RecordWell Data

William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee — Agenda Packet

Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee · meeting of Jun 12, 2024 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee Meeting Wednesday, June 12, 2024, 1:00 PM 1 Town Center Court, Hilton Head Island, SC Benjamin M. Racusin Council Chambers The meeting can be viewed on the Town’s YouTube Channel, the Beaufort County Channel, and Spectrum Channel 1304. 1. Call to Order 2. Approval of the Minutes a. Regular Meeting Minutes of April 22, 2024. b. Regular Meeting Minutes of May 8, 2024. 3. Unfinished Business a. Update on Project Progress 4. New Business a. Presentation of Findings for Downstream Intersection Impacts b. Consideration of a Resolution to Accept the Findings of the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent End to End Analysis 5. Appearance by Citizens: 6. Adjournment FOIA Compliance: Public notification of this meeting has been published, posted, and distributed in compliance with the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act and the requirements of the Town of Hilton Head Island. In accordance with the requirements of Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 ("ADA"), the Town of Hilton Head Island will not discriminate against qualified individuals with disabilities on the basis of disability in its services, programs, or Page 1 of 300 activities. Auditory accommodations are available. Any person requiring further accommodation should contact the Town of Hilton Head Island ADA Coordinator as soon as possible but no later than 48 hours before the scheduled event. Municipal Association of South Carolina (MASC) Civility Pledge: “I pledge to build a stronger and more prosperous community by advocating for civil engagement, respecting others and their viewpoints, and finding solutions for the betterment of my city or town.” Page 2 of 300 Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 4/22/2024 Page | 1 Town of Hilton Head Island WILLIAM HILTON PARKWAY GATEWAY CORRIDOR INDEPENDENT REVIEW ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEETING Monday, April 22, 2024, 1:00 PM Minutes 1. Call to Order Mayor Perry called the meeting to order at 1:00 PM. Those present were: Mayor Alan Perry, Chairman; Diederik Advocaat; Edward C. Warren, Jr.; Charles P. Walczak, PE; and Willie Young. Absent was: Herbert Ford, Alternate. 2. Approval of the Minutes a. Meeting Minutes of April 10, 2024 will be approved at the next regular meeting. Mr. Advocaat stated he had appeared remotely at the April 10, 2024, meeting; however, he had technical issues with his microphone and was unable to pose questions or comments. Therefore, he would like his points to be recorded. Point 1: At the last meeting, there was no discussion or opinion made concerning the bridges - one span vs. two spans. If you have a 1 span, 11 lane bridge, is that technically feasible or make sense? Point 2: The on-grade bypass option needs to be given serious consideration. It is less obtrusive environmentally, has less impact on Stoney, can be a quick connection to the Cross Island Parkway, has the lowest cost option, and cuts the commute time. Point 3: The grading matrix produced in my opinion is really comparing apples and oranges, and you cannot add numbers and come to a conclusion. Point 4: The bike lane - a cost/benefit analysis should be done, its usage, and whether funds for a bike lane can be better allocated elsewhere. Point 5: The adaptive management system - you are still working in clusters at the end of 278, there has to be a way these 2 can be connected during peak hours to create a better flow, and disabling the Windmill Harbour light during peak hours should be explored. Point 6: I question whether the bow tie alternative would actually work, and should be tested in your simulation models. Point 7: What is the cost picture for the elevated bypass, does it makes sense at all, and has it been discussed with SCDOT as a potential solution, and what is their opinion? Point 8: The $425M which has been mentioned as a number, which is a 50% increase. Where does that come from and how is that put together. All these points I would like Lochmueller to consider, take them into account, and where applicable, add onto the simulation models. 3. Unfinished Business Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager - Community Development, thanked everyone for their appearance on such a short notice. He explained that at the last meeting Lochmueller Page 3 of 300 Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 4/22/2024 Page | 2 had presented 4 viable Alternatives to advance for additional evaluation. A comparative assessment was presented for each of those Alternatives, and the Committee asked for additional information related to cost, and property impact to both public and private lands. Lochmueller has developed that additional information, along with a third element relating to the construction period, based on their professional opinion of the project. He turned the presentation over to Nate Nohren and his Lochmueller team, with Brad Strader and Brian Kinzelman available remotely. Mr. Colin clarified for the Committee that with regard to Mr. Advocaat's points, the matter of additional funding for this project is not within the scope of work for Lochmueller. a. Additional Details on Property Impacts, Cost, and Construction Period for Alternatives. Nate Nohren, Project Manager for Lochmueller, introduced his team joining the meeting remotely: Kate Swinford and Michelle Romaine, Traffic Engineering Leads; Chad Costa, Chief Environental Engineer; Lorne Jackson, Chief Roadway Engineer. He noted this meeting is designed to present the additional information requested at the April 10 meeting, which included delineating between public and private parcels, providing high order of magnitude cost estimates as well as estimates for the construction duration, and a matrix incorporating everything provided. Mr. Nohren presented slides of the Alternatives, which slides are a part of the presentation contained in the agenda packet. He briefly outlined on the slides Alternative #1, Alternative #2, Alternative #3, and Alternative #4. He pointed out the travel time comparison when compared to 2045 No Build for each Alternative completed in Synchro for the Hilton Parkway corridor between Moss Creek and Indigo Run. Questions from the Committee members were answered by Mr. Nohren, Mr. Jackson, and Mr. Colin. Discussion ensued about whether SCDOT or Beaufort County has reviewed the Lochmueller plans. Mr. Colin reminded the Committee that a part of the scope for Lochmueller was a provision to refrain from any communication with the County or SCDOT during the engineering evaluations and assessments until the Committee identifies Alternatives to be advanced, at which point any design modifications would then be shared with both the County and SCDOT for consideration. He also raised the issue of where additional funding would come from above the original project cost for the deficient bridge and funding sources from the State Infrastructure Bank, grant, and referendum, leaving a current deficit of $100M+. While there have been communications, he noted none were specifically about SCDOT vetting all of the engineering solutions. Mr. Colin indicated he would like to have the benefit of this meeting's results and the Committee's position so that he can schedule further conversations this week. Mr. Nohren concluded his presentation with slides detailing the additional right of way required for each Alternative, with estimated cost ranging from $426M to $575M, and estimated construction duration ranging from 36 to 48 months, with the resulting scoring and ranking. A lengthy discussion followed concerning the scoring system and matrix, how impact was determined for additional right of way acreage needed, difficulties and Page 4 of 300 Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 4/22/2024 Page | 3 delays that could result, whether a sufficient right of way exists in Stoney to accommodate a larger paved roadway, and the review being made Lochmueller's structural engineers of the seismic study,with the initial analysis indicating no feasible way to retrofit an existing bridge to meet SEE requirements. Mr. Colin stated that after the last meeting when Lochmueller presented its evaluation and comparative assessment of the alternatives, the goal was to identify an Alternative that would be the preferred Alternative to put through the VISSIM model so they could then perform the deeper analysis and evaluation, and they could move beyond the current study area, as well, to look at the full end-to-end that was requested down to Sea Pines Circle and to Wilborn and Indigo Run. Therefore, with the additional information presented today as requested plus construction duration, they would like the Committee to weigh in on the Alternative or Alternatives to continue to move forward and advance. He asked for the Committee's feedback at this time. Each Committee member stated their current choices and reasoning involved, but no clear consensus was reached. Discussion continued among the Committee members and Mr. Nohren concerning keeping a 4-lane bridge, and Mr. Nohren indicated the analyses done by them and other studies reviewed, indicate this is not practical. Mayor Perry noted there are questions concerning whether the State Infrastructure Bank, the State House, or other source would grant the additional funding for the Alternative chosen, and conversations with these entities needed to be held soon. Mr. Colin agreed that with a potential shortfall in the current funding, and the failure of the Committee to narrow down the Alternatives for Lochmueller to proceed into the VISSIM model, it would be appropriate to share the Alternatives presented by Lochmueller with Beaufort County officials and SCDOT to determine feasibility and funding availability. The Committee members indicated their support for that plan, with Mr. Colin to schedule meetings and report back soon. 4. Appearance by Citizens No citizens have requested to appear before the Committee regarding items not on the agenda. No comments were received through the Open Town Hall Portal. A citizen remarked that the traffic lights are not synchronized nor optimized at Spanish Wells and Squire Pope Road intersections. He also mentioned that cost/value for benefit gained in minutes should be a consideration. Christopher Cliffe noted he had attended 32 committee meetings since November 2018 chaired by David Johnson, 12 or more joint broadcasts of Beaufort County and the Town, numerous Town Council meetings, and at no time during those meetings until recently has cost come up as a determining factor. He questioned how the construction duration was computed, where the idea of pedestrian and bike paths originated, whether construction costs were based on 2022 numbers, and whether there were certain aspects of the bridge that would be the Town's responsibility. An Indigo Run resident stressed the need for a fair, transparent, and independent analysis Page 5 of 300 Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 4/22/2024 Page | 4 free from political manipulation, but he questioned whether that is the case. He stated too much attention is being placed on an oversize bridge and not enough on traffic lights, which are the real cause of our congestion problems. Better and cheaper options, with less community impact on the Gullah community, have been suggested and ignored. The Town's decision will be one of the most consequential decision in years and will impact our Town for decades. Louise Miller Cohen, a native of Hilton Head Island, stated God had given her a job to keep the Gullah Geechee culture alive on Hilton Head Island. All that is remaining is the land left by their ancestors and passed down to the current generation. She expressed her gratitude to everyone who feels their pain, and asked the members to put themselves in their shoes and help them keep their land, their culture, and their community. 5. New Business None. 6. Adjournment The meeting was declared adjourned at 2:42 PM. Approved: The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov Page 6 of 300 Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 5/8/2024 Page | 1 Town of Hilton Head Island WILLIAM HILTON PARKWAY GATEWAY CORRIDOR INDEPENDENT REVIEW ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEETING Wednesday, May 8, 2024, 1:00 PM Minutes 1. Call to Order Mayor Perry called the meeting to order at 1:00 PM. Present were: Mayor Alan Perry, Chairman; Diederik Advocaat; Edward C. Warner, Jr.; and Willie Young. Absent were: Charles P. Walczak and Henry Ford, Alternate. 2. Approval of the Minutes a. Regular Meeting Minutes of April 10, 2024 Mr. Warner made a motion to approve the minutes as presented, at which time Mr. Advocaat asked that a sentence on Page 3 describing a discussion with the consultant concerning a 4-lane bridge in the minutes of the April 10, 2024 meeting be struck. Mayor Perry asked for a review of the recording to provide more clarification, so the Motion by Mr. Warner was amended to approve the minutes with the following condition: that the recording be reviewed and the sentence in question be clarified. The motion was seconded by Mr. Advocaat and unanimously adopted. b. Special Meeting Minutes of April 22, 2024 Mr. Warner made a motion to approve the minutes as presented, at which time Mr. Advocaat questioned whether the Committee had approved Mr. Colin moving forward with a meeting with Beaufort County and SCDOT concerning the Alternatives as stated in the minutes of the April 22, 2024 meeting. Mayor Perry asked for a review of the recording to provide more clarification, so the Motion by Mr. Warner was amended to approve the minutes with the following condition: that the recording be reviewed and the question of approval be clarified. The motion was seconded by Mr. Advocaat and unanimously adopted. 3. Unfinished Business a. Update on Project Progress Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager - Community Development, noted that Mr. Nohren and his team would be going through a more in-depth evaluation, but he presented a brief review of the scope of work and progress made. In addition, he would share the Page 7 of 300 Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 5/8/2024 Page | 2 responses on the Alternatives received from SCDOT at the Committee's request, as well as SCDOT responses to bridge rehab vs. new bridge, and safety information. He pointed out that the authorizing resolution for this Committee was to perform 4 key functions, 3 of which have been completed, with the 4th to move through the scope of work to make sure it is executed in accordance with the scope that the Committee and Town Council had adopted, and that is now in progress. b. Update on Committee Requests At the last meeting, the Committee requested that there be an evaluation of Alternatives that were developed independently by Lochmueller, as well as the proposed Alternative called the Express Bypass, and labeled Bypass 3.1. Mr. Colin reported that in accordance with the request from the Committee, a trip was made to Columbia last Wednesday. Alternatives #1, #2, #3, and #4 that were identified in the Lochmueller presentation, both on April 10 and April 22, were shared with the South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) in advance of the trip. The other Alternative not recommended by Lochmueller, but recommended for submission to SCDOT for response was the Bypasss 3.1 that has been discussed for some time. After review, feedback from SCDOT regarding Alternatives was provided at the meeting. They also provided some information related to the bridge rehab vs. a reconstruction or new bridge, and did a thorough review of the Alternatives to provide technical evaluation and feedback related to feasibility or viability of the Alternatives to advance. Mr. Advocaat questioned why all the Alternatives are being discussed with SCDOT when the Committee is still reviewing these. Mr. Colin explained he was working under the unanimous direction of the Committee to have these Alternatives vetted and to provide feedback. Mayor Perry and Mr. Advocaat disagreed on what had been agreed by the Committee to seek from the SCDOT and also the role of individual committee members who discuss matters outside the meeting, which may be construed as representing the Committee as a whole. Mr. Colin reiterated that the direction supported by the Committee was to have the Alternatives vetted and request a response from SCDOT, but there was no direction on the method used to obtain that information, therefore a meeting was held in Columbia at which the feedback requested was obtained. He reported the general feedback was technical in nature related to project implications for costs, implication to the Environmental Assessment (EA) and timing, implications to funding, and then also, feasibility to advance through Federal Highway Administration. As a result of the discussion held on May 1, the SCDOT drafted a response letter, which was officially submitted by their Deputy Secretary of Transportation and Chief Engineer. A copy of the letter dated May 2, 2024, from the SCDOT was received after the agenda packet had been published to the public, however, a copy of that letter is attached to the Minutes and Page 8 of 300 Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 5/8/2024 Page | 3 made a part hereof, and a copy was provided to all Committee members. Mr. Colin reviewed in detail the comments from the SCDOT letter that were specific to each Alternative. He noted that Alternatives #2, #3, and #4 are very low on feasibility or viability to be able to advance based upon the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) process and to get these through Federal Highways with minimizing impacts. These were the 3 Lochmueller Alternatives. Questions concerning whether SCDOT provided a breakdown of the $425M cost estimate and the size bridge this encompassed were addressed by Mr. Colin. He indicated the cost estimate is based upon the configuration that is included in the EA, with the project being a 6-lane bridge, with a barrier between eastbound and westbound traffic, including 2-10' shoulders, one in each direction operating as breakdown lanes, with 6' shoulders on the interior, having been reduced from 10' shoulders. It includes a 12' bike and pedestrian pathway along the bridge. He indicated those are the elements that are included, with mitigation also included that is the original mitigation that the SCDOT and County had worked on, but in his opinion may not be enough. Mr. Colin indicated he had not requested detailed breakdown of every line item in the $425M estimate for this project, especially since no Alternative has yet been selected, and he suggested that at this point it would be beneficial to look at the comparative assessment between Alternatives to understand what the approximate cost of each might be. As the EA progressed, he noted that cost was not a factor in the initial assessment done to vet Alternatives, but instead was brought in as a secondary criteria, along with other items, as you work through the NEPA process. He noted there is still an element remaining that is required by the NEPA process, and that is a value engineering. Once an Alternative is selected, there is an advance made through Federal Highways and there is a value engineering that must be done to identify where there may be additional cost-savings for the project. Mr. Colin identified those attending the meeting in Columbia from the Town as being: Mayor Perry, Town Manager Marc Orlando, Councilman Alex Brown, Shawn Colin, and Thomas Boxley, Chairman of the Community Development Corporation. From the County, those attending were: John Robinson, Interim Administrator, Joe Passiment, Chairman of Beaufort County Council, and Jared Fralix, PE, Assistant County Administrator-Infrastructure. Mr. Advocaat noted for the record that he considered the trip premature and suggested another trip be made after the Committee's evaluation. Mayor Perry noted Mr. Advocaat's concerns. A question concerning reducing the width of the 3 lanes was answered by Mr. Colin, who indicatied that had been suggested in a previous conversation with SCDOT several years ago, and the response was concerns about the volume and speed associated with the bridge, and about freight traffic requiring a 12' foot lane width. Simply re-striping to accommodate 3-lanes on the existing bridges would not provide a breakdown lane. The SCDOT suggested that the County with Town support could submit a design exception that they could possibly support to reduce on Jenkins Island the 2 interior lanes in each direction to 11', but 12' lanes on the outer lanes should be maintained for freight traffic. Page 9 of 300 Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 5/8/2024 Page | 4 A motion was made by Mr. Advocaat that the Committee fully consider the horizontal bypass, and he would like Lochmueller to include in full detail in their evaluatoin. Mr. Young seconded the motion. Mayor Perry noted this could be done for discussion, but if it involves an increase in cost, then it must go back to Town Council for approval. Mr. Advocaat indicated he had been given a proxy from Mr. Walczak, who had indicated his approval. Mayor Perry noted that Mr. Walczak had given no notice of his proxy. Mayor Perry indicated while the Committee had not yet been given the Lochmueller presentation, he was unclear whether this would be beneficial at this point. Discussion followed concerning the viability of considering this prior to the Lochmueller presentation and the SCDOT response as to their findings. Mr. Colin offered to provide information to help make an educated vote, and he requested that Mr. Nohren and any member of the Lochmueller team to provide their opinion on this alternative from an engineering standpoint and state whether or not they believe it is a feasible alternative to advance. In response to Mr. Advocaat's request for an immediate vote, Mayor Perry called for a vote. The motion passed 3-2, with Mr. Advocaat, Mr. Young, and Mr. Advocaat voting by proxy on behalf of Mr. Walczak in favor. Those opposed were Mayor Perry and Mr. Warner. Mr. Colin noted the Express Bypass 3.1 that was most recently submitted was provided to SCDOT for their input and feedback and accessment on viability for advancement. Due to the significant amount of impact to the Stoney Community, they thought this would trigger a full Environmental Impact Statement (EIS), and would increase significantly the environmental impacts. See full SCDOT comments in Letter dated May 2, 2024, as noted before and attached to the minutes. Mr. Colin noted that Alternatives #2, #3 and #4 were given very low feasibility to advance, and there are statements from SCDOT that they would be eliminated, as is the case with the Express Bypass that was presented. What was submitted to SCDOT was exactly the same as what was submitted to the Town for consideration, and this is the response from SCDOT. They do not believe that the Express Bypass is a viable option on many counts, including property impact, environmental impact, cost, timeframe, and would not advance this. Federal Highways would likely reject this option if submitted due to the additional TCP impact, as it would be counter to their objectives of avoiding or minimizing property impacts and mitigating, in that order. He asked for Mr. Nohren's professional engineering opinion on the feasibility of this alternative advancing. Mr. Nohren indicated that would be a part of his presentation later on the Agenda. Although it was not included in the scope of services, Lochmueller experts, Loren and Chad, and from traffic perspective it was also considered, and Lochmueller's would be provided. Mr. Advocaat expressed concern about the independent consultant being privy to the indepth conversations that have taken place with SCDOT and their findings. Mr. Nohren advised that the information developed by Lochmueller was completed before seeing the SCDOT document that was emailed to him today, and today's presentation would be their independent viewpoints on the Bypass. Page 10 of 300 Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 5/8/2024 Page | 5 Mr. Colin reiterated that he could not modify the scope of work just at the direction of this Committee, as the scope was approved by Town Council. The Committee's charge was to work with the consultant to move forward consistent with the scope of work they created. Before a contract amendment could be executed to evaluate this alternative, Town Council approval would be needed. Mr. Colin continued with his presentation of the Alternatives which the Committee asked be vetted through SCDOT, as there have been some questions related to a bridge rehab vs. a new bridge, SCDOT was asked about the design cost and construction implications related to bridge rehabilitation vs. new bridge. He noted the existing bridge is approaching 70 years in its lifecycle and is nearing the end of the design lifecycle of 70-75 years set by SCDOT. Their response was that bridge rehabilitation could be performed, but their preference is for a new bridge. Mr. Colin also showed a slide of a Heat Map and Collision Data outlining a significant amount of traffic incidents or collisions from 2016 to 2024 through the bridge corridor section and also as you approach the Stoney Community. The detailed response from SCDOT, Heat Map, and Collision Data are all shown on the slides presented by Mr. Colin and included in the agenda packet. These were presented to provide reasons for advancing a project to put in place a mechanism to provide improvements in this area, including reducing speeds, traffic calming, and providing a safer transportation system through this area. He reviewed the Town Council Authorized Scope of Work, which included an independent study by a consultant to review all the assumptions, methodologies, and come up with what they believed for alternatives to advance for this project. They were encouraged to develop their own ideas and recommend their own alternatives, which in Mr. Colins's opinion has been done. The proposed plans have to pass NEPA review, and any additional impacts, including safety and other items that are considered by Federal Highway. He noted that wha Lochmueller has done is look at the alternatives and viability and ability for them to move through the NEPA process and have alternatives that are supported by Federal Highway. The anticipation for completion was set at 6 months. He briefly reviewed the Tasks, noting those completed, ongoing, provided by staff, or in progress. c. Presentation of Findings - SCDOT Seismic Study Review Mr. Nohren noted the members of the Lochmueller team joining the meeting remotely - Kate, Michelle, Chad, and Loren and new team members, Jason Hickle, structural department manager who helped perform the analysis of existing bridge data, and Shawn Dykes, in-house transit expert, who provided input on the Memorandum regarding the feasibility of trying to maintain 4-lanes west of Squire Pope. Mr. Nohren began his presentation, which is included in the agenda packet, and included an outline of the completion data for Tasks #1, #2, #3, #4 and #5, with an overall completion progress of 80%. Mr. Advocaat asked to see the live modeling of the area Hilton Head Plantation to Moss Creek, and Mr. Nohren indicated that is a part of Task #4, with VISSIM and Synchro modeling included for the entire study area. Mr. Nohren moved into Task 1.8, which is the SCDOT Seismic Study Review Findings, which was approved by the Page 11 of 300 Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 5/8/2024 Page | 6 Committee and Town Council. He explained this was a review only of the SCDOT approved US 278 Bridge Seismic Study, approximately 1800 pages in total, dated April 2020, which was received by Lochmueller on April 15, 2024. The focus for Lochmueller was on the detailed Life Cycle Cost Analysis (LCCA) to provide their input. He reviewed the 3 options considered, rehabilitation and seismic retrofits or construction of a new 6- lane structure similar to the SCDOT Preferred Alternative. d. Presentation of Finding - Technical Report Detailed review findings and key observations for Options 1, 2 and 3 can be found in the presentation included in the agenda packet. In summary, Mr. Nohrens stated Lochmueller does not recommend rehabilitation and/or retrofit options be pursued. Questions from Committee members were addressed by the Lochmueller team. Michelle Romine, Lochmueller team member, attending the meeting remotely, continued with the 4-Lane Viability Technical Memo (Task 1.3.3). She stated the objective was to perform a cursory, high-level review to determine if one or more select strategies [second bridge, modifications to the existing mass transit system, implementation of a new ferry system, or implementation of a facility usage fee (congestion pricing)] could be implemented to allow for a 4-lane section of William Hilton Parkway between Moss Creek and Squire Pope Road, as included in the Agenda Packet. She outlined the various methods used to arrive at the concluding opinion by Lochmueller that these strategies should not be considered as viable alternatives to be used individually and/or collectively to solely address traffic congestion and mobility related concerns along US 278 within the project study area, to allow a four-lane section to be maintained along US 278 within the study area. Questions from Committee members were addressed by Ms. Romine. e. Review of Overall Evaluation Matrix for 4 Alternatives Mr. Nohren noted that at the April 22, 2024, meeting, a request was made for a delineation between public and private parcels. With additional information provided by the Town's GIS staff, Lochmueller used that data to determine if that impacted their findings. He pointed out that for Alternative #3, the acreage changed from the April 22 acreage of 1.4, and with the new information, the figure has been reduced to 1.1 acres, which also changes the rankings of the Alternatives. A discussion ensued with Mr. Advocaat reiterating his opposition to the way the rankings were determined, and the Lochmueller team noting that ultimately it was providing the Committee with the information needed to make the final decision and differentiate between the Alternatives through a high level evaluation. However, if desired, they offered to amend the matrix to remove the last 2 rows for scoring and ranking purposes. Mr. Colin noted the scope of work asked for the consultant to determine a way to evaluate, but did not specify exactly how that was to be accomplished. Elements were added that needed to be included in the evaluation, and questions could be made about the conclusions and findings that they have made or presented, but the goal of this Committee is to make sure the project is being executed against that scope of work. When you ask for an independent review based on engineering to provide you with information, this has been done according to the scope of work. You can disagree with some of their conclusions, but not the Page 12 of 300 Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 5/8/2024 Page | 7 methodology. Mr. Advocaat continued to voice his opinion that it was wrong to draw conclusions on the numbers and the Lochmueller team noted this practice has been applied across other projects throughout the country, but it should be considered just another way of screening. Mr. Colin noted that the first 3 Tasks have been completed to move through the independent review of all Alternatives, including any additional Alternatives Lochmueller thought worthy to advance. He reported that feedback has been obtained from SCDOT at the Committee's direction, and there is an Alternative that is preferred from the SCDOT's feedback, and there are additional design modifications that could be considered to reduce the right of way impacts, further reducing the impact to the TCP and the Stoney Community. He stated that Lochmueller needs to evaluate the downstream impacts to complete the next few Tasks in the scope of work, so the final informationcan be included in a delivered report. He has asked Lochmueller to move forward with Alternative #1 with design modifications to consider based on the feedback received from SCDOT on the Alternatives, so this could be built into their modeling for VISSIM to fully understand the downstream impacts. Mr. Colin reminded the Committee that the current Preferred Alternative that the County has recommended as part of the EA document, results in 3.4 acres of total impact to the TCP, with1.12 acres being privately owned property. The current design as you come on- Island includes 2 left turn lanes from William Hilton Parkway eastbound onto Squire Pope Road, with a design modification being evaluated by SCDOT from a performance and right of way impact standpoint, to reduce those 2 left turn lanes eastbound to 1 left turn lane onto Squire Pope Road. Also, there are currently 2 right turn lanes proposed as you come southbound on Squire Pope Road and right turn onto William Hilton Parkway westbound going off-Island. There has been a design modification request made to SCDOT from the Town and the County to reduce those 2 right turn lanes to 1 right turn lane, again further reducing the right of way impact on the Squire Pope and William Hilton Parkway segment. The third modification is that going westbound off-Island, there is a dedicated left turn only lane that accesses the Crazy Crab Restaurant. There has been a design modification request to shift that westbound and have that turn lane serve all of the driveway points on the southern side. The SCDOT has committed to evaluate those design considerations to see if the right of way and cross-section would be reduced for the roadway need, and therefore reduce the property impacts that is in the EA proposals for the current project. We believe there will be significant reductions if those design modifications are supported, and understanding the relationship between the transportation corridor land use and the performance of the roadway are all considerations. One of the primary goals of Federal Highways is social justice and social impact, so they are significantly interested in alternatives that reduce the impact as much as possible. That is why the other Alternatives that were shared with the SCDOT were unlikely to be feasible from their standpoint. Those are the design modifications that we have requested from SCDOT and are included in the Alternative #1 to move the modeling for the next phase of the project forward at this time. Page 13 of 300 Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 5/8/2024 Page | 8 Comments and questions were posed by Committee members. Mr. Advocaat reiterated his opinion that this is still premature without finishing the study and looking at the new Alternative being put forth today. Mr. Warner questioned how firm the SCDOT is in their comments, and whether there might be a hesitation on their part. Mr. Colin reported they were not interested at all in advancing Alternative #4, and as mentioned before, money is a consideration, and whether there is another viable solution that minimizes the overall impact and is less expensive. They will consider some additional elements, but the position that has been conveyed to the Town and the County consistently is that those additional costs would have to be borne at the local level. He reported that when talks began about alternatives, they let us know they were not in favor of Alternative #4 with an elevated bypass, but they are willing to understand design modifications proposed from local input in the project. f. Observations Related to Southern "Bypass" Alternative Ms. Romine continued by noting that although not contained within their scope, Lochmueller did look at the Southern Bypass. She provided a cursory traffic overview, Mr. Jackson provided a cursory engineering overview, and Mr. Costa provided a cursory environmental overview, which are all included in the Agenda Packet. Mr. Advocaat stated his opinion that the critical element is traffic lights that basically stop traffic coming onto Hilton Head Island, and the horizontal bypass which circumvents the traffic lights, should be considered due to less impact on the wetlands and deserves a good look. Concerns were expressed about impact on the wetlands, timing of construction, traffic capacity and signals, and other issues by the Committee members. The Lockmueller team reiterated their opinion that there is no other alignment that could be done that will not have similar or more impacts as what has already been shared with the Committee. Mr. Costa stated that although he could not speak for the Federal Highway Administration, but based on his experience, his professional opinion is that the horizontal bypass would be a difficult project for them to approve. Mr. Colin noted that what he has heard from SCDOT concerning the southern bypass is that it has a very, very small chance, if any, of advancing through the process. Timing of integration of the Windmill Harbour and Moss Creek lights into the adaptive signal system was also discussed. Mr. Advocaat pointed out the Southern Bypass would remove traffic from the regular US 278, and it could be made a toll road if the Town chooses to do so, and would then be a significant source of income. 