Town Council Meeting — Agenda Packet
Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · Town Council · meeting of Jul 23, 2024 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Town of Hilton Head Island
Town Council Meeting
Tuesday, July 23, 2024, 3:00 PM
1 Town Center Court, Hilton Head Island, SC
Benjamin M. Racusin Council Chambers
The meeting can be viewed on the Town’s YouTube Channel, the Beaufort County
Channel, and Spectrum Channel 1304.
1. Call to Order
2. Pledge to the Flag
3. Invocation – Reverend Diane Knauf, First Presbyterian Church
4. Adoption of the Agenda
5. Approval of the Minutes
a. Special Workshop Minutes of June 17, 2024
b. Regular Meeting Minutes of June 18, 2024
c. Special Workshop Minutes of June 20, 2024
d. Special Meeting Minutes of June 28, 2024
6. Presentations and Recognitions
a. Report of the Town Manager
b. Sand Shark Welcome Week Proclamation - Mayor Perry
c. Parks and Recreation Month Proclamation - Mayor Perry
d. Office of Cultural Affairs Update - Natalie Harvey, Director of Cultural Affairs
7. Reports from Members of Town Council
a. General Reports from Town Council
b. Report of the Lowcountry Area Transportation Study – Glenn Stanford
Page 1 of 92
c. Report of the Lowcountry Council of Governments – Tammy Becker
d. Report of the Beaufort County Airports Board – David Ames
e. Report of the Southern Lowcountry Regional Board – Glenn Stanford
f. Report of the Island Recreation Association Board – Alex Brown
g. Report of the Community Services and Public Safety Committee – Tammy
Becker
h. Report of the Public Planning Committee – David Ames
i. Report of the Finance and Administrative Committee – Alex Brown
8. Unfinished Business
a. Consideration of an Ordinance of the Town of Hilton Head Island Authorizing
the Execution and Delivery of a Quit Claim Deeds for a Portion of Property
Owned by the Town of Hilton Head Island and Beaufort County Identified as 54
Muddy Creek Road and the Purchase of a Stormwater Easement for the
Same- Second and Final Reading - Josh Gruber, Deputy Town Manager
9. New Business
a. Consideration of a Resolution Authorizing the Acceptance of a Donated Right-
of-Way and Corresponding Pathway Easement for Property Located at 272
Mitchelville Road - Josh Gruber, Deputy Town Manager
b. Consideration of a Resolution Relating to the Declaration of Intent by the Town
of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, to Reimburse Certain Expenditures Prior
to the Execution and Delivery of a Tax-Exempt Equipment Lease for Purchase
of Fire Rescue Vehicles in an Amount not to Exceed Twelve Million Dollars -
John McGowan, Assistant Finance Director
10. Public Comment - Non Agenda Items
11. Executive Session
a. Discussion of Negotiations Incident to Proposed Contractual Arrangements
and Discussions for the Proposed Sale or Purchase of Property (Pursuant to
the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act Section 30-4-70 [a]) related to:
1. Pope Avenue Area
2. Hilton Head Public Service District Easement Request at the Old
Welcome Center Tract
3. Hilton Head Public Service District Easement Request at the Ashmore Tract
4. Former Modern Classic Motors Site
5. Former Driftwood Stables Site
Page 2 of 92
6. Status Update on Beaufort County Greenspace Applications
a. Mitchelville Road
b. Jonesville Road
c. Marshland Road
d. William Hilton Parkway
b. Discussion Regarding the Development of Security Personnel or Devices
(Pursuant to South Carolina Freedom of Information Act 30-4-70(a)(3)
1. Receipt of Legal Advice from the Town Attorney on the Use of Automatic
License Plate Readers
c. Discussion of the Employment, Appointment, Compensation, Promotion,
Demotion, Discipline, or Release of a Person Regulated by a Public Body
(Pursuant to South Carolina Freedom of Information Act 30-4-70(a)(1)) related
to:
1. Discussion of the Annual Performance Review of the Town Attorney and
Contractual Matters Related Thereto.
12. Action from Executive Session
13. Adjournment
FOIA Compliance: Public notification of this meeting has been published, posted, and
distributed in compliance with the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act and the
requirements of the Town of Hilton Head Island.
In accordance with the requirements of Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of
1990 ("ADA"), the Town of Hilton Head Island will not discriminate against qualified
individuals with disabilities on the basis of disability in its services, programs, or
activities. Auditory accommodations are available. Any person requiring further
accommodation should contact the Town of Hilton Head Island ADA Coordinator as
soon as possible but no later than 48 hours before the scheduled event.
Municipal Association of South Carolina (MASC) Civility Pledge:
“I pledge to build a stronger and more prosperous community by advocating for civil
engagement, respecting others and their viewpoints, and finding solutions for the
betterment of my city or town.”
Page 3 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Special Workshop Minutes
6/17/2024 Page 1 of 4
Town of Hilton Head Island
TOWN COUNCIL SPECIAL WORKSHOP
Monday, June 17, 2024, 5:00 PM
Minutes
Call to Order
Mayor Perry called the workshop to order at 5:00 p.m.
Council Members present: Alan Perry, Mayor, David Ames, Ward 3, Mayor Pro-Tempore;
Alex Brown, Ward 1; Patsy Brison, Ward 2; Tammy Becker, Ward 4; Steve Alfred, Ward
5; Glenn Stanford, Ward 6
Adoption of the Agenda
Mr. Ames moved to approve. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 6-0.
Report of Findings from Gateway Corridor Project Independent Study
Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager, Engineering and Capital Projects provided
background information regarding the proposed project. He introduced the following: Jared
Fralix, Assistant County Administrator; Thomas Boxley, Executive Director, Gullah
Geechee Historic Neighborhoods CDDC; Brian Kinzelman, Senior Principal, MKSK; and
representatives of Lochmueller Group.
Mr. Colin proceeded to his presentation.
This project began in 2017 as a need was identified by the South Carolina Department of
Transportation (SCDOT) to improve the eastbound Mackay Creek Bridge that connects
the mainland to the island (there are two bridges in each direction). The Town and County
requested a more comprehensive approach to address this corridor rather than a series
of projects and improvements over several years.
November, 2018 - Sales Tax Referendum was approved containing the following: » $80
Million would go towards U.S. 278 Corridor Traffic Improvements including repairing and
replacing the existing spans of the bridges to Hilton Head Island and the other improvements
between Moss Creek Drive and Suire Pope Road. » Since that time, Beaufort County as the
project sponsor and SCDOT as the project Manager have involved time and funding to
conduct an evaluation of alternatives and prepared a draft Preferred Recommendation
following the NEPA process. There has been public involvement, with many workshops,
well over 60 public meeting, and opportunities to provide comments.
April, 2021, the Town worked with technical consultants with expertise in engineering,
planning, and design, starting in April 2021 to review the project and draft recommendations
to improve the corridor alignment and design elements.
Page 4 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Special Workshop Minutes
6/17/2024 Page 2 of 4
Town Council approved 26 recommendations on October12, 2021, to be considered within
the project to improve the corridor alignment and design elements.
In order to make certain that all reasonable alternatives have been evaluated before a final
decision is made. Town Council approved a Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) with
Beaufort County on October 4, 2022. The MOA outlined acritical path and steps to take to
reach a point for municipal consent consideration.
Town Council created the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review
Advisory Committee in February, 2023 Appointments made on March 21, 2023.
Town Council approved Request for Proposals and Scope of Work for Independent Study
in June, 2023
August, 2023 to October, 2023 Consultant, The Lochmueller Group, Inc. procured to
conduct Independent Study.
October, 2023 CBB Transportation Engineers and Planners, contracted through Beaufort
County, presented findings from its Independent Review of the Gateway Corridor.
October, 2023 to present Hilton Head Island Procured Independent Study in progress (10
public meetings of the Committee occurred between November 3, 2023, and June 12, 2024)
December, 2023 – June, 2024 the Lochmueller Group presenting findings and
recommendations to the Committee in accordance with the Town Council approved Scope
of Work.
The purpose of this project is to address structural deficiencies, identified by SCDOT in 2015
at the existing eastbound Mackay Creek bridge and reduce congestion within the project
study area. The Mackay Creek bridge was built during the 1950s (opened in 1956) and is
scheduled for replacement as part of SCDOT’s bridge replacement program.
Cracks can be seen on the underpinnings of the mainland end of U.S. 278’s Karl S. Bowers
Bridge over Mackay Creek on Aug. 18, 2015. The span, built in 1956, has been listed among
South Carolina’s 25 most structurally deficient bridges.
Mr. Colin reviewed the full project extent and reference points.
In order to see the full presentation and preferred alternative video for the WHP Gateway
Corridor project please go to the following link:
William Hilton Parkway Corridor June 17, 2024 Town Council Workshop Presentation
(hiltonheadislandsc.gov)
HHI_Final_V5 on Vimeo
Throughout the presentation, Council members held discussion, asked questions and
made comments regarding: clarification of the February 18 report – the Committee
proposed a mitigation plan for Stoney and Town Council did not adopt it at that time;
confirmation that the guiding principal to consider future transportation alternatives has
been completed; inquiry as to notification and involvement process for Jenkins Island and
Windmill Harbour regarding the current design; an opinion the proposed project is not
Page 5 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Special Workshop Minutes
6/17/2024 Page 3 of 4
aesthetically designed; question as to whether all guiding principals have been met;
inquiry and confirmation photos regarding congestion were taken during a.m. workday
peak traffic hours; confirmation the environmental assessment prepared by SCDOT was
reviewed; inquiry as to a second bridge alternative; inquiry as to the County’s position on
a second bridge; clarification a second bridge alternative is not part of his specific project;
comment that decisions are being made prior to determination being assessed;
clarification the new proposed bridge will be very close in proximity to the same distance
as the existing bridge; clarification as to what trees will be impacted; inquiry as to better
access to pickleball courts on Old Schoolhouse property; inquiry as to cost of
improvements put forth from Hilton Head Island Town Council and confirmation of
additional costs for Hilton Head Island as they ae not included in the projected cost;
confirmation SCDOT and the County did not agree to the costs for the additional items
and overruns regarding requests and they will be incurred by local funding; concern over
the process for Municipal Consent; concern over what recourse they have after giving
Municipal Consent; confirmation that until there is a final design a line item cost estimate
cannot be completed; discussion regarding width and medians on the existing bridge and
proposed project; confirmation the medians will be concrete barriers; concern over
minimal impact of time saved in commuting to the Island; suggestion transportation
alternatives need to be discussed; lengthy discussion on the impact on the Stoney
Community; and confirmation discussions have been ongoing with business and private
property owners.
Public Comment
John Stewart addressed Council regarding his concern regarding noise pollution and
spoke in opposition to the plan.
Linda Herrington addressed Council regarding her opposition to the plan by reading her
statement noting they are risking destroying the habitat without proper studies.
Christopher Cliff addressed Council regarding his opinion that there is no need for a
bridge this size with a useless bike lane.
Chris Ruffner addressed Council stating a larger bridge will bring more people and
suggested tax incentives and flexible work hours could possibly alleviate the traffic issues.
Frank Babel addressed Council stating the existing bridge is failing and businesses are
failing because people cannot get here. If we can’t get the bridge fixed, the Town will be
in trouble.
Skip Hogland addressed Council regarding allowing too much tourism and the effect it
has on the Island. He stated the Town needs to stop promoting Hilton Head Island and
the proposed corridor will not solve traffic problems.
Felice Lamarka address Council stating the more we build, the more people will come.
She proposed looking at other solutions.
Gray Smith addressed Council in opposition to the plan noting he supports refurbishing
the existing bridge.
Page 6 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Special Workshop Minutes
6/17/2024 Page 4 of 4
John O’Toole addressed Council stating the need for empathy for people dealing with the
bridge traffic and the need to address an aging infrastructure before a major catastrophe
takes place.
David Johnson addressed Council stating the guiding principals need to be revisited.
Steve Robinson addressed Council stating the bridge is not safe and a new one needs
built. His opinion is the lights are the issue with traffic.
Angie Hutchins addressed Council regarding the need to be creative due to the job
shortage.
Deiderick Advocaat addressed Council stating the advisory committee has yet to make a
final recommendation and encouraged Council not to dissolve the committee.
Lynn Greeley addressed Council regarding the crowdedness of Hilton Head Island and
the traffic lights do not address the issue of traffic back-up.
Peter Kristian addressed Council and encouraged them to address the growth issue on
the Island and implement a moratorium on development.
John Casey addressed Council stating the advisory committee has not yet made a
recommendation to Council and suggestions the Town is being pressured by Beaufort
County.
Memorandum of Understanding with Beaufort County for the William Hilton Parkway
Gateway Corridor Project
Due to the lateness of the hour, this item was not discussed.
Ms. Brison expressed concern regarding the Town Council meeting scheduled for June
20 which included action items regarding William Hilton Parkway. Mayor Perry stated he
would take the concerns under advisement to determine the next steps forward.
Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 10:49 p.m.
Approved:
_________________________
Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk
_______________________
Alan R. Perry, Mayor
The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s
website at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
Page 7 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
6/18/2024
Page 1 of 7
Town of Hilton Head Island
TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
Tuesday, June 18, 2024, 3:00 PM
Minutes
Call to Order
Mayor Perry called the meeting to order at 3:00 p.m.
Council Members present: Alan Perry, Mayor, David Ames, Ward 3, Mayor Pro-Tempore;
Alex Brown, Ward 1; Patsy Brison, Ward 2; Tammy Becker, Ward 4; Steve Alfred, Ward
5; Glenn Stanford, Ward 6
Invocation – Pastor Brett Meyers, First Baptist Church of Hilton Head Island
Pastor Meyers delivered the invocation.
Adoption of the Agenda
Mr. Ames moved to approve. Mr. Stanford seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
Adoption of the Minutes
Regular Meeting Minutes of June 4, 2024
Mr. Ames moved to approve. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
Report of the Town Manager
Mr. Orlando introduced Derrick Coaxum, Facilities Director. He stated Mr. Coaxum
previously worked at the Town and has more than 25 years of experience and welcomed
him back as part of the team.
General Reports from Town Council
Mayor Perry announced that the originally scheduled meeting for Thursday, June 20 at
3:00 p.m. has been changed from a meeting to a workshop where the discussion
regarding the Wiliam Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Project will continue. He stated
the room set-up will be the same as a Town Council meeting to accommodate the
attendees.
Ms. Brison referenced Wednesday, June 19 as Juneteenth and expressed her
appreciation to the Mitchelville Board of Directors for the wonderful celebration held on
Saturday, June 15.
Mr. Ames recognized Sam Gillman stating he will be competing in the trials for the United
States Olympic Team in the 1500 meter race on Friday, June 21 at 8pm. He encouraged
all to root Sam on in his endeavor.
Report of the Lowcountry Area Transportation Study - Glenn Stanford
Mr. Stanford stated there was a meeting on June 7 and reviewed the County-wide
Transportation Impact Analysis ordinance in an effort to move it forward, they approved
support for the South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) East Coast
Greenway Active Transportation infrastructure investment, and discussion regarding
Page 8 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
6/18/2024
Page 2 of 7
Section 5.b of the Bluffton Parkway Project. He added that SCDOT presented a report on
where the improvements to Interstate 95 will occur.
Report of the Lowcountry Council of Governments - Tammy Becker
No report.
Report of the Beaufort County Airports Board - David Ames
No report
Report of the Southern Lowcountry Regional Board - Glenn Stanford
Mr. Stanford stated the Board met on May 28 and received an update from Joel Taylor,
President, Hilton Head Regional Hospital regarding the new ownership and the impacts
emphasizing the large investment the new owners are going to make in the hospital
facilities. Beaufort County Council Chairman conducted a presentation regarding the
proposed tax referendum.
Report of the Island Recreation Association Board - Alex Brown
No report.
Report of the Community Services and Public Safety Committee - Tammy Becker
Ms. Becker stated the Committee has conducted interviews for upcoming vacancies for
boards, commissions and committees and will be making recommendations to the full
Council during Executive Session.
Report of the Public Planning Committee - David Ames
No report.
Report of the Finance and Administrative Committee - Alex Brown
No report.
Appearance by Citizens
John Casey addressed Council expressing his appreciation that Thursday’s meeting
is now a workshop to further the William Hilton Parkway Corridor Project.
John Davidson addressed Council regarding the need to focus on how decisions
impact health care providers and workers. He stated the primary responsibility of
Council is the enhancement of property values. He expressed his opinion the Town
needs to hire an Urban Economic Law Firm.
Skip Hoagland addressed Council stating the need for transparency and a forensic
audit.
Unfinished Business
Consideration of an Ordinance Amending Section 10-5-50 of the Municipal Code of
the Town of Hilton Head Island to Award a Non-Exclusive Commercial Beach
Franchise Agreement - Second and Final Reading - Josh Gruber, Deputy Town
Manager
Mr. Gruber assured Council that everything discussed at the June 4 Town Council
meeting has been incorporated into the document before them for consideration of
approval.
Page 9 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
6/18/2024
Page 3 of 7
Mayor Perry asked for public comment. There was none.
Council members made comments, asked questions and held discussion regarding:
confirmation that the Franchise Fee is 3%.
Mr. Ames moved to approve. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
Consideration of an Ordinance Amending Sections 2-5-15 (Public Meetings and
Public Hearings of Town Council and Boards and Commissions); 2-5-50 (Agenda and
Order of Business); 2-5-70 (Appearance by Citizens During Public Meetings); and 2-
5-80 (Rules of Decorum) of the Municipal code of the Town of Hilton Head Island -
Second and Final Reading - Josh Gruber
Mr. Gruber stated there were no changes to the proposed ordinance since first
reading. He added there have been no public comments or feedback submitted. He
said the item changes code regarding the order of items on agendas, the process by
which people can make public comment and an outline of the expected behavior when
speaking at public meetings
Mayor Perry asked for public comment.
John Davidson addressed Council suggesting asking people who speak during public
comment if they are taxpayers and how they are impacted by the item being
addressed because the primary duty of this Council is to promote the growth of real
property values.
Mr. Ames moved to approve. Mr. Alfred seconded.
Council members made comments, asked questions and held discussion regarding:
inquiry as to how the public is going to be educated and informed regarding the rules;
inquiry as to how Boards, Committees and Commissions will be trained; confirmation
this will define the expectations regarding conduct and procedures when there are
public comments; confirmation ongoing training will take place annually for all Boards,
Committees and Commissions and a confirmation public comment will still take place
regarding agenda items and non-agenda items.
