RecordWell Data

Town Council Meeting — Agenda Packet

Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · Town Council · meeting of Sep 17, 2024 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Tuesday, September 17, 2024, 3:00 PM 1 Town Center Court, Hilton Head Island, SC Benjamin M. Racusin Council Chambers The meeting can be viewed on the Town’s YouTube Channel, the Beaufort County Channel, and Spectrum Channel 1304. 1. Call to Order 2. Pledge to the Flag 3. Invocation – Reverend General Hay, First Historic African Baptist Church 4. Adoption of the Agenda 5. Approval of the Minutes a. Special Workshop Minutes of June 17, 2024 b. Special Workshop Minutes of June 20, 2024 c. Special Meeting Minutes of June 28, 2024 d. Regular Meeting Minutes of August 20, 2024 e. Special Meeting Minutes of August 29, 2024 6. Presentations and Recognitions a. Report of the Town Manager 7. Reports from Members of Town Council a. General Reports from Town Council b. Report of the Lowcountry Area Transportation Study – Glenn Stanford c. Report of the Lowcountry Council of Governments – Tammy Becker d. Report of the Beaufort County Airports Board – David Ames Page 1 of 329 e. Report of the Southern Lowcountry Regional Board – Glenn Stanford f. Report of the Island Recreation Association Board – Alex Brown g. Report of the Community Services and Public Safety Committee – Tammy Becker h. Report of the Public Planning Committee – David Ames i. Report of the Finance and Administrative Committee – Alex Brown 8. New Business a. An Ordinance of the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina Amending Title 12, Chapter 3, of the Municipal Code Entitled: Motor Vehicles and Traffic Control, Parking, to Revise Regulations Related to Paid Parking and Other Matters Related Thereto, and to Provide for Severability and an Effective Date, First Reading – Josh Gruber, Deputy Town Manager b. Consideration of a Resolution Adopting a Beach Parking Fee Schedule - Josh Gruber, Deputy Town Manager c. Consideration of a Resolution to Accept the Final Report for the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Project Independent Study - Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager d. Consideration of a Resolution to Dissolve the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee - Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager 9. Public Comment - Non Agenda Items 10. Executive Session a. Discussion of Negotiations Incident to Proposed Contractual Arrangements and Discussions for the Proposed Sale or Purchase of Property (Pursuant to the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act Section 30-4-70 (a)(1)) related to: 1. Bay Pines Road Area FEMA Grant Agreement 2. Audubon Pond Road Area FEMA Grant Agreement 3. Beach City Road Area 4. Easement Request in the Marshland Road Area 5. Easement Requests by the South Island Public Service District a. Pope Avenue b. William Hilton Parkway c. Wexford Drive 6. Hilton Head Island Land Trust Easements a. William Hilton Parkway Area b. Mathews Drive c. Wild Horse Road Area d. Leg O'Mutton Road Area e. Gardner Drive Area Page 2 of 329 11. Action from Executive Session 12. Adjournment FOIA Compliance: Public notification of this meeting has been published, posted, and distributed in compliance with the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act and the requirements of the Town of Hilton Head Island. In accordance with the requirements of Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 ("ADA"), the Town of Hilton Head Island will not discriminate against qualified individuals with disabilities on the basis of disability in its services, programs, or activities. Auditory accommodations are available. Any person requiring further accommodation should contact the Town of Hilton Head Island ADA Coordinator as soon as possible but no later than 48 hours before the scheduled event. Municipal Association of South Carolina (MASC) Civility Pledge: “I pledge to build a stronger and more prosperous community by advocating for civil engagement, respecting others and their viewpoints, and finding solutions for the betterment of my city or town.” Page 3 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Special Workshop Minutes 6/17/2024 Page 1 of 5 Town of Hilton Head Island TOWN COUNCIL SPECIAL WORKSHOP Monday, June 17, 2024, 5:00 PM Minutes Edits Provided by Council Member Patsy Brison Call to Order Mayor Perry called the workshop to order at 5:00 p.m. Council Members present: Alan Perry, Mayor, David Ames, Ward 3, Mayor Pro-Tempore; Alex Brown, Ward 1; Patsy Brison, Ward 2; Tammy Becker, Ward 4; Steve Alfred, Ward 5; Glenn Stanford, Ward 6 Also present: Marc Orlando, Town Manager; Curtis Coltrane, Town Attorney; Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk Adoption of the Agenda Mr. Ames moved to approve. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 6-0. Report of Findings from Gateway Corridor Project Independent Study Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager , Engineering and Capital Projects provided background information regarding the proposed project. He introduced the following: Jared Fralix, Assistant County Administrator; Thomas Boxley, Executive Director, Gullah Geechee Historic Neighborhoods CDDC; Brian Kinzelman, Senior Principal, MKSK; and representatives of Lochmueller Group. Mr. Colin proceeded to his presentation. This project began in 2017 as a need was identified by the South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) to improve the eastbound Mackay Creek Bridge that connects the mainland to the island (there are two bridges in each direction). The Town and County requested a more comprehensive approach to address this corridor rather than a series of projects and improvements over several years. November, 2018 - Sales Tax Referendum was approved containing the following: » $80 Million would go towards U.S. 278 Corridor Traffic Improvements including repairing and replacing the existing spans of the bridges to Hilton Head Island and the other improvements between Moss Creek Drive and Suire Pope Road. Since that time, Beaufort County as the project sponsor and SCDOT as the Project Manager have involved time and funding to conduct an evaluation of alternatives and prepared a draft Preferred Recommendation following the NEPA process. There has been public involvement, with many workshops, Page 4 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Special Workshop Minutes 6/17/2024 Page 2 of 5 well over 60 public meeting, and opportunities to provide comments. April, 2021, t he Town worked with technical consultants with expertise in engineering, planning, and design, starting in April 2021 to review the project and draft recommendations to improve the corridor alignment and design elements. Town Council approved 26 recommendations on October12, 2021, to be considered within the project to improve the corridor alignment and design elements. In order to make certain that all reasonable alternatives have been evaluated before a final decision is made. Town Council approved a Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) with Beaufort County on October 4, 2022. The MOA outlined acritical path and steps to take to reach a point for municipal consent consideration. Town Council created the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee in February, 2023 Appointments made on March 21, 2023. Town Council approved Request for Proposals and Scope of Work for Independent Study in June, 2023 August, 2023 to October, 2023 Consultant, The Lochmueller Group, Inc . procured to conduct Independent Study. October, 2023 CBB Transportation Engineers and Planners, contracted through Beaufort County, presented findings from its Independent Review of the Gateway Corridor. October, 2023 to present Hilton Head Island Procured Independent Study in progress (10 public meetings of the Committee occurred between November 3, 2023, and June 12, 2024) December, 2023 – June, 2024 t he Lochmueller Group presenting findings and recommendations to the Committee in accordance with the Town Council approved Scope of Work. The purpose of this project is to address structural deficiencies, identified by SCDOT in 2015 at the existing eastbound Mackay Creek bridge and reduce congestion within the project study area. The Mackay Creek bridge was built during the 1950s (opened in 1956) and is scheduled for replacement as part of SCDOT’s bridge replacement program. Cracks can be seen on the underpinnings of the mainland end of U.S. 278’s Karl S. Bowers Bridge over Mackay Creek on Aug. 18, 2015. The span, built in 1956, has been listed among South Carolina’s 25 most structurally deficient bridges. Mr. Colin reviewed the full project extent and reference points. In order to see the full presentation and preferred alternative video for the WHP Gateway Corridor project please go to the following link: William Hilton Parkway Corridor June 17, 2024 Town Council Workshop Presentation (hiltonheadislandsc.gov) HHI_Final_V5 on Vimeo Throughout the presentation, Council members held discussion, asked questions and Page 5 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Special Workshop Minutes 6/17/2024 Page 3 of 5 made comments regarding: clarification of the February 18 report – the Committee proposed a mitigation plan for Stoney and Town Council did not adopt it at that time; confirmation that the guiding principle to consider future transportation alternatives has been completed; inquiry as to notification and involvement process for Jenkins Island and Windmill Harbour regarding the current design; an opinion the proposed project is not aesthetically designed; question as to whether all guiding princip les have been met; inquiry and confirmation photos regarding congestion were taken during a. m. workday peak traffic hours; confirmation the environmental assessment prepared by SCDOT was reviewed; inquiry as to a second bridge alternative; inquiry as to the County’s position on a second bridge; clarification a second bridge alternative is not part of this specific project; comment that decisions are being made prior to determination being assessed; clarification the new proposed bridge will be very close in proximity to the same distance as the existing bridge; clarification as to what trees will be impacted; inquiry as to better access to pickleball courts on Old Schoolhouse property; inquiry as to cost of improvements put forth from Hilton Head Island Town Council and confirmation of additional costs for Hilt on Head Island as they ar e not included in the projected cost; confirmation SCDOT and the County did not agree to the costs for the additional items and overruns regarding requests and they will be incurred by local funding; concern over the process for Municipal Consent; concern over what recourse they have after giving Municipal Consent; confirmation that until there is a final design a line item cost estimate cannot be completed; discussion regarding width and medians on the existing bridge and proposed project; confirmation the medians will be concrete barriers; concern over minimal impact of time saved in commuting to the Island; suggestion transportation alternatives need to be discussed; lengthy discussion on the impact on the Stoney Community; and confirmation discussions have been ongoing with business and private property owners; concerns about failure of Lochmeuller to compete all tasks within their scope of services; confirmation that their would be a red uction in project costs when reducing the number of lanes on the bridge sections and through Stoney; expression of great alarm at the display of a slide showing potential “second bridge” locations which had not been seen by Town Council. Public Comment John Stewart addressed Council regarding his concern regarding noise pollution and spoke in opposition to the plan. Linda Harrington addressed Council regarding her opposition to the plan by reading her statement noting they are risking destroying the habitat without proper studies. Christopher Cliffe addressed Council regarding his opinion that there is no need for a bridge this size with a useless bike lane. Chris Ruffner addressed Council stating a larger bridge will bring more people and suggested tax incentives and flexible work hours could possibly alleviate the traffic issues. Frank Babel addressed Council stating the existing bridge is failing and businesses are failing because people cannot get here. If we can’t get the bridge fixed, the Town will be Page 6 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Special Workshop Minutes 6/17/2024 Page 4 of 5 in trouble. Skip Hogland addressed Council regarding allowing too much tourism and the effect it has on the Island. He stated the Town needs to stop promoting Hilton Head Island and the proposed corridor will not solve traffic problems. Felice Lamarca address Council stating the more we build, the more people will come. She proposed looking at other solutions. Gray Smith addressed Council in opposition to the plan noting he supports refurbishing the existing bridge. John O’Toole addressed Council stating the need for empathy for people dealing with the bridge traffic and the need to address an aging infrastructure before a major catastrophe takes place. David Johnson addressed Council stating the guiding principles need to be revisited. Steve Robinson addressed Council stating the bridge is not safe and a new one needs built. His opinion is the lights are the issue with traffic. Angie Hutchins addressed Council regarding the need to be creative due to the job shortage. Deiderick Advocaat addressed Council stating the advisory committee has yet to make a final recommendation and encouraged Council not to dissolve the committee. Lynn Greeley addressed Council regarding the crowdedness of Hilton Head Island and the traffic lights do not address the issue of traffic back-up. Peter Kristian addressed Council and encouraged them to address the growth issue on the Island and implement a moratorium on development. Richard Bisi addressed Council stating congestion is more than inadequate roads and bridges, but it is due to Island capacity. He suggested a moratorium on marketing the Island. John Casey addressed Council stating the advisory committee has not yet made a recommendation to Council and suggestions the Town is being pressured by Beaufort County. Yolanda Cohen McKinley addressed Council stating the negative impacts that will impact the Native Island Community. She expressed concern of their voices not being heard and the negative effects on the quality of life within the Stoney Community. A woman that did not identify herself addressed Council stating the proposed bridge looks like a bridge built for Interstate 95 rather than as an entrance to Hilton Head Island. Tom Reitz, Beaufort County Council member , addressed Council and advised them to hold off on Municipal Consent. He stated more answers were needed before a decision can be made. Memorandum of Understanding with Beaufort County for the William Hilton Parkway Page 7 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Special Workshop Minutes 6/17/2024 Page 5 of 5 Gateway Corridor Project Ms. Brison raised a question about how to proceed with this item on the agenda and asked that the Town Attorney address the questions The Town Attorney provided options. Due to the lateness of the hour, this item was not discussed. Ms. Brison also expressed concern regarding the Town Council meeting scheduled for June 20 which included action items regarding William Hilton Parkway. Mayor Perry stated he would take the concerns under advisement to determine the next steps forward. Adjournment The meeting was adjourned at 10:49 p.m. Approved: _________________________ Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk _______________________ Alan R. Perry, Mayor The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov Page 8 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Special Workshop Minutes 6/20/2024 Page 1 of 15 Town of Hilton Head Island TOWN COUNCIL SPECIAL WORKSHOP Monday, June 20, 2024, 3:00 PM Minutes Edits Provided by Council Member Patsy Brison Call to Order Mayor Perry called the workshop to order at 3:00 p.m. Council Members present: Alan Perry, Mayor, David Ames, Ward 3, Mayor Pro-Tempore; Alex Brown, Ward 1; Patsy Brison, Ward 2; Tammy Becker, Ward 4; Steve Alfred, Ward 5; Glenn Stanford, Ward 6 Also present: Marc Orlando, Town Manager; Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk Absent – Curtis Coltrane, Town Attorney Discussion of the William Hilton Parkway Corridor Project. Ms. Becker moved to have a 15- minute public comment period before discussion begins. Mr. Ames seconded. Motion carried 7-0. Richard Bisi addressed Council regarding his opinion that Council did not ask enough questions on Monday and questioned the assumption the additional lanes will reduce traffic congestion. Ashleigh Phillips addressed Council questioning the aesthetics of the proposed bridge, concern over the character of the Island, voiced her objections to Municipal Consent; expressed concern for the Gullah Community, and her opinion the new bridge will not bring more employees to the Island. Skip Hoagland addressed Council stating people moved here for Island life – not Myrtle Beach. Doris Grant addressed Council stating the meeting times are inconvenient for the working people of the Island. She expressed concern and questioned closing the turning land to Squire Pope Road. Steven Woodall addressed Council stating Council needs to remain in the conversation but doesn’t need to approve Municipal Consent. He asked that Council vote no on the matter. Mayor Perry asked that Shawn Colin address the question of closing the turn lane at Squire Pope Road. Mr. Colin stated there is no discussion of closures but there has been discussion of limiting peak hour left turns within the Stoney Community. Mayor Perry made a statement regarding the items at hand. He stated that Council Page 9 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Special Workshop Minutes 6/20/2024 Page 2 of 15 cannot operate by inaction. He stated that over the past seven years there has been great community engagement for this project from the SCDOT, Beaufort County and the Town of Hilton Head Island. He noted it is a difficult decision for Town Council, but it is no reason for hatred. There is an issue of the philosophical question regarding the project and a lot of different answers. He reminded all there is a deadline and stated that after Monday’s meeting, they reached out to Secretary Justin Powell to s ee if an extension could be granted. He proceeded to read a letter he received in return which is below: Page 10 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Special Workshop Minutes 6/20/2024 Page 3 of 15 Mayor Perry invited Senator Tom Davis to address Council and provide input from the State’s perspective. Senator Davis explained that the first thing that comes to mind is what does a timely manner mean. He offered his thoughts regarding what he thinks it means. He stated we’ve been operating under an environmental assessment period for three years, which terminates on June 28, and once that deadline passes it is his understanding that it’s possible to obtain an extension of the environmental assessment but that would be up to the Corps of Engineers as to whether to extend it or go back to one of the more beginning processes. He summarized that he doesn’t know what would happen if Municipal Consent is not given by June 28. Senator Davis expressed his opinion that Secretary Powell says in a timely manner, he means a decision one way or the other, yes or no affirmatively by that date. He added that from speaking with Secretary Powell that if Municipal Consent is not given that he feels like he has no choice but to go forward and allocate the $74 million that SCDOT has set aside for that first span and begin the process of deciding whether you’re going to rehabilitate it or replace it. He stated that one of the practical consequences of Municipal Consent either not being given by delaying the vote or a no affirmatively would be SCDOT going forward on that Plan B to repair that first span. He added his thoughts that if the project doesn’t go forward, or the project as presented doesn’t go forward one question that arises is what happens to the $80 million that was raised in the penny sales tax in 2018 for the purpose of this project. He rev iewed three different scenarios that could take place: 1) the $80 million raised is what’s used first to conduct the repairs in lieu of the $74 million; 2) if Municipal Consent is not granted it would be difficult to hold on to the $120 million from the State Infrastructure Bank that was awarded to Beaufort County for the project and 3) the money would be reallocated during the next round of projects. Senator Davis stated he has been focusing on two things throughout the process. 1) trying to hold in place the funding and cobble together enough money to make the project work; and 2) give the Town enough time so that it becomes a decision they feel comfortable with, which has been a good process. Senator Davis stated that irrespective of the decision, whether to give Municipal Consent or not give Municipal Consent, he will stand behind the Town of Hilton Head Island and try to help accomplish what the Town wants to accomplish by working with the SC DOT, Federal Government and the General Assembly. Council members made comments, asked questions and held discussion with Senator Davis regarding: an expression of appreciation from all Council members regarding Senator Davis’ hard work that he’s done on this project; explanation and pointed out that the penny sales tax was to repair or replace the bridge and the interpretation that nothing was mentioned regarding expansion; confirmation the funding would not go away automatically but the local delegation would have to put on a full court press to keep that $120 million set aside for the project and it would be difficult to keep that $120 million set aside for Hilton Head Island if they move into July without a deciding vote; confirmation Page 11 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Special Workshop Minutes 6/20/2024 Page 4 of 15 from the Senator that if Hilton Head Island would decide they need more time, he would make the best case he could in representing Hilton Head Island and it would be very difficult; confirmation there is approximately $300 million dollars dedicated to the project and a gap of $180 million dollars; an explanation of sources to cover the gap in funding which could possibly be: 1) go back to the State Infrastructure Bank and ask for more; 2) approach SCDOT for additional funding and 3) a scenario of Beaufort C ounty obtaining bonding; confirmation that if conditions are required they need to be included in Municipal Consent with the SCDOT as well as the MOU with the County ; and an expression of concerns over the Stoney area and plans to make it better. Mayor Perry invited Mr. Orlando to provide comments and insight as to how we got to this point. Mr. Orlando expressed appreciation to Senator Davis for his assistance during this process. He reviewed how we got to this point noting the Eastbound Mackey Creek Bridge showed structural damage during a SCDOT inspection in 2015, and then Hurricane Mathew hit in 2016. Following that Beaufort County initiated a Bridge and Corridor Improvement Project through a voter referendum sales tax referendum in 2018. Following the referendum, Hilton Head Island Town Council created a US 278 Corridor Committee in 2019 and a year later subsequently adopted Guiding Principles from the Committee to establish project expectations in 2020 . Council adopted the Committee Report but did not endorse an associated proposed mitigation plan at that time. He added that since then, there have been several years of discussions and project assessments with Council, Community Members, affected Community members, and affected property owners, SCDOT and Beaufort County. He noted the project sponsor is Beaufort County and is being designed by SCDOT and their selected design consultants. Many project alternatives have been presented to the Hilton Head Island Community by Beaufort County and SCDOT over time. He noted that this started well before his time began with the Town of Hilton Head Island as well as before the time of several seated Council members serving. In 2021, Council directed Mr. Orlando to establish a way to best represent Hilton Head Island as this project was being considered. In 2021, Beaufort County presented a project plan with significant impacts in the Stoney Neighborhood. It was a consensus of Council and Hilton Head Island Staff to object to the proposal. The goal was to see if the Town could affect the project positively and bring it back to Council to consider Municipal Consent. Beaufort County and the Town entered into a mutual agreement in 2022, which included recommendations of Town Council and a commitment to work together to try and achieve those initiatives. The project was further refined, further assessed by several traffic engineers hired by SCDOT, Beaufort County and the Town of Hilton Head Island. The Town separately hired traffic and transportation engineers for input and the project was further enhanced. Since Council’s directive Mr. Orlando has met with S CDOT Secretary Christy Hall (now retired) and the newly appointed Secretary Justin Powell to explain the challenges and to explain the project challenges for Hilton Head Island. He made it clear that just because Page 12 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Special Workshop Minutes 6/20/2024 Page 5 of 15 these elements were included in the project it didn’t mean that he would bring this back for a predetermined Municipal Consent. He suggested discussing the bridge, the corridor, the project and the program and all the variables that go into it and review impacts. He stated he believes staff has done their best to provide Council with as much consultant data and analysis from SCDO T, Beaufort County and from the Town traffic and transportation consultants. He closed by stating that Council’s decision whether to support or oppose this major corridor and bridge to and from Hilton Head Island must consider many factors to ensure that the collective decision aligns with the Community’s best interest. Mr. Orlando introduced Shawn Colin to conduct a presentation regarding the matter. Mr. Colin proceeded with his presentation. Section 57-5-830 of the South Carolina Code of Laws, which he stated was the basis for Municipal Consent and used the term “may” states that, “[i]n every case of a proposed permanent improvement, construction, reconstruction, or alteration by the Department of any highway or highway facility within a municipality, the municipality may review and approve the plans before the work is started; except that a municipality may not have the right to review and approve plans to remove, replace, or improve a bridge and its approaches within its limits where such bridge and its approaches have been certified by the Department to be functionally obsolete or structurally deficient and if the bridge crosses the intracoastal waterway.” Mr. Colin reviewed the proposal for New Full Bridge Construction: • While the Town has requested consideration for a 4- lane bridge, according to SCDOT, if a new bridge is built, it will be built as 3 lanes each way, plus inside and outside shoulders. • 12-foot travel lanes. • 1 10-foot outside shoulder and 1 6 foot inside shoulder in each direction. • 1 span that replaces all 4 current bridges • Provides uniform 75+ year lifespan for bridge • Design Speed of 45mph • Posted speed of 40 mph • Current bridge widths - 80’ and 100’ as explained Monday. • New Bridge is 121’ wide which includes 14’ to accommodate the pathway. • New bridge would be 107’ wide without the pathway • Town Council recommendations and MOU requested the additional pathway. • 1 12-foot shared-use pathway along the southern side of the bridge • 2 bulb-out refuges, 20 feet wide by 50 feet long, located along the southern shared- use path at Mackay Creek and Skull Creek • Shared-use pathway to connect to mainland pathway system at Buckingham Planation Road and to pathway system on Jenkins Island • Construction methods will cause this bridge to shift south within current power line easement. • Bridge height clearance to remain at 65 feet over Skull Creek • Bridge height clearance over Pinckney Island minimum of 17.19 feet Page 13 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Special Workshop Minutes 6/20/2024 Page 6 of 15 • Bridge length is 1.376 miles of the 4.218-mile project • Seismic and storm impact mitigation elements included in the overall structural design. • Will meet highest seismic standards • Designed to withstand Category 5 hurricane • No at grade intersection on Pinckney Island Mr. Colin next presented the proposal for the Jenkins Island Section: • Design Speed of 45mph • Posted speed of 40 mph • Bridge landing located within existing right-of-way • 3 12-foot travel lanes eastbound • 3 12-foot travel lanes westbound • All Jenkins Island Traffic consolidated at Windmill Harbour signalized intersection • Jenkins Road access to William Hilton Parkway is removed • Access to Hog Island, Mariners Cove, Blue Heron Point, Jenkins Island Cemetery, Hilton Head Harbor RV Resort and Hilton Head Harbor Marina will be from new frontage road on Jenkins Island • No pedestrian crossings at Windmill Harbour intersection • Windmill Harbour traffic signal upgraded with Adaptive Traffic Management System and included in Town system with 30 days of MOU • Shared pathway on northern side of corridor would be located within Town-owned Property along new frontage road connecting to the RV Park, the Marina, and the Jenkins Island Cemetery bridge to mainland and Town of Hilton Head Island pathway system • Shared-use pathway on southern side would connect Windmill Harbour to connect to bridge, as well as connection via to under-bridge connection to the northern side shared-use pathway • Access to Hog Island, Blue Heron Point, and Mariners Cove moved from southern side to northern side of corridor and maintain the existing connection under the bridge connection • Landscaped medians with varying widths • Exterior curbing installed to reduce right-of-way and handle drainage Next, Mr. Colin described the proposal for the Stoney Neighborhood Section: • Design Speed of 45mph • Posted speed of 40 mph • Within the current ROW for most of the corridor through Stoney neighborhood • 2 x 11’ lanes in each direction • 1 x 12’ lane in each direction • Additional turn lanes • Crosswalks at intersections • 10’ wide pathway • Public open space • Stormwater mitigation Page 14 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Special Workshop Minutes 6/20/2024 Page 7 of 15 • Landscaping • Potential Relocation or Removal of 2 culturally sensitive structures • Willie Young’s Upholstery ( formerly Patterson’s Store) and the structure which formerly housed Island Psychic • Former Island Psychic • Removal of curb cut at Memory Matters and William Hilton Parkway • Total ROW impacts 2.78 acres • Total ROW impacts on private property 0.89 acres (22 properties) Overview of SCDOT US 278 Corridor Improvements Environmental Assessment The National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) requires federal agencies to consider the impacts their projects may have on the environment and to integrate the NEPA process with other environmental law compliance. In association with the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) and Beaufort County, the SCDOT has developed an Environmental Assessment (EA) in accordance with NEPA. The EA includes a review of all proposed alternatives and evaluates potential impacts to the natural and human environment. This EA is the culmination of technical studies and reports, interagency coordination, and community outreach and feedback. The EA documents the purpose and need for the project; presents a discussion of the alternatives and the analysis of them; describes the affec ted environment, assessment of the environmental, transportation, social, and economic impacts; identifies potential community enhancements; and presents a Recommended Preferred Alternative. It also incorporates analysis and feedback from public and agency sources gathered during the various phases of the EA development. The Table of Contents includes: • Chapters 1 & 2 (Includes Cover, Table of Contents, and Commitments, Introduction & Purpose and Need) • Chapters 3(Alternatives Analysis) • Chapters 4 (Existing Conditions and Environmental Consequences) • Chapters 5 (Navigation) • Chapters 6 (Agency Coordination and Public Involvement) • Appendix A (Agency Coordination Plan) • Appendix B Phase 1 Traffic Report, Traffic Report Appendices • Appendix C (Traffic Technical Memorandums: Reversible Lane Analysis and Alternative Intersection Analyses) • Appendix D (Community Impact Assessment, Visual Impact Assessment, Relocation Impact Study) • Appendix E (Environmental Justice Analysis) • Appendix F (Noise Analysis Report) • Appendix G (Preliminary Jurisdictional Determination) • Appendix H (Essential Fish Habitat Technical Memorandum) • Appendix I (SCDOT Bridge Replacement Scoping Trip Risk Assessment Form, Floodplains Checklist, 2-D Hydraulic Analysis) • Appendix J (Biological Evaluation) Page 15 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Special Workshop Minutes 6/20/2024 Page 8 of 15 • Appendix K (Marine Mammal Protection Act Technical Memorandum) • Appendix L Part One, Part Two (Cultural Resources Survey and Section 106 Consultation) • Appendix M (Traditional Cultural Property Report) • Appendix N (Cultural Resources Memorandum of Agreement) • Appendix O (Section 4(f) Coordination) • Appendix P Part One, Part Two, Part Three (Hazardous Materials Phase I Environmental Site Assessment) • Appendix Q (QUS Coast Guard Navigation Report) • Appendix R Part One, Part Two, Part Three, Part Four Part Five (Public Information Meeting Plans and Summaries) • Appendix S (Website) • Appendix T (Newsletters) • Appendix U Part One, Part Two (Community Meeting Plans and Summaries) • Appendix V Part One, Part Two, Part Three, Part Four (Stakeholder Meeting Plans and Summaries US 278 Corridor Improvements Environmental Assessment Expires June 28, 2024 Mr. Colin then noted that the Town Council Approved Guiding Principles on February 18, 2020, as follows: • Fix the transportation issues in the corridor in a way that improves the safety and quality of life for all residents, workers, and visitors to Hilton Head Island • Address transportation needs for natural disasters and resiliency of island access • Consider future transportation alternatives • Improve the safety and quality of life for the residents of the neighborhoods and businesses directly impacted by the US 278 corridor • Stoney Community • Neighborhoods on Jenkins and Hog Islands (including but not limited to Windmill Harbor) • Have gateway to and from Hilton Head Island that the region will be proud of: • Aesthetically pleasing and reflecting the Hilton Head Island/Lowcountry values • Safe and functional pathways for pedestrians and cyclists • Minimizes environmental impacts and enhances the national asset of Pinckney Island Mr. Colin n ext stated that the Town Council Approved Recommendations on October 12, 2021 as follows: Corridor Wide Recommendations 1. Reduce lane widths to 11’ to calm traffic & reduce property impacts Page 16 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Special Workshop Minutes 6/20/2024 Page 9 of 15 2. Eliminate raised curbs in medians wherever possible, encourage existing vegetation and natural drainage in these areas 3. Vary median widths and meander roadway alignments where possible for traffic calming and aesthetics 4. Take advantage of Town-owned property for sake of Parkway improvements 5. Utilize ITS smart signal technology throughout 6. Reduce curb cuts & provide for alternative/safer property access throughout 7. Provide trails on both sides of Parkway where possible with sufficient separation from road and in lieu of sidewalks 8. Create a comprehensive system of safe, comfortable, and attractive shared use paths for cyclists and pedestrians 9. Open/encourage views to the water wherever possible, as a part of the Island’s “signature” 10. Ensure integration of unique, Hilton Head- specific signage, landscape schemes, public art program, architectural vocabulary, iconic features, and accent lighting that distinguish this parkway from all others 11. Reduce design & posted speeds throughout the corridor 12. Evaluate the island-wide transportation system Specific Recommendations 1. Encourage Moss Creek area improvements (commercial redevelopment, access/roadway improvements, trail connections) 2. Establish “Gateway Experience” threshold at west end of Mackay Creek bridges (landscape, island “icon”, art, lighting) 3. Reduce bridge mass with two separate bridges and Shared- Use Path on south side of eastbound bridge 4. Reduce bridge lane width to 11’, reduce shoulder width on left, only one breakdown lane on right. 