4. Appearance by Citizens Public comments concerning agenda items were to be submitted electronically via the Open Town Hall Portal. No comments were received through the Portal, and no requests were received to appear before the Committee regarding non-agenda items. Several citizens appeared before the Committee and provided comments. Christopher Cliffe commented that the SCDOT letter was quite explicit, with the Preferred Alternative being the only solution in their view, with no comments about the Lochmueller proposal, so it would appear they are making it quite clear that they are only prepared to Page 14 of 300 Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 5/8/2024 Page | 9 consider their option. He asked about a time constraint possible on the life span of the EA documents. He mentioned that Craig Winn had made it quite clear that the deficiencies in the McKay bridge had been provided for at a figure of $40M, but the seismic study numbers revealed today, there is no comparison, and questioned where the $40M figure came from. He also mentioned that Craig Winn had made it clear that Jenkins Island was not an accident hot spot, but the 6 fatalities shown on accident data presented today all involved DUI, so including accident data in SCDOT's Preferred Alternative is slightly misleading. The 6-lanes being pushed by everyone only pushes congestion further down the road, and the SCDOT Alternative is not a solution at all. Mr. Baer congratulated the job being done by the Committee to rationalize that the SCDOT plan is the one and only true plan with the studies based on a few key principles of staying in SCDOT's footprint and questioned who authorized this. Secondly, he suggested they have ignored proving the congestion problem has been solved. He questioned where is the stress test if you get more than expected, which he predicted would be 4,000 vehicles per hour and the plan was unproven and would not actually work, and the data has not been presented to support the plan. He noted there is no value being placed on Gullah Geechee land that is being taken, and questions from citizens are being ducked with no answers provided, and called the study the most unscientic study he has ever seen. Gray Smith commented on time saved eastbound and westbound reported by Lochmueller, using percentages that make it look worse. Today, the eastbound AM in 2045 would be 7 minutes longer if nothing was done, and westbound coming out would be 5 minutes longer and questioned the $500M being spent for this. He questioned the SCDOT rejection of all Alternatives except their own, and erred at the beginning of this project by ending it at Spanish Wells Road rather than include the adjacent major roadways that are integral to the project, namely Spanish Wells Road and Gumtree Road, which they say cannot be considered as part of the project without greatly extending the time of construction. He commented that as a 12- year Hilton Head Island resident, he is being asked to accept an inferior product at the outrageous cost of $500M, and he finds this totally unacceptable and asked the Committee to do the same. Louise Cohen, a native of Hilton Head Island, noted she is a member of the 5th generation of her family. She reminded the Committee members that as they serve and make decisions for other people, they should have a heart and understand how much the highway would affect the community they live in and that was established by their ancestors as their inheritance. Their homes mean as much to them as yours means to you, and she urged them to care about destroying a community, their heritage, and their culture. Richard Busy expressed his surprise that the beaurocrats in Columbia, the SCDOT, liked their plan the best. He noted they don't live here - we live here. He noted that due to the vote today, he would await an impartial and independent by the consultants on the Horizontal Bypass Plan. However, Mr, Colin has indicated Town Council will need to approve that, and he questioned whether this was just another obstacle, as this was first time any discussion has been held on the Horizontal Page 15 of 300 Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 5/8/2024 Page | 10 Bypass Plan - a plan which connects directly to the Cross Island Parkway, uses almost no private land, is less than half the price of your Plan #4. He pointed out that more than 50% of the traffic coming onto the Island are bound for the Cross Island Parkway, and yet none of the plans, including the State plan, provide a direct link to the Parkway. He could not understand how an 11-lane, aircraft carrier slab, a/k/a the bridges, is in keeping with preserving the character of Hilton Head Island. Richard Ritter, a member of the Executive Committee of the new Hilton Head-Bluffton branch of the NAAPP, noted they are in the process of drafting and submitting to the Town a letter expressing the concerns of the NAACP about all of the traffic proposals discussed today. The letter must be approved by the membership and then submitted to the State Conference of the NAACP for review and approval, so he could not discuss it in detail. He expected to have the letter ready to be sent to the Mayor within the next 2 weeks. Obviously, the concerns expressed will be about the impact of the plans on the Stoney and Gullah Geechee Community as a whole. He questioned whether it was true that Alternative #1 would have no adverse impact, as they know it will because there are homes on both sides of US 278, as well as business properties, that will be impacted. He noted the Stoney Community is 1 of 14 historic designated communities on Hilton Head Island, putting them in a special place, and his concern is to make sure the interests of this historic neighborhood are being fully accounted for and there are no alternatives that can be discussed and put in place. Sherry Sherman, President of the NAACP, commented she was new to the Island and wanted the Committee to keep in mind that the Gullah Geechee live here and are impacted by the decisions made by the Committee. Trey Graves, born and raised on Hilton Head Island, empathized with the Committee over its complex and difficult decision to be made as to how to solve the traffic congestion problem. He pointed out that 90% of the people in the room would not be sitting in that traffic in 2045, but he probably would be. Although the alternative is radical that was proposed decades ago to put another bridge off the Island, not in the same footprint of the Graves Bridge, but somewhere at the end of Beach City Road that could connect to St. Helena Island that would provide 2 entrances and exits onto the Island, act as a great circle to keep traffic moving, and make it easier for the working people coming from Ridgeland and Hardeeville who sit in 4 pinch points before even reaching the bridge. He acknowledged it would be expensive, would have to be a toll bridge, take extensive engineering, would affect the beauty of the Island, but it is not a problem or solution that the majority of the people affected today and making the decisions today will have to deal with when we are your age. Mr. Colin addressed Mr. Cliffe's question about the life span of the EA by explaining that projects that go through the NEPA process, whether it is an EIS or Environmental Assessment, the information the findings and conclusions are based on has a 3-year life span. So, that expires, then you have to amend or update the information, or potentially go through the entire process again. He indicated the end date for EA is the end of June, 2026. 5. New Business Page 16 of 300 Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 5/8/2024 Page | 11 None. 6. Adjournment Mayor Perry declared the meeting adjourned at 3:41 PM. Approved: The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov Page 17 of 300 Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex One Town Center Court  Hilton Head Island  South Carolina  29928 www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND Willliam Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Advisory Committee TO: Advisory Committee FROM: Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager DATE: June 12 2024 SUBJECT: Transmittal of Meeting Materials from the Lochmueller Group Agenda RECOMMENDATION: This memo serves as the transmittal document to cover the materials submitted for consideration by the Lochmueller Group. This material will be covered at the June 12, 2024 meeting of the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Advisory Committee. ATTACHMENTS: 1. The Lochmueller Group Document Transmittal Memo – dated June 10, 2024 2. Independent Study of WHP Corridor – Summary of Submitted Memorandums by the Lochmueller Group – June 10, 2024 3. WHP Committee Presentation – dated June 12, 2024 4. Technical Memorandum – Downstream Impacts to Task 4 Intersections – dated June 10, 2024 Page 18 of 300 TRANSMITTAL To: Shawn Colin, AICP – Town of Hilton Head Island From: Nate Nohren, PE, PTOE Date: June 10, 2024 Subject: Copies of Presentation Materials for 6/12/2024 Advisory Committee Meeting RE: William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Indepen dent Review Hi Shawn, Attached please find a PDF copy of the power point slides we will be presenting at the June 12, 2024, Advisory Committee meeting. The content provided w ithin our presentation can be summarized as follows: • Update on Project Progress – we will provide the Committee an update on what our team has been working on and/or completed since the May 8 Co mmittee meeting. We also provide current status of percent-of-work completed to date , as well as on-going or upcoming work subtasks, relative to Tasks 1, 2, 3, and 4 as describe d in the Town approved Scope of Services Addendum (9/29/2023). • Presentation of Downstream Impacts to Task 4 Interse ctions (Assuming Implementation of Modified Alternative 1 from Task 3) – we will present our findings related to the anti cipated impacts to intersections downstream of Gum Tree Roa d and Cross Island Parkway, assuming the implementation of the “modified” Alternative #1, whi ch includes the implementation of a single eastbound left-turn and a single southbound right-t urn lane at Squire Pope Road. We have also attached a PDF copy of the technical m emorandum we’ve prepared that details our findings related to the evaluation of downstream impacts to Task 4 intersections, which includes accompanying data tables and exhibits. Finally, we have also included a “Summary of Submit ted Memorandums” PDF, which includes all memorandums that Lochmueller has completed and subm itted to Town staff, as of June 10, 2024. Please let me know if you have any questions regard ing the information shared above. Otherwise, we look forward to speaking with you all on June 12. Sincerely, Nate Nohren, PE, PTOE Page 19 of 300 William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee Meeting June 12 th , 2024 Page 20 of 300 Agenda  Update on Project Progress  Presentation of Downstream Impacts to Task 4 Intersections (Assuming Implementation of Modified Alternative 1 from Task 3)  Questions Page 21 of 300 Update on Project Progress (Key Tasks Completed & Continuing to Work on Since Last Meeting )  Completed evaluations RE: impacts to Task 4 intersections (assuming implementation of Modified Alternative 1 from Task 3)  Continue traffic analyses and modeling (Synchro/VISSIM ) to determine proposed mitigation strategies for 2045 Build Year conditions at intersections downstream of CIP Page 22 of 300 • Task #1: Project Initiation and Coordination o ~98% Complete o Key Subtasks On-Going:  Remaining scheduled meetings with Town staff Update on Overall Project Progress (as of 6/10/24) 98% 2% Overall ~75% Complete 75% 25% Page 23 of 300 Update on Overall Project Progress (as of 6/10/24) Task #2: Review of Travel Demand Model & Evaluation of 2023 Existing Operating Conditions (Entire Study Area) o 100% Complete 100% Page 24 of 300 Update on Overall Project Progress (as of 6/10/24) • Task #3: Traffic Model and Operational Update – Modified Original Project Study Area o ~90% Complete o Key Subtasks Forthcoming:  Prepare for and present results of Final Summary of Findings Memo RE: Task #3 Alternatives Analysis to be presented to Town Council (6/17 & 6/18) 90% 10% Page 25 of 300 Update on Overall Project Progress (as of 6/10/24) • Task #4: Traffic Model and Operational Update – Entire Project Study Area o ~50% Complete o Key Subtasks On-Going:  Continue traffic analyses and modeling (Synchro/VISSIM ) to determine proposed mitigation strategies for 2045 Build Year conditions at intersections downstream of CIP o Key Subtasks Forthcoming:  Prepare Draft Summary of Findings memo RE: Task 4 analyses (Task 4.4)  Presentation of Task 4 findings to Town Council (date TBD) (Task 4.5) 50% 50% Page 26 of 300 Update on Overall Project Progress (as of 6/10/24) • Task #5: Final Report o Will commence immediately following Task 4 Page 27 of 300 Review Topics • Independent Study Goals • Reported Results Include the Following: o Level of Service (LOS) A - F o Delay (seconds) o 95 th Percentile Queue Length (feet) o Specifies a queue that is typically exceeded only once or twice during the day o Maximum Queue Length (feet) o Lane Capacity Level of Service Control Delay per Vehicle (sec/veh) Signalized Unsignalized A < 10 0-10 B > 10-20 > 10-15 C > 20-35 > 15-25 D > 35-55 > 25-35 E > 55-80 > 35-50 F > 80 > 50 Page 28 of 300 Review Topics • Traffic Volumes: • Hourly traffic volumes collected on March 22, 2023 were used for all scenarios • Corridor studies often reference the 30th highest day for traffic volumes to ensure that the volumes used in the analysis responsibly reflect peak conditions, while not over- or under- estimating the traffic volumes. • Historical traffic data was obtained from SCDOT from the most recent 365 days. Based on the data, it was determined that March 30, 2023 was the 30th highest day out of the year for traffic volumes. The counts collected on March 22, 2023 were adjusted to align with the estimated traffic volumes on March 30, 2023. • The volumes used in the study were provided during the Committee Meeting on March 27, 2024 as well as in the Corridor Alternatives Analysis Memorandum submitted on May 3, 2024. Excerpts are provided in the following slides. • Stress Testing / Sensitivity Analysis • Per the scope of services, only the 2023 existing conditions and 2045 future year under one growth rate is to be evaluated. If the recommended improvements hold in 2045, then it is assumed that they would also work in the years 2025, 2030, 2035, and 2040 as those years would have lower traffic volumes than 2045. Page 29 of 300 9 10 11 12 9 AM Peak Hour Volumes PM Peak Hour Volumes 212 0 45 43 1425 2 2 0 5 156 2620 2 US 278 Squire Pope Rd 11 12 70 127 56 1281 71 121 43 121 43 2481 146 US 278 Spanish Wells Rd 12 US 278 Gumtree Rd 10 US 278 Old Wild Horse Rd 20 1394 76 2670 92 179 212 189 775 193 8 144 290 154 1527 6 9 341 2 41 57 2687 2 2 25 2 222 1992 29 US 278 Squire Pope Rd 11 33 78 62 84 2508 31 259 47 60 51 1869 115 US 278 Spanish Wells Rd 12 US 278 Gumtree Rd 10 US 278 Old Wild Horse Rd 64 2736 10 2035 107 183 242 326 1542 195 224 207 277 125 1065 23 2023 Existing Traffic Volumes Page 30 of 300 9 10 11 12 2045 No Build Traffic Volumes • 0.56% Annual Growth Rate Applied 9 AM Peak Hour Volumes PM Peak Hour Volumes 240 0 51 49 1612 2 2 0 6 176 2963 2 US 278 Squire Pope Rd 11 14 79 144 63 1449 80 137 49 137 49 2806 165 US 278 Spanish Wells Rd 12 US 278 Gumtree Rd 10 US 278 Old Wild Horse Rd 23 1577 86 3020 104 202 240 214 876 218 9 163 328 174 1727 7 9 386 2 46 64 3039 2 2 28 2 251 2253 33 US 278 Squire Pope Rd 11 37 88 70 95 2837 35 293 53 68 58 2113 130 US 278 Spanish Wells Rd 12 US 278 Gumtree Rd 10 US 278 Old Wild Horse Rd 73 3094 11 2301 121 207 274 369 1745 220 253 234 313 141 1204 26 Page 31 of 300 Downstream Impacts to Task 4 Intersections (Assuming Implementation of Modified Alternative 1) • Lochmueller previously analyzed four alternatives intended to improve the operating conditions along US 278 between Moss Creek Dr and Gumtree Rd. • After review of the findings and discussion with SCDOT, Lochmueller was directed by the Town of Hilton Head Island to pursue Alternative 1: SCDOT Modified Recommended Preferred with modifications to provide a single eastbound left-turn lane and a single southbound right-turn lane at US 278 at Squire Pope Rd. • As a next step, Lochmueller evaluated the impacts the modified Alternative 1 would have on the entire project study area and determined what, if any, improvements should be made to accommodate the 2045 forecasted traffic. Page 32 of 300 Downstream Impacts to Task 4 Intersections (Assuming Implementation of Modified Alternative 1) Page 33 of 300 Downstream Impacts to Task 4 Intersections (Assuming Implementation of Modified Alternative 1) Corridor 2045 No Build Simulated travel time (secs) 2045 Modified Alternative 1 Simulated Travel Time (secs) % Difference AM PM AM PM AM PM Hilton Parkway between Moss Creek and Indigo Run EB 1579 642 628 631 -60.23% -1.71% WB 584 1544 597 616 2.23% -60.10% Hilton Parkway @Moss Creek to Cross Island Parkway @Sea Pine SB 1984 873 1387 874 -30.09% 0.11% NB 823 2465 848 904 3.04% -63.33% o VISSIM travel time results: o Under the 2045 No Build scenario, it is expected that it would take approximately 26.3 minutes to travel eastbound along Hilton Parkway between Moss Creek and Indigo Run during the AM peak hour. It is expected that the travel time will be reduced to approximately 10.5 minutes under the modified Alternative 1. o Under the 2045 No Build scenario, it is expected that it would take approximately 25.7 minutes to travel westbound along Hilton Parkway between Moss Creek and Indigo Run during the PM peak hour. It is expected that the travel time will be reduced to approximately 10.3 minutes under the modified Alternative 1. Page 34 of 300 Downstream Impacts to Task 4 Intersections (Assuming Implementation of Modified Alternative 1) Video to be inserted AM Eastbound on Hilton Parkway Page 35 of 300 Downstream Impacts to Task 4 Intersections (Assuming Implementation of Modified Alternative 1) Video to be inserted AM Southbound on Cross Island Parkway Page 36 of 300 Video to be inserted Downstream Impacts to Task 4 Intersections (Assuming Implementation of Modified Alternative 1) PM Westbound on Hilton Parkway Page 37 of 300 Downstream Impacts to Task 4 Intersections (Assuming Implementation of Modified Alternative 1) Video to be inserted PM Northbound on Cross Island Parkway Page 38 of 300 Intersection & Movements LOS (Delay, sec) [95 th Queue Length, ft] {Max Queue, ft} AM Peak Hour PM Peak Hour 9: Chamberlin Dr/Squire Pope Rd & Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection A (8.4) B (11.8) Eastbound Approach A (7.0) [102] {697} B (11.3) [124] {484} Westbound Approach A (8.2) [28] {237} A (5.8) [36] {524} Northbound Approach C (30.4) [<25] {56} E (67.0) [<25] {109} Southbound Approach C (22.6) [<25] {170} D (51.1) [128] {521} 10: Old Wild Horse Rd & Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Southbound Approach A (4.7) [<25] {56} B (12.5) [<25] {32} 11: Spanish Wells Rd/Wild Horse Rd & Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection B (16.6) C (23.8) Eastbound Approach B (11.0) [106] {998} C (27.9) [198] {861} Westbound Approach B (11.2) [56] {248} B (11.9) [84] {779} Northbound Approach D (48.6) [45] {135} E (65.2) [77] {196} Southbound Approach E (75.9) [74] {292} E (60.6) [49] {197} 12: Gumtree Rd & Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection D (37.1) D (43.8) Eastbound Approach C (33.4) [164] {682} E (57.1) [184] {562} Westbound Approach D (40.8) [130] {369} D (35.4) [236] {786} Northbound Approach C (26.6) [61] {264} D (37.3) [98] {327} Southbound Approach D (50.2) [93] {302} D (52.7) [119] {453} 10 • EB LT expected to fail during AM peak hour • SB LT expected to fail during PM peak hour • SB RT expected to have queues of over 500 ft during PM peak hour • EB, WB, and SB LT expected to fail during both peak hours 11 9 • WB LT expected to fail during AM peak hour 12 Downstream Impacts to Task 4 Intersections (Assuming Implementation of Modified Alternative 1) Page 39 of 300 Intersection & Movements LOS (Delay, sec) [95 th Queue Length, ft] {Max Queue, ft} AM Peak Hour PM Peak Hour 13: Jarvis Park Rd/Wilborn Rd & Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (26.7) B (18.8) Eastbound Approach C (25.4) [439] {1480} B (16.3) [103] {735} Westbound Approach C (21.6) [101] {686} B (18.2) [295] {1202} Northbound Approach E (68.6) [43] {170} F (87.6) [56] {191} Southbound Approach D (39.1) [66] {228} B (19.2) [29] {112} 14: Pembroke Dr/Museum St & Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (23.1) C (24.5) Eastbound Approach B (18.9) [403] {1224} B (17.2) [128] {910} Westbound Approach C (20.9) [75] {532} C (21.6) [171] {903} Northbound Approach D (53.1) [71] {257} E (60.1) [92] {299} Southbound Approach C (30.4) [<25] {89} D (40.3) [<25] {111} 15: Central Ave & Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn A (7.1) [<25] {<25} C (19.3) [<25] {25} Westbound Left Turn C (24.1) [<25] {26} A (9.5) [<25] {<25} Northbound Right Turn C (16.5) [<25] {27} B (13.9) [<25] {32} Southbound Right Turn B (12.5) [<25] {45} C (18.3) [<25] {38} 16: Hatton Pl/Merchant St & Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Northbound Right Turn A (9.5) [<25] {28} A (7.8) [<25] {63} Southbound Right Turn B (11.3) [<25] {36} C (22.9) [<25] {41} 17: Indigo Run Dr/Whooping Crane Way & Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (25.1) D (36.1) Eastbound Approach C (21.1) [134] {846} C (33.6) [128] {751} Westbound Approach B (17.3) [53] {359} C (28.0) [207] {887} Northbound Approach E (56.6) [33] {114} E (66.9) [65] {268} Southbound Approach D (47.7) [56] {192} E (57.6) [77] {264} 14 15 16 *Highlighted cells indicate that the maximum queues are expected to extend into the next intersection • WB LT expected to fail during AM peak hour 13 • EB LT and NB TH expected to fail during PM peak hour 17 Downstream Impacts to Task 4 Intersections (Assuming Implementation of Modified Alternative 1) Page 40 of 300 Intersection & Movements LOS (Delay, sec) [95 th Queue Length, ft] {Max Queue, ft} AM Peak Hour PM Peak Hour 27: Palmetto Bay Rd & Target Rd (signal) Overall Intersection C (29.0) B (19.0) Eastbound Approach D (36.9) [1380] {1512} B (15.9) [142] {823} Westbound Approach B (12.9) [39] {249} B (15.8) [85] {539} Northbound Approach C (26.6) [<25] {105} D (39.5) [65] {263} Southbound Approach D (35.7) [34] {151} C (25.5) [37] {140} 28: Palmetto Bay Rd & Dunnagans Alley (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn F (1,033.8) [80] {183} F (101.3) [<25] {99} Westbound Right Turn F (91.9) [109] {217} B (13.3) [35] {134} Southbound Left Turn C (22.0) [278] {513} B (13.7) [29] {465} 29: Palmetto Bay Rd & Hilton Pkwy (Sea Pines Circle, RAB) Overall Intersection F (53.4) F (79.2) Eastbound Approach F (314.9) [809] {838} F (179.8) [805] {838} Westbound Approach B (14.0) [56] {420} F (189.7) [1644] {1658} Northbound Approach A (4.1) [<25] {209} F (52.9) [463] {788} Southbound Approach C (18.5) [307] {461} A (9.1) [111] {460} 27 28 • Significant queueing along Palmetto Bay Rd is anticipated as a result of the failing roundabout. This queuing will result in long delays for WB left-turns at unsignalized intersections. 29 Downstream Impacts to Task 4 Intersections (Assuming Implementation of Modified Alternative 1) Page 41 of 300 Next Steps • Evaluate potential improvements to mitigate long queues and delays at intersections downstream of Gumtree Rd and Cross Island Parkway • Improvements may include: • Reconfiguring intersections and turn lanes to improve efficiency • Addition of lanes to improve capacity • Sea Pines roundabout improvements Page 42 of 300 QUESTIONS? https://www.islandpacket.com/news/local/traffic/article235209867.html Page 43 of 300 APPENDIX https://www.islandpacket.com/news/local/traffic/article235209867.html Page 44 of 300 2045 Modified Alternative 1 Results (VISSIM) No Improvements East of Gumtree Rd Intersection & Movements LOS (Delay, sec) [95 th Queue Length, ft] {Max Queue, ft} AM Peak Hour PM Peak Hour 1: Buckingham Plantation Dr & Bluffton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection B (17.0) B (17.3) Eastbound Approach B (19.6) [63] {351} C (20.4) [50] {242} Westbound Approach B (12.9) [<25] {188} B (16.0) [51] {406} Northbound Approach B (14.3) [<25] {74} B (14.2) [<25] {52} Southbound Approach A (6.6) [<25] {57} A (9.6) [<25] {91} 2: Buckingham Plantation Dr/Moss Creek Dr & Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection B (15.8) B (19.7) Eastbound Approach B (14.6) [59] {389} B (15.2) [51] {313} Westbound Approach B (15.7) [41] {286} C (21.5) [127] {700} Northbound Approach B (20.0) [<25] {159} D (37.5) [<25] {104} Southbound Approach C (22.8) [<25] {84} C (26.3) [<25] {116} 3: Salt Marsh Dr/Moss Creek Village & Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn A (8.0) [<25] {<25} C (17.1) [<25] {50} Westbound Left Turn A (8.7) [<25] {<25} A (8.3) [<25] {46} Northbound Approach B (11.3) [<25] {65} B (10.7) [<25] {66} Southbound Approach A (8.6) [<25] {79} B (10.5) [<25] {80} 4: Fording Island Rd Ext & Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn C (16.7) [<25] {<25} C (15.6) [<25] {32} Northbound Approach B (13.3) [<25] {37} B (12.1) [<25] {43} 1 2 4 3 Page 45 of 300 2045 Modified Alternative 1 Results (VISSIM) No Improvements East of Gumtree Rd Jenkins Rd 5 7 Crosstree Dr Intersection & Movements LOS (Delay, sec) [95 th Queue Length, ft] <v/c ratio> AM Peak Hour PM Peak Hour 5: Boat Landing Driveway/Wildlife Refuge Driveway & Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Northbound Right-Turn A (7.7) [<25] {<25} A (6.4) [<25] {<25} Southbound Right-Turn No volumes observed C (16.2) [<25] {25} 6: Blue Heron Point Rd & Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Intersection combined with Crosstree Dr 7: Crosstree Dr (Windmill Harbour) & Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection A (9.5) A (7.3) Eastbound Approach A (8.9) [80] {818} A (9.2) [58] {581} Westbound Approach A (8.6) [36] {330} A (3.3) [31] {188} Northbound Approach D (42.5) [<25] {124} E (58.1) [61] {244} Southbound Approach D (50.9) [<25] {92} D (44.9) [<25] {101} 8: Jenkins Rd & Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Intersection combined with Crosstree Dr Page 46 of 300 Intersection & Movements LOS (Delay, sec) [95 th Queue Length, ft] {Max Queue, ft} AM Peak Hour PM Peak Hour 9: Chamberlin Dr/Squire Pope Rd & Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection A (8.4) B (11.8) Eastbound Approach A (7.0) [102] {697} B (11.3) [124] {484} Westbound Approach A (8.2) [28] {237} A (5.8) [36] {524} Northbound Approach C (30.4) [<25] {56} E (67.0) [<25] {109} Southbound Approach C (22.6) [<25] {170} D (51.1) [128] {521} 10: Old Wild Horse Rd & Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Southbound Approach A (4.7) [<25] {56} B (12.5) [<25] {32} 11: Spanish Wells Rd/Wild Horse Rd & Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection B (16.6) C (23.8) Eastbound Approach B (11.0) [106] {998} C (27.9) [198] {861} Westbound Approach B (11.2) [56] {248} B (11.9) [84] {779} Northbound Approach D (48.6) [45] {135} E (65.2) [77] {196} Southbound Approach E (75.9) [74] {292} E (60.6) [49] {197} 12: Gumtree Rd & Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection D (37.1) D (43.8) Eastbound Approach C (33.4) [164] {682} E (57.1) [184] {562} Westbound Approach D (40.8) [130] {369} D (35.4) [236] {786} Northbound Approach C (26.6) [61] {264} D (37.3) [98] {327} Southbound Approach D (50.2) [93] {302} D (52.7) [119] {453} 10 11 9 12 Downstream Impacts to Task 4 Intersections (Assuming Implementation of Modified Alternative 1) Page 47 of 300 Intersection & Movements LOS (Delay, sec) [95 th Queue Length, ft] {Max Queue, ft} AM Peak Hour PM Peak Hour 13: Jarvis Park Rd/Wilborn Rd & Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (26.7) B (18.8) Eastbound Approach C (25.4) [439] {1480} B (16.3) [103] {735} Westbound Approach C (21.6) [101] {686} B (18.2) [295] {1202} Northbound Approach E (68.6) [43] {170} F (87.6) [56] {191} Southbound Approach D (39.1) [66] {228} B (19.2) [29] {112} 14: Pembroke Dr/Museum St & Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (23.1) C (24.5) Eastbound Approach B (18.9) [403] {1224} B (17.2) [128] {910} Westbound Approach C (20.9) [75] {532} C (21.6) [171] {903} Northbound Approach D (53.1) [71] {257} E (60.1) [92] {299} Southbound Approach C (30.4) [<25] {89} D (40.3) [<25] {111} 15: Central Ave & Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn A (7.1) [<25] {<25} C (19.3) [<25] {25} Westbound Left Turn C (24.1) [<25] {26} A (9.5) [<25] {<25} Northbound Right Turn C (16.5) [<25] {27} B (13.9) [<25] {32} Southbound Right Turn B (12.5) [<25] {45} C (18.3) [<25] {38} 16: Hatton Pl/Merchant St & Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Northbound Right Turn A (9.5) [<25] {28} A (7.8) [<25] {63} Southbound Right Turn B (11.3) [<25] {36} C (22.9) [<25] {41} 17: Indigo Run Dr/Whooping Crane Way & Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (25.1) D (36.1) Eastbound Approach C (21.1) [134] {846} C (33.6) [128] {751} Westbound Approach B (17.3) [53] {359} C (28.0) [207] {887} Northbound Approach E (56.6) [33] {114} E (66.9) [65] {268} Southbound Approach D (47.7) [56] {192} E (57.6) [77] {264} 14 15 16 13 17 Downstream Impacts to Task 4 Intersections (Assuming Implementation of Modified Alternative 1) Page 48 of 300 2045 Modified Alternative 1 Results (VISSIM) No Improvements East of Gumtree Rd Intersection & Movements LOS (Delay, sec) [95 th Queue Length, ft] {Max Queue, ft} AM Peak Hour PM Peak Hour 18: Cross Island Pkwy SB Ramp/Gumtree Rd & Honey Horn Rd (un-signalized) Eastbound Approach B (11.4) [<25] {45} B (10.9) [<25] {69} 19: Cross Island Pkwy SB Ramp & Marshland Rd (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn A (4.5) [<25] {63} A (2.4) [<25] {70} Southbound Left Turn A (6.1) [<25] {85} A (8.7) [<25] {127} Southbound Right Turn A (9.0) [<25] {51} B (12.2) [<25] {94} 20: Cross Island Pkwy NB Ramp & Marshland Rd (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn A (1.6) [<25] {49} A (1.5) [<25] {<25} Northbound Left Turn B (12.1) [<25] {76} D (27.7) [44] {227} Northbound Right Turn A (6.1) [<25] {101} A (7.5) [61] {252} 18 Honey Horn Rd 19 20 Page 49 of 300 2045 Modified Alternative 1 Results (VISSIM) No Improvements East of Gumtree Rd Intersection & Movements LOS (Delay, sec) [95 th Queue Length, ft] {Max Queue, ft} AM Peak Hour PM Peak Hour 21: Palmetto Bay Rd & Bay Pines Rd (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn No volumes observed E (47.6) [<25] {40} Eastbound Right Turn D (29.7) [<25] {41} C (17.8) [<25] {38} Northbound Left Turn F (91.9) [<25] {60} A (8.1) [<25] {26} 22: Palmetto Bay Rd & Point Comfort Rd/Arrow Rd (signal) Overall Intersection C (33.0) B (19.9) Eastbound Approach E (63.8) [98] {338} C (30.6) [40] {184} Westbound Approach C (21.9) [26] {112} C (28.0) [79] {328} Northbound Approach B (16.9) [50] {314} B (16.6) [99] {607} Southbound Approach D (36.4) [840] {1658} B (19.2) [120] {745} 23: Palmetto Bay Rd & Genesta St (un-signalized) Westbound Approach F (303.0) [78] {175} D (25.2) [<25] {54} Southbound Left Turn C (19.7) [494] {946} B (13.6) [<25] {26} 24: Palmetto Bay Rd & Palmetto Business Park Rd (un-signalized) Westbound Approach F (163.9) [109] {214} C (17.9) [<25] {59} Southbound Left Turn B (10.5) [233] {419} A (9.9) [<25] {<25} 25: Palmetto Bay Rd & Bow Cir (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn F (207.8) [89] {174} E (45.5) [<25] {40} Westbound Right Turn F (70.2) [118] {207} B (13.0) [<25] {74} Southbound Left Turn D (30.8) [1399] {1658} B (14.3) [<25] {28} 26: Palmetto Bay Rd & Archer Rd (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn F (2,462.0) [73] {88} E (35.5) [<25] {39} Westbound Right Turn B (13.2) [109] {125} B (12.9) [<25] {76} Southbound Left Turn C (22.2) [380] {493} B (11.6) [<25] {28} 22 23 24 25 26 21 Bay Pines Rd Page 50 of 300 Intersection & Movements LOS (Delay, sec) [95 th Queue Length, ft] {Max Queue, ft} AM Peak Hour PM Peak Hour 27: Palmetto Bay Rd & Target Rd (signal) Overall Intersection C (29.0) B (19.0) Eastbound Approach D (36.9) [1380] {1512} B (15.9) [142] {823} Westbound Approach B (12.9) [39] {249} B (15.8) [85] {539} Northbound Approach C (26.6) [<25] {105} D (39.5) [65] {263} Southbound Approach D (35.7) [34] {151} C (25.5) [37] {140} 28: Palmetto Bay Rd & Dunnagans Alley (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn F (1,033.8) [80] {183} F (101.3) [<25] {99} Westbound Right Turn F (91.9) [109] {217} B (13.3) [35] {134} Southbound Left Turn C (22.0) [278] {513} B (13.7) [29] {465} 29: Palmetto Bay Rd & Hilton Pkwy (Sea Pines Circle, RAB) Overall Intersection F (53.4) F (79.2) Eastbound Approach F (314.9) [809] {838} F (179.8) [805] {838} Westbound Approach B (14.0) [56] {420} F (189.7) [1644] {1658} Northbound Approach A (4.1) [<25] {209} F (52.9) [463] {788} Southbound Approach C (18.5) [307] {461} A (9.1) [111] {460} 27 28 29 Downstream Impacts to Task 4 Intersections (Assuming Implementation of Modified Alternative 1) Page 51 of 300 MEMO Huntington Tower, 201 W Springfield Avenue, Suite 1012 Champaign, Illinois 61820 PHONE: 217.673.7633 To: Town of Hilton Head, South Carolina From: Lochmueller Group Date: June 10, 2024 Subject: Independent Study of the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Downstream Impacts to Task 4 Intersections Memorandum – Task 4.4 Lochmueller Group (Lochmueller) has prepared the following memorandum pertaining to the Independent Study of the William Hilton Pkwy Gateway Corridor. Lochmueller previously submitted a Technical Memorandum dated May 3, 2024, which summarized four alternatives intended to improve the operating conditions along US 278 between Moss Creek Dr and Gumtree Rd. After review of the findings and discussion with SCDOT, Lochmueller was directed by the Town of Hilton Head Island to pursue Alternative 1: SCDOT Modified Recommended Preferred with modifications to provide a single eastbound left-turn lane and a single southbound right-turn lane at US 278 at Squire Pope Rd. As a next step, Lochmueller evaluated the impacts Alternative 1 would have on the entire project study area and determined what, if any, improvements should be made to accommodate the 2045 forecasted traffic at the intersections downstream of Gumtree Rd. The intention of this memorandum is to provide the Town of Hilton Head with the findings related to traffic impacts that would be seen within the entire project area which includes US 278 from Moss Creek Drive to Indigo Run Drive, as well as US 278 (Palmetto Bay Road) from Cross Island Pkwy to Sea Pines Circle, assuming Alternative 1: SCDOT Modified Recommended Preferred with modifications is implemented. For the purposes of this memorandum, no additional physical improvements were modeled for intersections downstream of Gumtree Rd or Cross Island Parkway; however, those improvements were modeled as part of Lochmueller’s next deliverable. Figure 1 shows the entire project area which was used for the analysis. Page 52 of 300 June 10, 2024 Page 2 FIGURE 1. ENTIRE PROJECT STUDY AREA Downstream Impacts As previously stated, the Town of Hilton Head Island directed Lochmueller to proceed with Alternative 1: SCDOT Modified Recommended Preferred with modifications to provide a single eastbound left-turn lane and a single southbound right-turn lane at US 278 at Squire Pope Rd. As such, Lochmueller was tasked to evaluate the impacts of the Modified Alternative 1 on the intersections downstream of Gumtree Rd and Cross Island Parkway. It should be noted that the results shown in this memorandum include the adaptive signals as well as the previously recommended improvements at Gumtree Rd. The improvements at Gumtree Rd include keeping the intersections at-grade; completely reconfiguring the intersection to improve its efficiency; and providing dual left-turn lanes for the westbound, northbound, and southbound approaches. Figure 2 displays SCDOT's recommended improvements for Alternative 1, excluding Gumtree Rd upgrades. Page 53 of 300 June 10, 2024 Page 3 FIGURE 2. ALTERNATIVE 1: SCDOT MODIFIED RECOMMENDED PREFERRED Page 54 of 300 June 10, 2024 Page 4 Modified Alternative 1 Traffic Analysis The travel time calculations and traffic volumes between the 2045 No Build conditions and the 2045 Modified Alternative 1 conditions were evaluated using VISSIM which provides microsimulation travel time results along corridors. The traffic volumes used for the 2045 Modified Alternative 1 analysis are the same traffic volumes provided in the Technical Memorandum dated May 3, 2024. As shown in Table 1, under the 2045 No Build scenario, it is expected that it would take approximately 26.3 minutes to travel eastbound along Hilton Parkway between Moss Creek and Indigo Run during the AM peak hour. It is expected that the travel time will be reduced to approximately 10.5 minutes under the Modified Alternative 1. Under the 2045 No Build scenario, it is expected that it would take approximately 25.7 minutes to travel westbound along Hilton Parkway between Moss Creek and Indigo Run during the PM peak hour. It is expected that the travel time will be reduced to approximately 10.3 minutes under the Modified Alternative 1. TABLE 1. 