Ms. Becker voiced her opposition to the ordinance stating her belief that it is a violation
of the First Amendment, she further inquired as to what resources were used to
determine behavior and decorum requirements.
Motion carried 6-1 (Becker opposed).
Skip Hoagland addressed Council regarding the question of legality when it comes to
awarding Power of Attorney to a second party to speak on your behalf.
Chester Williams stated Council has the right to regulate the time, place and manner
of speech but not what an individual can say.
Christopher Cliff inquired as to why this is being done.
Mr. Gruber continued by highlighting the revisions that were being addressed which
are an attempt to clean up matters within Code in order to go through the order of
business of Council and take public comment at the appropriate times.
New Business
Consideration of an Ordinance of the Town of Hilton Head Island Authorizing the
Execution and Delivery of Quit Claim Deeds for a Portion of Property Owned by the Town
Page 10 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
6/18/2024
Page 4 of 7
of Hilton Head Island Identified as 54 Muddy Creek Road and the Purchase of a
Stormwater Easement for the Same - First Reading - Josh Gruber, Deputy Town Manager
Mr. Gruber conducted a presentation regarding the item. He went through a chronological
order of how and why this item is pending before Council.
Several years ago, the Town was contacted by members of the Williams/Jones family
who were concerned that a portion of their family property located at 54 Muddy Creek
Road had been inappropriately acquired by the Town. Staff and the Town Attorney
conducted a search of the Town’s property records associated with this acquisition and
determined that the Town purchased its property in 2003 for a purchase price of $22,000.
The Town's title derives from a deed from Mr. Hubert Bernheim, that was recorded at the
time of the Town’s acquisition in 2003. Mr. Bernheim's title derives from a Treasurer's tax
deed he received in 1996. The property that Mr. Bernheim bought at the tax sale was
titled in the name of a "William Campbell." Neither the Town nor Mr. Bernheim cleared
the title to the property and therefore, the Town's title is uncertain, and a title clearance
action would have to be pursued to establish its ownership of the property. Sometime
after 2003, a sewer lift station was installed on the southernmost portion of the Town’s
property. That use continues to the present day and is currently fenced in on the property.
While the Town was researching the title issues associated with this property, staff within
the Stormwater Division determined that it was necessary to acquire an easement on a
portion of this property as well as a portion of the main Williams Family property. A survey
identifying this easement along with a corresponding property appraisal establishing the
purchase value of the easement was obtained. Information pertaining to both items is
enclosed as Attachments 1 and 2 respectively.
Based upon extensive discussions with the Williams/Jones family, the Town is proposing
to exchange Quit Claim Deeds with the family to release any interest that it may have in
the 54 Muddy Creek Road parcel while at the same time solidifying its interest in the
sewer lift station property which would be retained. Additionally, the Town would purchase
the stormwater easement from the family once these Quit Claim Deeds have been
exchanged and recorded by the parties. The Town’s appraisal indicated a fair market
value of $27,904. Based upon negotiations with the Williams/Jones family, they have
requested compensation of $35,000 to sign over the requested easement. Staff supports
this requested value and believes that it is justifiable under the circumstances of this
transaction.
If the Town Council is supportive of exchanging the quit claims deeds identified above as
well as supporting the acquisition of a stormwater easement for the requested $35,000,
an Ordinance authorizing the transfer of the property and a Resolution authorizing the
purchase of the property will be prepared by the Town Attorney for consideration by Town
Council.
Mayor Perry asked for public comment.
John Davidson addressed Council inquiring a to the merit of the transaction
Skip Hoagland addressed Council stating all transactions should benefit the Town.
Mr. Ames moved to approve. Mr. Stanford seconded.
Council members made comments, asked questions and held discussion regarding:
confirmation the public benefit to this transaction is that the Town is able to maintain the
Page 11 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
6/18/2024
Page 5 of 7
sewer lift station and also gain an easement for stormwater purposes; inquiry as to how
the $35,000 purchase price was determined; and confirmation fair market value was
considered.
Motion carried 7-0.
Consideration of a Resolution to Accept the Hilton Head Island Conditions and Trends
Assessment - Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager
Shawn Colin provided a presentation and the following information:
The Town of Hilton Head Conditions and Trends Assessment has been presented to the
Public Planning Committee on 3 occasions. The most recent presentation on May 9,
2024 was to address all outstanding questions and feedback on the report. At that
meeting, the Town of Hilton Head Public Planning Committee voted 4 to 0 to recommend
that Town Council consider a resolution to accept the Town of Hilton Head Conditions
and Trends Assessment.
This assessment is the result of the Island’s pursuit of excellence in serving the
community through decision-making based on these facts and trends. Town Council
named the establishment of a Growth Management Strategy as one of the top 15 priorities
for the town. This project was a key primary step to help shape that strategy. As a living
document, the Conditions and Trends Assessment will be updated regularly to
continuously monitor community datapoints, benchmarks and indicators for the Town of
Hilton Head Island.
The report and dataset are designed to enhance the community’s shared understanding
of current and emergent issues. This assessment will be used by the Town in several
ways including:
•Provide a common starting point
oAdd context to community conversations with respect local and regional
trends
oConnect key information; share source data and resources
oRemove the mystery on community needs, gaps, or opportunities
•Inform future plans and studies
oProvide base set of findings to help initially focus and direct work
oAccelerate the data assembly process with ready-made resources, tables,
maps, and other resources
oUncover pressing or emergent issues, opportunities, and/or needs
oSynchronize data across multiple planning efforts, departments, and
community partners
•Measure progress
oTake a moment-in-time “snapshot” of the Island across multiple trends
oMeasure progress or movement against this benchmark
oEvaluate policy effectiveness
oQuantify short and long-term impacts of major projects
The Town of Hilton Head Conditions and Trends Assessment pulls together benchmark
community information and statistics in 10 key topic areas including:
Page 12 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
6/18/2024
Page 6 of 7
•Demographics
•Workforce
•Economics
•Real Estate
•Natural and Cultural Environment
•Housing
•Governance
•Community Engagement
•Systems
•Land Use
Mayor Perry asked for public comment.
Skip Hoagland addressed Council stating the Bridge Corridor project should be stopped.
Christopher Cliff addressed Council and complimented the Community Development
Team on producing a fabulous document with important information.
John Davidson addressed Council stating the greater amount of data, the better decisions
can be made by the Town.
Mr. Ames moved to approve. Mr. Alfred seconded.
Ms. Becker voiced her concerns regarding the foundation for future land use and with
those concerns voiced her opposition to the resolution.
Motion carried 6-1 (Becker opposed).
Executive Session
Discussion of Appointment to Boards, Commissions, and Committees [Pursuant to the
South Carolina Freedom of Information Act Section 30-4-70(a)(1)] related to:
1. Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee
2. Board of Zoning Appeals
3. Construction Board of Adjustments and Appeals
4. Design Review Board
5. Gullah Geechee Historic Neighborhood Community Development
Corporation
6. Gullah Geechee Task Force
7. Housing Action Committee
8. Parks and Recreation Commission
9. Planning Commission
Discussion and Negotiations Incident to Proposed Contractual Arrangements for the
Northpoint Public-Private Partnership Workforce Housing Project [Pursuant to the South
Carolina Freedom of Information Act Section 30-4-70 (a)(2)]
Mayor Perry asked the Town Manager if there was a need to enter Executive Session. Mr.
Orlando stated there was a need regarding the items listed above.
At 4:04 p.m. Mr. Ames moved to enter into Executive Session for the reasons cited
by the Town Manager. Ms. Brison seconded. Motion carried 7-0
At 4:59 p.m. Ms. Brison moved to come out of Executive Session. Mr. Stanford
Page 13 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
6/18/2024
Page 7 of 7
seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
Action from Executive Session
Mayor Perry asked if there was any business as a result of Executive Session.
Mr. Ames moved to appoint Ray Kisiah, Ruthie Kucharewski and reappoint
Christina Kristian to the Parks and Recreation Commission with terms ending
06/30/2027. Ms. Becker seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
Mr. Ames moved to appoint Ed Cordes and reappoint Tom Henz, Ellen Whaley and
Bruce Siebold to the Planning Commission with terms ending 06/20/2027. Ms.
Becker seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
Mr. Ames moved to appoint Megan Fitzpatrick, Kevin Bradenburg, Patricia Pastor
and reappoint Tom Parker to the Design Review Board with terms ending
06/30/2027. Ms. Becker seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
Mr. Ames moved to reappoint Pastor Louis Johnson to the Gullah Geechee Historic
Neighborhoods Community Development Corporation with a term ending
06/30/2027. Ms. Becker seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
Mr. Ames moved to appoint Thomas Dowling, Adriaan Radder and reappoint John
Farrell to the Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee with terms ending
06/30/2027. Ms. Becker seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
Mr. Ames moved to appoint Carolyn McVitty and reappoint David Finderhut and
Michael Sackhaim to the Board of Zoning Appeals with terms ending
06/30/2027. Ms. Becker seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
Mr. Ames moved to approve a Resolution approving a Development Agreement for
Workforce Housing between the Town of Hilton Head Island and OneStreet
Residential. Ms. Brison seconded. Motion carried 6-1 (Becker opposed).
Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 5:10 p.m.
Approved:
Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk
Alan R. Perry, Mayor
The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website
at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
Page 14 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Special Workshop Minutes
6/20/2024 Page 1 of 14
Town of Hilton Head Island
TOWN COUNCIL SPECIAL WORKSHOP
Monday, June 20, 2024, 3:00 PM
Minutes
Call to Order
Mayor Perry called the workshop to order at 3:00 p.m.
Council Members present: Alan Perry, Mayor, David Ames, Ward 3, Mayor Pro-Tempore;
Alex Brown, Ward 1; Patsy Brison, Ward 2; Tammy Becker, Ward 4; Steve Alfred, Ward
5; Glenn Stanford, Ward 6
Discussion of the William Hilton Parkway Corridor Project.
Ms. Becker moved to have a 15-minute public comment period before discussion
begins. Mr. Ames seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
Richard Bizzy addressed Council regarding his opinion that Council did not ask enough
questions on Monday and questioned the assumption the additional lanes will reduce
traffic congestion.
Ashley Phillips addressed Council questioning the aesthetics of the proposed bridge,
concern over the character of the Island, voiced her objections to Municipal Consent;
expressed concern for the Gullah Community, and her opinion the new bridge will not
bring more employees to the Island.
Skip Hoagland addressed Council stating people moved here for Island life – not Myrtle
Beach.
Doris Grant addressed Council stating the meeting times are inconvenient for the working
people of the Island. She expressed concern and questioned closing the turning land to
Squire Pope Road.
Steven Woodall addressed Council stating Council needs to remain in the conversation
but don’t need to approve Municipal Consent. He asked that Council vote no on the
matter.
Mayor Perry asked that Shawn Colin address the question of closing the turn lane at
Squire Pope Road. Mr. Colin stated there is no discussion of closures but there has been
discussion of limiting peak hour left turns within the Stoney Community.
Mayor Perry made a statement regarding the items at hand. He stated that Council
cannot operate by inaction. He stated that over the past seven years there has been
great community engagement for this project from the SCDOT, Beaufort County and the
Town of Hilton Head Island. He noted it is a difficult decision for Town Council, but it is
no reason for hatred. There is an issue of the philosophical question regarding the project
Page 15 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Special Workshop Minutes
6/20/2024 Page 2 of 14
and a lot of different answers. He reminded all there is a deadline and stated that after
Monday’s meeting, they reached out to Secretary Justin Powell to see if an extension
could be granted. He proceeded to read a letter he received in return which is below:
Page 16 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Special Workshop Minutes
6/20/2024 Page 3 of 14
Mayor Perry invited Senator Tom Davis to address Council and provide input from the
State’s perspective.
Senator Davis explained that the first thing that comes to mind is what does a timely manner
mean? He offered his thoughts regarding what he thinks it means. He stated we’ve been
operating under an environmental assessment period for three years, which terminates on
June 28, and once that deadline passes it is his understanding that it’s possible to obtain
an extension of the environmental assessment but that would be up to the Corps of
Engineers as to whether to extend it or go back to one of the more beginning processes.
He summarized that he doesn’t know what would happen if Municipal Consent is not given
by June 28. Senator Davis expressed his opinion that Secretary Powell says in a timely
manner, he means a decision one way or the other, yes or no affirmatively by that date.
He added that from speaking with Secretary Powell that if Municipal Consent is not given
that he feels like he has no choice but to go forward and allocate the $74 million that SCDOT
has set aside for that first span and begin the process of deciding whether you’re going to
rehabilitate it or replace it. He stated that one of the practical consequences of Municipal
Consent either not being given by delaying the vote or a no affirmatively would be SCDOT
going forward on that Plan B going forward on repairing that first span.
He added his thoughts that if the project doesn’t go forward, or the project as presented
doesn’t go forward one question that arises is what happens to the $80 million that was
raised in the penny sales tax in 2018 for the purpose of this project. He reviewed three
different scenarios that could take place: 1) the $80 million raised is what’s used first to
conduct the repairs in lieu of the $74 million; 2) if Municipal Consent is not granted it would
be difficult to hold on to the $120 million that as awarded to Beaufort County for the project
and 3) the money would be reallocated during the next round of projects.
Senator Davis stated he has been focusing on two things throughout the process. 1) Trying
to hold in place the funding and cobble together enough money to make the project work;
and 2) give the Town enough time so that it becomes a decision they feel comfortable with,
which has been a good process.
Senator Davis stated that irrespective of the decision, whether to give Municipal Consent
or not give Municipal Consent, he will stand behind the Town of Hilton Head Island and try
to help accomplish what the Town wants to accomplish by working with the SCDOT,
Federal Government and the General Assembly.
Council members made comments, asked questions and held discussion with Senator
Davis regarding: an expression of appreciation from all Council members regarding
Senator Davis’ hard work that he’s done on this project; explanation and pointed out that
the penny sales tax was to repair or replace the bridge and the interpretation that nothing
was mentioned regarding expansion; confirmation the funding would not go away
automatically but the Delegation would have to put on a full court press to keep that $120
million set aside for the project and it would be difficult to keep that $120 million set aside
for Hilton Head Island if they move into July without a deciding vote; confirmation from
the Senator that if Hilton Head Island would decide they need more time, he would make
Page 17 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Special Workshop Minutes
6/20/2024 Page 4 of 14
the best case he could in representing Hilton Head Island and it would be very difficult;
confirmation there is approximately $300 million dollars dedicated to the project and a
gap of $180 million dollars; an explanation of sources to cover the gap in funding which
could possibly be: go back to the State Infrastructure Bank and ask for more; approach
SCDOT for additional funding and a scenario of Beaufort County obtaining bonding;
confirmation that if conditions are required they need to be included in Municipal Consent
as well as the MOU; and an expression of concerns over the Stoney area and plans to
make it better;
Mayor Perry invited Mr. Orlando to provide comments and insight as to how we got to this
point.
Mr. Orlando expressed appreciation to Senator Davis for his assistance during this process.
He reviewed how we got to this point noting the Eastbound Mackey Creek Bridge showed
structural damage and it was noted in an SCDOT inspection in 2015, and then Hurricane
Mathew hit in 2016. Following that Beaufort County initiated at Bridge and Corridor
Improvement Project through a voter referendum sales tax referendum in 2018. Following
the referendum, Hilton Head Island Town Council created a US 278 Corridor Committee in
2019 and a year later subsequently adopted Guiding Principles from the Committee to
establish project expectations in 2020. Council adopted the Committee Report but did not
endorse an associated proposed mitigation plan at that time. He added that since then,
there have been several years of discussions and project assessments with Council,
Community Members, affected Community members, and affected property owners,
SCDOT and Beaufort County.
He noted the project sponsor is Beaufort County and is being designed by SCDOT and
their selected design consultants. Many project alternatives have been presented to the
Hilton Head Island Community by Beaufort Cunty and SCDOT over time. He noted that
this started well before his time began with the Town of Hilton Head Island as well as before
the time of several seated Council members serving. In 2021, Council directed Mr. Orlando
to establish a way to best represent Hilton Head Island as this project was being
considered. In 2021, Beaufort County presented a project plan with significant impacts in
the Stoney Neighborhood. It was a consensus of Council and Hilton Head Island Staff to
object to the proposal. The goal was to see if the Town could affect the project positively
and bring it back to Council to consider Municipal Consent.
Beaufort County and the Town entered into a mutual agreement in 2022, which included
recommendations of Town Council and a commitment to work together to try and achieve
those initiatives. The project was further refined, further assessed by several traffic
engineers. SCDOT, Beaufort County and the Town of Hilton Head Island. The Town
separately hired traffic and transportation engineers for input and the project was further
enhanced.
Since Council’s directive Mr. Orlando has met with SCDOT Secretary Christie Hall and the
newly appointed Secretary, Justin Powell to explain the challenges and to explain the
project challenges for Hilton Head Island. He made it clear that just because these
elements were included in the project it didn’t mean that he would bring this back for a
Page 18 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Special Workshop Minutes
6/20/2024 Page 5 of 14
predetermined Municipal Consent. He suggested discussing the bridge, the corridor, the
project and the program and all the variables that go into it and review impacts. He stated
he believes staff has done their best to provide Council with as much consultant data and
analysis from SCDOT, Beaufort County and from the Town traffic and transportation
consultants. He closed by stating that Council’s decision whether to support or oppose this
major corridor and bridge to and from Hilton Head Island must consider many factors to
ensure that the collective decision aligns with the Community’s best interest. Mr. Orlando
introduced Shawn Colin to conduct a presentation regarding the matter.
Mr. Colin proceeded to his presentation.
Section 57-5-830 of the South Carolina Code of Laws states that, “[i]n every case of a
proposed permanent improvement, construction, reconstruction, or alteration by the
Department of any highway or highway facility within a municipality, the municipality may
review and approve the plans before the work is started; except that a municipality may
not have the right to review and approve plans to remove, replace, or improve a bridge
and its approaches within its limits where such bridge and its approaches have been
certified by the Department to be functionally obsolete or structurally deficient and if the
bridge crosses the intracoastal waterway.”
New Full Bridge Construction
•While the Town has requested consideration for a 4-lane bridge, according to
SCDOT, if a new bridge is built, it will be built as 3 lanes each way, plus inside and
outside shoulders.
•12-foot travel lanes.
•1 10-foot outside shoulder and 1 6 foot inside shoulder in each direction.
