert a pre-existing right to trial by jury of any issue beyond the subject matter jurisdiction of the Board, such as, but not limited to, a determination of the amount of damages due for an unconstitutional taking Page 31 of 65 Board of Zoning Appeals – Rules of Procedure (Power of Contempt) Contempt of the Board/Penalty – S.C. Code Ann. §6-29-810 In case of contempt by a party, witness, or other person before the board of appeals, the board may certify this fact to the circuit court of the county in which the contempt occurs and the judge of the court, in open court or in chambers, after hearing, may impose a penalty as authorized by law. Page 32 of 65 Development Services Board of Zoning Appeals - Rules of Procedure Training Page 33 of 65 Board of Zoning Appeals – Rules of Procedure Training Questions? Page 34 of 65 Agenda Item Summary Ordinance # / Resolution # : N/A Contact Person / Sponsor: Department: Date Requested to Be on Agenda: 6/3/2025 Information to Show on Agenda Below Title: Proposal: Property Details: Statutory Notices: Proposed Action Advances the Following Comprehensive Plan Guiding Principles: Points to Consider: Recommendation: Attachments: 1. 00 VAR-2025-0914 Milhorn - 1657 Old Lynwood Cir JB edit 2. 01 Milhorn Location Map 3. 02 Combined Application and Current Deed 4. 03 Survey showing existing locations and lot lines 5. 04 Proposed resolution of lot lines and setbacks 6. 05 NotApprovedLetter Minor SUb 7. 06 Plat 13-207 (1963) 8. 07 Plat 14238 - (1993) 9. 08 CHAIN OF TITLE 10. 09 Section 5.2.4 R15 development Page 35 of 65 11. 10 Current UDO Sec 2.4 Page 36 of 65 Case No. VAR-2025-0914 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: June 3, 2025 REQUEST: Application by Karla Sistare Milhorn requesting a Variance from UDO Section 2.4 District Development Standards to amend the setbacks required to re-subdivide a tract into single-family lots. CURRENT LOCATION: 1655, 1657, 1663, 1667, 1671, 1675, 1679, and 1683 Old Lynwood Cir (TM # 0087G-0D-011.00) ZONING DISTRICT: Medium Density Residential (MDR) HEARING NOTICES: Published The Lancaster News 5/17/2025 Notices mailed 5/23/2025 Signs posted 5/23/2025 Agenda posted online and in Administration Building Lobby 5/27/2025 OVERVIEW: The applicant is requesting a variance from Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) Section 2.4 District Development Standards to amend the setbacks required to re-subdivide a tract into single-family lots. Background The applicant owns property on Old Lynwood Cir (SC Road Number S-29-520) that was originally divided from a 26-acre tract in 1963. The 1963 plat laid out a subdivision of 60 residential home lots, averaging 75 ft wide at the road and 165 ft in depth. This subdivision also created Lynwood Circle Rd. Parcels were numbered 1 – 60, with the lots in the 50s fronting on Old Lynwood Cir (S-29-520). RELATION TO THE UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE: UDO Section 9.2.12, Variances - Standard of Review A. PURPOSE/LIMITATIONS 1. Purpose: The variance process administered by the Board of Zoning Appeals is intended to provide limited relief from the requirements of this ordinance in those cases where strict application of a particular requirement will create a practical difficulty or unnecessary hardship prohibiting the use of the land in a manner otherwise allowed under this ordinance. 2. Financial Hardship Not Sufficient Ground for Variance: It is not intended that variances be granted merely to remove inconveniences or financial burdens that the requirements of this ordinance may impose on property owners in general or to increase the profitability of a proposed development. 3. Use Variances Not Permitted: In no event shall the Board of Zoning Appeals grant a variance which would allow the establishment of a use which is not otherwise allowed in a land development district or which would change the land development district classification or the district boundary of the property in question. Nor shall the Board grant a variance which would Page 37 of 65 Case No. VAR-2025-0914 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: June 3, 2025 allow the establishment of a use set forth herein as requiring certain conditions or standards under conditions or standards less than those minimums. 