2045 VISSIM TRAVEL TIME RESULTS Corridor 2045 No Build Simulated travel time (secs) 2045 Modified Alternative 1 Simulated travel time (secs) % Difference AM PM AM PM AM PM William Hilton Pkwy between Moss Creek and Indigo Run EB 1579 642 628 631 -60.23% -1.71% WB 584 1544 597 616 2.23% -60.10% William Hilton Pkwy @Moss Creek to Cross Island Pkwy @Sea Pine SB 1984 873 1387 874 -30.09% 0.11% NB 823 2465 848 904 3.04% -63.33% The 2045 Modified Alternative 1 operating conditions at the study intersections were evaluated using VISSIM, which is a microsimulation tool that replicates individual vehicles and their interactions within complex traffic streams, such as interchanges, freeways, and expressway corridors with signalized intersections. Intersection performance or traffic operations are quantified by six Levels of Service (LOS), which range from LOS A ("Free Flow”) to LOS F ("Fully Saturated"). LOS D is considered acceptable for peak period conditions in urban and suburban areas. However, at side-street stop-controlled intersections, a LOS E or even a LOS F is a common occurrence for peak period conditions in urban and suburban areas as it is typical for delays to be longer for vehicles along the side -street as they wait to find acceptable gaps in the traffic to turn left into the traffic stream. Levels of service for intersections are determined based on the average d elay experienced by motorists. Signalized intersections reflect higher delay tolerances as compared to unsignalized and roundabout locations because motorists are accustomed to and accepting of longer delays at signals. For signalized and all-way stop intersections, the average control delay per vehicle is estimated for each movement and then aggregated for each approach and the intersection as a whole. For intersections with partial ( side- street) stop control, the delay is calculated for the minor movements only (side -street approaches and major road left-turns) since thru traffic on the major road is not required to stop. Page 55 of 300 June 10, 2024 Page 5 Table 2 summarizes the criterion for both signalized and unsignalized inte rsections, as defined by the Highway Capacity Manual (HCM) 6th Edition, last updated in 2016 by the Transportation Research Board. TABLE 2. INTERSECTION LEVEL OF SERVICE THRESHOLDS Level of Service Control Delay per Vehicle (sec/veh) Signalized Unsignalized/Roundabout A < 10 0-10 B > 10-20 > 10-15 C > 20-35 > 15-25 D > 35-55 > 25-35 E > 55-80 > 35-50 F > 80 > 50 The 2045 Modified Alternative 1 operating conditions are provided in Table 3. As shown, with the improvements proposed under the Modified Alternative 1, the study intersections are largely expected to operate favorably in the year 2045, with some exceptions. The eastbound and westbound through movements along US 278 are expected to operate with an overall LOS D or better between Moss Creek Dr and Gumtree Rd. While some of the side-street approaches at unsignalized intersections are still expected to experience failing conditions, the operations overall are significantly improved from the 2045 No Build scenario as vehicles can better complete their turning movement due to the reduction in congestion along the eastbound and westbound mainline. The intersections downstream of Gumtree Rd are largely expected to operate favorably in 2045 with no improvements in place. However, long eastbound queues extending from Pembroke Dr through Gumtree Rd are expected during the AM peak hour. Similarly, the westbound queue at Jarvis Park Rd/Wilborn Rd is expected to extend back to Pembroke Dr during the PM peak hour. Furthermore, the mainline is expected to be over capacity in the year 2045. However, overall, the intersections are expected to operate acceptably with an overall LOS D or better during both peak periods. As shown, the northbound approach at Jarvis Park Rd/Wilborn Rd is expected to have a failing LOS during the PM peak hour. It should be noted that this approach has minimal traffic volumes and the maximum queue expected is only approximately 200 ft. The eastbound left-turn movement at Indigo Run Dr is also expected to fail during the PM peak hour. The maximum queue length is expected to be approximately 335 ft, which would be contained within the existing turn lane. Along Palmetto Bay Rd, the roundabout at Sea Pines is expected to fail during both AM and PM peak hours. The failing conditions result in long queue lengths. The southbound queue is expected to extend past the study intersection at Target Rd and towards Point Comfort Rd during the AM peak hour. This results in failing movements for the westbound left-turns out of the unsignalized intersections along Palmetto Bay Rd as vehicles are unable to find a gap in the traffic to complete thei r turning movement. During the PM peak hour, nearly every approach of Sea Pines Circle is expected to fail in 2045 with no improvements in place as the roundabout is unable to accommodate the expected traffic volumes. Page 56 of 300 June 10, 2024 Page 6 TABLE 3. 2045 MODIFIED ALTERNATIVE 1 OPERATING CONDITIONS (VISSIM) Intersection & Movements LOS (Delay, sec) [95th Queue Length, ft] {Max Queue, ft} AM Peak Hour PM Peak Hour 1: Buckingham Plantation Dr & Bluffton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection B (17.0) B (17.3) Eastbound Approach B (19.6) [63] {351} C (20.4) [50] {242} Westbound Approach B (12.9) [<25] {188} B (16.0) [51] {406} Northbound Approach B (14.3) [<25] {74} B (14.2) [<25] {52} Southbound Approach A (6.6) [<25] {57} A (9.6) [<25] {91} 2: Buckingham Plantation Dr/Moss Creek Dr & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection B (15.8) B (19.7) Eastbound Approach B (14.6) [59] {389} B (15.2) [51] {313} Westbound Approach B (15.7) [41] {286} C (21.5) [127] {700} Northbound Approach B (20.0) [<25] {159} D (37.5) [<25] {104} Southbound Approach C (22.8) [<25] {84} C (26.3) [<25] {116} 3: Salt Marsh Dr/Moss Creek Village & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn A (8.0) [<25] {<25} C (17.1) [<25] {50} Westbound Left Turn A (8.7) [<25] {<25} A (8.3) [<25] {46} Northbound Approach B (11.3) [<25] {65} B (10.7) [<25] {66} Southbound Approach A (8.6) [<25] {79} B (10.5) [<25] {80} 4: Fording Island Rd Ext & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn C (16.7) [<25] {<25} C (15.6) [<25] {32} Northbound Approach B (13.3) [<25] {37} B (12.1) [<25] {43} 5: Boat Landing Driveway/Wildlife Refuge Driveway & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Northbound Right-Turn A (7.7) [<25] {<25} A (6.4) [<25] {<25} Southbound Right-Turn No volumes observed C (16.2) [<25] {25} 6: Blue Heron Point Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Intersection combined with Crosstree Dr 7: Crosstree Dr (Windmill Harbour) & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection A (9.5) A (7.3) Eastbound Approach A (8.9) [80] {818} A (9.2) [58] {581} Westbound Approach A (8.6) [36] {330} A (3.3) [31] {188} Northbound Approach D (42.5) [<25] {124} E (58.1) [61] {244} Southbound Approach D (50.9) [<25] {92} D (44.9) [<25] {101} Page 57 of 300 June 10, 2024 Page 7 8: Jenkins Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Intersection combined with Crosstree Dr 9: Chamberlin Dr/Squire Pope Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection A (8.4) B (11.8) Eastbound Approach A (7.0) [102] {697} B (11.3) [124] {484} Westbound Approach A (8.2) [28] {237} A (5.8) [36] {524} Northbound Approach C (30.4) [<25] {56} E (67.0) [<25] {109} Southbound Approach C (22.6) [<25] {170} D (51.1) [128] {521} 10: Old Wild Horse Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Southbound Approach A (4.7) [<25] {56} B (12.5) [<25] {32} 11: Spanish Wells Rd/Wild Horse Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection B (16.6) C (23.8) Eastbound Approach B (11.0) [106] {998} C (27.9) [198] {861} Westbound Approach B (11.2) [56] {248} B (11.9) [84] {779} Northbound Approach D (48.6) [45] {135} E (65.2) [77] {196} Southbound Approach E (75.9) [74] {292} E (60.6) [49] {197} 12: Gumtree Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection D (37.1) D (43.8) Eastbound Approach C (33.4) [164] {682} E (57.1) [184] {562} Westbound Approach D (40.8) [130] {369} D (35.4) [236] {786} Northbound Approach C (26.6) [61] {264} D (37.3) [98] {327} Southbound Approach D (50.2) [93] {302} D (52.7) [119] {453} 13: Jarvis Park Rd/Wilborn Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (26.7) B (18.8) Eastbound Approach C (25.4) [439] {1480} B (16.3) [103] {735} Westbound Approach C (21.6) [101] {686} B (18.2) [295] {1202} Northbound Approach E (68.6) [43] {170} F (87.6) [56] {191} Southbound Approach D (39.1) [66] {228} B (19.2) [29] {112} 14: Pembroke Dr/Museum St & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (23.1) C (24.5) Eastbound Approach B (18.9) [403] {1224} B (17.2) [128] {910} Westbound Approach C (20.9) [75] {532} C (21.6) [171] {903} Northbound Approach D (53.1) [71] {257} E (60.1) [92] {299} Southbound Approach C (30.4) [<25] {89} D (40.3) [<25] {111} Page 58 of 300 June 10, 2024 Page 8 15: Central Ave & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn A (7.1) [<25] {<25} C (19.3) [<25] {25} Westbound Left Turn C (24.1) [<25] {26} A (9.5) [<25] {<25} Northbound Right Turn C (16.5) [<25] {27} B (13.9) [<25] {32} Southbound Right Turn B (12.5) [<25] {45} C (18.3) [<25] {38} 16: Hatton Pl/Merchant St & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Northbound Right Turn A (9.5) [<25] {28} A (7.8) [<25] {63} Southbound Right Turn B (11.3) [<25] {36} C (22.9) [<25] {41} 17: Indigo Run Dr/Whooping Crane Way & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (25.1) D (36.1) Eastbound Approach C (21.1) [134] {846} C (33.6) [128] {751} Westbound Approach B (17.3) [53] {359} C (28.0) [207] {887} Northbound Approach E (56.6) [33] {114} E (66.9) [65] {268} Southbound Approach D (47.7) [56] {192} E (57.6) [77] {264} 18: Cross Island Pkwy SB Ramp/Gumtree Rd & Honey Horn Rd (un-signalized) Eastbound Approach B (11.4) [<25] {45} B (10.9) [<25] {69} 19: Cross Island Pkwy SB Ramp & Marshland Rd (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn A (4.5) [<25] {63} A (2.4) [<25] {70} Southbound Left Turn A (6.1) [<25] {85} A (8.7) [<25] {127} Southbound Right Turn A (9.0) [<25] {51} B (12.2) [<25] {94} 20: Cross Island Pkwy NB Ramp & Marshland Rd (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn A (1.6) [<25] {49} A (1.5) [<25] {<25} Northbound Left Turn B (12.1) [<25] {76} D (27.7) [44] {227} Northbound Right Turn A (6.1) [<25] {101} A (7.5) [61] {252} 21: Palmetto Bay Rd & Bay Pines Rd (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn No volumes observed E (47.6) [<25] {40} Eastbound Right Turn D (29.7) [<25] {41} C (17.8) [<25] {38} Northbound Left Turn F (91.9) [<25] {60} A (8.1) [<25] {26} 22: Palmetto Bay Rd & Point Comfort Rd/Arrow Rd (signal) Overall Intersection C (33.0) B (19.9) Eastbound Approach E (63.8) [98] {338} C (30.6) [40] {184} Westbound Approach C (21.9) [26] {112} C (28.0) [79] {328} Northbound Approach B (16.9) [50] {314} B (16.6) [99] {607} Southbound Approach D (36.4) [840] {1658} B (19.2) [120] {745} Page 59 of 300 June 10, 2024 Page 9 23: Palmetto Bay Rd & Genesta St (un-signalized) Westbound Approach F (303.0) [78] {175} D (25.2) [<25] {54} Southbound Left Turn C (19.7) [494] {946} B (13.6) [<25] {26} 24: Palmetto Bay Rd & Palmetto Business Park Rd (un-signalized) Westbound Approach F (163.9) [109] {214} C (17.9) [<25] {59} Southbound Left Turn B (10.5) [233] {419} A (9.9) [<25] {<25} 25: Palmetto Bay Rd & Bow Cir (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn F (207.8) [89] {174} E (45.5) [<25] {40} Westbound Right Turn F (70.2) [118] {207} B (13.0) [<25] {74} Southbound Left Turn D (30.8) [1399] {1658} B (14.3) [<25] {28} 26: Palmetto Bay Rd & Archer Rd (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn F (2,462.0) [73] {88} E (35.5) [<25] {39} Westbound Right Turn B (13.2) [109] {125} B (12.9) [<25] {76} Southbound Left Turn C (22.2) [380] {493} B (11.6) [<25] {28} 27: Palmetto Bay Rd & Target Rd (signal) Overall Intersection C (29.0) B (19.0) Eastbound Approach D (36.9) [1380] {1512} B (15.9) [142] {823} Westbound Approach B (12.9) [39] {249} B (15.8) [85] {539} Northbound Approach C (26.6) [<25] {105} D (39.5) [65] {263} Southbound Approach D (35.7) [34] {151} C (25.5) [37] {140} 28: Palmetto Bay Rd & Dunnagans Alley (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn F (1,033.8) [80] {183} F (101.3) [<25] {99} Westbound Right Turn F (91.9) [109] {217} B (13.3) [35] {134} Southbound Left Turn C (22.0) [278] {513} B (13.7) [29] {465} 29: Palmetto Bay Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (Sea Pines Circle, Roundabout) Overall Intersection F (53.4) F (79.2) Eastbound Approach F (314.9) [809] {838} F (179.8) [805] {838} Westbound Approach B (14.0) [56] {420} F (189.7) [1644] {1658} Northbound Approach A (4.1) [<25] {209} F (52.9) [463] {788} Southbound Approach C (18.5) [307] {461} A (9.1) [111] {460} Page 60 of 300 June 10, 2024 Page 10 Conclusions Lochmueller Group evaluated the downstream impacts of the 2045 Modified Alternative 1 conditions with modifications to provide a single eastbound left-turn lane and a single southbound right-turn lane at US 278 at Squire Pope Rd. The analysis included in this memorandum did not assume any physical, nor signal timing improvements to the intersections downstream of Gumtree Rd or Cross Island Parkway. With the improvements proposed under the Modified Alternative 1, the downstream study intersections are largely expected to operate acceptably in the year 2045. However, the eastbound and westbound approaches between Jarvis Park Rd and Pembroke Dr are expected to experience long queues and be over capacity in the year 2045, and the existing roundabout at Palmetto Bay Rd and Sea Pines Circle is expected to fail during both the AM and PM peak hours. As a result of the failing roundabout, the queue lengths are expected to extend beyond nearby intersections. As a next step, Lochmueller will evaluate potential improvements to the intersections downstream of Gumtree Rd and Cross Island Parkway to help mitigate the long queues and delays presented in this memorandum. Page 61 of 300 Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex One Town Center Court  Hilton Head Island  South Carolina  29928 www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND Willliam Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Advisory Committee TO: Advisory Committee FROM: Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager DATE: June 12 2024 SUBJECT: Consideration of a Resolution to Accept the Findings William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent End-to-End Analysis RECOMMENDATION: Consideration of a Resolution to Accept the Findings William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent End-to-End Analysis. BACKGROUND: On February 21, 2023, the Town Council of the Town of Hilton Head Island adopted a Resolution authorizing the creation and appointment of a William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee (Committee), as outlined in Exhibit A. On May 12, 2023, the Committee unanimously recommended a Scope of Work, as outlined in Exhibit B, be included in a Request for Qualifications to be considered by Town Council to procure the services of an Engineering consultant to perform the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent End-to-End Analysis. On June 6, 2023, Town Council unanimously adopted a Resolution Approving the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent End- to-End Analysis Request for Qualifications and Scope of Work. On August 28, 2023, the Committee unanimously recommended the Town award a contract with The Lochmueller Group, Inc. to perform the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent End-to-End Analysis. On October 12, 2023, the Town of Hilton Head Island executed a contract with the Consultant to perform William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent End-to-End Analysis. The Committee held 10 public meetings between November 3, 2023 and June 12, 2024 to review Consultant findings and recommendations for the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent End-to-End Analysis, as well as receive public input. Page 62 of 300 Page 2 of 2 As of June 12, 2024, the Consultant had delivered and presented technical reports and deliverables as outlined in the contracted Scope of Work to the Committee. The Consultant has substantially completed the work of the Independent William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent End-to-End Analysis and has conveyed findings to the Committee (Exh ibit C) and should consider acceptance of these findings at this time. ATTACHMENTS: Proposed Resolution Exhibit A – Resolution to Create Committee Exhibit B – Scope of Work for Independent End to End Analysis Exhibit C – Summary of Findings – Technical Memorandums Page 63 of 300 TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA RESOLUTION NO. _________________ A RESOLUTION OF THE WILLIAM HILTON PARKWAY GATEWAY CORRIDOR INDEPENDENT REVIEW ADVISORY COMMITTEE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, ACCEPTING THE FINDINGS OF THE WILLIAM HILTON PARKWAY GATEWAY CORRIDOR INDEPENDENT END TO END ANALYSIS. WHEREAS, on February 21, 2023, the Town Council of the Town of Hilton Head Island adopted a Resolution authorizing the creation and appointment of a William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee, hereinafter called the “Committee”, as outlined in Exhibit A; and, WHEREAS, on May 12, 2023, the Committee unanimously recommended a S cope of Work, as outlined in Exhibit B, be included in a Request for Qualifications to be considered by Town Council to procure the services of an Engineering consultant to perform the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent End-to-End Analysis; and WHEREAS, on June 6, 2023, Town Council unanimously adopted a R esolution Approving the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent End- to-End Analysis Request for Qualifications and Scope of Work; and, WHEREAS, on August 28, 2023, the Committee unanimously recommended the Town award a contract with The Lochmueller Group, Inc. hereinafter called “Consultant” to perform the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent End-to-End Analysis; and, WHEREAS, on October 12, 2023, the Town of Hilton Head Island executed a contract with the Consultant to perform William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent End -to- End Analysis; and, WHEREAS, the Committee held 10 public meetings between November 3, 2023 and June 12, 2024 to review Consultant findings and recommendations for the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent End-to-End Analysis, as well as receive public input; and WHEREAS, as of June 12, 2024, the Consultant had delivered and presented technical reports and deliverables as outlined in the contracted Scope of Work to the Committee. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT, AND HEREBY IT IS, RESOLVED BY THE WILLIAM HILTON PARKWAY GATEWAY CORRIDOR INDEPENDENT REVIEW ADVISORY COMMITTEE FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA AS FOLLOWS: Page 64 of 300 (1) The Town Council should consider a Resolution to accept the findings of the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent End- to-End Analysis delivered by the Consultant. (2) The Town Manager is hereby authorized to use the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent End-to-End Analysis for future planning purposes. MOVED, APPROVED, AND ACCEPTED BY THE WILLIAM HILTON PARKWAY GATEWAY CORRIDOR INDEPENDENT REVIEW ADVISORY COMMITTEE FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND ON THIS _____ DAY OF _____________, 2024. THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA ____________________________ Alan Perry, Mayor ATTEST: ______________________________________ Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: __________________________________ Curtis L. Coltrane, Town Attorney Introduced by Committee Member: ____________________________ Page 65 of 300 EXHIBIT A Page 66 of 300 Page 67 of 300 Page 68 of 300 Page 69 of 300 Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex One Town Center Court Hilton Head Island South Carolina 29928 www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov TOWNOF HILTONHEAD ISLAND Town Council TO: Town Council FROM: Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager – Community Development CC: Marc Orlando, Town Manager CC: Josh Gruber, Deputy Town Manager DATE: February 12, 2023 SUBJECT: Consideration of a Resolution authorizing the creation and appointment of a William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee RECOMMENDATION: That Town Council consider a Resolution authorizing the creation and appointment of a William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee. BACKGROUND: This project began in 2017 when a need was identified by the South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) to improve the westbound bridge that connects the mainland to the island (there are two bridges in each direction). The Town and County requested a more comprehensive approach instead of piecemealing an improvement over a series of years. Since that time, the SCDOT has involved time and funding to conduct an evaluation of alternatives and prepared a draft Preferred Recommendation following the NEPA process. There has been ample public involvement, with many workshops, well over 20 public meetings, and opportunities to provide comment. In addition, the Town has worked with MKSK, a planning and design consultant, since April 2021 to review the project and draft recommendations to improve the corridor alignment and design elements. Town Council approved 26 recommendations on October 12, 2021. This is a major investment by the SCDOT and Federal Highway Administration (FHWA). It will have a significant impact on parts of Beaufort County, the Town of Bluffton and especially the Town of Hilton Head Island. The approach to Hilton Head Island is viewed as a visual oasis welcoming everyone to the beauty of the island. Changes that would negatively impact this entry are a major concern to the residents and visitors who come to Hilton Head. As such, the Town and many of its residents, want to make certain that all reasonable alternatives have been evaluated before a final decision is made. Page 70 of 300 Page 2 of 3 On October 4, 2022 the Town approved an Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) with Beaufort County (Exhibit A). The MOA outlined a critical path and steps to take to reach a point for municipal consent consideration. One key step was the procurement of an Independent Consultant by a selection team consisting of Town and County representatives to execute the Scope of Work included in the MOA. Input from SCDOT Secretary Christy Hall and Senator Tom Davis, guided the final language for the RFQ which did not support the evaluation of additional alternatives for the corridor alignment, as in their opinion, the addition of this element as part of the Scope of Work to be executed by the Independent Consultant, could put the grant funding authorized by the State Infrastructure back in jeopardy. Town approval of the MOA did not provide municipal consent, nor did it preclude the submission of amended documents to the Federal Highway Administration to include recommendations that emerge from the Independent Review. The County issued a Request for Qualifications (RFQ) (Exhibit B) for an independent consultant (the “Independent Consultant”), (i.e. – one that does not have a previous or current contractual relationship with SCDOT, the County, or the Town) to perform an independent review of the project. One submission was received and reviewed by the appointed selection team which deemed it responsive, and the firm qualified to perform the requested work. However, the Town of Hilton Head wants to hire an independent specialist to review the information and make sure the recommendations will be in the best interests of all the players, including residents, employees, visitors, businesses, and the Gullah Cultural Community which is traversed by William Hilton Parkway. Therefore, a Town RFQ Exhibit C) has been drafted to complete work consistent with the Scope of Work agreed to in the MOA. In addition, Town Council requested that a William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee be created to guide work to complete the Independent Review. A Resolution (Exhibit D) to create the requested Committee outlines the membership to include: a. Member of Town Council b. Engineer c. Stoney Citizen Member d. Community Member e. Community Member SUMMARY: Adoption of the Resolution will authorize the creation of an Advisory Committee to guide work for the Independent Review. Staff will continue its execution of the approved MOA with Beaufort County, including work that needs to be completed to provide better understanding of project details and impacts needed to inform recommendations for improvements to the bridge, corridor, and project mitigation. Page 71 of 300 Page 3 of 3 ATTACHMENTS: 1. Exhibit A - MOA approved by Town of Hilton Head Island and Beaufort County Councils 2. Exhibit B - RFQ Issued by Beaufort County for Independent Consultant Review 3. Exhibit C - Draft RFQ to be issued by the Town for Independent Consultant Review 4. Exhibit D - Resolution authorizing the creation and appointment of a William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee Page 72 of 300 Page 73 of 300 Page 74 of 300 Page 75 of 300 Page 76 of 300 Page 77 of 300 Page 78 of 300 Page 79 of 300 Page 80 of 300 Page 81 of 300 Page 82 of 300 Page 83 of 300 Page 84 of 300 Page 85 of 300 Page 86 of 300 REQUESTFORQUALIFICATIONS WILLIAM HILTON PARKWAY/US278CORRIDOR INDEPENDENTREVIEW RFQ # 112322 Preparedby: EngineeringDepartment Dated: October25, 2022 ProposalDueDate: November23, 20223:00PM (EST) Page 87 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page1 COUNTYCOUNCILOFBEAUFORTCOUNTY PROCUREMENTSERVICESDEPARTMENT 106IndustrialVillage Road, Bldg. 2 PostOffice Drawer1228 Beaufort, SouthCarolina29901-1228 PROPOSALNOTICENO. RFQ112322 CLOSINGDATE AND TIME: November23, 2022at 3:00PM (EST)) PROPOSALTITLE: William Hilton Parkway/US278CorridorIndependentReview You areinvited to submitaproposal, in accordancewith therequirementsof this solicitationwhichare containedherein. Therewill beaMANDATORYmeetingwill beheldvirtually onNovember1, 2022/2:00PM (EST). PleasecontactVictoria Moyerat victoria.moyer@bcgov.net to receiveyourinvite. All vendorsare encouragedto attend. In order for your proposalto be considered, it must be submittedin Vendor Registry no later than November23, 2022at 3:00PM (EST)), at which time respondentsto this requestwill berecordedin the presenceof oneor morewitnesses. RFQreceivedby theProcurementServicesDepartmentafterthetime specifiedwill notbeconsidered. Dueto thepossibilityof negotiationwith all respondents, theidentity of anyrespondentsorthecontentsof anyproposalshallnotbepublicinformationuntil afterthecontractaward is made; therefore, thepublicis notinvited to theproposalclosing. Theproposalmustbesignedby anofficial authorizedtobindtheConsultant, andit shallcontainastatement to theeffectthattheproposalis firm for a periodof at least90 daysfrom theclosingdatefor submission of proposal. ProposalmustbesubmittedthroughVendorRegistryby goingto theCountyWebsite at www.beaufortcountysc.govandregisterasa vendor. Thereis nocostto registeryour company. Thiswill allowyouto submityourRFQelectronically. All submittals (seeSubmissionRequirements) receivedin responseto this Requestfor Proposalwill be ratedby a SelectionCommittee, baseduponthe EvaluationForm containedwithin this RFQ. If the best proposalrespondentis clearly identified from the point summary, there will not be a needfor oral presentations. If not, thenanoralpresentationfrom aminimumof thetoptwo ratedfirms shallberequired. This solicitationdoesnot commit BeaufortCountyto awarda contract, to pay anycostsincurredin the preparationof aproposal, orto procureorcontractfor thearticlesof goodsorservices. TheCountyreserves the right to acceptor rejectany or all proposalsreceivedasa resultof this request, to negotiatewith all qualifiedfirms, or to cancelin partor in its entiretythissolicitation, if it is in thebestinterestsof theCounty to doso. OriginalSigned” DaveThomas ProcurementServicesDirector 843) 255-2304 Page 88 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page2 IMPORTANT ELECTRONIC SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS Responsesubmittalsfor thisbid projectwill ONLY bereceivedelectronicallyandmustbesubmitted ONLINEpriorto thedateandtimelistedonpage1 of thisBid document. All responsesmustadhereto thefollowingguidelines: Suppliersareencouragedtosubmitresponsesassoonaspossible. Responsesarereceivedinto a ‘lockbox’ folderandcannotbeopenedprior to theduedateandtime. Thetimeanddateof receiptasrecordedby theserverwill serveastheofficial timeof receipt. TheCountyis not responsiblefor latesubmissions, regardlessof thereason. All requestedinformationand forms MUST be uploadedas one file if possible. Each submissionmustbeinclusiveof all forms. If necessaryto havemorethanoneupload, pricing andsignedacknowledgements, etc. areto bein thefirst upload. Submittalsmaybere-submittedpriorto thedateandtimeof bidopen; if multiplesubmissions arereceivedfromthesamesource, thesubmissionwith thelatesttimestampwill takepriority. If youhaveaproblemwith yourupload, youmaycontactVendorRegistryat844-802-9202or cservice@vendorregistry.com. Responseis to besubmittedONLINE by oneof thetwo methodsbelow: a. UsetheLink: VendorRegistry.com b. From theCounty’shomepage, selectBid Opportunities Thesubmittingofferoris requiredto haveonthequalificationpackettheircompanyname, contactinformation, theRFQnumber, openingdate, andtitle. 1. Questions: SubmitquestionsthroughVendorRegistry. 2. All submissionsto thisRFQmustnotexceed15double-sidedprintedpagesin length. Cover sheetandtableof contentsareexcluded. 3. Submissionrequirementsarelocatedonpage19. Page 89 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page3 COUNTY COUNCIL OF BEAUFORT COUNTY Title VI Statement to Prime Contractors, Subcontractors, Architects, Engineers, and Consultants It is the policy of the County Council of Beaufort County, South Carolina, hereafter referred to as “Beaufort County” or “the County”, to comply with Title VI of the 1964 Civil Rights Act (Title VI) and its related statutes. To this end, Beaufort County assures that no person shall be excluded from participation in, denied the benefit of, or subjected to discrimination under any of its programs or activities on the basis of race, color, national origin, age, sex, disability, religion, or language regardless of whether those programs and activities are Federally funded or not. The County is also committed to assuring every effort will be made to prevent the discrimination of low-income and minority populations as a result of any impact of its programs or activities. Beaufort County also assures that every effort will be made to prevent discrimination through the impacts of its programs, policies, and activities on minority and low-income populations. Additionally, the County will take reasonable steps to provide meaningful access to services for persons with limited English proficiency. In addition, Beaufort County will not retaliate against any person who complains of discrimination or who participates in an investigation of discrimination. Beaufort County will, where necessary and appropriate, revise, update, and incorporate nondiscrimination requirements into appropriate documents, directives, and regulations. Pursuant to Title VI requirements, any entity that enters into a contract with Beaufort County including, but not limited to Prime Contractors, Subcontractors, Architects, Engineers, and Consultants, may not discriminate on the basis of race, color, national origin, age, sex, disability, religion, or language in their selection and retention of first-tier subcontractors, and first- tier subcontractors may not discriminate in their election and retention of second-tier subcontractors, including those who supply materials and/or lease equipment. Further, Contractors may not discriminate in their employment practices in connection with highway construction projects or other projects assisted by the U.S. Department of Transportation (USDOT) and/or the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA). In all solicitations either by competitive bidding or negotiation made by the Contractor for work to Beaufort County to be performed under a subcontract, including procurements of materials or leases of equipment, each potential subcontractor or supplier shall be notified by the Contractor of the Contractor' s obligations under the contract and the Title VI regulations relative to nondiscrimination on the basis of race, color, national origin, age, sex, disability, religion, or language by providing such a statement in its bidding and contract documents. Upon request, the Contractor shall provide all information and reports required by Title VI requirements issued pursuant thereto, and shall permit access to its books, records, accounts and other sources of information, and its facilities as may be determined by Beaufort County, USDOT, and/or FHWA to be pertinent to ascertain compliance with such regulations, orders, and instructions. Where any information required of a Contractor is in the exclusive possession of another who fails or refuses to furnish this information, the Contractor shall so certify to USDOT or FHWA, as appropriate and via Beaufort County, and shall set forth what efforts it has made to obtain the information. In the event of the Contractor's non-compliance with nondiscrimination provisions of this contract, USDOT may impose such contract sanctions as it or FHWA may determine to be appropriate, including, but not limited to: Withholding of payments to the Contractor under the contract until the Contractor complies, and/or Cancellation, termination, or suspension of the contract, in whole or in part. In the event a Contractor becomes involved in, or is threatened with, litigation with a subcontractor or supplier as a result of this direction to comply with Title VI, the Contractor may request USDOT to enter into such litigation to protect the interests of USDOT and FHWA. Additionally, the Contractor may request the United States to enter into such litigation to protect the interests of the United States. Any person or Subcontractor who believes that they have been subjected to an unlawful discriminatory practice under Title VI has a right to file a formal complaint within one hundred eighty (180) days following the alleged discriminatory action. Any such complaint must be filed in writing or in person: Beaufort County Government Post Office Drawer 1228 Beaufort, SC 29901-1228 843- 255-2304 Telephone E-mail: dthomas@bcgov. net Page 90 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page4 PROJECTPURPOSE BeaufortCountyrequestsqualificationsfrom all interestedfirms, licensedin theStateof SouthCarolina, experiencedin providingengineeringservicesto completeanindependentreview for long-termmobility associatedwith theWilliam Hilton Parkway/US278CorridorImprovementproject. SCOPEOF WORK Task1: ProjectInitiation andCoordination: Initial meetingwith Townof Hilton HeadIsland, BeaufortCounty, andIndependentConsultant Biweeklyprojectdiscussionswith CountyandTownStaff Reviewmeetingwith representationsof BeaufortCounty, Townof Hilton HeadIsland, SCDOT andtheexistingdesignconsultantsonprior work performed Monthly updatemeetingswith TownManagerandCountyAdministrator Reviewanddefinethestudyarea Performa sitevisit/field review UnderstandtheTown of Hilton HeadIsland’s concernwith theproposedconceptandexisting model Identify whathasalreadybeencompletedfor theproject Task2: ModelandRecommendedConceptReview Reviewprevious modelsand conceptrecommendations Reviewassumptionscontainedwithin themodel – Daily Hour, LandUse, & otherinput variables Reviewdatacollectionapproachandstudyarea Reviewmodeloutputsandsubsequentrecommendationsfor intersectionoperationsandbridge concepts Model Reviewand ConceptReviewMemo Compilefindingsinto a SummaryReviewMemo, identifying primaryfindingsand recommendationsfor improvement Task3: UpdatingModel & OperationalUpdates Model and Operational AnalysisUpdates Themodelupdateswill bebasedon theversionof theLATS modelutilizedto developthe project Confirm thatthebasetraffic demandmodelaccuratelytakesinto trips generatedby visitor traffic, masstransittraffic, andtraffic demandfrom redevelopmentfrom existingislandparcels. Updatethemodelbasedonfindingsin Task2 andcoordinationwith theTownof Hilton Head & BeaufortCounty Expandthemodelandstudyareato includethefollowing signalizedintersectionsandmerge pointseastof SpanishWellsRoad US278mergewith CrossIslandParkway US278Bus (William Hilton Parkway) atGumTreeRoad US278Bus (William Hilton Parkway) atJarvisParkRoad US278Bus (William Hilton Parkway) atPembrokeDrive/MuseumStreet Page 91 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page5 US278Bus (William Hilton Parkway) atIndigoRunDrive/WhoopingCraneWay US278 (PalmettoBayRoad) atPointComfortRoad/Arrow Road PalmettoBayRoadat TargetRoad US278Bus (William Hilton Parkway) atPalmettoBayRoad (SeaPinesCircle) Expandthemodelandstudyareato includethefollowing signalizedintersectionsandmerge pointswestof Bluffton ParkwayFlyoveron US278 US278 (FordingIslandRoad) at BuckinghamPlantationDrive/MossCreekDrive (on Mainland) Bluffton ParkwayatBuckinghamPlantationDrive (onMainland) Traffic countsfor thestudyareaintersectionswill beobtainedfrom theTownof Hilton Head Island Any additionalcountsnotavailablefrom theTown of Hilton Heador SCDOTshallbecollected by theconsultantasnecessary. Ensurethemodelincludesmostrecenttraffic datathatreflectsthetoll removalontheCross IslandParkway Generatemodeloutputsfor studyareawith newassumptionsandvolumes & analyzeoperations in Synchro/VISSIM EvaluatehowAdaptiveTraffic Signalscouldimpactthetraffic flow andaveragetraveltimes alongthecorridorat peaktimesaswell asotherperiods. TheTownandCountyareexpectedto implementAdaptiveSignalson theWilliam Hilton Parkway/US278Corridorfrom I-95to Sea PinesCircle. Answerquestionsrelatedto potentialfor downstreamimpacts Evaluateopportunitiesto achieveoperationalefficiencyby maintainingfour lanes (two lanesin eachdirection) betweentheWindmill HarbourandSquirePopeRoadintersectionswith William Hilton Parkway. Theseincludesystemimprovementsthatresultfrom IntelligentTraffic Systems andotheroperationaladjustmentsthatmayprovideimprovedefficiencyin thesystem Coordinateandrefinerecommendationswith theTownof Hilton HeadIslandandBeaufort County Participatein meetingsasdirectedby theTownof Hilton HeadIslandandBeaufortCounty Task4: ProposedIntersectionImprovements & PotentialFutureProjects Evaluatethesafetyfor bicycleandpedestrianswithin theoriginalProjectStudyAreafrom Moss CreekDrive to SpanishWells Roadandmakerecommendationsonwaysto improvethesafetyof theproposedintersections. Identify potentialmodificationsto theproposedintersectiondesignsof thepreferredalternative within theoriginalProjectStudyAreafrom MossCreekto SpanishWells Roadthatdeliverthe same (or better) expectedoperationallevel within thesame (or smaller) footprint of thecurrently plannedproject. Includeestimatedincreasedor decreasedcostsfor thepotentialmodificationsto theintersectiondesigns. Potentialmodificationsthatincreasetheprojectfootprintandimpactsto thehumanandnaturalenvironmentshouldbeexcluded. Basedonthefindingsof Task3 for intersectionsoutsideof theoriginalprojectstudyarea, developalternativesto improveoperationsin thefuture. Evaluationshouldincludetraffic improvements (LOS, delay, etc.) aswell asanticipated projectcostsandknownimpactsor concernswith thealternatives Assumeupto 3 alternativesfor eachimpactedintersectionareevaluated Page 92 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page6 Developa Summaryof Recommendationsfor reviewby theTownof Hilton HeadandBeaufort Countythatcanbeutilizedto securefuturefundingfor theimprovementsbeyondtheProject StudyArea Task5: Draft andFinal Report Compilemodelupdates, operationalanalysis, andfindingsinto a reportfor a reviewand discussionwith BeaufortCountyandHilton HeadIslandstaff. Finalizeelementsinto draftandfinal reports, includingexecutivesummariesand recommendations Presentationof final findingsto bothCountyCouncilandTownCouncilfor endorsement/adoptionby bothCouncils Submitfinal reportelectronically Page 93 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page7 PROPOSALSUBMISSIONINSTRUCTIONS 1. Electronicallysubmitfile by usingthe VendorRegistryprocessthroughour CountyWebsiteat www.beaufortcountysc.gov. File namemustcontaintheVendorsnameandProjectname: a. ProposalSubmittal Contents (items #1-#5 on page8). b. ExhibitsA&B 2. Consultant(s) will beemaileda copyof theStatementof Award. 