•1 span that replaces all 4 current bridges
•Provides uniform 75+ year lifespan for bridge
•Design Speed of 45mph
•Posted speed of 40 mph
•Current bridge widths - 80’ and 100’ as explained Monday.
•New Bridge is 121’ wide which includes 14’ to accommodate the pathway.
•New bridge would be 107’ wide without the pathway
•Town Council recommendations and MOU requested the additional pathway.
•1 12-foot shared-use pathway along the southern side of the bridge
•2 bulb-out refuges, 20 feet wide by 50 feet long, located along the southern shared-
use path at Mackay Creek and Skull Creek
•Shared-use pathway to connect to mainland pathway system at Buckingham
Planation Road and to pathway system on Jenkins Island
•Construction methods will cause this bridge to shift south within current power line
easement.
•Bridge height clearance to remain at 65 feet over Skull Creek
•Bridge height clearance over Pinckney Island minimum of 17.19 feet
•Bridge length is 1.376 miles of the 4.218-mile project
•Seismic and storm impact mitigation elements included in the overall structural
Page 19 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Special Workshop Minutes
6/20/2024 Page 6 of 14
design.
•Will meet highest seismic standards
•Designed to withstand Category 5 hurricane
•No at grade intersection on Pinckney Island
Jenkins Island Section
•Design Speed of 45mph
•Posted speed of 40 mph
•Bridge landing located within existing right-of-way
•3 12-foot travel lanes eastbound
•3 12-foot travel lanes westbound
•All Jenkins Island Traffic consolidated at Windmill Harbour intersection
•Jenkins Road access to William Hilton Parkway is removed
•Access to Hog Island, Mariners Cove, Blue Heron Point, Jenkins Island Cemetery,
Hilton Head Harbor RV Resort and Hilton Head Harbor Marina will be from new
frontage road on Jenkins Island
•No pedestrian crossings at Windmill Harbour intersection
•Windmill Harbour traffic signal upgraded with Adaptive Traffic Management System
and included in Town system with 30 days of MOU
•Shared pathway on northern side of corridor located within Town-owned Property
along new frontage road connecting to bridge to mainland and Town of Hilton Head
Island pathway system
•Shared-use pathway on southern side from Windmill Harbour to connect to bridge,
as well as connection via to under-bridge connection to the northern side shared-
use pathway
•Access to Hog Island, Blue Heron Point, and Mariners Cove moved from southern
side to northern side of corridor with maintain under bridge connection
•Landscaped medians with varying widths
•Exterior curbing installed to reduce right-of-way and handle drainage in Stoney
Neighborhood Section
•Design Speed of 45mph
•Posted speed of 40 mph
•Within the current ROW for most of the corridor through Stoney neighborhood
•2 x 11’ lanes
•1 x 12’ lane
•Additional turn lanes
•Crosswalks at intersections
•10’ wide pathway
•Public open space
•Stormwater mitigation
•Landscaping
•Potential Relocation or Removal of 2 culturally sensitive structures
Page 20 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Special Workshop Minutes
6/20/2024 Page 7 of 14
•Willie Young’s Upholstery (Patterson’s Store)
•Former Island Psychic
•Removal of curb cut at Memory Matters and William Hilton Parkway
•Total ROW impacts 2.78 acres
•Total ROW impacts on private property 0.89 acres (22 properties)
Overview of SCDOT US 278 Corridor Improvements Environmental Assessment
The National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) requires federal agencies to consider the
impacts their projects may have on the environment and to integrate the NEPA process
with other environmental law compliance. In association with the Federal Highway
Administration (FHWA) and Beaufort County, the SCDOT has developed an
Environmental Assessment (EA) in accordance with NEPA. The EA includes a review of
all proposed alternatives and evaluates potential impacts to the natural and human
environment. This EA is the culmination of technical studies and reports, interagency
coordination, and community outreach and feedback. The EA documents the purpose
and need for the project; presents a discussion of the alternatives and the analysis of
them; describes the affected environment, assessment of the environmental,
transportation, social, and economic impacts; identifies potential community
enhancements; and presents a Recommended Preferred Alternative. It also incorporates
analysis and feedback from public and agency sources gathered during the various
phases of the EA development.
US 278 Corridor Improvements Environmental Assessment Expires June 28, 2024
Town Council Approved Guiding Principles - February 18, 2020
•Fix the transportation issues in the corridor in a way that improves the safety
and quality of life for all residents, workers, and visitors to Hilton Head Island
•Address transportation needs for natural disasters and resiliency of island
access
•Consider future transportation alternatives
•Improve the safety and quality of life for the residents of the neighborhoods and
businesses directly impacted by the US 278 corridor
•Stoney Community
•Neighborhoods on Jenkins and Hog Islands (including but not limited to
Windmill Harbor)
•Have gateway to and from Hilton Head Island that the region will be proud of:
•Aesthetically pleasing and reflecting the Hilton Head Island/Lowcountry
values
•Safe and functional pathways for pedestrians and cyclists
•Minimizes environmental impacts and enhances the national asset of
Pinckney Island
Page 21 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Special Workshop Minutes
6/20/2024 Page 8 of 14
Town Council Approved Recommendations – October 12, 2021
Corridor Wide Recommendations
1. Reduce lane widths to 11’ to calm traffic & reduce property impacts
2. Eliminate raised curbs in medians wherever possible, encourage existing
vegetation and natural drainage in these areas
3. Vary median widths and meander roadway alignments where possible for traffic
calming and aesthetics
4. Take advantage of Town-owned property for sake of Parkway improvements
5. Utilize ITS smart signal technology throughout
6. Reduce curb cuts & provide for alternative/safer property access throughout
7. Provide trails on both sides of Parkway where possible with sufficient separation
from road and in lieu of sidewalks
8. Create a comprehensive system of safe, comfortable, and attractive shared use
paths for cyclists and pedestrians
9. Open/encourage views to the water wherever possible, as a part of the Island’s
“signature”
10. Ensure integration of unique, Hilton Head-specific signage, landscape schemes,
public art program, architectural vocabulary, iconic features, and accent lighting
that distinguish this parkway from all others
11. Reduce design & posted speeds throughout the corridor
12. Evaluate the island-wide transportation system
Specific Recommendations
1. Encourage Moss Creek area improvements (commercial redevelopment,
access/roadway improvements, trail connections)
2. Establish “Gateway Experience” threshold at west end of Mackay Creek bridges
(landscape, island “icon”, art, lighting)
3. Reduce bridge mass with two separate bridges and Shared-Use Path on south
side of eastbound bridge
4. Reduce bridge lane width to 11’, reduce shoulder width on left, only one breakdown
lane on right.
5. Provide 14’ minimum width non-motorized lane on the bridge with multiple viewing
areas and protection/screening of vehicles
6. Attention to bridge design/details as viewed from afar and on-deck (parapet,
railings, structural forms)
7. Consolidate Jenkins Island access to one signalized location at C.
Heinrichs/Windmill Harbour Entrance
8. Provide traditional turn lanes and intuitive intersection configurations throughout
Stoney
9. Eliminate confusing SCDOT U-turns
10. Eliminate left turns and traffic introduction onto Old Wild Horse
Page 22 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Special Workshop Minutes
6/20/2024 Page 9 of 14
11. Create new park south of Parkway in Stoney to authentically showcase Gullah
Geechee culture/heritage
12. Consider a new Visitors Center as a part of this park that intentionally showcases
this heritage while introducing visitors to the Island’s offerings
13. Create a Stoney-authored vision plan for the next generation of that neighborhood
14. Create and professionally staff a Development Corporation as a vehicle for Stoney
Advancement
Town of Hilton Head Island/Beaufort County Approved Memorandum of Agreement –
October 4, 2022
1. The County and the Town agree to advance the Project in a cooperative manner
for the entire duration of the Project.
2. The County and the Town mutually agree to work together in good faith to address
the feasibility, and merits of recommendations approved by Town Council on
October 12, 2021 (as set forth in Exhibit A) (the "Recommendations") and further
agree that one bridge will be designed and constructed for the Project.
3. The County will procure an independent consultant (the “Independent
Consultant”), (i.e. – one that does not have a previous or current contractual
relationship with SCDOT, the County, or the Town) to perform an additional
independent review of the project. This Independent Consultant will conduct an
end-to-end simulation and study through and beyond the Project limits to include
additional intersections materially consistent with the Scope of Work set forth in
Exhibit A.
4. The County and the Town will establish a committee (the “Committee”) to select
the Independent Consultant through a competitive bid process. The following
County representatives shall sit on the Committee: (a) the County Administrator or
his designee (b) the Assistant County Administrator for Infrastructure: (c) and the
County Transportation Program Manager Consultant. The following Town
representatives shall sit on the Committee: (d) the Town Manager or his designee;
(e) the Assistant Town Manager of Community Development; and (f) the Town
Engineer.
5. All recommendations from the independent review for areas within the project
boundary will be considered for inclusion in the project. The County and Town
agree to pursue the “Finding of No Significant Impacts” (FONSI) from the Federal
Highway Administration concurrent with the Independent Review. If any findings
from the Independent Review affect environmental documents submitted for the
FONSI, those recommendations will be considered, and the environmental
documents will be updated and resubmitted as agreed upon by the County and the
Town.
6. The County and the Town, as required as part of the NEPA process, will coordinate
with SCDOT to perform a value engineering of the project to identify and eliminate
unwanted costs, and improve function and quality as well as to optimize initial and
long-term investment, ultimately seeking the best value for the lowest cost.
Page 23 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Special Workshop Minutes
6/20/2024 Page 10 of 14
7. The County and the Town mutually agree to work together, along with SCDOT and
Lowcountry Area Transportation Study, to design, implement and maintain a
connected and synchronized signal system along the entire length of US 278 from
I-95 to Sea Pines Circle. The synchronized system will include fiber connectivity,
Adaptive Signal technologies and other tools to help maximize flow. The County
and the Town mutually agree to work together to seek funds necessary to acquire
and implement the proposed improvements.
8. Any signal improvements from the synchronization project which are not already
installed within the corridor prior to the construction of the Project, will be
incorporated as such.
9. This Agreement does not provide the Town’s municipal consent. Such consent
may be provided by the Town Council after the Independent Review has been
evaluated by the Town and County and before the right-of-way acquisition phase
of the Project begins. Municipal consent by the Town will not be unreasonably
withheld.
10. The County and the Town agree that the Independent Review will be the last and
final study needed for the Town to make a final decision related to the Project.
Town Council – Project Considerations
•Project Scope
•Rehabilitate eastbound Mackay Creek Bridge or build new, single 6-lane
bridge?
•Shared-use pathway on the south side of bridge?
•Meander roadway on Jenkins Island?
•Aesthetics on bridge and through corridor?
•Community Impacts and Improvements?
•Property Impacts and Improvements through Stoney Neighborhood?
•Quality of Life
•Traffic and Transportation
•Traffic Management Level of Service?
•Environmental Impacts?
•Cost, Funding, and Economic Impacts and Benefits?
Next Steps for Council Consideration
1. Town Council consideration of Beaufort County/SCDOT request for Municipal
Consent
2. Path forward should Town Council not grant Municipal Consent to SCDOT
a. Per SCDOT Secretary Powell - the existing Mackay Creek bridge continues to
age in a challenging environment with tides and saltwater. While not load posted
today, future inspections may necessitate SCDOT putting a load posting on the
Page 24 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Special Workshop Minutes
6/20/2024 Page 11 of 14
bridge which could impact the movement of trucks, buses, and emergency
vehicles onto Hilton Head Island.
b. SCDOT and Beaufort County to Address eastbound Mackay Creek Bridge
c. State Infrastructure Bank Funding would be reallocated to other projects.
3. Path forward should Town Council grant Municipal Consent to SCDOT
a. Establish Town of Hilton Head Island/Beaufort County Memorandum of
Agreement that includes the following project conditions:
i. Design Elements
ii. Neighborhood Improvements
iii. Economic Sustainability
b. SCDOT Project Schedule Advances
Council members made comments, asked questions and held discussion regarding:
clarification of Section 57-5-820 and Section 57-5-830 of the South Carolina Code of
Laws; confirmation that SCDOT said the bridge must be six lanes and their authority to
do so; confirmation that the position of SCDOT that if it is a single span bridge it needs to
be six lanes; confirmation that if the current project is rejected, Council will have to go
back and redefine the project and get back in line to obtain funding, etc.; confirmation that
if Municipal consent is not granted to the County and this project is not submitted as
defined within the current purpose and need and a solution to this project would die and
a new project would have to be defined by going through the full process again;
confirmation that if the project doesn’t move forward, SCDOT would work to determine
which path was most effective and the best use of funds whether it’s to rehabilitate or
replace the Eastbound Mackey Bridge and it would be replacement with two lanes and if
it’s a rehab it would not include the seismic upgrades but a replacement would have
seismic upgrades; a request to hold off until after the election; a request to ask Senator
Davis to continue good work and obtain an extension on the Environmental Assessment
along with funding; confirmation Mackey Bridge replacement is eminent; speculation
three lanes offers the opportunity of an HOV lane; expression of the need for a bike lane
is necessary; acknowledgement we need to control who we are; acknowledgement
Council needs to stay on the topic which is bridges; a suggestion to deal with issues we
can control; acknowledgment the County is in charge of the projects; acknowledgement
the interests of the stoney Community are in the forefront; inquiry regarding methods to
protect causeways due to possible storm surges and confirmation this will be addressed
in future phases of design; inquiry into numbers used regarding correct width of existing
bridge to the width of the proposed bridge; clarification on requirements for consent and
adding conditions; acknowledgment of the need for conditions to be included in Municipal
Consent and the MOU and the need to make it public; request for visuals regarding
measurement; request that the pedestrian portion of the proposal needs to be changed;
proposal to include pedestrian crossing safety as a condition; concern over SCDOT
purpose and need to increase capacity and reduce congestion.
Page 25 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Special Workshop Minutes
6/20/2024 Page 12 of 14
Ms. Brison made lengthy remarks to her process in coming to her views regarding the
project and her proposed conditions.
Council members continued to make comments, ask questions and hold discussion
regarding: a suggestion that in conjunction with the project and improvements to the
Stoney area there should be address the infrastructure and redevelopment needs along
with funding which could possibly include a TIF District in a timely manner; use of Town
property within the Stoney area to accomplish the goals suggested; the need for an
overpass for crossing US278 in the Stoney Area; inquiry as to what a no vote would do
to any enhancements included for Stoney; confirmation the funds could be reallocated;
and confirmation that if the current project is able to advance securing the current gap in
funding is needed to move forward.
Public Comment
Christopher Cliff addressed Council regarding his opinion that the proposal doesn’t solve
traffic problems and the project will destroy the cache of the Island.
Chris Rates addressed Council expressing her concerns regarding transportation
alternatives, the lack of bike paths when expecting people to bike from the mainland, the
fact that the proposed project is not saving much travel time; and the need to protect the
Stoney Community.
Chris Ruffner addressed Council stating additional lanes does not help reduce traffic
congestion as well as speed limits do not assist either.
Mel Campbell addressed Council and stated he was a Native Islander and expressed his
opinion that the bridge is needed and the changes that brought Stoney to where it is today
were caused by design mistakes.
Ray Deal addressed Council noting the Chamber is a voice for all businesses on the
Island. The workforce is top priority for all businesses. He urged Council to approve the
project.
William Stewart addressed Council stated financial well and development needs to be
addressed in the Stoney Community through partnership. He stated the need for safety
to be addressed due to lost lives on US278 of which two of his brothers are included.
Steve Robinson addressed Council stating he couldn’t believe that Council has to ask
Staff as to what would happen if they voted no and if they knew what the purpose of the
question was.
David Johnson addressed Council regarding that citizen comments have assisted in
working through the project. Some residents are in favor of the project. He stated safety
and traffic is a huge issue.
Frank Babel addressed Council stating Stoney needs revitalized and it is appositive thing
to do so, and the traffic problems need fixed along with making the bridge structurally
safe. He encouraged approving the project.
Page 26 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Special Workshop Minutes
6/20/2024 Page 13 of 14
Eric Sommerville addressed Council and suggested the project move forward but to take
the Stoney Area into consideration and not ruin it.
Peter Kristian addressed Council stating a need for six lanes for employees coming on
the Island along with the need for bike lanes.
Cherry Norris addressed Council stating the Island is a special place and encouraged
Council not to expand the bridge. Her concern is does a bigger bridge mean more
development?
Dale Becker addressed Council stating Key West has more visitors that Hilton Head
Island and they do fine. The Gullah Geechee community needs to be honored and taken
care of and we do not need bike lanes on the bridge.
Angie Hutchinson addressed Council stating she likes clapping in meetings. She added
that Beaufort County doesn’t have a good track record. She stated the proposed bridge
is wider than the Brooklyn and Manhattan Bridges.
Linda Harrington addressed Council inquiring as to the duties of the Town Attorney and
asked why he wasn’t in attendance at the meeting. She stated her opinion that the study
for the proposed project is flawed.
Gray Smith addressed Council stating the Island shouldn’t be asked to give up its power
to others. Beaufort County is positional to take advantage of Hilton Head Island.
Carol Buxer addressed Council stating her opposition to the proposed bridge and the bike
paths. She encouraged Council to celebrate the Gullah Geechee Community.
Mr. Stewart addressed Council stating he is a Stoney resident and does not trust the
SCDOT. He spoke of drainage problems and too many tourists.
Lynn Greeley addressed Council stating the need is to beautify and not add a massive
bridge and she feels there are too many tourists.
John O’Toole addressed Council saying he supports the bridge project noting that traffic
is contributing to pollution. He stated he has confidence in Council and Staff.
Mayor Perry invited Shawn Colin to address the questions that were asked.
Mr. Colin stated that the travel time savings if a new bridge is put is place would be eights
minutes and 49 seconds eastbound and 10 minutes and 36 seconds westbound.
He stated the Mackey Bridge was built in 1956, and the other three bridges were built in
the early 1980’s.
Mr. Colin explained that the purpose and need for the project identified deems a four-lane
bridge does not achieve the purpose of reducing congestions, therefore its is rejected by
the project.
Mr. Colin informed Council the impervious surface information is on the project website.
Council and staff discussed the next steps forward and the process that will take place.
Page 27 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Special Workshop Minutes
6/20/2024 Page 14 of 14
Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 7:48 p.m.