4. Authority Limited to this Ordinance/ Conflicts with other Laws Prohibited: In no event shall the Board of Zoning Appeals grant a variance which would conflict with the International Building Code, as amended, or any other state code unless otherwise authorized by duly enacted applicable laws and regulations. C. FORMAL REVIEW 1. Action by the Board of Zoning Appeals a. Upon receipt of the request for a variance from the Administrator, the Board of Zoning Appeals shall hold a quasi-judicial hearing on the request. b. After conducting the hearing, the Board of Zoning Appeals may: deny the application; conduct an additional public hearing on the application; or grant the application. It shall take a majority vote of the Board to grant a variance. c. A decision by the Board of Zoning Appeals shall be made within 30 days of the date of the hearing. d. The Board of Zoning Appeals, as established by Lancaster County, shall hear and decide requests for variances from the requirements of the standards for the Flood Damage Prevention standards located in Chapter 8. 2. Standard of Review a. General Variance Requests: The Board of Zoning Appeals shall not grant a variance unless and until it makes all of the following findings: i. That there are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular property; ii. That these conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; iii. That because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; iv. That the authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. UDO Section 1.1.4, Purpose and Intent The regulations contained in the UDO have been adopted in accordance with the Comprehensive Plan for Lancaster County, South Carolina, as adopted, in order to: A. Promote a strong, diverse economy that supports a wide variety of businesses and enterprises. B. Provide sustainable, well-managed growth that maintains quality of life, protects open space and environmental quality, retains the natural character of the region, and maximizes the efficiency of the infrastructure investments. C. Promote a safe and healthy environment with good air and water quality. Page 38 of 65 Case No. VAR-2025-0914 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: June 3, 2025 D. Support increased collaboration among jurisdictions on issues that transcend boundaries, including growth management, transportation, and environmental concerns, in a manner that recognizes both regional and local needs. E. Promote community leadership and cooperative volunteerism for all residents. F. Create high quality educational opportunities that are available to all residents. G. Encourage community and stakeholder collaboration in development decisions, which are predictable, fair, and cost effective. H. Preserve open space, farmland, natural beauty, and critical environmental areas. I. Strengthen and direct development towards existing communities. J. Encourage mix of land uses with compact building design and walkable neighborhoods. K. Create a range of housing opportunities and choices. L. Foster distinctive, attractive communities with a strong sense of place. UDO Section 2.4: District Standards Table Page 39 of 65 Case No. VAR-2025-0914 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: June 3, 2025 Findings of Fact: TM # 0087G-0D-011.00 , Comprising eight residential lots under a single owner. 1. The applicant is the owner of 2.13 acres of property located along Old Lynwood Cir that has been assigned one TMS number of 0087G-0D-011.00. 2. The one TMS number encompasses eight (8) deeded lots of a 1961 subdivision created when Samuel G. Evans and Albert T. Bailey conveyed property to John T. Bailey, William L. Harper, and E. M. Melton via deed and plat. (Source: Deed Book B-5, Page 258, Lancaster County Registrar of Deeds) a. In 1961, Lancaster County did not have zoning regulations. 