3. Prohibitionof Gratuities: It shallbeunethicalfor anypersonto offer, or give, or agreeto giveany County employeeor former County employee, or for any County employeeor former County employeeto solicit, demand, accept, or agreeto acceptfrom anotherperson, a gratuityor anoffer of employmentin connectionwith any decision, approval, disapproval, recommendation, or preparationof any part of a purchaserequest, influencing the contentof any specificationor procurementstandard, renderingof advice, investigation, auditing, or in any other advisory capacityin anyproceedingor application, requestfor ruling, determination, claim or controversy, or otherparticularmatter, pertainingto anyprogramrequirementor acontractor subcontract, or to anysolicitationor proposaltherefore. 4. Questions a. Submitquestionsat leastten (10) calendardaysprior to proposalclosingdateto Vendor Registry b. Answersto questionsreceivedthat would changeand/or clarify this solicitationwill be providedbepostedonVendorRegistryasaddendum. c. SelectionCommitteemembersSHALL NOT becontactedduringtheRFQprocess. 5. In orderto dobusinesswith theBeaufortCounty, vendorsmustregisterwith Procurement Servicesthroughour VendorRegistrationsystem, poweredby VendorRegistry. TheCountymay rejectanyquotes, bids, proposals, andqualificationssubmittedby businessesthatarenot registered. Registeringalsoallowsbusinessesto identify thetypeof goodsandservicesthey providesothattheymayreceiveemailnotificationsregardingrelevantsolicitationsoutfor bid. To registerwith theCounty, goto www.beaufortcountysc.govandgoto theProcurementServices Department’spageandclick on VendorRegistration. Onceregisteredyoumaysubmityourproposal throughthesolicitationsectionin VendorRegistry. Page 94 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page8 PROPOSALSUBMITTAL CONTENTS To achievea uniform reviewprocessandallow for adequatecomparability, theinformationis to be organizedin the mannerspecifiedbelow andthe entirepackagemustnot exceed15 double- sidedprintedpagesexcludingExhibit A andB, coverpagesandtabs. 1. ExecutiveSummary: Objectivesof theproject, scopeof work, andrelatedissueswhich mustbe addressedthroughoutdevelopmentstagesof theplanning. 2. Approachto the Ranking/PlanningProcess: Explanationof the processto provide a ranking systemthatis equitableandrepeatablebasedonparametersdefinedin thescopeof work. 3. Work PlanandScheduling – A summaryof tasksto beperformedfromevaluationof datathrough County approvalof the final plan. Includea timeline of key milestonedatesto include overall durationsfor eachmajortask. 4. Experienceand Qualifications: Experienceand qualificationsof the teammembers, with an emphasison similar typeprojectcompletedwithin thelastfive (5) years. Provideanorganization chartincludingsub-consultantsandcontractors. 5. List anyexceptions, qualifications, or exclusionsto thisRFQ: ALL OTHER PAGESSHALL REMAIN PART OF THE RFQ BY REFERENCE AND IT IS NOT NECESSARYTO RETURN THESE ITEMS. Page 95 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page9 ReservedRights TheCountyshallnotberesponsiblefor anyof thecostsassociatedwith respondingto this requestandall submittedmaterialsshallbecomethepropertyof theCounty. Furthermore, theCountyexpresslyreserves theright andoptionsto: Rejectanyor all consultantsandre-advertiseif deemednecessary Waiveanyor all formalitiesandtechnicalities Approve, disapprove, or cancelall servicesassociatedwith theproject Selection & Notification Theselectedfirms will begivenwrittennotificationof beingselectedby theCounty. This work maybe awardedin wholeor in partat thesolediscretionof theCounty. TheCountywill negotiateandexecutea contractwith theselectedfirm(s) prior to thebeginningof theactualservices. Shouldcontract negotiationsfail, theCountywill negotiatewith oneor theotherhighly rankedfirms. In general, the contractwill complywith applicablelawsandstandardprovisionsandshallcontainthefollowing terms: Detailedscopeof services Schedulefor providingservices Page 96 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page10 BeaufortCountyStandardsfor Contracting CHAPTER1. TYPESOFCONSULTANTSERVICES 1-1. ConsultantServices CHAPTER 2. PROCEDURESFOR SELECTION OF CONSULTANTS 2-1. General 2-2. Objective 2-3. Qualifications-BasedSelectionProcedures 2-4. SelectionCriteria CHAPTER 3. CONTRACT FORMAT AND PROVISIONS 3-1. MandatoryContractProvisions 3-2. TimeOverrunsBeyondControlof theConsultant CHAPTER 4. METHODS OF CONTRACTING AND ALLOWABLE COSTS 4-1. Allowable Costs 4-2. NonallowableCosts 4-3. FixedPayment CHAPTER5. BEAUFORTCOUNTYSTANDARDCLAUSES 5-1. ContractRequirements 5-2. SpecialInstructions Page 97 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page11 CHAPTER1. TYPESOFCONSULTANTSERVICESREQUIRED: BeaufortCountyrequestsqualificationsfrom all interestedfirms, licensedin theStateof SouthCarolina, experiencedin providingengineeringservicesto completeanindependentreview for long-termmobility associatedwith theWilliam Hilton Parkway/US278CorridorImprovementproject CHAPTER2. PROCEDURESFORSELECTIONOFCONSULTANTS 2-1. GENERAL Qualifications-basedproceduresrequirethatacontractfor consultingservicesbeawardedpursuant to a fair and openselectionprocessbasedon the qualificationsof the firms. The feesfor such servicesareestablishedfollowing selectionof a firm througha negotiationprocessto determinea fair andreasonableprice. 2-2. OBJECTIVE Consultantsemployedfor work on projectsshallberesponsibleandpossesstheability to perform successfullyunderthetermsandconditionsof theproposedprocurement. Considerationshallbe givento suchmattersasintegrity, recordof pastperformance, extentof experiencewith thetype of servicesrequiredby the sponsor, technicalresources, and accessibilityto other necessary resources. 2-3. QUALIFICATIONS-BASED SELECTIONPROCEDURES. Consultantsshallbeselectedbased on their qualifications and experience, with fees determinedthrough negotiationsfollowing selection. Thehighestrankedofferor shallbeselected, andprice shallbenegotiatedwith highestrankingfirm asidentifiedthroughthequalifications-basedselectionprocedure. 2-4. SELECTIONCRITERIA. Criteriainclude, butarenotlimited to, thefollowing: a) Experienceandknowledgewith local, state, andfederalregulationsandpermitting. Consultantto disclosethetypeandnumberof projectsperformedfor SCDOT, BeaufortCountyor theTown of Hilton Headoverthelast5 years. b) Knowledgeof localconditionsandpotentialchallengesto beconsideredin developingtheproject. Theability to addressandsolvechallengesin thedesignprocess. c) Ability to providevariousdesignoptions, to evaluatecost-benefitanalysis, takingconstructionand maintenancecostsinto consideration. d) Track record in meeting deadlines, achieving positive results, and providing most cost- effective/bestoptionsto implement. Page 98 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page12 CHAPTER3. CONTRACTFORMAT 3-1. MANDATORY CONTRACTPROVISIONS. All contractsinvolving Stateor Federalfundsmust containtheapplicableprocurementstandardsin 49 CFR18.36. Listedbelowarethoseprovisions which pertainto consultantcontracts: a. Contractsshall contain provisions or conditions which will allow for administrative, contractual, or legal remediesin instanceswherecontractorsviolate or breachcontract termsandprovidefor sanctionsandpenaltiesasmaybeappropriate. b. Contractsover $10,000 shall containsuitableprovisionsfor terminationby the sponsor, includinghow it will beaffectedandthebasisfor settlement. In addition, contractsshall describeconditionsunderwhich the contractmay be terminatedfor default as well as conditionswherethe contractmay be terminatedbecauseof circumstancesbeyondthe controlof theconsultant. c. All negotiatedcontractsshall includeprovisionsto the effect that sponsors, the Federal Departmentof Transportation, theComptrollerGeneralof theUnitedStates, or anyof the duly authorizedrepresentativesshall haveaccessto any books, documents, papers, and recordsof consultantswhich are directly pertinentto a specific grant program, for the purposeof making audits, examinations, excerpts, and transcriptions. Sponsorsshall requireconsultantstomaintainall requiredrecordsfor 3 yearsafterthesponsormakesfinal paymentandall otherpendingmattersareclosed. d. In additionto therequirementscontainedin 49CFRSection23, Participationby Minority BusinessEnterprisesin Departmentof TransportationPrograms, and AC 150/5100-15, Civil RightsRequirementsfor theAirport ImprovementProgram, currentedition, theTitle VI, andDisadvantagedBusinessEnterpriseAssurancesin Appendix1 shallbeincludedin eachcontract. 3-2. TIME OVERRUNSBEYOND CONTROLOFTHE CONSULTANT. Frequently, theconsultantis calleduponto continuetechnicalinspectionserviceson constructioncontracts--overrunningtheprogram schedulecontemplatedatthetime of negotiation. In mostinstances, thetime elementis beyondthecontrol of theconsultant. To providefor thecontingencyof overrunof time, theagreementbetweenthe County andtheconsultantwill statetheperiodfor whichthecompensationshallapplyandthattheconsultantshall bereimbursedfor servicesin excessof thespecifiedperiodof time ata mutuallyacceptablefeenegotiated at thetime all thepertinentcircumstancesareknown. CHAPTER 4. METHODS OF CONTRACTING AND ALLOWABLE COSTS 4-1. ALLOWABLE COSTS. a. Direct SalaryCosts. 1) Direct salary cost is defined as the cost of salariesof engineers, draftsmen, surveyors, stenographers, clerks, etc., for time directlychargeableto theproject. 2) Salariesorimputedsalariesof partnersorprincipals, totheextentthattheyperform technicalor advisoryservicesdirectlyapplicableto theproject, areto beaddedto salarycost. b. OverheadCosts. Overheadcosts include overheadon direct salary costs and general and administrativeoverhead. 1) LaborOverhead. Overheadondirectsalarycostsincludessickleave, vacation, and holiday pay; unemployment, excise, and payroll taxes; contributionsfor social security, employmentcompensationinsurance, retirementbenefits, andmedical insurancebenefits; andany otherbenefitscustomarilypaid to or enjoyedby all Page 99 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page13 employees. Theallowablepercentagefor laboroverheadallocableto a projectis theratio of (a) a firm's total directlaboroverheadcoststo (b) a firm's total direct salarycosts (excludingovertime) for a given period, usuallythe averagefor the past3 years. 2) GeneralandAdministrativeOverhead. Generalandadministrativeoverhead includesthefollowing indirectcostswhich arenotdirectlyattributableto specific projects. a) Provisionsfor office, light, heat, and similar terms for working space, depreciationallowancesor rental for furniture, drafting equipmentand engineeringinstruments, andoffice anddraftingsuppliesnot identifiable to specificprojects. b) Taxesandinsuranceotherthanthoseincludedassalarycostbutexcluding stateandFederalincometaxes. c) Library andperiodicalexpenses, andothermeansof keepingabreastof advancesin engineeringsuchasattendanceat technicalandprofessional meetingsand subscriptionsto trade, business, professional, or technical periodicals. d) Executive, administrative, accounting, legal, stenographic, and clerical salaries, andexpenses (otherthanidentifiablesalariesincludedin salary costsand expensesincludedin reimbursablenon-salary expenses, plus salariesor imputedsalariesof partnersandprincipals) to the extentthat they perform general executive and administrative services as distinguishedfrom technicalor advisoryservicesdirectly applicableto projects. e) Costs of membershipsin trade, business, technical, and professional organizations. f) Incentive compensationfor managementemployees, cash bonuses, suggestionawards, safetyawards, andincentivecompensationbasedon production, costreduction, or efficient performanceareallowableto the extentthat the overallcompensationis determinedto be reasonable, and suchcostsarepaid or accruedpursuantto an agreemententeredinto in goodfaith betweentheconsultantandtheemployeesbeforetheservices arerenderedor pursuantto anestablishedplanfollowedby theconsultant soconsistentlyasto imply, in effect, anagreementto makesuchpayment. The allowable percentagefor general and administrative overhead allocableto aprojectis theratio of (a) all generalandadministrativecosts to (b) total direct salarycosts (excludingovertime) for a given period, usuallytheaveragefor thepast3 years. c. Direct Non-salaryExpenses. Direct non-salaryexpensesusuallyincurredmayincludethe following (detailedrecordsmustbekeptsupportingchargesandallow auditing): 1) Living andtravelingexpensesof employees, partners, andprincipalswhenawayfrom the home office on businessconnectedwith the project. (Recordsmust includeemployee name, dates, pointsof travel, mileagerate, lodging, andmeals.) 2) Identifiablecommunicationexpensessuchaslong-distancetelephone, telegraph, cable, expresscharges, andpostage, otherthanfor generalcorrespondence. 3) Servicesdirectly applicableto the work such as speciallegal and accounting Page 100 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page14 expenses, computerrental and programmingcosts, specialconsultants, borings, laboratorycharges, commercialprintingandbindings, andsimilarcoststhatis not applicableto generaloverhead. 4) Identifiabledraftingsuppliesandstenographicsuppliesandexpenseschargedto the sponsor's work as distinguishedfrom such suppliesand expensesthat are applicableto two or moreprojects. 5) Identifiable reproductioncosts applicable to the work such as blueprinting, photosetting, mimeographing, printing, etc. 6) Advertisingcostswhicharesolelyfor therecruitmentof personnelrequiredfor the performanceby theconsultantof obligationsarisingunderthecontract. 4-2. NON-ALLOWABLE COSTS. Theexpenseslistedbelowarenotallowablefor reimbursement: a. Costsof amusementandsocialactivitiesandincidentalcostsrelatingtheretosuchasmeals, lodging, rentals, transportation, andgratuities. b. Contributionsanddonations. c. Bad debts, including lossesdue to uncollectiblecustomer's accountsand other claims, related collection costs, and related legal costs, arising from other businessesof the consultant. d. Dividend provisions or paymentsand, in the caseof sole proprietorsand partners, distributionsof profit. e. Interestonborrowedcapital. f. Bonuspaymentfor earlycompletionof work. 4-3. FIXED PAYMENT. To all theestimatedcosts, includingoverhead, apercentagerateis appliedto determinepaymentfor profit, willingnessto serve, andassumptionof responsibility. CHAPTER5. BEAUFORTCOUNTYSTANDARDCLAUSES CONTRACTUALREQUIREMENTS 1.0 EXCUSABLEDELAY: TheFirm shallnotbeliable for anyexcesscosts, if thefailureto perform thecontractarisesoutof causesbeyondthecontrolandwithoutthefault or negligenceof theFirm. Suchcausesmayinclude, but arenot restrictedto, actsof Godor of thepublic enemy, actsof the Governmentin eitherits sovereignor contractualcapacity, fires, floods, epidemics, quarantine restrictions, strikes, freightembargoes, andunusuallysevereweather; but in everycasethefailure to performmustbebeyondthecontrolandwithoutthefault or negligenceof theFirm. If thefailure to performis causedby the default of a subcontractor, and if suchdefault arisesout of causes beyondthecontrolof boththeFirm andthesubcontractor, andwithout thefault or negligenceof eitherof them, theFirm shall not beliable for anyexcesscostsfor failure to perform, unlessthe suppliesor servicesto be furnishedby the subcontractorwereobtainablefrom othersourcesin sufficienttimeto permittheFirm to meettherequireddeliveryschedule. 2.0 S.C. LAW CLAUSE: Upon awardof a contractunderthis Requestfor QUALIFICATIONS, the person, partnership, association, or corporationto whomtheawardis mademustcomplywith local andStatelawswhich requiresuchpersonor entity to beauthorizedand/or licensedto do business in BeaufortCounty. Notwithstandingthefact thatapplicablestatutesmayexemptor excludethe successfulofferorfromrequirementsthatit beauthorizedand/orlicensedto dobusinessin Beaufort County, by submissionof thissignedRequestfor QUALIFICATIONS theofferoragreesto subject Page 101 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page15 itself to thejurisdiction andprocessof theFourteenthJudicialCircuit Courtof BeaufortCounty, as to all mattersanddisputesarisingor to ariseunderthe contractandthe performancethereof including any questionsas to the liability for taxes, licenses, or fees levied by Stateor local government. 3.0 OFFEROR’S QUALIFICATIONS: Firms must, uponrequestof theCounty, furnish satisfactory evidenceof their ability to furnish servicesin accordancewith the termsand conditionsof this Requestfor QUALIFICATIONS. The ProcurementServicesDepartmentreservesthe right to makethe final determinationasto the offeror’s ability to providethe servicesrequestedherein, beforeenteringinto anycontract. 4.0 OFFERORRESPONSIBILITY: EachFirm shallfully acquainthimselfwith conditionsrelatingto thescopeandrestrictionsattendingtheexecutionof thework undertheconditionsof this Request for QUALIFICATIONS. Thefailureoromissionof anofferorto acquaintthemselveswith existing conditions shall in no way relieve him of any obligation with respectto this Requestfor QUALIFICATIONS or to thecontract. 5.0 AFFIRMATIVE ACTION: The Firm will takeaffirmative actionin complyingwith all Federal and Staterequirementsconcerningfair employmentand employmentof the handicappedand concerningthe treatmentof all employees, without regardor discriminationby reasonof race, religion, sex, nationalorigin, or physicalhandicap. 6.0 FIRM RESPONSIBILITIES: The Firm will be requiredto assumesole responsibilityfor the completeeffort, asrequiredby this RFQ. TheCountywill considertheFirm to bethesolepoint of contactwith regardto contractualmatters. 7.0 SUBCONTRACTING: If any part of the work coveredby this RFQ is to be subcontracted, the Firm shall identify the subcontractingorganizationandthe contractualarrangementsmadewith same. All subcontractorsmustbeapproved, in writing by theCounty, or whenapplicableapolitical subdivisionwithin the County with the County’s concurrence. The successfulFirm will also furnishthecorporateorcompanynameandthenamesof theofficersof anysubcontractorsengaged by the Firm. The County reservesthe right to reject any or all subcontractorsand require substitutionof a firm qualifiedto participatein thework asspecifiedherein. 8.0 OWNERSHIPOFMATERIAL: Ownershipof all data, material, anddocumentationoriginatedand preparedfor theCountypursuantto this contractshallbelongexclusivelyto theCounty. 9.0 PERFORMANCEAND PAYMENT BONDS: (NOT Requiredfor ProfessionalServices) The successfulContractorshall furnish, within ten (10) days after written notice of acceptanceof Requestfor QUALIFICATIONS, PerformanceandPaymentBonds. Contractorshallprovideand paythecostof abothbonds. TheBondsshallbein theamountof onehundredpercent (100%) the contract, issuedby a SuretyCompanylicensedin SouthCarolinawith an “A” minimumratingof performanceas statedin the most currentpublication of “Best’s Key Rating Guide, Property Liability” which shallshowa financialstrengthratingof at leastfive (5) timestheContractPrice. TheBondshallbeaccompaniedby a “Powerof Attorney” authorizingtheattorney-in-fact to bind thesuretyandcertifiedto includethedateof thebond. 10.0 NONRESIDENTTAXPAYERS: If theofferor is a SouthCarolinanonresidenttaxpayerandthe contractamountis $10,000.00or more, theofferoracknowledgesandunderstandsthatin theevent heis awardeda contractofferor shallsubmita NonresidentTaxpayerRegistrationAffidavit (State Page 102 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page16 form #1-312-6/94), beforea contractcanbe signed. Affidavit mustcertify that the nonresident taxpayeris registeredwith theS.C. Departmentof Revenueor theS.C. Secretaryof State’sOffice, in accordancewith Section12-9-310(A) (2) (3) of S.C. Codeof Laws (1976) asamended. 11.0 BUSINESSLICENSEIn accordancewith the BeaufortCountyBusinessLicenseOrdinance, 99- 36, Article III, asenactedNovember22, 1999, anybusinessor individualgeneratingincomein the unincorporatedareaof BeaufortCounty is requiredto pay an annuallicensefee and obtain a businesslicense. The ordinancereferencedis available on the Beaufort County website at www.beaufortcountysc.gov or by calling the BusinessLicenseAdministratorat (843) 255-2270 for a list of schedules. 12.0 ADDITIONAL ELIGIBILITY: Other BeaufortCounty Public Procurementunits shall, at their option, beeligible for useof anycontractsawardedpursuantto this Invitation. 13.0 INSURANCE REQUIREMENTS: Prior to commencing work/delivery hereunder, Contractor/Firm, athis expense, shallfurnishinsurancecertificationshowingthecertificateholder asBeaufortCounty, P.O. Drawer1228, Beaufort, SC29901-1228, Attention: ProcurementServices Director and with a specialnotation namingBeaufort County as an additionalinsuredon the liability coverage. Minimum coverageshallbeasfollows: A) Worker’sCompensationInsurance - Contractorshallhaveandmaintain, duringthelife of this contract, Worker’s CompensationInsurancefor his employeesconnectedto the work/delivery, in accordancewith the Statutesof the Stateof SouthCarolinaand any applicablelaws. B) CommercialGeneralLiability Insurance – Contractorshallhaveandmaintain, duringthe life of this contract, CommercialGeneralLiability Insurance. SaidCommercialGeneral Liability Policy shall containContractualLiability and Products/CompletedOperations Liability subject to the following minimum limits: $ 1,000,000 Each Occurrence/ 2,000,000GeneralAggregateand $2,000,000Products/CompletedOperationsAggregate namingBeaufortCountyasanadditionalinsured. C) ComprehensiveAutomobileLiability Insurance - TheContractorshallhaveandmaintain, duringthelife of thiscontract, ComprehensiveAutomobileLiability, includingnon-owned andhiredvehicle, of at least $500,000COMBINED SINGLELIMIT. D) ADDITIONAL INSURANCE REQUIREMENT: Umbrella Liability Insurance – Contractorshall haveand maintain, during the life of this contract, Umbrella Liability Insurancewith aminimumlimit of $2,000,000 E) ProfessionalLiability ( Errors & Omissions) – The vendorshall maintaina limit no less than $1,000,000peroccurrence. F) Therequiredinsurancepolicy at thetime of issuemustbewritten by a companylicensed to dobusinessin theStateof SouthCarolinaandbeacceptableto theCounty. G) TheContractor/vendorshallnotcauseanyinsurancetobecanceledorpermitanyinsurance to lapse. All insurancepoliciesshallcontaina clauseto theeffectthatthepolicy shallnot be canceledor reduced, restricted, or limited until fifteen (15) daysafterthe Countyhas receivedwritten notice, as evidencedby return receiptof registeredor certified letter. Certificatesof Insuranceshall containtranscriptfrom the properoffice of theinsurer, the location, and theoperationsto whichtheinsuranceapplies, theexpirationdate, andtheabove-mentioned noticeof cancellationclause. H) Theinformationdescribedabovesetsforth-minimumamountsandcoveragesandis notto beconstruedin anyway asa limitation ontheContractor’sliability. Page 103 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page17 14.0 INDEMNITY: The Firm herebyagreesto indemnify and saveharmlessthe County, its officers, agents, and employeesfrom andagainstanyandall liability, claims, demands, damages, fines, fees, expenses, penalties, suits, proceedings, actionsandcostof actions, includingattorney’s feesfor trial andon appealof any kind and naturearising or growing out of or in any way connectedwith the performanceof the Agreement, whetherby act of omissionsof the Firm, its agents, servants, employeesor others, or becauseof or dueto the mereexistenceof the Agreementbetweenthe parties. 15.0 TERMINATION FORDEFAULT: 15.1 The performanceof Work underthe Agreementmay be terminatedby the Procurement ServicesDirector, in accordancewith this clause, in wholeor in part, in writing, whenever theDirectorof ProcurementServicesshalldeterminethattheContractorhasfailedto meet theperformancerequirementsof this Agreement. 15.2 TheProcurementServicesDirectorhastheright to terminatefor default, if theFirm fails to makedeliveryof thecontracteddeliverablesor performtheWork, or if theFirm fails to performtheWork within thetimespecifiedin theAgreement, orif theFirm fails toperform anyotherprovisionsof theAgreement. 16.0 TERMINATION FORCONVENIENCE: The Countymay without causeterminatethis contract in wholeor in partatanytimefor its convenience. In suchinstance, andadjustmentshallbemade to the Firm, for the reasonablecostsof the work performedthrough the date of termination. Terminationcostsdo not includelost profits, consequentialdamages, delaydamages, unabsorbed or underabsorbedoverheadof theFirm or its subcontractors, and/or failureto includetermination for convenienceclauseinto its subcontractsand materialpurchaseordersshall not exposethe Countyto liability for lost profits in conjunctionwith a terminationfor conveniencesettlementor equitableadjustment. The Firm expresslywaives any claims for lost profit or consequential damages, delaydamages, or indirectcostswhichmayarisefrom theCounty’selectionto terminate this contractin wholeor in partfor its convenience. 17.0 TERMINATION FORNON-APPROPRIATIONS: Fundsfor this contractarepayablefrom State and/or Federaland/or BeaufortCountyappropriations. In the eventsufficient appropriationsare notmadeto paythechargesunderthecontractit shallterminatewithoutanyobligationto Beaufort County. Page 104 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page18 SPECIALINSTRUCTIONS 1.0 INTENT TO PERFORM: It shallbetheFirm’s responsibilityto advisetheProcurementServices Departmentif anylanguage, requirements, etc., or anycombinationsthereofinadvertentlyrestricts or limits therequirementsstatedin thisRFQto asinglesource. Suchnotificationmustbesubmitted in writing andmustbe receivedby the ProcurementServicesDepartmentnot laterthanten (10) daysprior to the Requestfor QUALIFICATIONS openingdate. A review of suchnotifications will bemade. 2.0 RECEIPTOF REQUESTFOR QUALIFICATIONS: Requestfor Qualifications, amendments thereto, or withdrawalrequestsreceivedafter the time advertisedfor Requestfor Qualifications openingwill bevoid, regardlessof whentheyweremailed. 3.0 PREPARATIONOFREQUESTFORQUALIFICATIONS 3.1 All Requestsfor QUALIFICATIONS shouldbecompleteandcarefullywordedandmust conveyall theinformationrequestedby theCounty. If significanterrorsarefoundin the offeror’sRequestfor QUALIFICATIONS, or if theRequestfor QUALIFICATIONS fails to conformto theessentialrequirementsof theRFQ, theCountyandtheCountyalonewill be the judgeas to whetherthat varianceis significantenoughto reject the Requestfor QUALIFICATIONS. 3.2 Requestfor QUALIFICATIONS shouldbepreparedsimply andeconomically, providing astraightforward, concisedescriptionof offerorscapabilitiesto satisfytherequirementsof theRFQ. Emphasisshouldbeon completenessandclarity of content. 3.3 Eachcopyof theRequestfor QUALIFICATIONS shouldbeboundin a singlefile where practical. All documentationsubmittedwith theRequestfor QUALIFICATIONS should beboundin thatsinglefile. 3.4 If yourRequestfor QUALIFICATIONS includesanycommentoverandabovethespecific informationrequestedin ourRequestfor Requestfor QUALIFICATIONS (RFQ), youare toincludethisinformationasaseparateappendixtoyourRequestfor QUALIFICATIONS. 4.0 AMENDMENTS: If it becomesnecessaryto reviseany part of the RFQ, an amendmentwill be providedto all offerorswho receivedthe original Requestfor Requestfor QUALIFICATIONS. TheCountyshallnotbelegallyboundby anamendmentor interpretationthatis notin writing. 5.0 ADDITIONAL INFORMATION: Offerors requiring additional information may submit their questions, in writing throughVendorRegistry. Answersto questionsreceivedthatshouldchange and/or clarify thissolicitationwill beprovidedin writing to all offerorsvia anamendment. 6.0 ORAL PRESENTATION/DISCUSSIONS: Any offeror or all offerorsmay berequestedto make anoral presentationof their Requestfor QUALIFICATIONS to theCounty, aftertheRequestfor QUALIFICATIONS opening. Discussionsmaybeconductedwith responsibleFirms, whosubmit Requestfor QUALIFICATIONS determinedto be reasonablysusceptibleof being selectedfor awardfor the purposeof clarification to assurefull understandingof and responsivenessto the solicitationrequirement. Page 105 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page19 Firms shall be accordedfair andequaltreatmentwith respectto anyopportunityfor discussions and revision of Requestfor QUALIFICATIONS, and such revisionsmay be permittedafter submissionsandprior to award. Thepurposeof thesepresentations/discussionswill beto: A) Determinein greaterdetailsuchofferor’s QUALIFICATIONS. B) Explorewith theFirm thescopeandnatureof theproject, theofferor’s proposedmethod of performance, andtherelativeutility of alternativemethodsof approach. C) Determinethat the Firm will make availablethe necessarypersonneland facilities to performwithin therequiredtime. D) Agreeuponfair andreasonablecompensation, takinginto accounttheestimatedvalueof the requiredservices, the scopeandcomplexityof proposedproject, andnatureof such services. 7.0 FUNDING: The offeror shall agreethat fundsexpendedfor the purposesof thecontactmustbe appropriatedby the County Council for eachfiscal year included within the contractperiod. Therefore, thecontractshallautomaticallyterminatewithout penaltyor terminationcostsif such fundsarenot appropriated. In theeventthatfundsarenot appropriatedfor thecontract, theFirm shallnotprohibitor otherwiselimit theCounty’sright to pursueandcontractfor alternatesolutions andremedies, asdeemednecessaryby theCountyfor theconductof its affairs. Therequirements statedin this paragraphshallapplyto anyamendmentor theexecutionof anyoptionto extendthe contract. 8.0 AWARD: An awardresultingfrom thisrequestshallbeawardedto theresponsiveandresponsible Firm whoseRequestfor QUALIFICATIONS is determinedto bemostadvantageousto theCounty, taking into considerationprice andthe evaluationfactorssetforth herein; however, the right is reservedto rejectanyandall Requestfor QUALIFICATIONS received, andin all casestheCounty will be the sole judge as to whethera Firm’s Requestfor QUALIFICATIONS hasor hasnot satisfactorilymettherequirementsof this RFQ. 9.0 PUBLIC ACCESS TO PROCUREMENT INFORMATION: No such documentsor other documentsrelatingto this procurementwill bepresentedor madeotherwiseavailableto anyother person, agency, or organizationuntil afteraward. Commercialor financialinformationobtained in responseto thisRFQ, whichis privilegedandconfidential, will notbedisclosed. Suchprivileged and confidentialinformationincludesinformation which, if disclosed, might causeharm to the competitivepositionof theofferor supplyingtheinformation. All Firms, therefore, must visibly mark as “Confidential” eachpart of their Requestfor QUALIFICATIONS, which they considercontainingproprietaryinformation. 10.0 DEVIATIONS: Any deviationsfrom therequirementsof this RFQmustbe listedseparatelyand identifiedassuchin thetableof contents. 12.0 GRATUITIES: It shall beunethicalfor anypersonto offer, or give, or agreeto give anyCounty employeeor formerCountyemployee; or for anyCountyemployeeor formerCountyemployeeto solicit, demand, accept, or agreeto acceptfrom anotherpersonagratuityor anofferof employment in connectionwith anydecision, approval, disapproval, recommendation, orpreparationof anypart of a programrequirementor a purchaserequest, influencingthe contentof any specificationor procurementstandard, renderingof advice, investigation, auditing, or in any other advisory capacityin anyproceedingor application, requestfor ruling, determination, claim or controversy, Page 106 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page20 or otherparticularmatterpertainingto anyprogramrequirement, or acontractor subcontract, or to anysolicitationor Requestfor QUALIFICATIONS therefore. 