Approved:
_________________________
Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk
_______________________
Alan R. Perry, Mayor
The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s
website at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
Page 28 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
6/28/2024 Page 1 of 10
Town of Hilton Head Island
TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
Friday, June 28, 2024, 10:00 AM
Minutes
Call to Order
Mayor Perry called the workshop to order at 10:00 a.m.
Council Members present: Alan Perry, Mayor, David Ames, Ward 3, Mayor Pro-Tempore;
Alex Brown, Ward 1; Patsy Brison, Ward 2; Tammy Becker, Ward 4; Steve Alfred, Ward
5; Glenn Stanford, Ward 6
Invocation – Reverend Steve Salvas, Grace Community Church
Reverend Salvas delivered the Invocation.
Adoption of the Agenda
Mr. Ames moved to approve. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
Ms. Becker moved to postpone the vote on Items 5a. and b. Motion failed due to
lack of a second.
Ms. Becker explained her reasoning for asking that the votes be postponed. She
referenced a book written by Buzz Carota – Evolution of a Town. She stated she is trying
to remind members of Council that this project, just like the project that is described in the
book with regards to the Cross Island Parkway, has the same elements that the County
is looking to do this project to enhance what they can take out of our community without
consideration for our residents.
Mr. Stanford reiterated that the County is the sponsor of the project, not the Town. The
purpose of the meeting is to enter into an agreement that puts the Town firmly at the table
for all decision making.
Mayor Perry read a second letter he received from Secretary Powell. It is below:
June 27, 2024
Mayor Perry:
It is my understanding that the Town of Hilton Head Island intends to take up a
Municipal Consent resolution for the US-278 project at a special meeting
called on Friday, June 28. I wanted to provide some comments on behalf of
the South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) related to the
pending action.
As stated in my letter dated June 20, 2024, time is of the essence. The
Environmental Assessment for this project will expire on June 28 absent
action from the Town of Hilton Head Island. Moreover, I remained concerned
that the existing US-278 eastbound bridge over Mackay Creek will continue to
Page 29 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
6/28/2024 Page 2 of 10
deteriorate absent a plan to move forward. Should Municipal Consent not be
granted on June 28, I am prepared to instruct SCOOT staff to begin
developing a plan to rehabilitate or replace the existing Mackay Creek bridge
only. This could have ramifications to the South Carolina Transportation
Infrastructure Bank's agreement to provide $120,000,000 to Beaufort County
for the project.
This project initiated out of a desire from Beaufort County to replace the
bridges and improve traffic operations between Bluffton and Hilton Head
Island. In lieu of a separate project for the Mackay Creek bridge only, SCOOT
entered into an intergovernmental agreement with Beaufort County to serve
as project manager of the US-278 bridge and improvement projects.
As is standard practice on any project of this scope and size, SCOOT has
engaged with the public, Beaufort County, the Town of Hilton Head Island,
and other interested stakeholders in substantial public involvement and
studies related to the project. This has resulted in a modified recommended
preferred alternative that generally conforms to the Lochmueller
recommendation. On May 16, 2024, I sent a letter to Interim County
Administrator John Robinson (attachment 1) indicating that the Department
of Transportation is willing to proceed with the modified recommended
alternative.
Per SC Code Section 57-5-810, SCOOT is required to obtain Municipal
Consent when a project occurs within a municipality except for structurally
deficient or functionally obsolete bridges that cross the Atlantic lntracoastal
Waterway. For this project, SCOOT has determined that the project elements
between the bridge approaches and the Cross Island Parkway necessitate
Municipal Consent under state law. We are at a juncture where the Town of
Hilton Head Island needs to approve or disapprove a resolution authorizing
Municipal Consent.
I am in receipt of the draft Municipal Consent resolution. It is SCDOT's
posture that it requires a clean Municipal Consent resolution consistent with
its standard template (attachment 2) without further stipulations. Therefore,
I request that if the Town of Hilton Head Island intends to approve Municipal
Consent, it adopt a resolution consistent with our standard template with
no additional stipulations being placed on SCOOT. I am amenable to deleting
language related to utilities as requested by the Town as the Town does not
own or operate a municipal utility.
I recognize that this project will make substantive changes to the crossing
from Bluffton to Hilton Head Island, as well as the historic gateway onto the
island. It is my intent that, if this project does proceed, SCOOT intends to
deliver a quality project that meets all state and federal requirements and
improves transportation on Hilton Head Island. To that end, I want to offer the
attached comments to the proposed stipulations as a good faith effort that
SCOOT intends to cooperatively pursue this project with Beaufort County and
the Town of Hilton Head Island.
SCOOT appreciates the continued partnership with the Town of Hilton Head
Page 30 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
6/28/2024 Page 3 of 10
Island and Beaufort County. We are prepared to deliver a quality project for
the benefit of all parties involved.
Justin P Powell
SCDOT
Secretary of Transportation
Mayor Perry invited Senator Tom Davis to speak to the efforts he has put into this
throughout the process.
Senator Davis explained his role in the process to date which includes facilitating funding
for the project, making sure the Town has enough time, space and resources to come up
with a decision. He stated that irrespective of SCDOT being the contractor and builder
and irrespective of the County being the sponsor and project manager, he has always
looked to the Town of Hilton Head and the Council as being representatives of the citizens
as being the primary determinant of whether or not this project goes forward.
Senator Davis noted that if Council deems more time is necessary, he will do his best to
have the Environmental Assessment extended. He noted that there have been
assessments granted in the past and some have not. He reiterated Secretary Powell’s
statement that absent Municipal Consent they will go forward with repairs on the Mackey
Bridge.
Senator Davis reviewed the funding statistics noting that the State Infrastructure Bank
has been pressured to take allocations and apply them to projects being built. He
commented on comments from previous meetings from members of Council regarding a
bilateral relationship with the Town and SCDOT as well as Beaufort County to assure
needs are conveyed.
Senator Davis stated that if this project were to move forward, in terms of if consent is
given, either with or without conditions, there would then be a process then he would
engage in along with other members of the delegation to ensure that those conditions
were discharged. He explained it would be to make appropriation advocations in the
General Assembly, to work with the County for appropriation requests, work with the
Town on a potential TIF District, to go to Washington, DC and talk with the Federal
Delegation to come up with funding that is necessary and to make what Council envisions
a reality. He said the process is going to take a couple years to move from where we are
right now even if Consent is given. He stated the next step would then be for the SCDOT
to submit an application to the Feds for a finding of no significant impact would which take
months and there may be processes associated with it that would involve action by this
Council. Concluding that, the SCDOT would complete the engineering drawings which
the Town will be involved in and that step could take several months.
He summarized that his point is there is a tremendous amount of work to be done even if
consent is given, which is going to entail Council’s continued involvement throughout the
Sincerely,
Page 31 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
6/28/2024 Page 4 of 10
entire process.
He proceeded to review the funding obtained to date and the process to obtain further
funding and answered questions from Council regarding the process.
He concluded with stating the primary thing is getting a project Council feels is reflective
of what the people of Hilton Had Island want.
Mr. Orlando stated that he along with staff and the Town Attorney have incorporated
directives given to them within the proposed resolution and memorandum of
understanding. He invited Shawn Colin to come forward and review all the changes and
additions.
New Business
Consideration of a Resolution of the Town of Hilton Head Island Authorizing a
Memorandum of Agreement with Beaufort County for the William Hilton Parkway
Gateway Corridor Project
Mr. Colin conducted a thorough review of the documents and the changes that were
applied. He noted there were no changes to the Resolution but there were changes and
additions to Exhibit A of the Resolution which is the Memorandum of Agreement (MOA).
He detailed each change and projected them on the screen for viewing.
Mayor Perry asked for public comment.
Eric Sommerville addressed Council regarding his concern that rather than having less
lanes he would prefer a traffic jam on the bridge.
Lynn Greeley addressed Council stating she feels like she is in Washington, DC and
expressed her views in opposition to the project.
Skip Hoagland addressed Council noting the traffic problem is not caused by the resident
but by allowing too much tourism. He stated tourism needs to be balanced and spoke in
opposition to the project.
Dee Anthony address Council voicing her concern for Stoney and all of the residents on
the north end of the Island. She stated her opinion that this will expand further north all
all of the neighborhoods including Squire Pope, Gumtree, Spanish Wells, Marshland
Road and many vulnerable neighborhoods.
Bill Fishburne addressed Council regarding his support for the project noting service
workers need to have better access to Hilton Head Island.
Melinda Tunner addressed Council stating she has spoken with may residents of Ward 6
and most agree the bridges need replaced but do not want three travels lanes in each
direction but two and most want two bridges as opposed to one structure.
Dale Becker addressed Council addressed travel time from Old Town Bluffton to Skull
Creek noting driving time was 18 minutes, biking time was 46 minutes and walking was
three hours. His point was a bike lane is not needed for the structure.
John Casey addressed Council stating the document is being produced in a rush and
stated his opinion that Beaufort County will not take the Town’s conditions into
consideration. He encouraged Council to vote no to the resolutions.
Lynn Bullard addressed Council stating the project has been taken from its original
Page 32 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
6/28/2024 Page 5 of 10
purpose with its size and number of lanes.
Ashley Phillips addressed Council reminding them that however they vote constituents
are watching.
Thoms C. Barnwell, Jr. addressed Council thanking all Town council, Beaufort County
Counsil and staff. He stated the highway needs to be improved, safety needs to be
considered and repairs should be completed. He encouraged them to focus on
evacuations during hurricane season.
Morris Campbell addressed Council stating history is different from everyone’s
perspective. He stated the proposal makes sense in securing the Stoney Neighborhood
and the residents. He encouraged Council to keep working on it. He stated he realizes
the process will take give and take.
Rosmary Kimball addressed Council asking that Council not rush this process. She
encouraged them to postpone the vote.
Linda Harrington addressed Council stating she felt a TIF District is not appropriate. She
added that the Greater Island Council is a lobbying group and if any Council members
are members of the group they should recuse themselves from voting on these
resolutions.
Christopher Cliff addressed Council needs to invest time and effort into finding a solution
to getting traffic coming onto the Island more directly to the Cross Island Parkway and
then backing into a bridge design. He emphasized the need to improve safety in the
Stoney Community.
Jack Alderman addressed Council stating he supports the plan and they involve the best
solutions. He feels important criteria includes: quality of life, workforce; community values
and economic vitality.
Diedrik Advocaat addressed Council regarding the need to be a good neighbor. He stated
he feels the WHP Advisory Committee has not finished its work and the need for better
communication. He encouraged Council to not commit to two or three lanes but to wait
to see what works best.
Joe Judge addressed Council suggesting the bridge should be repaired rater than
expanding it.
Ira Polack signed up and was called on but was not present to speak.
Pamela Martin Ovens addressed Council stating the Safety Committee should review this
project. She suggested just rebuilding the existing bridge as is and to address the problem
with parking with the funds saved.
Chuck Lobaugh addressed Council thanking all for the compromise solution to access his
building and business from US278 and Old Wild Horse Road.
Gerald DeVito addressed Council regarding the need for the improvements to deal with
traffic congestion and safety issues.
John Stewart addressed Council encouraging them to make another way onto the Island.
William Stewart addressed Council stating he feels the plan was not properly prepared
and was created by misinformed individuals.
Page 33 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
6/28/2024 Page 6 of 10
John Smarszly addressed Council encouraging them to vote no on the resolutions.
Louise Cohen addressed Council noting her concerns regarding signage, and the black
cemetery. She encouraged Council to replace the bridge but not to destroy things.
Steve Robinson addressed Council noting Council should not do what they think they
should do but what their constituents want them to do.
Lee Lucier addressed Council regarding his support for the project stating it needs Hilton
Head Island input and design.
A woman who did not identify herself spoke encouraging Council to move forward and
listen to make the best decision they can.
John Score addressed Council in support of the project stating we need the people that
travel to the Island.
Ken Campbell addressed Council voicing his support for the project and expressed his
appreciation for all the hard work done by everyone and with the conditions and proposals
going forward will ensure that it is done right.
Frank Babel addressed Council voicing his support for the project encouraging Council
to not postpone the project but to move forward.
David White addressed Council and encouraged them to give Municipal Consent with
conditions.
Carol Buxer addressed Council stating the need for the bridge but the proposed bridge is
not designed the appropriate scale and design for Hilton Head Island. She expressed
her opinion the bridge should not be 6 lanes and there should not be a bike path.
Jerry Cutrer addressed Council and expressed his support for passing the Consent
resolution and encouraged Council to vote in favor of it.
Cole Peterson addressed Council and expressed his appreciation concerning the
attention given to protecting the Gullah Community. He spoke in support of the project
and encouraged Council to vote in favor of Municipal consent.
Brian Herrington addressed Council stating that there are 11,000 or more people against
the project. He encouraged Council to listen to their constituents and wait until all
alternatives are in before a decision is made.
Mayor Perry stated there was a need to enter into Executive Session for the purpose of
advice from legal counsel.
At 1:03 p.m. Mr. Ames moved to enter into Executive Session for the purpose stated
by the Mayor. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
At 2:23 p.m. Ms. Brison moved to end Executive Session and return to the meeting.
Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
Mayor Perry asked if there was any action to be taken during Executive Session. Mr.
Ames stated no actions were taken during Executive Session.
Mr. Ames moved to approve the resolution of the Town of Hilton Head Island
authorizing a memorandum of Agreement with Beaufort County for the Hilton Head
Island Parkway Gateway Corridor Project as presented with the edits provided
today. Mr. Alfred seconded.
Page 34 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
6/28/2024 Page 7 of 10
Ms. Brison referenced Item #4 under Sub-Section C which reads up to two
pedestrian overpasses and intersection protections. She suggested it reads to
read: Up to two pedestrian overpasses within the Stoney Historic Community and
intersection protections throughout the corridor that will facilitate safe movement
of pedestrians and bicyclist across the proposed roadway area.
Mr. Ames amended his motion to correspond with Ms. Brison’s recommendation.
Mr. Colin was asked to address the inquiry regarding turn lanes on or off Wildhorse Road.
Mr. Colin stated that the Wildhorse Road turn lanes remain as they are today. He added
that intersection has advanced upgrades with addition right turn lane an a second left turn
lane off of Spanish Wells Road. He added there was a provision in the document that
speaks to further consideration of left turn restrictions during peak hours which will be
assessed with SCDOT. In conclusion, he said there no restriction in the intersection
design for left turns.
Ms. Becker read a statement from Richard Bisi at his request. Mr. Bisi wrote the decision
they are about to make will have ramifications for decades to come and could change the
character of our Island. He stated the Advisory Committee has not finished their job and
urged Council to vote against Municipal Consent.
Ms. Becker made a motion to remove Item 4.c. – the installation of up to two pedestrian
overpasses from the document being reviewed for Municipal Consent and MOA and that
further work be done to find a solution to bringing that community together. Motion failed
due to lack of a second.
Ms. Becker made a motion to remove Item 5.a. from the document. Motion failed
due to lack of a second.
Ms. Becker moved to amend Item 6.d by striking “County Council” as part of the
language. Ms. Brison seconded.
Mr. Stanford stated the entrance to the bridge is not within Town limits and should require
County approval. Mr. Colin added that the entire project is within the County. Clarification
was provided that the Design Review Board would only have authority to review the
aesthetics as you come through the corridor.
Motion failed 5-2 (Alfred, Ames, Brown, Perry, Stanford against).
Ms. Becker had numerous questions and Mr. Colin addressed each one as she asked.
Mr. Ames moved to close discussion. Mr. Alfred seconded.
Mayor Perry called the vote.
Amended motion carried 6-1 (Becker opposed).
Consideration of a Resolution of the Town of Hilton Head Island Authorizing
Municipal Consent with the South Carolina Department of Transportation for the
William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Project
Mr. Colin clarified that the current resolution as written will include the amendments
made in the earlier vote on the MOA.
Mayor Perry invited Senator Davis to speak.
Page 35 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
6/28/2024 Page 8 of 10
Senator Davis addressed Council stating Secretary Powell made a suggestion that
Council deliver the consent and that Council take up the conditions in a separate
resolution which would communicate the Town’s expectations and provide a
blueprint for the Delegation to try to accomplish the things that the Town deems
important in connection with this project.
Curtis Coltrane addressed Council explaining explained that following the
information delivered by Senator Davis regarding the statements from Secretary
Powell, two things have been completed for Council’s consideration. The first is a
proposal for a resolution for Municipal Consent with no conditions attached to it. He
explained this is the form of Municipal Consent the Secretary delivered to the Town
with his correspondence. He clarified it is not the text that is on today’s agenda, or
that was included in the agenda packet. If Council should decide that it wished to
do this a motion to amend this resolution would be needed in order to conform the
document to what the SCDOT wishes to see. Secondly, following the advice of
Senator Davis, a second resolution has been created that expresses the will of
Council that includes all of the items that were in the resolution that is on today’s
agenda packet, as well as incorporating the Towns expectation that all of the things
set out in Secretary Powell’s correspondence to the Mayor will be complied with.
Including that the Town expects the assistance of the County’s Legislative
Delegation to push through the design, construction, and funding of this project in a
manner consistent with what the Town wishes. Since this is a new resolution, in
order for Council to consider that today, there would need to be a motion and finding
by the Town that some form of emergency or exigent circumstance exists and in this
case you are facing a deadline of 5:00 p.m. and we have only received the advice
from the Secretary on what the SCDOT says it requires. Council would then have
to amend the agenda to consider the resolution.
Mayor Perry asked for public comment.
Christopher Cliff addressed Council sharing his opinion that rather than using the word
will rather than shall within the resolution. He stated he was of the opinion the document
was a poor contract. He questioned the timing of Secretary Powell’s response.
John Casey addressed Council stating he feels Council is just giving clean consent and
a wish list. He doubts Beaufort County will honor the wish list. He feels the conditions
should be within the Consent.
Mr. Ames moved to amend the proposed resolution by deleting the text of the
proposed resolution following the words Project ID Number 030450 in its entirety
and replacing it with the following text:
WHEREAS, the South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) proposed
to construct, reconstruct, alter, or improve the certain segments of the highway in
the State Highway System referenced above which is located within the corporate
limits of the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina (hereinafter, the “Town”).
WHEREAS, the Town wishes to authorize the construction and improvements of
the aforesaid highway in accordance with the plans to be prepared by or for SCDOT
(the “Project Plans”).