3. The subdivision was further detailed in a plat dated June 20, 1963 and filed with Lancaster County. (Source: Plat Book 13, Page 207, Lancaster County Registrar of Deeds) 4. The eight (8) lots were further outlined in a plat dated December 14, 1993 and recorded with a deed from Oscar Horne to James and Joyce Dickerson. (Source: Deed Book W- 11 Pages 304-305 and “Plat No 14238”, December 16, 1993, Lancaster County Registrar of Deeds) 5. Between 1993 and 2006, the Dickerson family owned the land. (Source: Lancaster County Registrar of Deeds. See “Chain of Title” exhibit.) 6. In 2006, David and Tammy Dickerson conveyed the property to Rhonda F. Sistare. ( Source: Deed Book 336, Pages 52-53, Lancaster County Registrar of Deeds) 7. Between 2006 – 2008, eight (8) single family structures were built on the property. (Source: Lancaster County Assessor’s Office) a. The zoning at the time of construction was R15. The 2006 UDO describes R15 as follows: “The R -15, Moderate Density Residential/Agricultural District, is designed to accommodate the most dense single -family residential developments (not including manufactured homes) in areas of the county which are either experiencing urban growth or which ar e expected to experience urban growth in the near future. This type of development requires that both water and sewer lines be installed prior to construction beginning on the site. If water and sewer are not available to the site, the site shall be developed based on the regulations of the R-30 district (see below).” b. Zoning standards for the R15 were divided between sites with and without central water and sewer services. Sites like the subject property, which had central water and sewer, were regulated under Section 5.2.4, which included allowances for zero lot line development under certain conditions. (Source: Section 5.2.4, Lancaster County UDO as of June 2007) 8. In 2008, the property was conveyed from Rhonda F. Sistare to B. Scott Sistare and assigned one tax map system (TMS) number, being 0087G-0D-011.00. (Source: Deed Book 480, Pages 276-278, Lancaster County Registrar of Deeds) 9. On March 18, 2025, B. Scott Sistare conveys the 2.13-acre property identified as TMS 0087G-0D- 011.00, and described as “lots 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, and 59”to Karla S. Milhorn and Rhonda Sistare. (Source: Deed Book 1896, Page 264-266, Lancaster County Registrar of Deeds) 10. On April 16, 2025, surveyor Jim Crumpler applied for a minor subdivision of the subject property on behalf of the owners. The request was to revert the property to the eight (8) lots created by the 1961 deed. a. The following are the relevant dimensions provided in the proposed plat: Page 40 of 65 Case No. VAR-2025-0914 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: June 3, 2025 Measurements in Feet; Left/Right Based on View from Road Lot # Lot Width at Front Setback Smallest Side Setback (Left) Smallest Side Setback (Right) 59 78.66 10.73 9.40 58 67.56 9.20 9.80 57 62.19 10.00 9.30 56 70.00 9.20 7.70 55 67.54 9.90 19.70 54 85.34 19.60 13.10 53 77.08 13.50 8.80 52 96.60 9.83 12.47* Meets Current Code *abuts unopened ROW Does Not Meet Current Code 11. On April 16, 2025, staff denied the application due to the following: a. The plat sought to divide the property into eight (8) lots; a minor subdivision is five (5) or fewer lots. b. The houses on the site did not fall correctly between the lot lines, which followed the 1963 and 1993 plats. In more than one case, a structure was built on top of a lot line. (Source: plat drawing by Isley Surveying; Lancaster County GIS) Page 41 of 65 Case No. VAR-2025-0914 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: June 3, 2025 PHOTOGRAPHS STAFF COMMENTS: Staff is unable to determine from past records what the conditions were when the structures were first built that led to the houses being built outside of the original lot lines. We are also unable to approve a re-subdivision of the subject property due to the property lines being too