Design Review Board Meeting — Minutes
Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · Design Review Board · meeting of Sep 10, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Town of Hilton Head Island Design Review Board
Meeting Minutes
9/10/2024 Page | 1
Town of Hilton Head Island
DESIGN REVIEW BOARD MEETING
Tuesday, September 10, 2024, 2:30 PM
Minutes
1. Call to Order
Chair Judd Carstens called the meeting to order at 2:35 p.m.
2. Adoption of the Agenda
Ms. Fitzpatrick made a Motion to approve the agenda with the modification of moving agenda
item DRB-001202-2024 1014 William Hilton Parkway - Alteration - Mural to the last item on the
agenda. Mr. Theodore seconded. The Motion was approved unanimously.
3. Approval of the Minutes
a. Regular Meeting Minutes of August 27, 2024
Mr. Theodore made a Motion to approve the meeting minutes of August 27th. Ms. Lippert
seconded. The Motion passed unanimously.
4. Unfinished Business
None.
5. New Business
a. DRB-001202-2024 - 1014 William Hilton Parkway - Alteration - Mural
Mr. Carstens passed the gavel to Ms. Lippert, recused himself, and left the dias. As a
result, the Board lacked a quorum, and no vote was taken. The vote will be postponed
until the next meeting on September 24th.
Melissa Paul-Leto, Principal Planner, presented the proposed mural for the Local Legend
Brewery and car storage facility at 1014 William Hilton Parkway. The applicant, Alan Wolf
from SERG Group, submitted two mural options for the Board’s review. Staff
recommended the submission of a material and color board, with colors chosen to blend
naturally with the architecture and landscaping. They also requested lighting
specifications for any exterior lighting used to enhance the mural, along with any
additional information required by the Board. Brian Larson, director of PDG Architects,
discussed the mural and responded to questions.
Mr. Theodore expressed concern that the mural might be considered a sign rather than
artwork. He preferred muted colors and suggested distressing the design to create a
weathered appearance. Ms. Fitzpatrick agreed with Mr. Theodore’s color preferences and
Town of Hilton Head Island Design Review Board
Meeting Minutes
9/10/2024 Page | 2
shared the concern about the mural being classified as a sign. She requested a scaled
design that includes the food court oak trees to better visualize the mural in its setting and
asked for clarification on the amount of square footage being used for other signage on
the property.
Mr. Larson inquired whether the Design Guide contained specific guidelines for murals.
Ms. Lippert sought clarification on whether the artwork was a sign or a mural, noting the
inclusion of text and the company name. She referred to the Design Guide and LMO,
suggesting that removing the text could make the mural less like a sign. The Board
requested further clarification on whether the artwork should be considered a sign or a
commercial advertisement and recommended that the issue be referred back to Staff for
review.
b. DRB-001203-2024 - 100 South Forest Beach Drive Unit:Church - Addition -
Conceptual
Mr. Carstens returned to the dais, and Ms. Lippert passed the gavel back to him. Ms.
Paul-Leto presented the proposed additions to the First Baptist Church sanctuary, which
include a restroom with ADA-compliant handicap facilities. Staff recommended approval
with conditions, including the submission of a physical material and color board on an
11x17" board, the addition of dimensions on plans, elevations, and sections, and the
provision of lighting specifications for any exterior use, along with a full lighting plan if
applicable. A landscape plan for any proposed exterior work, a boundary survey, and any
additional information required by the Board were also requested.
Ms. Paul-Leto addressed questions and recorded Board recommendations on behalf of
the applicant, Architect Neil Gorden, who was not present. Ms. Fitzpatrick and Ms. Lippert
expressed support for the staff's recommendations. Mr. Theodore raised concerns about
the impact on site access, specifically regarding sidewalks and ramps. Mr. Carstens
discussed potential landscape improvements.
Ms. Lippert made a motion for conceptual approval with the condition that staff
recommendations be integrated. She also noted that any tinting of glazing should match
existing materials, that any damaged landscaping should be replaced in kind, and that
building access should be reviewed as needed. Ms. Fitzpatrick seconded the motion.
Motion passed unanimously.
c. DRB-001207-2024 - 1 Brams Point - Spanish Wells Entry - Final
Mr. Theodore recused himself and left the dais. As a result, the Board lacked a quorum,
and no vote was taken. The vote will be postponed until the next meeting on September
24th.
Ms. Paul-Leto presented the final plan for the Spanish Wells Entry for review. The
applicant, David McAllister from Wood + Partners, addressed plan revisions and
answered questions. Ms. Lippert proposed a condition clarifying that security cameras are
not included in the project's current scope. Should cameras be added later, they will be
Town of Hilton Head Island Design Review Board
Meeting Minutes
9/10/2024 Page | 3
mounted within the landscaping. Ms. Fitzpatrick praised the use of native plants and the
landscaping improvements. Mr. Carstens raised concerns about the safety of the existing
turnaround sections once the entrance road is widened.
6. Public Comment - Non Agenda Items
None.
7. Board Business
None.
8. Staff Reports
None.
9. Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 3:32 p.m.
APPROVED: September 24th, 2024.
The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website
at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.