Page 36 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
6/28/2024 Page 9 of 10
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that, pursuant to S. C. Code Ann. § 57-5-820
(2018, as amended), the Town does hereby consent to the construction or
improvements of the aforesaid highway within its corporate limits in accordance
with the Project Plans, and further, the Town, having reviewed the plans for said
construction, does hereby approve said plans as provided in S. C. Code 57-5-830.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the foregoing consent and approval shall be the
sole approval necessary from the Town for SCDOT to complete the project under
the Project Plans and constitutes a waiver of any and all other requirements with
regard to construction within the Town’s limits. The foregoing waiver and consent
shall also extend to the benefit of utility companies engaged in relocating utility
lines on account of the Project. Further, the Town shall exempt all existing and new
right-of-way and all other properties purchased in connection with right-of-way for
the Highway from any general or special assessment against real property for
municipal services.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Town hereby signifies its intention to faithfully
observe the provisions of Chapter 5, Title 56, Code of Laws of South Carolina, 1976,
and all amendments thereto relating to the regulation of traffic on the Highway to
be constructed, reconstructed, altered or improved as hereinabove identified and
further agrees to refrain from placing or maintaining any traffic control devices
upon any section of the Highway without having first obtained written approval of
the South Carolina Department of Transportation as required by S. C. Code Ann. §
56-5-930 (1976, as amended), or enacting any traffic regulation ordinances
inconsistent therewith.
Mr. Alfred seconded.
Ms. Becker moved to ask for an extension. Motion failed for lack of a second.
Council held discussion regarding the amendment and process. The Town Attorney
clarified the items in question.
Mayor Perry called for a vote.
Motion passed 4-3 (Bown, Becker and Brison opposed).
Mr. Ames moved to approve the resolution as amended. After discussion the
motions passed 5-2 (Becker and Brison opposed).
Mr. Ames moved to amend the agenda to add a resolution regarding the sense of
Town Council related to this project and expectations of the Town Council
regarding the US278 Corridor, and that the Town is faced with an emergency
exigent circumstance related to the deadline that is imposed on the Town for the
decision on Municipal Consent and the information delivered today by the SCDOT
regarding the form of Municipal Consent that is acceptable to the Department in
addition to the emergent and exigent circumstance. The text in the proposed
resolution is the same text that is in the proposed Municipal Consent Resolution
that was attached to the agenda for today’s meeting, meaning that nothing in the
proposed resolution to be added to the agenda is now, rather it is a change of the
Page 37 of 92
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
6/28/2024 Page 10 of 10
methodology. Mr. Alfred seconded. Concluding discussion, the motion carried 6-
1 (Becker opposed).
Shawn Colin approached the dias and explained the resolution that was added to the
agenda. Council further discussed the MOA and the resolution with the conditions in
detail.
Mayor Perry asked for public comment.
Christopher Cliff addressed Council noting Council’s responsibilities are to the Town and
Secretary Powell’s responsibilities are to the SCDOT. He said with the Town signing off
on the MOA with the County and the resolution for Municipal Consent with the SCDOT is
all that is needed.
Concluding further discussion, Mr. Ames moved for Council to approve a resolution of the
Town Council for the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, expressing the sense
of the Town Council regarding the project to improve the US Highway 278 Corridor from
the intersection of US Highway 278 and Moss Creek Drive to the Intersection of US
Highway 278 and Spanish Wells Road and Wildhorse Road. Mr. Sandford seconded.
After points of view by various Council members were given Mayor Perry called for
a vote. Motion carried 6-1 (Becker opposed).
Public Comment - Non Agenda Items
None.
Adjournment
The meeting adjourned at 4:26 p.m.
Approved:
Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk
Alan R. Perry, Mayor
The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website at
www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
Page 38 of 92
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
Town Council
TO: Town Council
FROM:
DATE: July 23, 2024
SUBJECT: Sand Shark Welcome Week Proclamation - Mayor Perry
RECOMMENDATION:
SUMMARY:
BACKGROUND:
ATTACHMENTS:
1. USCB Sand Shark Week -2024
Page 39 of 92
Page 40 of 92
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
Town Council
TO: Town Council
FROM:
DATE: July 23, 2024
SUBJECT: Parks and Recreation Month Proclamation - Mayor Perry
RECOMMENDATION:
SUMMARY:
BACKGROUND:
ATTACHMENTS:
1. Parks and Recreation Month
Page 41 of 92
Page 42 of 92
Office of Cultural
Affairs
Natalie Harvey - Director
HILTON HEAD ISLAND TOWN COUNCIL
JULY 23 , 2024
Page 43 of 92
Promote Hilton Head Island’s Art, Culture, and History.
Increased listings on CultureHHI.org event calendar
Sponsored content with Georgia Public Broadcasting
Distribution of Cultural Trail Map to visitors and residents
Social Media followers (9,800 FB, 1,900 IG) and E-Newsletter
subscribers (5,340) up 10% in FY24.
Increase the community’s access to cultural, historical,
and artistic experiences.
2 artist exhibits each month at Island Rec Center
Assisted Arts Center of Coastal Carolina with a mural
commission for Hilton Head Island Middle School
Create and implement community-oriented programs,
events, and experiences connected to arts and culture.
Rock painting activity at Island Rec Center’s Party in the
Park + Maker’s Fair in cooperation with The Breeze Trolley
Lantern workshops this fall
Pursue a Cultural District application with SC Arts
Commission in 2025
Page 44 of 92
Public Art Projects
Hilton Head Fishing Cooperative exhibit and mural unveiling
Temporary installation at Shelter Cove Sculpture Trail
changing in September
Outreach, Community Engagement, and Special Events
Assisting with Juneteenth events at Historic Mitchelville
Freedom Park
OCA tents at community events (Gullah Celebration, Wingfest,
Juneteenth, Oyster Festival, etc.) & attend events
Presentations at 9 resort properties weekly – with over 6,000
in attendance since November.
Attended SC Arts Advocacy Day in Columbia in February.
Crescendo and Lantern Parade
Kickoff scheduled 10/15 – Guest artist, Grammy
Award winner Charlton Singleton & Contemporary
Flow
Lantern Parade – 11/23
Page 45 of 92
Coming soon!
September 19-22
Community Tree Lighting & Program December 7
Community Menorah Lighting - TBD
October 15 – November 23
• Weekly Songwriters Concerts at LCP -
Thursdays
• Family friendly entertainment at
Community Market – Saturdays
• 100+ arts, culture, and history events
scheduled
Lantern Parade – November 23
Page 46 of 92
TO: Town Council Members
FROM: Joshua Gruber, Deputy Town Manager
CC: Marc Orlando, Town Manager
Curtis Coltrane, Town Attorney
DATE: July 23, 2024
SUBJECT: Consideration of an Ordinance of the Town of Hilton Head Island
Authorizing the Execution and Delivery of Quit Claim Deeds for a
Portion of Property Owned by the Town of Hilton Head Island
Identified as 54 Muddy Creek Road and the Purchase of a
Stormwater Easement for the Same
RECOMMENDATION:
The Town Council is requested to consider the potential acquisition and release of parcels of
real property that are located adjacent to 54 Muddy Creek Road to resolve outstanding
concerns related to the ownership of the properties and to secure a stormwater easement
for future maintenance. If the Town Council determines that it is appropriate to pursue any
one or more of these acquisitions, it should identify the terms and conditions upon which it
would be willing to release a portion of these parcels and to acquire a dedicated
stormwater easement.
At its m eeting on June 18, 2024, Town Council voted un animously to approve Fir st
Reading of this Ordinance.
PARCEL BACKGROUND:
Muddy Creek Road Area – 54 Muddy Creek Road
Several years ago, the Town was contacted by members of the Williams/Jones family
who were concerned that a portion of their family property located at 54 Muddy Creek
Road had been inappropriately acquired by the Town. Staff and the Town Attorney
conducted a search of the Town’s property records associated with this acquisition and
determined that the Town purchased its property in 2003 for a purchase price of $22,000.
The Town's title derives from a deed from Mr. Hubert Bernheim, that was recorded at the
time of the Town’s acquisition in 2003. Mr. Bernheim's title derives from a Treasurer's tax
deed he received in 1996. The property that Mr. Bernheim bought at the tax sale was
titled in the name of a "William Campbell." Neither the Town nor Mr. Bernheim cleared
the title to the property and therefore, the Town's title is uncertain, and a title clearance
action would have to be pursued to establish its ownership of the property.
Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex
One Town Center Court Hilton Head Island South Carolina 29928
www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
TOWN COUNCIL
Page 47 of 92
Page 2 of 2
Sometime after 2003, a sewer lift station was installed on the southernmost portion of the
Town’s property. That use continues to the present day and is currently fenced in on the
property.
While the Town was researching the title issues associated with this property, staff within
the Stormwater Division determined that it was necessary to acquire an easement on a
portion of this property as well as a portion of the main Williams Family property. A survey
identifying this easement along with a corresponding property appraisal establishing the
purchase value of the easement was obtained. Information pertaining to both items is
enclosed as Attachments 1 and 2 respectively.
Based upon extensive discussions with the Williams/Jones family, the Town is proposing
to exchange Quit Claim Deeds with the family to release any interest that it may have in
the 54 Muddy Creek Road parcel while at the same time solidifying its interest in the
sewer lift station property which would be retained. Additionally, the Town would purchase
the stormwater easement from the family once these Quit Claim Deeds have been
exchanged and recorded by the parties. The Town’s appraisal indicated a fair market
value of $27,904. Based upon negotiations with the Williams/Jones family, they have
requested compensation of $35,000 to sign over the requested easement. Staff supports
this requested value and believes that it is justifiable under the circumstances of this
transaction.
CONCLUSION:
If the Town Council is supportive of exchanging the quit claims deeds identified above as well
as supporting the acquisition of a stormwater easement for the requested $35,000, an
Ordinance authorizing the transfer of the property and a Resolution authorizing the purchase
of the property will be prepared by the Town Attorney for consideration by Town Council.
ATTACHMENTS:
1. Ordinance Authorizing the Execution and Delivery of Quit Claim Deeds for a
Portion of Property Identified as 54 Muddy Creek Road and the Purchase of a
Stormwater Easement
Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex
One Town Center Court Hilton Head Island South Carolina 29928
www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
Page 48 of 92
Page 1 of 5
ORDINANCE NUMBER 2024-____
A
N ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA,
AUTHORIZING THE CONVEYANCE OF THREE PARCELS OF REAL ESTATE IN
WHICH THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, OWNS OR HAS
AN INTEREST IN, AND AUTHORI NG THE ACQUISITION OF AN EASEMENT FOR
DRAINAGE, UNDER TH E AUTHORITY OF S. C. CODE ANN. § 5-7- 40 (SUPP. 2023),
AND § 2-7-20, MUNICIPAL CODE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH
CAROLINA (1983), AND S. C. CODE ANN. § 5-7-40 (SUPP. 2023), AND PROVI DING
FOR SEVERABILITY AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
L
EGISLATIVE FINDINGS
Wher
eas, the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, hold title to certain real
property by virtu e of a Limited Warranty Deed of Hubert L. Bernh eim that is recorded
the Office of The Register of Deeds for Beaufort County, South Carolina, in Official Record
Book 1852 at Page 2182, which is known and described as follows:
All that certain piece, parcel or lot of land situate, lying and being on Hilton
Head Island, Beaufort County, South Carolina, containing 1.81 acres, more
or less, shown as R500, Map 20, Parcel 34, on the Tax Maps for B eaufort
County (herein, the “Town Property”).
Whereas, Hubert L. Bernheim held title to the own Property under a Tax Title
issued by the Treasurer for Beaufort County, South Carolina, dated January 10, 1996, and
recorded in the Office of The Register of Deeds for Beaufort County, South Carolina, in
Official Record Book 829 at Page 349; and,
Whereas, Eugene Williams holds title to a parcel of real property described as R510
010 000 0035, under a Tax Title issued by the T reasurer for Beaufort County, South
Carolina, date December 3, 2008, and recorded in the Office of The Register of Deeds for
Beaufort County, South Carolina, in Official Record Book 2788 at Page 1746 (hereinafter
the “Williams Property”); and,
Attachment 1
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA
Page 49 of 92
Page 2 of 5
W hereas, the state of the title and the boundaries of bo th the Town Property and
the Williams Property are unclear, and the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina,
and Eugene Williams have agreed on the location of the common boundary line between
the Town Property and the Williams Property; and,
Whereas, the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, also holds title to real
property that adjoins both the Town Prope rty and the Williams Property, that is known
and described as follows:
All those certain parcels, tracts, and lots of land, collectively comprising 7.19
acres, more or less, and more particularly described as Lots A -1, A-2, A-3,
A-4, A-5, A-6, B-1, B-2, B-3, B-4, B-5, B-6, C-1, C-2, C-3, C-4, C-5, C-6, C-7,
C-8, and the rights of way shown as Bryant Road, Deep Fording, Still Run
Ramble, Little Garden Path, and the area shown as “Open Space - Pond,” all
as shown on a Plat entitled “Plat of Spanish Grove Subdivision, Bryant
Road, Hilton Head Island, Beaufort County, South Carolina,” prepared by
Michael A. Mack, PLS 12244 of Horizon Surveying Associates dated July 31,
1996, and recorded in the Office of the Register of Deeds for Beaufort
County, South Carolina, i n Plat Book 64 at Page 95 (herein, the “Spanish
Grove Property”).
W hereas, the public record reveals the existence of a survey discrepancy along the
common boundary line between the Williams Property and the Spanish Grove Pro perty;
and,
Whereas, a storm water drainage ditch exists on the property, and following the
conveyances authorized by this Ordinance, the storm water drainage ditch will cross both
the Town Property and the Williams Property; and,
Whereas, Eugene Williams has agreed to convey an easement for access to, us of
and maintenance of the storm water drainage ditch for the appraised valu e of the
easement; and,
Whereas, the Town Council for the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina,
finds that it is in the best interest of the T own and its citizens and residents to authorize
Page 50 of 92
Page 3 of 5
the conveyance of a part of the Town Property in exchange for a conveyance of a part of
the Williams property to resolve the title and bounda ry issues described above, and to
acquire an easement from Eugene Williams for access to, us of and maintenance of the
storm water drainage ditch on the Williams Property; and,
Whereas, the Plat that is attached hereto as Exhibit “A” shows the location of the
agreed upon common boundary lines between the Town Property, the Williams Property
and the Spanish Grove Property and the location of the storm water drainage ditch; and
Whereas, S. C. Code Ann. § 5-7-40 (Supp. 2023), § 2-7-20, Municipal Code Of The Town
Of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina (1983), and S. C. C ode A nn. § 5-7- 40 (S upp.
2023), authorizes municipalities to acquire and own real property and interests in real
property.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT OR DERED AND ORDAINED BY THE TOWN COUNCIL
FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, AND IT IS HEREBY
ORDAINED BY THE AUTHORITY OF THE TOWN COUNCIL, AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. Execution and Delivery of Conveyance and Payment for Easement.
(a) The Mayor and Town Manager rea hereby authorized to execute a Quit Claim Deed
to Eugene Williams for the property sh own and described as “Tract 1 ” on the Plat that is
attached hereto as Exhibit “A”. The Quit Claim Deed shall be in a form and substance
similar to the document attached hereto as Exhibit “B.”
(b) The Mayor and Town Manager rea hereby authorized to accept a Quit Claim Deed
to Eugene Williams for the property sh own and described as “Tract 2” and “Tract 3” on
the Plat that is attached here to as Exhibit “A”. The Quit Claim Deed shall be in a form
and substance similar to the document attached hereto as Exhibit “C.”
(c) The Mayor and Town Manager rea hereby authorized to accept an Easement for a
Permanent Storm Water Drainage Easem ent from Eugene Williams for the property
Page 51 of 92
Page 4 of 5
shown and described as “Drainage & Utility Reserve Easement, Area: 4,360 Sq. Ft., 0.100
Acres” on the Plat that is attached hereto as Exhibit “A”. The Quit Claim Deed shall be in
a form and substance similar to the document attached hereto as Exhibit “D,” and to pay
Eugene Williams the appraised value for the easement area, being the sum of Twenty
Seven Thousand Nine Hundred Four and no/100 ($27,904.00) Dollars.
(d) T he Mayor and Town Manager are authorized to take such other and further
actions as may be necessary to complete the conveyances of real property and the
easement authorized by this Ordinance.
Section 2. Severability.
If any section, phrase, sentence, or portion of this Ordinance is, for any reason, held or
deemed to be invalid or unconstitutional by any Court of competent jurisdiction, then
such section, phrase, sentence, or portion shall be deemed to be a separate, distinct, and
independent provision, and its invalidity or unconstitutionality shall not affect any other
provision.
Section 3. Effective Date.
This Ordinance shall become effective upon adoption by the Town Council for the
Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina.
Page 52 of 92
Page 5 of 5
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED BY THE TOWN COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF
HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, ON THIS ___ DAY OF JUNE, 2024.
Alan R. Perry, Mayor
ATTEST:
Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk
First Reading: June ___, 2024
Second Reading: July ___, 2024
Approved as to Form:
Curtis L. Coltrane, Town Attorney
Page 53 of 92
EXHIBIT “A” TO ORDINANCE 2024-____
Page 54 of 92
DEEP FORDING ROAD
(PRIVATE R/W VARIES)
DEEP FORDING ROAD(PRIVATE R/W VARIES)
MUDDY CREEK ROAD
(40' PUBLIC R/W)
N/F
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
SOUTH CAROLINA
54 MUDDY CREEK ROAD
TMS # R510-010-000-0034-0000
DB 1852, PG 2182
N/F
EUGENE WILLIAMS JR.