13.0 KICKBACKS: It shallbeunethicalfor anypayment, gratuity, or offer of employmentto bemade by or onbehalfof a subcontractorunderacontractto theprimeor highertier subcontractor, or any personassociatedtherewith, asaninducementfor theawardof a subcontractororder. 14.0 PROTESTPROCEDURES 14.1 Right to Protest: Any actualor prospectivebidder, offeror, or firm, who is aggrieved, in connectionwith the solicitationor awardof a contract, may protestto the Procurement ServicesDirector. Theprotestshallbesubmittedin writing fourteen (14) daysaftersuch aggrievedpersonknowsor shouldhaveknownof thefactsgiving risethereto. Theprotest mustbeaccompaniedby adetailedstatement, indicatingthereasonsfor suchprotest. 14.2 Authority to ResolveProtest: The ProcurementServicesDirector shall haveauthority, prior to thecommencementof anactionin courtconcerningthecontroversy, to settleand resolvea protestof an aggrievedbidder, offeror, or contractor; actual or prospective, concerningthesolicitationor awardof a contract. 14.3 Decision: If the protestis not resolvedby mutualagreement, the ProcurementServices Directorshallissuea decision, in writing within ten (10) days. Thedecisionshall, A) Statethereasonsfor theactiontaken; and B) Inform the protestantof its right to administrativereview as provided in this Section. 14.4 Notice of Decision: A decisionunderSubsection (3) of this Sectionshall be mailedor otherwisefurnishedimmediatelyto theprotestantandanyotherpartyintervening. 14.5 Finality of Decision: A decisionunderSubsection (3) of this Sectionshall befinal and conclusive, unlessfraudulent, or A) Any personadverselyaffectedby thedecisionappealsadministratively, within ten 10) daysafterreceiptof decisionunderSubsection (3) to theCountyCouncilin accordancewith this Section. B) Any protesttakento theCountyCouncilor courtshallbesubjectto theprotestant payingall administrativecosts, attorneyfees, andcourtcostswhenit is determined thattheprotestis without standing. Page 107 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page21 EXHIBIT A Certification regarding Debarment, Suspension, Ineligibility, and Voluntary exclusion Thecontractorcertifies, by submissionof this qualificationstatementor acceptanceof acontract, that neitherit nor its principalsis presentlydebarred, suspended, proposedfor debarment, declaredineligible, or voluntarily excludedfrom participationin this transactionby anyState, Federaldepartment, or agency. It furtheragreesby submittingthis qualificationstatementthatit will includethis clausewithout modificationin all lowertier transactions, solicitations, proposals, contracts, andsubcontracts. Wherethe bidder/contractoror anylower tier participantis unableto certify to thisstatement, it shallattachan explanationto this solicitation/bid. Statewhetheryourcompanyhasbeeninvolvedin anylitigationwithin thepastfive (5) years, arisingoutof yourperformance. CircleYesor No if you answeryes, explain fully if it hasbeeninvolved in any litigation involving performance. Page 108 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page22 EXHIBIT B CERTIFICATIONBY CONTRACTOR Regarding NON-SEGREGATEDFACILITIES The Bidder certifiesthat he doesnot, and will not, provideandmaintainsegregatedfacilities for his employeesat his establishmentsand, further that he doesnot, and will not, permit his employeesto performtheir servicesat thoselocations, underhis control, wheresegregatedfacilities areprovidedand maintained. Segregatedfountains, transportation, parking, entertainment, recreation, ad housing facilities; waiting, rest, wash, dressing, andlockerroom, andtime clock, work, storage, restaurant, and othereatingareaswhich aresetapartin fact, or by explicit directive, habit, local custom, or otherwise, basedon color, creed, nationalorigin, andrace. TheBidder agreesthat, exceptwherehe hasobtained identicalcertificationsfrom proposedsubcontractorsfor specifictime periods, he will obtainidentical certificationsfrom proposedsubcontractorsprior to theawardof subcontractorsexceeding $10,000.00 which arenot exemptfrom theprovisionsof theEqualOpportunityclause, andthathewill retainsuch certificationsin his files. TheBidderagreesthata breachof thiscertificationis aviolation of theEqualOpportunityclausein this Contract. Thepenaltyfor makingfalsestatementsis prescribedin 18 U.S.C. 1001. Contractor Signature) NameandTitle of Signer Date Page 109 of 300 RFQ #112322DOCUMENTS Page23 EXHIBIT C EVALUATIONFORM DATE: ________________________ RFQ#: ______ TITLE: ___________________ OFFEROR: _____ POINTRANGE POINTSASSIGNED 1.0 Experienceandknowledgewith local, state, andfederalregulationsand permitting. Consultantto disclosethetype andnumberof projectsperformedfor SCDOT, BeaufortCountyor theTownof Hilton Headoverthelast5 years. 0-25Points 2.0 Knowledgeof local conditionsand potentialchallengesto beconsideredin developingtheproject. Theability to addressandsolvechallengesin thedesign process. 0-25Points 3.0 Ability to providevariousdesignoptions, to evaluatecost-benefitanalysis, taking constructionandmaintenancecostsinto consideration 0-25Points 4.0 Trackrecordin meetingdeadlines, achievingpositiveresults, andproviding mostcost-effective/bestoptionsto implement. 0-25Points Page 110 of 300 TOWNOF HILTON HEAD ISLAND RFQTransmittalPage 1 | Page DateAdvertised: February ##, 2023 OfferorsShallCompleteAllInformationRequestedOnThisPageandSubmitItWithTheirQualifications REQUEST FOR QUALIFICATIONS RFQ) QualificationsSubmission: QualificationswillONLYbeacceptedelectronicallyviathe Town’sProcurementPortalwhichcanbeaccessedusingthe linkbelow: hiltonheadislandsc.bonfirehub.com SolicitationNumber: RFQ2023-## Description/Title: IndependentReviewoftheWilliamHiltonParkway GatewayCorridor QualificationsSubmittalDeadline: 10:00amEasternTimeon _______, 2023 Submittalswillnotbeacceptedafterthestatedtimeanddate. Submittalswillbepublicallyopenedviavirtualconference at 10:15amEasternTimeon _____, 2023. Thelinktoparticipate inthevirtualopeningisprovidedinSectionIofthisRFQ. Pre-SubmittalConferenceInformation: Notapplicableforthissolicitation TownContact: RichardGroth, ProcurementOfficer richg@hiltonheadislandsc.gov 843) 341-4711 DeadlineForQuestions: 2:00pm EasternTimeon _______, 2023 QuestionsmustbesubmittedthroughtheTown’sProcurement Portalusingthe “OpportunityQ&A” featureinthe “Messages” SectionofthePortal. OfferorName: OfferorContactName: OfferorMailingAddress: OfferorContactPhone: City-State-Zip-Code: OfferorContactEmailAddress: Bysignaturebelow, Icertifythatthissubmissionismadeandsubmittedwithoutpriorunderstanding, agreement, orconnectionwithanycorporation, firmor anycorporation, firm, orpersonsubmittingqualificationsforthesamematerials, supplies, equipmentorservices, andisinallrespectsfairandwithout collusionorfraud. Iagreethatthissubmittalshallbegoodandheldopenforaperiodofatleastsixty (60) daysfromtheSubmittalDeadline. I agreetoabide byallconditionsofthissolicitationandcertifythatIamauthorizedtosignthisdocumentonbehalfoftheOfferor. OfferorAuthorizedSignature: Signature Date NameandTitleofSignator: Name:______________________________________________ Title:_______________________________________________ Page 111 of 300 2 | Page TOWNOFHILTONHEADISLAND RFQ2023-## IndependentReviewof the William Hilton ParkwayGatewayCorridor I. GENERALINFORMATIONANDSUBMITTALINSTRUCTIONS The Town of Hilton HeadIslandis solicitingresponsesfrom qualified engineering firms (“Offerors” or “Consultants”) licensedin SouthCarolinato provideIndependent Reviewof the WilliamHiltonParkwayGatewayCorridor for the Townin accordance with the scopeof work andspecificationsprovidedherein. Qualificationsmustbe submittedby the QualificationsSubmittalDeadlineshownon the TransmittalPage. Qualificationswill ONLYbe acceptedelectronicallyvia the Town’s Procurement Portal which can be accessedusing the following link hiltonheadislandsc.bonfirehub.comhttps://hiltonheadislandsc.bonfirehub.com/portal. If electronic submittal poses a hardship, please notify the Town Contact person identifiedon the TransmittalPage. There will be a MANDATORYmeeting will be held virtually on February ##, 2023/#:00PM (EST). Pleasecontact RichGroth at richg@bcgov.net to request an invitation. Only vendorsthat attend this meeting shall be qualified to submit a proposal. TheTownwill haveanadvisorycommitteeandreviewthe submittalsand makerecommendationfor selectionbasedon the statedcriteria. Submittalswill be publicallyopened via virtual conferenceat the date and time indicatedon the TransmittalPage. Onlythe namesof Offerorswill be providedat the opening. Noother informationwill besharedat that time. Toparticipate, please usethe followingmeetinglink andinformation. Virtual Openingof SubmittalsLinkandInformation 10:15am EasternTimeon _______, 2023 Tojoin the meetingon a computeror mobilephone: https:// bluejeans.com/8433843231?src=calendarLink&flow=joinmeeting PhoneDial-in 1.404.458.0105 (UnitedStates) 1.312.216.0325 (US (Chicago)) GlobalNumbers: https:// www.bluejeans.com/numbers MeetingID: 8433843231 Wantto test yourvideoconnection? https:// bluejeans.com/111 All questionsregardingthis solicitationmustbesubmittedin writing viathe Town’s Page 112 of 300 3 | Page Procurement Portal using the “Opportunity Q&A” feature in the “Messages” Section. Questionswill be answeredvia the ProcurementPortal as well. Offeror’s who havedownloadedan originalsolicitationwill receiveemail notification if any addendumshavebeenissuedfor that solicitation. However, it is still the Offeror’s responsibilityto checkthe procurementportal for any issuedaddendumsprior to submitting their qualifications. TheTownreservesthe right to acceptor reject any or all submittalsreceivedasa result of this solicitation, to negotiatewith all qualifiedOfferors, to awardmultiple contractsfor all or part of the scopeof work, or to cancelin part or in whole this solicitation, if in the bestinterestsof the Town. TheTownreservesthe right to refuse any and all submittalsand to waive any technicalitiesand formalities. The Town reservesthe right to waive any requirementin this solicitation, includingmaterial requirements, if suchrequirement is unmet by all Offerors, and, sucha waiver is determinedto bein the bestinterestsof the Town. Thissolicitationdoesnot committhe Townto awarda contractor to procurefor any articlesof goodsor services. TheTownshallnot incuror payfor anycostsassociated with the preparationof Offerorsubmittals. Submittalsmust be signedby an official of Offeror authorized to bind Offeror. Electronicsignatureusingsecuresignaturesoftware is acceptable. By submitting, Offeroragreesthat its submittalshallbe goodandheldopenfor a periodof at least sixty (60) daysfrom the DueDate. The Town does not discriminateon the basisof race, color, national origin, sex includingpregnancyandchildbirth (or relatedmedicalconditions)], religion, ageor disabilityin employmentor in the provisionof goodsandservices. The Town recognizesthat small businessesenterprises as well as businesses enterprisesowned and operated by women and/or minority persons (collectively disadvantagedbusiness”) havehistoricallyfacedchallengesresultingin lessthanfull participation in the free enterprisesystemto a degreedisproportionateto other businesses. Therefore, the Towniscommittedto ensuringthat suchdisadvantaged businessenterprisesareaffordedeveryopportunity to fully andfairly participatein the Town’s procurementprocessfor goodsand services. In the eventof a tie after the scoringof responsesinvolving a certified disadvantagedOfferor and a non- disadvantagedOfferor, the Town will award the contract to the certified disadvantagedOfferor. Tied responses involving two certified disadvantaged Offerorswill be settledby selectingthe Offeror havingthe lowest total cost to the Town. It is the obligationof the disadvantagedOfferor to submit proof of current certificationfrom agovernmentalentity in the UnitedStatesat the time theysubmit their responsein order for the certification to be consideredby the Town in determining an award as describedabove. Tied responsesinvolving two non- disadvantagedOfferorswill be settled by selectingthe Offeror havingthe lowest total costto the Town. Page 113 of 300 4 | Page II. SCOPEOFWORK TheTowndesiresto contractwith qualifiedfirm to conductan IndependentReview of the WilliamHilton ParkwayGatewayCorridorproject. It isthe intent of the Town to have the selected firm review and verify the assumptions, methodologies, alternatives and preferred designrecommendationare technicallyaccurateand servethe bestinterestof HiltonHeadIsland. Thespecificscope, scheduleandfeefor the servicesnecessaryto develop the plan will be negotiated once the firm is selected. Anticipatedservicesandtasksassociatedwith the developmentof the plan mayinclude, but arenot limited to, the following: Task1: ProjectInitiation andCoordination: Initial meeting with Town of Hilton HeadIsland, Beaufort County, and IndependentConsultant ConductBi-weeklyprojectstatusmeetingswith Townstaffandthe project advisorycommittee. Reviewmeetingwith representationsof BeaufortCounty, Townof Hilton Head Island, SCDOTand the existingdesignconsultantson prior work performed Monthly updatemeetingswith TownManager Reviewanddefinethe studyarea Performa sitevisit/field review Understandthe Townof Hilton HeadIsland’s concernwith the proposed conceptandexistingmodel Identifywhat hasalreadybeencompletedfor the project Task2: ReviewModel DataandRecommendedDesignConcept Reviewassumptionscontainedwithin the model – Daily, Hour, LandUse, other input variables Reviewdatacollectionapproachandstudyarea Reviewmodeloutputsandsubsequentrecommendationsfor intersection operationsandbridgeconcepts Model ReviewandConceptReviewMemo Compile findings into a SummaryReview Memo, identifying primary findingsandrecommendationsfor improvement Task3: Model andOperationalAnalysisUpdates Themodelupdateswill bebasedon the versionof the LATSmodelutilized to developthe project Confirm that the basetraffic demandmodel accuratelytakesinto trips generatedby visitor traffic, masstransit traffic, and traffic demandfrom Page 114 of 300 5 | Page redevelopmentfrom existingislandparcels. Updatethe modelbasedon findingsin Task2 and coordinationwith the Townof Hilton Head Expandthe model and study area to include the following signalized intersectionsandmergepointseastof SpanishWellsRoad: WilliamHilton Parkway (US278) mergewith CrossIslandParkway WilliamHilton Parkway (US278Bus) at GumTreeRoad WilliamHilton Parkway (US278Bus) at JarvisParkRoad William Hilton Parkway (US278 Bus) at PembrokeDrive/Museum Street William Hilton Parkway (US278 Bus) at IndigoRunDrive/Whooping CraneWay PalmettoBayRoad (US278) at PointComfortRoad/Arrow Road PalmettoBayRoadat TargetRoad SeaPinesCircle - WilliamHiltonParkway (US278Bus) at PalmettoBay Road Expandthe model and study area to include the following signalized intersectionsand mergepoints west of Bluffton ParkwayFlyoveron US 278: US278 (FordingIslandRoad) at BuckinghamPlantationDrive/Moss CreekDrive (on Mainland) Bluffton Parkwayat BuckinghamPlantationDrive (on Mainland) Existingtrafficcountsfor the studyareaintersectionswill beobtainedfrom the Townof Hilton HeadIslandandSCDOT Any additional counts not availablefrom the Town of Hilton Head or SCDOTshall be collected by the consultant as deemed necessaryand agreedto by the Town Themodelshallincludemostrecentavailabletraffic datathat reflectsthe toll removalon the CrossIslandParkway The model shall include the new adaptive traffic signal management systembeingdeployedby the Town (Summer2023) Generate model outputs for study area with agreed upon new assumptions and latest volumes and analyze operations in Synchro/VISSIM. A keydeliverableof this project isa visualsimulationof the modelswhichcanshowthe comparisonof the options Evaluatehow AdaptiveTraffic Signalscould impact the traffic flow and averagetravel times along the corridor at peak times as well as other periods. TheTownandCountyareexpectedto implementAdaptiveSignals on the William Hilton Parkway/US278 Corridor from I-95 to SeaPines Circle. Answerquestionsrelatedto potentialfor downstreamimpacts Evaluateopportunities to achieveoperationalefficiencyby maintaining four lanes (two lanesin eachdirection) betweenthe WindmillHarborand SquirePopeRoadintersectionswith WilliamHiltonParkway. Theseinclude system improvementsthat result from Intelligent Traffic Systemsand other operationaladjustmentsthat mayprovideimprovedefficiencyin the Page 115 of 300 6 | Page system Coordinateand refine recommendationswith the Town of Hilton Head IslandandBeaufortCounty Participatein meetingsasdirectedby the Townof Hilton HeadIsland Task4: ProposedIntersectionImprovements & PotentialFutureProjects Evaluatethe safetyfor bicycleandpedestrianswithin the originalProject Study Area from Moss CreekDrive to SpanishWells Road and make recommendationson ways to improve the safety of the proposed intersections. Identify potential modificationsto the proposedintersectiondesignsof the preferredalternativewithin the originalProjectStudyAreafrom Moss Creekto SpanishWellsRoadthat deliver the same (or better) expected operationallevel within the same (or smaller) footprint of the currently plannedproject. Includeestimatedincreasedor decreasedcostsfor the potentialmodificationsto the intersectiondesigns. Potentialmodifications that increasethe projectfootprint andimpactsto the humanandnatural environmentshouldbe excluded. Basedon the findingsof Task3 for intersectionsoutside of the original project study area, develop alternativesto improve operations in the future. Evaluationshouldincludetraffic improvements (LOS, delay, etc.) aswellas anticipated project costs and known impacts or concerns with the alternatives Assumeup to 3 alternativesfor eachimpactedintersectionareevaluated DevelopaSummaryof Recommendationsfor reviewbythe Townof Hilton HeadandBeaufortCountythat canbeutilizedto securefuture fundingfor the improvementsbeyondthe ProjectStudyArea Task5: FinalReport Compilemodelupdates, operationalanalysis, andfindingsinto areport for a reviewanddiscussion. Thereport shallcontaina detailedquantitative, objectivecomparisonof alternativesincludingprosandconsof eachthat assessesthe conveyance and capacity efficacy, safety improvements, community and social impacts, environmentalimpacts, appearance/aestheticimpacts, andtotal costs. Thiscomparisonshall be summarizedin a simpleto understand, tabularformat. Finalize elements into draft and final reports, including executive summariesandrecommendations. Presentationof final findingsto TownCouncilfor endorsement/adoption Submit final report electronicallyfor endorsement/adoption by Town Council. All engineeringwork mustbe certifiedby a ProfessionalEngineer. Page 116 of 300 7 | Page TheanticipatedTableof Contentsfor the FinalReportisprovidedbelow. Hilton HeadIsland IndependentReviewof the William Hilton ParkwayGateway Corridor Tableof Contents 1. ExecutiveSummaryandRecommendationsfor TownAction 2. Introduction 3. StudyObjectives 4. DataSourcesandNeeds 5. Modeling – ReviewandUpdating a. DataSources b. AssumptionsandMethodologies 6. RegulatoryandLegalImpacts a. Town, CountyandStateRegulations b. LegalImplications 7. AlternativeStrategiesfor TrafficMitigation a. ScopeandExtents b. CostEstimates c. Schedule 8. Recommendations 9. Glossary - AcronymsandTerms 10. References 11. Listof FiguresandTables 12. Appendices Page 117 of 300 8 | Page III. SUBMITTALREQUIREMENTSANDFORMATTING Offerorsare REQUIREDto submit all requestedinformation and/or documentation outlined in this RFQ. AnyOfferor failingto do somayhavetheir responserejected asbeingnon-responsiveandmakingthemineligiblefor contractaward. Offerormust completeandreturn with their responsethe “Checklistof SubmittalRequirements”, a copyof whichisincludedin thissolicitationasExhibitA. Offerorsshallsubmittheir responsesin a format andsequencethat followsthe sectionnumberingandlayout providedin this solicitationto assistthe Townin its evaluationof responses. A. QUALIFICATIONSSUBMITTAL: Section1 - Generalfirm backgroundandexperienceto includeat a minimum: Locationof primaryoperations/office (address) for work on this projectandnumberof yearsat this location Numberof yearsfirm hasperformedsimilarwork on IndependentReviewof the WilliamHiltonParkwayGateway Corridor; Statethe total numberof similarprojectscompletedin the last5 yearsandfor eachprovidewhetheryourfirm wasthe primeor a subconsultant; IdentifyExperience ________ – list all similarprojects performed (projectname, year, location) in the last5 years Providethe dollaramountof the contract/project; Dateof the contractcompletion, the type(s) andquantityof work; Provideclient referenceinformationto includeclientname, locationof the contractwork, andcontactperson’sname, telephonenumberande-mailaddress. Anyadditionalrelatedinformationdeemedpertinent. Section2 - QualificationsandOrganizationof KeyPersonnel/ProjectTeam. Provideat a minimum: Provideanorganizationalchartof the teamthat will be assignedfor the work on this contractwith a nameandrole for eachprojectteammember, includingsupportpersonnel; Aresumefor eachteammemberto beassignedto this contract; Theofficelocationfor eachteammemberto beassignedto this contract. Section3 - Summaryof firm’stechnicalcapabilitiesrelatedto the Scopeof Workdescribedin SectionII. Identifyanyuniquequalifications, tools, equipment, software, or methodologiesto be employed underthis contract. Section4 - Listof anylitigationhistoryof the firm for the past5 years Page 118 of 300 9 | Page Section5 - Anyadditionalrelevantinformationnot providedabove. B. QUESTIONNAIRE Offerorsshallcompletethe Questionnaireprovidedin ExhibitD. C. REQUIREDFORMS ExhibitA - Checklistof SubmittalRequirements ExhibitC - IllegalImmigrationReformActAffidavit Certificateof Insuranceasevidencethat Consultantmeetsthe insurancerequirementsspecifiedin ExhibitBof this RFQ. V. EVALUATIONCRITERIA If acontractisawardedasresultof thissolicitation, suchawardshallbemadeto the responsiveand responsibleOfferor with the highestrated responsebasedon the statedevaluationcriteria. EvaluationCriteria 1. Nature/Comparability/Quality of previouslycompletedcontracts/projects of similarscope (40%): 2. Qualifications/abilities/experienceof personnel (50%) 3. Projectteam localexperience (SoutheastUSAtlantic coast ) (10%): After initial scoringof the abovecriteria, the Town reservesthe right to selecta short list of finalistsfor a presentation/interview. Resultsof the interview process shallfactor into the final scoringfor contractaward. VI. CONTRACTAWARD If acontractisawardedasresultof thissolicitation, suchawardshallbemadeto the mostqualifiedrespondent(s). In the eventthat contractnegotiationswith the most qualified respondent(s) are unsuccessful, the Town reservesthe right to begin contract negotiationswith next most qualified respondent(s). TheTownreserves the right to awardmultiple contractsandanticipatesawardingto two firms. Contractaward, aswellascontractcontinuationof the contractin subsequentfiscal periods, is subject to availability of Town funds. In the event that contract negotiationswith the highestratedOfferorareunsuccessful, the Townreservesthe right to begincontractnegotiationswith nexthighestrated Offeror. VII. STANDARDCONTRACTTERMSANDCONDITIONS Page 119 of 300 10 | Page Offeror acknowledgesit has read and understandsthe terms and conditions providedin the Town’s standardcontractclausesattachedhereto asExhibitB, and Offeroralsoagreesthat suchclausesshallsubstantiallyform the basisfor acontract betweenOfferor and Town. Offeror alsoacknowledgesthat terms and conditions providedin this RFQ, either in their entirety or relevantportions thereof, maybe includedand becomepart of any resultingcontract. Theanticipatedterm of the resultingcontractshallbe oneyearwith the option to amendasmutuallyagreed. Page 120 of 300 EXHIBITA RFQ2023-## IndependentReviewof the William Hilton ParkwayGatewayCorridor Checklistof SubmittalRequirements Thefollowing checklistis intendedto advisethe Offeror of all items or information that must be includedwith their submittal. Offerorsshallprovide: 1. CompletedSubmittalTransmittalPage (page1 of RFQ) 2. A QualificationsSubmittalthat addressesall the requiredelementsandformattingas specifiedin this RFQ. 3. CompletedQuestionnaire (ExhibitD) 4. Copyof SCLicense 5. FeeSchedule (mustbe submittedseparatefrom the mainqualificationssubmittalof qualifications) 6. SignedOfferorAcknowledgementon this ExhibitAbelow. 7. CompletedAffidavitacknowledgingthe requirementsof the SouthCarolinaIllegal ImmigrationReformAct, ExhibitC. 8. Certificateof Insuranceasevidencethat Consultantmeetsthe insurancerequirements specifiedin ExhibitBof this RFQ. Townof HiltonHeadIslandshallbe addedasan AdditionalInsuredon Consultant’sInsuranceuponcontractaward. 9. OfferorshouldincludecurrentTownbusinesslicensewith their submittalif they have one. If not, Offerorwill berequiredto obtainoneprior to commencinganywork if awardedthe contract. Offeror Acknowledgements: In the spaceprovided, Offerorshallacknowledgereceiptandreviewof the following addendumsissuedfor thissolicitation. Addendum #’s: _______________________________________ I havereadthe abovechecklistof submittalrequirementsaswell asthis solicitationin its entirety, andunderstandthat failureto submitanyitem, document, form or informationidentifiedasbeingrequiredin either document, mayresultin the rejection of our submittalandeliminateour companyfrom considerationfor contractaward. Offeror/Firm: Signature: Name: Title: Page 121 of 300 EXHIBITB STATEOFSOUTHCAROLINA ) AGREEMENT COUNTYOFBEAUFORT ) THIS AGREEMENT (“Agreement”) is made this << Date>> between <<Company Name>> (hereinaftercalled “Consultant") andthe Town of Hilton HeadIsland (hereinaftercalled Town"), a municipal corporationorganizedand existing under the laws of the Stateof South Carolina. WHEREAS, theTownhasaneedfor aqualifiedconsultantto provideIndependentReview of theWilliam Hilton ParkwayGatewayCorridor; and WHEREAS, the Town andthe Consultantdesireto enterinto an Agreementwhereinthe Consultantshallprovidesuchservicesassetforth hereinbelow. NOW, THEREFORE, for andin considerationof themutualpromises, undertakingsand covenantssetforth herein, thereceiptandsufficiencyof whichis acknowledgedandaffirmedby the TownandtheConsultant, thepartiesheretoagreeasfollows: 1. The Consultantshall provideIndependentReviewof the William Hilton Parkway GatewayCorridor in accordancewith thescopeof work attachedheretoasExhibit andmadepartof thisAgreement. 2. Consultantshall be compensatedin accordancewith the itemized Fee Schedule attachedheretoasExhibit __, andmadepartof this Agreement. 3. Thetermof this Agreementshallbefor aperiodof one (1) yearcommencingonthe dateof execution. 4. The Consultantis requiredto maintain appropriatelevels of insurancefor both workerscompensationcoverageandfor autoliability. TheConsultantis requiredto maintain one million dollars ($1,000,000) of generalliability insuranceand one million dollars ($1,000,000) of professionalliability insurance. TheConsultantmust provide the Town with a Certificate of Insuranceevidencingthat they havethe requiredinsurancecoverages. The Town shall be namedasan additionalinsured with respectto liability coverages. TheConsultantis requiredto immediatelycontact the Town should any changeto thesepolicies occur during the courseof the performanceof this contract. Failure to maintain thesepolicies is groundsfor termination. 5. Termination. 5.1 TheTownmayterminatethis Agreementin wholeor in partat anytime for theconvenienceof theTown by deliveryof a written noticeto theConsultantof theTown's electionto terminatethis Agreementfor theconvenienceof theTown. If this Agreementis terminatedfor the convenienceof the Town, the Town will pay the Consultantonly for thoseservicesrenderedby the Consultantup to the dateof termination, basedon theexistingratesof this Agreement, andproratedto thedateof termination. Page 122 of 300 EXHIBITB 5.2 TheTownmayalsoterminatethis Agreementif fundsarenotappropriatedor otherwisemadeavailableto supportcontinuationof this Agreementin subsequent fiscal years. In suchevent, theTownshalldeliverawrittennoticeto theConsultant thatthisAgreementis terminatedeffectivethelastdayof thethencurrentfiscalyear dueto the lack of appropriatedfunds, andthe Town will pay the Consultantonly throughtheendof thethencurrentfiscalyearattheexistingratesin thisAgreement. 6. Shouldany part of this Agreementbe renderedvoid, invalid, or unenforceableby any court of law, such a determination shall not render void, invalid, or unenforceableanyotherpartof this Agreement. 7. This Agreementhasbeenmadeandenteredinto in theStateof SouthCarolina, and the laws of South Carolina shall govern the validity and interpretationof this Agreementin theperformanceduehereunder. 8. This Agreementmay not be modified unlesssuchmodification is in writing and signedby bothparties. 9. TheConsultantmaynotassignthis Agreementwithouttheprior writtenapprovalof theTown. 10. The Consultantshall defend, indemnify, andhold harmlessthe Town, its officers, directors, agents, andemployeesfrom andagainstanyandall actions, costs, claims, losses, expenses, and/or damages, includingattorney’s fees, whetherincurredprior to theinstitutionof litigation, duringlitigation, oronappealarisingoutof orresulting from the conduct of any activity herebyauthorizedor the performanceof any requirementimposedpursuantby this Agreement, howevercausedor occasioned, unlesscausedby thewillful misconductor grossnegligenceof theTown. 11. The parties hereto intend that no master/servant, employer/employee, or principal/agentrelationshipwill be createdby this Agreement. Nothing contained hereincreatesanyrelationshipbetweentheTownandtheConsultantotherthanthat which is expresslystatedherein. The Town is interestedonly in the resultsto be achievedunder this Agreement, and the conductand control of the agentsand employeesof theConsultantandthemethodsutilizedby theConsultantin fulfilling its obligationshereundershalllie solelyandexclusivelywith theConsultantandits agentsandemployeesshallnot beconsideredagentsor employeesof theTown for anypurpose. No personemployedby theConsultantshallhaveanybenefits, status, or right of employmentwith theTown. 12. The Consultant, by signing this Agreement, herebycertifiesthat Consultantshall comply with all applicablerequirementsof theSouthCarolinaIllegal Immigration ReformAct, S.C. CodeAnn. §41-8-10 (2007) etseq., (the "Act"), andthatConsultant covenantsandagreesasfollows: 12.1. Consultantshallnotknowinglyorintentionallyemployanyunauthorizedalien and, unlessexcludedfrom coverageof the "Act", shallverify thework authorization of newlyhiredemployeesperformingwork undertheAgreementby registeringand participatingin the FederalWork AuthorizationProgram (E- verify) andverifying thework authorizationof everynewhiredemployeewithin three (3) businessdays afteremployingemployee. Page 123 of 300 EXHIBITB 12.2. Consultantagreesto provideto theTownall documentationrequestedby it to establisheither: a) theapplicabilityof theSouthCarolinaIllegal ImmigrationReformAct to Consultant; or b) compliancewith the SouthCarolinaIllegal ImmigrationReformAct by Consultant. 12.3. Consultantagreesto includein anycontractswith its sub-consultantslanguage requiringits sub-consultantsto: a) comply with the applicablerequirementsof Title 8, Chapter14 of the SouthCarolinaCodeof Laws; and b) includein their contractswith thesub-subconsultantslanguagerequiring thesub-subconsultantsto complywith theapplicablerequirementsof Title 8, Chapter14 of theSouthCarolinaCodeof Laws. 12.4. Consultantacknowledgesandagreesthatit shallcomplywith requirementsof theImmigrationReformandControlAct of 1986includingthenon-discrimination provisionsthereof, andshallcompleteall requiredI-9 documentationfor all workers employedby it. 12.5. Consultantcertifiesit shallcomplywith all state, federal, andlocallaws, rules, regulationsandordersapplicableto it in performanceof work underthecontract. IN WITNESSWHEREOF, thepartiesheretohaveaffixedtheirsignaturesheretothe datefirst written hereinabove. WITNESSES: << CONSULTANT’S FULL NAME>> By: Its: WITNESSES: TOWNOFHILTON HEADISLAND By: Marc Orlando Its: Town Manager Page 124 of 300 EXHIBITC CONSULTANTAFFIDAVIT SOUTHCAROLINA ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION REFORMACT In accordancewith therequirementsof theSouthCarolinaIllegal ImmigrationReformAct, Consultant") herebycertifiesthatit is currentlyin compliancewith the requirementsof Title 8, Chapter14 of the South Carolina Code Annotatedand will remain in compliancewith suchrequirementsthroughoutthetermof its contractwith theTownof Hilton HeadIsland, SouthCarolina TheConsultantherebyacknowledgesthatin orderto complywith requirementsof S. C. CodeAnnotated Section8-14-20(B), it will registerandparticipatein thefederalwork authorizationprogram (E-verify) to verify theemploymentauthorizationof all newemployees; andrequireagreementfrom its subconsultants, andthroughthesubconsultants, thesub-subconsultants, to registerandparticipatein thefederalverification employmentauthorizationof all newemployees. The Consultantagreesto provide to the Town of Hilton HeadIsland upon requestany documentation required to establishthe applicability of the South Carolina Illegal Immigration Reform Act to the consultant, subconsultantor sub-subconsultant. The Consultantfurther agreesthat it will, uponrequest, providetheTown of Hilton HeadIslandwith anydocumentationrequiredto establishthattheconsultant andanysubconsultantsor sub-subconsultantsarein compliancewith therequirementsof Title 8, Chapter 14of theS. C. CodeAnnotated. Date: _______________________ By: ____________________________________ Name: _____________________________________ Title: _____________________________________ Page 125 of 300 Construction By signingits bid or proposal, Consultantcertifiesthatit will complywith theapplicablerequirements of Title 8, Chapter14of theSouthCarolinaCodeof Lawsandagreesto provideto theTownof Hilton HeadIslanduponrequestanydocumentationrequiredto establisheither: (a) thatTitle 8, Chapter14is inapplicablebothto Consultantandits subconsultantsor sub-subconsultants; or (b) thatConsultantand its subconsultantsorsub-subconsultantsarein compliancewith Title 8, Chapter14. Pursuantto Section 8-14-60, "A personwho knowingly makesor files any false, fictitious, or fraudulent document, statement, or reportpursuantto this chapteris guilty of a felony, and, uponconviction, mustbefined within thediscretionof thecourtorimprisonedfor notmorethanfive years, orboth." Consultantagrees to includein anycontractswith its subconsultantslanguagerequiringits subconsultantsto (a) comply with theapplicablerequirementsof Title 8, Chapter14, and (b) includein their contractswith thesub- subconsultantslanguagerequiringthesub-subconsultantsto complywith theapplicablerequirements of Title 8, Chapter14. Non-Construction By signingyour offer, you certify that you will comply with the applicablerequirementsof Title 8, Chapter14of theSouthCarolinaCodeof Lawsandagreeto provideto theTownof Hilton HeadIsland uponrequestanydocumentationrequiredto establisheither: (a) thatTitle 8, Chapter14is inapplicable to you andyour subconsultantsor sub-subconsultants; or (b) thatyou andyour subconsultantsor sub- subconsultantsarein compliancewith Title 8, Chapter14. Pursuantto Section8-14-60, "A personwho knowingly makesor files anyfalse, fictitious, or fraudulentdocument, statement, or reportpursuantto this chapteris guilty of a felony, and, uponconviction, mustbefined within thediscretionof thecourt or imprisonedfor not morethanfive years, or both." You agreeto includein anycontractswith your subconsultantslanguagerequiringyour subconsultantsto (a) complywith theapplicablerequirements of Title 8, Chapter14, and (b) includein theircontractswith thesub-subconsultantslanguagerequiring thesub-subconsultantsto complywith theapplicablerequirementsof Title 8, Chapter14. Page 126 of 300 EXHIBITD 1 TOWNOF HILTON HEAD ISLAND RFQ 2023-## QUESTIONNAIRE - INDEPENDENT REVIEW OF THE WILLIAM HILTON PARKWAYGATEWAY CORRIDOR INSTRUCTIONSFORCOMPLETIONOFTHE QUESTIONNAIRE PleasereadtheenclosedQuestionnairecarefully. “Thefirm” referredto in this Questionnaireis thebusinessentity offering qualificationsfor thereferencedprojectfor theTown. DO NOT leaveanyquestionsunanswered, norOMIT anyrequiredsignatures. All questionsmustbeanswered. If thereis truly a questionthatdoesnotapply, pleaseenter Not Applicable" or "N/A". In theeventadditionalspaceis requiredto completeananswer, youmaysupplementwith additionalpagesthatshallbe securelyattachedto this Questionnaire. If informationis providedon othertypedor preprintedsheets, theymustinclude all therequestedinformation, beproperlyreferenced, andsecurelyattachedto this Questionnaire. Saidsupplementsor attachmentsshallbeconsidereda partof this Affidavit andits oath. BeginQuestionnairebelow NOTE: In orderfor theresponseto beconsidered, it is necessaryfor anauthorizedindividual of thefirm, andon behalfof thefirm, to furnishtheinformationrequestedbelow. DatePrepared: SubmittedTo: Townof Hilton HeadIsland. ATTN: EngineeringDivision, OneTownCenter Court, Hilton HeadIsland, SC29928. SubmittedBy: CompleteFirm Name: Must bethesameasonSubmittalTransmittalPage) CompleteStreetAddressandSuiteNumber, if applicable) P. O. Box Number, if applicable) (Zip Codefor P. O. Box Number) City) (County) (State) (Zip Codefor StreetAddress) TelephoneNumber: ( ) FaxNumber: ( ) FederalEmployerIdentificationNumber: Page 127 of 300 2 1. How is thefirm presentlyorganized? (I.e. Corporation, Company, Partnership, Sole Proprietorship, etc.) 2. Dateof Organization: 3. OrganizedundertheLawsof whichState? 