Design Review Board Meeting — Minutes
Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · Design Review Board · meeting of Jul 23, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Town of Hilton Head Island Design Review Board
Meeting Minutes
7/23/2024 Page | 1
Town of Hilton Head Island
DESIGN REVIEW BOARD MEETING
Tuesday, July 23, 2024, 2:30 PM
Minutes
1. Call to Order
Chair Judd Carstens called the meeting to order at 2:30 p.m.
2. Adoption of the Agenda
Mr. Parker moved to approve the agenda. Ms. Lippert seconded. The adoption of the agenda
passed unanimously 6-0.
3. Approval of the Minutes
a. Regular Meeting Minutes of July 9th, 2024.
Ms. Lippert moved to approve the minutes of July 9th, 2024. Mr. Parker seconded. The
approval of the minutes passed unanimously 6-0.
4. Unfinished Business
a. DRB-000928-2024 – 27 New Orleans – Final
Melissa Paul-Leto, Principal Planner, presented the Final Review for the Major
Development Plan Review located at 27 New Orleans Road. This site previously served
as a drainage channel, no longer in use. The proposed facility will consist of a bicycle
warehouse and donut production and sales shop on the first floor, with the second floor
being for storage warehouse use. This item was tabled since the last June meeting of the
9th. Board comments addressed: avoid high contrast colors, remove IRC on plan sheets,
bike rack specs with color specs provided, materials color and lighting cut sheets are
needed, revised plan to improve impervious to pervious brick. The applicant noted a
tabby path landing as well as a crushed shell pathway. Staff recommends approval with
the conditions that the applicant adheres to conditions set forth on March 12th and will
require a building permit and a major DRP (Development Review Plan). Applicant asks
for modified utility plan to keep the significant pine tree. Conceptual review approved
March 12th.
Board Discussion: Mr. Parker questions the makeup air unit on the front of the building,
suggesting it be moved to the back of the building. Mr. Parker noted the black color to be
acceptable for the bike rack. Ms. Lippert recommends the trim and garage door be a
different color to provide more contrast. Other color changes can be handled with a staff
level review. Mr. Carsten suggests not using any lighting hanging from trees.
Town of Hilton Head Island Design Review Board
Meeting Minutes
7/23/2024 Page | 2
Ms. Lippert made a motion to approve with the following conditions: revise the globe
lighting on the tree to an up-light, moving the makeup air fan to the back of the building,
review the three parking spaces near the pine tree, revising the color palate for subtle
contrast, and provide info on tabby concrete, stucco, shell size and color with two staff
members and two DRB members reviewing the re-submission. Mr. Parker seconded. The
motion was approved unanimously 6-0.
b. DRB-000955-2024 – 75 Mathews Drive – Wells Fargo Signs – Final
The item was presented as a final design for Wells Fargo on 75 Mathews Drive during the
July 9th meeting. The applicant came back with a redesign for the sign colors and lighting
specifications, as requested by Council members during the previous meeting. The
applicant requested "Drum Beat Red" be used for the welcome sign, which is not visible
from the front of the building. Halo lighting is confirmed at 3000k for the Wells Fargo sign.
Board Discussions: Mr. Parker notes the ATM is not allowed to be internally lit. Ms.
Lippert suggests the number on the sign be the same red as the sign instead of black,
and she is fine with limited accent colors being used for the "Hello" sign. Ms. Lippert and
Mr. Brandenburg agreed with the size variance for the sign, and requires confirmation by
Fire Rescue for the sizing of the street numbers on the street sign. Ms. Fitzpatrick
inquired about the proposed "Do Not Enter" dimensions and suggested they be eight
inches tall by four feet wide. Mr. Carstens pointed out that the submittal should show
Dover White and Glidden Drum Beat Red and directionals be legacy colors, as well as
notate in the rendering that the street sign be double-sided.
Ms. Lippert made a motion to approve with the following conditions: the "Do not enter"
sign and clearance signs to be four feet by eight inches, the address number be Gildden
Drum Beat Red and the street number size be determined by the fire department, all halo
lighting be 3000K with the lumens at 2,700 maximum, notating double-sided street sign,
and fix notation regarding white on page 22 and 23. The motion was approved
unanimously 6-0.
c. DRB-000960-2024- 1 Greenwood Drive – Wells Fargo Signs – Final
This item was presented at the July 9th meeting, with conditions, for the Wells Fargo sign
at 1 Greenwood Dr and Sea Pines circle. The colors were revised to Drum Beat Red with
Dover White with halo lighting of 3000k and lumen count, and address numbers were
added to the top right of the street sign. The applicant stresses the importance of
matching the 75 Mathews Dr location signage.
Board Discussions: Ms. Lippert noted there is too much space around the ATM sign on
page #34 of the rendering and noted the same conditions for the 75 Mathews Drive
location. Mr. Carsten requested all notes on the fabricator sheets are correct. A motion to
approve was made by Ms. Lippert with the following conditions: the address number size
to be determined by the Fire Marshal, the halo lit sign to be no cooler than 3000K, the
ATM sign be fourteen inches wide by twenty inches tall with a single post, cleaning up the
color notes on the shop drawings, clearly indicate what is brand reference vs fabrication
Town of Hilton Head Island Design Review Board
Meeting Minutes
7/23/2024 Page | 3
direction and address number to be "Glidden Drum Beat Red". Mr. Theodore seconded.
The motion was approved 6-0.
5. New Business
a. Nomination and Election of Officers for July 1, 2024 – June 30, 2025.
Chair Carstens asked if anyone would like to make a motion to nominate a board member
to serve as Chair for this new term. Mr. Theodore nominated Mr. Carstens. Mr. Parker
seconded. The motion passed unanimously 6-0.