52 MUDDY CREEK ROAD
TMS # R510-010-000-0035-0000
DB 2788, PG 1746
PB 44, PG 63
LOT
A-5
LOT
A-6
LOT
A-4
LOT
B-5
LOT
B-4
LOT
B-6
LOT
B-3
N/F
CAROLYN DEBARR
46 BRYANT ROAD
TMS # R510-010-000-0311-0000
DB 3513, PG 1081
N/F
MARIA DEL CARMEN SOTO VEGA
36 MUDDY CREEK ROAD
TMS # R510-010-000-0312-0000
DB 4135, PG 1329
N/F
GONZALO LOPEZ AGUILAR
66 MUDDY CREEK ROAD
TMS # R510-010-000-040A-0000
DB 3328, PG 3173
N/F
EMILY BRYANT
31 BRYANT ROAD
TMS # R510-010-000-032E-0000
DB 533, PG 2133
N/F
ALFRED YOUNG & CORDELIA L. JTROS
95 ALFRED LANE
TMS # R510-010-000-033F-0000
DB 693, PG 2226
N/F
LINDA T. GREEN
41 MUDDY CREEK ROAD
TMS # R510-010-000-036E-0000
DB 433, PG 478
N/F
EDWARD SNIDER & ANNIE JTROS
MUDDY CREEK ROAD
TMS # R510-010-000-0036-0000
DB 842, PG 438
N/F
HUGO A. RAMIREZ
6 EUGENE DR
TMS # R510-010-000-036G-0000
DB 3183, PG 1854
N/F
CHARLES E SIMMONS &
ROSA G SIMMONS
MUDDY CREEK ROAD
TMS # R510-001-000-032B-0000
DB 4142, PG 574
N/F
DEIHA TORIN LIVING TRUST
61 MUDDY CREEK RD
TMS # R510-010-000-040J-0000
DB 3889, PG 78
N/F
RICHARD A. SILVER
69 WIDEWATER ROAD
TMS # R510-010-000-0262-0000
DB 4113, PG 1050
N/F
NELSON R. GLUCK & ASHLEY E. STURM
71 WIDEWATER ROAD
TMS # R510-010-000-0263-0000
DB 3358, PG 2230
N/F
JESUS AGUILAR GOMEZ & IRIS AGUILAR
72 MUDDY CREEK RD
TMS # R510-010-000-040B-0000
DB 3326, PG 2054
LOT
A-3
LOT
A-2
LOT
A-1
N/F
HHSC, LLC
26 BRYANT RD
SPANISH GROVE SUBDIVISION
DB 3395, PG 865
PB 64, PG 95
LOT
C-1
LOT
C-2
LOT
C-3
LOT
C-4
LOT
C-5
LOT
C-6
LOT
C-7
LOT
C-8
LOT
B-2
LOT
B-1
OPEN SPACE
POND
20' BUFFER
20' BUFFER
10' UTILITY EASEMENT
10' UTILITY EASEMENT
20' BUFFER
24' PARK EASEMENT
33' PARK EASEMENT
1/2" RBF
2X2 CMF
2" OTPF
5/8" RBCF
2X2 CMF
2X2 CMF
2X2 CMF
N: 129464.42
E: 2071706.02
POB TRACT 1
5/8" RBF
2X2 CMF
2" OTPF
5/8" RBF
PKF
N: 129401.28
E: 2071422.66
POB TRACT 3
3X3 CMF
3X3 CMF
5/8" RBCF
N/F
HAROLD YOUNG
25 BRYANT ROAD
TMS # R510-010-000-033A-0000
DB 363, PG 762
N/F
JEROME YOUNG
27 BRYANT ROAD
TMS # R510-010-000-033I-0000
DB 2654, PG 2492
N/F
LELAND F. TOMLINSON & LORA K. MEADOWS
67 WIDEWATER ROAD
TMS # R510-010-000-0261-0000
DB 3828, PG 2777
N/F
BRIAN A. RODEN & CARLA J. MOSER
65 WIDEWATER ROAD
TMS # R510-010-000-0260-0000
DB 4052, PG 996
N/F
TREVOR J. DENNER &
YASMIN C. DENNER TRUST
63 WIDEWATER ROAD
TMS # R510-010-000-0259-0000
DB 4142, PG 1425
N/F
SPANISH WELLS CLUB
1 BRAMS POINT ROAD
TMS # R510-010-000-046F-0000
EUGENE DRIVE(30' PRIVATE R/W)
N/F
CURTIS WILLIAMS
6 SNIDER WALK
TMS # R510-010-000-036B-0000
DB 3100, PG 2228
DRAINAGE & UTILITY RESERVE
EASEMENT AREA
AREA: 4,360 SQ FT, 0.100 ACRES
4' CHAIN LINK FENCE
GATE
7' CHAIN LINK FENCE
7' CHAIN LINK FENCE
1-STORY
WOOD HOUSE
1-STORY
DILAPIDATED
WOOD HOUSE
1-STORYDILAPIDATEDWOOD HOUSE
MOBILE HOME
SHED
WOOD SHED
5' CHAIN LINK FENCE
6' WOOD FENCE
3' WOOD FENCE
7' WOOD FENCE
6' WOOD FENCE
7' WOOD FENCE
6' WOOD FENCE
PUMP
STATION W/
6' METAL
FENCE
DIRT DRIVE
DIRT DRIVE
GARDEN
6' WOOD FENCE
6' WOOD FENCE
4' METAL FENCE
7' WOOD FENCE
DECK
SAND PILE
DOG HOUSE W/ 6'
CHAIN LINK FENCE
SATELLITE DISH
STILL RUN RAMBLE
(30' PRIVATE R/W)
LITTLE GARDEN PATH
(25' PRIVATE R/W)
25' ACCESSEASEMENT
10' UTILITY EASEMENT
10' UTILITY EASEMENT
30' ACCESS
EASEMENT
33' PARK EASEMENT
33' PARK EASEMENT
20' BUFFER
20' BUFFER
20' BUFFER
BRYANT ROAD
(PRIVATE R/W VARIES)
N13°19'33"W
556.59'
N65°34'34"E 590.28'
S15°31'24"E 502.42'
S60°58'49"W 621.68'
N15°31'24"W 457.99'
188.10'
103.31'
S11°25'21"E 426.27'
S60°59'07"W 266.80'
S87°19'26"W 257.31'
N60°59'07"E 266.80'
S11°25'21"E 119.77'
66.31'
170.00'
60.00'
60.00'
25.55'
34.45'
60.00'
77.41'
2.88'
44.43'
183.16'
274.84'
2.0'
7' CHAIN LINK FENCE
7' CHAIN LINK FENCE
130.17'
130.99'
141.52'
219.00'
TRACT 1
TRACT 2
TRACT 3
2" OTPF POSSIBLY
DISTURBED. LOCATION
DOES NOT COINCIDE
WITH WITH ALL OTHER
CORNERS FOUND ON
THE THREE TRACTS
AND ADJOINERS
5/8" RBS
N: 128929.20
E: 2071814.15
POB TRACT 2
POC TRACT 1 & 3
5/8" RBS
MOVEABLE CONEX CONTAINER
5/8" RBS
TIE: S11°25'21"E
137.12' (GRND)
TIE: S18°13'36"E 93.75' (GRND)
TIE: S12°26'49"E 100.46' (GRND)
N68°40'53"E 291.41'
TELEPHONE: (843) 459-7894
CHARLESTON SC, 29492
454 DEANNA LANE SUITE A
SOUTH CAROLINA FIRM COA NUMBER: 453
www.mckimcreed.com
BOUNDARY SURVEY
PREPARED FOR
THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
SURVEY OF
SPANISH GROVE SUBDIVISION & 54 MUDDY CREEK ROAD
BRYANT ROAD, HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, 29926
JUNE 2, 2023
DWG
VICINITY MAP - NOT TO SCALE
SITE
SHEET 1 OF 2
NOTES
1. FIELD SURVEY COMPLETION DATE: MAY 30, 2023.
2. ALL DISTANCES ARE HORIZONTAL GROUND IN INTERNATIONAL FEET.
3. HORIZONTAL BEARINGS BASED ON SC GRID NAD83/2011. VERTICAL BASED ON NAVD88.
4. REFERENCES: AS SHOWN ON MAP.
5. THIS SURVEY IS NOT INTENDED TO EXPRESS AN OPINION REGARDING OWNERSHIP OR
TITLE.
6. THE WORD CERTIFY IS UNDERSTOOD TO BE AN EXPRESSION OF PROFESSIONAL
JUDGEMENT BY THE SURVEYOR, WHICH IS BASED ON HIS BEST KNOWLEDGE,
INFORMATION AND BELIEF.
7. SUBSURFACE AND ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS WERE NOT EXAMINED OR CONSIDERED
AS A PART OF THIS SURVEY. NO STATEMENT IS MADE CONCERNING THE EXISTENCE OF
UNDERGROUND OR OVERHEAD CONTAINERS OR FACILITIES THAT MAY AFFECT THE USE
OR DEVELOPMENT OF THIS TRACT.
8. THE EXISTENCE OR NONEXISTENCE OF WETLANDS ON SUBJECT PROPERTY HAS NOT BEEN
DETERMINED BY THIS SURVEY.
9. SUBJECT TO ALL EASEMENTS, RIGHT OF WAYS, AND OR ENCUMBRANCES THAT MAY
EFFECT THIS PROPERTY.
10.
ALL INFORMATION SHOWN OUTSIDE OF PROPERTY LINES ARE FOR ILLUSTRATIVE
PURPOSES ONLY AND HAVE NOT BEEN LOCATED.
11. THIS PROPERTY IS LOCATED IN FLOOD ZONE "X" AS INDICATED ON FLOOD INSURANCE
RATE MAP COMMUNITY PANEL NO. 45013C 0434G & 45013C 0442G, DATED MARCH 23, 2021,
PER FEMA.GOV.
12. ROAD R/W AND LOTS SHOWN ON TRACT 3 ARE SHOWN PER THE REFERENCE PLAT OF
SPANISH GROVE SUBDIVISION AND CURRENT GIS MAPPING. BUILDING FOOTPRINT,
PAVEMENT LIMITS, OPEN SPACE POND, ETC. ARE SHOWN PER THE DATE OF THE FIELD
SURVEY.
LEGEND
GROSS LAND AREA
PARCELAREA (SQ FT, AC)
SPANISH GROVE SUBDIVISION
(TRACT 3)313,063 SQ. FT., 7.186 AC
TMS # R510-010-000-0034-0000
(TRACT 2)15,229 SQ. FT., 0.350 AC
TMS # R510-010-000-0035-0000
(TRACT 1)120,595 SQ. FT., 2.768 AC
PLAT SHOWING THE ADJUSTED LINES BETWEEN
THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
AND
THE EUGENE WILLIAMS FAMILY
BRYANT ROAD & MUDDY CREEK ROAD, HILTON HEAD ISLAND,
BEAUFORT COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA, 29926
OCTOBER 25, 2023
ZONING VERIFICATION
BASE ZONING: RM-4 - LOW TO MODERATE DENSITY RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT
SOURCE: HILTON HEAD ISLAND ZONING DISTRICTS GIS MAP & HILTON
HEAD ISLAND CODE OF ORDINANCES.
Preliminary
10/31/2023 7:39:40 AM
Attachment 8
Page 55 of 92
TELEPHONE: (843) 459-7894
CHARLESTON SC, 29492
454 DEANNA LANE SUITE A
SOUTH CAROLINA FIRM COA NUMBER: 453
www.mckimcreed.com
BOUNDARY SURVEY
PREPARED FOR
THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
SURVEY OF
SPANISH GROVE SUBDIVISION & 54 MUDDY CREEK ROAD
BRYANT ROAD, HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, 29926
JUNE 2, 2023
DWG
VICINITY MAP - NOT TO SCALE
SITE
SHEET 2 OF 2
TRACT 1
TMS# R510-010-000-0035-0000
ALL THAT CERTAIN PARCEL OF LAND LYING ON THE WESTERLY LINE OF MUDDY
CREEK ROAD, IN THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, BEAUFORT COUNTY, SOUTH
CAROLINA, KNOWN AS LAND NOW OR FORMERLY OF EUGENE WILLIAMS, JR. AND
SHOWN ON PLAT BOOK __ PG __ AS RECORDED IN BEAUFORT COUNTY REGISTER
OF DEEDS ON _____________, AND BEING MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS
FOLLOWS:
COMMENCING AT A 5/8” REBAR SET AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER TRACT 2 AS
SHOWN ON SAID PLAT; ALSO, BEING THE NORTHEASTERLY CORNER OF LAND NOW
OR FORMERLY GONZALO LOPEZ AGUILAR (DB 3328 PG 3173), SAID POINT HAVING
SCSPC N 128929.20, E. 2071814.15 AND THE WESTERLY LINE OF MUDDY CREEK
ROAD (40' PUBLIC ROW); THENCE ALONG MUDDY CREEK ROAD N.11°25'21”W 546.04'
TO 2'X2' CONCRETE MONUMENT AND THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF LAND NOW OR
FORMERLY OF MARIA DEL CARMEN & SOTO VEGA (DB 4135 PG 1329) , HAVING
SCSPC N.129464.42, E. 2071706.02, THE TRUE POINT OR PLACE OF BEGINNING,
RUNNING THENCE ALONG MUDDY CREEK ROAD S.11°25'21”E 426.27' TO A 5/8”
REBAR SET AT THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF TRACT 2 AS SHOWN ON SAID PLAT
AND ALSO THE NORTHERLY LINE OF LAND OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND;
THENCE ALONG THE LINE OF TRACT 2 S. 60°59'07”W. 266.80' TO A COMPUTED POINT
REFERENCED BY AN OLD IRON PIPE 2.0' SOUTHWEST OF SAID CORNER, AND BEING
THE SOUTHEASTERLY CORNER OF THE FORMER SPANISH GROVE SUBDIVISION (PB
64 PG 95) NOW LAND OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND; THENCE
N.15°31'24”W. 457.99' ALONG THE EASTERLY LINE OF SAID SUBDIVISION AND THE
WESTERLY OF LAND NOW OR FORMERLY EUGENE WILLIAMS TO A 5/8” REBAR SET
AT THE NORTH WEST CORNER OF TRACT 1 AND THE SOUTHWESTERLY CORNER
OF LAND NOW OR FORMERLY OF CAROLYN DEBARR; RUNNING THENCE ALONG
THE NORTH LINE OF TRACT 1 AND SOUTHERLY LINE OF THE LAND NOW OR
FORMERLY OF CAROLYN DEBARR AND NOW OR FORMERLY MARIA DEL CARMEN
SOTO VEGA N.68°40'53”E. 291.41' TO THE POINT OR PLACE OF BEGINNING.
CONTAINING 120595 SQ FT, 2.768 ACRES
TRACT 2
TMS# R510-010-000-0034-0000
ALL THAT CERTAIN PARCEL OF LAND LYING ON THE WESTERLY LINE OF MUDDY
CREEK ROAD, IN THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, BEAUFORT COUNTY, SOUTH
CAROLINA, KNOWN AS LAND NOW OR FORMERLY OF EUGENE WILLIAMS, JR. AND
SHOWN ON PLAT BOOK __ PG __ AS RECORDED IN BEAUFORT COUNTY REGISTER
OF DEEDS ON _____________, AND BEING MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS
FOLLOWS:
BEGINNING AT A 5/8” SET AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER TRACT 2 AS SHOWN ON
SAID PLAT; ALSO, BEING THE NORTHEASTERLY CORNER OF LAND NOW OR
FORMERLY GONZALO LOPEZ AGUILAR (DB 3328 PG 3173), SAID POINT HAVING
SCSPC N 128929.20, E. 2071814.15 AND THE WESTERLY LINE OF MUDDY CREEK
ROAD (40' PUBLIC ROW);
THENCE ALONG THE LINE OF TRACT 2 AND LAND NOW OR FORMERLY GONZALO
LOPEZ AGUILAR S.87°19'26” W. 257.31' TO A COMPUTED POINT MARKED BY AN OLD
IRON PIPE 2.0 SOUTHWEST OF SAID CORNER, AND BEING THE SOUTHEASTERY
CORNER OF THE FORMER SPANISH GROVE SUBDIVISION (PB 64 PG 95) NOW LAND
OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND; RUNNING THENCE ALONG THE
SOUTHERLY LINE OF TRACT 1 N.60°59'07”E. 266.80' TO A 5/8” REBAR SET ON THE
WESTERLY LINE OF MUDDY CREEK ROAD; THENCE S. 11°25'21”E. 119.77' TO THE
POINT OR PLACE OF BEGINNING.
CONTAINING 15229 SQ FT, 0.350 ACRES
TRACT 3
FORMER SPANISH GROVE SUBDIVISION
ALL THAT CERTAIN PARCEL OF LAND LYING WEST OF MUDDY CREEK ROAD, IN THE
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, BEAUFORT COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA, KNOWN
AS THE FORMER SPANISH GROVE SUBDIVISION (PB 64 PG 95) AND SHOWN ON PLAT
BOOK __ PG __ AS RECORDED IN BEAUFORT COUNTY REGISTER OF DEEDS ON
_____________, AND BEING MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:
COMMENCING AT A 5/8” SET AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER TRACT 2 AS SHOWN ON
SAID PLAT; ALSO, BEING THE NORTHEASTERLY CORNER OF LAND NOW OR
FORMERLY GONZALO LOPEZ AGUILAR (DB 3328 PG 3173), SAID POINT HAVING
SCSPC N 128929.20, E. 2071814.15 AND THE WESTERLY LINE OF MUDDY CREEK
ROAD (40' PUBLIC ROW); THENCE ALONG THE SOUTHERLY LINE OF TRACT 2 AND
LAND NOW OR FORMERLY GONZALO LOPEZ AGUILAR S.87°19'26” W. 257.31' TO A
COMPUTED POINT MARKED BY AN OLD IRON PIPE 2.0 SOUTHWEST OF SAID
CORNER, AND BEING THE SOUTHEASTERY CORNER OF THE FORMER SPANISH
GROVE SUBDIVISION (PB 64 PG 95) NOW LAND OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD
ISLAND; THENCE N.15°31'24”W. 502.42' ALONG THE EASTERLY LINE OF SAID
SUBDIVISION AND THE WESTERLY OF LAND NOW OR FORMERLY EUGENE WILLIAMS
TO A PK FOUND AT THE NORTH EAST CORNER OF THE SPANISH GROVE
SUBDIVISION ,HAVING SCSPC N. 129401.28', E. 2071422.66' THE POINT OR PLACE OF
BEGINNING;
RUNNING THENCE S.15°31'24”E. 502.42' TO A COMPUTED POINT MARKED BY AN OLD
IRON PIPE 2.0 SOUTHWEST OF SAID CORNER, AND BEING THE SOUTHEASTERY
CORNER OF THE FORMER SPANISH GROVE SUBDIVISION (PB 64 PG 95); THENCE
ALONG THE SOUTHERLY LINE OF THE SPANISH GROVE SUBDIVISION, THROUGH A
SERIES OF MONUMENTS MARKING THE SOUTHERLY ADJOINERS PARCELS
S.60°58'49”W. 621.68' TO 2” OPEN TOP PIPE THE SOUTHWESTERLY CORNER OF SAID
SUBDIVISION; THENCE N. 13°19'33”W. ALONG THE WESTERLY LINE OF THE
SUBDIVISION 556.59' TO 2”X 2” CONCRETE MONUMENT THE NORTHWESTERLY
CORNER OF THE SPANISH GROVE SUBDIVISION; THENCE ALONG THE NORTHERLY
LINE OF THE SUBDIVISION N.65°34'34”E. 590.28' TO THE POINT OR PLACE OF
BEGINNING.