4. DateCommencedBusiness: 5. If thefirm is acorporation, is it registeredwith theSecretaryof State, to do businessin South Carolina? If yes, give dateof Certificateof Existenceor Authority. 6. If thefirm is acorporationnotorganizedunderthelawsof SouthCarolina, providethe completenameandaddressof its RegisteredAgentin SouthCarolina. 7. Is thefirm licensedwith SouthCarolinaStateBoardof Registrationfor Professional Engineers? LicenseNumber: 8. How manyyearshasthefirm beenin businessunderthepresentname? 9. Whatis thelocationof thebaseof operations? 10. How manyyearshasthefirm beenat thislocation? 11. How manyyearshasthefirm hadTransportationEngineeringrelatedservices? 12. List thepresentofficersof thefirm andtheirtitles: Page 128 of 300 3 13. Indicatebelowtheexperienceof key individualsandtechnicalsupportpresentlyemployedby thefirm who will work on Townprojects. Pleaseattachresumesandanorganizationalchart. Individual' s Name Licenseor Cert. Present Position Years Employed By The Firm Yearsof Experience In What Capacity 14. Providea summaryof technicalcapabilitiesandexperiencerelatedto theanticipated servicesandtasksbulletedin theRFQ (addspaceif necessary): Sea Flood Page 129 of 300 4 Page 130 of 300 5 15. List recentlycompleted, similar projects/contractspreferablyrelatingto major roadway/parkwaycorridoranalysisanddesign (addspaceif necessary): Contract Amount Project Nameand Type of Work Date Completed ReferenceName, Address, & PhoneNumber 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. Page 131 of 300 6 16. Identify anyuniquequalifications, abilities, tools, equipment, software, or methodologiesused by thefirm. 17. Theindividualslistedbelowareauthorizedto approve, signand/or executeonthefirm’s behalf, thefollowing documents: DocumentCodeNos.: 1 - Organization's Statementof ExperienceandEquipment. 2 - ProposalsandContracts 3 - ChangeOrder(s)/SupplementalAgreement(s) NAME TITLE DOCUMENT CODE NO. Page 132 of 300 7 It is thesoleresponsibilityof thesubmittingfirm to notify theTownof anychangesto thislist, post preparationdate. Notification shallbeby certifiedoriginaldocuments. 18. Hasthefirm, its parentor subsidiaryeverbeensuspended, disqualified, or debarredby any Municipality, Stateor theFederalGovernment? If yes, provide complete details, includingwhen, whereandwhy. Page 133 of 300 8 19. Has any owner, stockholder, officer, partner, or employee(s) of the firm beensuspended, disqualified, or debarredfrom doingbusinessby SouthCarolina, anyotherStateor theFederal Government? If yes, providecompletedetails, includingwhen, whereandwhy. 20. Haveyou or any of the individualsor entitiesreferredto above, in the pastsix years, been indicted, pledguilty, plednolo contendere, or beenconvictedof embezzlement, theft, forgery, bribery, receivingstolenproperty, or anyotheroffenseindicatinga lack of businessintegrity, or businesshonestywhich seriouslyanddirectlyaffectsthequestionof presentresponsibility asa consultantin anyjurisdictionin theUnitedStates? details. If yes, givecomplete Page 134 of 300 9 21. Hasthe firm, its subsidiaries, affiliates or parentcompanieseverdefaultedon a contractwith anyLocal, Stateor FederalGovernment? If yes, givecompletedetails. 22. List thefirm's subsidiaries, affiliatesandparentcompanies. 23. Is the firm herein offering the submittal, including owners, corporate officers or stockholders, either collectively or individually, currently suspended, disqualified or debarredfrom doingbusinesswith anyLocal, Stateor with theFederalGovernment? If so, list theagencyandcircumstance. AFFIDAVIT BEINGDULY SWORNDEPOSESAND SAYS THAT HE/SHE IS AUTHORIZED TO EXECUTE THIS AFFIDAVIT FOR AND ON BEHALF OF THE APPLICANT FIRM, AND THE ANSWERS TO THE FOREGOING QUESTIONS AND ALL STATEMENTS HEREIN CONTAINED ARE TRUE AND CORRECTTO THE BESTOFHIS/HERKNOWLEDGE. Swornandsubscribedto before meon this dayof ( Nameof ApplicantFirm) Page 135 of 300 10 AuthorizedSignature) NotaryPublic) ( Print or TypeName) Not anOfficer of thefirm) Title) AFFIX CORPO RATE SEAL HERE NOTICE: THE TOWN MUST BE NOTIFIED OFANY SIGNIFICANT CHANGE IN THE INFORMATION FURNISHEDIN THIS QUESTIONNAIREWITHIN FIFTEEN (15) DAYS OFTHE OCCURRENCEOFSUCH CHANGE. Page 136 of 300 EXHIBIT B INDEPENDENT STUDY OF THE WILLIAM HILTON PARKWAY GATEWAY CORRIDOR SCOPE OF WORK 1. The Consultant shall conduct an Independent Study of the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor project. It is the intent of the Town to have the Consultant review and verify that the assumptions, methodologies, alternatives and preferred design recommendations are technically accurate and serve the best interest of Hilton Head Island. The Consultant shall take a fresh look at the project and test possible new alternative solutions over the project scope. The Consultant is strongly encouraged to develop their own ideas and recommend their own alternatives. 2. Proposed plans will have to pass NEPA review Thus, the Consultant should have a familiarity with that process and its applicability to this project. It should be noted that, in addition to environmental impacts, Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) considers safety as a prime issue in its evaluation. Also, a demonstrated solution of the congestion problem over the project scope above is essential. Thus, plans that deal with these issues have a higher probability of success in the NEPA and community review. 3. The study is anticipated to take no longer than six (6) months to complete. Anticipated services and tasks associated with the development of the plan may include, but are not limited to, the following: Task 1: Project Initiation and Coordination: • Initial meeting with Town of Hilton Head Island and Independent Consultant. • Conduct Bi-weekly project status meetings with Town staff and the project advisory committee. • Review meeting with representatives of Town of Hilton Head Island, SCOOT and the existing design consultants on prior work performed • Monthly update meetings with Town Manager. • Review and define the study area. • Perform a site visit/field review. • Review and understand bridge inspection data. • Understand the Town of Hilton Head Island's and Community concern with the proposed concept and existing model. • Study existing project reports including: the SCOOT Draft Environmental Assessment, Town Council recommendations supported by MKSK and HOR studies, and the Technical Working Group report dated 3/31/23 to FHWA/Council on Environmental Quality/SCOOT. Task 2: Provide Modeling of Data and Recommended Design Concepts Page 137 of 300 EXHIBIT B • Review assumptions contained within the model - Daily, Hour, Land Use, and identify other input variables, including adaptive traffic signals and safety provisions. The results of each alternative evaluated should include but not be limited by the following: Throughput and Traffic Simulation This includes factors such as end-end delay, level of service, and average speed. We wish to see these computed via event simulation from end-to­ end in each direction (for each alternative) including modeling the coupling and interactions of all proposed traffic lights, merges, splits, and other possible constrictions, as opposed to summing them as acting individually. The simulation must operate on the smallest interval possible to provide meaningful results. Costs Since detailed engineering for the various Corridor options is not available at this point, the Consultant shall use broad-gauge cost estimates similar to those used by SCDOT. The Consultant shall solicit assistance from SCOOT, the County, and the Town in developing cost estimates for the various options and identifying the split between covered and uncovered costs. Safety, Environmental and Community Impacts • Review data collection approach and study area. • Review model outputs and subsequent recommendations for intersection operations and bridge concepts. • Model Review and Concept Review Memo. • Compile findings into a Summary Review Memo, identifying primary findings and recommendations for improvement. • Review data collection from Adaptive Traffic Signals. Task 3: Model and Operational Analysis Updates • The model updates will be based on the version of the Lowcountry Area Transportation Study (LATS) model utilized to develop the project. Consultant to study and recommend a model alternative if warranted. • Provide simulation and modeling of various data. • Confirm that the base traffic demand model accurately takes into account trips generated by visitor traffic, workforce traffic, mass transit traffic, and traffic demand from redevelopment from existing island parcels. • Update the model based on findings in Task 2 and coordination with the Town of Hilton Head. • Expand the SCOOT project model and study area to include the following signalized intersections and merge points east of Spanish Wells Road: • William Hilton Parkway (US 278) merge with Cross Island Parkway. Page 138 of 300 EXHIBIT B • William Hilton Parkway (US 278 Bus} at Gum Tree Road. • William Hilton Parkway (US 278 Bus) at Jarvis Park Road / Wilborn Road. • William Hilton Parkway (US 278 Bus} at Pembroke Drive/Museum Street. • William Hilton Parkway (US 278 Bus} at Indigo Run Drive/Whooping Crane Way. • Palmetto Bay Road (US 278) at Point Comfort Road/Arrow Road. • Palmetto Bay Road at Target Road. • Sea Pines Circle - William Hilton Parkway (US 278 Bus) at Palmetto Bay Road. • Expand the model and study area to include the following signalized intersections and merge points west of Bluffton Parkway Flyover on US 278: • US 278 (Fording Island Road) at Buckingham Plantation Drive/Moss Creek Drive (on Mainland). • Bluffton Parkway at Buckingham Plantation Drive (on Mainland) • Existing traffic counts for the study area intersections will be obtained from the Town of Hilton Head Island and SCOOT Any additional counts not available from the Town of Hilton Head Island or SCOOT shall be collected by the Consultant as deemed necessary and agreed to by the Town. • The model shall include the most recent available traffic data that reflects the toll removal on the Cross Island Parkway. • The model shall include the new adaptive traffic signal management system being deployed by the Town (Summer 2023}. • Generate model outputs for study area with agreed upon new assumptions and latest volumes and analyze operations using appropriate tools. A key deliverable of this project is a visual simulation of the models which can show the comparison of the options. • Evaluate how Adaptive Traffic Signals could impact the traffic flow and average travel times along the corridor at peak times as well as other periods. The Town and County are expected to implement Adaptive Signals on the William Hilton Parkway/US 278 Corridor from 1-95 to Sea Pines Circle. Answer questions related to potential for downstream impacts. • • Evaluate opportunities to achieve desired operational efficiency by maintaining four lanes (two lanes in each direction) between the Windmill Harbor and Squire Pope Road intersections with William Hilton Parkway. These include system improvements that result from Intelligent Traffic Systems and other operational adjustments that may provide improved efficiency in the system. • Evaluate impacts of alternatives, including those impacts to the Traditional Cultural Property defined in the Environmental Assessment, and commonly referred to as the Stoney Community. Develop strategic options for consideration to mitigate impacts. Page 139 of 300 EXHIBIT B • Evaluate the safety for bicycle and pedestrians within the original Project Study Area. • Coordinate and refine recommendations with the Town of Hilton Head Island. • Participate in meetings as directed by the Town of Hilton Head Island. Task 4: Proposed Intersection Improvements and other important elements: • Evaluate the safety for bicycle and pedestrians within the original Project Study Area including new signal proposed at Windmill Harbour. • Evaluate vehicular safety of the Project and make cost-effective recommendations to reduce accidents and enhance safety for the motoring public including emergency response considerations. • Identify potential modifications to the proposed intersection designs of the preferred alternative within the original Project Study Area from Moss Creek to Spanish Wells Road that deliver the same (or better) expected operational levels. • Based on the findings of Task 3 for intersections outside of the original project study area, develop alternatives to improve operations in the future. Evaluation should include but not be limited to traffic conveyance and capacity improvements (LOS, delay, etc.) as well as anticipated project costs and known impacts or concerns with the alternatives • Evaluate, quantify, and explain the Project's impacts on the Stoney Community. • Develop a Summary of Findings and Recommendations for review by the Town of Hilton Head that can be utilized to secure future funding for the improvements beyond the Project Study Area. Task 5: Final Report • Compile model updates, operational analysis, and findings into a report for a review and discussion. • Integrate safety objectives based on the results of data and analysis into findings and recommendations. • The report shall contain a detailed quantitative, objective comparison of alternatives including pros and cons of each that assesses the conveyance and capacity efficacy, safety improvements, community and social impacts, environmental impacts, appearance/aesthetic impacts, and total costs. This comparison shall be summarized in a simple to understand, tabular format as agreed to by the Town. • Finalize elements into draft and final reports, including executive summaries and recommendations. • Presentation of study, with final findings and recommendations, to Town Council for endorsement/adoption. • Submit final report electronically for endorsement/adoption by Town Page 140 of 300 EXHIBIT B Council. • All engineering work must be certified by a Professional Engineer licensed in South Carolina. Page 141 of 300 Independent Study of WHP Gateway Corridor Summary of Submitted Memorandums Hilton Head Island, South Carolina Prepared for: Town of Hilton Head Island 1 Town Center Court Hilton Head Island, South Carolina 843.341.4600 Prepared by: Lochmueller Group Huntington Tower, 201 W Springfield Avenue Suite 1012 Champaign, Illinois 61820 217 .673 .7633 JUNE 10, 2024 Page 142 of 300 P A G E | i Independent Study of WHP Gateway Corridor Summary of Submitted Memorandums Table of Contents Executive Summary ....................................................................................................................................... ii Four Lane Viability Memorandum (Task 1.3.3) ............................................................................................. 3 SCDOT Seismic Study Review Findings Memorandum (Task 1.8) ................................................................. 9 Traffic Forecasting Memorandum (Task 2.3) .............................................................................................. 12 Corridor Alternatives Analysis Memorandum (Task 3.6) ............................................................................ 21 Downstream Impacts to Task 4 Intersections Memorandum (Interim Task 4.4) ..................................... 115 Response to Advisory Committee Desire to Fully Evaluate Southern Bypass Alternative (Deliverable not included in Original Scope of Services ...................................................................................................... 115 1 7 25 34 137 148 Page 143 of 300 P A G E | ii Independent Study of WHP Gateway Corridor Summary of Submitted Memorandums Executive Summary Lochmueller Group (Lochmueller) is preparing an independent study that evaluates congestion and mobility challenges along the William Hilton Parkway (WHP) Gateway Corridor. The intention of this memorandum is to provide the Town of Hilton Head Island with each of the memorandums completed as of June 10, 2024 by Lochmueller throughout the course of the project in one document. It should be noted that the memorandums are provided in order as they appear in the scope of services, rather than by submission date. In addition to the mem orandums completed as part of the scope of service s, Lochmueller prepared a memorandum responding to the Advisory Committee’s desire to fully evaluate the southern bypass alternative which has also been provided in this comprehensive summary of submitted memorandums. Page 144 of 300 P A G E | 1 Independent Study of WHP Gateway Corridor Summary of Submitted Memorandums Four Lane Viability Memorandum (Task 1.3.3) Page 145 of 300 MEMO Huntington Tower, 201 W Springfield Avenue, Suite 1012 Champaign, Illinois 61820 PHONE: 217.673.7633 To: Town of Hilton Head, South Carolina From: Lochmueller Group Date: May 3, 2024 Subject: Independent Study of the William Hilton Parkway Gat eway Corridor Four Lane Viability Review Technical Memorandum – T ask 1.3.3 Lochmueller Group (Lochmueller) is preparing an ind ependent study that evaluates congestion and mobility challenges along the William Hilton Parkwa y Gateway Corridor. As part of this independent study, Lochmueller evaluated the viability of sever al strategies in order to determine if they should be included or excluded from further consideration as part of this project. These items include the viabi lity of maintaining four lanes along William Hilton Parkway (US 278) between Windmill Harbour and Squire Pope Road; the implementation of a second bridge; modifi cations to the existing mass transit system; implementation of a new ferry system; and the imple mentation of a facility usage fee. It should be not ed that an in-depth detailed analysis of any of these items was excluded from the scope of work. The intention of this memorandum is to provide the Town of Hilton Head with Lochmueller’s professional opinion regarding the feasibility of William Hilton Parkway being able to remain a four lane facility within areas between Moss Creek Drive and Squire Pope Road , if one or more of these strategies were implemented. Viability of Maintaining Four Lanes Between Windmill Harbour and Squire Pope Road Lochmueller evaluated the viability of maintaining four lanes between Windmill Harbour and Squire Pope Road. Currently, the intersection of Squire Pope Ro ad and US 278 experiences significant congestion, specifically during the PM peak hour. The westbound approach has failing conditions and queues which extend 2,500 feet from Squire Pope past Spanish Wells. This congestion is expected to be exacerbated by 2045 with the forecasted growth. Travel times were calculated using VISSIM, which is a microsimulation tool that accurately replicates individual vehicles and their interactions within c omplex traffic streams, such as interchanges, freew ays, and expressway corridors with signalized intersecti ons. A robust amount of data and field observations were conducted to calibrate VISSIM to reproduce fie ld conditions. The travel time results are provided in Table 1. As shown, it currently takes approximately 19 minute s to travel along US 278 between Moss Creek Drive and Indig o Run Drive during the AM peak hour, and it takes approximately 21 minutes to travel along US 278 b etween Indigo Run Drive and Moss Creek Drive during the PM peak hour today. US 278 between Moss Creek Drive and Indigo Run Drive i s approximately 8.2 miles. Based on the travel times, the existing average speed along this corridor is 26 miles per hour (mph) during the AM peak hour and 23 mph during the PM peak hour. This is well belo w the posted speed limits of 45 mph and 55 mph along the corridor. Page 146 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 2 These travel times are expected to increase by appr oximately 36% during the AM peak hour and by approximately 23% during the PM peak hour in the year 2045 with the anticipated background growth. It is evident based on the travel times that the exist ing four-lane section already struggles to accommod ate the 2023 traffic volumes, and the 2045 forecasted traffic v olumes would be expected to significantly deteriorate operating conditions along the corridor . TABLE 1. VISSIM 2023 EXISTING AND 2045 NO BUILD TRAVEL TIME RESULTS Corridor 2023 Existing Simulated travel time (secs) 2045 No Build Simulated travel time (secs) % Difference AM PM AM PM AM PM William Hilton Parkway between Moss Creek and Indigo Run EB 1157 619 1579 642 36.47% 3.72% WB 572 1252 584 1544 2.10% 23.32% A preliminary analysis was completed in an effort t o determine how much the 2023 existing and 2045 no build traffic volumes would need to be reduced in o rder for the existing four-lane section to operate acceptably. It was determined that the 2023 existing tr affic volumes would need to be reduced by approximately 30% for the current four-lane configura tion to operate acceptably. Furthermore, based on an annual growth rate of 0.56%, the 2045 traffic volumes w ould need to be reduced by approximately 40% for the current four-lane configuration to operat e acceptably. Implementation of a Second Bridge Lochmueller was asked to evaluate the implementatio n of a second bridge and/or point of access onto Hilton Head Island from the mainland. It is Lochmue ller’s understanding that a second bridge or point of access has been discussed locally to address conges tion along US 278. A new bridge could take up to twenty years to come to fruition once all studies, planning, environmental, design, and construction i s complete. While there are clear benefits to providing a secon d bridge, such as redundancy, the operating conditi ons along US 278 are already congested today. As previousl y stated, the 2023 existing traffic volumes would need to be reduced by approximately 30% and the 2045 tr affic volumes would need to be reduced by approximately 40% for the current four-lane configura tion to operate acceptably. Given the congestion already experienced along this corridor today and t he time it would take to construct a second bridge, it is our opinion that a six-lane section of US 278 onto Hil ton Head Island is needed independently of a second bridge. Modifications to Existing Transit System Lochmueller evaluated whether modifications to the existing mass transit system and its services, or t he implementation of a new mass transit system, could provide enough benefit to maintain the needed levels of efficiency and operations of a four-lane section between Windmill Harbour and Squire Pope Road. Page 147 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 3 Based on data provided by the Lowcountry Regional T ransportation Authority (LRTA), transit service in the region has been on the decline. It should be noted that the transit service does show signs of rebound ing; however, it remains to be seen what the new normal or equilibrium state may mean and if this is sustainable and long lasting for passenger volumes as transit agencies struggle with driver shortages, funding gaps and other operational challenges. The following ridership data was provided from the LRTA: • The Palmetto Breeze commuter bus’s yearly unlinked trips peaked in 2019 at 196,978 • Trips declined to 129,160 in 2021 (post pandemic) • Trips increased by 4.45% to 134,916 in 2022 according to the Federal Transit Administration (FTA) National Transit Database (NTD) data The transit service in the region is fragmented by service area and type (commuter/worker, worker/tourist) and serves different markets with l imited coordination. According to the LRTA, they currently have 72,963 yearly unlinked trips or 201 unlinke d trips daily across all the routes that serve Hilton Head, with 363 service days and one AM and PM t rip respectively. The Breeze Trolley, a seasonal service had 34,600 unlinked trips (2023) across 143 service d ays or 242 trips per day with 18 daily runs Sunday to Thursday and 20 runs on Friday and Saturday . The trolley runs April through Labor Day from 1 PM to 10 PM daily, with extended service to 11 PM Frida y and Saturday. There is an on-demand van service countywide with t rips to Hilton Head. However, the ridership is unknown, and a 24 hour prior reservation is needed to make a trip. The is also a Beach Parking shuttle which operates 47 days per year from 10 AM to 4:30 PM on Friday, Saturday, Sunday and holidays from Memorial Day to Labor Day, with 3,980 riders (2023). The fixed route Breeze transit option, as currently structured, only largely addresses the employment side to/from the island, and the trolley partially addre sses trips of visitors, residents and likely some workers once they are on the island. The Breeze service doe s provide long distance routes. The on-island troll ey is seasonal and has limited service hours. Overall, th ere is little coordination between the transit serv ice types (commuter bus and trolley/shuttle), and there is service gap from Labor Day to April when the trolley does not currently run. Based upon Lochmueller’s evaluations, it appears tr ansit across all services currently only provides a fraction of the total regional trip making to and f rom, and on, the island. In the future, transit would need to be more robust in terms of service span (number of trips daily and days per year of service) and coordinated to be most effective, with some sort of travel time advantage and way to address the last mile distribution once passengers are on the island . As described in the preceding sections of this memo randum, the 2023 existing traffic volumes would need to be reduced by approximately 30% and the 2045 traffic volumes would need to be reduced by approximately 40% for the current 4-lane configuratio n to operate acceptably. By comparison, in 2021, the transit mode share was less than 1% in the regi on 1 , and would therefore have to grow exponentially to be effective enough to reduce the need for six l anes along US 278 in the area under study. 1 https://datausa.io/profile/geo/hilton-head-island- bluffton-towns-beaufort-city-puma-sc#housing Page 148 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 4 Therefore, it is Lochmueller’s opinion that even if significant modifications were made to the existin g Palmetto Breeze transit system, it would be highly unlikely these modifications alone could account fo r enough trips and the mode share percentage needed t o sufficiently reduce the number of trips across th e US 278 bridges, such that a four-lane facility could b e maintained. Ferry System/Facility Usage Fee In addition to expanding the existing mass transit system, Lochmueller evaluated whether the implementation of a new ferry system or the impleme ntation of a facility usage fee, also commonly known as congestion pricing, would provide enough b enefit to maintain the existing four-lane section across the US 278 bridges and/or between Windmill Har bour and Squire Pope Road. In regard to the implementation of a new ferry system, it is our understanding that during the development of the 2045 Lowcountry Area Transportation Study (LATS) Long Range Transportation Plan (LRTP), long-term transit considerations were discu ssed with the public and stakeholders. One of these considerations included implementing high-speed fer ry services between Hilton Head Island and Beaufort or Port Royal to the north, and Savannah or Tybee I sland to the south. It should be noted, however, that no formal studies have been initiated by the LATS Policy Committee o r other governing bodies to determine the feasibility of implementing and/or maintaining a high-speed ferry system to/from Hilton Head Island. Therefore, it is reasonable to assume that a high speed ferry system to/from Hilton Head Island would not be full y operational within the next ten to fifteen years. If/when a new ferry system is implemented, it is highly unlikely the resulting reduction in traffic wo uld allow for a four-lane section to be maintained alon g US 278 across the bridges and/or between Windmill Harbour and Squire Pope Road (e.g., 30% reduction in 2023 traffic or 40% reduction in traffic by 2045), given that the existing Palmetto Breeze transit system accounts for less than 1% of the region’s transi t mode share today. In regard to the implementation of a facility usage fee, it is our understanding that laws within the State of South Carolina only allow tolls/fees to be imple mented on new roads within the State system. As suc h, implementing facility usage fees on any of the existing roadways that are within the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Study area would be prohib ited. It should be noted that, even if a facility usage fee could be implemented, the fee would largely imp act commuters, not tourists, who enter and exit the island for work, as the majority of traffic during the AM and PM peak hours is a result of commuter tr affic. Therefore, even if a facility usage fee could be implemented, it is highly unlikely the resulting redu ction in traffic would allow for a four-lane section to be maintained along US 278 across the bridges and/or between Windmill Harbour and Squire Pope Road (e.g. , e.g., 30% reduction in 2023 traffic or 40% reduction in traffic by 2045). Page 149 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 5 Conclusions Lochmueller evaluated the viability of maintaining four lanes along William Hilton Parkway (US 278) between Windmill Harbour and Squire Pope Road; the implementation of a second bridge; modifications to the existing mass transit system; implementation of a new ferry system; and the implementation of a facility usage fee. These evaluations were completed by Lochmueller to determine feasibility of maintaining a four lane section along William Hilto n Parkway between Moss Creek Drive and Squire Pope Road, if one or more of these strategies were imple mented. As noted in this technical memorandum, the existing traffic volumes already create significant congest ion along US 278, and the congestion is expected to be ex acerbated by 2045 with the forecasted background growth. Based on a preliminary analysis, the existi ng traffic volumes would need to be reduced by approximately 30%, and the 2045 traffic volumes would ne ed to be reduced by approximately 40%, in order for a four-lane section to operate acceptably . Based on Lochmueller’s evaluations, it was conclude d that it would be highly unlikely that modificatio ns to the existing transit system alone could account for enough trips and the mode share percentage needed to sufficiently reduce the number of trips a cross the US 278 bridges, such that a four-lane facil ity could be maintained, given that the current transit mode share within the region is less than 1%, and would therefore have to increase exponentially to r each the target goal. In addition, neither the implementation of a new ferry system, nor the imple mentation of a facility usage fee (if there were a legal way to implement said fee), would be able to signif icantly reduce the number of vehicles along US 278 within the study area to allow for a four-lane section to be maintained. In order for the existing four-lane section to operate acceptably, the total reduction in vehicles fro m mass transit, a new ferry system, and the implementation of a facility usage fee would need to be between 30 - 40%. While implementing the aforementioned types of t ransportation strategies would help slow future traffic growth on US 278, it is Lochmueller’s opinion that even if all of these strategies are implement ed, the reduction in vehicles would not reach 30%. Furth ermore, these strategies would not address the structural issues associated with the existing brid ges over Mackay Creek and Skull Creek. Consequently , it is Lochmueller’s opinion that these strategies shou ld not be considered as viable alternatives to be u sed individually and/or collectively to solely address traffic congestion and mobility related concerns al ong US 278 within the project study area, that could allow a four-lane section to be maintained along US 278 within the study area. In regard to implementing a second bridge and/or po int of access onto Hilton Head Island from the mainland, while it is acknowledged there are clear benefits to providing a second bridge (e.g., redund ancy during natural disasters), Lochmueller’s evaluation s show that operating conditions along US 278 are already congested today. Given the congestion that is already experienced along this corridor today, t he amount of traffic that would need to be removed fro m the existing traffic stream to be able to maintai n four lanes across the bridge (i.e., 30% reduction in 2023 traffic or 40% reduction in traffic by 2045), and the time it would take to construct a second bridge , it is our opinion that a six-lane section of US 278 onto Hilton Head Island is needed independently of a sec ond bridge. Page 150 of 300 P A G E | 9 Independent Study of WHP Gateway Corridor Summary of Submitted Memorandums SCDOT Seismic Study Review Findings Memorandum (Task 1.8) 7 Page 151 of 300 MEMO Huntington Tower, 201 W Springfield Avenue, Suite 1012 Champaign, Illinois 61820 PHONE: 217.673.7633 To: Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina From: Lochmueller Group Date: May 31, 2024 Subject: Independent Study of the William Hilton Parkway Gat eway Corridor SCDOT Seismic Study Review Findings – Task 1.8 During the May 8, 2024, William Hilton Parkway Gateway C orridor Independent Review Advisory Committee meeting, Lochmueller provided findings re lated Lochmueller’s cursory, high-level review the US 278 Bridge Seismic Study prepared by the South Caro lina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) in April of 2020. Lochmueller was asked to perform this cursory, high-level review of SCDOT’s Seismic Study to offer a professional opinion regarding the feasi bility of seismically retrofitting and structurally rehabilitating the existing US 278 bridges to allow fo r six travel lanes (three eastbound lanes and three westbound lanes), rather than constructing the new six-lane bridge proposed by SCDOT. A copy of the Seismic Study Review related slides that were prese nted during the 5/8 Committee meeting are attached to this memorandum as Appendix A . The SCDOT Seismic Study included an evaluation of o ptions to retrofit, widen, or replace the existing US 278 bridges onto Hilton Head Island, and provided info rmation to SCDOT to implement best replacement strategies, as well as detailed Life Cycle Cost Ana lysis (LCCA) results, considering three Options: • Option #1 – Construct a new eastbound bridge over Mackay Cre ek & Skull Creek; widen the existing westbound bridge over Mackay Creek; and mo dify the existing Skull Creek bridges for westbound movements. • Option #2 – Construct a new eastbound bridge over Mackay Cre ek & Skull Creek; replace the existing westbound bridge over Mackay Creek; and mo dify the existing Skull Creek bridges for westbound movements. • Option #3 – Construct a new six-lane bridge between Bluffton and Hilton Head Island, and then remove all existing bridges across Mackay Creek and Skull Creek. A copy of the LLCA prepared by SCDOT’s Design team is shown below: Page 152 of 300 May 31, 2024 Page 2 It should be noted that Lochmueller’s efforts in re viewing the Seismic Study prepared by SCDOT were limited to a cursory review of the SCDOT Design Tea m’s structural analysis related assumptions and findings; LLCA results; their noted benefits/risks with Options 1/2/3; and if these efforts by SCDOT’s Design Team appeared to following standard engineer ing practices. Lochmueller’s efforts did not inclu de any detailed evaluations of the SCDOT Design Team’s design calculations or software modeling inputs/results; any considerations for alternative Options to consider for inclusion in the Seismic St udy; any roadway, bridge, or environmental design/review services; or coordination with SCDOT, their Design Team, Beaufort County, Town of Hilton Head, and/or any other governing Agency or design consultant associated with the US 278 project. Key observations from Lochmueller’s review of the SCDOT Seismic Study are summarized below. Please refer to Appendix A for additional information: • The SCDOT Design Team’s structural analysis finding s; LCCA results; and noted benefits/risks with Options 1/2/3 appear valid and appear to follow standa rd engineering practices. • The LCCA results do not account for costs that woul d be required to improve seismic conditions for Options 1 & 2. Therefore, true costs associated with Options 1 & 2 would be significantly higher to implement, than what is shown in the LCCA table above. • Options 1 & 2 would take approximately 2 years longer to construct vs Option 3. The rehabilitated structures would still need to be rep laced at some point, and time required to do so is not accounted for in this table. • Existing bridge structures would be approximately 50 years old after improvements made by Options 1 or 2, with rehab efforts likely to extend life of existing structures by approximately 25 to 35 years. By comparison, typical design life for Option 3 newly constructed bridges approximately 75 to 100 years. • Options 1 & 2 being pursued for use solely as tempora ry condition would require more than $130M to construct initially (using 2020 costs), and these costs do not account for needed Functional Evaluation Earthquake (FEE) seismic desi gn improvements. Depending upon when remaining structures were replaced, the future/user /maintenance costs req’d over that time would assuredly lead to higher overall cost than bu ilding new at outset. • Options 1 & 2 would put maintenance/replacement sched ules of the structures on varying timeframes, which would cause additional user disru ptions in the future. • Existing structures under Options 1 & 2 would never m eet Safety Evaluation Earthquake (SEE) seismic design requirements. New structures can be built to meet SEE seismic design requirements. • In summary, Lochmueller does not recommend rehabili tation and/or retrofit options being pursued for this project, in lieu of constructing a new six-lane bridge connecting Bluffton and Hilton Head Island. Page 153 of 300 SCDOT Seismic Study Review Findings (Task 1.8) • Objective: Perform cursory, high-level review of seismic study and offer professional opinion regarding feasibility of seismic retrofit & structural rehab existing bridges vs. constructing new bridge o PDF copy of SCDOT approved US 278 Bridge Seismic Study (dated April 2020) provided to Lochmueller on 4/15/24. o Study included evaluation of options to retrofit, widen, or replace the existing US 278 bridges onto HHI, and provided information to SCDOT to implement best replacement strategy, as well as detailed Life Cycle Costs Analysis (LCCA) results, considering following three Options:  Option #1 – Construct new EB bridge over Mackay Creek & Skull Creek; widen existing WB bridge over Mackay Creek; modify existing Skull Creek bridges for WB movements.  