5. Provide 14’ minimum width non-motorized lane on the bridge with multiple viewing areas and protection/screening of vehicles 6. Attention to bridge design/details as viewed from afar and on- deck (parapet, railings, structural forms) 7. Consolidate Jenkins Island access to one signalized location at C. Heinrichs/Windmill Harbour Entrance 8. Provide traditional turn lanes and intuitive intersection configurations throughout Stoney 9. Eliminate confusing SCDOT U-turns 10. Eliminate left turns and traffic introduction onto Old Wild Horse 11. Create new park south of Parkway in Stoney to authentically showcase Gullah Geechee culture/heritage 12. Consider a new Visitors Center as a part of this park that intentionally showcases this heritage while introducing visitors to the Island’s offerings 13. Create a Stoney-authored vision plan for the next generation of that neighborhood 14. Create and professionally staff a Development Corporation as a vehicle for Stoney Advancement Page 17 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Special Workshop Minutes 6/20/2024 Page 10 of 15 Next Mr. Colin outlined the Town of Hilton Head Island/Beaufort County Memorandum of Agreement which was approved on October 4, 2022: 1. The County and the Town agree to advance the Project in a cooperative manner for the entire duration of the Project. 2. The County and the Town mutually agree to work together in good faith to address the feasibility, and merits of recommendations approved by Town Council on October 12, 2021 (as set forth in Exhibit A) (the "Recommendations") and further agree that one bridge will be designed and constructed for the Project. 3. The County will procure an independent consultant (the “Independent Consultant”), (i.e. – one that does not have a previous or current contractual relationship with SCDOT, the County, or the Town) to perform an additional independent review of the project. This Independent Consultant will conduct an end-to-end simulation and study through and beyond the Project limits to include additional intersections materially consistent with the Scope of Work set forth in Exhibit A. 4. The County and the Town will establish a committee (the “Committee”) to select the Independent Consultant through a competitive bid process. The following County representatives shall sit on the Committee: (a) the County Administrator or his designee (b) the Assistant County Administrator for Infrastructure: (c) and the County Transportation Program Manager Consultant. The following Town representatives shall sit on the Committee: (d) the Town Manager or his designee; (e) the Assistant Town Manager of Commu nity Development; and (f) the Town Engineer. 5. All recommendations from the independent review for areas within the project boundary will be considered for inclusion in the project. The County and Town agree to pursue the “Finding of No Significant Impacts” (FONSI) from the Federal Highway Administration c oncurrent with the Independent Review. If any findings from the Independent Review affect environmental documents submitted for the FONSI, those recommendations will be considered, and the environmental documents will be updated and resubmitted as agreed upon by the County and the Town. 6. The County and the Town, as required as part of the NEPA process, will coordinate with SCDOT to perform a value engineering of the project to identify and eliminate unwanted costs, and improve function and quality as well as to optimize initial and long-term investment, ultimately seeking the best value for the lowest cost. 7. The County and the Town mutually agree to work together, along with SCDOT and Lowcountry Area Transportation Study, to design, implement and maintain a connected and synchronized signal system along the entire length of US 278 from I-95 to Sea Pines Circle. The synchronized system will include fiber connectivity, Adaptive Signal technologies and other tools to help maximize flow. The County and the Town mutually agree to work together to seek funds necessary to acquire and implement the proposed improvements. Page 18 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Special Workshop Minutes 6/20/2024 Page 11 of 15 8. Any signal improvements from the synchronization project which are not already installed within the corridor prior to the construction of the Project, will be incorporated as such. 9. This Agreement does not provide the Town’s municipal consent. Such consent may be provided by the Town Council after the Independent Review has been evaluated by the Town and County and before the right -of-way acquisition phase of the Project begins. Munic ipal consent by the Town will not be unreasonably withheld. 10. The County and the Town agree that the Independent Review will be the last and final study needed for the Town to make a final decision related to the Project. Mr. Coli n next presented data on the “Traffic Management Assessment” which was prepared by Lochmeuller, the Town’s engineering consultant. The data included travel times and performance levels at intersections. Town Council – Project Considerations were listed by Mr. Colin as follows: • Project Scope • Rehabilitate eastbound Mackay Creek Bridge or build new, single 6- lane bridge? • Shared-use pathway on south side of bridge? • Meander roadway on Jenkins Island? • Aesthetics on bridge and through corridor? • Community Impacts and Improvements? • Property Impacts and Improvements through Stoney Neighborhood? • Quality of Life • Traffic and Transportation • Traffic Management Level of Service? • Environmental Impacts? • Cost, Funding, and Economic Impacts and Benefits? Next Steps for Council Consideration 1. Town Council consideration of Beaufort County/SCDOT request for Municipal Consent 2. Path forward should Town Council not grant Municipal Consent to SCDOT a. Per SCDOT Secretary Powell - the existing Mackay Creek bridge continues to age in a challenging environment with tides and saltwater. While not load posted today, future inspections may necessitate SCDOT putting a load posting on the bridge which could impact the movement of trucks, buses, and emergency vehicles onto Hilton Head Island. b. SCDOT and Beaufort County to Address eastbound Mackay Creek Bridge c. State Infrastructure Bank Funding would be reallocated to other projects. 3. Path forward should Town Council grant Municipal Consent to SCDOT Page 19 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Special Workshop Minutes 6/20/2024 Page 12 of 15 a. Establish Town of Hilton Head Island/Beaufort County Memorandum of Agreement that includes the following project conditions: i. Design Elements ii. Neighborhood Improvements iii. Economic Sustainability b. SCDOT Project Schedule Advances The Mayor asked for comments from Town Council members. Ms. Brison raised a threshold issue that the Town staff had citeed the wrong stature which requires Municipal Consent. She stated that it should be Section 57- 5-820 of the South Carolina Code of Laws which provides for mandatory consent instead of Section 57- 5-830. She cited the Municipal Consent documents previously required of the Town for the Cross Island Parkway and of the Town of Mount Pleasant for th bridge over the Wando River. Council members then made comments, asked questions and held discussion regarding: clarification of Section 57- 5-820 and Section 57- 5-830 of the South Carolina Code of Laws; confirmation that SCDOT said the bridge must be six lanes and their authority to do so; confirmation that the position of SCDOT that if it is a single span bridge it needs to be six lanes; confirmation that if the current project is rejected, Council will have to go back and redefine the project and get back in line to obtain funding, etc.; confirmation that if Municipal Consent is not granted to SCDOT and this project is not submitted as defined within the current purpose and need and a solution to this project would die and a new project would have to be defined by going through the full process again; confirmation that if the project doesn’t move forward, SCDOT would work to determine which path was most effective and the best use of funds whether it’s to rehabilitate or replace the Eastbound Mackey Bridge and it would be replacement with two lanes and if it’s a rehab it would not include the seismic upgrades but a replacement would have seismic upgrades; a request to hold off until after the election; a request to ask Senator Davis to continue good work and obtain an extension on the Environmental Assessment along with funding ; confirmation Mackey Creek Bridge replacement is eminent ; speculation three lanes offers the opportunity of an HOV lane; expression of the need for a bike lane is necessary; acknowledgement we need to control who we are; acknowledgement Council needs to stay on the topic which is bridges; a suggestion to deal with issues we can control; acknowledgment the County is in charge of the projects; acknowledgement the interests of the Stoney Community are in the forefr ont; inquiry regarding methods to protect causeways due to possible storm surges and confirmation this will be addressed in future phases of design; inquiry into numbers used regarding correct width of existing bridge to the width of the proposed bridge; clarification on requirements for consent and adding conditions; acknowledgment of the need for conditions to be included in Municipal Consent and the MOU with the County and the need to make it public; request for visuals regarding measurement; request that the pedestrian portion of the proposal needs to be changed; proposal to include pedestrian crossing safety as a condition; concern over SCDOT purpose and need to increase capacity and reduce congestion. Council Member Brison made lengthy remarks about her process in coming to her views regarding the project and her proposed conditions. Page 20 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Special Workshop Minutes 6/20/2024 Page 13 of 15 Ms. Brison asked technical questions about plans for the three causeways to addres s storm surges and the cost of that design and pointed to three options for Munici9pal Consent: 1) Yes; 2) Yes, with conditions; and 3) No. Ms. Brison then made remarks about the process she used in leading to her decision and her proposed conditions. Her proposed conditions included: (1) a Stoney Improvement Plan which consists of a reduction in the proposed number of lanes, pedestrian and bicyc list overpasses, landscaped medians, improved and safe access to all Gullah properties and businesses, and drainage improvements, with all costs included in the Project budget and secured by at least a $10 million escrow for the Stoney Improvement Plan; (2) a Pedestrian and Bicyclist Safety Plan which consist of safe refuges in median areas, separation of pathways from vehicular lanes, overpasses and intersection protections, with all costs included in the Project budget; (3) Aesthetic & Design Elements which consists of landscaped medians, incorporation n of MKSK designs, reduction in the size of the bridge sections by eliminating one travel lane in each direction, bridge designs and corridor entrance elements completed in accordance with Hilton Head Island Design Review Guidelines and Town Council approval of bridge design and corridor entrance elements; (4) Installation of Improved Traffic Management Systems which consists of incorporating the Windmill Harbour traffic signal into the Town’s adaptive traffic signal system testing time of day limitations on left turn, closing left turn on Pinckney Island, and reducing the speed limit to 40 mph, all to be done immediately; (5) Address storm surges on causeways; and (6) address bottlenecked mergers with Cross-Island Parkway. Council members continued to ma ke comments, ask questions and ho ld discussion regarding: a suggestion that in conjunction with the project and improvements to the Stoney area there should be address the infrastructure and redevelopment needs along with funding which could possibly include a TIF District in a timely manner; use of Town property within the Stoney area to accomplish the goals suggested; the need for an overpass for crossing US278 in the Stoney A rea; inquiry as to what a no vote would do to any enhancements included for Stoney ; confirmation the funds could be reallocated; and confirmation that if the current project is able to advance securing the current gap in funding is needed to move forward. Public Comment Christopher Cliffe addressed Council regarding his opinion that the proposal doesn’t solve traffic problems, and the project will destroy the cache of the Island. Chris Rates addressed Council expressing her concerns regarding transportation alternatives, the lack of bike paths when expecting people to bike from the mainland, the fact that the proposed project is not saving much travel time; and the need to protect the Stoney Community. Page 21 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Special Workshop Minutes 6/20/2024 Page 14 of 15 Chris Ruffner addressed Council stating additional lanes does not help reduce traffic congestion as well as speed limits do not assist either. Mel Campbell addressed Council and stated he was a Native Islander and expressed his opinion that the bridge is needed and the changes that brought Stoney to where it is today were caused by design mistakes. Ray Deal addressed Council noting the Chamber is a voice for all businesses on the Island. The workforce is top priority for all businesses. He urged Council to approve the project. William Stewart addressed Council stated financial well and development needs to be addressed in the Stoney Community through partnership. He stated the need for safety to be addressed due to lost lives on US278 of which two of his brothers are included. Steve Robinson addressed Council stating he couldn’t believe that Council has to ask Staff as to what would happen if they voted no and if they knew what the purpose of the question was. David Johnson addressed Council regarding that citizen comments have assisted in working through the project. Some residents are in favor of the project. He stated safety and traffic is a huge issue. Frank Babel addressed Council stating Stoney needs revitalized and it is appositive thing to do so, and the traffic problems need fixed along with making the bridge structurally safe. He encouraged approving the project. Eric Sommerville addressed Council and suggested the project move forward but to take the Stoney Area into consideration and not ruin it. Peter Kristian addressed Council stating a need for six lanes for employees coming on the Island along with the need for bike lanes. Cherry Norris addressed Council stating the Island is a special place and encouraged Council not to expand the bridge. Her concern is does a bigger bridge mean more development? Dale Becker addressed Council stating Ky West has more visitors that Hilton Head Island and they do fine. The Gullah Geechee community needs to be honored and taken care of and we definitely do not need bike lanes on the bridge. Angie Hutchinson addressed Council stating she likes clapping in meetings. She added that Beaufort County doesn’t have a good track record. She stated the proposed bridge is wider than the Brooklyn and Manhatton Bridges. Linda Harrington addressed Council inquiring as to the duties of the Town Attorney and asked why he wasn’t in attendance at the meeting. She stated her opinion that the study for the proposed project is flawed. Gray Smith addressed Council stating the Island shouldn’t be asked to give up its power to others. Beaufort County is positional to take advantage of Hilton Head Island. Page 22 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Special Workshop Minutes 6/20/2024 Page 15 of 15 Carol Buxser addressed Council stating her opposition to the proposed bridge and the bike paths. She encouraged Council to celebrate the Gullah Geechee Community. Mr. Stewart addressed Council stating he is a Stoney resident and does not trust the SCDOT. He spoke of drainage problems and too many tourists. Lynn Greeley addressed Council stating the need is to beautify and not add a massive bridge and she feels there are too many tourists. John O’Toole addressed Council saying he supports the bridge project noting that traffic is contributing to pollution. He stated he has confidence in Council and Staff. Mayor Perry invited Shawn Colin to address a couple of the questions that were asked. Mr. Colin said that the travel time savings if a new bridge is put is place would be eights minutes and 49 seconds eastbound and 10 minutes and 36 seconds westbound. He stated the Mackey Bridge was built in 1956, and the other three bridges were built in the early 1980’s. Mr. Colin explained that the purpose and need for the project identified deems a four-lane bridge does not achieve the purpose of reducing congestions, therefore its is rejected by the project. Mr. Colin informed Council the impervious surface information is on the project website. Ms. Brison asked that the Town Attorney address the status of the conveyance of Town- owned land to SCDOT for the Project right-of-way. She requested that it not be conveyed until the Town has an agreement with SCDOT. Council and staff discussed the next steps forward and the process that will take place. Adjournment The meeting was adjourned at 7:48 p.m. Approved: _________________________ Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk _______________________ Alan R. Perry, Mayor The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov Page 23 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 6/28/2024 Page 1 of 11 Town of Hilton Head Island TOWN COUNCIL MEETING Friday, June 28, 2024, 10:00 AM Minutes Edits Provided by Council Member Patsy Brison Call to Order Mayor Perry called the workshop to order at 10:00 a.m. Council Members present: Alan Perry, Mayor, David Ames, Ward 3, Mayor Pro-Tempore; Alex Brown, Ward 1; Patsy Brison, Ward 2; Tammy Becker, Ward 4; Steve Alfred, Ward 5; Glenn Stanford, Ward 6 Also present: Marc Orlando, Town Manager; Curtis Coltrane, Town Attorney; Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk Invocation – Reverend Steve Salvas, Grace Community Church Reverend Salvas delivered the Invocation. Adoption of the Agenda Mr. Ames moved to approve. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 7-0. Ms. Becker moved to postpone the vote on Items 5a. and b. Motion failed due to lack of a second. Ms. Becker explained her reasoning for asking that the votes be postponed. She referenced a book written by Buzz Carota – Evolution of a Town. She stated she is trying to remind members of Council that this project, just like the project that is described in the book with regards to the Cross Island Parkway, has the same elements that the County is looking to do this project to enhance what they can take out of our community without consideration for our residents. Mr. Stanford reiterated that the County is the sponsor of the project, not the Town. The purpose of the meeting is to enter into an agreement that puts the Town firmly at the table for all decision making. Mayor Perry read a second letter he received from Secretary Powell. It is below: June 27, 2024 Mayor Perry: It is my understanding that the Town of Hilton Head Island intends to take up a Municipal Consent resolution for the US -278 project at a special meeting called on Friday, June 28. I wanted to provide some comments on behalf of the South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) related to the pending action. Page 24 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 6/28/2024 Page 2 of 11 As stated in my letter dated June 20, 2024, time is of the essence. The Environmental Assessment for this project will expire on June 28 absent action from the Town of Hilton Head Island. Moreover, I remained concerned that the existing US-278 eastbound bridge over Mackay Creek will continue to deteriorate absent a plan to move forward. Should Municipal Consent not be granted on June 28, I am prepared to instruct SCOOT staff to begin developing a plan to rehabilitate or replace the existing Mackay Creek bridge only. This could have ramifications to the South Carolina Transportation Infrastructure Bank's agreement to provide $120,000,000 to Beaufort County for the project. This project initiated out of a desire from Beaufort County to replace the bridges and improve traffic operations between Bluffton and Hilton Head Island. In lieu of a separate project for the Mackay Creek bridge only, SCOOT entered into an intergovernmental agreement with Beaufort County to serve as project manager of the US-278 bridge and improvement projects. As is standard practice on any project of this scope and size, SCOOT has engaged with the public, Beaufort County, the Town of Hilton Head Island, and other interested stakeholders in substantial public involvement and studies related to the project. This has resulted in a modified recommended preferred alternative that generally conforms to the Lochmueller recommendation. On May 16, 2024, I sent a letter to Interim County Administrator John Robinson (attachment 1) indicating that the Department of Transportation is willing to proceed with the modi fied recommended alternative. Per SC Code Section 57- 5-810, SCOOT is required to obtain Municipal Consent when a project occurs within a municipality except for structurally deficient or functionally obsolete bridges that cross the Atlantic Intracoastal Waterway. For this project, SCOOT has determined that the project elements between the bridge approaches and the Cross Island Parkway necessitate Municipal Consent under state law. We are at a juncture where the Town of Hilton Head Island needs to approve or disapprove a resolution authorizing Municipal Consent. I am in receipt of the draft Municipal Consent resolution. It is SCDOT's posture that it requires a clean Municipal Consent resolution consistent with its standard template (attachment 2) without further stipulations. Therefore, I request that if the Town of Hilton Head Island intends to approve Municipal Consent, it adopt a resolution consistent with our standard template with no additional stipulations being placed on SCOOT. I am amenable to deleting language related to utilities as requested by the Town as the Town does not own or operate a municipal utility. I recognize that this project will make substantive changes to the crossing from Bluffton to Hilton Head Island, as well as the historic gateway onto the island. It is my intent that, if this project does proceed, SCOOT intends to deliver a quality project that meets all state and federal requirements and improves transportation on Hilton Head Isl and. To that end, I want to offer the attached comments to the proposed stipulations as a good faith effort that SCOOT intends to cooperatively pursue this project with Beaufort Page 25 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 6/28/2024 Page 3 of 11 County and the Town of Hilton Head Island. SCOOT appreciates the continued partnership with the Town of Hilton Head Island and Beaufort County. We are prepared to deliver a quality project for the benefit of all parties involved. Justin P Powell SCDOT Secretary of Transportation The attachments to the letter were not read. Mayor Perry invited Senator Tom Davis to speak to the efforts he has put into this throughout the process. Senator Davis explained his role in the process to date which includes facilitating funding for the project, making sure the Town has enough time, space and resources to come up with a decision. He stated that there is about $300 million committed to the Project, with a delta of about $60 million for the Projects. He stated that irrespective of SCDOT being the contractor and builder and irrespective of the County being the sponsor and project manager, he has always looked to the Town of Hilton Head and the Council as being representatives of the citizens as being the primary determinant of whether or not this project goes forward. Senator Davis noted that if Council deems more time is necessary, he will do his best to have the Environmental Assessment extended. He noted that there have been assessments extensions granted in the past and some have not. He reiterated Secretary Powell’s statement that, absent Municipal Consent, they will go forward with replacement of or repairs on the Mackey Creek Bridge. Senator Davis reviewed the funding statistics noting that the State Infrastructure Bank has been pressured to take allocations and apply them to projects being built. He commented on comments from previous meetings from members of Council regarding a bilateral relationship with the Town and SCDOT as well as Beaufort County to assure needs are conveyed. Senator Davis stated that if this project were to move forward, in terms of if consent is given, either with or without conditions, there would then be a process then he would engage in along with other members of the delegation to ensure that those conditions were discharged. He explained it would be to make appropriation advocations in the General Assembly, to work with the County for appropriation requests, work with the Town on a potential TIF District, to go to Washington, DC and talk with the Federal Delegation to come up with funding that is necessary and to make what Council envisions a reality. He said the process is going to take a couple years to move from where we are right now even if Consent is given. He stated the next step would then be for the SCDOT Sincerely, Page 26 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 6/28/2024 Page 4 of 11 to submit an application to the Feds for a finding of no significant impact would which take months and there may be processes associated with it that would involve action by this Council. Concluding that, the SCDOT would complete the engineering drawings which the Town will be involved in and that step could take several months. He summarized that his point is there is a tremendous amount of work to be done even if consent is given, which is going to entail Council’s continued involvement throughout the entire process. He proceeded to review the funding obtained to date for the Gullah Community, which has been a top priority of his, and the process to obtain further funding and answered questions from Council regarding the process. He concluded with stating the primary thing is getting a project Council feels is reflective of what the people of Hilton Head Island want. Mr. Orlando stated that he, along with staff and the Town Attorney , have incorporated directives given to them within the proposed resolution and memorandum of understanding. He invited Shawn Colin to come forward and review all the changes and additions. New Business Consideration of a Resolution of the Town of Hilton Head Island Authorizing a Memorandum of Agreement with Beaufort County for the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Project Mr. Colin conducted a thorough review of the documents and the changes that were applied. He noted there were no changes to the Resolution but there were changes and additions to Exhibit A of the Resolution which is the Memorandum of Agreement (MOA). He detailed each change and projected them on the screen for viewing. Mayor Perry asked for public comment. Eric Sommerville addressed Council regarding his concern that rather than having less lanes he would prefer a traffic jam on the bridge. Lynn Greeley addressed Council stating she feels like she is in Washington, DC and expressed her views in opposition to the project. Skip Hoagland addressed Council noting the traffic problem is not caused by the resident but by allowing too much tourism. He stated tourism needs to be balanced and spoke in opposition to the project. Dee Anthony address Council voicing her concern for Stoney and all the residents on the north end of the Island. She stated her opinion that this will expand further north to all of the neighborhoods including Squire Pope, Gumtree, Spanish Wells, Marshland Road and many vulnerable neighborhoods. Bill Fishburne addressed Council regarding his support for the project noting service workers need to have better access to Hilton Head Island. Melinda Tunner addressed Council stating she has spoken with many residents of Ward 6 and most agree the bridges need replaced but do not want three travel lanes in each direction and most want two bridges as opposed to one structure. Dale Becker addressed Council addressed travel time from Old Town Bluffton to Skull Page 27 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 6/28/2024 Page 5 of 11 Creek noting driving time was 18 minutes, biking time was 46 minutes and walking was three hours. His point was a bike lane is not needed for the structure. John Casey addressed Council stating the document is being produced in a rush and stated his opinion that Beaufort County will not take the Town’s conditions into consideration. He encouraged Council to vote no to the resolutions. Lynn Bullard addressed Council stating the project has been taken from its original purpose with its size and number of lanes. Ashleigh Phillips addressed Council reminding them that however they vote constituents are watching. Thoms C. Barnwell, Jr. addressed Council thanking all Town council, Beaufort County Counsil and staff. He stated the highway needs to be improved, safety needs to be considered and repairs should be completed. He encouraged them to focus on evacuations during hurricane season. Morris Campbell addressed Council stating history is different from everyone’s perspective. He stated the proposal makes sense in securing the Stoney Neighborhood and the residents. He encouraged Council to keep working on it. He stated he realizes the process will take give and take. Rosmary Kimball addressed Council asking that Council not rush this process. She encouraged them to postpone the vote. Linda Harrington addressed Council stating she felt a TIF District is not appropriate. She added that the Greater Island Council is a lobbying group and if any Council members are members of the group, they should recuse themselves from voting on these resolutions. Christopher Cliffe addressed Council needs to invest time and effort into finding a solution to getting traffic coming onto the Island more directly to the Cross Island Parkway and then backing into a bridge design. He emphasized the need to improve safety in the Stoney Community. Jack Alderman addressed Council stating he supports the plan and they involve the best solutions. He feels important criteria includes: quality of life, workforce; community values and economic vitality. Diederick Advocaat addressed Council regarding the need to be a good neighbor. He stated he feels the WHP Advisory Committee has not finished its work and the need for better communication. He encouraged Council to not commit to two or three lanes but to wait to see what works best. Joe Judge addressed Council suggesting the bridge should be repaired rat her than expanding it. Ira Polack signed up and was called on but was not present to speak. Pamela Martin Ovens addressed Council stating the Safety Committee should review this project. She suggested just rebuilding the existing bridge as is and to address the problem with parking with the funds saved. Chuck Lobaugh addressed Council thanking all for the compromise solution to access his building and business from US278 and Old Wild Horse Road. Page 28 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 6/28/2024 Page 6 of 11 Gerald DeVito addressed Council regarding the need for the improvements to deal with traffic congestion and safety issues. John Stewart addressed Council encouraging them to make another way onto the Island. William Stewart addressed Council stating he feels the plan was not properly prepared and was created by misinformed individuals. John Smarszly addressed Council encouraging them to vote no on the resolutions. Louise Cohen addressed Council noting her concerns regarding signage, and the black cemetery. She encouraged Council to replace the bridge but not to destroy things. Steve Robinson addressed Council noting Council should not do what they think they should do but what their constituents want them to do. Lee Lucier addressed Council regarding his support for the project stating it needs Hilton Head Island input and design. A woman who did not identify herself spoke encouraging Council to move forward and listen to make the best decision they can. John Score addressed Council in support of the project stating we need the people that travel to the Island. Ken Campbell addressed Council voicing his support for the project and expressed his appreciation for all the hard work done by everyone and with the conditions and proposals going forward will ensure that it is done right. Frank Babel addressed Council voicing his support for the project encouraging Council to not postpone the project but to move forward. David White addressed Council and encouraged them to give Municipal Consent with conditions. Carol Buxser addressed Council stating the need for the bridge, but the proposed bridge is not designed the appropriate scale and design for Hilton Head Island. She expressed her opinion the bridge should not be 6 lanes and there should not be a bike path. Jerry Cutrer addressed Council and expressed his support for passing the Consent resolution and encouraged Council to vote in favor of it. Cole Peterson addressed Council and expressed his appreciation concerning the attention given to protecting the Gullah Community. He spoke in support of the project and encouraged Council to vote in favor of Municipal consent. Brian Harrington addressed Council stating that there are 11,000 or more people against the project. He encouraged Council to listen to their constituents and wait until all alternatives are in before a decision is made. Mayor Perry stated there was a need to enter into Executive Session for the purpose of advice from legal counsel. At 1:03 p.m. Mr. Ames moved to enter into Executive Session for the purpose stated by the Mayor. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 7-0. At 2:23 p.m. Ms. Brison moved to end Executive Session and return to the meeting. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 7-0. Page 29 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 6/28/2024 Page 7 of 11 Mayor Perry asked if there was any action taken during Executive Session. Mr. Ames stated no actions were taken during Executive Session. Mr. Ames moved to approve the resolution of the Town of Hilton Head Island authorizing a memorandum of Agreement with Beaufort County for the Hilton Head Island Parkway Gateway Corridor Project as presented with the edits provided today. Mr. Alfred seconded. Ms. Brison referenced Item #4 under Sub -Section C which reads up to two pedestrian overpasses and intersection protections. She suggest ed it read s to read: Up to two pedestrian overpasses within the Stoney Historic Community and intersection protections throughout the corridor that will facilitate safe movement of pedestrians and bicyclists across the proposed roadway area. Mr. Ames amended his motion to correspond with Ms. Brison’s recommendation. Mr. Colin was asked to address the inquiry regarding turn lanes on or off Wildhorse Road. Mr. Colin stated that the Wildhorse Road turn lanes remain as they are today. He added that intersection has advanced upgrades with addition right turn lane an a second left turn lane off of Spanish Wells Road. He added there was a provision in the document that speaks to further consideration of left turn restrictions during peak hours which will be assessed with SCDOT. In conclusion, he said there no restriction in the intersection design for left turns. Ms. Becker read a statement from Richard Bisi at his request. Mr. Bisi wrote the decision they are about to make will have ramifications for decades to come and could change the character of our Island. He stated the Advisory Committee has not finished their job and urged Council to vote against Municipal Consent. Ms. Becker made a motion to remove Item 4.c. – the installation of up to two pedestrian overpasses from the document being reviewed for Municipal Consent and MOA and that further work be done to find a solution to bringing that community together. Motion failed due to lack of a second. Ms. Becker made a motion to remove Item 5.a. from the document. Motion failed due to lack of a second. Ms. Becker moved to amend Item 6.d by striking “County Council” as part of the language. Ms. Brison seconded. Mr. Stanford stated the entrance to the bridge is not within Town limits and should require County approval. Mr. Colin added that the entire project is within the County. Clarification was provided that the Design Review Board would only have authority to review the aesthetics as you come through the corridor. After Town Council discussion, Mr. Ames called the question. Motion failed 5-2 (Alfred, Ames, Brown, Perry, Stanford opposed) Ms. Becker had numerous questions and Mr. Colin addressed each one as she asked. Mr. Ames moved to close discussion. Mr. Alfred seconded. Mayor Perry called for the vote. Amended motion carried 6-1 (Becker opposed). Consideration of a Resolution of the Town of Hilton Head Island Authorizing Municipal Consent with the South Carolina Department of Transportation for the Page 30 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 6/28/2024 Page 8 of 11 William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Project Mr. Colin clarified that the current resolution as written will include the amendments made in the earlier vote on the MOA with Beaufort County. Mayor Perry invited Senator Davis to speak. Senator Davis addressed Council stating Secretary Powell made a suggestion that Council deliver the consent and that Council take up the conditions in a separate resolution which would communicate the Town’s expectations and provide a blueprint for the Delegation to try to accomplish the things that the Town deems important in connection with this project. Curtis Coltrane addressed Council explaining explained that following the information delivered by Senator Davis regarding the statements from Secretary Powell, two things have been completed for Council’s consideration. The first is a proposal for a resolution for Municipal Consent with no conditions attached to it. He explained this is the form of Municipal Consent the Secretary delivered to the Town with his correspondence. He clarified it is not the text that is on today’s agenda, or that was included in the agenda packet. If Council should decide that it wished to do this a motion to amend this resolution would be needed in order to conform the document to what the SCDOT wishes to see. Secondly, following the advice of Senator Davis, a second resol ution has been created that expresses the will of Council that includes all of the items that were in the resolution that is on today’s agenda packet, as well as incorporating the Town’s expectation that all of the things set out in Secretary Powell’s correspondence to the mayor will be complied with and including that the Town expects the assistance of the County’s Legislative Delegation to push through the design, construction, and funding of this project in a manner consistent with what the Town wishes. Since this is a new resolution, in order for Council to consider that today, there would need to be a motion and finding by the Town that some form of emergency or exigent circumstance exists and in this case you are facing a deadline of 5:00 p.m. and we have only recently received the advice from the Secretary on what the SCDOT says it requires. Council would then have to amend the agenda to consider adding the resolution which requires a 2/3 vote. Mayor Perry asked for public comment. Christopher Cliffe addressed Council sharing his opinion that rather than using the word will rather than shall within the resolution. He stated he was of the opinion the document was a poor contract. He questioned the timing of Secretary Powell’s response. John Casey addressed Council stating he feels Council is just giving clean consent and a wish list. He doubts Beaufort County will honor the wish list. He feels the conditions should be within the Consent. Mr. Ames moved to amend the proposed resolution by deleting the text of the proposed resolution following the words Project ID Number P030450 in its entirety and replacing it with the following text: Page 31 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 6/28/2024 Page 9 of 11 WHEREAS, the South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) proposed to construct, reconstruct, alter, or improve the certain segments of the highway in the State Highway System referenced above which is located within the corporate limits of the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina (hereinafter, the “Town”). WHEREAS, the Town wishes to authorize the construction and improvements of the aforesaid highway in accordance with the plans to be prepared by or for SCDOT (the “Project Plans”). NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that, pursuant to S. C. Code Ann. § 57-5-820 (2018, as amended), the Town does hereby consent to the construction or improvements of the aforesaid highway within its corporate limits in accordance with the Project Plans, and further, the Town, having reviewed the plans for said construction, does hereby approve said plans as provided in S. C. Code 57-5-830. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the foregoing consent and approval shall be the sole approval necessary from the Town for SCDOT to complete the project under the Project Plans and constitutes a waiver of any and all other requirements with regard to construction within the Town’s limits. The foregoing waiver and consent shall also extend to the benefit of utility companies engaged in relocating utility lines on account of the Project. Further, the Town shall exempt all existing and new right-of-way and all other properties purchased in connection with right-of-way for the Highway from any general or special assessment against real property for municipal services. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Town hereby signifies its intention to faithfully observe the provisions of Chapter 5, Title 56, Code of Laws of South Carolina, 1976, and all amendments thereto relating to the regulation of traffic on the Highway to be constructed, reconstructed, altered or improved as hereinabove identified and further agrees to refrain from placing or maintaining any traffic control devices upon any section of the Highway without having first obtained written approval of the South Carolina Department of Transportation as required by S. C. Code Ann. § 56-5-930 (1976, as amended), or enacting any traffic regulation ordinances inconsistent therewith. Mr. Alfred seconded. Ms. Becker moved to ask for an extension. Motion failed for lack of a second. Ms. Brison objected to being forced with Municipal Consent without conditions she cited clear precedent with SCDOT accepting “conditional consent” for the Cross -Island Parkway and with other jurisdictions. Council held discussion regarding the amendment and process. The Town Attorney clarified the items in question. Mayor Perry called for a vote. Motion passed 4-3 (Bown, Becker and Brison opposed). Mr. Ames moved to approve the resolution authorizing Municipal Consent be given Page 32 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 6/28/2024 Page 10 of 11 to SCDOT, without conditions, as amended. The Mayor called for public comment. Christopher Cliffe stated that the Council should only approve Municipal Conse nt with conditions. After discussion the motion passed 5-2 (Becker and Brison opposed). Mr. Ames moved to amend the agenda to add a resolution regarding the sense of Town Council related to this project and expectations of the Town Council regarding the US278 Corridor, and that the Town is faced with an emergency exigent circumstance related to the deadline that is imposed on the Tow n for the decision on Municipal Consent and the information delivered today by the SCDOT regarding the form of Municipal Consent that is acceptable to the Department in addition to the emergent and exigent circumst ance. The text in the proposed resolution is the same text that is in the proposed Municipal Consent Resolution that was attached to the agenda for today’s meeting, meaning that nothing in the proposed resolution to be added to the agenda is ne w, rather it is a change of the methodology. Mr. Alfred seconded. Concluding discussion by the Council , the motion carried 6-1 (Becker opposed). Consideration of a Resolution of the Town of Hilton Head Island Expressing the Sense of the Town Council Regarding Compliance with Elements of the U.S, Highway 278 Corridor Project. Shawn Colin approached the dais and explained the resolution that was added to the agenda. Council further discussed the MOA with the County and the prepared resolution with the conditions in detail. Mayor Perry asked for public comment. Christopher Cliffe addressed Council noting Council’s responsibilities are to the Town and Secretary Powell’s responsibilities are to the SCDOT. He said with the Town signing off on the MOA with the County and the resolution for Municipal Consent with the SCDOT , there is no way of enforcing the conditions in this resolution. The Council held further discussion on the proposed resolution. Mr. Ames moved for Council to approve a resolution of the Town Council for the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, expressing the sense of the Town Council regarding the project to improve the US Highway 278 Corridor from the intersection of US Highway 278 and Moss Creek Drive to the Intersection of US Highway 278 and Spanish Wells Road and Wildhorse Road. Mr. Standford seconded. After points of view by various Council members were given Mayor Perry called for a vote. Motion carried 6-1 (Becker opposed). Public Comment - Non Agenda Items None. Page 33 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 6/28/2024 Page 11 of 11 Adjournment The meeting adjourned at 4:26 p.m. Approved: Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk Alan R. Perry, Mayor The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov Page 34 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 8/20/2024 Page 1 of 10 Town of Hilton Head Island TOWN COUNCIL MEETING Tuesday, August 20, 2024, 3:00 PM Minutes Call to Order Mayor Perry called the meeting to order at 3:00 p.m. Council Members present: Alan Perry, Mayor, David Ames, Ward 3, Mayor Pro- Tempore; Alex Brown, Ward 1; Patsy Brison, Ward 2; Tammy Becker, Ward 4; Steve Alfred, Ward 5; Glenn Stanford, Ward 6 (via Microsoft Teams) Also present: Marc Orlando, Town Manager; Curtis Coltrane, Town Attorney; Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk Invocation – Rabbi Brad Bloom, Congregation Beth Yam Rabbi Bloom delivered the invocation. Adoption of the Agenda Mr. Alfred moved to approve. Ms. Becker seconded. Motion carried 7-0. Approval of the Minutes Regular Meeting Minutes of June 18, 2024 Regular Meeting Minutes of July 23, 2024 Emergency Meeting Minutes of August 6, 2024 Mr. Ames moved to approve the above referenced minutes. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 7-0. Report of the Town Manager Mr. Orlando provided a synopsis and after-action report regarding the recent tropical storm Debby. He extended his appreciation to Town Council, the Community and Town staff for their efforts during the storm. Mr. Orlando stated that beginning on August 2, staff initiated communication with private communities, golf courses, property management agencies to warn them of the potential risks associated with Debby and urged them to lower water surface elevations and lagoon systems to maximize storm water storage capacity and to clean all drainage system intakes. The Town inspected critical components of the Town’s drainage infrastructure, including the four pump stations, major controls structures and primary channels and outfalls. Staff cleared the beach of items that would cause problems and stabilized Town facilities and parks. Page 35 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 8/20/2024 Page 2 of 10 Tropical storm Debbie began affecting Hilton Head on the evening of August 4 and the Town was warned that a total of 30 inches of rain was anticipated for our area. While the storm did not bring 30 inches of rain to us, Hilton Head Island received 10 inches of rainfall from Sunday to Wednesday and two feet of storm surge in and around the same time at high tide. Palmetto Electric reported three outages which resulted in 5700 customers without service. They returned power quickly. Mr. Orlando referenced the mobile application MyHHI that is available to residents for reporting issues during these events. He stated there were close to 30 requests through the MyHHI applications which were addressed before the Emergency Operations Center closed. Through a request by the Gullah Geechee Historic Neighborhood Development Corporation, as well as Fire Rescue Staff several wellness checks were conducted. Staff responded to several reports of flooding across the Island and staff responded as quickly as possible to verify, assess, document and help with the situation. He referenced two of the areas affected by flooding which were Helmsman Way and Sea Olive Road in Point Comfort. Staff and a team from SCDOT were able to restore flow to the drainage structure on Helmsman Way and the Sea Olive Road blockage was cleared with assistance from the Department of Transportation Beaufort Maintenance Office. Mr. Orlando reported that the pump stations (Lawton, Jarvis Creek and Wexford) pumped over four hundred and forty-one million gallons of water within 161 hours. He stated there were a total of seven damaged structures (5 residential and 2 commercial), mostly due to flooding issues. Mr. Orlando stated that there are over 75 after-action items from staff which will be used for future preparation and response to these types of disasters. An example for future preparation is the need for sandbags to be dropped on Hilton Head Island. It was learned that Beaufort County did provide them to Bluffton and the northern part of the County but due to limited staff, they could not include Hilton Head Island. He stated that if we need sandbags in the future, a partnership will need to be formed with the County going forward. Staff coordinated with the County regarding ditch maintenance issues, and they are working on improvements. The Emergency Management Dashboard will be improved for staff, Council, and community access, along with a daily situation report which will be distributed to Council and shared with the community as a whole. Mr. Orlando stated the need to assess options to position a Jet Vac truck to provide timely responses during future incidents. He expressed appreciation to the SCDOT for having a Jet Vac truck close by and to Beaufort County for mobilizing with the Town. Mr. Orlando stated that Jarvis Creek, Lawton, Wexford pump stations and the Shipyard booster-pump station are key in the line of defense against flooding. He explained Jarvis Creek pumps water from 1000 acres into Jarvis Creek, Lawton Station protects 2000 acres by pumping to Lawton Creek and Wexford manages water flow into Broad Creek that services a 1500-acre watershed. He noted these pump stations are not just for immediate areas but for significant surrounding areas and are designed to operate during these extreme events demonstrating resilience and preparedness for our community. Page 36 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 8/20/2024 Page 3 of 10 Mr. Orlando expressed his appreciation to the leadership and staff for a job well done. Hilton Head Island Destination Marketing Organization (DMO) Quarterly Report - Angie Stone, Assistant Town Manager Ms. Stone addressed Council stating that staff has worked closely with the Designated Marketing Organization (DMO) to ensure alignment of their efforts on the Town’s behalf with the destination values Council has articulated. The report not only provides an insight into the activities the DMO is taking on the Town’s behalf, but also gives Council an opportunity to ask questions of the DMO Leadership. She introduced Ariana Pernice, Vice President of the Visitors and Convention Bureau. Ms. Pernice noted the report encompasses April, May and June of 2024. She informed Council that the New York Times highlighted Andrew Carmine’s efforts surrounding mariculture and how he brings that forward through his efforts. The article touches on our ecotourism. She emphasized the importance of the article highlighting the destination which is Hilton Head Island. She noted the results of the article with an outreach of 366,783 in print circulation, and 143 million in UVPM/Digital audience. In terms of paid media partnerships, the DMO is working closely with Kingdom Magazine. There was piece which was a three-page run that was in the magazine from April through July. The distribution was over 205,000 and the readership is over 780,00. More importantly the piece speaks to that high end consumer. The Smithsonian is another paid media partnership which uncovers the surprising history of Hilton Head Island’s 16 th Century Capital. The native article drives awareness of Hilton Head Island and highlights partners in the arts, culture and history sectors, combined with a digital campaign. Full performance results will be finalized at the conclusion of the campaign which runs from May through August 2024 and published in the next report. She stated the piece has over one million impressions to date. Ms. Pernice stated that during Covid and post Covid a focus was on the domestic traveler but since Covid international focus is an important piece to the conversation of travel and tourism. She referenced the international relationships regarding paid media one of which is Wallpaper Magazine – The Travel Issue. Wallpaper is an international publication focused on design and architecture, fashion, travel, art, and lifestyle. She noted a 1.7 million digital audience and over 100 thousand print distribution. Conde’ Nast Traveler campaign with dates from October 2023- June 2024. She reviewed results of the media partnership which resulted in 21.5 million impressions, 1.9 million views of the video and 214,000 TikTok views that viewed the video in its entirety. Ms. Pernice noted the importance of the Hilton Head Island Official Vacation Planner. The Vacation Planner brings our destination into the homes of our visitors, further instilling our core values and key attributes while serving as a planning tool for those looking to travel to Hilton Head Island. The distribution Page 37 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 8/20/2024 Page 4 of 10 consists of online requests, phone inquiries, Savannah Airport, Hilton Head Island Airport, South Carolina Welcome Centers, AAA offices nationwide, hotel partners and tradeshows and events. There is a total of 85,00 printed with a quarterly distribution of 13,050. She informed Council the Vacation Planner has been recognized for the best in the country which is very exciting. Destination website and social media resulted in the following: The combination of website analytics and social media insights empowers data-driven decision- making, ensuring adaptability and responsiveness to digital out-marketing efforts. There was a total of 986 thousand visits/sessions, 789,000 users and 400,000 partner referrals. Top pages visited included the Homepage, Things to Do, Dining and Offers. Based on available data women made up the largest percentage of visitation, while users within the 55-64 age range visited the website most frequently. The DMO has started capturing how many posts are made regarding Wellness, Recreation, Arts & Culture, Ecotourism and History. She reported the top three posts for the fourth quarter were regarding the Sea Turtles. A review of the data regarding hotels, home and villa rentals the fourth quarter was down 8%, with ADR up 2% and Rev PAR was down 6%. She noted this is being monitored and they are working with hoteliers. They have made adjustments with content and are tracking, articulating and communicating with partners in the community regarding efforts the DMO can do to adjust as well as what they can do to help support the needs in the marketplace. Members of Council asked questions, made comments and held discussion regarding: appreciation that the DMO is highlighting community values; inquiry as to the efforts regarding shoulder travel versus summer travel; confirmation that the DMO does not focus is on bringing visitors to the Island during the summer time frame but focus is on off-season and early spring time frame to ensure that brand awareness efforts are working; a request to see how the DMO is doing the focus of attracting visitors in those time frames; inquiry as to whether the decline in occupancy is industry wide; confirmation the decline is national; confirmation the statistics being presented are specifically for the 4 th quarter report versus the 4 th quarter report of the previous year; inquiry regarding pre-Covid comparisons; a request to separate input from residents and visitors; inquiry regarding social media posts regarding the community values; confirmation posts are a combination of both user generated and DMO assets; a suggestion to draw them evenly or focus on the ones that don’t have as many posts; the need for itinerary focused suggestions for the five Community Values; the need for a return on investment regarding the Community Values; and an inquiry into the forecasts for future months and the need to have that information going forward on a regular basis. General Reports from Town Council Ms. Brison congratulated Fire Chief Joheida Fister for receiving the 2024 Page 38 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 8/20/2024 Page 5 of 10 Presidential Award from APCO which is a 911 Communications Council. Mayor Perry noted the following upcoming workshops: September 16 – Priority Amendments of the LMO September 24 – District Plans October 8 – Major Thoroughfares Plan/Adaptive Signals October 22 – Beach Renourishment Resiliency Update/Stormwater Utility Update He noted Senator Davis was in attendance at tonight’s meeting and thanked him for his presence. Report of the Lowcountry Area Transportation Study – Glenn Stanford Mr. Stanford reported that at a recent meeting there was a review of long-term plans. He stated they are seeking input on public transportation issued and encouraged all to go to the website and complete the survey. He stated that there was an emphasis on what is going on with the expansion and widening of I-95. He said there are plans to widen I-95 from the border up to Exit 8 which is the Hilton Head Island exit and it is projected to be completed in six years. Report of the Lowcountry Council of Governments – Tammy Becker No report. Report of the Beaufort County Airports Board – David Ames No report. Report of the Southern Lowcountry Regional Board – Glenn Stanford No report. Report of the Island Recreation Association Board – Alex Brown Mr. Brown reported the Board and staff members met for an Annual Planning Session with discussion regarding short- and long-term goals resulting in a change regarding working committees. He stated the Island Recreation Center website is now in English and Spanish. Report of the Community Services and Public Safety Committee – Tammy Becker Ms. Becker reported the Committee met on August 19 to discuss a parking fee implementation. After a presentation by Mr. Gruber, the Committee held discussion and heard public comments regarding the item and voted in favor of moving the recommendation forward to Town Council for review and consideration. Report of the Public Planning Committee – David Ames Mr. Ames reported the Committee met on July 22 and heard a report from the Lowcountry Regional Transportation Authority regarding the Palmetto Breeze Annual Service Plan. The report included updates regarding the trolley service, beach shuttle service and the future capital and systems improvements. Following the report the Committee voted to request the Town Manager investigate alternative strategies to address transportation challenges and opportunities for regional and Island services Page 39 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 8/20/2024 Page 6 of 10 with the goal of increasing ridership. Report of the Finance and Administrative Committee – Alex Brown No report. Unfinished Business Consideration of an Ordinance of the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina Authorizing the Execution and Delivery of Easements to the Hilton Head Public Service District Encumbering Real Estate Owned by the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina Under the Authority of S.C. Code Ann. Section 5-7-40 and Section 2- 7-20, Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, and Providing for Severability and an Effective Date - Second and Final Reading - Josh Gruber, Deputy Town Manager Mayor Perry noted this item was approved unanimously at the first reading held on July 23rd. He asked if members of Council felt the need for a presentation at this time. All were in agreement there was no need for a presentation. Mr. Ames moved to approve. Mr. Alfred seconded. There were no requests for public comment. Motion carried 7-0. New Business Consideration of a Resolution Authorizing the Town Manager to Execute an Intergovernmental Agreement with Beaufort County for the William Hilton Parkway Safety and Pedestrian Improvements from Beach City Road to Dillon Road and along Palmetto Bay Road - Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager Mr. Colin stated this is an execution step in a project Town Council has supported. He proceeded to conduct a presentation. In January 2024, Town Staff and Beaufort County began discussions relating to potential funding available for projects on Hilton Head Island. Beaufort County advised that County Impact Fee funding was available for projects that improve safety or improve capacity on William Hilton Parkway and Palmetto Bay Road with the intent that they be completed by October 2024. The two projects recommended by Staff are projects that meet the criteria and can be accomplished by the October 2024 deadline: • William Hilton Parkway - Northridge Area Segment 3 Safety Improvements This project will update crosswalk pavement markings and replace existing pedestrian crossing signs with a push button rectangular rapid flashing beacon (RRFB). • William Hilton Parkway and Palmetto Bay Road Intersection Safety Improvements, Signage and Pavement Marking This project will update pavement markings, street signs, and make safety Page 40 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 8/20/2024 Page 7 of 10 improvements to intersections. The IGA is in the amount of $600,000 and was unanimously approved by Beaufort County Council on April 8, 2024. On July 9, 2024, the Finance & Administrative Committee voted unanimously to recommend this Resolution to Town Council for approval. Members of Council asked questions, made comments and held discussion regarding: appreciation to staff for moving the item forward; acknowledgment of appreciation to County Council for providing funding for this project; and confirmation that staff is trying to obtain approval for puck lighting in the crosswalks and a reduction in the posted speed limit to 35 mph. Consideration of a Resolution to Support a Best Buddies Certified Inclusive Playground at Shelter Cove Community Park - Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager In April 2024, the Town was approached by Miracle Recreation and Best Buddies regarding a collaborative partnership to bring inclusive playgrounds to communities across the United States, including Hilton Head Island. Miracle Recreation, a playground manufacturer for nearly a century, and Best Buddies, a nonprofit dedicated to creating opportunities for friendship, employment, leadership development and inclusive living for people with intellectual and developmental disabilities (IDD), have announced an ambitious program to develop Best Buddies commercial playgrounds and Buddy Benches. Best Buddies-Miracle Recreation playgrounds will be designed to provide a new standard of best-in-class inclusive and accessible playground equipment for all ages and abilities. Best Buddies + Miracle Recreation Inclusive Playgrounds are intentionally designed so children of all abilities and their caregivers can play, be challenged and have fun together. Their playgrounds go beyond wheelchair accessibility to include designs and features that support the needs kids with intellectual and developmental disabilities, so everyone has a truly inclusive, inviting and enjoyable playground experience. Miracle Recreation and Best Buddies expect to have their Buddy Benches and first inclusive playgrounds installed in 2024. Staff believes the recently approved Shelter Cove Community Park expansion provides the best opportunity to participate in this program. The Shelter Cove Community Park master plan includes a new, larger, inclusive playground in the park programming components. Staff received Parks and Recreation Commission input on the program and their recommendation for approval to Town Council. Best Buddies is a nonprofit 501(c)(3) organization dedicated to establishing a global volunteer movement that creates opportunities for one-to-one friendships, integrated employment, leadership development and inclusive living for people with intellectual and developmental disabilities (IDD). Founded in 1989 by Anthony K. Shriver, Best Buddies is a vibrant organization that has grown from one original chapter to nearly 3,000 middle school, high school, and college chapters worldwide. Today, Best Page 41 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 8/20/2024 Page 8 of 10 Buddies’ 11 formal programs - Elementary Schools, Middle Schools, High Schools, Colleges, Citizens, e-Buddies®, Jobs, Ambassadors, Promoters, Transitions and Inclusive Living - engage participants in each of the 50 United State and in 49 countries, positively impacting the lives of nearly one million people with and without disabilities around the world. In many cases, as a result of their involvement with Best Buddies, people with intellectual and developmental disabilities secure rewarding jobs, live on their own, become inspirational leaders, and make lifelong friendships. For more information, please visit www.bestbuddies.org. In April 2022, Staff and their consultant team developed a project scope for the expansion of Shelter Cove Community Park, which has been open to the public since 2015. The scope of work identified opportunities for enhancements to park amenities including vehicular parking, playground expansion, and views to Broad Creek. The Master Plan for Shelter Cove Community Park includes the following improvements: • Expansion of the existing park’s Promenade, • Pathway network through an existing forested area, • Expanded passive open lawn spaces with public art, • A larger, more inclusive playground, • Additional vehicular parking, and • Iconic overlook structure with views of Broad Creek. On April 18, 2023, Town Council voted unanimously to adopt the Master Plan for Shelter Cove Community Park Town Council recently approved funding in the FY25 Capital Budget for the final design and permitting for the park. On July 11, 2024, the Parks & Recreation Commission voted unanimously (6-0) to recommend Town Council consider supporting the Best Buddies certified playground. If this is approved by Town Council, Staff would work with our park design team and the Miracle Recreation representatives to design a playground that is Best Buddies certified and appropriate for Hilton Head Island. Miracle Recreation equipment can be purchased from a cooperative purchasing program that allows the Town to purchase equipment from existing, competitively solicited contracts. Cooperative purchasing is “Procurement conducted by, or on behalf of, one or more Public Procurement Units” as defined by the American Bar Association Model Procurement Code for State and Local Governments. This form of competitive purchasing meets the Contracting/Procurement requirements established in Title 11 of the Town’s Municipal Code. Sue Churchich provided background regarding Best Buddies stating that Miricle and Best Buddies came together early in the year which resulted in producing a very Best Buddy specific playground. She noted this will create another identity for the Town of Hilton Head Island in attracting visitors to the Island. Mr. Ames moved to approve. Ms. Brison seconded. Page 42 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 8/20/2024 Page 9 of 10 There were no requests for public comment. Members of Council asked questions, made comments and held discussion regarding: consensus the choice of Shelter Cove Park for the location is a good one; an inquiry to define the partnership; confirmation the Town will fund the entire project; confirmation the Town will coordinate on the design and integration of the program elements within the park playground before executing the project; and confirmation this makes us an inclusive community. Motion carried 7-0. Public Comment - Non Agenda Items Richard Bisi address Council stating he felt Council granting Municipal Consent to a deeply flawed project will go down in history. He expressed his dissatisfaction in Town Council’s actions. Melinda Tunner addressed Council stating granting Municipal Consent is just one step in a very long process and the building of the new bridge and roadways is estimated to be completed by the end of 2030. She encouraged all to focus on things that can be done to control traffic during the meantime. Executive Session Discussion of Negotiations Incident to Proposed Contractual Arrangements and Discussions for the Proposed Sale or Purchase of Property (Pursuant to the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act Section 30-4-70 (a)(1)) related to: 1. Pope Avenue Area 2. St. James Baptist Church Relocation 3. Marshland Road Area 4. South Forest Beach Drive Area 5. Easement Requests by the South Island Public Service District a. Pope Avenue b. William Hilton Parkway c. Wexford Drive 6. Mitchelville Road Area 7. Beach City Road Area Discussion of the Employment, Appointment, Compensation, Promotion, Demotion, Discipline, or Release of a Person Regulated by a Public Body (Pursuant to South Carolina Freedom of Information Act 30-4-70 (a)(1)) related to: 8. Discussion of the Annual Performance Review of the Town Attorney and Contractual Matters Related Hereto At 4:33 p.m. Mr. Ames moved to enter into Executive Session for the purposes Page 43 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes 8/20/2024 Page 10 of 10 stated by the Town Manager listed above. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 7- 0. At 6:36 p.m. Mr. Ames moved to end Executive Session and return to the meeting. Ms. Brison seconded. Motion carried 6-0. (Mr. Stanford was not in attendance at this time.) Action from Executive Session Mr. Ames moved that the Town Council authorize the Town Manager to execute and deliver a revocable license agreement by and between the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, and the Beach House Owner, LLC, granting the Town and its contractors a right of entry over the property of the Beach House Owner, LLC, for access to the Beaches of the Atlantic Ocean. Ms. Becker seconded. Motion carried 6-0. Mr. Ames moved that the Town Council authorize the Mayor and Town Manager to execute and deliver the agreement by and between the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, and 69 Pope LLC, for the purchase and sale of 1.286 acres, more or less, on Pope Avenue, and to take such other and further actions as may be necessary to complete the transaction described in the agreement. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 6-0. Mr. Ames moved to extend the contract with the Town of Hilton Head Island Town Attorney for an additional 12 months, under the same terms and conditions. Ms. Becker seconded. Motion carried 6-0. Adjournment Mr. Ames moved to adjourn. Ms. Becker seconded. Motion carried 6-0. Approved: Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk Alan R. Perry, Mayor The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov Page 44 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Meeting Minutes Page 1 of 1 8/20/2024 Town of Hilton Head Island TOWN COUNCIL SPECIAL MEETING Thursday, August 29, 2024, 11:00 AM Minutes Call to Order Mayor Perry called the meeting to order at 11:00 a.m. Council Members present: Alan Perry, Mayor, David Ames, Ward 3, Mayor Pro-Tempore; Alex Brown, Ward 1; Tammy Becker, Ward 4 (via Microsoft Teams);Steve Alfred, Ward 5; Glenn Stanford, Ward 6 Council Member absent: Patsy Brison, Ward 2 Also present: Marc Orlando, Town Manager; Curtis Coltrane, Town Attorney; Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk Adoption of the Agenda Mr. Ames moved to approve. Mr. Stanford seconded. Motion carried 6-0. Public Comment - Non Agenda Items None. Executive Session Discussion of Negotiations Incident to Proposed Contractual Arrangements for the Proposed Sale or Purchase of Property [Pursuant to the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act Section 30-4-70(a)(2)] related to: 1. Mitchellville Road Area At 11:03 a.m. Mr. Ames moved to enter into Executive Session for the purposes stated by the Town Manager listed above. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 6-0. At 11:48 Mr. Ames moved to end Executive Session and return to the meeting. Stanford seconded. Motion carried 6-0. Action from Executive Session None. Adjournment The meeting was adjourned at 11:49 a.m. Approved: Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk __________________________ Alan R. Perry, Mayor The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov Page 45 of 329 __________________________________________________________________________ RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Town Council consider the recommendations of the Community Services and Public Safety Committee regarding the establishment of a paid Beach Parking Program and a corresponding Resolution setting forth p arking rates and other ancillary matters. This evaluation should consider various public policy implications and strategic objectives related to beach parking, traffic management, and the corresponding revenues and expenses of operating a beach parking program. ANALYSIS: The Town has been exploring the establishment of a paid beach parking program since the adoption of a Beach Parking Master Plan by Town Council on November 4, 2020. Copies of this Master Plan and the corresponding tasks completed by Walker Consultants as a precursor to developing this Plan can be found on the Town’s website at the following address: https://hiltonheadislandsc.gov/parkingstudy/home.cfm Following the adoption of the Beach Parking Master Plan, the Town began implementing the Plan’s recommendations. This included procuring the services of a professional parking management organization, PCI Municipal Services, who began managing the Town’s beach parking in February 2023. Additional recommendations included updating the Town’s Code relative to overall parking management, administration, and enforcement. The attached Ordinance has been prepared to accomplish this particular recommendation. This document was initially considered by the Community Services and Public Safety Committee and recommended for consideration by the Town Council on September 18, 2023. However, the decision was made to with hold further consideration of the Ordinance until the corresponding Resolution setting forth proposed parking rates and other relevant criteria c ould also be considered contemporaneously with Town Council’s consideration of this Ordinance. In the interim, members of the Community Services and Public Safety Committee as well as members of Town Council have TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND TOWN COUNCIL TO: Town Council Members FROM: Joshua Gruber, Deputy Town Manager CC: Marc Orlando, Town Manager DATE: September 17, 2024 SUBJECT: Consideration of An Ordinance of the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina Amending Title 12, Chapter 3, of the Municipal Code Entitled: Motor Vehicles and Traffic Control, Parking, to Revise Regulations Related to Paid Parking and Other Matters Related Thereto, and to Provide for Severability and an Effective Date Page 46 of 329 Page 2 of 3 requested revisions to better reflect the full complement of policy recommendations arising from the Committee and to revise other verbiage that is not of a substantive nature. As such, this document has been updated to incorporate those proposed revisions and should be considered by the Town Council in its revised state. A. Core Objectives of Beach Parking Management Ordinance. • Establish a general policy framework for beach parking that is intended to influence beach parking decisions, promote public safety, parking accessibility, and convenience of beachgoers while promoting the efficient use of parking resources. • Remove antiquated language and allow for new parking technology solutions. • Define paid beach parking areas but allow for the implementation of paid parking rates within any or all these beach parking areas as established by separate Resolution. • Develop rules and regulations for administration of the beach parking program and corresponding enforcement measures to ensure compliance. B. Beach Parking Management Ordinance Structure. The Beach Parking Management Ordinance has been structured to offer clarity, ensuring that every stakeholder has a comprehensive understanding of its purpose and the expectations therein. A breakdown of the structure for this proposed Ordinance is as follows: 1. Purpose and intent statement. This section articulates the expressed goals and objectives of the ordinance, establishing a rationale behind its formulation. 2. Definitions section. Here, we provide clear interpretations of all terms and terminologies used within the ordinance, ensuring that there is no ambiguity for readers. 3. Designation of paid parking areas. This section identifies the areas where paid parking may be implemented, thus giving clarity on what Town -owned properties may or may not require payment to park. 4. Fees, payment, and enforcement. This section details information on the applicable parking fees, modes and methods of payment, and the mechanisms in place for enforcing the stipulated payment requirements. 5. Exemptions. This section lists the specific cases or individuals who might be exempted from adhering to certain rules or payments under this ordinance. Page 47 of 329 Page 3 of 3 6. Resident beach pass. This section details the privileges and processes associated with obtaining a beach parking pass for residents of Hilton Head Island. 7. Rules and regulations. This section clearly spells out certain behavior that is prohibited in the paid parking areas (e.g., no parking outside of the hours of operation). 8. Administrative penalties and fines. This section outlines a graduated penalty schedule for violations of the ordinance. 9. Appeals. This section explains the t hree-tiered appeals process, first to PCI Municipal Services, then to the Town Attorney, and finally, to a court. CONCLUSION: The proposed Beach Parking Management Ordinance, previously reviewed and recommended for adoption by the C ommunity Services and Public Safety Committee, has been updated to reflect the Committee’s and Town Council member’s input, including the elimination of resident beach parking pass fees and the exemption of Chaplin Beach Park from paid parking during youth recreation seasons. The Town Council is requested to review the provisions outlined in the Beach Parking Management Ordinance and provide policy guidance regarding the adoption of the proposed language contained therein. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Beach Parking Management Ordinance Draft 2. Beach Parking Resolution Draft Page 48 of 329 TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA AMENDING TITLE 12, CHAPTER 3, OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, ENTITLED: MOTOR VEHICLES AND TRAFFIC CONTROL, PARKING, TO REVISE REGULATIONS RELATED TO PAID PARKING AND OTHER MATTERS RELATED THERETO, AND TO PROVIDE FOR SEVERABILITY AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE WHEREAS, the Town Council of the Town of Hilton Head Island has authority to establish paid parking within designated paid parking areas pursuant to Section 12- 3-111, et seq. of the Municipal Code of Hilton Head Island; and WHEREAS, to provide for a more comprehensive and effective paid parking program, the Town Council now desires to amend the Municipal Code for the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina as further outlined herein; and WHEREAS, through the enactment of this Ordinance, the Town Council desires to control demand and influence beach parking decisions, communicate timely information on beach parking availability and alternative parking options, provide paid parking areas that are safe/secure, provide a paid parking program that is convenient, user friendly, and provides superior customer service, and protects adjoining neighborhoods and businesses from paid parking/overflow impacts. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT, AND IT HEREBY IS, ORDAINED BY THE TOWN COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA: Section 1. Amendment. Revisions to Sections 12-3-111 through 12-6-120 of the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island relating to the establishment of paid parking areas, creation of a parking management program, and parking enforcement measures, are hereby adopted as outlined in Attachment 1 attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference . Newly added language is illustrated with double underline and deleted language is illustrated with strikethrough. Section 2. Severability . If any section, phrase, sentence or portion of this Ordinance is for any reason held invalid or unconstitutional by a court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed a separate, distinct, and independent provision, and such holding shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions thereof. Section 3: Effective Date. This Ordinance shall take effect on January 1, 2025. MOVED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED THIS ____DAY OF ______________, 2024. _______________________________ Alan R. Perry, Mayor Page 49 of 329 ATTEST: ___________________________________ Kimberely Gammon, Town Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: ___________________________________ Curtis Coltrane, Town Attorney Introduced by Council Member: ____________________________ Page 50 of 329 ATTACHMENT 1 Chapter 3 - PARKING Sec. 12-3-111. - Authority to establish parking zones and install meters paid parking areas. The town council may establish by resolution, from time to time as traffic conditions require, zones to be known as parking meter zones paid parking areas upon such streets or properties of the town as are selected by the town council for the location of such meters designation; and, in such parking meter zones paid parking areas, the town manager shall cause parking meters to be installed and parking meter spaces appropriate signage and notification of paid parking equipment or other similar electronic paid parking capabilities to be designated as hereinafter provided. Sec. 12-3-112. - Location and operation of meters paid parking areas. Parking meters installed in the parking meter zones established by the provisions of this article shall be placed upon the curb immediately adjacent to the individual parking places hereinafter described. Each parking meter shall be placed or set in such a manner as to show or display by a signal that the parking space adjacent to such meter is or is not legally in use. Each parking meter shall be installed and set to display, upon the deposit of an official coin of the United States of America, which is at the time legal tender, a signal indicating legal parking for a designa ted time period. Each meter shall also be arranged so that, upon the expiration of the legal parking time, it will indicate by a mechanical operation and the dropping of the proper signal that the lawful parking has expired. The town manager shall be authorized to establish the parking fees. The town manager shall take such actions as may be necessary and appropriate to implement the collection and corresponding enforcement of paid parking areas as designated by the town council. These actions shall include the posting of necessary signage, the installation of paid parking infrastructure, and the implementation of a comprehensive paid parking program either directly or through contracting with appropriate entities as may be required to effectuate the directives of the town council. Sec. 12-3-114. - Depositing coins. When any vehicle shall be parked in any space alongside of or next to which a parking meter is located in accordance with the provisions of this article, the operator of such vehicle shall, upon entering the parking space, immediately deposit or cause to be deposited a coin of the United States of America, which is, at the time, legal tender, in such parking meter and the parking space may then be lawfully occupied by such vehicle during the period indicated on the meter. If such vehicle shall remain parked in any such parking space beyond the parking time limit, the parking meter shall display a sign or signal showing illegal parking or expiration of time allotted, and in that event, such vehicle shall be considered as parked overtime. Overtime means beyond the period of legal parking time. The parking of a vehicle overtime in any such part of a street where any such meter is located shall be a violation of this article. Sec. 12-3-117. - Defacing, injuring, etc. Page 51 of 329 It shall be unlawful for any person to deface, injure, tamper with, open or willfully break, destroy or impair the usefulness of any parking meter signage or devise installed under the provisions of this article. Sec. 12-3-118. - Violations; parking enforcement personnel to report; notices; penalty. (a) It shall be the duty of the enforcement officer of the town town, the designated parking contractor of the Town, or the Beaufort County Sheriff’ to report: 1. The number of each parking meter identity of each paid parking area which indicates that the vehicle occupying the a designed parking space adjacent to such parking meter within such paid parking area is or has been parked in violation of any of the provisions of this article Chapter; and 2. The state license number of such vehicle; and 3. Any other facts, knowledge of which is necessary to a thorough understanding of the circumstances surrounding such violation. (b) Each such parking enforcement officer community code enforcement officer, designated town staff member, designated parking contractor, or member of the Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office shall also attach to such vehicle a notice to the owner thereof that such vehicle has been parked in violation of a provision of this article stating the bond set by the town for said violation the administrative penalty associated with such violation . Every person who violates or fails to comply with any of the provisions of this article shall be punished for each such violation as provided for in section 1-5-10 of this Code. (c) In any parking meter zone paid parking area, every hour or fraction of an hour of overtime parking shall constitute a separate offense. Sec. 12-3-121. - Penalties for delinquent parking fines. The following penalties are hereby established for delinquent parking fines: (a) Delinquent after 10 days, add .....$10.00 (b) After every 30 days add an additional .....10.00 (c) Maximum penalty .....40.00 ARTICLE 6 - Beach Parking Management Sec. 12-6-110. - Purpose and Intent. Page 52 of 329 The purpose of this Article is to establish regulations for the management of paid parking areas for public beach access within the jurisdiction of the Town of Hilton Head Island. The intent of this Article is to promote the effective use of parking resources and ensure the public safety, accessibility, and convenience of beachgoers, while minimizing adverse effects on the neighboring environment. Sec. 12-6-111. - Definitions. Paid Parking Area. Any area designated by the town requiring payment to park therein. Parking Contractor. The town or its designed vendor to manage the beach parking program. Resident. For purposes of this Article, resident shall mean: (a) Any person who owns any single or multi -family residence in the municipal limits of the Town, irrespective of whether the person qualifies for the 4% special assessment ratio except: 1. The owner of a property that is offered for leases of any term of more than 183 days in any calendar year is not deemed a “resident” eligible for a beach parking pass based on the ownership of that property. (b) Any person who is a tenant under a lease for a single or multi-family residence for a period of 183 days or more in any calendar year. (c) Any person who owns time-share interests totaling more than 183 days per year. Sec. 12-6-112. – Designation of paid parking areas. The following areas are designated as paid parking areas: (a) Alder Lane Beach Park (b) Chaplin Beach Park (c) Coligny Beach Park (d) Driessen Beach Park (e) Fish Haul Beach Park (f) Folly Field Beach Park (g) Islanders Beach Park The Town Council shall determine the appropriate rates for the paid parking areas by resolution. Page 53 of 329 The town manager or designee shall install and maintain appropriate signs indicating the boundaries of the paid parking areas and the parking rates established therefore. Sec. 12-6-113. – Fees, payment, and enforcement. (a) The parking fees for any paid parking area shall be established by a resolution of the town council. (b) Any person who parks a vehicle in a paid parking area must pay the appropriate fee as specified by the town or designated parking contractor. (c) Payment shall be made through the designated payment mechanism installed by the town of designated parking contractor or otherwise provided for electronically for the express purpose of paying for a designated parking space. (d) The town or designated parking contractor shall enforce the payment of parking fees and may issue administrative citations or take other appropriate measures to ensure compliance, including but not limited to vehicle immobilization and/or towing. Sec. 12-6-114. - Exemptions. (a) The following vehicles shall be exempt from payment of parking fees: 1. Vehicles of emergency responders while engaged in official duties; 2. Vehicles of disabled persons displaying appropriate placards or license plates; and 3. Vehicles of authorized Town employees engaged in official duties. (b) The town manager may establish additional exemptions during permitted special events. (c) Vehicles which have been registered pursuant to the Town’s Resident Beach Parking Pass program shall be exempt from the payment of parking fees. Sec. 12-6-115. – Resident beach pass. (a) The town shall issue resident beach parking passes to residents who can prove primary residency within the Town of Hilton Head Island as defined in Section 12-6-111. Resident beach parking passes will allow residents to park within the paid parking areas during the established hours of operation without paying the daily parking fees as designated by the town council. (b) Qualified residents of Hilton Head Island shall be entitled to receive a maximum of two beach parking passes per household. Beginning in calendar year 2025, the beach parking passes provided for in this section shall be issued without charge. However, the t own council shall have the right to assess a fee for these passes in the future and shall be Page 54 of 329 authorized to set such fee by the adoption of a corresponding resolution setting forth this amount. (c) Residents who receive a beach parking pass are subject to the parking regulations of this Article. (d) The town may revoke or refuse to issue resident beach passes for individuals who violate this Article. Sec. 12-6-116. – Defrauding, opening, impairing, or damaging paid parking devices. It shall be unlawful for any person to defraud, open, impair, or damage a paid parking device or related equipment. Violations of this section shall be punishable as set forth in Section 1- 5-10 of the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island. Sec. 12-6-117. – Rules and regulations. (a) The following rules and regulations are applicable in the paid parking area and shall be enforced by the designated parking contractor, community code enforcement officers or the Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office: 1. No parking outside of the hours of operation of the paid parking area; 2. No parking in areas designated as no parking zones; 3. No parking in areas marked for emergency vehicles; 4. No parking in areas reserved for handicapped individuals unless a valid handicapped placard is visibly displayed; and 5. No parking in any area within a designated paid parking area that is not specifically identified as a parking space. Sec. 12-6-118. – Dates and Hours of operation, Chaplin Beach Park exception. (a) Paid parking areas shall be open for public use during the dates and hours designated by the town council, which shall be formalized through either through the adoption of a n ordinance or corresponding paid parking area resolution setting forth such dates and/or hours. (b) The dates and hours of operation adopted by the town council and the corresponding paid parking requirements therein shall be posted on appropriate signs and may be adjusted from time to time as deemed necessary by subsequent action of the town council. (c) Paid parking requirements at the Chaplin Beach Park shall be suspended during any youth recreational sports programming season facilitated by the Island Recreation Association. Page 55 of 329 The Town will coordinate with the Island Recreation Association on the dates that this exemption will be in place and will cause appropriate signage to be installed notifying individuals when paid parking will be required at this location. Sec. 12-6-119. – Penalties and fines. (a) Unless otherwise stated in this Article, any person who violates any provision of this Article shall be subject to fines and vehicle tow or immobilization. The fine schedule shall be on a graduated basis based on the number of violations issued within a 12- month period as follows: 1. First violation: a written warning and/or a fine of $50, reminder of parking regulations and notification of potential vehicle tow or immobilization for future violations. 2. Second violation: a fine of $100 and possible towing or immobilization of vehicle at owner’s expense. 3. Third and subsequent violations: a fine of $250 and mandatory towing or immobilization of vehicle at owner’s expense. 4. Fourth and subsequent violations: a fine of $500 and mandatory towing or immobilization of vehicle at owner’s expense. (b) A $25 late fee shall be applied to any original fine not paid within 30 days of being issued. (c) The town, parking contractor, or the Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office may also immobilize, tow, or impound any vehicle parked in violation of this Chapter if, in its sole discretion, deems it necessary for public safety purposes. Sec. 12-6-120. – Appeals of administrative citation. (a) Any person who receives an administrative citation related to paid parking may appeal the citation by submitting a written appeal to the designated parking contractor within 30 days of the citation. (b) The parking contractor shall review the appeal and issue a written decision within 30 days of receiving the appeal. (c) If the person appealing the citation disagrees with the decision of the parking contractor , he or she may appeal to the town attorney or his or her designee within 30 days of receiving the decision of the parking contractor. An appeal to the town attorney or his or her designee shall include statements of fact and conclusions of law to support the appeal. Page 56 of 329 (d) The decision of the t own attorney or his or her designee shall be final. Any subsequent appeals may be made to a court of competent jurisdiction within 30 days of receiving the town attorney’s final decision. (e) This section does not apply to violations issued in accordance with Section 12- 5-517 of this Article. Page 57 of 329 TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA A RESOLUTION OF THE TOWN COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA ESTABLISHING PARKING FEES IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTIONS 12-6-111 THROUGH 12 -6-120, OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND WHEREAS, the Town Council of the Town of Hilton Head Island has authority to establish parking fees within paid parking areas pursuant to Section 12 -6-112 of the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island; and WHEREAS, the recommendations from the Town’s Community Services and Public Safety Committee are reflected as alternative options for the Town Council to consider and are stated as such below; and WHEREAS, after determining which option(s) the Town Council wishes to adopt, this Resolution will be amended to reflect these selections prior to its execution. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT, AND IT HEREBY IS, RESOLVED BY THE TOWN COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, THAT: Section 1: Parking Fees. The fee for parking within designated beach parking areas shall be A. $3.00 per hour; or B. $5.00 per hour. Section 2: Daily Maximum Fee . Regardless of the hourly rate charged, any individual parking a vehicle shall be given the option to pay a maximum daily rate of A. $15.00 for all-day parking within any individually designated paid space on any single calendar day Monday – Friday, and a flat rate of $20.00 per day per vehicle on Saturdays and Sundays; or B. $15.00 for all -day parking within any individually designated paid space on any single calendar day Monday – Friday, and a flat $20.00 per day per vehicles on Saturdays and Sundays during the months of June, July, and August; or C. $30.00 for all -day parking within any individually designated paid space on any single calendar day Monday – Friday, and a flat fee of $25.00 per day per vehicle on Saturdays and Sundays. Section 3: Resident Beach Parking Passes. Residents of the Town of Hilton Head Island as identified in Section 12- 6-111 of the Town’s Municipal Code shall be authorized to register two (2) vehicles per household free of charge upon the submission of appropriate documentation to the Town, or to the Town’s parking management contractor , Page 58 of 329 demonstrating compliance the required residency qualifications. The registration of such vehicle will entitle such vehicle to park for free within any publicly available beach parking space that is not otherwise reserved for handicapped individuals (unless also displaying an approved handicapped placard) or are otherwise restricted by posted signage. Section 4: Hours of Operations. The Town’s Beach Parks designated in the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island as consisting of Alder Lane Beach Park, Chaplin Beach Park, Coligny Beach Park, Driessen Beach Park, Fish Haul Beach Park, Folly Field Beach Park, and Islanders Beach Park shall be open from 6:00AM to 10:00PM daily unless otherwise modified or closed by action of the Town Council or Town Manager. Section 5: Hours for Collection of Parking Fees. Paid parking will be collected within the Town’s Beach Parks identified in Section 4 above from 7:00AM to 7:00P M daily during those periods specified in Section 6 below unless otherwise directed by the Town Council. Section 6: Dates for Collection of Parking Fees. The collection of paid parking fees shall occur from May 1 st until September 30 th of each year unless otherwise modified or amended by the Town Council. Section 7: Special Event Parking. The Town Manager , or their designee, is hereby authorized to approve the suspension of the paid parking requirements outlined herein to support any activity which has received a special event permit as set forth in Title 17, Chapter 12, of the Town of Hilton Head Island Municipal Code. Section 8: Implementation and Collection . The Town Manager, or their designee, shall take all necessary steps to implement and collect the fees as provided for in this Resolution, consistent with the procedures and provisions of the Town’s Municipal Code. Section 9: Effective Date. This Resolution shall take effect on January 1, 2025. MOVED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED THIS ____DAY OF ______________, 2024. _______________________________ Alan R. Perry, Mayor ATTEST: __________________________________________ Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: __________________________________________ Page 59 of 329 Curtis L. Coltrane, Town Attorney Introduced by Council Member:__________________________________ Page 60 of 329 __________________________________________________________________________ RECOMMENDATION: The C ommunity Services and Public Safety Committee (the “Committee”) is recommending that the Town Council consider the adoption of a Resolution setting forth several policy matters related to the imposition of a paid beach parking program. BACKGROUND: At its August 19, 2024, meeting, the Committee performed a comprehensive review of a Resolution setting forth various aspects of a paid beach parking program. Those aspects included addressing resident beach parking passes , establishing a proposed beach parking rate inclusive of location, hours of operation and hours of collection, seasonal or year-round collection, and addressing concerns related to employee parking for business located in and around the Pope Avenues area. At the conclusion of its April meeting, the Committee voted 3- 1 to adopt the following recommendations: • Elimination of the $15.00 fee for resident beach parking passes. • Maintain the cap of two resident beach parking passes per household. • Require paid beach parking at all Town beach parking facilities. • Suspend paid beach parking at Chaplin Beach Park during youth recreational sports programming. • Require paid beach parking seasonally from March 1 st to September 30th of each year. • Establish uniform hours of operation for the Town’s beach park s from 6:00AM – 10:00PM daily and require paid beach parking be collected during the hours of 7:00AM – 7:00PM. • The Committee chose to recommend several possible options in terms of setting a paid parking rate. • The Committee recommended that employee parking concerns for businesses located in the Pope Avenue area be addressed through the establishment of a park and ride program utilizing either USCB, Crossings Park, or some other Town- TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND TOWN COUNCIL TO: Town Council Members FROM: Joshua Gruber, Deputy Town Manager CC: Marc Orlando, Town Manager DATE: September 17, 2024 SUBJECT: Consideration of a Resolution Adopting a Beach Parking Fee Schedule Page 61 of 329 owned property not currently within the vicinity of the Colig ny Beach Park . Additionally, a corresponding shuttle service will need to be contracted to meet the transportation needs of this recommended program. To support these continued discussions with the Town Council, this Staff Report includes data provided to the Committee regarding the goals sought to be accomplished through this program, evaluation of current and future fiscals impacts for both program revenues and expenditures, market data regarding other communities who impose paid beach parking, and a comprehensive analysis on options to address employee parking concerns. ANALYSIS: 1. Beach Parking Program Purpose. In defining the program’s purposes, staff prepared the following items based upon prior discussions with the public, the Committee, and members of Town Council. Those points include the following: • Control Demand and Influence Beach Parking Decisions. • Communicate Timely Information on Beach Parking Availability and Alternative Options. • Provide Parking Areas that are Safe/Secure. • Provide a Paid Parking Program that is Convenient, User Friendly, and Provides Superior Customer Service. • Protect Adjoining Neighborhoods and Businesses from Paid Parking/Overflow Impacts. 2. Current and Future Fiscal Impacts. In 2023, Town Council authorized a budget amendment to facilitate the hiring of PCI Municipal Services (PCI) to manage the Town’s Beach Parking Program. This Fiscal Year 2024 Budget amendment included operational expenses of $366,965 and a Capital budget of $502,765, for a combined expenditure of $869,730. A copy of this Ordinance has been enclosed as Attachment 1. For Fiscal Year 2025 budget, PCI has submitted a proposed operating budget of $598,789 and a recurring Capital budget of $25,000, for a total combined expenditure of $623,789. A copy of that information is enclosed as Attachment 2. In addition to the existing program expenses discussed above, the Committee is recommending that the current $15.00 fee for Island Resident Beach Parking Passes be made free of charge . The adoption of this recommendation will add an additional $105,000 in yearly expenses to the Beach Parking Management Program. Therefore, in order t o financially support these combined expenses, the Town Council should consider adopting an updated parking fee rate structure that will generate Page 62 of 329 Page 3 of 10 sufficient revenues to cover these program costs. 3. Beach Parking Rate Data. A survey was conducted of other similar jurisdictions to determine currently prevailing beach parking rates and whether they established a maximum daily charge. A summary of that data, effective as of August 1, 2024, is as follows: Location State Hourly Rate Daily Rate/Max Weekend Rate Notes: Folly Beach South Carolina $2.50 $10.50 - $15.00 n/a One parking location has a maximum daily rate of $15.00 with no hourly parking offered. All others are $2.50 per hour up to a $10.50 per day cap. Charleston County South Carolina n/a $5.00 - $15.00 $20.00 Parking rates are per day and based on a seasonal schedule with out of season at $5.00 per day, shoulder season at $10.00 per day, and peak season at $15.00 per day Mon.