CONTAINING 313063 SQ FT, 7.187 ACRES
GROSS LAND AREA
PARCELAREA (SQ FT, AC)
SPANISH GROVE SUBDIVISION
(TRACT 3)313,063 SQ. FT., 7.186 AC
TMS # R510-010-000-0034-0000
(TRACT 2)15,229 SQ. FT., 0.350 AC
TMS # R510-010-000-0035-0000
(TRACT 1)120,595 SQ. FT., 2.768 AC
PLAT SHOWING THE ADJUSTED LINES BETWEEN
THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
AND
THE EUGENE WILLIAMS FAMILY
BRYANT ROAD & MUDDY CREEK ROAD, HILTON HEAD ISLAND,
BEAUFORT COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA, 29926
OCTOBER 25, 2023
Preliminary
10/31/2023 7:39:46 AM
Page 56 of 92
EXHIBIT “B” TO ORDINANCE 2024-____
Page 57 of 92
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) QUIT CLAIM DEED
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
Know All Persons by These Presents, that The Town of Hilton Head Island, South
Carolina, in the State aforesaid and in consideration of the sum of Ten and no/100 ($10.00)
Dollars, to them in hand paid at and before the execution, sealing and delivery of these
presents, by Eugene Williams, having an address of 54 Muddy Creek Road, Hilton Head
Island, SC, 29926, in the State aforesaid, the receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged,
subject to the easements, restrictions, and conditions set forth in the legal description
below, have granted, bargained, released and quit claimed, and by these Presents does
grant, bargain, release and quit claim to Eugene Williams, his heirs and assigns, forever the
following property:
All that certain piece, parcel or lot of land lying and being on Hilton Head
Island, Beaufort County, South Carolina, which is shown and described as
“Tract 1”, on a plat titled “Plat Showing the Adjusted Lines between the Town
of Hilton Head Island and the Eugene Williams Family,” dated October 25,
2023, prepared by McKim & Creed, Raymond B. Dawber, SCPLS 24270,
which is recorded in the Office of the Register of Deeds for Beaufort County,
South Carolina, in Plat Book ___ at Page ___.
Page 1 of 3
Page 58 of 92
This conveyance is made subject to all applicable covenants, conditions,
limitations, easements, affirmative obligations, etc., recorded in the Office of
the Register of Deeds for Beaufort County, South Carolina.
This being a part of the same property conveyed to The Town of Hilton Head
Island, South Carolina, by Deed recorded in the Office of the Register of
Deeds for Beaufort County, South Carolina, in Official Record Book 829 at
Page 349;
This Deed was prepared in the law office of Coltrane & Wilkins, LLC, Post
Office Box 6808, Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, 29938, by Curtis L.
Coltrane.
A Part of TMS# R 510 010 000 0034 0000
Together with all and singular, the Rights, Members, Hereditaments and
Appurtenances to the said Premises belonging, or in anywise incident or appertaining.
To Have and to Hold, all and singular, the said Premises before mentioned to Eugene
Williams, his heirs and assigns forever.
Page 2 of 3
Page 59 of 92
Witness the hand and seal of the duly authorized officers of The Town of Hilton
Head Island, South Carolina on this ___ day of July, 2024.
WITNESSES: THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD
ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA
Alan R. Perry, Mayor
Marc A. Orlando, Town Manager
STATE OF SOUTH CAROINA )
) UNIFORM ACKNOWLEDGMENT
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
The undersigned Notary Public does hereby certify that Alan R. Perry and Marc A.
Orlando, the duly authorized Mayor and Town Manager of The Town of Hilton Head
Island, South Carolina, personally appeared before me this day and acknowledged the due
execution of this Quit Claim Deed.
Sworn to before me on this ____
Day of July, 2024.
Notary Public for South Carolina
My Commission Expires:
Page 3 of 3
Page 60 of 92
EXHIBIT “C” TO ORDINANCE 2024-____
Page 61 of 92
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) QUIT CLAIM DEED
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
Know All Persons by These Presents, that Eugene Williams, in the State aforesaid
and in consideration of the sum of Ten and no/100 ($10.00) Dollars, to them in hand paid
at and before the execution, sealing and delivery of these presents, by The Town of Hilton
Head Island, South Carolina, having an address of One Town Center Court, Hilton Head
Island, SC, 29928, in the State aforesaid, the receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged,
subject to the easements, restrictions, and conditions set forth in the legal description
below, have granted, bargained, released and quit claimed, and by these Presents does
grant, bargain, release and quit claim to The Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina
and its successors and assigns, forever the following property:
All that certain piece, parcel or lot of land lying and being on Hilton Head
Island, Beaufort County, South Carolina, which is shown and described as
“Tract 2” and “Tract 3” on a plat titled “Plat Showing the Adjusted Lines
between the Town of Hilton Head Island and the Eugene Williams Family,”
dated October 25, 2023, prepared by McKim & Creed, Raymond B. Dawber,
SCPLS 24270, which is recorded in the Office of the Register of Deeds for
Beaufort County, South Carolina, in Plat Book ___ at Page ___.
Page 1 of 3
Page 62 of 92
This conveyance is made subject to all applicable covenants, conditions,
limitations, easements, affirmative obligations, etc., recorded in the Office of
the Register of Deeds for Beaufort County, South Carolina.
This being a part of the same property conveyed to Eugene Williams, by Deed
recorded in the Office of the Register of Deeds for Beaufort County, South
Carolina, in Official Record Book 2788 at Page 1746.
This Deed was prepared in the law office of Coltrane & Wilkins, LLC, Post
Office Box 6808, Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, 29938, by Curtis L.
Coltrane.
A Part of TMS# R 510 010 000 0035 0000
Together with all and singular, the Rights, Members, Hereditaments and
Appurtenances to the said Premises belonging, or in anywise incident or appertaining.
To Have and to Hold, all and singular, the said Premises before mentioned to The
Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, its successors and assigns forever.
Page 2 of 3
Page 63 of 92
Witness the hand and seal of Eugene Williams on this ___ day of July, 2024.
WITNESSES:
Eugene Williams
STATE OF SOUTH CAROINA )
) UNIFORM ACKNOWLEDGMENT
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
The undersigned Notary Public does hereby certify that Eugene Williams personally
appeared before me this day and acknowledged the due execution of this Quit Claim Deed.
Sworn to before me on this ____
Day of July, 2024.
Notary Public for South Carolina
My Commission Expires:
Page 3 of 3
Page 64 of 92
EXHIBIT “D” TO ORDINANCE 2024-____
Page 65 of 92
Page 1 of 6
______________________________________________________
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) PERMANENT STORM WATER
) DRAINAGE EASEMENT
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT ) AGREEMENT
This Permanent Stormwater Drainage Easement Agreement (hereinafter the
“Agreement”) is made this ___ Day of July, 2024, by and between Eugene Williams and
the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina.
Whereas, the Town has planned and desires to undertake drainage work which
involves drainage improvements, ongoing maintenance, and related work thereto, on a
storm and surface water drainage ditch that crosses the property of Eugne Williams as
further described in this Agreement which work is for the benefit and use property in the
vicinity of Muddy Creek Road including that of Eugene Williams; and,
Whereas, Eugene Williams has agreed to convey to the Town of Hilton Head
Island, South Carolina, a permanent storm water drainage easement for access and for
the improvement, maintenance and use of the aforementioned storm and surface water
drainage ditch, subject to the terms and conditions set forth herein.
Now, Therefore, know all men by these presents, Eugene Williams , for and in
consideration of the sum of Twenty Seven Thou sand Nine Hundred Fo ur and 00/100
Dollar ($ 27,904.00) and no other valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency
whereof is acknowledged, has bargained, granted, and sold and by these presents does
Page 66 of 92
Page 2 of 6
hereby bargain, grant, and sell to the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina , its
successors and assigns, a perpetual, non -exclusive easement on, under, over and across
that portion of Eugene Williams’ property, which is described as follows:
All that certain piece, parcel or lot of land lying and being on Hilton Head
Island, Beaufort County, South Carolina, which is shown and described as
“Drainage & Utility Reserve Easement Area: 4,360 SQ FT, o.100 Acres”, on
a plat titled “Plat Showing the Adjusted Lines between the Town of Hilton
Head Island and the Eugene Williams Family,” dated October 25, 2023,
prepared by McKim & Creed, Raymond B. Dawber, SCPLS 24270, which is
recorded in the Office of the Register of Deeds for Beaufort County, South
Carolina, in Plat Book ___ at Page ___.
A portion of Beaufort County Property ID (R510 010 000 0035 0000).
(herein, the “Easement Property”).
The Easement granted herein is for the purpose of improving , maintaining, and
using the Easement Property for the collection, conveyance and drainage of surface and
storm water runoff. Eugene Williams further grants to the Town a perpetual, non -
exclusive easement for the purpose of draining storm and surface water runoff through
the storm and surface water drainage ditch in Easement Property pursuant to this
Agreement. Eugene Williams further grants to the Town an easement for access, ingress
and egress over property owned by Eugene Williams for access to and from the Easement
Property in connection with the performance of work in accordance with the terms of this
Agreement.
This Agreement is granted and accepted subject to the following terms:
1. This Agreement is entered into subject to all other easements, licenses, and
conveyances of record and is subject to the rights herein reserved by Eugene Williams and
his heirs and assigns, to utilize the Easement Property at any time, in any manner, and
for any purpose, provided, however, that such use by Eugene Williams shall not be
Page 67 of 92
Page 3 of 6
inconsistent with nor prevent the full utilization by the Town of Hilton Head Island, South
Carolina, of the rights and privileges granted herein.
2. Eugene Williams shall erect no permanent structure of any kind on, over or
across the Easement Property, including but not limited to buildings, sheds, walls, or any
other structures. Eugene Williams shall not impede, obstruct, or allow to be obstructed,
the natural flow of storm and/or surface water through the Easement Property.
3. The Town agrees to plan the improvements and maintenance of and to the
storm and surface water drainage ditch in the Easement Property, and further agrees that
the improvements to, maintenance of, use of, and access to, the storm and surface water
drainage ditch in the Easement Property shall be under the exclusive control of the Town,
and that the Town shall at all times comply with all applicable laws, rules, codes, and
regulations.
4. From the date of t his Agreement, the Town of Hilton Head Island, South
Carolina, shall, at its sole cost and expense, cause all timely clearing of natural debris,
repair, renovation, and all other improvements in general to the storm and surface water
drainage ditch and the Easement Property as shall be or shall become necessary and/or
prudent in the discretion of the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina.
5. The Town agrees to cause all work contemplated hereunder to be performed
in a workmanlike fashion with minimal interference to Eugene Willams and his assigns,
invitees, guests, licensees, and agents. The Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina,
further agrees to cause the work contemplated hereunder to be completed in an
expeditious and timely fashion, that the storm and surface water drainage ditch and the
Easement Property shall at all times be maintained in a safe condition, and that all debris
and construction materials relating to work undertaken by the Town of Hilton Head
Page 68 of 92
Page 4 of 6
Island, South Carolina, pursuant to the rights granted hereunder shall be promptly
removed.
6. With the exception of any permanent improvements to be made in and to
the storm and surface water drainage ditch and the Easement Property pursuant to
completion of work performed in accordance with this Agreement, the Town agrees to
restore the Easement Property to its pre- existing condition including the removal of all
equipment, materials, litter, debris, etc. upon conclusion of any work.
7. The Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, hereby warrants to
Eugene Williams that the granting of the Easements described in this Agreement will not
affect “set back” lines under The Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina ’s
jurisdiction on the of Eugene Williams.
8. Eugene Williams represents and warrants that it has full authority to
execute, deliver and perform this Agreement.
To have and to hold, all and singular, the rights, privileges, and easements
aforesaid unto the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina , its successors, and
assigns, forever.
Page 69 of 92
Page 5 of 6
In Witness whereof Eugene Williams has executed and delivered this Permanent
Stormwater Drainage Easement Agreement on this ___ day of July, 2024.
WITNESSES:
By:
Eugene Williams
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) UNIFORM ACKNOWLEDGMENT
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
I, the undersigned Notary Public do hereby certify that Eugene Williams personally
appeared before me on this day and duly acknowledged the execution of this Permanent
Stormwater Drainage Easement Agreement.
Sworn to and Subscribed before me
this ___ Day of July, 2024.
Notary Public for South Carolina
My Commission Expires:
Page 70 of 92
Page 6 of 6
In Witness whereof, The Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, by and
through Alan R. Perry and Marc A. Orlando, its duly authorized Mayor and Town
Manager has executed and delivered this Permanent Stormwater Drainage Easement
Agreement on this ___ day of July, 2024
WITNESSES: THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND,
SOUTH CAROLINA
By:
Alan R. Perry, Mayor
Attest:
Marc A. Orlando, Manager
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) UNIFORM ACKNOWLEDGMENT
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
I, the undersigned Notary Public do hereby certify that Alan R. Per ry, Mayor, and
Marc A. Orlando, Town Manager, personally appeared before me on this day and duly
acknowledged the execution of this Permanent Stormwater Drainage Easement
Agreement.
Sworn to and Subscribed before me
This ___ Day of July, 2024.
Notary Public for South Carolina
My Commission Expires:
Page 71 of 92
Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex
One Town Center Court Hilton Head Island South Carolina 29928
www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
Town Council
TO: Town Council
FROM: Karla Vincent, PE, Senior Project Engineer
VIA: Marc Orlando, Town Manager
Curtis Coltrane, Town Attorney
Bryan McIlwee, PE, Director of Engineering
Shawn Colin, AICP, Assistant Town Manager
DATE: July 23, 2024
SUBJECT: Consideration of a Resolution Authorizing the Acceptance of a
Donated Right-of-Way and Corresponding Pathway Easement for
Property Located at 272 Mitchelville Road
Recommendation:
Consideration of a Resolution Authorizing the Acceptance of a Donated Right-of-Way
and Corresponding Pathway Easement for Property Located at 272 Mitchelville Road.
Background:
The Town has been pursuing right of way donations along the private, westerly, dead-
end segment of Mitchelville Road since 2016 under the Town’s private Dirt Road Paving
Program.
The Program affords a means for private road owners to each donate necessary rights of
way to the Town to create a public road right of way, which shall then be improved
(pavement and storm drainage construction) and perpetually maintained by the Town. All
property owners required to donate rights to the existing private right of way along this
segment of Mitchelville Road agreed to donate the necessary land rights, except for one
property owner.
In 2011, the Town and County jointly purchased two parcels of land (R510 004 000 0007
0000 which is 5.2 acres and R510 004 000 0007 0000 which is 8.0 acres). It is in the
Town and County’s best interest to provide public road access to these publicly owned
lands.
At the January 9, 2018 meeting, Town Council voted unanimously to approve the five key
policy issues for staff to move forward in pursuit of public road rights of way on qualifying
private unpaved roads as outlined below:
Page 72 of 92
Page 2 of 2
1. To qualify for this program, the road must serve more than 5 dwellings/address
points.
a. If a private unpaved road serving 5 dwellings or less, lying within a low-
moderate income area, that emergency responders have deemed
impassable, and there is 100% participation amongst all affected property
owners to donate a public road right of way to the Town, staff shall bring
that road before the Public Facilities Committee and Town Council as an
exception to the policy and for consideration of dedication and acceptance.
2. Property owners must express interest in public road right of way assemblage
(100% willing participation).
3. Land for the public road right of way must be donated to the Town.
4. Condemn land only as necessary due to unclear title issues (i.e., heirs’ property).
5. Community volunteers may assist staff with facilitating right of way donations.
At the August 14, 2018 meeting, Town Council unanimously approved a recommendation
from the Public Facilities Committee to direct Town staff to pursue the acquisition of public
road rights of way on the unpaved private road Mitchelville Road.
At the July 27, 2020 meeting, the Community Service and Public Safety Committee
unanimously approved a motion that the Town move forward with acquisition of
Mitchelville Road as part of the dirt road paving program.
The donation of right of way and easement on parcel
R510 004 000 0307 0000 is the last
remaining donation of land rights to the Town for the necessary public right of way.
Summary:
The primary objective of the Dirt Road Paving Program is to accept donations of public
road rights-of-way on qualifying private unpaved roads with a goal to provide publicly
maintained infrastructure within these rights -of-way. These acquisitions are prioritized
based on a rating scheme which emphasizes public safety, the condition of the road, and
the number of dwellings served. Town Council budgeted funds this fiscal year for both
design and acquisition purposes. The acquisition funds shall include survey and legal
costs necessary for acquisitions and are not intended for compensation to property
owners.
Attachments:
1. Resolution
2. Right-of-Way and Easement Plat
Page 73 of 92
A RESOLUTION OF THE TOWN COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF HILTON
HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, UNDER THE AUTHORITY OF S. C.
CODE ANN. § 28-2-10, ET SEQ. (SUPP. 2024), AND § 16-5-105(D)(5),
MUNICIPAL CODE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH
CAROLINA (1983), AUTHORIZING ACCEPTANCE OF PROPERTY FOR A
PUBLIC RIGHT OF WAY FOR A ROADWAY KNOWN AS “MITCHELVILLE
LANE,” AND A PATHWAY EASEMENT.
WHEREAS, on August 18, 2020, The Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina,
adopted Resolution 2020-16, authorizing the acquisition of a parcel of real property that
is occupied by an unpaved roadway known as “Mitchelville Lane”; and,
WHEREAS, Resolution 2020-16 was adopted by The Town of Hilton Head Island,
South Carolina, under S. C. Code Ann. § 28-2-70 (Supp. 2024); and,
WHEREAS, Moshe Dekel, a landowner abutting the roadway parcel has agreed to
convey a parcel of property to The Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, of 0.161
acres, more or less, for road right of way for “Mitchelville Lane,” and a pathway easement
of 0.023 acres; and,
WHEREAS, The Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, determines that it
is in the best interests of The Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina and its citizens
and residents to accept the conveyance of 0.161 acres, more or less, for road right of way
for “Mitchelville Lane,” and a pathway easement of 0.023 acres, as a donation under § 16-5-
105(D)(5), Municipal Code of The Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina (1983).