Option #2 – Construct new EB bridge over Mackay Creek & Skull Creek; replace existing WB bridge over Mackay; modify existing Skull Creek bridges for WB movements.  Option #3 – Construct new 6-lane bridge; remove all existing bridges APPENDIX A PAGE 1 OF 15 Page 154 of 300 SCDOT Seismic Study Review Findings (Task 1.8) • With each Option, a new EB bridge will be constructed o Designed to SCDOT standards to withstand seismic events o Serve as a “lifeline” bridge in case of significant seismic event for Options 1 or 2 • Assumed Construction Sequence o Options #1 or #2 :  New EB structure constructed wide enough to accommodate 4-Lanes, 2-Way traffic in temporary condition & 6-Lanes in permanent condition.  All traffic moved to new EB structure, while demolition / seismic retrofits / structural repairs & replacements take place on existing structures.  Traffic then moved in to final positions  If necessary, traffic can be returned to the 4-Lanes, 2-Way traffic pattern on EB structure o Option #3 :  Entire new 6-Lane structure can constructed with traffic retained in existing patterns APPENDIX A PAGE 2 OF 15 Page 155 of 300 SCDOT Seismic Study Review Findings (Task 1.8) APPENDIX A PAGE 3 OF 15 Page 156 of 300 SCDOT Seismic Study Review Findings (Task 1.8) APPENDIX A PAGE 4 OF 15 Page 157 of 300 SCDOT Seismic Study Review Findings (Task 1.8) APPENDIX A PAGE 5 OF 15 Page 158 of 300 SCDOT Seismic Study Review Findings (Task 1.8) APPENDIX A PAGE 6 OF 15 Page 159 of 300 SCDOT Seismic Study Review Findings (Task 1.8) APPENDIX A PAGE 7 OF 15 Page 160 of 300 SCDOT Seismic Study Review Findings (Task 1.8) • Key Assumptions/Findings Noted by SCDOT Design Team: o All existing bridges designed and constructed prior to SCDOT’s implementation of seismic analysis and detailing. Therefore, all existing bridges are considered inadequate when compared to today’s seismic design standards . o In order to model existing structures, SCDOT design team assumed minimum level of seismic retrofits would be performed. Design team did not determine if existing structures could withstand any seismic event without minimum retrofits being performed. o SCDOT design team intended to evaluate the bridges for two seismic events as required by SCDOT Seismic Design Specifications (SDS):  Functional Evaluation Earthquake (FEE) = lower magnitude earthquake event that has higher chance of occurrence during life of the bridge.  Safety Evaluation Earthquake (SEE) = higher magnitude earthquake event that has lower chance of occurrence during life of the bridge.  NOTE: US 278 Bridges assigned highest SCDOT SDS classification rating OC 1; therefore, must meet FEE design thresholds at a minimum APPENDIX A PAGE 8 OF 15 Page 161 of 300 SCDOT Seismic Study Review Findings (Task 1.8) • Key Assumptions/Findings Noted by SCDOT Design Team (cont.): o It was determined that soils around and below the existing bridge foundations and roadway approaches can liquefy at ground accelerations just above the FEE event:  This liquefaction could cause bridges/roadways to settle, slide or collapse during and/or after seismic event.  Design team recognized that mitigation for liquefaction (i.e., add’l foundations, deep soil mixing, etc.) would likely exceed costs for new construction, and would greatly increase environmental disturbance.  Design team therefore elected to limit structural improvements through seismic retrofits to FEE level, w/ SCDOT concurrence.  New bridges can be constructed to meet SEE requirements; existing bridges only will be able to attain FEE requirements at best. APPENDIX A PAGE 9 OF 15 Page 162 of 300 SCDOT Seismic Study Review Findings (Task 1.8) • Key Assumptions/Findings Noted by SCDOT Design Team (cont.): o SCDOT Design team prepared LCCA, for Options 1/2/3, as shown below.  Costs are in 2020 dollars, assume annual inflation of 2% for future costs.  Construction costs developed from historical data, as well as correspondence w/ local Contractors. Widening existing structures over water ~1.5 to 2 times more expensive than new construction.  User Costs developed from SCDOT provided data, based on cost/lane/day.  Maintenance costs based on existing bridge details and assumed new bridges.  NOTE: LCCA costs only reflect rehabilitation related costs (e.g., widening, maintenance, cosmetic improvements), and do not include retrofit related costs (e.g., seismic related improvements). Therefore, true costs to attain FEE standards for Options 1 & 2 would be significantly higher than those shown in the table below . APPENDIX A PAGE 10 OF 15 Page 163 of 300 SCDOT Seismic Study Review Findings (Task 1.8) • Key Assumptions/Findings Noted by SCDOT Design Team (cont.): o SCDOT Design team evaluated benefits & risks of Options 1/2/3 APPENDIX A PAGE 12 OF 15 Page 164 of 300 SCDOT Seismic Study Review Findings (Task 1.8) • Key Assumptions/Findings Noted by SCDOT Design Team (cont.): o SCDOT Design team evaluated benefits & risks of Options 1/2/3 (cont.) APPENDIX A PAGE 13 OF 15 Page 165 of 300 SCDOT Seismic Study Review Findings (Task 1.8) • Key Observations by Lochmueller Group: o SCDOT Design Team’s structural analysis findings; LCCA results; and noted benefits/risks associated with Options 1/2/3 appear valid and appear to follow standard engineering practices. o LCCA results do not account for costs that would be required to improve seismic conditions for Options 1 & 2. Therefore, true costs associated with Options 1 & 2 would be significantly higher to implement, than what is shown in the LCCA table above . o Options 1 & 2 would take ~ 2 years longer to construct vs Option 3. The rehabilitated structures would still need to be replaced at some point, and time required to do so is not accounted for in this table. APPENDIX A PAGE 14 OF 15 Page 166 of 300 SCDOT Seismic Study Review Findings (Task 1.8) • Key Observations by Lochmueller Group (cont.): o Existing bridge structures would be ~50 years old after improvements made by Options 1 or 2, with rehab efforts likely to extend life of existing structures by ~25 to 35 years. By comparison, typical design life for Option 3 newly constructed bridges ~ 75 to 100 years . o Options 1 & 2 being pursued for use solely as temporary condition would require >$130M to construct initially (using 2020 costs), and these costs do not account for needed FEE improvements . Depending upon when remaining structures were replaced, the future/user/maintenance costs req’d over that time would assuredly lead to higher overall cost than building new at outset. APPENDIX A PAGE 15 OF 15 Page 167 of 300 SCDOT Seismic Study Review Findings (Task 1.8) • Key Observations by Lochmueller Group (cont.): o Options 1 & 2 would put maintenance/replacement schedules of the structures on varying timeframes, which would cause additional user disruptions in the future . o Existing structures under Options 1 & 2 would never meet SEE seismic design requirements . New structures can be built to meet SEE seismic design requirements. o In summary, Lochmueller does not recommend rehabilitation and/or retrofit options be pursued. Page 168 of 300 P A G E | 27 Independent Study of WHP Gateway Corridor Summary of Submitted Memorandums Traffic Forecasting Memorandum (Task 2.3) 25 Page 169 of 300 MEMORANDUM Lochmueller Group (Lochmueller) was retained by the Town of Hilton Head Island to conduct an independent study of the William Hilton Parkway (WH P) Gateway Corridor. This memorandum summarizes the review of the existing Lowcountry Ar ea Transportation Study (LATS) Travel Demand Model (TDM) and recommends future traffic gr owth at the William Hilton Parkway Bridge connecting Hilton Head Island with the mainland. The future traffic growth estimation was based on a thorough review of historic traffic volu mes, socio-economic trends for Jasper and Beaufort Counties, and accommodation and restaurant tax revenues collected per year by the Town of Hilton Head. LATS TDM Evaluation The Lowcountry TDM was updated in December 2021 wit h a new base year, 2019, and a new horizon year, 2045. Lochmueller completed a thorough review of the TDM to determine its ability to forecast traffic growth along WHP. The detailed review of the LATS TDM revealed the following: • The latest update was limited/minor in nature and d id not include any major model changes. • 2045 Horizon year roadway network did not include all future planned projects. • Socio-economic (e.g., population, household, employ ment) growth for the horizon year 2045 was forecasted by simply extrapolating 2040 at tributes of the previous version of the TDM. • Socio-economic projections did not consider recent land-use plan updates from municipalities within the TDM boundaries. • The TDM update did not include a complete model re-estimation and re-calibration. • The LATS Long-Range 2045 Transportation Plan forecasts 48,500 more future population in Jasper and Beaufort Counties than incorporated into the TDM. To: Shawn Colin, AICP (Town of Hilton Head) Cc: Bryan McIlwee, PE (Town of Hilton Head) Jim Iwanicki, PE (Town of Hilton Head) From: Nate Nohren, PE, PTOE Sharif Ullah, PE, PTP Date: February 12, 2024 Subject: Independent Study of WHP Gateway Corridor Traffic Forecasting Memorandum Page 170 of 300 Independent Study of the WHP Gateway Corridor: Traffic Forecasting Memorandum February 12, 2024 Page 2 of 8 Based on these findings, Lochmueller staff determin ed the LATS TDM may not provide accurate traffic forecasts for WHP. To that end, alternative methods of traffic forecasting were investigated. First, key data indicators of traffic growth were researched. Socio-Economic Trends for Hilton Head Island, Jasper County, and Beaufort County Hilton Head Island is located in Beaufort County. B eaufort and neighboring Jasper County experienced significant growth over the last 20 yea rs. Table 1 shows population growth trends for Beaufort and Jasper Counties and Hilton Head Is land based on the US Census. This data reflects permanent residents. Table 1: Population Trends 1 Geographic Unit Year Annual Growth (%) (2000 -2010) Annual Growth (%) (2010 -2020) 2000 2010 2020 Beaufort County 120,937 162,233 187,117 3.0 1.4 Jasper County 20,678 24,777 28,791 1.8 1.5 Hilton Head Island 33,862 37,099 37,661 0.9 0.2 As shown in Table 1 , both Beaufort and Jasper Counties experienced sig nificant population growth since 2000. However, population growth was m uch slower between 2010 and 2020 compared to 2000 to 2010. Hilton Head Island experi enced a modest growth rate of 0.2% from 2010 and 2020. Table 2 shows the total employment for Beaufort and Jasper Counties and Hilton Head Island for 2010 and 2020. Page 171 of 300 Independent Study of the WHP Gateway Corridor: Traffic Forecasting Memorandum February 12, 2024 Page 3 of 8 Table 2: Total Employment Trend 1 Geographic Unit Year Annual Growth (%) (2010 -2020) 2010 2020 Beaufort County 51,761 62,001 1.8 Jasper County 6,522 9,819 4.2 Hilton Head Island 21,346 21,854 0.2 As can be seen in Table 2 , both Jasper and Beaufort Counties experienced sig nificant growth in jobs between 2010 and 2020. Overall job growth in H ilton Head Island was small and similar to the island’s population growth rate. Population Growth Projections for Beaufort and Jasper Counties Population growth estimates are a key element in forecasting traffic growth for a region. For this study, Lochmueller staff researched reliable population growth estimates for Beaufort and Jasper counties. The State of South Carolina’s Revenue and Fiscal Affairs Office provides population growth estimates for all counties within the state through 2035. Table 3 shows the population projections for Beaufort and Jasper Counties for 2035 and the corresponding growth rates. Table 3: Population Growth Projections 2 County Year Annual Growth Rate (%) 2020 2035 Beaufort 187,691 204,374 0.56 Jasper 29,073 34,046 1 Total 216,764 238,420 0.6 Page 172 of 300 Independent Study of the WHP Gateway Corridor: Traffic Forecasting Memorandum February 12, 2024 Page 4 of 8 Historic Annual Average Daily Traffic Volume Trends at the WHP Bridge Lochmueller staff obtained Annual Average Daily Tra ffic (AADT) volumes on WHP near the WHP Bridge (Site ID #0035) from the South Carolina Department of Transportation’s Traffic Data Site 3. Table 4 shows the AADT volumes by year. These volumes effe ctively represent the volume of traffic entering and exiting Hilton Head Island via US 278. As shown in Table 4 , there was a significant reduction in growth betwe en 2019 and 2020 and a significant increase in growth between 2020 and 202 1. Such sudden changes were attributed to COVID-19 pandemic-related restrictions. Overall tra ffic growth on WHP from 2010 to 2023 was approximately 16.5%. Table 4: AADT Volumes on WHP near the WHP Bridge 3 Year AADT Annual Growth (%) 2010 49,600 2011 49,900 0.60% 2012 50,700 1.60% 2013 52,200 2.96% 2014 53,200 1.92% 2015 54,700 2.82% 2016 54,700 0.00% 2017 56,300 2.93% 2018 56,100 -0.36% 2019 57,100 1.78% 2020 51,400 -9.98% 2021 57,400 11.67% 2022 57,400 0.00% 2023 57,800 0.70% Page 173 of 300 Independent Study of the WHP Gateway Corridor: Traffic Forecasting Memorandum February 12, 2024 Page 5 of 8 Short-Term Rental Permit and Tax Revenue Data Lochmueller staff received information on the short -term rental units per year and the accommodation (hotel) and restaurant tax revenues c ollected by the Town of Hilton Head. The short-term rental unit information was available on ly for 2023. Thus, this information was not used in statistical analysis. The accommodation and restaurant tax revenue information was available from 2018 to 2023. Lochmueller staff eval uated the revenue data to test any relation between revenues and the volume of traffic entering and exiting Hilton Head Island. These measures are intended to represent the visitor popu lation as compared to permanent residents reflected in the Census data. Table 5 shows the annual accommodation and restaurant tax revenue information for the Town of Hilton Head Island. Table 5: Annual Accommodation and Hospitality Tax (Source: Town of Hilton Head Island) Year Tax Revenue (2021 USD) Accommodation Tax Hospitality Tax 2018 $3,827,423 $7,419,881 2019 $3,964,475 $6,807,961 2020 $3,624,196 $6,598,684 2021 $5,561,900 $8,051,256 2022 $6,534,674 $9,213,533 2023 $6,260,297 $8,905,425 As shown in Table 5 , the tax revenues have increased significantly sin ce 2020 after a reduction due to Covid-19 Pandemic-related impacts. These inc reases have outpaced traffic growth on WHP entering/exiting the island and can be at least partially attributed to factors beyond the number of visitors to the island, such as high rates of inflation in recent years. Traffic Growth Estimation Using Available Data Lochmueller staff performed regression analyses utilizing the preceding available socio-economic and revenue information data as indicators of traffic on WHP at the WHP bridge. The regression analyses considered AADT volumes as the dependent v ariable and evaluated whether different independent variables (e.g., population, employment , tax revenue) had a statistically significant influence on the AADT volumes. In regression analysis, the coefficient of determination (R 2) and the P-values were used to identify independent variables with significant impact on th e dependent variable. R 2 values explain to what degree an independent variable (e.g., populati on) explains the variation of the dependent variable (AADT). R2 values range from 0 to 1. An R 2 value of 0.7 indicates that 70% of the variation in the output variable can be explained by the independent variable(s). Page 174 of 300 Independent Study of the WHP Gateway Corridor: Traffic Forecasting Memorandum February 12, 2024 Page 6 of 8 The P-value is the probability that the observed di fference between the dependent and independent variables is due to chance. Its value r anges from 0 to 1. A P-value close to 0 means that any observed difference in the dependent varia ble is more likely due to the independent variable (not by chance). For regression analysis w ith a 95% confidence interval, a P-value less than 0.05 would represent a strong correlation betw een the dependent and independent variables. Table 6 shows the simple regression analysis (95% Confidence Interval) results in terms of R 2 and P-values for various independent variables relative to the dependent variable (AADT). Table 6: Simple Regression Analysis Results with Different Independent Variables Independent Variable Co-efficient of Determination (R 2) P-Value Total Population of Beaufort and Jasper Counties 0.95 1.5E-08 Total Employment in Beaufort and Jasper Counties 0.9 8.1E-07 Accommodation Tax 0.64 0.1 Hospitality Tax 0.37 0.28 As shown in Table 6, the total population and total employment in Beaufort and Jasper Counties clearly influence the AADT volumes. P-values in both of these cases are very close to zero, which confirms the differences in AADT are influenced by changes in population and employment numbers in the two counties. On the other hand, there is no clear correlation between hospitality tax and AADT and between accommodation tax and AADT. Lochmueller staff also completed a more complex mul tiple regression analysis combining both independent variables (population and employment). With the multiple regression analysis, the adjusted R 2 value showed almost no improvement. Therefore, the simple regression analysis using the total population of Beaufort and Jasper Counties was utilized to formulate an equation for estimating AADT on WHP as a function of populat ion in the counties. Equation 1 shows the regression equation for the AADT estimate. Equation 1: Regression Equation for AADT Estimate AADT = 0.262684*(Total Population of Beaufort and Jasper Counties) + 830 Page 175 of 300 Independent Study of the WHP Gateway Corridor: Traffic Forecasting Memorandum February 12, 2024 Page 7 of 8 Equation 1 was then used to forecast future traffic on WHP ba sed on anticipated population growth. Lochmueller estimated the 2045 population of Beaufort and Jasper Counties utilizing the following assumptions: • Annual population growth in Hilton Head Island from 2020 to 2045 will be very small (0.1%). As the population within Hilton Head Island is stable and available land for development is very limited. Moreover, population growth in Hilton Head Island from 2010 to 2020 was only 0.2% per year. • Annual population growth from 2020 and 2045 for the rest of Beaufort County and Jasper County will be 0.6%, as suggested by the State of South Carolina’s Revenue and Fiscal Affairs Office, referenced in Table 3 . Based on the above-mentioned population growth assu mptions, Table 7 shows the projected 2045 population for the Beaufort and Jasper Counties. Table 7: Projected Population Geographic Unit Projected Annual Growth Rate Population 2020 2045 Hilton Head Island 0.10% 37,661 38,614 Jasper County and Beaufort County (Excluding Hilton Head Island) 0.60% 178,247 207,000 Total 215,908 245,614 As shown in Table 7 , the total population in 2045 for Beaufort and Jasper Counties was estimated at 245,614. Applying Equation 1 , that population number would translate to 65,349 AADT on WHP at the WHP Bridge. Table 8 shows the estimated annual traffic growth rate fro m 2023 to 2045 based on the 2045 forecast of 65,425 compared to the 2023 traffic count. Page 176 of 300 Independent Study of the WHP Gateway Corridor: Traffic Forecasting Memorandum February 12, 2024 Page 8 of 8 Table 8: Projected Traffic Growth Rate at the WHP Bridge Year AADT Annual Growth Rate (%) 2023 57,800 0.56 2045 65,349 Conclusion Lochmueller determined that the LATS TDM may not be a reliable source of future traffic on WHP. Through careful application of statistical analysis, an alternative method for forecasting traffic on WHP was developed using the population of Beaufort and Jasper Counties as the key indicator. Based on this method, traffic on WHP at the WHP Bridge is expected to increase by 0.56 percent annually, resulting in an AADT forecast of 65,349 daily vehicles in 2045. Lochmueller Group appreciates the opportunity to serve the Town of Hilton Head by performing this independent analysis to determine the appropri ate annual background growth rate that should be utilized for the overall corridor study. Should you have any questions regarding the information shared within this technical memorandum , please do not hesitate to contact us at nnohren@lochgroup.com or 217-821-8435. Reference 1. U.S. Census Bureau (www.census.gov ) 2. South Carolina Revenue and Fiscal Affairs Office. (www.rfa.sc.gov ). 3. South Carolina Department of Transportation Traffic Counts Website. (www.scdot.org/travel/travel-trafficdata.aspx ) Page 177 of 300 P A G E | 36 Independent Study of WHP Gateway Corridor Summary of Submitted Memorandums Corridor Alternatives Analysis Memorandum (Task 3.6) 34 Page 178 of 300 MEMO Huntington Tower, 201 W Springfield Avenue, Suite 1012 Champaign, Illinois 61820 PHONE: 217.673.7633 To: Town of Hilton Head, South Carolina From: Lochmueller Group Date: May 3, 2024 Subject: Independent Study of the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Corridor Alternatives Analysis Memorandum – Task 3.6 Lochmueller Group (Lochmueller) has prepared the following memorandum pertaining to the Independent Study of the William Hilton Pkwy Gateway Corridor. This memorandum summarizes the findings related to the 2023 existing conditions and 2045 no build conditions for the entire project area which includes US 278 from Moss Creek Drive to Indigo Run Drive, as well as US 278 (Palmetto Bay Road) from Cross Island Pkwy to Sea Pines Circle. Figure 1 shows the entire project area which was used for the 2023 existing conditions and 2045 no build analysis. This memorandum also provides a summary of the four alternatives considered for the 2045 build conditions for the modified original project area which extends along US 278 from Moss Creek Dr to Gumtree Road. Figure 2 shows the modified original project area which was used for the 2045 alternatives analysis. The intention of this memorandum is to provide the Town of Hilton Head with the findings of the 2023 existing, 2045 no build, and 2045 alternatives analysis. Page 179 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 2 FIGURE 1. ENTIRE PROJECT STUDY AREA FIGURE 2. MODIFIED ORIGINAL PROJECT STUDY AREA Moss Creek Dr Indigo Run Dr Gumtree Rd Sea Pines Circle Moss Creek Dr Gumtree Rd Page 180 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 3 2023 Existing Conditions The 2023 existing conditions analysis is intended to reflect current conditions. This scenario provides a baseline to ensure accurate calibration of the models as well as serve as a comparison to the future 2045 no build and 2045 alternatives analyses. 2023 Existing Traffic Volumes Traffic volumes were collected by others at the following intersections on March 22, 2023: • Buckingham Plantation Dr and Bluffton Pkwy • Buckingham Plantation Dr and US 278 • Moss Creek Dr and US 278 • WB Bluffton Pkwy Ramp and WB US 278 • EB Bluffton Pkwy Ramp and EB US 278 • Fording Island Rd Extension and US 278 • Pinckney Wildlife Refuge and US 278 • Blue Heron Point Rd and US 278 • Crosstree Dr and US 278 • Jenkins Rd and US 278 • Squire Pope Rd and US 278 • Spanish Wells Rd and US 278 • Cross Island Pkwy Diverge and EB US 278 • Cross Island Pkwy Merge and WB US 278 • Gumtree Rd and Cross Island Pkwy Off and On Ramps • Gumtree Rd and Business US 278 • Jarvis Park Rd and Business US 278 • Pembroke Dr and Business US 278 • Indigo Run Dr and Business US 278 • Marshland Rd and Spanish Wells Rd • Marshland Rd and SB Cross Island Pkwy Ramps • Marshland Rd and NB Cross Island Pkwy Ramps • Arrow Rd and US 278 • Target Rd and US 278 • Sea Pines Circle and US 278 This study evaluates conditions during the morning and evening peak periods of a typical weekday, as these periods represent the most critical times of day for traffic operations within the study area for commuter peaks. If traffic can be accommodated during these peak periods, it stands to reason that adequate capacity would be available throughout the remainder of the day. Corridor studies often reference the 30th highest day for traffic volumes to ensure that the volumes used in the analysis reflect peak conditions, while not over- or under-estimating the traffic volumes. Therefore, it was necessary to ensure that the counts collected accurately reflect the 30 th highest day. Historical traffic data was obtained from SCDOT from the most recent 365 days. Given that the study focuses on commuter peak hours, the hourly data from 6:00 AM – 6:00 PM was referenced. After reviewing the traffic volumes throughout the year, it was determined that March 30, 2023 was the 30th highest day out of the year for traffic volumes. The counts collected on March 22, 2023 were grown by the percent difference between the two dates to bring them up to the estimated traffic volumes on March 30, 2023 (30th highest day). The resulting 2023 traffic volumes used in this study are provided in Appendix A. 2023 Existing Traffic Analysis The 2023 existing traffic analysis was completed using the volumes provided in Appendix A at the study intersections shown in Figure 1. The 2023 existing traffic analysis includes the adaptive signal improvements approved by The Town of Hilton Head and implemented by Q-Free in the fall of 2023. Page 181 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 4 Synchro Analysis This preliminary analysis was completed using Synchro 11 traffic modeling software, which is based upon the methodologies outlined in the “Highway Capacity Manual” (HCM) published by the Transportation Research Board. Intersection performance or traffic operations are quantified by six Levels of Service (LOS), which range from LOS A ("Free Flow”) to LOS F ("Fully Saturated"). LOS D is considered acceptable for peak period conditions in urban and suburban areas. However, at side-street stop-controlled intersections, a LOS E or even a LOS F is a common occurrence for peak period conditions in urban and suburban areas as it is typical for delays to be longer for vehicles along the side -street as they wait to find acceptable gaps in the traffic to turn left into the traffic stream. Levels of service for intersections are determined based on the average d elay experienced by motorists. Signalized intersections reflect higher delay tolerances as compared to unsignalized and roundabout locations because motorists are accustomed to and accepting of longer delays at signals. For signalized and all-way stop intersections, the average control delay per vehicle is estimated for each movement and then aggregated for each approach and the intersection as a whole. For intersections with partial ( side- street) stop control, the delay is calculated for the minor movements only (side -street approaches and major road left-turns) since thru traffic on the major road is not required to stop. Table 1 summarizes the criterion for both signalized and unsignalized inte rsections, as defined by the Highway Capacity Manual (HCM) 6th Edition, last updated in 2016 by the Transportation Research Board. TABLE 1: INTERSECTION LEVEL OF SERVICE THRESHOLDS Level of Service Control Delay per Vehicle (sec/veh) Signalized Unsignalized/Roundabout A < 10 0-10 B > 10-20 > 10-15 C > 20-35 > 15-25 D > 35-55 > 25-35 E > 55-80 > 35-50 F > 80 > 50 Operating conditions at the study intersections were evaluated using Synchro 11 and are summarized in Table 2. The measures of effectiveness reported include LOS, delay, queue, and volume -to-capacity ratio (v/c). The delay is reported in seconds per vehicle. The queue is reported in feet as the 95th percentile queue. The v/c ratio compares vehicle demand to the capacity of an associated lane group. A v/c ratio of 1.0 represents a road segment that is at full capacity. As shown, eastbound traffic experiences significant congestion during the AM peak period , whereas westbound traffic experiences significant congestion during the PM peak period. This is consistent with the commuter traffic patterns in the Town of Hilton Head. While several intersections experience long delays and queue lengths during the AM peak hour, the PM peak hour appears to have overall worse operating conditions . Long delays occur along side-streets at Page 182 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 5 unsignalized intersections throughout the entire study area. Additionally, a rolling queue begins at Wilborn Rd and continues in the westbound lanes of US 278 over the bridge during the PM peak hour. The westbound queue length reaches up to approximately 2,500 ft (101 cars) at Squire Pope during the PM peak hour. It is evident that the study area currently experiences congestion during both the AM and PM peak periods. TABLE 2. 2023 EXISTING OPERATING CONDITIONS (SYNCHRO) Intersection & Movements LOS (Delay, sec) [95th Queue Length, ft] <v/c ratio> AM Peak Hour PM Peak Hour 1: Buckingham Plantation Dr & Bluffton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection B (10.4) B (15.3) Eastbound Approach A (7.1) [196] <0.37> A (9.1) [166] <0.29> Westbound Approach B (12.4) [146] <0.21> B (17.5) [346] <0.46> Northbound Approach D (41.9) [63] <0.14> C (34.2) [48] <0.15> Southbound Approach B (18.4) [55] <0.25> C (24.3) [m81] <0.30> 2: Buckingham Plantation Dr/Moss Creek Dr & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection B (19.2) C (29.6) Eastbound Approach B (15.0) [413] <0.56> B (19.5) [391] <0.64> Westbound Approach B (14.6) [291] <0.36> C (26.8) [710] <0.71> Northbound Approach D (45.5) [126] <0.67> E (75.9) [103] <0.56> Southbound Approach E (59.4) [107] <0.57> F (81.3) [#174] <0.91> 3: Salt Marsh Dr/Moss Creek Village & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Eastbound Left Turn C (16.5) [<25] <0.03> E (43.4) [<25] <0.22> Westbound Left Turn D (33.5) [<25] <0.05> D (26.6) [<25] <0.15> Northbound Approach D (26.5) [<25] <0.23> C (21.7) [<25] <0.23> Southbound Approach D (30.8) [45] <0.41> F (165.4) [150] <0.99> 4: Fording Island Rd Ext & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn C (18.0) [<25] <0.02> B (14.8) [<25] <0.04> Northbound Approach F (242.4) [75] <0.81> F ($744.7) [168] <1.97> 5: Boat Landing Driveway/Wildlife Refuge Driveway & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn C (15.4) [<25] <0.01> E (45.1) [<25] <0.05> Westbound Left Turn No volumes observed C (22.7) [<25] <0.01> Northbound Approach E (38.1) [<25] <0.02> F ($2538.4) [68] <2.99> Southbound Approach No volumes observed F (50.4) [<25] <0.17> Page 183 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 6 6: Blue Heron Point Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn No volumes observed C (23.8) [<25] <0.01> Northbound Approach F ($794.0) [58] <1.19> F ($2033.9) [118] <3.51> 7: Crosstree Dr (Windmill Harbour) & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection B (15.5) E (59.1) Eastbound Approach C (21.2) [#1701] <0.97> B (10.3) [697] <0.82> Westbound Approach A (5.2) [291] <0.62> F (93.2) [#2084] <1.16> Northbound Approach D (38.0) [65] <0.42> E (68.0) [105] <0.72> Southbound Approach 0 (0.0) [<25] <0.01> 0 (0.0) [<25] <0.00> 8: Jenkins Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn C (15.6) [<25] <0.02> F (56.9) [<25] <0.13> Southbound Approach F ($469.6) [45] <0.73> F ($7285.9) [158] <12.12> 5: Boat Landing Driveway/Wildlife Refuge Driveway & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn C (15.4) [<25] <0.01> E (45.1) [<25] <0.05> Westbound Left Turn No volumes observed C (22.7) [<25] <0.01> Northbound Approach E (38.1) [<25] <0.02> F ($2538.4) [68] <2.99> Southbound Approach No volumes observed F (50.4) [<25] <0.17> 6: Blue Heron Point Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn No volumes observed C (23.8) [<25] <0.01> Northbound Approach F ($794.0) [58] <1.19> F ($2033.9) [118] <3.51> 7: Crosstree Dr (Windmill Harbour) & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection B (15.5) E (59.1) Eastbound Approach C (21.2) [#1701] <0.97> B (10.3) [697] <0.82> Westbound Approach A (5.2) [291] <0.62> F (93.2) [#2084] <1.16> Northbound Approach D (38.0) [65] <0.42> E (68.0) [105] <0.72> Southbound Approach 0 (0.0) [<25] <0.01> 0 (0.0) [<25] <0.00> 8: Jenkins Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn C (15.6) [<25] <0.02> F (56.9) [<25] <0.13> Southbound Approach F ($469.6) [45] <0.73> F ($7285.9) [158] <12.12> 9: Chamberlin Dr/Squire Pope Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection B (12.5) F (101.4) Eastbound Approach A (6.3) [530] <0.66> B (14.4) [#387] <0.93> Westbound Approach A (9.4) [264] <0.55> F (140.5) [~2514] <1.26> Northbound Approach C (24.0) [<25] <0.03> E (79.9) [70] <0.22> Page 184 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 7 Southbound Approach F (97.3) [#319] <1.01> F (296.1) [#709] <1.61> 10: Old Wild Horse Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Southbound Approach C (21.5) [28] <0.28> F (53.5) [<25] <0.13> 11: Spanish Wells Rd/Wild Horse Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (30.1) D (36.0) Eastbound Approach C (26.2) [1224] <0.85> B (16.7) [383] <0.62> Westbound Approach B (18.2) [274] <0.66> C (25.2) [862] <0.80> Northbound Approach E (61.8) [223] <0.62> F (214.3) [#667] <1.46> Southbound Approach F (117.7) [#284] <1.00> E (65.7) [187] <0.36> 12: Gumtree Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection E (59.1) E (66.1) Eastbound Approach E (64.3) [#1177] <0.98> E (65.7) [763] <0.90> Westbound Approach C (33.6) [#412] <0.93> D (54.5) [648] <1.00> Northbound Approach E (72.0) [#312] <0.89> E (61.5) [351] <0.86> Southbound Approach F (90.7) [#418] <0.90> F (115.5) [#517] <1.07> 13: Jarvis Park Rd/Wilborn Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (22.1) C (30.8) Eastbound Approach B (16.6) [m516] <0.74> C (20.5) [m596] <0.73> Westbound Approach B (11.3) [316] <0.50> C (25.6) [#1420] <0.98> Northbound Approach F (99.7) [143] <0.61> F (108.7) [146] <0.76> Southbound Approach E (65.5) [262] <0.77> E (67.9) [223] <0.96> 14: Pembroke Dr/Museum St & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection B (19.7) C (29.6) Eastbound Approach B (11.2) [560] <0.73> B (18.0) [546] <0.60> Westbound Approach A (9.0) [155] <0.44> C (22.9) [508] <0.82> Northbound Approach F (101.1) [#317] <0.86> F (89.3) [324] <0.84> Southbound Approach D (39.8) [78] <0.39> D (49.2) [95] <0.60> 15: Central