-Fri., and $20.00 per day Sat. and Sun. Edisto Beach South Carolina n/a n/a n/a Parking is included with your admission fee. Admission is $8.00 per adult, $5.00 per senior, and $4.00 per child aged 6-15. Isle of Palms South Carolina $2.00 $10.00 $15.00 Paid parking is charged from 8AM – 8PM, March 1– October 31. The daily rate is $10.00 Monday–Friday and $15.00 on weekends and Page 63 of 329 Page 4 of 10 holidays. After 4 PM, the hourly rate is $2.00 per hour until 8PM. Residents and seasonal parking pass holders can park for free in these lots. Myrtle Beach South Carolina $2.00 - $3.00 $10.00 - $15.00 n/a The direct beach access areas have a rate of $3.00 per hour and a maximum daily rate of $15.00. The core business district has an hourly rate of $2.00 per hour with no daily maximum. Surfside Beach South Carolina $0.50 - $2.00 $10.00 n/a Some parking lots have no daily maximum. Kiawah Island South Carolina n/a $5.00 - $15.00 $20.00 Parking rates are per day and based on a seasonal schedule with out of season at $5.00 per day, shoulder season at $10.00 per day, and peak season at $15.00 per day Mon.-Fri., and $20.00 per day Sat. and Sun. Wrightsville Beach North Carolina $5.00 $25.00 n/a Parking fees are enforced March to October. Tybee Island Geogia $4.00 n/a n/a Enforced 8AM - 8PM, 365 days a year. Jekyll Island Geogia n/a $10.00 n/a Flat rate vehicle entry fee onto the Island. St. Augustine Beach Florida n/a $10.00 n/a Discounts offered for disabled and Page 64 of 329 Page 5 of 10 active military members. Gulf Shores Beach Alabama n/a $5.00 - $15.00 n/a Parking fees enforced March to November. Two lots offer a four- hour block for $5.00 or $15.00 for the entire day. All other lots are $15.00 per day. At the conclusion of its discussion, the Committee recommended that the Town Council consider several different parking rate options: A. $3.00/hr with a maximum daily rate of $15.00 from Monday – Friday, and a flat rate of $20.00 per day on Saturdays and Sundays. B. $3.00/hr with a maximum daily rate of $15.00 from Monday – Friday and a flat rate of $20.00 per day on Saturdays and Sundays during the months of June. July, and August. C. $5.00/hr with a maximum daily rate of $30.00 from Monday – Friday, and a flat fee of $25.00 on Saturdays and Sundays. 4. Establishing a Daily Paid Parking Rate. Based upon the recommendations from the Committee, staff has prepared a chart identifying financial projections for various paid parking rates ranging from $3.00 per hour to $7.00 per hour. Additionally, a separate chart showing the collection of these rates on a seasonal basis as recommended by the Committee is shown below in Chart B. A. Year 1 Revenue Projections - $3.00/$5.00/$7.00 Per Hour (Year-Round) Public Space Available for Payment Month Days Per Month Parking Utilization % Average Parking Sessions $3/hr $5/hr $7/hr 1101 January 31 10% 2.0 $20,479 $34,131 $47,783 February 28 10% 2.0 $18,497 $30,828 $43,159 March 30 20% 2.0 $39,636 $66,060 $92,484 April 30 25% 3.0 $74,318 $123,863 $173,408 May 31 65% 3.5 $232,944 $388,240 $543,536 June 30 90% 3.5 $312,134 $520,223 $728,312 July 31 90% 3.5 $322,538 $537,563 $752,589 Page 65 of 329 Page 6 of 10 August 31 90% 3.5 $322,538 $537,563 $752,589 September 30 65% 3.5 $225,430 $375,716 $526,003 October 31 20% 2.0 $40,957 $68,262 $95,567 November 27 10% 2.0 $17,836 $29,727 $41,618 December 27 10% 2.0 $17,836 $29,727 $41,618 Revenue Totals $1,645,142 $2,741,903 $3,838,664 B. Year 1 Revenue Projections - $3.00/$5.00/$7.00 Per Hour (Seasonal) Public Space Available for Payment Month Days Per Month Parking Utilization % Average Parking Sessions $3/hr $5/hr $7/hr 1101 March 30 20% 2.0 $39,636 $66,060 $92,484 April 30 25% 3.0 $74,318 $123,863 $173,408 May 31 65% 3.5 $232,944 $388,240 $543,536 June 30 90% 3.5 $312,134 $520,223 $728,312 July 31 90% 3.5 $322,538 $537,563 $752,589 August 31 90% 3.5 $322,538 $537,563 $752,589 September 30 65% 3.5 $225,430 $375,716 $526,003 Revenue Totals $1,529,538 $2,549,228 $3,568,921 C. 10-Year Expense Calculations * Does not include benefit expenses of appx. 40% or $150,000/year. ^ PCI FY2025 Contract = $623,789 D. 10-Year Net Revenue Projections ($3.00/hr – Seasonal Collection) *25% Projected Increase Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Year 7 Year 8 Year 9 Year 10 Total Labor* $376,155 $391,201 $406,849 $423,123 $440,048 $457,650 $475,956 $494,994 $514,794 $535,385 $4,516,154 Other Expenses $76,500 $66,435 $68,428 $70,481 $72,595 $74,773 $77,016 $79,327 $81,707 $84,158 $751,420 Total^ $452,655 $457,636 $475,277 $493,604 $512,643 $532,423 $552,972 $574,321 $596,500 $619,543 $5,267,574 Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6* Year 7 Year 8 Year 9 Year 10 Total Gross Revenues $1,529,538 $1,529,538 $1,529,328 $1,529,328 $1,529,328 $1,911,660 $1,911,660 $1,911,660 $1,911,660 $1,911,660 $17,205,990 Less Expenses $452,655 $457,636 $475,277 $493,604 $512,643 $532,423 $552,972 $574,321 $596,500 $619,543 $5,267,574 Net Revenues $1,076,883 $1,071,902 $1,054,051 $1,035,724 $1,016,685 $1,379,237 $1,358,688 $1,337,339 $1,315,160 $1,292,117 $11,938,416 Page 66 of 329 Page 7 of 10 In addition to the projected revenues and expenses listed above, staff has identified current beach park related expenses that could be considered for financial support from beach parking revenues. This list includes, but is not limited to, any actions which support the Town’s beach park environmental and sustainability initiatives, enhancements to multi-modal transportation, enhanced trash collection and recyclin g, energy efficiency projects, Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) upgrades and accessibility, and expansion of beach related environmental partnerships. A spreadsheet identifying current General Fund or CIP beach park related expenses is shown below: E. Table of Potential Surplus Revenue Uses Expense Type Description Cost Beach Management & Monitoring Ongoing activities to manage the beach including Island wide beach survey and monitoring, endangered species monitoring, Beach Program Economic Sustainability Analysis, etc. $300,000 Beach Renourishment Activities related to Beach Renourishment Project, including permitting, bidding, and construction. Construction of next cycle of renourishment anticipated to begin in April 2025. Pine Island, Fish Haul Creek, and Heel must be complete by August 2025 to achieve Fish & Wildlife Permit requirements. Renourishment of remaining island beaches in FY26. FEMA funds must be reimbursed by December 2025. $16,500,000 Beach Park Maintenance & Improvements Maintenance and general improvements to 7 beach parks such as paving, landscaping, lighting, and site furnishings, etc. FY25 - Upgrades to Recycling, Trash, Wayfinding, Rules, Signage, Lighting $250,000 Islanders Beach Park Improvements FY24 - Design of Islanders Park Renovation and construction of pedestrian pathway from Folly Field Road to restroom and playground in FY24. FY25 - Construction of Islanders Park Renovation pending coordination with Beach Renourishment staging area $3,750,000 Beach Wheelchair Storage Permanent storage structure for increased beach wheelchairs stemming from Chamber Leadership Class project; 5 locations ($19,800 each) $99,000 Beach Parks Janitorial Janitorial $106,000 Page 67 of 329 Page 8 of 10 Beach Waste & Recycling Waste $425,000 Beach Parking Shuttle Shuttle $24,000 Land Acquisition Land Acquisition $4,000,000 Total Costs $25,454,000 5. Employee Parking Considerations. One of the concerns expressed by the Committee was the potential impacts to adjacent businesses in the Pope Avenue area. Specifically, local business owners have expressed a concern about the impact paid parking may have on their workforce. In response, Town staff initiated a survey of all businesses that are believed to be located within a radius of 300 feet (100 yards) of the Coligny Beach Parking lot based upon information contained in the Town’s emergency addressing database. 146 separate businesses were identified as having active business licenses located within this identified boundary. To support the Committee ’s discussion of this matter, staff surveyed other beachfront communities to identify how these jurisdictions have approached addressing this concern. The results of that survey are as follows: Jurisdiction Local Business/Employee Parking Provisions Folly Beach No Charleston County No Edisto Beach State Park No Isle of Palms No Myrtle Beach Yes, but is limited to specific geographic area, limited to type of parking space that can be occupied, costs $50.00 per year. Surfside Beach Yes* Spaces in certain lots are designated for employee parking. Kiawah Island No Wrightsville Beach No* Contractor passes are available for $10/day Tybee Island Yes, A discounted parking rate is offered for local businesses to purchase for their employees ($200 per year) Jekyll Island No St. Augustine, FL No Sarasota, FL Yes, either a $10/month or $20/month pass is offered for employee parking depending upon location Clearwater, FL Yes, a $40 monthly pass is offered but parking is limited to certain geographic areas Gulf Shores, AL Free parking for all City residents Beaufort, SC Yes, a discounted parking pass of $35 per month Page 68 of 329 Page 9 of 10 At the conclusion of its discussion, the Committee recommended that Town Council consider creating a remote park and ride program utiliz ing Town-owned property and a contracted transportation provider to facilitate employee parking for businesses located within the Pope Avenue area that may be affected by the imposition of paid beach parking. These program expenses would be in addition to those shown in the expense calculations provided above and would range from approximately $60 - $90 per hour depending upon the length of time and frequency that shuttle service will be provided. 6. Recreational Sports/Beach Parking Considerations. In addition to the previously discussed recommendations, the Committee expressed support for exempting the collection of parking fees at Chaplin Beach Park while recreational sports programming is being facilitated at this location. This would essentially result in paid beach parking being collected at Chaplin Beach Park from Memorial Day until Labor Day and would otherwise remain free of charge at all other times due to current recreational sports league schedules. The Town will coordinate directly with the Island Recreation Association in this regard and will prepare appropriate signage to communicate this information if ultimately adopted. 7. Policy Questions to be Addressed. The Committee has recommended several matters of policy for the Town Council to consider as it weighs whether to implement paid beach parkin g. A summary of those policy questions includes the following: 1. Resident Parking Passes a. Free for Residents? b. Limit 2 per Household? 2. Establish Parking Rate a. Hourly Rate? b. Locations? c. Year-Round or Seasonal? d. Hours of Operation? e. Hours of Parking Collection? 3. Employee Parking at Coligny Beach Park Area a. Remote Lot/Shuttle Services? b. Dedicated Spaces? c. Monthly Passes? CONCLUSION: The draft Ordinance to facilitate a paid beach parking program has previously been considered by the Committee and is now before the Town Council. However, to make Page 69 of 329 Page 10 of 10 sure that all issues associated with this program have been addressed at the time of the Ordinance’s adoption, the Resolution setting forth the proposed beach parking rates and addressing other ancillary issues is recommended for contemporaneous consideration. This would allow for both a framework that is necessary to administer a beach parking program and the necessary rate structure to fully implement this program. ATTACHMENTS: 1. FY2024 Budget Amendment Ordinance 2. FY2025 Proposed Parking Management Budget 3. Beach Parking Management Ordinance Draft 4. Beach Parking Resolution Draft Page 70 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Parking Program Annual Operating Expense Budget FY23 Operating Expense FY23 Labor 151,425$ Equipment 13,250$ Office Expense 21,600$ Uniforms 3,500$ Marketing 10,000$ License/Permits 1,250$ Supplies 6,850$ Vehicle Expense 5,700$ Software Licenses & Fees 90,975$ Professional Services Fees 12,350$ Management Fees / Insurance 39,165$ Signage 10,900$ Subtotal Operations 366,965$ Capital Expense 502,765$ Total Annual Expense 869,730$ Page 71 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Parking Program Capital Expense Budget Item Location Quantity Unit Cost Total Cost Parking Space Sensors Multiple 153 305.00$ 46,665.00$ Fixed LPR Cameras Chaplin Park/Castnet Overflow 8 10,475.00$ 83,800.00$ Fixed LPR Cameras Coligny Beach Park 4 10,475.00$ 41,900.00$ Fixed LPR Cameras Driessen Beach Park 2 10,475.00$ 20,950.00$ Fixed LPR Cameras Fish Haul Park 2 10,475.00$ 20,950.00$ Fixed LPR Cameras Islanders Beach Park 2 10,475.00$ 20,950.00$ Fixed LPR Cameras Folly Field Beach Park 4 10,475.00$ 41,900.00$ Automated Parking Gates Folly Field Beach Park 6 10,550.00$ 63,300.00$ Automated Parking Gates Coligny Beach Park 4 10,550.00$ 42,200.00$ Automated Parking Gates Driessen Beach Park 1 10,550.00$ 10,550.00$ Automated Parking Gates Fish Haul Park 1 10,550.00$ 10,550.00$ Automated Parking Gates Islanders Beach Park 1 10,550.00$ 10,550.00$ Program Vehicles N/A 2 30,000.00$ 60,000.00$ Mobile LPR N/A 1 28,500.00$ 28,500.00$ 502,765.00$ Assumptions Gate Expense Concrete Island/Pad 1,675.00$ Exit Gate Only Electrical 3,500.00$ Install / Loop 1,250.00$ Gate Mechanism 3,750.00$ Gate Arm 375.00$ 10,550.00$ Fixed LPR Camera Pole / Fixture 775.00$ Electrical 2,000.00$ Installation 795.00$ Camera 3,750.00$ Software License 3,155.00$ 10,475.00$ Page 72 of 329 Town of Hilton Head Island Parking Program Annual Operating Expense Budget FY23 Operating Expense 869,730$ November December January February March April May June FY Total Labor 151,425$ Manager 4,625$ 9,250$ 9,250$ 9,250$ 9,250$ 9,250$ 9,250$ 9,250$ 69,375$ Assistant Manager -$ -$ 4,725$ 4,725$ 4,725$ 4,725$ 4,725$ 4,725$ 28,350$ Enforcement -$ -$ -$ -$ 5,725$ 5,725$ 5,725$ 5,725$ 22,900$ Ambassador -$ -$ -$ -$ 2,500$ 7,500$ 10,400$ 10,400$ 30,800$ Equipment 13,250$ Citation Handhelds -$ -$ 5,250$ -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ 5,250$ Citation Printers -$ -$ 2,000$ -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ 2,000$ Equipment Repairs -$ -$ -$ -$ 1,000$ 1,000$ 1,000$ 1,000$ 4,000$ Flags & Flashlights -$ -$ 500$ 250$ -$ -$ -$ -$ 750$ Cones & Barricades -$ -$ 1,000$ 250$ -$ -$ -$ -$ 1,250$ Office Expense 21,600$ Rent 1,350$ 1,350$ 1,350$ 1,350$ 1,350$ 1,350$ 1,350$ 1,350$ 10,800$ Furniture -$ 4,500$ 1,500$ -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ 6,000$ Utilities 200$ 200$ 200$ 200$ 200$ 200$ 200$ 200$ 1,600$ Telephone & Data 400$ 400$ 400$ 400$ 400$ 400$ 400$ 400$ 3,200$ Uniforms -$ -$ -$ -$ 2,500$ 500$ 250$ 250$ 3,500$ Marketing 10,000$ Website -$ 3,500$ -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ 3,500$ Information Flyers -$ 5,000$ -$ -$ 1,000$ -$ -$ -$ 6,000$ Promotional -$ 500$ -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ 500$ License/Permits -$ 500$ -$ 750$ -$ -$ -$ -$ 1,250$ Supplies 6,850$ Office Supplies -$ 1,500$ 500$ 250$ 250$ 250$ 250$ 250$ 3,250$ Citation Paper Rolls -$ -$ -$ 3,600$ -$ -$ -$ -$ 3,600$ Vehicle Expense 5,700$ Repairs & Maintenance -$ -$ -$ -$ 350$ 350$ 350$ 350$ 1,400$ Fuel -$ -$ -$ -$ 350$ 350$ 350$ 350$ 1,400$ Insurance -$ -$ -$ -$ 725$ 725$ 725$ 725$ 2,900$ Software Licenses & Fees 90,975$ VERGE -$ -$ -$ 3,500$ 3,500$ 3,500$ 3,500$ 3,500$ 17,500$ Spot Parking (Wayfinding App) -$ -$ -$ 35,000$ -$ -$ -$ -$ 35,000$ Park Loyalty (Citation Software) -$ -$ -$ -$ 1,800$ 1,800$ 1,800$ 1,800$ 7,200$ Park Lync (Permitting) 300$ 300$ 300$ 300$ 300$ 300$ 300$ 300$ 2,400$ LPR Licenses & Support -$ -$ -$ -$ 26,275$ -$ -$ -$ 26,275$ Nwave Sensors -$ -$ -$ -$ 650$ 650$ 650$ 650$ 2,600$ Professional Services Fees 12,350$ Banking Fees -$ 250$ 250$ 250$ 250$ 250$ 250$ 250$ 1,750$ Credit Card Fees -$ 500$ 500$ 500$ 500$ 2,000$ 3,000$ 3,000$ 10,000$ Accounting & Legal -$ -$ -$ -$ 150$ 150$ 150$ 150$ 600$ Management Fees / Insurance 39,165$ Management Fee -$ 3,000$ 3,000$ 3,000$ 3,000$ 3,000$ 3,000$ 3,000$ 21,000$ General Liability Insurance -$ 2,595$ 2,595$ 2,595$ 2,595$ 2,595$ 2,595$ 2,595$ 18,165$ Signage -$ -$ -$ 5,000$ 5,000$ 500$ 200$ 200$ 10,900$ Capital Expense -$ -$ 200,000$ 150,000$ 152,765$ -$ -$ -$ 502,765$ Monthly Total 6,875$ 33,345$ 233,320$ 221,170$ 227,110$ 47,070$ 50,420$ 50,420$ 869,730$ GRAND TOTAL Page 73 of 329 FY25 Labor Sa laries & Benefits $449,229.53 Total Labor Expenses $449,229.53 General Expense Licenses $2,778.92 Vehicle Expense $10,150.00 Equipment $2,500.00 Software Licenses & Fees $14,820.00 Supplies Lot $4,800.00 Tickets $0.00 Signs $6,000.00 Uniform $3,600.00 Dues & Subscriptions $0.00 Postage $200.00 Office Supplies $0.00 Marketing $0.00 Professional Service Fees $11,550.45 Office Expenses $23,740.00 Total General Expenses $80,139.37 Management Liability Insurance/Management Fee $69,420.00 Total Management Expenses $69,420.00 Total Operating Expenses $598,788.90 Capital Expense Capital/Technology Expenses $25,000.00 Total Budget $623,788.90 PCI Municipal Services Fiscal Year 2025 Budget Page 74 of 329 TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA A RESOLUTION OF THE TOWN COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA ESTABLISHING PARKING FEES IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTIONS 12-6-111 THROUGH 12 -6-120, OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND WHEREAS, the Town Council of the Town of Hilton Head Island has authority to establish parking fees within paid parking areas pursuant to Section 12 -6-112 of the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island; and WHEREAS, the recommendations from the Town’s Community Services and Public Safety Committee are reflected as alternative options for the Town Council to consider and are stated as such below; and WHEREAS, after determining which option(s) the Town Council wishes to adopt, this Resolution will be amended to reflect these selections prior to its execution. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT, AND IT HEREBY IS, RESOLVED BY THE TOWN COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, THAT: Section 1: Parking Fees. The fee for parking within designated beach parking areas shall be A. $3.00 per hour; or B. $5.00 per hour. Section 2: Daily Maximum Fee . Regardless of the hourly rate charged, any individual parking a vehicle shall be given the option to pay a maximum daily rate of A. $15.00 for all-day parking within any individually designated paid space on any single calendar day Monday – Friday, and a flat rate of $20.00 per day per vehicle on Saturdays and Sundays; or B. $15.00 for all -day parking within any individually designated paid space on any single calendar day Monday – Friday, and a flat $20.00 per day per vehicles on Saturdays and Sundays during the months of June, July, and August; or C. $30.00 for all -day parking within any individually designated paid space on any single calendar day Monday – Friday, and a flat fee of $25.00 per day per vehicle on Saturdays and Sundays. Section 3: Resident Beach Parking Passes. Residents of the Town of Hilton Head Island as identified in Section 12- 6-111 of the Town’s Municipal Code shall be authorized to register two (2) vehicles per household free of charge upon the submission of appropriate documentation to the Town, or to the Town’s parking management contractor , Page 75 of 329 demonstrating compliance the required residency qualifications. The registration of such vehicle will entitle such vehicle to park for free within any publicly available beach parking space that is not otherwise reserved for handicapped individuals (unless also displaying an approved handicapped placard) or are otherwise restricted by posted signage. Section 4: Hours of Operations. The Town’s Beach Parks designated in the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island as consisting of Alder Lane Beach Park, Chaplin Beach Park, Coligny Beach Park, Driessen Beach Park, Fish Haul Beach Park, Folly Field Beach Park, and Islanders Beach Park shall be open from 6:00AM to 10:00PM daily unless otherwise modified or closed by action of the Town Council or Town Manager. Section 5: Hours for Collection of Parking Fees. Paid parking will be collected within the Town’s Beach Parks identified in Section 4 above from 7:00AM to 7:00P M daily during those periods specified in Section 6 below unless otherwise directed by the Town Council. Section 6: Dates for Collection of Parking Fees. The collection of paid parking fees shall occur from May 1 st until September 30 th of each year unless otherwise modified or amended by the Town Council. Section 7: Special Event Parking. The Town Manager , or their designee, is hereby authorized to approve the suspension of the paid parking requirements outlined herein to support any activity which has received a special event permit as set forth in Title 17, Chapter 12, of the Town of Hilton Head Island Municipal Code. Section 8: Implementation and Collection . The Town Manager, or their designee, shall take all necessary steps to implement and collect the fees as provided for in this Resolution, consistent with the procedures and provisions of the Town’s Municipal Code. Section 9: Effective Date. This Resolution shall take effect on January 1, 2025. MOVED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED THIS ____DAY OF ______________, 2024. _______________________________ Alan R. Perry, Mayor ATTEST: __________________________________________ Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: __________________________________________ Page 76 of 329 Curtis L. Coltrane, Town Attorney Introduced by Council Member:__________________________________ Page 77 of 329 TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA AMENDING TITLE 12, CHAPTER 3, OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, ENTITLED: MOTOR VEHICLES AND TRAFFIC CONTROL, PARKING, TO REVISE REGULATIONS RELATED TO PAID PARKING AND OTHER MATTERS RELATED THERETO, AND TO PROVIDE FOR SEVERABILITY AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE WHEREAS, the Town Council of the Town of Hilton Head Island has authority to establish paid parking within designated paid parking areas pursuant to Section 12- 3-111, et seq. of the Municipal Code of Hilton Head Island; and WHEREAS, to provide for a more comprehensive and effective paid parking program, the Town Council now desires to amend the Municipal Code for the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina as further outlined herein; and WHEREAS, through the enactment of this Ordinance, the Town Council desires to control demand and influence beach parking decisions, communicate timely information on beach parking availability and alternative parking options, provide paid parking areas that are safe/secure, provide a paid parking program that is convenient, user friendly, and provides superior customer service, and protects adjoining neighborhoods and businesses from paid parking/overflow impacts. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT, AND IT HEREBY IS, ORDAINED BY THE TOWN COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA: Section 1. Amendment. Revisions to Sections 12-3-111 through 12-6-120 of the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island relating to the establishment of paid parking areas, creation of a parking management program, and parking enforcement measures, are hereby adopted as outlined in Attachment 1 attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference . Newly added language is illustrated with double underline and deleted language is illustrated with strikethrough. Section 2. Severability . If any section, phrase, sentence or portion of this Ordinance is for any reason held invalid or unconstitutional by a court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed a separate, distinct, and independent provision, and such holding shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions thereof. Section 3: Effective Date. This Ordinance shall take effect on January 1, 2025. MOVED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED THIS ____DAY OF ______________, 2024. _______________________________ Alan R. Perry, Mayor Page 78 of 329 ATTEST: ___________________________________ Kimberely Gammon, Town Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: ___________________________________ Curtis Coltrane, Town Attorney Introduced by Council Member: ____________________________ Page 79 of 329 ATTACHMENT 1 Chapter 3 - PARKING Sec. 12-3-111. - Authority to establish parking zones and install meters paid parking areas. The town council may establish by resolution, from time to time as traffic conditions require, zones to be known as parking meter zones paid parking areas upon such streets or properties of the town as are selected by the town council for the location of such meters designation; and, in such parking meter zones paid parking areas, the town manager shall cause parking meters to be installed and parking meter spaces appropriate signage and notification of paid parking equipment or other similar electronic paid parking capabilities to be designated as hereinafter provided. Sec. 12-3-112. - Location and operation of meters paid parking areas. Parking meters installed in the parking meter zones established by the provisions of this article shall be placed upon the curb immediately adjacent to the individual parking places hereinafter described. Each parking meter shall be placed or set in such a manner as to show or display by a signal that the parking space adjacent to such meter is or is not legally in use. Each parking meter shall be installed and set to display, upon the deposit of an official coin of the United States of America, which is at the time legal tender, a signal indicating legal parking for a designa ted time period. Each meter shall also be arranged so that, upon the expiration of the legal parking time, it will indicate by a mechanical operation and the dropping of the proper signal that the lawful parking has expired. The town manager shall be authorized to establish the parking fees. The town manager shall take such actions as may be necessary and appropriate to implement the collection and corresponding enforcement of paid parking areas as designated by the town council. These actions shall include the posting of necessary signage, the installation of paid parking infrastructure, and the implementation of a comprehensive paid parking program either directly or through contracting with appropriate entities as may be required to effectuate the directives of the town council. Sec. 12-3-114. - Depositing coins. When any vehicle shall be parked in any space alongside of or next to which a parking meter is located in accordance with the provisions of this article, the operator of such vehicle shall, upon entering the parking space, immediately deposit or cause to be deposited a coin of the United States of America, which is, at the time, legal tender, in such parking meter and the parking space may then be lawfully occupied by such vehicle during the period indicated on the meter. If such vehicle shall remain parked in any such parking space beyond the parking time limit, the parking meter shall display a sign or signal showing illegal parking or expiration of time allotted, and in that event, such vehicle shall be considered as parked overtime. Overtime means beyond the period of legal parking time. The parking of a vehicle overtime in any such part of a street where any such meter is located shall be a violation of this article. Sec. 12-3-117. - Defacing, injuring, etc. Page 80 of 329 It shall be unlawful for any person to deface, injure, tamper with, open or willfully break, destroy or impair the usefulness of any parking meter signage or devise installed under the provisions of this article. Sec. 12-3-118. - Violations; parking enforcement personnel to report; notices; penalty. (a) It shall be the duty of the enforcement officer of the town town, the designated parking contractor of the Town, or the Beaufort County Sheriff’ to report: 1. The number of each parking meter identity of each paid parking area which indicates that the vehicle occupying the a designed parking space adjacent to such parking meter within such paid parking area is or has been parked in violation of any of the provisions of this article Chapter; and 2. The state license number of such vehicle; and 3. Any other facts, knowledge of which is necessary to a thorough understanding of the circumstances surrounding such violation. (b) Each such parking enforcement officer community code enforcement officer, designated town staff member, designated parking contractor, or member of the Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office shall also attach to such vehicle a notice to the owner thereof that such vehicle has been parked in violation of a provision of this article stating the bond set by the town for said violation the administrative penalty associated with such violation . Every person who violates or fails to comply with any of the provisions of this article shall be punished for each such violation as provided for in section 1-5-10 of this Code. (c) In any parking meter zone paid parking area, every hour or fraction of an hour of overtime parking shall constitute a separate offense. Sec. 12-3-121. - Penalties for delinquent parking fines. The following penalties are hereby established for delinquent parking fines: (a) Delinquent after 10 days, add .....$10.00 (b) After every 30 days add an additional .....10.00 (c) Maximum penalty .....40.00 ARTICLE 6 - Beach Parking Management Sec. 12-6-110. - Purpose and Intent. Page 81 of 329 The purpose of this Article is to establish regulations for the management of paid parking areas for public beach access within the jurisdiction of the Town of Hilton Head Island. The intent of this Article is to promote the effective use of parking resources and ensure the public safety, accessibility, and convenience of beachgoers, while minimizing adverse effects on the neighboring environment. Sec. 12-6-111. - Definitions. Paid Parking Area. Any area designated by the town requiring payment to park therein. Parking Contractor. The town or its designed vendor to manage the beach parking program. Resident. For purposes of this Article, resident shall mean: (a) Any person who owns any single or multi -family residence in the municipal limits of the Town, irrespective of whether the person qualifies for the 4% special assessment ratio except: 1. The owner of a property that is offered for leases of any term of more than 183 days in any calendar year is not deemed a “resident” eligible for a beach parking pass based on the ownership of that property. (b) Any person who is a tenant under a lease for a single or multi-family residence for a period of 183 days or more in any calendar year. (c) Any person who owns time-share interests totaling more than 183 days per year. Sec. 12-6-112. – Designation of paid parking areas. The following areas are designated as paid parking areas: (a) Alder Lane Beach Park (b) Chaplin Beach Park (c) Coligny Beach Park (d) Driessen Beach Park (e) Fish Haul Beach Park (f) Folly Field Beach Park (g) Islanders Beach Park The Town Council shall determine the appropriate rates for the paid parking areas by resolution. Page 82 of 329 The town manager or designee shall install and maintain appropriate signs indicating the boundaries of the paid parking areas and the parking rates established therefore. Sec. 12-6-113. – Fees, payment, and enforcement. (a) The parking fees for any paid parking area shall be established by a resolution of the town council. (b) Any person who parks a vehicle in a paid parking area must pay the appropriate fee as specified by the town or designated parking contractor. (c) Payment shall be made through the designated payment mechanism installed by the town of designated parking contractor or otherwise provided for electronically for the express purpose of paying for a designated parking space. (d) The town or designated parking contractor shall enforce the payment of parking fees and may issue administrative citations or take other appropriate measures to ensure compliance, including but not limited to vehicle immobilization and/or towing. Sec. 12-6-114. - Exemptions. (a) The following vehicles shall be exempt from payment of parking fees: 1. Vehicles of emergency responders while engaged in official duties; 2. Vehicles of disabled persons displaying appropriate placards or license plates; and 3. Vehicles of authorized Town employees engaged in official duties. (b) The town manager may establish additional exemptions during permitted special events. (c) Vehicles which have been registered pursuant to the Town’s Resident Beach Parking Pass program shall be exempt from the payment of parking fees. Sec. 12-6-115. – Resident beach pass. (a) The town shall issue resident beach parking passes to residents who can prove primary residency within the Town of Hilton Head Island as defined in Section 12-6-111. Resident beach parking passes will allow residents to park within the paid parking areas during the established hours of operation without paying the daily parking fees as designated by the town council. (b) Qualified residents of Hilton Head Island shall be entitled to receive a maximum of two beach parking passes per household. Beginning in calendar year 2025, the beach parking passes provided for in this section shall be issued without charge. However, the t own council shall have the right to assess a fee for these passes in the future and shall be Page 83 of 329 authorized to set such fee by the adoption of a corresponding resolution setting forth this amount. (c) Residents who receive a beach parking pass are subject to the parking regulations of this Article. (d) The town may revoke or refuse to issue resident beach passes for individuals who violate this Article. Sec. 12-6-116. – Defrauding, opening, impairing, or damaging paid parking devices. It shall be unlawful for any person to defraud, open, impair, or damage a paid parking device or related equipment. Violations of this section shall be punishable as set forth in Section 1- 5-10 of the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island. Sec. 12-6-117. – Rules and regulations. (a) The following rules and regulations are applicable in the paid parking area and shall be enforced by the designated parking contractor, community code enforcement officers or the Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office: 1. No parking outside of the hours of operation of the paid parking area; 2. No parking in areas designated as no parking zones; 3. No parking in areas marked for emergency vehicles; 4. No parking in areas reserved for handicapped individuals unless a valid handicapped placard is visibly displayed; and 5. No parking in any area within a designated paid parking area that is not specifically identified as a parking space. Sec. 12-6-118. – Dates and Hours of operation, Chaplin Beach Park exception. (a) Paid parking areas shall be open for public use during the dates and hours designated by the town council, which shall be formalized through either through the adoption of a n ordinance or corresponding paid parking area resolution setting forth such dates and/or hours. (b) The dates and hours of operation adopted by the town council and the corresponding paid parking requirements therein shall be posted on appropriate signs and may be adjusted from time to time as deemed necessary by subsequent action of the town council. (c) Paid parking requirements at the Chaplin Beach Park shall be suspended during any youth recreational sports programming season facilitated by the Island Recreation Association. Page 84 of 329 The Town will coordinate with the Island Recreation Association on the dates that this exemption will be in place and will cause appropriate signage to be installed notifying individuals when paid parking will be required at this location. Sec. 12-6-119. – Penalties and fines. (a) Unless otherwise stated in this Article, any person who violates any provision of this Article shall be subject to fines and vehicle tow or immobilization. The fine schedule shall be on a graduated basis based on the number of violations issued within a 12- month period as follows: 1. First violation: a written warning and/or a fine of $50, reminder of parking regulations and notification of potential vehicle tow or immobilization for future violations. 