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE TOWN COUNCIL OF
THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, AND IT HEREBY
IS RESOLVED BY THE AUTHORITY OF THE SAID COUNCIL:
1. The Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, is authorized to accept the
conveyance of 0.161 acres, more or less, for road right of way for “Mitchelville Lane,” and
a pathway easement of 0.023 acres as a donation from Moshe Dekel under § 16-5-
Page 1 of 2
ATTACHMENT 1
Page 74 of 92
105(D)(5), Municipal Code of The Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina (1983.
2. The Mayor and Town Manager are authorized to accept the conveyance of the road
right of way parcel and the pathway easement in a form and substance similar to the
documents attached hereto as Exhibits “A” and “B,” and to take all other and further actions
as may be necessary to complete the transaction described in this Resolution.
MOVED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED THIS ____ DAY OF JULY, 2024.
Alan R. Perry, Mayor
ATTEST:
By:
Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
Curtis L. Coltrane
Page 2 of 2
Page 75 of 92
EXHIBIT “A” TO RESOLUTION REGARDING ACCEPTANCE OF QUIT CLAIM DEED
AND PATHWAY EASEMENT FROM MOSHE DEKEL FOR MITCHELVILLE LANE
Page 76 of 92
Page 1 of 3
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) QUIT CLAIM DEED
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
Know All Men by These Presents, that Moshe Dekel (the “Grantor”), in the State
aforesaid and in consideration of the sum of One and no/100 ($1.00) Dollars, actual
consideration, to him in hand paid at and before the execution, sealing , and delivery of
these Presents, by The Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina (the “Town”), having
an address of One Town Center Court, Hilton Head Island, SC, 29928, in the State
aforesaid, the receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, and as a donation by the Grantor
to the Town under the Town’s Dirt Road Paving Program , subject to the easements,
restrictions, and conditions set forth in the legal description below, has quit -claimed,
bargained, sold, and released, and by these Presents does quit -claim, bargain, sell , and
release to the Town, its successors and assigns, forever, all his right, title and interest in
and to the following property:
Page 77 of 92
Page 2 of 3
All that certain piece or parcel of land shown and described as “Proposed
Town of Hilton Head Island Public Road 50’ R/W 0.161 AC. (6,998 SF.)” on
a Plat titled “A Right of Way Plat of Mitchelville Road, Hilton Head Island,
Beaufort County, South Carolina” prepared by Nandina, d/b/a Sea Island
Land Survey, dated April 28, 2023, last revised January 31, 2024, certified
by Justin R. Kesselring, SCPLS 29901, which is recorded in the Office of the
Register of Deeds for Beaufort County, South Carolina, in Plat Book ___ at
Page ___.
This Quit-Claim Deed was prepared in the law office of Coltrane & Wilkins,
LLC, Post Office Box 6808, Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, 29938, by
Curtis L. Coltrane.
A Part of TMS# R510 004 000 0307 0000
Together with all and singular, the Rights, Members, Hereditaments and
Appurtenances to the said Premises belonging, or in anywise incident or appertaining.
To Have and to Hold, all and singular, the said Premises before mentioned to the
Town, its successors and assigns, forever.
Page 78 of 92
Page 3 of 3
Witness the hand and seal of Moshe Dekel on this ___ day of July, 2024.
WITNESSES:
____________________________ ________________________(L.S.)
Moshe Dekel
____________________________
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) UNIFORM ACKNOWLEDGMENT
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
The undersigned Notary Public does hereby certify that Moshe Dekel personally
appeared before me this day and acknowledged the due execution of this Quit -Claim
Deed.
Sworn to before me on this ____
Day of July, 2024.
____________________________________
Notary Public for South Carolina
My Commission Expires:
Page 79 of 92
EXHIBIT “B” TO RESOLUTION REGARDING ACCEPTANCE OF QUIT CLAIM DEED
AND PATHWAY EASEMENT FROM MOSHE DEKEL FOR MITCHELVILLE LANE
Page 80 of 92
Page 1 of 6
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) PATHWAY EASEMENT
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
This Pathway Easement is made and accepted this ____ day of July , 2024, by
and between Moshe Dekel (the “Grantor”), whose address is 272 Mitchelville Road,
Hilton Head Island, SC 29926, and The Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina,
having an address of One Town Center Court, Hilton Head Island, South Carolina 29928,
(hereinafter, the "Town").
WHEREAS, the Town has planned and desires to lay out and build a paved
pathway for pedestrian and bicycle travel, a part of which will lie on the property which is
described below, with the paved pathway being for the use and benefit of the general
public; and,
WHEREAS, the Grantor is the owner of real property on which a part of the paved
pathway will be located; and,
WHEREAS, the Town desires to acquire from the Grantor a permanent easement
for the construction and maintenance of the paved pathway by the Town, and use of the
paved pathway by the general public, subject to the terms and conditions set forth herein.
Page 81 of 92
Page 2 of 6
NOW, THEREFORE, know all men by these presents that the Grantor, for and in
consideration of the sum of Ten and no/100 ($10.00) Dollars, the receipt and sufficiency
whereof is acknowledged, has bargained, granted, and sold and by these presents does
hereby bargain, grant, and sell to the Town, its successors and assign s, a perpetual, non-
exclusive easement to plan, lay out, build, maintain and use a paved pathway and any
necessary lighting and associated electrical equipment for pedestrian and bicycle trave l,
with said pathway to be utilized by the general public, on, over and across that portion of
the Grantor’s property which is described as follows:
All that certain piece, parcel or parcel consisting of .023 acres, shown and
described as “Permanent Pathway Easement & Proposed Easement 2’ Off of
Right of Way 0.023 Ac. (1,042) ” on a Plat titled “A Right of Way Plat of
Mitchelville Road, Hilton Head Island, Beaufort County, South Carolina”
prepared by Nandina, d/b/a Sea Island Land Survey, dated April 28, 2020,
last revised January 31, 2024, certified by Justin R. Kesselring, SC PLS
29901, which is recorded in the Office of the Register of Deeds for Beaufort
County, South Carolina, in Plat Book ___ at Page ___ (hereinafter, the
“Easement Property”).
This easement is granted by the Grantor and accepted by the Town subject to the
following terms:
1. This easement is conveyed subject to all covenants, conditions, restrictions,
easements, licenses, mortgages, liens, encumbrances, reservations , and conveyances of
record, to all matters shown on the above -referenced plat depicting the Easement
Property, and to all matters that would be revealed by an accurate survey and inspection
of the Easement Property, and is subject to the rights herein reserved by the Grantor and
its successors and assigns, to utilize the Grantor ’s property at any time, in any man ner,
and for any purpose, provided, however, that such use by the Grantor shall not be
Page 82 of 92
Page 3 of 6
inconsistent with nor prevent the full utilization by the Town and the general public of
the rights and privileges granted herein.
2. The Town agrees to plan, lay out, and build a paved pathway for pedestrian and
bicycle travel by the general public on and across the Easement Property, and further
agrees that the construction of, maintenance of, repair of, use of, access to , and travel
upon the paved pathway shall be under the exclusive control of the Town and that the
Town shall at all times comply with all applicable laws, rules, codes, and regulations in
connection with the development, construction, use and maintenance of the Ease ment
Property and the paved pathway to be located therein.
3. From the date of the commencement of the construction of the paved pathway
described in this Pathway Easement, the Town shall be solely responsible for, at its sole
cost and expense, all cleaning, maintenance, repair, renovation, landscaping, signage,
striping, drainage improvements, lighting, and all other improvements in general in
connection with the paved pathway as shall be or shall become necessary or prudent for
the reasonable safety of the general public using said paved pathway.
4. The Town agrees to cause all work contemplated hereunder to be performed in a
workmanlike fashion with minimal interference to the Grantor and its successors,
assigns, residents, invitees, guests, licensees, and agents. The Town further agrees to
cause the work contemplated hereunder to be completed in an expeditious and timely
fashion, that the paved pathway shall at all times be maintaine d in a safe condition, and
that all debris and construction materials pertaining to work undertaken by the Town
pursuant to the rights granted in the Pathway Easement shall be promptly removed. The
Page 83 of 92
Page 4 of 6
Town shall restore any other part of the Grantor ’s property that may be damaged as a
result of the Town's exercise of the rights granted in this Pathway Easement to its pre -
existing state.
5. As a material inducement to the Grantor to grant the easement provided for herein,
the Town hereby warrants to the Grantor (a) that neither the granting of the within
easement nor the construction of the pathway or any other improvements pursuant
hereto will now or in the future affect any buffers or "set backs" lines or requirements now
or in the future provided for in the Town’s Land Management Ordinance [§16 -1-101, et
seq., Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina (1983)]; and (b) that the
pathway to be constructed by the Town within the Easement Property is a permitted use
in the adjacent street buffer required by the provisions of the Town’s Land Management
Ordinance.
To have and to hold, all and singular, the rights, privileges, and easements
aforesaid unto the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, its successors and
assigns, forever.
In Witness whereof, the parties hereto have caused this Pathway Easement to be
executed by the Grantor and by the duly authorized officers of the Town on this ___ day
of July, 2024.
(Signatures on Following Pages)
Page 84 of 92
Page 5 of 6
WITNESSES
_________________________ __________________________
Moshe Dekel
_________________________
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) UNIFORM ACKNOWLEDGMENT
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
I, the undersigned Notary Public do hereby certify that Moshe Dekel personally
appeared before me on this day and duly acknowledged the execution of this Pathway
Easement.
Sworn to and Subscribed before me
on this
Day of July, 2024.
____________________________________
Notary Public for South Carolina
My Commission Expires:
Page 85 of 92
Page 6 of 6
WITNESSES: THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND,
SOUTH CAROLINA
________________________ By
Alan R. Perry, Mayor
________________________ By
:
Marc A. Orlando, Manager
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) UNIFORM ACKNOWLEDGMENT
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
I, the undersigned Notary Public do hereby certify that The Town of Hilton Head
Island, South Carolina, by and through Alan R. Perry, Mayor, and Marc A. Orlando,
Manager, personally appeared before me on this day and duly acknowledged the
execution of this Pathway Easement.
Sworn to and Subscribed before me
on this Day of July, 2024.
________________________________
Notary Public for South Carolina
My Commission Expires:
Page 86 of 92
SCALE : DATE :1" = 30'
MITCHELLVILLE ROAD,
BEAUFORT COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA
04/28/20
A RIGHT OF WAY PLAT OF:
PREPARED FOR:
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
HILTON HEAD ISLAND,
SHEET 1 of 2 SHEETS
d.b.a. Sea Island Land Survey, Inc.
DWG No. : FILE No :13068.54-13068.5
E-mail: admin@nandinainc.com
Hilton Head Island,
SC 29926
Tel (843) 681-3248 10 Oak Park Drive, Unit C1,
REVISED: 1/31/2024
ATTACHMENT 2
Page 87 of 92
MITCHELLVILLE ROAD,
BEAUFORT COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA
A RIGHT OF WAY PLAT OF:
PREPARED FOR:TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
HILTON HEAD ISLAND,
SHEET 2 of 2 SHEETS
SCALE : DATE :1" = 30' 04/28/20
d.b.a. Sea Island Land Survey, Inc.
DWG No. : FILE No :
Fax (843) 689-3871
13068.54-13068.5
E-mail: admin@nandinainc.com
Hilton Head Island,
SC 29926
Tel (843) 681-3248 10 Oak Park Drive, Unit C1,
REVISED: 1/31/2024
ATTACHMENT 2
Page 88 of 92
Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex
One Town Center Court Hilton Head Island South Carolina 29928
www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
Town Council
TO: Town Council
FROM: John McGowan, Assistant Finance Director
CC: Marc Orlando, ICMA-CM, Town Manager
Adriana Burnett, Finance Director
Josh Gruber, Deputy Town Manager
DATE: July 11, 2024
SUBJECT: Consideration of a Resolution Relating to the Declaration of Intent by
Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, to Reimburse Certain
Expenditures Prior to the Execution and Delivery of a Tax-Exempt
Equipment Lease by the Town
RECOMMENDATION:
Town Council is requested to review and approve the attached Reimbursement
Resolution, which will give the Town the ability to replenish Hospitality Tax fund balances
expended for the initial purchase of fire trucks . T his replenishment would be
accomplished via proceeds from a Tax-Exempt Equipment Lease with a third -party
financial institution, to be executed in FY2025.
BACKGROUND:
Town staff, including Fire Rescue Team leadership, had proposed replacing 10 fire
vehicles as part of the FY2022 Budget, based on the vehicles exceeding their standard
useful life of 10 years and growing repair costs/downtime associated with servicing
these older vehicles. During the budget approval process, it was discussed that the
funding for these vehicles would be sought through some form of an equipment lease.
The funding for these equipment lease payments has subsequently been carried
forward into the FY2023, FY2024 and FY2025 Budgets.
Based on the FY2022 budget approval, the Town entered into an agreement (“the 2021
Purchase Agreement”) with Safe Industries on December 1, 2021 (updated and
extended on November 14, 2023) to provide 10 new fire vehicles (8 pumpers and 2
quints) to the Town for a total cost of $7,450,473. Due to production delays and supply
chain issues, the initial delivery of these vehicles was delayed several times. The Town
has now begun taking delivery of these vehicles in June, 2024, and is expected take
delivery of all additional vehicles between July and December of 2024. Payment of each
vehicle is due within 30 days of each delivery, and the Town will initially pay for each
Page 89 of 92
Page 2 of 2
vehicle purchased under the 2021 Purchase Agreement via cash from the Hospitality
Tax revenues.
Additionally, as part of the approved FY2025 Budget, funding was included to allow for
the acquisition of two ladder trucks, as the Town’s two existing ladder trucks have now
also reached the end of their useful life. Delivery of these ladder trucks is expected in
late FY2025. The Finance team will work with Fire Rescue leadership to execute
another purchase agreement to acquire these vehicles.
These FY2025 ladder trucks will also be purchased from Safe Industries, at a cost of
$4,500,000, thereby creating a combined purchase price of just under $12,000,000 for
all vehicles (FY2022 purchase: 8 pumpers, 2 quints; FY2025 purchase: 2 ladder trucks).
The plan is to reimburse the Hospitality Tax revenues for the upfront acquisition costs
through an equipment lease arrangement . Given that the delivery of these vehicles is
being spread out over multiple months, it is necessary to prepare documentation for Town
Council’s approval that will allow the Town to roll all these purchases into a single Tax -
Exempt Equipment Lease.
The proposed Tax-Exempt Equipment Lease agreement will not count against the
Town’s 8% General Obligation Bond limitation, though it will be a long-term obligation of
the Town until it is paid off.
SUMMARY:
Approving the attached Reimbursement Resolution provides the Town the ability to roll
all of the upfront expenditures associated with the authorized Fire and Rescue vehicle
purchases into a Tax-Exempt Equipment Lease, and to reimburse the upfront payments
that it has made upon the delivery of each vehicle via the Tax-Exempt Equipment Lease
proceeds. The Tax-Exempt Equipment Lease will be paid back over a 10-year period via
Hospitality Tax revenues.
If approved by the Town Council, this reimbursement action would preserve a strong
FY2025 Hospitality Tax fund balance and allows the Town to pursue additional approved
capital projects. Additionally, matching the Town’s annual lease payments to the
anticipated 10-year useful life of the fire trucks is a more equitable way of paying for this
long-term capital improvement relative to a one-time FY2025 $12 million Hospitality Tax
fund cash expenditure.
ATTACHMENTS:
Draft Reimbursement Resolution
Page 90 of 92
54602805 v2
A RESOLUTION
A RESOLUTION RELATING TO THE DECLARATION OF INTENT BY THE TOWN OF
HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, TO REIMBURSE CERTAIN EXPENDITURES
PRIOR TO THE EXECUTION AND DELIVERY OF A TAX-EXEMPT EQUIPMENT LEASE BY
THE TOWN
WHEREAS, the Internal Revenue Service and U.S. Treasury Department have promulgated
Section 1.150-2 of the Treasury Regulations (the “Regulations”) that authorizes an issuer to reimburse itself
for expenditures made with respect to projects prior to the issuance or execution of tax-exempt obligations
for such projects; and
WHEREAS, the Regulations require an issuer to adopt an official intent to reimburse an
expenditure not later than sixty (60) days after the payment of the expenditure; and
WHEREAS, the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina (the “Town”), anticipates incurring
expenditures (the “Expenditures”) related to the acquisition of fire trucks (the “Projects”) prior to the
execution of a tax-exempt equipment lease for such purpose by the Town (the “Lease”); and
WHEREAS, the Town reasonably expects that it will reimburse Expenditures from the proceeds
of the Lease; and
WHEREAS, the Town expects that the maximum principal amount of the Lease to be issued for
the Projects will not exceed $12,000,000 plus costs of issuance.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Council (the “Town Council”) of the Town:
Section 1. The Town Council hereby declares that this Resolution shall constitute its
declaration of official intent pursuant to Section 1.150 -2 of the Regulations to reimburse the Town from
the proceeds of tax-exempt obligations in the form of the Lease to be executed pursuant to South Carolina
state law, for Expenditures with respect to the Projects. The Town Council anticipates incurring
Expenditures with respect to the Projects prior to the execution by the Town of the Lease for such purposes.
Section 2. To be eligible for reimbursement of the Expenditures, the reimbursement
allocation must be made not later than 18 months after the later of (a) the date on which the Expenditures
were paid, or (b) the date the first Project was placed in service, but in no event more than three (3) years
after the original Expenditures.
Section 3. The Town understands that Expenditures which may be reimbursed are limited to
Expenditures which are (1) properly chargeable to a capital account (or would be so chargeable with a
proper election or with the application of the definition of placed in ser vice under Section 1.150-2 of the
Regulations) under general federal income tax principles; or (2) certain de minimis or preliminary
expenditures satisfying the requirements of Section 1.150-2(f) of the Regulations.
Section 4. The Town Council hereby authorizes the use of general fund monies or other
legally-available funds on hand as the source of funds for the Expenditures with respect to the Projects.
Section 5. This Resolution shall be in full force and effect from and after its adoption as
provided by law. This Resolution shall be made available for inspection during normal business hours by
the general public at the offices of the Town.
Page 91 of 92
54602805 v2
Adopted this ______ day of ___________, 2024.
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND,
SOUTH CAROLINA
_______________________________________
Mayor
(SEAL)
Attest:
__________________________________
Clerk, Town Council
Page 92 of 92
Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.