Chair Carstens asked if anyone would like to make a motion to nominate a board member
to serve as Vice Chair for this new term. Mr. Theodore nominated Ms. Lippert. Mr. Parker
seconded. The motion passed unanimously 6-0.
b. Appointment of Board of Secretary for July 1, 2024 – June 30, 2025
Chair Carstens asked if anyone would like to make a motion to nominate Mrs. Ashley
Facenda to serve as the Board Secretary for the new term. Ms. Lippert nominated Mrs.
Facenda. Mr. Theodore seconded. The motion passed unanimously 6-0.
c. DRB-000967-2024 – 51 S South Forest Beach Drive – Conceptual
Mr. Theodore recused himself. This item is to discuss alterations to the Marriott Grand
Ocean. Ms. Leto presented the Marriott Grand Ocean alteration. It is not a conceptual
and will not need a final. The applicant is requesting to repaint all eleven buildings on the
property. Marriott selected all colors which were presented to the board with a sample.
Board Discussion: Ms. Lippert suggests making the hurricane shutters on the parking
garage side the "Colonial Revival Stone" color as the base as opposed to the white, Mr.
Brandenburg agrees, Ms. Fitzpatrick asked about the existing color palette, Mr. Carstens
did not note any issues. A motion to approve was made by Mr. Parker with the following
conditions: Trim around windows to be notated as body color, parking garage louvers to
match the base color and the others in the stairwell can remain white. Ms. Lippert
seconded. The motion passed unanimously 5-0.
d. DRB-000992-2024 – 120 Arrow Road – Conceptual
Item to discuss design concepts for the Atlantic Laundry building located at 120 Arrow
Road. The applicant is Mike Vaccaro from Vaccaro Architecture.
Ms. Leto presented, mentioning several commercial uses within the building. Ms. Leto
stated several changes which will be made to the exterior of the building: removing the
existing parapet and replacing it with a new one, painting the existing stucco wall of the
building, replacing some stucco with fiberglass cement siding, replacing the exterior
staircase with a covered staircase, the addition of a loading dock, no change in the
building footprint. Staff recommends approval of the conditions that a material board be
provided for the final review. A building permit and minor Development Planning Reviews
Town of Hilton Head Island Design Review Board
Meeting Minutes
7/23/2024 Page | 4
(DPR) are required prior to construction. No change in the building footprint, only material
changes.
Board Discussion – Mr. Parker inquired about storefront changes in which Mr. Vaccaro
explained it would not change, Mr. Parker suggested unifying the storefront. Mr. Parker
also suggested a screening fence for tanks. Ms. Lippert inquired about floor plans and
roof plans as well as awnings, which Mr. Vaccaro stated will be removed. Ms. Lippert
expressed that she did not agree with painting the roof and suggested replacing it. She
also noted that all materials specifications must be provided. Mr. Brandenburg inquired
about signage changes. Ms. Fitzpatrick expressed that she thinks the renderings have
too much of a modern feel and explained that more elements are needed, such as
landscaping, etc. She also noted that it would be worth considering Land Management
Ordinance (LMO) changes pertaining to Arrow Road. Mr. Theodore suggests checking
into the Sea Pines Architecture Review Board (ARB) for zoning purposes. He also
suggests that the storefront be updated. Mr. Carstens made comments regarding the
potential for the building and screening of dumpsters in the future.
A motion to approve was made by Mr. Parker with the following conditions: coordination
of signage with building will be required, landscaping considered, screening provided for
existing equipment cohesive with new design of building and dumpster screens, color
scheme and material details provided as well as a more complete set of plans -
specifically the floor, roof, lighting, and storefront and windows. And a review of whether
this falls under the ARB requirements, as well as potential revisions for LMO pertaining to
Arrow Road. Mr. Theodore seconded. The motion passed unanimously 6-0.
e. DRB-000996-2024 – 148 Beach City Road - Final
Mr. Parker recused himself. The item is a final review of the proposed car parking barn at
148 Beach City Rd. The applicant is Tim Probst with PDG Architects. Ms. Leto presented,
stating updates to the original design: The dumpster yard has been shifted farther away from the
entrance door with a new elevation plan, and the sidewalk has been corrected to lead to the entry
door. Final review for the car barn with demolition of the parking lot. Lighting spec sheets
and exterior lighting plans were provided. Staff requires approval since this is a major
development plan, and a building permit.
Board Discussion: Ms. Lippert asked detailed questions regarding the color scheme,
including garage door, roof, and siding, which Mr. Probst addressed. Mr. Brandenburg
had no further comment. Ms. Fitzpatrick had no further comment. Mr. Theodore
recommends the entrance be a concrete paved area to break up the use of asphalt. Mr.
Carstens inquired about the landscape plan and requested the height of sycamores be
higher and updated landscaping on the backside of the building, regardless of low
visibility.
A motion to approve was made by Ms. Lippert with the following conditions: a concrete
pad in the entry area, a revised landscape plan provided which will come back to staff in
Town of Hilton Head Island Design Review Board
Meeting Minutes
7/23/2024 Page | 5
addition to both landscape architects on the board, clarification that the garage doors and
the fascia color to match Sheffield Ash Gray, the main doors and frames also must match
the Sheffield Ash Gray, and building sections on A2.3 be updated to match the
elevations. Mr. Brandenburg seconded. The motion was approved 5-0.
6. Public Comment - Non Agenda Items
None.
7. Board Business
None.
8. Staff Reports
None.
9. Adjournment
The meeting was declared adjourned at 5:33 p.m.
APPROVED: August 13th, 2024.
The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website
at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.