close – at times even through – the houses on site, in violation of Section 2.4 of the UDO. The proposed plat, however, goes a long way to correcting the errors and would allow the applicant to sell the home sites individually. Page 42 of 65 Case No. VAR-2025-0914 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: June 3, 2025 Staff does not oppose the variance request. If the Board wishes to approve the proposed plat that resolves many of the nonconformities, staff recommends the following variances: • Section 2.4.1.C Density (2.5 units/acre) enough to allow the eight (8) lots to be separated. • Section 2.4.2.B Lot Width at Front Setback for Lots 58, 57, and 55: o Lot 58 – from 70’ to 67.56’ o Lot 57 – from 70’ to 62.19’ o Lot 55 – from 70’ to 67.54’ • Section 2.4.3.B Street Side/Secondary Front Setback for Lot 52, which sits along an unopened right-of-way: o Lot 52 – from 15’ to 12.47’ • Section 2.4.3.C Side (from adjacent lot) Setback for all lots except 54: o Lot 59, Right Side – from 10’ to 9.4’ o Lot 58, Left Side – from 10’ to 9.2’ o Lot 58, Right Side – from 10’ to 9.8’ o Lot 57, Right Side – from 10’ to 9.3’ o Lot 56, Left Side – from 10’ to 9.2’ o Lot 56, Right Side – from 10’ to 7.7’ o Lot 55, Left Side – from 10’ to 9.9’ o Lot 53, Right Side – from 10’ to 8.8’ o Lot 52, Left Side – from 10’ to 9.83’ PLAT OF PROPOSED LOT LINE ADJUSTMENTS Page 43 of 65 Case No. VAR-2025-0914 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: June 3, 2025 ATTACHMENTS: 1. Location Map 2. Variance Applications (Applicant and Owner signatures) 3. Survey showing existing lot boundaries 4. Plat showing proposed resolution 5. Not Approved letter: Minor Subdivision 6. Plat 13/207 (1963) 7. Plat # 14238 (1993) 8. Deeds and Chain of Title 9. Section 5.2.4. R15 Development Regulations from 2007 UDO 10. Current UDO Section 2.4 STAFF CONTACT: Allison Hardin, Development Services Director ahardin@lancastercountysc.gov | 803-285-6005 Page 44 of 65 Page 45 of 65 Page 46 of 65 Page 47 of 65 Page 48 of 65 Page 49 of 65 Page 50 of 65 Page 51 of 65 Page 52 of 65 Page 53 of 65 Page 54 of 65 Lancaster County Planning Department P. O. Box 1809 Lancaster, SC 29721 803.285.6005 planning@lancastercountysc.net 207 Chesterfield Ave. Lancaster, SC 29721 April 16, 2025 Jim Crumpler Parcel(s) Stage Location Project Number Status Minor Subdivision Not Approved 0087G-0D-011.00 Old Lynwood Circle Project Name Milhorn 20250915 Dear: Jim Crumpler This letter is to confirm NOT APPROVAL, per the attached comments of your Minor Subdivision plans by the Lancaster County Planning Department. If the attached comments require changes to the plans, a pdf of the plan can be uploaded to the online portal. The online portal is on the homepage of the Lancaster County websites. If you have any questions please contact our office at 803-285-6005. Sincerely, Page 1 of 24/16/2025 Page 55 of 65 Plan Review Comments Planning - Jennifer Bryan - 803-285-6005 jbryan@lancastercountysc.gov Not Approved Review Comments: The plat was presented as a confirmation of lot lines depicted on plat book 13 page 207 (1963) and plat 14238 (1993). Plat cannot be accepted for filing by ROD because structures were built over lot lines. It cannot be reviewed under current Minor Plat regulations because it depicts 8 lots. Applicant was advised to have surveyor depict proposed new lot lines that would resolve the encroachments, and apply to the Board of Zoning Appeals for relief from setback requirements to address remaining non-conformities. Page 2 of 24/16/2025 Page 56 of 65 Page 57 of 65 Page 58 of 65 CHAIN OF TITLE - SISTARE PROPERTY TMS 0087G-0D-011.00 3/18/2025 DB 1896 PG 264-266 Grantor: B. Scott Sistare Grantee: Karla S. Milhorn and Rhonda Sistare - 2.13 acres - Lots 52,53,54,55,56,57,58,59 - On plat for James H & Joyce A Dickerson 12/14/1993 “plat no 14238” - Being property conveyed 8/22/2008, DB 480 PG 276 8/22/2008 DB 480 PG 276-278 Grantor: Rhonda F Sistare Grantee: B. Scott Sistare - 2.13 acres - Fronting on Hwy S-29-520 (Old Lynwood Cir) - Lots 52,53,54, 