2. Second violation: a fine of $100 and possible towing or immobilization of vehicle at owner’s expense. 3. Third and subsequent violations: a fine of $250 and mandatory towing or immobilization of vehicle at owner’s expense. 4. Fourth and subsequent violations: a fine of $500 and mandatory towing or immobilization of vehicle at owner’s expense. (b) A $25 late fee shall be applied to any original fine not paid within 30 days of being issued. (c) The town, parking contractor, or the Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office may also immobilize, tow, or impound any vehicle parked in violation of this Chapter if, in its sole discretion, deems it necessary for public safety purposes. Sec. 12-6-120. – Appeals of administrative citation. (a) Any person who receives an administrative citation related to paid parking may appeal the citation by submitting a written appeal to the designated parking contractor within 30 days of the citation. (b) The parking contractor shall review the appeal and issue a written decision within 30 days of receiving the appeal. (c) If the person appealing the citation disagrees with the decision of the parking contractor , he or she may appeal to the town attorney or his or her designee within 30 days of receiving the decision of the parking contractor. An appeal to the town attorney or his or her designee shall include statements of fact and conclusions of law to support the appeal. Page 85 of 329 (d) The decision of the t own attorney or his or her designee shall be final. Any subsequent appeals may be made to a court of competent jurisdiction within 30 days of receiving the town attorney’s final decision. (e) This section does not apply to violations issued in accordance with Section 12- 5-517 of this Article. Page 86 of 329 Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex One Town Center Court  Hilton Head Island  South Carolina  29928 www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND Town Council TO: Town Council FROM: Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager CC: DATE: Marc Orlando, ICMA-CM, Town Manager September 17, 2024 SUBJECT: Consideration of a Resolution to Accept the Final Report for the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Project Independent Study RECOMMENDATION: Consideration of a Resolution to Accept the Final Report for the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Project Independent Study BACKGROUND: The Town desired to contract with a qualified firm to conduct an Independent Study of the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor project, to have the selected firm review and verify that the assumptions, methodologies, alternatives and preferred design recommendations are technically accurate and serve the best interest of Hilton Head Island. The achieve this the following steps were completed: February 2023 – Town Council created the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee (Committee) March 2023 - Appointments made on March 21, 2023. May 2023 – Committee approved draft Request for Qualifications and Scope of Work for Independent Study and forwarded to Town Council for consideration June 2023 - Town Council approved final Request for Qualifications and Scope of Work for Independent Study (Attachment 1) August to October 2023 – Consultant, The Lochmueller Group, Inc. procured to conduct Independent Study Oct 2023 to June 2024 – The Lochmueller Group and Town staff consultant conducted 10 public meetings with the Committee as they worked through the agreed upon scope of contracted work. Findings for the Gateway Corridor, from Moss Creek to Gum Tree Road were presented to the committee on June 12, 2024 and Town Council on Jun 17, 2024. Page 87 of 329 Page 2 of 2 August 2024 – The final draft report, which includes downstream impacts from the Gateway Corridor Project to Whooping Crane Way/Indigo Run Drive on the William Hilton Parkway Business Route, and to Sea Pines Circle on the Cross-island Parkway Route, was presented to the Advisory Committee on August 14, 2024. The committee voted 2-2 to accept the final draft report, with one member of the committee absent. September 2024 – Town Council to consider a Resolution (Attachment 2) to accept the final report (Exhibit A) presented to Town Council. The presentation of the downstream impacts and recommendations for consideration from final report completes the Scope of Work deliverables for this project (Attachment 3). ATTACHMENTS: 1. William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Study RFQ Scope of Work 2. Resolution to Accept the Final Report for the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Project Independent Study a. Exhibit A Independent Study of the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Traffic Operations and Safety Report – dated August 9, 2024 3. Presentation by the Lochmueller Group – dated August 14, 2024 Page 88 of 329 3 | Page TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND RFQ 2023-16 Independent Study of the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor I. GENERAL INFORMATION AND SUBMITTAL INSTRUCTIONS The Town of Hilton Head Island is soliciting responses f rom qualified engineering firms (“Offerors” or “Consultants”) with an ability to be licensed in South Carolina to provide Independent Study of the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor for the Town in accordance with the scope of work and specifications provided herein. To be eligible for consideration, an Offeror cannot have current or previous affiliation with the Town of Hilton Head Island, Beaufort County, SC , or t he S outh Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT). Qua lifications must be submitted by the Qualifications Submittal Deadline shown on the Transmittal Page. Qualifications will ONLY be accepted electronically via the Town’s Procurement Portal which can be accessed using the following link https://hiltonheadislandsc.bonfirehub.com/portal . If electronic submittal poses a hardship, please notify the Town Contact person identified on the Transmittal Page. Th ere will be a MANDATORY meeting held virtually on June 21, 2023 at 2:00PM (EST). Only vendors that attend this meeting shall be qualified to submit a proposal. Meeting information is below: Mandatory Virtual Pre-Submittal Meeting Link and Information June 21, 2023 at 2:00PM Microsoft Teams meeting Join on your computer, mobile app or room device Click here to join the meeting Meeting ID: 219 092 821 712 Passcode: q4h93B Download Teams | Join on the web Sub mittals will be publicly opened via virtual conference at the date and time indicated on the Transmittal Page. Only the names of Offerors will be provided at the opening. No other information will be shared at that time. To participate, please use the following meeting link and information. Virtual Opening of Submittals Link and Information 8:30 am Eastern Time on July 11, 2023 Join Zoom Meeting https://us06web.zoom.us/j/85390157263?pwd=eFJpajVqUlhpbHZrdkV1aVN vUS9rZz09 Meeting ID: 853 9015 7263 ATTACHMENT 1 Page 89 of 329 4 | Page Passcode: 866529 One tap mobile +19294362866,,85390157263#,,,,*866529# US (New York) +13017158592,,85390157263#,,,,*866529# US (Washington DC) Dial by your location • +1 929 436 2866 US (New York) • +1 301 715 8592 US (Washington DC) Meeting ID: 853 9015 7263 Passcode: 866529 Find your local number: https://us06web.zoom.us/u/kckCmsWNiz All questions regarding this solicitation must be submitted in writing via the Town’s Procurement Portal using the “Ask a question” button. Questions will be answered via the Procurement Portal as well. Offeror’s who have downloaded an original solicitation will receive email notification if any addendums have been issued for that solicitation. However, it is still the Offeror’s responsibility to check the procurement portal for any issued addendums prior to submitting their qualifications. The Town reserves the right to accept or reject any or all submittals received as a result of this solicitation, to neg otiate with all qualified Offerors, to award multiple contracts for all or part of the scope of work, or to cancel in part or in whole this solicitation, if in the best interests of the Town. The Town reserves the right to refuse any and all submittals and to waive any technicalities and formalities. The Town reserves the right to waive any requirement in this solicitation, including material requirements, if such material requirement is unmet by all Offerors, and, such a waiver is determined to be in the best interests of the Town. This solicitation does not commit the Town to award a contract or to procure for any articles of goods or services. The Town shall not incur or pay for any costs associated with the preparation of Offeror submittals. Submittals must be signed by an official of Offeror authorized to bind Offeror. Electronic signature using secure signature software is acceptable. By submitting, Offeror agrees that its submittal shall be good and held open for a period of at least sixty (60) days from the Due Date. The Town does not discriminate on the basis of race, color, national origin, sex [including pregnancy and childbirth (or related medical conditions)], religion, age or disability in employment or in the provision of goods and services. Page 90 of 329 5 | Page The Town recognizes that small businesses enterprises as well as businesses enterprises owned and operated by women and/or minority persons (collectively “disadvantaged business”) have historically faced challenges resulting in less than full participation in the free enterprise system to a degree disproportionate to other businesses. Therefore, the Town is committed to ensuring that such disadvantaged business enterprises are afforded every opportunity to fully and fairly participate in the Town’s procurement process for goods and services. In the event of a tie after the scoring of responses involving a certified disadvantaged Offeror and a non- disadvantaged Offeror, the Town will award the contract to the certified disadvantaged Offeror. Tied responses involving two certified disadvantaged Offerors will be settled by a random s election method . It is the obligation of the disadvantaged Offeror to submit proof of current certification from a governmental entity in the United States at the time they submit their response in order for the certification to be considered by the Town in determining a n award as described above. Tied responses involving two non-disadvantaged Offerors will be settled by a random selection method. T he Town is required under the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act, to upon request, make public and disclose all documents of, and documents incidental to, executed contractual arrangements. Therefore, Offerors, by submitting a response to this solicitation, are acknowledging that all materials submitted in their response may be subject to such disclosure, regardless of a ny labeling of materials as “confidential” or “proprietary” or other similar notations. T he Town of Hilton Head Island’s meetings on the Independent Study of the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor with the Committee, the Town, the County and or the Offeror will be open to the public. II. SCOPE OF WORK 1. T he Town desires to contract with a qualified firm to conduct an Independent Study of the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor project. It is the intent of the Town to have the selected firm review and verify that the assumptions, methodologies, alternatives and preferred design recommendation s are technically accurate and serve the best interest of Hilton Head Island. T he qualified firm is to t ake a fresh look at the pro ject and test possible new alternative solutions over the project scope . The consultant is strongly encouraged to develop their own ideas and recommend their own alternatives. 2. P roposed plans will have to pass NEPA review Thus, the consultant should have a familiarity with that process and its applicability to this project. It should be noted that , in addition to environmental impacts, F ederal Highway Administration (FHWA) considers safety as a prime issue in its evaluation. Also, a demonstrated solution of the congestion problem over the project scope above is essential. Thus, plans that deal with these issues have a higher probability of success in the NEPA and community review. Page 91 of 329 6 | Page 3. T he study is anticipated to take no longer than six months to complete. The specific scope, schedule and fee for the services necessary to develop the plan will be negotiated once the firm is selected . Anticipated services and tasks associated with the development of the plan may include, but are not limited to, the following: Task 1: Project Initiation and Coordination: • Initial meeting with Town of Hilton Head Island and Independent Consultant. • Conduct Bi-weekly project status meetings with Town staff and the project advisory committee. • Review meeting with representati ves of Town of Hilton Head Island, SCDOT and the existing design consultants on prior work performed • Monthly update meetings with Town Manager. • Review and define the study area. • Perform a site visit/field review. • Review and understand bridge inspection data. • Understand the Town of Hilton Head Island’s and Community concern with the proposed concept and existing model. • Study existing project reports including: the SCDOT Draft E nvironmental Assessment, Town Council recommendations supported by MKSK and HDR studies, and the T echnical Working Group report dated 3/31/23 to FHWA/Council on Environmental Quality/SCDOT. Task 2: Provide Modeling of Data and Recommended Design Concepts • Review assumptions contained within the model – Daily, Hour, Land Use, and identify other input variables , including adaptive traffic signals and safety provisions. T he results of each alternative evaluated should include but not be limited by the following: T hroughput and Traffic Simulation This includes factors such as end- end delay, level of service, and average speed. We wish to see these computed via event simulation from end -to-end in each direction (for each alternative) including modeling the coupling and interactions of all proposed traffic lights, merges, splits, and other possible constrictions, as opposed to summing them as acting individually. The simulation must operate on the smallest interval possible to provide meaningful results. Costs Since detailed engineering for the various Corridor options is not available at this point, the Consultant shall use br oad-gauge cost estimates similar to those used by SCDOT. The Consultant shall solicit assistance from SCDOT , the County, and the Town in developing cost estimates for the various Page 92 of 329 7 | Page options and identifying the split between covered and uncovered costs. Safety, Environmental and Community Impacts • Review data collection approach and study area. • Review model outputs and subsequent recommendations for intersection operations and bridge concepts. • Model Review and Concept Review Memo. • Compile findings in to a Summary Review Memo, identifying primary findings and recommendations for improvement. • Review data collection from Adaptive Traffic Signals. Task 3: Model and Operational Analysis Updates • The model updates will be based on the version of the L owcountry Area Transportation Study (L ATS) model utilized to develop the project. Consultant to study and recommend a model alternative if warranted. • Provide simulation and modeling of various data. • Confirm that the base traffic demand model accurately takes into account trips generated by visitor traffic, workforce traffic, mass transit traffic, and traffic demand from redevelopment from existing island parcels. • Update the model based on findings in Task 2 and coordination with the Town of Hilton Head. • Expand the SCDOT project model and study area to include the following signalized intersections and merge points east of Spanish Wells Road: • William Hilton Parkway (US 278) merge with Cross Island Parkway. • William Hilton Parkway (US 278 Bus) at Gum Tree Road. • William Hilton Parkway (US 278 Bus) at Jarvis Park Road / Wilborn Road. • William Hilton Parkway (US 278 Bus) at Pembroke Drive/Museum Street. • William Hilton Parkway (US 278 Bus) at Indigo Run Drive/Whooping Crane Way. • Palmetto Bay Road (US 278) at Point Comfort Road/Arrow Road. • Palmetto Bay Road at Target Road. • Sea Pines Circle - William Hilton Parkway (US 278 Bus) at Palmetto Bay Road. • Expand the model and study area to include the following signalized intersections and m erge points west of Bluffton Parkway Flyover on US 278: • US 278 (Fording Island Road) at Buckingham Plantation Drive/Moss Creek Drive (on Mainland). • Bluffton Parkway at Buckingham Plantation Drive (on Mainland) • Existing traffic counts for the study area intersections will be obtained from the Town of Hilton Head Island and SCDOT Any additional counts not available from the Town of Hilton Head Island or SCDOT shall be collected by the consultant as deemed necessary and agreed to by the Town. Page 93 of 329 8 | Page • The model shall include the most recent available traffic data that reflects the toll removal on the Cross Island Parkway. • The model shall include the new adaptive traffic signal management system being deployed by the Town (Summer 2023). • Generate model ou tputs for study area with agreed upon new assumptions and latest volumes and analyze operations using appropriate tools. A key deliverable of this project is a visual simulation of the models which can show the comparison of the options. • Evaluate how Adaptive Traffic Signals could impact the traffic flow and average travel times along the corridor at peak times as well as other periods. The Town and County are expected to implement Adaptive Signals on the William Hilton Parkway/US 278 Corridor from I -95 to Sea Pines Circle. Answer questions related to potential for downstream impacts. • • Evaluate opportunities to achieve desired operational efficiency by maintaining four lanes (two lanes in each direction) between the Windmill Harbor and Squire Pope Road intersections with William Hilton Parkway. These include system improvements that result from Intelligent Traffic Systems and ot her operational adjustments that may provide improved efficiency in the system. • Evaluate impacts of alternatives, including those impacts to the Traditional Cultural Property defined in the Environmental Assessment, and commonly referred to as the Stoney Community. Develop strategic options for consideration to mitigate impacts. • Evaluate the safety for bicycle and pedestrians within the original Project Study Area. • Coordinate and refine recommendations with the Town of Hilton Head Island. • Participate in meetings as directed by the Town of Hilton Head Island. Task 4: Proposed Intersection Improvements and other important elements: • E valuate the safety for bicycle and pedestrians within the original Project Study Area including new signal proposed at Windmill Harbour. • Evaluate vehicular safety of the Project and make cost -effective recommendations to reduce accidents and enhance safety for the motoring public including emergency response considerations. • Identify potential modifications to the proposed intersection designs of the preferred alternative within the original Project Study Area from Moss Creek to Spanish Wells Road that deliver the same (or better) expected operational levels. • Based on the findings of Task 3 for intersections outside of the original project study area, develop alternatives to improve operations in the future. Evaluation should include but not be limited to traffic conveyance and capacity improvements (LOS, delay, etc.) as well as anticipated project costs and known impacts or concerns with the alternatives Page 94 of 329 9 | Page • Evaluate, quantify, and explain the Project’s impacts on the Stoney Community. • Develop a Summary of Findings and Recommendations for review by the Town of Hilton Head that can be utilized to secure future funding for the improvements beyond the Project Study Area. Task 5: Final Report • Compile model updates, operational analysis, and findings into a report for a review and discussion. • Integrate safety objectives based on the results of data and analysis into findings and recommendations. • The report shall contain a detailed quantitative, objective comparison of alternatives including pros and cons of each that assesses the conveyance and capacity efficacy, safety improvements, community and social impacts, environmental impacts, appearance/aesthetic impacts, and total costs. This comparison shall be summarized in a simple to understand, tabular format as agreed to by the Town. • Finalize elements into draft and final reports, including executive summaries and recommendations. • Presentation of study, with final findings and recommendations, to Town Council for endorsement/adoption. • Submit final report electronically for endorsement/adoption by Town Council. • All engineering work must be certified by a Professional Engineer licensed in South Carolina. Page 95 of 329 Page 1 of 2 TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA RESOLUTION NO. _________________ A RESOLUTION OF THE TOWN COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, TO ACCEPT THE FINAL REPORT FOR THE WILLIAM HILTON PARKWAY GATEWAY CORRIDOR PROJECT INDEPENDENT STUDY. WHEREAS, The Town desired to contract with a qualified firm to conduct an Inde pendent Study of the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor project, to have the selected firm review and verify that the assumptions, methodologies, alternatives and preferred design recommendations are technically accurate and serve the best interest of Hilton Head Island. WHEREAS, Town Council adopted a Resolution on February 21, 2023 to create the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee (Committee) with the following expectations: WHEREAS, Town Council appointed 5 members and an alternate member to the Committee on March 21, 2023; and, WHEREAS, the Committee reviewed and assessed the Town’s request for qualifications, including recommending a scope of work for the RFQ on May 12, 2023 to be considered by Town Council; and, WHEREAS, Town Council approved the RFQ and recommended scope of work on June 6, 2023; and, WHEREAS, the Committee reviewed proposals and identified and interviewed preferred firms to be considered for contract award; and, WHEREAS, the Committee selected The Lochmueller Group, Inc. as the preferred firm on August 28, 2023; and, WHEREAS, the Committee met 12 times between October 2023 and August 2024 to work through the agreed upon scope of contracted work; and, WHEREAS, Findings and recommendations for consideration for the Gateway Corridor, from Moss Creek to Gum Tree Road were presented to the Committee on June 12, 2024 and Town Council on June 17, 2024; and, WHEREAS, the final draft report, which includes downstream impacts from the Gateway Corridor Project to Whooping Crane Way/Indigo Run Drive intersection on the William Hilton Parkway Business Route, and to Sea Pines Circle on the Cross -Island Parkway Route, was presented to the Committee on August 14, 2024. The Committee vote to accept the final draft failed on a vote of 2-2, with one member of the Committee absent; and, Page 96 of 329 Page 2 of 2 WHEREAS, the final draft report has been forwarded to the Town Council without a recommendation by the Committee; and, WHEREAS, the final William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Study was presented to Town Council on September 17, 2024. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT, AND HEREBY IT IS, RESOLVED BY THE TOWN COUNCIL, 1. The Town Council here by accepts the Final William Hilton Parkway Independent Study; and, 2. Town Staff is authorized to utilize the Final William Hilton Parkway Independ ent Study to inform future planning and project considerations. MOVED, APPROVED, AND ACCEPTED BY THE COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND ON THIS _____ DAY OF _____________, 2024. THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA ____________________________ Alan Perry, Mayor ATTEST: ______________________________________ Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: __________________________________ Curtis L. Coltrane, Town Attorney Introduced by Council Member: ____________________________ Page 97 of 329 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Traffic Operations and Safety Report Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina Prepared for: Town of Hilton Head Island 1 Town Center Court Hilton Head Island, South Carolina 843.341.4600 Prepared by: Lochmueller Group Huntington Tower, 201 W Springfield Avenue Suite 1012 Champaign, Illinois 61820 217.673.7633 AUGUST 9, 2024 EXHIBIT A Page 98 of 329 P A G E | i Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT CONTENTS List of Figures ............................................................................................................................................... iii List of Tables ................................................................................................................................................ iv Executive Summary ....................................................................................................................................... v Existing and No-Build Conditions .............................................................................................................. v Corridor Study Goals ................................................................................................................................. v Proposed Alternatives Selected for Analysis ........................................................................................... vi Introduction .................................................................................................................................................. 1 Study Objective ......................................................................................................................................... 1 Study Overview ......................................................................................................................................... 3 Background ................................................................................................................................................... 3 Data Collection and Field Inventory .......................................................................................................... 3 Analysis Methodology ............................................................................................................................... 5 Existing Conditions ........................................................................................................................................ 8 Existing Synchro Traffic Operational Analysis ........................................................................................... 8 Existing VISSIM Traffic Operational Analysis............................................................................................. 9 Existing VISSIM Network Performance ..................................................................................................... 9 2045 No-Build Conditions ........................................................................................................................... 10 2045 No-Build Synchro Traffic Operational Analysis .............................................................................. 11 2045 No-Build VISSIM Traffic Operational Analysis ................................................................................ 11 2045 No-Build VISSIM Network Performance ........................................................................................ 11 2045 Alternatives Analysis .......................................................................................................................... 13 Corridor Study Goals ............................................................................................................................... 14 Alternatives Considered .......................................................................................................................... 14 2045 Alternative 1: SCDOT Modified Recommended Preferred ............................................................ 22 2045 Alternative 2: Bowties at Squire Pope and Spanish Wells ............................................................. 23 2045 Alternative 3: Echelon / Center Turn Overpass ............................................................................. 26 2045 Alternative 4: Elevated Bypass ....................................................................................................... 30 Alternatives Comparison and Conclusions ............................................................................................. 32 Town Selected Alternative ...................................................................................................................... 38 Downstream Impacts of Town Selected Modified Alternative 1 ................................................................ 39 Page 99 of 329 P A G E | ii Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT Modified Alternative 1 Traffic Analysis ................................................................................................... 39 Additional Mitigation Solutions for Local Intersections ............................................................................. 42 Options A and B VISSSIM Traffic Operational Analysis ........................................................................... 44 Options A and B VISSIM Travel Time Comparison .................................................................................. 44 Options A and B Network Performance .................................................................................................. 46 Multimodal and Safety Recommendations for Local Intersections ........................................................ 47 Conclusions ................................................................................................................................................. 50 2045 Altneratives Analysis ...................................................................................................................... 50 Downstream Impacts of Town Selected Alternative 1 ........................................................................... 53 Additional Mitigation Solutions for Local Intersections ......................................................................... 53 Appendix ..................................................................................................................................................... 55 Appendix A: 2023 Existing Traffic Volumes .......................................................................................... A-1 Appendix B: 2023 Existing Operating Conditions (Synchro) .................................................................. B-1 Appendix C: 2023 Existing Operating Conditions (VISSIM) .................................................................... C-1 Appendix D: Traffic Forecasting Memorandum .................................................................................... D-1 Appendix E: 2045 No-Build Traffic Volumes .......................................................................................... E-1 Appendix F: 2045 No-Build Traffic Operating Conditions (Synchro)...................................................... F-1 Appendix G: 2045 No-Build Traffic Operating Conditions (VISSIM) ..................................................... G-1 Appendix H: Four Lane Viability Review Technical Memorandum; Seismic Study Review; Cursory Review of Southern Bypass ................................................................................................................... H-1 Appendix I: 2045 Alternative 1 Traffic Volumes and Operating Conditions (Synchro) ........................... I-1 Appendix J: Technical Environmental Overview .................................................................................... J-1 Appendix K: 2045 Alternative 2 Traffic Volumes and Operating Conditions (Synchro) ........................ K-1 Appendix L: 2045 Alternative 3 Traffic Volumes and Operating Conditions (Synchro) ......................... L-1 Appendix M: 2045 Alternative 4 Traffic Volumes and Operating Conditions (Synchro) ..................... M-1 Appendix N: 2045 Modified Alternative 1 Operating Conditions (VISSIM) .......................................... N-1 Appendix O: 2045 Local Intersections Operating Conditions (VISSIM) ................................................ O-1 Page 100 of 329 P A G E | iii Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1. Entire Project Study Area ............................................................................................................... 2 Figure 2. Modified Original Project Study Area ............................................................................................ 2 Figure 3. Alternative 1: SCDOT Modified Recommended Preferred .......................................................... 15 Figure 4. Example Bowtie Intersection (Provided by Virginia DOT) ........................................................... 16 Figure 5. Example Echelon (Provided by Virginia DOT) .............................................................................. 18 Figure 6. Example Center Turn Overpass (Provided by Virginia DOT) ........................................................ 18 Figure 7. Example of Elevated Bypass - 01 .................................................................................................. 20 Figure 8. Example of Elevated Bypass - 02 .................................................................................................. 20 Figure 9. Example of Elevated Bypass - 03 .................................................................................................. 21 Figure 10. Example of Elevated Bypass - 04 ................................................................................................ 21 Figure 11. Proposed Roundabout Configuration at Sea Pines Circle Under Option A ................................ 43 Page 101 of 329 P A G E | iv Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT LIST OF TABLES Table 1. Intersection Level of Service Criteria .............................................................................................. 6 Table 2. 2023 Existing VISSIM Calibration Travel Time Results .................................................................... 7 Table 3. 2023 Existing VISSIM Calibration Traffic Volumes Results .............................................................. 8 Table 4. Existing Corridor Speeds (VISSIM) ................................................................................................. 10 Table 5. Network Performance – Existing Conditions ................................................................................ 10 Table 6. 2045 No-Build VISSIM Calibration Travel Time Results ................................................................. 12 Table 7. 2045 No-Build VISSIM Calibration Traffic Volumes Results .......................................................... 12 Table 8. Network Performance – 2045 No-Build Conditions ...................................................................... 13 Table 9. Travel Time Comparison for Alternative 1 .................................................................................... 