Ave & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn B (10.7) [<25] <0.01> B (14.9) [<25] <0.01> Westbound Left Turn C (16.0) [<25] <0.02> B (12.3) [<25] <0.01> Northbound Right Turn C (18.3) [<25] <0.02> B (14.5) [<25] <0.03> Southbound Right Turn B (12.8) [<25] <0.05> C (17.1) [<25] <0.02> Page 185 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 8 16: Hatton Pl/Merchant St & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Northbound Right Turn C (17.6) [<25] <0.04> C (16.1) [<25] <0.17> Southbound Right Turn B (12.7) [<25] <0.02> C (17.5) [<25] <0.04> 17: Indigo Run Dr/Whooping Crane Way & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (31.1) D (42.1) Eastbound Approach C (27.3) [693] <0.65> C (30.8) [634] <0.71> Westbound Approach B (16.2) [343] <0.41> C (31.3) [891] <0.75> Northbound Approach E (70.1) [112] <0.48> E (68.9) [205] <0.68> Southbound Approach E (70.3) [#188] <0.78> F (96.0) [#247] <0.98> 18: Cross Island Pkwy SB Ramp/Gumtree Rd & Honey Horn Rd (un -signalized) Eastbound Approach B (11.0) [<25] <0.00> B (12.8) [<25] <0.15> 19: Cross Island Pkwy SB Ramp & Marshland Rd (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn A (8.9) [<25] <0.12> A (8.4) [<25] <0.14> Southbound Left Turn C (17.2) [<25] <0.08> D (33.6) [35] <0.35> Southbound Right Turn A (9.2) [<25] <0.04> B (12.9) [<25] <0.16> 20: Cross Island Pkwy NB Ramp & Marshland Rd (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn A (8.2) [<25] <0.11> A (8.4) [<25] <0.05> Northbound Left Turn B (14.5) [<25] <0.17> C (23.0) [100] <0.61> Northbound Right Turn A (9.2) [<25] <0.07> B (10.2) [<25] <0.20> 21: Palmetto Bay Rd & Bay Pines Rd (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn - F (209.4) [30] <0.40> Eastbound Right Turn C (18.7) [<25] <0.02> B (14.9) [<25] <0.03> Northbound Left Turn C (16.4) [<25] <0.02> B (13.0) [<25] <0.05> 22: Palmetto Bay Rd & Point Comfort Rd/Arrow Rd (signal) Overall Intersection B (13.8) C (21.1) Eastbound Approach D (43.3) [175] <0.70> C (30.2) [101] <0.38> Westbound Approach C (28.0) [74] <0.44> D (46.9) [249] <0.88> Northbound Approach A (5.4) [75] <0.30> B (17.8) [756] <0.66> Southbound Approach B (11.5) [535] <0.61> B (15.4) [432] <0.65> 23: Palmetto Bay Rd & Genesta St (un-signalized) Westbound Approach D (33.1) [<25] <0.08> F (84.2) [<25] <0.19> Southbound Left Turn A (9.6) [<25] <0.02> B (14.6) [<25] <0.01> Page 186 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 9 24: Palmetto Bay Rd & Palmetto Business Park Rd (un-signalized) Westbound Approach D (33.8) [<25] <0.08> F (61.2) [<25] <0.20> Southbound Left Turn A (9.6) [<25] <0.03> B (14.6) [<25] <0.01> 25: Palmetto Bay Rd & Bow Cir (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn C (23.7) [<25] <0.03> E (41.3) [<25] <0.10> Westbound Right Turn B (11.1) [<25] <0.01> C (16.7) [<25] <0.03> Southbound Left Turn A (9.8) [<25] <0.05> B (14.6) [<25] <0.03> 26: Palmetto Bay Rd & Archer Rd (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn C (24.7) [<25] <0.06> E (41.3) [<25] <0.10> Westbound Right Turn B (11.2) [<25] <0.01> C (16.7) [<25] <0.03> Southbound Left Turn A (9.9) [<25] <0.07> B (14.6) [<25] <0.03> 27: Palmetto Bay Rd & Target Rd (signal) Overall Intersection B (10.6) B (18.6) Eastbound Approach D (39.4) [82] <0.32> E (59.5) [247] <0.80> Westbound Approach E (56.6) [154] <0.68> C (33.7) [119] <0.49> Northbound Approach A (8.7) [199] <0.31> B (15.3) [530] <0.59> Southbound Approach A (3.9) [102] <0.58> A (8.7) [155] <0.53> 28: Palmetto Bay Rd & Dunnagans Alley (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn D (26.5) [<25] <0.03> E (40.3) [<25] <0.24> Westbound Right Turn B (11.4) [<25] <0.02> C (17.1) [<25] <0.18> Southbound Left Turn B (10.6) [<25] <0.16> B (13.0) [<25] <0.02> 29: Palmetto Bay Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (Sea Pines Circle, RAB) Overall Intersection D (25.8) C (24.4) Eastbound Approach D (34.2) [200] <0.81> E (45.6) [300] <0.92> Westbound Approach C (16.4) [125] <0.64> E (36.6) [75] <0.85> Northbound Approach B (12.1) [75] <0.54> D (32.4) [275] <0.88> Southbound Approach F (59.4) [500] <1.03> E (39.2) [375] <0.94> # – 95th Percentile volume exceeds capacity $ – Delay more than 300 seconds m – Upstream metering is in effect VISSIM Analysis In addition to Synchro, the traffic analysis was also completed using VISSIM, which is a microsimulation tool that accurately replicates individual vehicles and their interactions within complex traffic streams, such as interchanges, freeways, and expressway corridors with signalized intersections. A robust amount of data and field observations were conducted to calibrate VISSIM to reproduce field conditions . Page 187 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 10 Field observations were conducted over the course of two weekdays in December 2023 and included both the AM and PM peak periods. Travel time runs and average speeds were conducted during the AM and PM peak periods along William Hilton Pkwy between Moss Creek and Indigo Run, as well as from William Hilton Pkwy at Moss Creek Dr to Cross Island Pkwy at Sea Pines Circle, to aid in the calibration of the VISSIM model. As part of the calibration criteria, it was determined that the travel times reported in the VISSIM model should be within 10% of the travel times recorded in the field. The travel times calculated in the VISSIM model were inflated by 15% to account for higher volumes in March versus in December when the travel times were collected. The travel time results are provided in Table 3. As shown all of the travel times were within 10%, therefore all travel time targets were satisfied. TABLE 3. 2023 EXISTING VISSIM CALIBRATION TRAVEL TIME RESULTS Corridor Observed travel time (secs) Simulated travel time (secs) % Difference AM PM AM PM AM PM William Hilton Pkwy between Moss Creek and Indigo Run EB 1108 672 1157 619 4.42% -7.91% WB 605 1202 572 1252 -5.50% 4.17% William Hilton Pkwy @Moss Creek to Cross Island Pkwy @Sea Pine SB 1378 821 1356 857 -1.58% 4.37% NB 800 1516 826 1520 3.20% 0.25% In addition to travel time calculations, traffic volumes were also used to help calibrate the VISSIM model. Similar to the travel times, it was determined that the traffic volumes reported in the VISSIM model should be within 10% of the 2023 existing traffic volumes provided in Appendix A. The traffic volume results are provided in Table 4. As shown all of the traffic volumes were within 10%, therefore all traffic volume targets were satisfied. TABLE 4. 2023 EXISTING VISSIM CALIBRATION TRAFFIC VOLUMES RESULTS Location Observed traffic volumes (vehicles) Simulated traffic volumes (vehicles) % Difference AM PM AM PM AM PM William Hilton Pkwy west of Squire Pope EB 2774 2237 2970 2240 7.07% 0.13% William Hilton Pkwy west of Squire Pope WB 1639 3030 1650 2898 0.67% -4.36% William Hilton Pkwy east of Spanish Wells EB 2729 1991 2929 1955 7.33% -1.81% William Hilton Pkwy east of Spanish Wells WB 1408 2623 1423 2614 1.07% -0.34% Cross Island Pkwy north of Marshland Rd NB 975 1422 964 1371 -1.13% -3.59% Cross Island Pkwy north of Marshland Rd SB 1416 1190 1486 1167 4.94% -1.93% Page 188 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 11 The VISSIM traffic models evaluate conditions during the morning and afternoon peak hours and provide performance measures as outputs. The LOS criteria for signalized and unsignalized intersections are the same as Table 1. The measures of effectiveness (MOE) reported include levels of service, delay, average queue length, and maximum queue length. The delay is reported in seconds per vehicle and the queue is reported in feet. The 2023 existing operating conditions based on the VISSIM model are summarized in Table 5. As shown, the traffic operations largely agree with those shown in Table 2 from the Synchro analysis. The PM peak hour appears to have overall worse operating conditions. The long delays presented in the Synchro analysis along side-streets at unsignalized intersections throughout the entire study area were confirmed in this VISSIM analysis. Therefore, it can be concluded that the study area currently experiences significant congestion during both the AM and PM peak periods. TABLE 5. 2023 EXISTING TRAFFIC OPERATIONS (VISSIM) Intersection & Movements LOS (Delay, sec) [95th Queue Length, ft] {Max Queue, ft} AM Peak Hour PM Peak Hour 1: Buckingham Plantation Dr & Bluffton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection B (12.2) B (11.4) Eastbound Approach B (12.5) [43] {324} B (11.7) [<25] {178} Westbound Approach A (8.3) [<25] {171} A (9.3) [<25] {234} Northbound Approach D (38.1) [<25] {73} C (32.2) [<25] {65} Southbound Approach A (9.0) [<25] {68} B (12.6) [<25] {84} 2: Buckingham Plantation Dr/Moss Creek Dr & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection D (47.2) B (19.5) Eastbound Approach E (70.7) [807] {1620} B (15.6) [65] {522} Westbound Approach B (14.4) [35] {353} B (19.1) [100] {633} Northbound Approach D (35.9) [37] {263} D (53.6) [<25] {104} Southbound Approach D (42.4) [<25] {92} C (33.6) [29] {161} 3: Salt Marsh Dr/Moss Creek Village & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn E (35.3) [720] {1302} C (19.7) [<25] {47} Westbound Left Turn F (414.9) [37] {107} B (11.2) [<25] {41} Northbound Approach B (10.1) [<25] {61} A (7.3) [<25] {55} Southbound Approach C (19.7) [<25] {76} A (8.0) [<25] {73} 4: Fording Island Rd Ext & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn E (40.7) [46] {102} C (16.8) [<25] {28} Northbound Approach F (591.0) [120] {186} C (17.5) [<25] {41} Page 189 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 12 5: Boat Landing Driveway/Wildlife Refuge Driveway & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn C (21.4) [691] {1658} D (33.1) [<25] {<25} Westbound Left Turn No volumes observed C (20.9) [<25] {<25} Northbound Approach F (270.5) [<25] {38} C (20.8) [<25] {46} Southbound Approach No volumes observed C (18.2) [<25] {39} 6: Blue Heron Point Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn No volumes observed D (27.7) [<25] {<25} Northbound Approach F (1,270.4) [123] {228} C (23.8) [<25] {60} 7: Crosstree Dr (Windmill Harbour) & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection B (10.4) A (8.2) Eastbound Approach A (8.4) [335] {1093} A (5.4) [62] {890} Westbound Approach B (10.7) [53] {655} A (7.5) [292] {1626} Northbound Approach E (67.8) [30] {164} E (79.0) [52] {214} Southbound Approach B (17.3) [<25] {<25} A (0.0) [<25] {<25} 8: Jenkins Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn A (8.2) [<25] {<25} F (98.0) [<25] {54} Southbound Approach F (51.8) [<25] {44} F (109.4) [<25] {92} 9: Chamberlin Dr/Squire Pope Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection D (39.2) E (67.3) Eastbound Approach E (56.8) [451] {1334} B (19.3) [283] {1132} Westbound Approach A (7.0) [39] {618} F (104.8) [874] {1383} Northbound Approach C (31.9) [<25] {38} E (78.6) [<25] {76} Southbound Approach C (21.7) [<25] {147} F (91.6) [220] {638} 10: Old Wild Horse Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Southbound Approach A (1.3) [<25] {<25} A (6.4) [<25] {25} 11: Spanish Wells Rd/Wild Horse Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (29.8) F (240.4) Eastbound Approach C (26.6) [270] {1027} B (17.1) [103] {622} Westbound Approach C (21.9) [87] {471} F (415.7) [892] {989} Northbound Approach E (57.1) [85] {321} F (395.1) [1241] {1288} Southbound Approach F (89.0) [103] {319} E (63.9) [58] {242} Page 190 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 13 12: Gumtree Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection D (40.7) E (66.4) Eastbound Approach D (40.6) [765] {1592} D (49.9) [203] {779} Westbound Approach C (30.3) [136] {357} E (75.2) [961] {1610} Northbound Approach C (29.0) [75] {291} D (45.2) [175] {338} Southbound Approach E (77.2) [182] {579} F (93.4) [234] {779} 9: Chamberlin Dr/Squire Pope Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection D (39.2) E (67.3) Eastbound Approach E (56.8) [451] {1334} B (19.3) [283] {1132} Westbound Approach A (7.0) [39] {618} F (104.8) [874] {1383} Northbound Approach C (31.9) [<25] {38} E (78.6) [<25] {76} Southbound Approach C (21.7) [<25] {147} F (91.6) [220] {638} 10: Old Wild Horse Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Southbound Approach A (1.3) [<25] {<25} A (6.4) [<25] {25} 11: Spanish Wells Rd/Wild Horse Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (29.8) F (240.4) Eastbound Approach C (26.6) [270] {1027} B (17.1) [103] {622} Westbound Approach C (21.9) [87] {471} F (415.7) [892] {989} Northbound Approach E (57.1) [85] {321} F (395.1) [1241] {1288} Southbound Approach F (89.0) [103] {319} E (63.9) [58] {242} 12: Gumtree Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection D (40.7) E (66.4) Eastbound Approach D (40.6) [765] {1592} D (49.9) [203] {779} Westbound Approach C (30.3) [136] {357} E (75.2) [961] {1610} Northbound Approach C (29.0) [75] {291} D (45.2) [175] {338} Southbound Approach E (77.2) [182] {579} F (93.4) [234] {779} 13: Jarvis Park Rd/Wilborn Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (21.8) C (25.8) Eastbound Approach B (17.1) [178] {929} B (13.8) [67] {754} Westbound Approach B (17.9) [73] {543} C (34.2) [668] {1285} Northbound Approach F (81.1) [45] {168} E (77.4) [43] {186} Southbound Approach D (45.4) [72] {233} C (21.7) [28] {120} Page 191 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 14 14: Pembroke Dr/Museum St & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection B (18.7) C (33.7) Eastbound Approach B (12.6) [134] {991} B (14.3) [76] {754} Westbound Approach B (12.7) [39] {443} D (42.4) [645] {1261} Northbound Approach E (72.0) [84] {274} E (69.4) [93] {310} Southbound Approach D (37.3) [<25] {91} D (42.2) [<25] {115} 15: Central Ave & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn A (8.5) [<25] {<25} F (55.9) [<25] {50} Westbound Left Turn C (16.5) [<25] {<25} A (9.7) [<25] {<25} Northbound Right Turn C (21.6) [<25] {27} B (12.4) [<25] {32} Southbound Right Turn B (11.3) [<25] {41} F (165.1) [<25] {65} 16: Hatton Pl/Merchant St & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Northbound Right Turn B (11.5) [<25] {25} A (7.7) [<25] {61} Southbound Right Turn B (10.6) [<25] {46} F (93.1) [<25] {72} 17: Indigo Run Dr/Whooping Crane Way & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (23.3) D (44.1) Eastbound Approach B (18.9) [115] {848} C (30.6) [116] {772} Westbound Approach B (15.3) [40] {333} D (44.8) [592] {1536} Northbound Approach D (54.0) [29] {103} E (58.6) [46] {190} Southbound Approach D (49.7) [52] {187} E (73.4) [83] {324} 18: Cross Island Pkwy SB Ramp/Gumtree Rd & Honey Horn Rd (un -signalized) Eastbound Approach A (9.1) [<25] {45} B (10.9) [<25] {61} 19: Cross Island Pkwy SB Ramp & Marshland Rd (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn A (3.7) [<25] {63} A (2.1) [<25] {60} Southbound Left Turn A (8.8) [<25] {47} B (10.6) [<25] {77} Southbound Right Turn A (6.1) [<25] {80} A (7.9) [<25] {110} 20: Cross Island Pkwy NB Ramp & Marshland Rd (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn A (1.3) [<25] {36} A (1.4) [<25] {<25} Northbound Left Turn B (10.8) [<25] {69} C (21.3) [31] {193} Northbound Right Turn A (6.0) [<25] {94} A (7.0) [46] {218} 21: Palmetto Bay Rd & Bay Pines Rd (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn No volumes observed E (40.7) [<25] {33} Eastbound Right Turn B (14.3) [<25] {25} B (12.5) [<25] {31} Northbound Left Turn A (9.0) [<25] {<25} A (7.1) [<25] {34} Page 192 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 15 22: Palmetto Bay Rd & Point Comfort Rd/Arrow Rd (signal) Overall Intersection B (13.2) B (16.9) Eastbound Approach C (33.3) [52] {191} C (32.0) [37] {175} Westbound Approach B (18.8) [<25] {106} C (23.2) [56] {261} Northbound Approach B (10.5) [29] {261} B (15.7) [92] {612} Southbound Approach B (10.9) [94] {873} B (14.2) [67] {606} 23: Palmetto Bay Rd & Genesta St (un-signalized) Westbound Approach C (17.1) [<25] {50} C (18.1) [<25] {52} Southbound Left Turn A (3.2) [<25] {<25} B (13.2) [<25] {<25} 24: Palmetto Bay Rd & Palmetto Business Park Rd (un-signalized) Westbound Approach C (18.0) [<25] {53} C (17.4) [<25] {53} Southbound Left Turn A (4.0) [<25] {37} A (7.5) [<25] {<25} 25: Palmetto Bay Rd & Bow Cir (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn D (27.5) [<25] {<25} D (30.0) [<25] {35} Westbound Right Turn A (8.4) [<25] {58} B (13.1) [<25] {68} Southbound Left Turn A (3.6) [<25] {40} B (11.0) [<25] {26} 26: Palmetto Bay Rd & Archer Rd (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn D (30.6) [<25] {27} D (32.8) [<25] {39} Westbound Right Turn A (8.8) [<25] {63} B (11.4) [<25] {75} Southbound Left Turn A (4.3) [<25] {98} B (11.9) [<25] {<25} 27: Palmetto Bay Rd & Target Rd (signal) Overall Intersection B (16.0) B (17.6) Eastbound Approach C (33.3) [<25] {110} D (41.8) [62] {248} Westbound Approach D (37.1) [35] {151} C (29.4) [38] {149} Northbound Approach A (9.7) [28] {214} B (13.3) [71] {508} Southbound Approach B (15.4) [287] {1309} B (13.9) [99] {742} 28: Palmetto Bay Rd & Dunnagans Alley (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn F (184.7) [<25] {50} F (65.5) [<25] {75} Westbound Right Turn A (9.1) [<25] {84} B (13.1) [<25] {110} Southbound Left Turn B (10.4) [112] {512} B (12.5) [<25] {383} Page 193 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 16 29: Palmetto Bay Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (Sea Pines Circle, RAB) Overall Intersection E (37.0) F (51.8) Eastbound Approach F (208.4) [615] {814} F (51.0) [285] {770} Westbound Approach A (7.5) [<25] {263} F (168.3) [1635] {1658} Northbound Approach A (4.2) [<25] {223} D (30.8) [228] {738} Southbound Approach B (12.9) [194] {461} A (8.4) [85] {460} 2045 No Build Conditions The 2045 no build conditions analysis is intended to reflect future conditions within the study area while accounting for an increase in “background” traffic. No modifications were made to the lane configurations. However, the 2045 no build scenario does include the effects of the adaptive signal system implemented in the fall of 2023. 2045 No Build Traffic Volumes In order to evaluate traffic conditions through the year 2045, it was necessary to forecast the anticipated growth within the study area based on an increase in “background” traffic resulting from increasing population and commercial and employment growth in The Town of Hilton Head. An annual background growth rate of 0.56% was determined after careful consideration of the Lowcountry Area Transportation Study (LATS) Travel Demand Model (TDM), census data, Beaufort County historic growth trends, historic traffic growth on the US 278 bridge, sale and restaurant tax revenue, public parking revenue, and short term rental data. A memorandum detailing the methodology behind the 0.56% growth rate is provided an Appendix B. The 2023 existing traffic volumes (Appendix A) were grown annually by 0.56% to 2045 in order to produce the 2045 no build traffic volumes which are provided in Appendix C. 2045 No Build Traffic Analysis Similar to the 2023 existing conditions, the 2045 no build traffic analysis was completed using both Synchro and VISSIM. The 2045 no build operating conditions were evaluated using the same methodology applied to the 2023 existing conditions. Synchro Analysis The 2045 no build operating conditions at the study intersections were evaluated using Synchro 11 and are summarized in Table 6. As shown, the previously failing conditions and congestion experienced in the 2023 existing conditions are expected to be exacerbated by 2045 with the forecasted growth. Significant congestion is expected throughout the study area. Therefore, it can be concluded tha t the study intersections cannot accommodate the forecasted traffic growth in their existing state. Page 194 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 17 TABLE 6. 2045 NO BUILD OPERATING CONDITIONS (SYNCHRO) Intersection & Movements LOS (Delay, sec) [95th Queue Length, ft] <v/c ratio> AM Peak Hour PM Peak Hour 1: Buckingham Plantation Dr & Bluffton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection B (17.6) C (25.5) Eastbound Approach B (15.1) [298] <0.54> B (16.0) [207] <0.50> Westbound Approach C (25.4) [202] <0.38> D (36.7) [#496] <0.86> Northbound Approach B (15.9) [37] <0.08> B (15.7) [30] <0.11> Southbound Approach A (9.9) [m23] <0.18> A (6.1) [m21] <0.23> 2: Buckingham Plantation Dr/Moss Creek Dr & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection B (18.2) C (26.9) Eastbound Approach B (16.9) [443] <0.64> B (17.1) [345] <0.75> Westbound Approach B (17.9) [290] <0.51> C (28.1) [#644] <0.89> Northbound Approach C (21.2) [98] <0.56> D (49.7) [m#76] <0.74> Southbound Approach C (31.2) [70] <0.45> E (60.9) [#123] <0.88> 3: Salt Marsh Dr/Moss Creek Village & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn C (18.8) [<25] <0.03> F (65.8) [33] <0.33> Westbound Left Turn E (44.8) [<25] <0.08> D (34.9) [<25] <0.22> Northbound Approach D (34.4) [33] <0.31> D (26.7) [30] <0.30> Southbound Approach F (57.0) [88] <0.63> F (649.6) [273] <2.05> 4: Fording Island Rd Ext & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn C (21.6) [<25] <0.02> C (17.0) [<25] <0.06> Northbound Approach F (684.9) [115] <1.63> F ($1880.2) [225] <4.10> 5: Boat Landing Driveway/Wildlife Refuge Driveway & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn C (17.8) [<25] <0.01> F (67.3) [<25] <0.08> Westbound Left Turn No volumes observed C (28.7) [<25] <0.01> Northbound Approach F (50.7) [<25] <0.03> D (32.3) [<25] <0.09> Southbound Approach No volumes observed F (74.9) [<25] <0.26> 6: Blue Heron Point Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn No volumes observed D (30.2) [<25] <0.01> Northbound Approach F ($1763.6) [73] <2.35> F ($5024.3) [145] <8.33> Page 195 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 18 7: Crosstree Dr (Windmill Harbour) & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection E (67.8) F (92.1) Eastbound Approach F (105.5) [#2262] <1.19> C (33.3) [#1547] <1.00> Westbound Approach A (5.9) [320] <0.64> F (133.8) [~2456] <1.26> Northbound Approach B (14.6) [34] <0.39> E (77.5) [#106] <0.86> Southbound Approach 0 (0.0) [<25] <0.01> 0 (0.0) [<25] <0.00> 8: Jenkins Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn C (18.3) [<25] <0.03> F (91.5) [<25] <0.22> Southbound Approach F ($1398.4) [65] <1.86> F (151.3) [73] <.69> 9: Chamberlin Dr/Squire Pope Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (23.4) F (144.6) Eastbound Approach B (15.2) [918] <0.81> B (12.6) [370] <0.91> Westbound Approach C (31.1) [625] <0.74> F (233.2) [m#2394] <1.49> Northbound Approach B (13.0) [<25] <0.02> E (70.6) [67] <0.29> Southbound Approach E (69.0) [#286] <0.92> F (231.6) [#577] <1.46> 10: Old Wild Horse Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Southbound Approach D (26.7) [40] <0.36> F (77.9) [<25] <0.20> 11: Spanish Wells Rd/Wild Horse Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection D (37.5) D (45.1) Eastbound Approach D (38.7) [#1280] <1.02> C (20.5) [381] <0.89> Westbound Approach C (24.0) [345] <0.91> D (45.2) [m909] <0.99> Northbound Approach D (51.5) [214] <0.60> F (171.7) [#606] <1.35> Southbound Approach F (94.1) [#306] <0.97> D (49.3) [168] <0.34> 12: Gumtree Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection F (84.2) F (80.1) Eastbound Approach F (94.6) [~1146] <1.16> D (54.0) [#842] <0.99> Westbound Approach D (43.1) [#391] <0.90> D (44.6) [m539] <0.97> Northbound Approach F (113.6) [#372] <1.13> F (137.9) [#466] <1.29> Southbound Approach F (119.0) [#473] <1.09> F (178.8) [#506] <1.33> 13: Jarvis Park Rd/Wilborn Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (20.2) E (57.5) Eastbound Approach B (16.0) [257] <0.90> A (7.6) [m262] <0.76> Westbound Approach B (12.0) [306] <0.69> D (38.2) [#1335] <1.01> Northbound Approach F (82.7) [136] <0.58> F (259.8) [#208] <1.33> Page 196 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 19 Southbound Approach D (52.5) [249] <0.73> F (250.2) [#358] <1.61> 14: Pembroke Dr/Museum St & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (27.8) D (38.3) Eastbound Approach B (15.6) [#1252] <0.91> B (13.7) [351] <0.71> Westbound Approach D (36.7) [681] <0.55> D (47.7) [1072] <0.89> Northbound Approach E (73.6) [254] <0.76> F (86.1) [#355] <0.89> Southbound Approach C (32.7) [74] <0.36> D (49.5) [93] <0.68> 15: Central Ave & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn B (11.4) [<25] <0.01> B (17.2) [<25] <0.02> Westbound Left Turn C (18.7) [<25] <0.02> B (13.6) [<25] <0.01> Northbound Right Turn C (21.0) [<25] <0.03> C (15.9) [<25] <0.04> Southbound Right Turn B (13.8) [<25] <0.06> C (19.5) [<25] <0.03> 16: Hatton Pl/Merchant St & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Northbound Right Turn C (17.6) [<25] <0.04> C (16.1) [<25] <0.17> Southbound Right Turn B (12.7) [<25] <0.02> C (17.5) [<25] <0.04> 17: Indigo Run Dr/Whooping Crane Way & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection B (18.0) D (36.4) Eastbound Approach A (3.5) [<25] <0.79> B (16.9) [#297] <0.93> Westbound Approach B (19.2) [407] <0.51> D (38.4) [#951] <0.92> Northbound Approach E (62.2) [112] <0.52> E (70.5) [#245] <0.82> Southbound Approach D (54.9) [178] <0.71> E (67.7) [212] <0.86> 18: Cross Island Pkwy SB Ramp/Gumtree Rd & Honey Horn Rd (un -signalized) Eastbound Approach B (11.5) [<25] <0.00> B (13.8) [<25] <0.19> 19: Cross Island Pkwy SB Ramp & Marshland Rd (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn A (9.1) [<25] <0.14> A (8.6) [<25] <0.17> Southbound Left Turn C (19.7) [<25] <0.1> E (49.9) [58] <0.49> Southbound Right Turn A (9.4) [<25] <0.05> B (14.1) [<25] <0.19> 20: Cross Island Pkwy NB Ramp & Marshland Rd (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn A (8.3) [<25] <0.12> A (8.6) [<25] <0.06> Northbound Left Turn C (16.2) [<25] <0.21> D (34.1) [160] <0.75> Northbound Right Turn A (9.4) [<25] <0.08> B (10.6) [<25] <0.23> Page 197 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 20 21: Palmetto Bay Rd & Bay Pines Rd (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn No volumes observed F ($454) [50] <0.74> Eastbound Right Turn C (21.7) [<25] <0.03> C (16.5) [<25] <0.04> Northbound Left Turn C (19.4) [<25] <0.03> B (14.5) [<25] <0.06> 22: Palmetto Bay Rd & Point Comfort Rd/Arrow Rd (signal) Overall Intersection B (17.1) C (26.9) Eastbound Approach D (46.0) [171] <0.71> C (24.5) [102] <0.35> Westbound Approach C (23.8) [73] <0.44> E (55.3) [#376] <0.94> Northbound Approach A (9.7) [136] <0.37> C (21.7) [443] <0.86> Southbound Approach B (15.2) [670] <0.73> C (24.3) [434] <0.88> 23: Palmetto Bay Rd & Genesta St (un-signalized) Westbound Approach E (46.3) [<25] <0.13> F (159.5) [30] <0.37> Southbound Left Turn B (10.0) [<25] <0.02> C (16.8) [<25] <0.02> 24: Palmetto Bay Rd & Palmetto Business Park Rd (un-signalized) Westbound Approach E (47.3) [<25] <0.13> F (114.3) [33] <0.37> Southbound Left Turn B (10.1) [<25] <0.04> C (16.7) [<25] <0.02> 25: Palmetto Bay Rd & Bow Cir (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn D (27.7) [<25] <0.04> F (54.8) [<25] <0.14> Westbound Right Turn B (11.6) [<25] <0.01> C (19.0) [<25] <0.04> Southbound Left Turn B (10.3) [<25] <0.07> C (16.7) [<25] <0.04> 26: Palmetto Bay Rd & Archer Rd (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn D (29.0) [<25] <0.07> F (54.8) [<25] <0.14> Westbound Right Turn B (11.7) [<25] <0.01> C (19.0) [<25] <0.04> Southbound Left Turn B (10.5) [<25] <0.08> C (16.7) [<25] <0.04> 27: Palmetto Bay Rd & Target Rd (signal) Overall Intersection B (10.8) B (18.7) Eastbound Approach C (33.2) [81] <0.31> D (51.4) [241] <0.82> Westbound Approach D (48.8) [152] <0.69> C (30.4) [115] <0.50> Northbound Approach B (10.9) [240] <0.37> B (19.0) [585] <0.72> Southbound Approach A (4.6) [149] <0.69> A (7.3) [233] <0.66> 28: Palmetto Bay Rd & Dunnagans Alley (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn D (33.5) [<25] <0.09> F (55.4) [<25] <0.33> Westbound Right Turn B (12.0) [<25] <0.02> C (20.0) [<25] <0.24> Southbound Left Turn B (11.5) [<25] <0.21> B (14.6) [<25] <0.03> Page 198 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 21 29: Palmetto Bay Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (Sea Pines Circle, RAB) Overall Intersection F (56.0) F (60.3) Eastbound Approach F (83.3) [375] <1.04> F (117.9) [550] 0.98> Westbound Approach D (26.1) [200] <0.79> F (92.4) [425] <1.08> Northbound Approach C (16.4) [125] <0.65> F (78.2) [525] <0.98> Southbound Approach F (134.4) [900] <1.23> F (94.3) [675] <1.13> # – 95th Percentile volume exceeds capacity $ – Delay more than 300 seconds m – Upstream metering is in effect VISSIM Analysis The travel time calculations and traffic volumes between the 2023 existing conditions and 2045 no build conditions were evaluated. As shown in Table 7 and Table 8, several corridors and locations have negative percent differences and the 2045 no build simulated volumes are less than the 2023 simulated volumes. This is due to over-saturation of the study area and results in vehicles not being able to enter the netwo rk to process through each intersection. During the AM peak hour, the eastbound travel time is expected to increase by approximately 36% along Hilton Pkwy between Moss Creek and Indigo Run and by approximately 46% along Hilton Pkwy at Moss Creek to Cross Island Pkwy at Sea Pines Circle. During the PM peak hour, the westbound travel time is expected to increase by approximately 23% along Hilton Pkwy between Moss Creek and Indigo Run and by approximately 62% along Hilton Pkwy at Moss Creek to Cross Island Pkwy at Sea Pines Circle. Therefore, it is evident that the study area is expected to experience significant congestion through the year 2045. TABLE 7. 2045 NO BUILD VISSIM CALIBRATION TRAVEL TIME RESULTS Corridor Existing Simulated travel time (secs) 2045 No Build Simulated travel time (secs) % Difference AM PM AM PM AM PM William Hilton Pkwy between Moss Creek and Indigo Run EB 1157 619 1579 642 36.47% 3.72% WB 572 1252 584 1544 2.10% 23.32% William Hilton Pkwy @Moss Creek to Cross Island Pkwy @Sea Pine SB 1356 857 1984 873 46.31% 1.87% NB 826 1520 823 2465 -0.36% 62.17% Page 199 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 22 TABLE 8. 2045 NO BUILD VISSIM CALIBRATION TRAFFIC VOLUMES RESULTS Location Existing Simulated volume results (vehicles) 2045 No Build Simulated volume results (vehicles) % Difference AM PM AM PM AM PM William Hilton Pkwy west of Squire Pope EB 2970 2240 2783 2524 -6.30% 12.68% William Hilton Pkwy west of Squire Pope WB 1650 2898 1843 2754 11.70% -4.97% William Hilton Pkwy east of Spanish Wells EB 2929 1955 2748 2198 -6.18% 12.43% William Hilton Pkwy east of Spanish Wells WB 1423 2614 1570 2413 10.33% -7.69% Cross Island Pkwy north of Marshland Rd NB 964 1371 1065 919 10.48% -32.97% Cross Island Pkwy north of Marshland Rd SB 1486 1167 1440 1299 -3.10% 11.31% The 2045 no build operating conditions at the study intersections were evaluated using VISSIM and are summarized in Table 9. As shown, the operating conditions largely agree with those shown in the 2045 no build Synchro operating conditions (Table 6) and validate the travel time and volume conclusions above. Significant congestion is expected throughout the study area through the year 2045. The congestion that currently exists throughout the study area is expected to be exacerbated by 2045 with the forecasted growth. TABLE 9. 2045 NO BUILD OPERATING CONDITIONS (VISSIM) Intersection & Movements LOS (Delay, sec) [95th Queue Length, ft] {Max Queue, ft} AM Peak Hour PM Peak Hour 1: Buckingham Plantation Dr & Bluffton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (22.3) B (15.9) Eastbound Approach C (26.6) [123] {700} B (18.5) [43] {241} Westbound Approach B (14.0) [<25] {168} B (14.4) [32] {218} Northbound Approach B (14.1) [<25] {68} B (14.5) [<25] {53} Southbound Approach A (6.6) [<25] {56} A (8.5) [<25] {83} Page 200 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 23 2: Buckingham Plantation Dr/Moss Creek Dr & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection E (74.1) B (18.6) Eastbound Approach F (146.0) [1628] {1658} B (16.6) [86] {567} Westbound Approach B (14.1) [37] {302} B (18.4) [86] {474} Northbound Approach C (26.4) [25] {186} D (39.3) [<25] {91} Southbound Approach D (35.8) [<25] {88} C (24.4) [<25] {119} 3: Salt Marsh Dr/Moss Creek Village & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn F (54.8) [1075] {1304} C (18.8) [<25] {55} Westbound Left Turn F (4,646.8) [142] {214} B (12.4) [<25] {45} Northbound Approach B (12.3) [<25] {63} A (7.4) [<25] {62} Southbound Approach D (29.4) [49] {107} A (8.1) [<25] {77} 4: Fording Island Rd Ext & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn F (3,675.2) [85] {146} C (19.0) [<25] {34} Northbound Approach F (3,448.2) [171] {189} C (18.4) [<25] {43} 5: Boat Landing Driveway/Wildlife Refuge Driveway & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn C (20.9) [902] {1658} D (26.6) [<25] {<25} Westbound Left Turn No volumes observed C (21.4) [<25] {<25} Northbound Approach F (426.9) [<25] {38} C (20.6) [<25] {47} Southbound Approach No volumes observed C (17.5) [<25] {42} 6: Blue Heron Point Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Westbound Left Turn No volumes observed F (131.6) [<25] {<25} Northbound Approach F (2,505.2) [214] {351} E (49.9) [<25] {74} 7: Crosstree Dr (Windmill Harbour) & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection A (9.5) B (13.4) Eastbound Approach B (11.3) [433] {1093} B (10.6) [216] {1092} Westbound Approach A (5.3) [26] {601} A (6.0) [86] {913} Northbound Approach D (41.6) [<25] {138} F (237.4) [193] {326} Southbound Approach A (9.8) [<25] {<25} A (0.0) [<25] {<25} 8: Jenkins Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn B (14.4) [<25] {<25} D (32.0) [<25] {33} Southbound Approach D (29.2) [<25] {47} E (43.5) [<25] {62} Page 201 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 24 9: Chamberlin Dr/Squire Pope Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (26.8) E (70.7) Eastbound Approach D (38.4) [361] {1332} B (13.9) [235] {1106} Westbound Approach A (8.4) [55] {700} F (128.0) [1018] {1383} Northbound Approach C (21.2) [<25] {42} E (67.4) [<25] {73} Southbound Approach B (19.2) [<25] {189} F (80.3) [228] {693} 10: Old Wild Horse Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Southbound Approach A (1.4) [<25] {26} A (8.0) [<25] {29} 11: Spanish Wells Rd/Wild Horse Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (30.3) F (328.8) Eastbound Approach C (25.2) [169] {787} B (15.1) [98] {668} Westbound Approach B (15.5) [80] {365} F (637.7) [896] {989} Northbound Approach E (63.1) [122] {407} F (510.5) [1241] {1288} Southbound Approach F (147.4) [192] {319} D (49.1) [51] {243} 12: Gumtree Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection D (51.9) E (76.0) Eastbound Approach D (43.1) [838] {1562} D (50.4) [254] {711} Westbound Approach C (31.2) [128] {375} E (76.3) [1203] {1623} Northbound Approach D (38.8) [166] {334} F (92.7) [280] {356} Southbound Approach F (143.1) [1039] {1452} F (121.3) [657] {1380} 13: Jarvis Park Rd/Wilborn Rd & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (22.3) C (33.4) Eastbound Approach B (17.7) [169] {962} B (12.6) [51] {552} Westbound Approach C (21.5) [106] {673} D (42.5) [907] {1289} Northbound Approach E (67.4) [42] {178} F (281.4) [153] {297} Southbound Approach D (36.9) [65] {225} C (25.8) [32] {153} 14: Pembroke Dr/Museum St & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (22.1) E (55.1) Eastbound Approach B (17.8) [227] {1081} B (18.9) [99] {679} Westbound Approach B (19.5) [72] {553} D (54.5) [998] {1279} Northbound Approach D (52.8) [71] {260} F (260.2) [397] {719} Southbound Approach C (31.1) [<25] {87} D (43.2) [<25] {114} Page 202 of 300 May 3, 2024 Page 25 15: Central Ave & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Eastbound Left Turn B (13.4) [<25] {<25} C (21.6) [87] {146} Westbound Left Turn C (22.4) [<25] {25} C (21.8) [<25] {<25} Northbound Right Turn C (16.2) [<25] {29} B (12.6) [<25] {31} Southbound Right Turn B (12.3) [<25] {44} F (2,448.4) [87] {171} 16: Hatton Pl/Merchant St & William Hilton Pkwy (un-signalized) Northbound Right Turn A (8.1) [<25] {<25} A (6.9) [<25] {64} Southbound Right Turn B (11.0) [<25] {36} F (1,211.0) [123] {244} 17: Indigo Run Dr/Whooping Crane Way & William Hilton Pkwy (signal) Overall Intersection C (24.5) E (66.7) Eastbound Approach B (19.7) [107] {764} C (34.5) [115] {636} Westbound Approach B (17.3) [53] {371} E (75.8) [1341] {1658} Northbound Approach E (55.2) [32] {110} E (76.4) [65] {265} Southbound Approach D (47.7) [57] {203} F (126.4) [327] {1023} 18: Cross Island Pkwy SB Ramp/Gumtree Rd & Honey Horn Rd (un -signalized) Eastbound Approach A (9.7) [<25] {45} B (12.1) [<25] {72} 1

Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.

Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.