55,56,57,58,59 - On plat for James H & Joyce A Dickerson 12/14/1993 “plat no 14238” - TMS numbers include 0087G-0D-011.00 5/23/2006 DB 336 PG 52-53 Grantor: David Dickerson and Tammy Dickerson Grantee: Rhonda F . Sistare - 2.13 acres - Fronting on Hwy S-29-520 (Old Lynwood Cir) - Lots 52,53,54, 55,56,57,58,59 Page 59 of 65 - On plat for James H & Joyce A Dickerson 12/14/1993 “plat no 14238” - TMS number is singular: 0087G-0D-011.00 3/12/1999 DB 39 PG 09-11 Grantor: James Dickerson and Joyce Dickerson Grantee: David Dickerson and Tammy Dickerson - 2.13 acres - Fronting on Hwy S-29-520 (Old Lynwood Cir) - Lots 52,53,54, 55,56,57,58,59 - On plat for James H & Joyce A Dickerson 12/14/1993 “plat no 14238” - TMS is listed as 87G-D-11 12/16/1993 DB W-11 PAGE 304-305 Grantor: Oscar Horne Grantee: James Dickerson and Joyce Dickerson - 2.13 acres - Fronting on Hwy S-29-520 (Old Lynwood Cir) - Lots 52,53,54, 55,56,57,58,59 - On plat for James H & Joyce A Dickerson 12/14/1993 “plat no 14238” - TMS is listed as 87G-D-11 Page 60 of 65 Page 61 of 65 4/24/1973 (recorded 4/26/1973) DB B-6, PG 979 Grantor: William Harper and E. M. Melton Grantee: Carol K. Horne - 2.13 acres - Fronting on Lynwood Cir for 75’ each - Lots 58,59 - On plat by Paul Clark, dated 1962, PB 13 PG 207 - Portion of property conveyed to grantors by deeds in DB B-5 PG 258 and DB F-5 PG 58 6/21/1963 PB 13 PG 207 Plat drawn June 20, 1963 Page 62 of 65 SUBDIVISION OCCURS 10/28/1961 DB B-5 PG 258 Grantor: Samuel G Evans and Albert T Bailey Grantee: John T Bailey, William L Harper and EM Melton - 26.69 acres - Plat Book 2 at page 257 (record in files does not match description on deed) - Deed Book Y-4 at Page 278 - NOT INCLUDED: Lots 1 and 2 8/30/1960 DB Y-4 PG 278 Grantor: Katherine E Senter Grantee: Samuel G Evans and Albert T Bailey - 26.69 acres - Plat Book 2 at page 257 4/22,24,28/1947 PB 2 PG 257 All files show one acre lot Page 63 of 65 UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE OF LANCASTER COUNTY 4. In areas which are zoned R-15 or R-30 and where both central water and sewer services are available and adequate, or in areas zoned R-15D or R-15S, where both central water and sewer services are available and adequate and the proposed subdivision is to be constructed with either site-built or modular homes, any subdivision shall comply with the following requirements: (Ord. #400, 4/8/02) (Ord. #529, 2/3/03) a. DENSITY: The maximum density is 2.5 dwelling units per acre. The total number of dwelling units allowed on the site shall be based on the gross acreage of the site. For example, a 1'00-acre parcel ofland shall be allowed to have 250 dwelling units built on the site. b. LOT SIZE: Minimum standard lot size is 10,000 square feet. c. LOT WIDIB AND SETBACK REQUIREMENfS: If the square footage of the lot contains at least 29,040 square feet, .then the requirements for front, side and rear yards shall be the same as those contained in Chapter 5, Density and Dimensional Regulations,' based on how the property is zoned. • If the square footage of the lot is at least 10,000 square feet but less than 29,040 square feet, then the following setback requirements shall apply: Lot Width: Front Yard: Side Yard: 70 feet 30feet 10 feet However, the side yard requirement may be reduced to zero (0) provided the following conditions are met: I. A windowless wall is placed on one side property line and the total side yard requirement is provided on the opposite side property line. For example, if a lot is 60 feet in width, then a 12-foot side yard would be required to be placed on the opposite property line from where the windowless wall is placed. .2. The structure shall not encroach upon or be placed on the side yard property line adjacent to a street. 