23 Table 10. Travel Time Comparison for Alternative 2 .................................................................................. 25 Table 11. Expected Change in Travel Time for Left-Turning Vehicles at Bowtie Intersections .................. 25 Table 12. Travel Time Comparison for Alternative 3 .................................................................................. 28 Table 13. Travel Time Comparison for Alternative 4 .................................................................................. 31 Table 14. Traffic Operations Overview Matrix ............................................................................................ 33 Table 15. Bicycle and Pedestrian Overview Matrix..................................................................................... 34 Table 16. Right-of-Way Overview Matrix ................................................................................................... 35 Table 17. Environmental Overview Matrix ................................................................................................. 36 Table 18. Overall Scoring Matrix ................................................................................................................. 37 Table 19. 2045 Modified Alternative 1 VISSIM Travel Time Results ........................................................... 40 Table 20. Network Performance – 2045 Modified Alternative 1 Without Improvements to Downstream Intersections ............................................................................................................................................... 41 Table 21. Comparison of Final Travel Times for Entire Study Area ............................................................ 46 Table 22. Network Performance for Entire Study Area .............................................................................. 47 Page 102 of 329 P A G E | v Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina commissioned an independent study of the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor to assess the need for improvements along US 278 (William Hilton Parkway) from Moss Creek Drive to Indigo Run Drive, as well as along US 278 (Palmetto Bay Road) from Cross Island Parkway to Sea Pines Circle. This report summarizes Existing and future year No-Build traffic operations along the corridor to quantify mobility issues that exist today and that would be expected in the future, absent any upgrades to the roadway network. Additionally, this report details the numerous corridor alternatives considered for implementation along William Hilton Parkway between Moss Creek Drive and Gum Tree Road. Proposed alternatives consisting of two at-grade solutions and two grade separated solutions were analyzed in further detail. The goal of the corridor alternatives analysis was to provide an objective, data-driven evaluation of the four alternatives. This evaluation was then used to assist with the selection of a single recommended alternative for the corridor between Moss Creek and Gum Tree Road. EXISTING AND NO -BUILD CONDITIONS CONGESTION AND CORRIDOR MOBILITY • In 2045, out of a total of 105 intersection approaches, 19 and 24 intersection approaches experienced levels of service between E/F throughout the study corridor during the AM and PM peak hours, respectively. • The existing vehicle speeds along William Hilton Parkway between Moss Creek Drive and Indigo Run Drive average at approximately 19 miles per hour (mph) in the eastbound direction during the AM peak hour and approximately 17 mph in the westbound direction during the PM peak hour. This is well below the posted speed limits, indicating significant congestion along the corridor today. • It was found that an over-saturation of the study area under the 2045 No-Build scenario resulted in vehicles not being able to enter the VISSIM simulation network. Therefore, some of the vehicles in the model were not processed through each intersection. • The 2045 No-Build travel times along the William Hilton Parkway corridor between Moss Creek Drive and Indigo Run are higher than existing conditions. It is expected that the travel time in the eastbound direction during the AM peak hour will increase from approximately 19.3 minutes to 26.3 minutes, an increase of 7 minutes (36%) when compared to existing conditions. During the PM peak hour, it is expected that the travel time in the westbound direction will increase from 20.9 minutes to 25.7 minutes, an increase of approximately 5 minutes (23%) when compared to existing conditions. CORRIDOR STUDY GOALS The following goals for improving the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor were established by Town of Hilton Head representatives to guide the development of alternatives and form the basis for the alternatives analysis: Page 103 of 329 P A G E | vi Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT • Fix the transportation issues in the corridor in a way that improves the safety and quality of life for all residents, workers, and visitors to Hilton Head Island a) Address transportation needs for natural disasters and resiliency of island access b) Consider future transportation alternatives • Improve the safety and quality of life for the residents of the neighborhoods and businesses directly impacted by the US 278 corridor a) Stoney Community b) Neighborhoods on Jenkins and Hog Islands (including but not limited to Windmill Harbor) • Have a gateway to and from Hilton Head Island that the region will be proud of: a) Aesthetically pleasing and reflecting the Hilton Head Island/Low Country values b) Safe and functional pathways for pedestrians and cyclists c) Minimizes environmental impacts and enhances the national asset of Pinckney Island PROPOSED ALTERNATIVES SELECTED FOR ANALYSIS Four proposed corridor alternatives were developed to help mitigate congestion along William Hilton Parkway between Moss Creek Drive and Gum Tree Road. ALTERNATIVE 1: SCDOT MODIFIED RECOMMENDED PREFERRED • Alternative 1 considers the SCDOT Modified Recommended Preferred alternative with adaptive signals in place and improvements at Gum Tree Road. • The improvements at Gum Tree Road include keeping the intersection at-grade, completely reconfiguring the intersection to improve its efficiency, and providing dual left-turn lanes for the westbound, northbound, and southbound approaches. ALTERNATIVE 2: BOWTIES • Alternative 2 considers bowties at Squire Pope Road and Spanish Wells Road with adaptive signals in place and aforementioned improvements at Gum Tree Rd. • A bowtie intersection removes left-turns from the intersection and requires vehicles to navigate through roundabouts along the side-street to return to the signal and continue in their intended direction of travel. ALTERNATIVE 3: ECHELON / CENTER TURN OVERPASS • Alternative 3 considers either an echelon or a center turn overpass at either Squire Pope Road or Spanish Wells Rd. Echelons or Center Turn Overpasses at both Squire Pope Road and Spanish Wells Road were not considered because there is not enough distance between intersections for both to be independently grade-separated. • Alternative 3 also considers the aforementioned improvements at Gum Tree Road. Page 104 of 329 P A G E | vii Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT • An echelon is a grade-separate intersection where one approach on both roadways is elevated. For example, the northbound and eastbound approaches would be elevated and the southbound and westbound approaches would remain at-grade to create two intersections. Both intersections would be signalized and all pedestrian and bicycle movements would remain at-grade. • A center turn overpass is also a grade-separated intersection which raises only the left-turn movements from the main intersection using ramps to create two intersections. Both intersections would be signalized and all pedestrian and bicycle movements would remain at-grade. ALTERNATIVE 4: ELEVATED BYPASS • Alternative 4 considers an elevated bypass which would begin west of Squire Pope Road and end east of Gum Tree Road. The elevated bypass takes the four internal lanes, two in each direction, and elevates them over the study intersections. This would allow free-flow movement for the eastbound and westbound thru traffic from just east of the Jenkins Island causeway to just west of Wilborn Road. One lane in each direction along William Hilton Parkway would remain at grade along with a separate eastbound right-turn lane at Squire Pope Road and left-turn lanes at Squire Pope Road and Spanish Wells Road. This allows for full access to be maintained at Squire Pope Road and Spanish Wells Road. Full access could also be provided at Old Wild Horse Rd, which is currently a right-in/right-out intersection, in this scenario. • The elevated bypass would directly connect to the Cross Island Parkway and allow thru vehicles to bypass Gum Tree Road. In the eastbound direction, the two eastbound lanes would expand to provide one lane to the Cross Island Pkwy, one lane to William Hilton Parkway at-grade for access to Gum Tree Road, and two lanes will continue along the elevated bypass and connect to the at-grade section just east of Gum Tree Road, allowing thru vehicles to also bypass Gum Tree Road. The goal of the alternatives analysis was to provide an objective, data-driven evaluation of the four corridor alternatives. Therefore, various matrices were compiled with respect to traffic operations, bicycle and pedestrian accommodations, right-of-way (ROW) requirements, and environmental factors to inform an overall scoring matrix. Each of the matrices includes scores for various categories. A score of 1 is the highest ranking, whereas a score of 4 is the lowest ranking. The ranking for each category were tallied to reach a total aggregate score per alternative. Alternative 1 ranked first with a total score of 20. Alternative 4 ranked second with a total score of 21. Alternative 2 ranked third with a total score of 24, and Alternative 3 ranked last with a total score of 28. Page 105 of 329 P A G E | viii Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT Resource/Category Alternative 1 (Mod. SCDOT Recommended Preferred) Alternative 2 (Bowties at Squire Pope and Spanish Wells) Alternative 3 (Echelon / Center Turn Overpass) Alternative 4 (Elevated Bypass) Traffic Operations (Throughput and Traffic Simulations) 4 3 3 1 ROW Impact 2 4 4 1 Environmental Impact 1 3 4 2 Safety 4 3 3 1 Bike/Pedestrian Impact 4 3 1 2 Community and Social Impact 1 3 4 2 Aesthetic 2 1 3 4 Preliminary Probable Opinion of Cost 1 2 3 4 Construction Duration 1 2 3 4 TOTAL 20 24 28 21 RANK 1 3 4 2 Page 106 of 329 P A G E | ix Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT Per the direction of the Town of Hilton Head Island, Lochmueller Group was directed to pursue corridor Alternative 1: South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) Modified Recommended Preferred with modifications to provide a single eastbound left-turn lane and a single southbound right-turn lane at the intersection of William Hilton Parkway at Squire Pope Road. With the recommended improvements under Alternative 1: SCDOT Modified Recommended Preferred in place, this report further provides an evaluation on the impacts to the intersections downstream (i.e., east of Gum Tree Road to Indigo Run, and south of Cross Island Parkway to Sea Pines Circle). Two additional options for mitigation are provided herein for the Town of Hilton Head Island’s consideration to help ease congestion along the local intersections between Gum Tree Road and Indigo Run Drive, as well as along the Cross Island Parkway towards Sea Pines Circle. Page 107 of 329 P A G E | 1 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT INTRODUCTION The Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina commissioned an independent review of the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor to assess congestion related issues along US 278 (William Hilton Parkway) from Moss Creek Drive to Indigo Run Drive, as well as along US 278 (Palmetto Bay Road) from Cross Island Parkway to Sea Pines Circle. This report summarizes Existing and future year No-Build traffic operations along the William Hilton Parkway corridor to quantify mobility issues that exist today and that would be expected in the future, absent any upgrades to the corridor. Additionally, this report details the numerous alternatives considered for implementation along William Hilton Parkway between Moss Creek Drive and Gum Tree Road. Proposed alternatives consisting of two at-grade solutions and two grade separated solutions were then analyzed to help alleviate congestion along the corridor. The goal of the corridor alternatives analysis was to provide an objective, data-driven evaluation of the four alternatives. After review of the four corridor alternatives, the Town of Hilton Head Island directed Lochmueller Group to pursue further evaluation of Alternative 1: SCDOT Modified Recommended Preferred with modifications to provide a single eastbound left-turn lane and a single southbound right-turn lane at William Hilton Parkway at Squire Pope Rd. This report details the final projected operating conditions for the selected alternative and addresses the potential downstream impacts to the intersections along William Hilton Parkway between Gum Tree Road and Indigo Run Drive, as well as along Cross Island Parkway to Sea Pines Circle assuming no additional improvements are in place. Lastly, two additional mitigation solutions were developed to address congestion issues at the local intersections between Gum Tree Road and Indigo Run Drive, as well as along Cross Island Parkway to Sea Pines Circle. STUDY OBJECTIVE The objective of this study was to provide an independent review and end-to-end analysis of the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor. This study assessed congestion related issues along the corridor between Moss Creek Drive and Indigo Run Drive, as well as along the Cross Island Parkway to Sea Pines Circle. The intention of this study was to evaluate several corridor alternatives to help address the existing and future projected congestion in order to provide the Town of Hilton Head Island with a data driven analysis. Page 108 of 329 P A G E | 2 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT Figure 1. Entire Project Study Area Figure 2. Modified Original Project Study Area Moss Creek Dr Indigo Run Dr Gum Tree Rd Sea Pines Circle Buckingham Plantation Dr Moss Creek Dr Gum Tree Rd Buckingham Plantation Dr Page 109 of 329 P A G E | 3 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT STUDY OVERVIEW William Hilton Parkway (US 278) is currently classified as a principal arterial oriented in the east-west direction within the study area, providing connectivity to Hilton Head Island. This study was completed in several phases. The first phase evaluated the 2023 Existing conditions and 2045 No-Build conditions for the entire project area, which includes William Hilton Parkway from Moss Creek Drive to Indigo Run Drive, as well as Palmetto Bay Road from Cross Island Parkway to Sea Pines Circle, as shown in Figure 1. The second phase evaluated four alternatives to help reduce congestion along the William Hilton Parkway corridor between Moss Creek Drive and Gum Tree Road. This is referred to as the Modified Original Project Study Area and is shown in Figure 2. Of those four corridor alternatives, one was selected for further evaluation to assess the impacts throughout the Entire Project Study Area. The third and final phase evaluated the impacts of the selected corridor alternative from the second phase of analysis, and further recommendations were made to help improve the overall operations of the Entire Project Study Area (Figure 1). BACKGROUND DATA COLLECTION AND FIELD INVENTORY TRAFFIC DATA Traffic volumes were collected by others at the following intersections on March 22, 2023, and provided to Lochmueller Group for use in this analysis: • Buckingham Plantation Dr and Bluffton Pkwy • Buckingham Plantation Dr and US 278 • Moss Creek Dr and US 278 • WB Bluffton Pkwy Ramp and WB US 278 • EB Bluffton Pkwy Ramp and EB US 278 • Fording Island Rd Extension and US 278 • Pinckney Wildlife Refuge and US 278 • Blue Heron Point Rd and US 278 • Crosstree Dr and US 278 • Jenkins Rd and US 278 • Squire Pope Rd and US 278 • Spanish Wells Rd and US 278 • Cross Island Pkwy Diverge and EB US 278 • Cross Island Pkwy Merge and WB US 278 • Gum Tree Rd and Cross Island Pkwy Off and On Ramps • Gum Tree Rd and Business US 278 • Jarvis Park Rd and Business US 278 • Pembroke Dr and Business US 278 • Indigo Run Dr and Business US 278 • Marshland Rd and Spanish Wells Rd • Marshland Rd and SB Cross Island Pkwy Ramps • Marshland Rd and NB Cross Island Pkwy Ramps • Arrow Rd and US 278 • Target Rd and US 278 • Sea Pines Circle and US 278 This study evaluated conditions during the morning and evening peak periods of a typical weekday, as these periods represent the most critical times of day for traffic operations within the study area for commuter peaks. If traffic can be accommodated during these peak periods, it stands to reason that adequate capacity would be available throughout the remainder of the day. Page 110 of 329 P A G E | 4 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT Traffic data utilized for this study is based on a combination of historical traffic counts obtained from SCDOT supplemented with new counts performed in March 2023. From the data, the weekday peak hours of traffic for the entire project study area were determined to occur between 7:00 AM and 8:00 AM in the morning and from 4:30 PM to 5:30 PM during the afternoon. Corridor studies often reference the 30th highest day for traffic volumes to ensure that the volumes used in the analysis reflect peak conditions, while not over- or under-estimating the traffic volumes. Therefore, it was necessary to ensure that the counts collected accurately reflect the 30th highest day. Historical traffic data was obtained from SCDOT from the most recent 365 days. Given that the study focuses on commuter peak hours, the hourly data from 6:00 AM – 6:00 PM was referenced. After reviewing the traffic volumes throughout the year, it was determined that March 30, 2023 was the 30th highest day out of the year for traffic volumes. The counts collected on March 22, 2023 were grown by the percent difference between the two dates to bring them up to the estimated traffic volumes on March 30, 2023 (30th highest day). The resulting 2023 traffic volumes used in this study are provided in Appendix A. Page 111 of 329 P A G E | 5 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT FIELD INVENTORY A detailed inventory of field conditions was performed to capture both physical and operational characteristics of the study area network. The physical inventory emphasized static features of the roadway and included items such as posted speed limits, number of travel lanes, lane designations at intersections, adaptive signal operations, and traffic signal phasing (e.g., protected turn arrows versus permissive turning movements). This detailed inventory of field conditions, as well as traffic observations focused on traffic flows during the peak periods, was performed over the course of two weekdays in December 2023. Locations of congestion and traffic backups were identified and monitored to determine sources of constrained flows. Prevailing queue lengths at intersections were inventoried. Traffic signal operations were monitored to determine the quality of traffic progression along the William Hilton Parkway corridor and to identify the operations of the recently installed (late Fall 2023) adaptive signal system. Travel time runs and average speeds were conducted during the AM and PM peak periods along William Hilton Parkway between Moss Creek Drive and Indigo Run Drive, as well as from William Hilton Parkway at Moss Creek Drive to Cross Island Parkway at Sea Pines Circle, as detailed in the model calibration section of this document. ANALYSIS METHODOLOGY TRAFFIC A preliminary analysis was completed using Synchro 11 traffic modeling software, which is based upon the methodologies outlined in the “Highway Capacity Manual” (HCM) published by the Transportation Research Board. Intersection performance or traffic operations are quantified by six Levels of Service (LOS), which range from LOS A ("Free Flow”) to LOS F ("Fully Saturated"). LOS D is considered acceptable for peak period conditions in urban and suburban areas. However, at side-street stop-controlled intersections, LOS E or even F is common occurrence for peak period conditions as it is typical for delays to be longer for vehicles along the side-street as they wait to find acceptable gaps in the traffic to turn into the traffic stream. Table 1 shows the LOS criteria for signalized and unsignalized intersections. Levels of service for intersections are determined based on the average delay experienced by motorists. Signalized intersections reflect higher delay tolerances as compared to unsignalized and roundabout locations because motorists are accustomed to and accepting of longer delays at signals. For signalized and all-way stop intersections, the average control delay per vehicle is estimated for each movement and then aggregated for each approach and the intersection as a whole. For intersections with partial (side-street) stop control, the delay is calculated for the minor movements only (side-street approaches and major road left-turns) since thru traffic on the major road is not required to stop. Page 112 of 329 P A G E | 6 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT Table 1. Intersection Level of Service Criteria Level of Service Control Delay per Vehicle (sec/veh) Signalized Unsignalized A ≤ 10 0 - 10 B > 10 - 20 > 10 - 15 C > 20 - 35 > 15 - 25 D > 35 - 55 > 25 -35 E > 55 - 80 > 35 - 50 F > 80 > 50 Source: HCM 6th Edition In addition to Synchro, VISSIM software was also used, which is a microsimulation tool that accurately replicates individual vehicles and their interactions within complex traffic streams, such as interchanges, freeways, and expressway corridors with signalized intersections. A robust amount of data and field observations were conducted, as previously described, to calibrate the VISSIM models to closely replicate field conditions. MODEL CALIBRATION The VISSIM traffic simulation model calibration process began with the development of a base model, which aims to replicate Existing conditions. As previously noted, a robust data collection effort was required to support this effort, including roadway geometry, turning speeds, traffic signal timings, etc. The first step in base model development involved coding the roadway geometry (number of lanes, lane configurations, link lengths, etc.) with links and connectors using a recent aerial as a template. Once the network backbone was established, free-flow speed distributions were created. Reduced speed zones were also established for turning movements and locations in the network where the roadway geometry physically limits speeds below the free-flow speed or posted speed limits. The next steps addressed traffic control. The adaptive traffic signal timings obtained from Q-Free were input into the simulation, with detectors coded where applicable. Stop-controlled movements received stop signs coded into the network. Locations where yielding or traffic control priority needed to be established (such as a right-turn-on-red) were coded with conflict areas or priority rules. Conflict areas are most commonly used unless further refinement of the gap times or yielding characteristics was necessary, in which case priority rules were deployed. Traffic volumes were then represented in the VISSIM model as an origin-destination matrix estimated from turning movement counts. The matrix specifies the model’s traffic patterns and the routes vehicles take to traverse the model network. Traffic entering the model network was coded using vehicle inputs. Vehicle inputs specify volumes and vehicle type compositions, which were grouped into passenger vehicles, trucks, light-goods, and buses. The origin-destination matrix was routed statically with routes traversing the entire network for optimum accuracy rather than simply intersection by intersection. Page 113 of 329 P A G E | 7 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT Since VISSIM starts with zero vehicles in the network, a warm-up period is needed to initiate the model with traffic prior to capturing data. The warm-up period is known as the seeding period and its length and volume characteristics were adjusted as part of the calibration process. Given the scale of the network, a 60-minute seeding period was used to establish background traffic before recording results. Given the inherent stochastic nature of simulation (imposed by random seeds), multiple simulation runs using different seed numbers were required for each scenario and the reported model results were averaged across runs. Ten simulation runs were completed, which is typically sufficient to obtain an appropriate level of confidence in the results. The model calibration process finished with a detailed review of model parameters and thorough consideration of adjustments to improve the model’s ability to replicate field conditions. The final calibration process compared data output from the model, such as travel times and flow rates, to field measurements of the same attributes. As part of the calibration criteria, it was determined that the travel times reported in the VISSIM model should be within 10% of the travel times recorded in the field. The travel times calculated in the VISSIM model were inflated by 15% to account for higher volumes in March (when traffic counts were collected) versus in December (when the travel times were collected). The travel time results are provided in Table 2. As shown, all the travel times reported by the Existing conditions VISSIM model were within 10% of the observed travel times recorded during field observations. Therefore, all travel time targets were satisfied. Table 2. 2023 Existing VISSIM Calibration Travel Time Results Corridor Observed Travel Time (secs) [min] Simulated Travel Time (secs) [min] % Difference AM PM AM PM AM PM William Hilton Pkwy between Moss Creek and Indigo Run EB 1108 [18.5 min] 672 ]11.2 min] 1157 [19.3 min] 619 [10.3 min] 4.42% -7.91% WB 605 [10.1 min] 1202 [20 min] 572 [9.5 min] 1252 [20.9 min] -5.50% 4.17% William Hilton Pkwy from Moss Creek to Sea Pine Circle via Cross Island Pkwy SB 1378 [23 min] 821 [13.7 min] 1356 [22.6 min] 857 [14.3 min] -1.58% 4.37% NB 800 [13.3 min] 1516 [25.3 min] 826 [13.8 min] 1520 [25.3 min] 3.20% 0.25% In addition to travel time calculations, traffic volumes were also used to help calibrate the VISSIM model. Similar to the travel times, it was determined that the traffic volumes reported in the VISSIM model should be within 10% of the 2023 existing traffic volumes provided in Appendix A. The traffic volume results are provided in Table 3. As shown, all the traffic volumes reported by the existing conditions VISSIM model were within 10% of the calculated 2023 existing corridor traffic volumes. Therefore, all traffic volume targets were satisfied. Page 114 of 329 P A G E | 8 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT Table 3. 2023 Existing VISSIM Calibration Traffic Volumes Results Location Observed Traffic Volumes (vehicles) Simulated Traffic Volumes (vehicles) % Difference AM PM AM PM AM PM William Hilton Pkwy west of Squire Pope EB 2774 2237 2970 2240 7.07% 0.13% William Hilton Pkwy west of Squire Pope WB 1639 3030 1650 2898 0.67% -4.36% William Hilton Pkwy east of Spanish Wells EB 2729 1991 2929 1955 7.33% -1.81% William Hilton Pkwy east of Spanish Wells WB 1408 2623 1423 2614 1.07% -0.34% Cross Island Pkwy north of Marshland Rd NB 975 1422 964 1371 -1.13% -3.59% Cross Island Pkwy north of Marshland Rd SB 1416 1190 1486 1167 4.94% -1.93% EXISTING CONDITIONS EXISTING SYNCHRO TRAFFIC OPERATIONAL ANALYSIS A preliminary analysis was completed using Synchro 11 traffic modeling software, which is based upon the methodologies outlined in the “Highway Capacity Manual” (HCM) published by the Transportation Research Board. Operating conditions at the study intersections were evaluated using Synchro 11 and are summarized in Appendix B. The measures of effectiveness reported include LOS, delay, queue, and volume-to-capacity ratio (v/c). The delay is reported in seconds per vehicle. The queue is reported in feet as the 95th percentile queue, which represents a value that is only expected to be exceeded once or twice during a peak hour. The v/c ratio compares vehicle demand to the capacity of an associated lane group. A v/c ratio of 1.0 represents a road segment that is at full capacity. A v/c ratio that exceeds 1.0 represents a road segment that is oversaturated or has more vehicular demand than the provided roadway geometry can theoretically support. It was found that the eastbound traffic experiences significant congestion during the AM peak period, whereas westbound traffic experiences significant congestion during the PM peak period. This is consistent with the commuter traffic patterns in the Town of Hilton Head. While several intersections experience long delays and queue lengths during the AM peak hour, the PM peak hour appears to have overall worse operating conditions. Long delays occur along side-streets at unsignalized intersections throughout the entire study area. Additionally, a rolling queue begins at Wilborn Road and continues in the westbound lanes of William Hilton Parkway over the bridge during the PM peak hour. The westbound queue length reaches up to approximately 2,500 ft (101 cars) at Squire Pope during the PM peak hour. It is evident that the study area currently experiences congestion during both the AM and PM peak periods. Page 115 of 329 P A G E | 9 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT EXISTING VISSIM TRAFFIC OPERATIONAL ANALYSIS A VISSIM traffic model was also completed to further evaluate conditions during the morning and afternoon peak hours, and provides performance measures as outputs. The LOS criteria for signalized and unsignalized intersections are the same as Table 1. The measures of effectiveness (MOE) reported include levels of service, delay, average queue length, and maximum observed queue length. The delay is reported in seconds per vehicle and the queue is reported in feet. The 2023 Existing operating conditions based on the VISSIM model are summarized in Appendix C. The traffic operations largely agree with those shown in Appendix B from the Synchro analysis. The PM peak hour appears to have overall worse operating conditions than the AM peak period. The long delays presented in the Synchro analysis along side-streets at unsignalized intersections throughout the entire study area were confirmed in the VISSIM analysis. The study area experiences significant congestion during both the existing AM and PM peak periods. EXISTING VISSIM NETWORK PERFORMANCE The existing average recorded speeds along William Hilton Parkway between Moss Creek Drive and Indigo Run range from approximately 19 miles per hour (mph) in the AM peak hour to 35 mph during the PM peak hour for the eastbound direction, as shown in Table 4. The posted speed limit along the corridor ranges between 45-55 mph. Therefore, it is evident that the existing average recoded speeds are well below the posted speed limit, which is an indication that there is significant congestion along the corridor. The westbound direction experiences average speeds of approximately 38 mph during the AM peak hour and 17 mph during the PM peak hour. This indicates significant congestion in the westbound direction during the PM peak hour, as is evidenced by the commuter peaks. Between Moss Creek Drive and Sea Pines Circle via the Cross Island Parkway in the southbound direction, the average recorded speed is approximately 27 mph during the AM peak hour and the average recorded speed is 42 mph during the PM peak hour. In the opposite direction, the average recorded speed is approximately 44 mph during the AM peak hour and 24 mph in the PM peak hour. Similar to the William Hilton Parkway corridor between Moss Creek Drive and Indigo Run, this corridor also experiences congestion in relation to the commuter peaks. Table 5 further breaks down overall network performance for the existing peak period conditions. As shown, throughout the entire project area, vehicles are required to stop on average between 6 to 10 times when traveling along the corridor. Page 116 of 329 P A G E | 10 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT Table 4. Existing Corridor Speeds (VISSIM) Routes Average Speed (mph) AM Peak Hour PM Peak Hour Moss Creek Drive to Indigo Run Drive – Eastbound 18.9 35.2 Indigo Run Drive to Moss Creek Drive – Westbound 38.0 17.4 Moss Creek Drive to Sea Pines Circle – Southbound 26.6 42.1 Sea Pines Circle to Moss Creek Drive – Northbound 43.9 23.8 Table 5. Network Performance – Existing Conditions Peak Hour Average Number of Stops per Vehicle Average Speed (mph) Total Vehicles (vph) Existing AM 6.5 25 10,497 Existing PM 9.9 22 12,393 2045 NO -BUILD CONDITIONS 2045 was selected as the project’s design year for purposes of evaluating traffic operations conditions into the future. The 2045 No-Build conditions analysis is intended to reflect future conditions within the study area while accounting for an increase in “background” traffic. No modifications were made to the lane configurations. The 2045 No-Build scenario does include the effects of the adaptive signal system implemented in the Fall of 2023, as well as the inclusion of Windmill Harbour into the adaptive signal system. In order to evaluate traffic conditions through the year 2045, it was necessary to forecast the anticipated growth within the study area based on an increase in “background” traffic resulting from increasing population and commercial and employment growth in The Town of Hilton Head. An annual background growth rate of 0.56% was determined after careful consideration of the Lowcountry Area Transportation Study (LATS) Travel Demand Model (TDM), census data, Beaufort County historic growth trends, historic traffic growth on the US 278 bridge, sale and restaurant tax revenue, public parking revenue, and short term rental data. A memorandum detailing the methodology behind the 0.56% growth rate is provided in Appendix D. The 2023 Existing traffic volumes were grown annually by 0.56% to 2045 in order to produce the 2045 No-Build traffic volumes which are provided in Appendix E. Page 117 of 329 P A G E | 11 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT 2045 NO -BUILD SYNCHRO TRA FFIC OPERATIONAL ANALYSIS The 2045 No-Build operating conditions at the study intersections were preliminarily evaluated using Synchro 11 and are summarized in Appendix F. The previously failing conditions and congestion experienced in the 2023 Existing conditions are expected to be exacerbated by 2045 with the forecasted background traffic growth. Significant congestion is expected throughout the study area. Therefore, it can be concluded that the study intersections cannot accommodate the forecasted traffic growth in their existing state. 2045 NO -BUILD VISSIM TRAFFIC OPERATIONAL ANALYSIS The 2045 No-Build operating conditions at the study intersections were further evaluated using VISSIM and are summarized in Appendix G. The operating conditions largely agree with those shown in the 2045 No-Build Synchro operating conditions (Appendix F) and validate the travel time and volume conclusions above. Significant congestion is expected throughout the study area through the year 2045. The congestion that currently exists throughout the study area is expected to be exacerbated by 2045 with the forecasted growth. 2045 NO -BUILD VISSIM NETWORK PERFORMANCE The VISSIM differences in reported travel time calculations and traffic volumes between the 2023 Existing conditions and 2045 No-Build conditions were evaluated and shown in Table 6 and Table 7, respectively. It is expected that the travel time in the eastbound direction along Hilton Parkway between Moss Creek Drive and Indigo Run Drive during the AM peak hour will increase from approximately 19.3 minutes to 26.3 minutes, an increase of 7 minutes (36%) when compared to existing conditions. During the PM peak hour along Hilton Parkway between Moss Creek Drive and Indigo Run Drive, it is expected that the travel time in the westbound direction will increase from 20.9 minutes to 25.7 minutes, an increase of approximately 5 minutes (23%) when compared to existing conditions It is expected that the travel time in the southbound direction along Hilton Parkway at Moss Creek to Cross Island Parkway at Sea Pines Circle during the AM peak hour will increase from approximately 22.6 minutes to 30.1 minutes, an increase of 7.5 minutes (46%) when compared to existing conditions. During the PM peak hour along Hilton Parkway at Moss Creek to Cross Island Parkway at Sea Pines Circle, it is expected that the travel time in the northbound direction will increase from 25.3 minutes to 41.1 minutes, an increase of approximately 16 minutes (62%) when compared to existing conditions Multiple locations have negative percent differences for traffic volume results where the 2045 No-Build simulated volumes are less than the 2023 Existing simulated volumes. This is due to over-saturation of the study area in the model, and results in vehicles not being able to enter the simulation network to process through each intersection. Therefore, it is evident that the study area is expected to experience significant congestion through the year 2045. Page 118 of 329 P A G E | 12 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT Table 6. 2045 No-Build VISSIM Calibration Travel Time Results Corridor Existing Simulated Travel Time (secs) [min] 2045 No-Build Simulated Travel Time (secs) [min] % Difference AM PM AM PM AM PM William Hilton Pkwy between Moss Creek and Indigo Run EB 1157 [19.3 min] 619 [10.3 min] 1579 [26.3 min] 642 [10.7 min] 36.47% 3.72% WB 572 [9.5 min] 1252 [20.9 min] 584 [9.7 min] 1544 [25.7 min] 2.10% 23.32% William Hilton Pkwy from Moss Creek to Sea Pine Circle via Cross Island Pkwy SB 1356 [22.6 min] 857 [14.3 min] 1984 [30.1 min] 873 [14.6 min] 46.31% 1.87% NB 826 [13.8 min] 1520 [25.3 min] 823 [13.7 min] 2465 [41.1 min] -0.36% 62.17% Table 7. 2045 No-Build VISSIM Calibration Traffic Volumes Results Location Existing Simulated Volume Results (vehicles) 2045 No-Build Simulated Volume Results (vehicles) % Difference AM PM AM PM AM PM William Hilton Pkwy west of Squire Pope EB 2970 2240 2783 2524 -6.30% 12.68% William Hilton Pkwy west of Squire Pope WB 1650 2898 1843 2754 11.70% -4.97% William Hilton Pkwy east of Spanish Wells EB 2929 1955 2748 2198 -6.18% 12.43% William Hilton Pkwy east of Spanish Wells WB 1423 2614 1570 2413 10.33% -7.69% Cross Island Pkwy north of Marshland Rd NB 964 1371 1065 919 10.48% -32.97% Cross Island Pkwy north of Marshland Rd SB 1486 1167 1440 1299 -3.10% 11.31% Table 8 summarizes overall network performance for the 2045 No-Build scenario as compared to the Existing conditions through the entire study area. During the PM peak hour, vehicles stops will increase throughout the study area. Vehicles will be required to stop on average 10 to 15 times. Additionally, the average vehicle speeds during the PM peak hour will degrade to an average of 16 mph. These metrics are indicative of stop and go conditions and peak hour congestion. This is below the already congested existing average off-peak speed for the corridor which is 25 mph and 22 mph for AM and PM peak hours, respectively. Page 119 of 329 P A G E | 13 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT Due to congestion during the 2045 No-Build condition, approximately 10% of total network vehicles were unable to enter the model network, and therefore are not captured in the network performance results shown in Table 8. Table 8. Network Performance – 2045 No-Build Conditions Scenario Average Number of Stops per Vehicle Average Speed (mph) Total Vehicles (vph) Existing AM 6.5 25 10,497 Existing PM 9.9 22 12,393 2045 No-Build AM 9.9 21 11,143 2045 No-Build PM 15.4 16 12,393 2045 ALTERNAT IVES ANALYSIS In addition to the simulation modeling of the study area, Lochmueller evaluated several strategies in order to determine the viability of maintaining four lanes along William Hilton Parkway between Windmill Harbour and Squire Pope Road. The strategies included: • Implementation of a second bridge • Modifications to the existing mass transit system • Implementation of a new ferry system • Implementation of a facility usage fee Ultimately, it was determined that it would be highly unlikely that modifications to the existing transit system, the implementation of a new ferry system, or the implementation of a facility usage fee would reduce traffic volumes enough to maintain the existing four-lane section. Furthermore, it was determined that a six-lane section of William Hilton Parkway onto Hilton Head Island would be needed independently of a second bridge. Additional preliminary evaluations pertaining to the financial feasibility of structurally rehabilitating and/or seismically retrofitting the existing Mackay Creek and Skull Creek bridges in lieu of building a new six-lane structure were completed. A cursory, high-level evaluation of a potential southern bypass was also completed. Additional information regarding the above stated topics are provided in Appendix H. As evidenced by the Existing and No-Build conditions, some of the existing traditional signalized intersections will no longer be able to process the volume of vehicles within the William Hilton Parkway corridor study area by the year 2045. Therefore, innovative concepts to improve the capacity of the corridor were considered. Both at-grade and grade separated innovative intersections were evaluated to improve safety, reduce delay, and increase efficiency. Page 120 of 329 P A G E | 14 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT CORRIDOR STUDY GOALS The following goals for improving the William Hilton Parkway corridor were established by The Town of Hilton Head Island to guide the development of alternatives and form the basis of the alternatives analysis: • Fix the transportation issues in the corridor in a way that improves the safety and quality of life for all residents, workers, and visitors to Hilton Head Island a) Address transportation needs for natural disasters and resiliency of island access b) Consider future transportation alternatives • Improve the safety and quality of life for the residents of the neighborhoods and businesses directly impacted by the US 278 corridor a) Stoney Community b) Neighborhoods on Jenkins and Hog Islands (including but not limited to Windmill Harbor) • Have a gateway to and from Hilton Head Island that the region will be proud of: a) Aesthetically pleasing and reflecting the Hilton Head Island/Low County values b) Safe and functional pathways for pedestrians and cyclists c) Minimizes environmental impacts and enhances the national asset of Pinckney Island ALTERNATIVES CONSIDERED With the guiding principles in mind, the following four corridor alternatives were recommended for further study: • Alternative 1: SCDOT Modified Recommended Preferred • Alternative 2: Bowties at Squire Pope and Spanish Wells • Alternative 3: Echelon / Center Turn Overpass ➢ Grade-Separated Intersection at either Squire Pope or Spanish Wells, but not both • Alternative 4: Elevated Bypass As agreed upon with the Town of Hilton Head, the alternative analysis was completed for the Modified Original Project Study Area shown in Figure 2. ALTERNATIVE 1: SCDOT MODIFIED RECOMMENDED PREFERRED Alternative 1 considers the SCDOT Modified Recommended Preferred alternative with adaptive signals in place and improvements at Gum Tree Road. The improvements at Gum Tree Road include keeping the intersection at-grade, completely reconfiguring the intersection to improve its efficiency, and providing dual left-turn lanes for the westbound, northbound, and southbound approaches. Figure 3 shows the improvements recommended as part of Alternative 1, as provided by SCDOT. It should be noted that the improvements at Gum Tree Road are not reflected in Figure 3, which was provided by SCDOT. Page 121 of 329 P A G E | 15 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT Figure 3. Alternative 1: SCDOT Modified Recommended Preferred Page 122 of 329 P A G E | 16 ALTERNATIVE 2: BOWTIES AT SQUIRE POPE AND SPANISH WELLS Alternative 2 considers bowties at Squire Pope Road and Spanish Wells Road with adaptive signals in place and improvements at Gum Tree Road. The improvements at Gum Tree Road are the same as what was included in Alternative 1, which keeps the intersections at-grade, reconfigures the intersection to improve its efficiency, and provides dual left-turn lanes for the westbound, northbound, and southbound approaches. A bowtie intersection removes left-turns from the intersection and requires vehicles to navigate through roundabouts along the side-street to return to the signal and continue in the intended direction of travel. Figure 4 shows an example of a bowtie intersection. Note that this is only an example and not a schematic drawing of William Hilton Parkway. Figure 4. Example Bowtie Intersection (Provided by Virginia DOT) Page 123 of 329 P A G E | 17 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT Bowtie intersections provide several benefits. They improve safety as fewer conflicting vehicle and pedestrian movements are allowed. Bowtie intersections have 12 fewer conflict points when compared to traditional intersections, which have 32 conflict points. Bowtie intersections also encourage lower vehicle speeds through the roundabouts. The size of main intersections can be reduced as left-turn lanes are removed. Lastly, bowtie intersections increase the efficiency of the signalized intersections as more of the signal time can go to the main thru movements, improving traffic operations. However, bowtie intersections require a change in decision making for drivers as all left-turn movements would be required to navigate the adjacent roundabouts along Squire Pope Road and Spanish Wells Road. Bowtie intersections also may increase the amount of travel time for left-turning vehicles and may require additional ROW for the roundabouts. ALTERNATIVE 3: ECHELON / CENTER TURN OVERPASS Alternative 3 considers either an echelon or a center turn overpass at either Squire Pope Road or Spanish Wells Road. Echelons or center turn overpasses at both Squire Pope Road and Spanish Wells Road were not considered because there is not enough distance between the two intersections for both to be independently grade-separated. Alternative 3 includes the adaptive signals in place as well as the previously detailed improvements at Gum Tree Road. The improvements at Gum Tree Road are the same as what was included in Alternative 1, which keeps the intersections at-grade, reconfigures the intersection to improve its efficiency, and provides dual left-turn lanes for the westbound, northbound, and southbound approaches. An echelon is a grade-separated intersection where one approach on both roadways is elevated. For example, the northbound and eastbound approaches would be elevated and the southbound and westbound approaches would remain at-grade to create two intersections. Both intersections would be signalized and all pedestrian and bicycle movements would remain at-grade. Figure 5 shows an example of an echelon. Note that this is only an example and not a schematic drawing of William Hilton Parkway. An echelon improves safety as fewer conflicting vehicle and pedestrian movements are allowed. Echelon intersections have 10 fewer conflict points when compared to traditional intersections (32 conflict points). They do not require a change in decision making for drivers as all movements would remain at Squire Pope Road and Spanish Wells Road. Echelons increase the efficiency of the signalized intersections as more of the signal time can go to the main thru movements, improving traffic operations. While each approach would likely need the same lane configurations as shown in Alternative 1, only two approaches would conflict. However, echelons do require grade separation of intersections and large intersections would likely remain as all movements (left-turn, thru, and right-turn) are still allowed. A center turn overpass is also a grade-separated intersection which raises only the left-turn movements from the main intersection using ramps to create two intersections. Both intersections would be signalized and all pedestrian and bicycle movements would remain at-grade. Figure 6 shows an example of a center turn overpass. Note that this is only an example and not a schematic drawing of William Hilton Parkway. Page 124 of 329 P A G E | 18 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT A center turn overpass improves safety as fewer conflicting vehicle and pedestrian movements are allowed. Center turn overpass intersections have 8 fewer conflict points when compared to traditional intersections (32 conflict points). They increase the efficiency of the signalized intersections as more of the signal time can go to the main thru movements, improving traffic operations. However, similar to echelons, center turn overpasses require grade separation and large intersections would likely remain as all movements (left-turn, thru, and right-turn) are still allowed. Figure 5. Example Echelon (Provided by Virginia DOT) Figure 6. Example Center Turn Overpass (Provided by Virginia DOT) Page 125 of 329 P A G E | 19 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT ALTERNATIVE 4: ELEVATED BYPASS Alternative 4 considers an elevated bypass which would begin west of Squire Pope Road and end east of Gum Tree Road. The elevated bypass would take the four internal lanes, two in each direction, and elevate them over the study intersections. This would allow free-flow movement for the eastbound and westbound thru traffic from just east of the Jenkins Island causeway to just west of Wilborn Road. One lane in each direction along William Hilton Parkway would remain at grade along with a separate eastbound right-turn lane at Squire Pope Road and left-turn lanes at Squire Pope Road and Spanish Wells Road. This allows for full access to be maintained at Squire Pope Road and Spanish Wells Rd. Full access could also be provided at Old Wild Horse Road, which is currently a right-in/right-out intersection today. The elevated bypass would directly connect to the Cross Island Parkway. In the eastbound direction, the two eastbound lanes would expand to provide one lane to the Cross Island Pkwy, one lane to William Hilton Parkway at-grade for access to Gum Tree Road, and two lanes will continue along the elevated bypass and connect to the at-grade section just east of Gum Tree Road, allowing thru vehicles to also bypass Gum Tree Road. In the westbound direction, two lanes would be provided along William Hilton Parkway just east of Gum Tree Road. These lanes would be reduced to one lane prior to the merge with the westbound Cross Island Parkway ramp. The westbound Cross Island Parkway ramp and the single elevated westbound bypass ramp would then merge into a two-lane elevated section. Alternative 4 also assumes the adaptive signal system would remain in operation. However, the improvements needed at Gum Tree Road in Alternatives 1, 2, and 3 would no longer be needed. In fact, the Gum Tree Road intersection would be able to be reduced in size, as most of the eastbound and westbound thru traffic would remain on the bypass rather than navigating thru the at-grade intersection. Similarly, the at-grade intersections at Squire Pope Road and Spanish Wells Road would also be able to be reduced in size. An elevated bypass would improve safety, as fewer thru vehicles would remain at grade, thereby reducing the conflicts between vehicles and pedestrians. In addition, the efficiency of the at-grade signalized intersections would be increased despite the reduction in the size of the intersection. Lastly, Alternative 4 provides the most capacity for traffic growth along the corridor. However, this alternative would be the most expensive and would result in the largest construction impact. Alternative 4 also requires grade separation and a change in decision making, as drivers looking to continue traveling eastbound or westbound would need to enter the bypass, rather than go thru the local intersections of Squire Pope Road, Old Wildhorse Road, and Spanish Wells Road as they do today. Full access would still be provided at-grade. Figure 7 through Figure 10 provide an example schematic of the elevated bypass. Page 126 of 329 P A G E | 20 Figure 7. Example of Elevated Bypass - 01 Figure 8. Example of Elevated Bypass - 02 Spanish Wells Rd Page 127 of 329 P A G E | 21 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT Figure 9. Example of Elevated Bypass - 03 Figure 10. Example of Elevated Bypass - 04 Elevated Bypass Spanish Wells Rd Page 128 of 329 P A G E | 22 2045 ALTERNATIVE 1: SCDOT MODIFIED RECOMMENDED PREFERRED 2045 ALTERNATIVE 1 TRAFFIC VOLUMES The traffic volumes used for the 2045 Alternative 1 analysis were largely similar to the 2045 No-Build traffic volumes. However, some intersections were combined in this alternative, requiring traffic diversions. The 2045 Alternative 1 traffic volumes are provided in Appendix I. 2045 ALTERNATIVE 1 TRAFFIC OPERATIONAL ANALYSIS As agreed upon with the Town of Hilton Head, a preliminary traffic analysis was completed using Synchro 11. The 2045 Alternative 1 operating conditions were evaluated using the same methodology applied to the 2023 Existing and 2045 No-Build conditions. The operating conditions for the 2045 Alternative 1 scenario are shown in Appendix I. Overall the study intersections are expected to operate acceptably under Alternative 1. Each signalized intersection is expected to operate with a LOS D or better overall. However, side-street and unsignalized approaches may still experience long delays. This is to be expected given the heavy volumes experienced along the mainline of William Hilton Parkway and the inability of side-street traffic to find gaps in the mainline traffic to complete their movement. In addition to the Synchro operating conditions, preliminary travel time calculations were performed in Synchro along the William Hilton Parkway corridor between Moss Creek Drive and Indigo Run Drive. Synchro was used for the purposes of evaluating alternatives at a high level, as its results provide a reasonable comparison useful for preferred alternative selection. Final travel time results for the chosen preferred alternative were conducted in VISSIM. Table 9 shows the changes in travel time for the 2045 Alternative 1 scenario when compared to the 2045 No-Build scenario travel time results gathered from Synchro. As shown, Alternative 1 is expected to improve the travel time along eastbound William Hilton Parkway by approximately 16% during the AM peak period and westbound William Hilton Parkway by approximately 34% during the PM peak period. It should be noted that westbound William Hilton Parkway during the AM peak period and eastbound William Hilton Parkway during the PM peak period are not expected to experience significant congestion in the 2045 No-Build scenario, as traffic patterns in the study area largely follow commuter travel patterns. Therefore, the increase in travel time shown is not expected to significantly impact the operating conditions of the study area. Page 129 of 329 P A G E | 23 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT Table 9. Travel Time Comparison for Alternative 1 Scenario Difference in Travel Time (seconds) when Compared to 2045 No-Build % Difference AM PM AM PM 2045 Alternative 1: SCDOT Modified Recommended Preferred EB -109 [-1.8 min] +18 [<1 min] -16.1% 2.7% WB +43 [<1 min] -276 [-4.6 min] 6.3% -34.2% 2045 ALTERNATIVE 1 RIGHT -OF -WAY IMPACTS The proposed modifications to the SCDOT Preferred Alternative in this alternative involve reconfiguring the Gum Tree Road intersection to provide dual left-turn lanes for the westbound, northbound, and southbound approaches. These improvements will require a strip of additional ROW of approximately 0.2 acre on Town owned land, in the northeast quadrant to accommodate the additional southbound left turn lane. The lane additions on the westbound and northbound approaches can be accommodated within existing ROW. It should be noted that the ROW estimates refer to permanent ROW needed for the completed improvements only, and do not consider temporary ROW needed for construction or staging. 2045 ALTERNATIVE 1 ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS As noted above, Alternative 1 would require 0.2 acre of additional ROW. The additional ROW impacts are located within the Squire Pope neighborhood. The additional ROW to be acquired is owned by the Town of Hilton Head. The SCDOT Environmental Assessment (EA) determined that this area is an environmental justice community. One hazardous material site, Shell Food Mart Station 101 (165 William Hilton Pkwy), is located near the corridor. No impacts to the site are anticipated as a result of Alternative 1. The SCDOT recommended preferred alternative was determined to have a “may affect- not likely to adversely affect” finding for threatened and endangered species. Alternative 1 is not anticipated to alter this finding. Coordination with the USFWS and the NOAA National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) will need to occur to affirm this finding. Alternative 1 would not result in additional impacts to National Wetland Inventory (NWI) wetlands, streams, floodplains, or essential fish habitat types. No additional relocations would occur as a result of Alternative 1. No additional impacts to cultural resources or Section 4(f) properties would occur as a result of Alternative 1. Please refer to the Technical Environmental Overview in Appendix J for additional details. 2045 ALTERNATIVE 2: BOWTIES AT SQUIRE POPE AND SPANISH WELLS 2045 ALTERNATIVE 2 TRAFFIC VOLUMES The traffic volumes used for the 2045 Alternative 2 analysis were largely similar to the 2045 No-Build traffic volumes. However, given that the left-turns along William Hilton Parkway were removed at Squire Pope Road and Spanish Wells Road, some traffic diversions were necessary. The 2045 Alternative 2 traffic volumes are provided in Appendix K. Page 130 of 329 P A G E | 24 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT It should be noted that Lochmueller agrees with the improvements proposed along William Hilton Parkway between Moss Creek Drive and Crosstree Drive in Alternative 1. These improvements include the following: • Widen William Hilton Parkway from four lanes to six lanes from Salt Marsh Drive through Spanish Wells Drive • Reconfigure the intersection of William Hilton Parkway and Wildlife Refuge Driveway to eliminate left-turns and provide right-in/right-out access only • Consolidate Jenkins Island access to one signalized location at Crosstree Drive Therefore, those improvements were included in Alternative 2. As such, the traffic volumes at those intersections would be the same between Alternative 2 and Alternative 1. 2045 ALTERNATIVE 2 TRAFFIC OPERATIONAL ANALYSIS As agreed upon with the Town of Hilton Head, the preliminary traffic analysis was completed using Synchro 11. The 2045 Alternative 2 operating conditions were evaluated using the same methodology applied to the 2023 Existing and 2045 No-Build conditions. The operating conditions for the 2045 Alternative 2 scenario are shown in Appendix K. The bowties at Squire Pope and Spanish Wells are expected to improve operations throughout the study area. Overall, the study intersections are expected to operate acceptably under Alternative 2. Each signalized intersection is expected to operate with a LOS D or better overall. However, side-street and unsignalized approaches may still experience long delays. Similar to Alternative 1, this is to be expected given the heavy volumes experienced along the mainline of William Hilton Parkway and the inability of side-street traffic to find gaps in the mainline traffic to complete their movement. In addition to the Synchro operating conditions, preliminary travel time calculations were performed in Synchro along the William Hilton Parkway corridor between Moss Creek Drive and Indigo Run Drive. Synchro was used for the purposes of evaluating alternatives at a high level, as its results provide a reasonable comparison useful for preferred alternative selection. Final travel time results for the chosen preferred alternative were conducted in VISSIM. Table 10 shows the changes in travel time for the 2045 Alternative 2 scenario when compared to the 2045 No-Build scenario travel time results gathered from Synchro. As shown, Alternative 2 is expected to improve the travel time along eastbound William Hilton Parkway by approximately 15% during the AM peak period and westbound William Hilton Parkway by approximately 36% during the PM peak period. Page 131 of 329 P A G E | 25 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT Table 10. Travel Time Comparison for Alternative 2 Scenario Difference in Travel Time (seconds) when Compared to 2045 No-Build % Difference AM PM AM PM 2045 Alternative 2: Bowties at Squire Pope and Spanish Wells EB -104 [-1.7 min] -39 [<1 min] -15.3% -6.6% WB +9 [<1 min] -290 [-4.8 min] 1.4% -36.4% As previously noted, bowtie intersections may increase the total travel time for left-turning vehicles as they must alter their course to navigate through a roundabout and return to the main intersection to complete their movement. Therefore, the expected change in travel time was calculated in Synchro to better determine the additional time for the re-routed left-turn movements. The changes in travel time are shown in Table 11. As shown, it could take an additional two minutes for a vehicle making a northbound left-turn at Squire Pope Road to navigate through the bowtie intersection. However, several left-turning movements, such as the eastbound left-turn at Spanish Wells Rd, are expected to experience a decrease in travel time as compared to the 2045 No-Build scenario, due to the long delay those movements are expected to face absent any changes to the intersection. Table 11. Expected Change in Travel Time for Left-Turning Vehicles at Bowtie Intersections Intersection Difference in Travel Time (seconds) for Left-Turning Vehicles AM PM Squire Pope Road EB Left-Turn +63 [1.1 min] +42 [<1 min] WB Left-turn +82 [1.4 min] +81 [1.4 min] NB Left-Turn +101 [1.7 min] +120 [2 min] SB Left-Turn +44 [<1 min] +4 [<1 min] Spanish Wells Road EB Left-Turn -10 [<1 min] -26 [<1 min] WB Left-turn -13 [<1 min] -7 [<1 min] NB Left-Turn +89 [1.5 min] -42 [<1 min] SB Left-Turn +43 [<1 min] +61 [1 min] 2045 ALTERNATIVE 2 RIGHT -OF -WAY IMPACTS The proposed Bowtie configurations of Alternative 2 will require the 0.2 acre of additional ROW at Gum Tree Road, as well as additional ROW along the crossroads to accommodate the construction of the roundabouts. It should be noted that the ROW estimates refer to permanent ROW needed for the completed improvements only, and do not consider temporary ROW needed for construction or staging. At the Squire Pope Road intersection, the north roundabout would be located along Squire Pope Road at Old Stony Lane, requiring approximately 0.2 acres of additional ROW from privately owned land. The Page 132 of 329 P A G E | 26 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT south roundabout would be located at the end of Chamberlin Road and would require approximately 0.4 acre of additional ROW from Town owned land. At the Spanish Wells Road intersection, the north roundabout would be located along Wild Horse Road at Old Wild Horse Road, requiring approximately 0.2 acre of additional ROW from Town owned land. The south roundabout would be located south of Humane Way and would require approximately 0.1 acre of additional ROW from Town owned land. This alternative could potentially reduce the ROW required for the widening of William Hilton Parkway by 0.5 acre or more due to the elimination of the left turn lanes at the intersections. 2045 ALTERNATIVE 2 ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS As noted above, Alternative 2 would require 1.10 acres of additional ROW. The Town of Hilton Head owns 0.9 acre of the ROW that would need to be acquired. The additional ROW impacts are located within the Stoney and Squire Pope neighborhoods. The SCDOT EA determined that the Stoney neighborhood is an environmental justice community. The Squire Pope neighborhood was outside of the SCDOT EA investigation area, but is also a Gullah Geechee community. The Gullah Geechee people are the only African-American population in the United States that have maintained a separate language and a distinct culture. Therefore, the Squire Pope neighborhood is likely an environmental justice community. The SCDOT recommended alternative was determined to have a “may affect- not likely to adversely affect” finding for threatened and endangered species. Alternative 2 is not anticipated to alter this finding. Coordination with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration-National Marine Fisheries Service (NOAA-NMFS) would need to occur to affirm this finding. Alternative 2 would require additional impacts to the Stoney Traditional Cultural Property (TCP). The SCDOT identified the Stoney community as a TCP and as a resource eligible for inclusion in the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP). As a NRHP-eligible resource, it is also considered a Section 4(f) property. Alternative 2 would not result in additional impacts to hazardous materials sites, NWI wetlands, streams, floodplains, or essential fish habitat types. No additional relocations would occur as a result of Alternative 2. Please refer to the Technical Environmental Overview in Appendix J for additional details. 2045 ALTERNATIVE 3: ECHELON / CENTER TURN OVERPASS 2045 ALTERNATIVE 3 TRAFFIC VOLUMES The traffic volumes used for the 2045 Alternative 3 analysis were largely similar to the 2045 No-Build traffic volumes. The traffic volumes for the intersections impacted by Alternative 3 are provided in Appendix L. It should be noted that Lochmueller agrees with the improvements proposed along William Hilton Parkway between Moss Creek Drive and Crosstree Drive in Alternative 1, as detailed below: Page 133 of 329 P A G E | 27 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT • Widen William Hilton Parkway from four lanes to six lanes from Salt Marsh Drive through Spanish Wells Drive • Reconfigure the intersection of William Hilton Parkway and Wildlife Refuge Driveway to eliminate left-turns and provide right-in/right-out access only • Consolidate Jenkins Island access to one signalized location at Crosstree Drive Therefore, those improvements were included in Alternative 3. As such, the traffic volumes at those intersections would be the same between Alternative 3 and Alternative 1. 2045 ALTERNATIVE 3 TRAFFIC OPERATIONAL ANALYSIS As agreed upon with the Town of Hilton Head, the preliminary traffic analysis was completed using Synchro 11. The 2045 Alternative 3 operating conditions were evaluated using the same methodology applied to the 2023 Existing and 2045 No-Build conditions. The operating conditions for the 2045 Alternative 3 scenario are shown in Appendix L. Overall the study intersections are expected to operate acceptably under Alternative 3. Each signalized intersection is expected to operate with a LOS D or better overall for either configuration. Similar to the previous scenarios, side-street and unsignalized approaches may still experience long delays. The long queues and delays that are expected under the 2045 No-Build Scenario would be expected to be improved overall. It should be noted that while operating conditions overall would be expected to improve when compared to the 2045 No-Build conditions, some movements would be expected to experience failing levels of service. When considering an echelon at Squire Pope Road, the southbound approach at Squire Pope Road is expected to fail. This is caused by a reduction in green time for the heavy southbound right-turns. Additionally, when considering a center turn overpass at Squire Pope Road, the northbound approach at Spanish Wells Road is expected to experience failing operating conditions. This is due to the limited amount of green time allowed for this movement under this scenario. However, overall each option in Alternative 3 is an improvement when compared to the 2045 No-Build scenario. In addition to the Synchro operating conditions, preliminary travel time calculations were performed in Synchro along the William Hilton Parkway corridor between Moss Creek Drive and Indigo Run Drive. Synchro was used for the purposes of evaluating alternatives at a high level, as its results provide a reasonable comparison useful for preferred alternative selection. Final travel time results for the chosen preferred alternative were conducted in VISSIM. Table 12 shows the changes in travel time for the 2045 Alternative 3 scenario when compared to the 2045 No-Build scenario travel time results gathered from Synchro. As shown, between the four options provided in Alternative 3, the travel time calculations indicate that the travel time along eastbound William Hilton Parkway would improve between approximately 18-32% during the AM peak period and westbound William Hilton Parkway would improve between approximately 41-60% during the PM peak period. Page 134 of 329 P A G E | 28 Independent Study of William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor TRAFFIC OPERATIONS AND SAFETY REPORT Table 12. Travel Time Comparison for Alternative 3 Scenario Difference in Travel Time (seconds) when Compared to 2045 No-Build % Difference AM PM AM PM 2045 Alternative 3: Echelon at Squire Pope EB -191 [-3.2 min] -68 [-1.1 min] -32.1% -12.1% WB -79 -[1.3 min] -407 [-6.8 min] -13.9% -60.0% 2045 Alternative 3: Echelon at Spanish Wells EB -140 [-2.3 min] -11 [<1 min] -21.6% -1.8% WB -15 [<1 min] -331 [-5.5 min] -2.3% -44.0% 2045 Alternative 3: Center Turn Overpass at Squire Pope EB -122 [-2 min] +23 [<1 min] -18.4% 3.5% WB -21 [<1 min] -319 [-5.3 min] -3.3% -41.6% 2045 Alternative 3: Center Turn Overpass at Spanish Wells EB -134 [-2.2 min] -17 [<1 min] -20.6% -2.9% WB -16 [<1 min] -339 [-5.7 min] -2.5% -45.4% 2045 ALTERNATIVE 3 RIGHT -OF -WAY IMPACTS The proposed Echelon or Center Turn Overpass configurations of Alternative 3 would still require the 0.2 acres of additional ROW at Gum Tree Road, as well as additional ROW along William Hilton Parkway for turn lanes and additional ROW along the crossroads to accommodate the construction of the turn arounds and/or roundabouts to maintain full access to parcels near the intersections. It should be noted that the ROW estimates refer to permanent ROW needed for the completed improvements only, and do not consider temporary ROW needed for construction or staging. At the Squire Pope Road intersection, the north roundabout would be located along Squire Pope Road at Old Stony Lane, requiring approximately 0.2 acres of additional ROW from privately owned land. The south roundabout would be located at the end of Chamberlin Road and would require approximately 0.4 acres of additional ROW from Town owned land. Widening of Chamberlin Road would require approximately 0.05 acres of additional ROW from private land and 0.05 acres of ROW from Town owned land. Widening along the north side of William Hilton Parkway will require approximately 0.1 acres of additional ROW from Town owned land. At the Spanish Wells Road intersection, the north roundabout would be located along Wild Horse Road at Old Wild Horse

Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.

Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.