3. Whenever a structure is located within fom (4) feet of a side property line, a perpetual easement for wall and roof maintenance shall be provided on the adjacent lot. • The minimum width of this maintenance access shall be four (4) feet. This easement shall be incorporated into each deed. 4. Zero lot line dc;velopment is only allowed in subdivisions where all of the lots shall use this technique. _ Rear Yard, Principle Structure: Rear Yard, Accessory Structure: d. OPEN SPACE: 45 feet 10 feet At least 65% of each lot shall not be covered by impervious surfaces. e. FROM EXTERNAL STREETS: The minimum setback from external streets shall be same as is prescribed in the underlying zoning district f. BETWEEN BUILDINGS: The minimum distance between any two buildings within this type of development shall be governed by the Standard Building Code. However, the Director of Emergency Preparedness shall approve the fire protection measures for any development where the principal buildings are separated by less than 20 feet. Page 5-3 Page 64 of 65 DISTRICT STANDARDS 2.4 DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS 2 2-7 UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE | Adopted 11.28.2016 STANDARD Low Density Residential (LDR) Medium Density Residential (MDR Professional Business (PB) Neighborhood Business (NB) General Business (GB) Regional Business (RB) 1. DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS A. District/Development Area (min) n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a B. Development/District Exterior Setback/Buffer n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a C. Density (max) 1.5 unit/acre 2.5 units/acre n/a n/a n/a n/a D. Open Space (min) 10% 20% n/a n/a n/a n/a E. Park Space (min) 5% 5% n/a n/a n/a n/a 2. LOT STANDARDS A. Lot Area (min) 29,040 sf 10,000 sf 5,000 sf n/a n/a n/a B. Lot Width at Front Setback (min) 90 ft Water/Sewer OR 130 ft Septic See Below (5) 70 ft Water/Sewer OR 130 ft Septic See Below (5) 100 ft 100 ft 100 ft 100 ft C. Pervious Surface (min) 45% 45% 24% 24% 24% 24% 3. PRINCIPAL BUILDING A. Principal Front Setback (min) 40 ft 30 ft 10 ft 25 ft 50 ft 50 ft B. Street Side/Secondary Front Setback (min) 20 ft 15 ft 10 ft 10 ft 15 ft 15 ft C. Side (from adjacent lot) Setback (min) 20 ft 10 ft 10 ft 10 ft 15 ft 15 ft D. Rear Setback (min) 25 ft 25 ft 10 ft 10 ft 15 ft 15 ft E. Other Standards n/a n/a See Below (4) See Below (4) See Below (4) See Below (4) 4. ACCESSORY STRUCTURE A. Side Setback 5 ft 5 ft 40 ft 40 ft 50 ft 50 ft B. Rear Setback 5 ft 5 ft 30 ft 30 ft 30 ft 30 ft C. Other Standards See Below (1,3) See Below (1, 2) See Below (1, 2) See Below (1,2) See Below (1, 2) See Below (1, 2) 5. PARKING CONFIGURATION A. Parking Location per Section 7.2.3 See Chart 7.2 See Chart 7.2 Per building type Per building type Per building type B. Parking in Exterior Setback/Buffer n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a 6. BUILDING HEIGHT A. Principal Building (max) 35 ft 35 ft 35 ft 35 ft or 3 stories (whichever is greater) 35 ft or 3 stories (whichever is greater) 50 ft B. Accessory Structure (max) 2 stories 2 stories 35 ft 35 ft 35 ft 35 ft C. Additional Height Permitted with Additional Setback n/a n/a n/a n/a 1 ft additional height permitted with each 2 ft horizontal setback 1 ft additional height permitted with each 2 ft horizontal setback 1. Accessory structures over 600 sf must comply with principal setback requirement. 2. No accessory structures may be located on corner lots between the street and wall line of the principal structure. 3. No accessory structures may be located on corner lots between the street and wall line of the principal structure, unless front setback requirements are provided on both streets. 4. For any nonresidential structure which is located immediately adjacent to a single family residential use or district, the lot boundary line minimum distance shall be determined as follows: For every foot building height, the developer shall provide setbacks equal to the height of the building. At no time shall the setback be less than what is indicated in the above table. 5. Any development/subdivision connected to both public water and sewer shall utilize the alternate dimensional standards given in the table. . Page 65 of 65

Source: Lancaster County website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.