William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee — Minutes
Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee · meeting of Jun 12, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory
Committee
Meeting Minutes
6/12/2024 Page | 1
Town of Hilton Head Island
WILLIAM HILTON PARKWAY GATEWAY
CORRIDOR INDEPENDENT REVIEW
ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEETING
Wednesday, June 12, 2024, 1:00 PM
Minutes
1. Call to Order
Mayor Perry called the meeting to order at 1:00 PM.
2. Approval of the Minutes
a. Regular Meeting Minutes of April 22, 2024.
Mr. Advocaat raised questions pertaining to the April 22, 2024, Special Meeting Minutes
regarding the Town's venture to Columbia to discuss Lochmueller findings with SCDOT.
After some discussion and clarification, a motion was made by Mr. Advocaat to approve
the minutes of April 22, 2024, with a second by Mr. Warner. The motion passed
unanimously.
b. Regular Meeting Minutes of May 8, 2024.
Mr. Advocaat made a motion to approve the Regular Meeting Minutes of May 8, 2024.
Mr. Warner seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
3. Unfinished Business
a. Update on Project Progress
Prior to the beginning of the update, Mr. Advocaat proposed that the Committee move
'Appearance by Citizens' from item five to item three on the agenda as he felt it necessary
to hear public comment prior to presentations. Mayor Perry called for a vote in which Mr.
Advocaat made the motion to move the item, with a second by Mr. Walczak. The motion
tied with a 2-0-2 vote, and the motion did not carry. Shawn Colin, Assistant Town
Manager - Engineering and Capital Projects, opened up the floor to Nathan Nohren,
Senior Traffic Engineer for the Lochmueller consultant group, to give updates on the
project progress. Mr. Nohren also introduced Kate Swinford, Michelle Romine, and Chad
Costa who virtually attended the meeting to assist in presenting and addressing any
questions from the committee.
The project progress, along with the agenda items that follow, consider the selection of
Alternative #1 as previously presented by Lochmueller with the modification of having a
Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory
Committee
Meeting Minutes
6/12/2024 Page | 2
single eastbound left turn and a single southbound right turn onto Squire Pope Road,
developing a Visum Model optimizing the timing considering the adaptive system from
Bluffton all the way through the Gum Tree Road, as well as incorporating the
intersections remaining within the study areas from Indigo Run down to the Sea Pines
Circle which Mr. Nohren noted are merely impacts and no mitigation strategies have been
evaluated pertaining to these intersections. Mr. Nohren stated that Lochmueller is
currently 75% completed with the entirety of the project, Task 1 is pending a meeting with
Town Staff and is near 100% complete, Task 3 is considered 90% complete with the
anticipation of presenting the findings to Town Council, Task 4 is considered 50%
complete with the understanding of what the impacts will be, and Task 5 is a
comprehensive document which will memorialize Lochmueller's work which will be
executed after completion of Task 4.
Mr. Advocaat expressed concern that the projects are moving at a rapid pace, and
questioned whether Lochmueller's work would be completed ahead of the June 17th
Town Council meeting. Mr. Nohren addressed this question and explained that
Lochmueller would be engaging council for the first time beginning June 17th, and the
meaning of the future Town Council meetings is to update Council with progress being
made from Task 1 through Task 3 explaning that all subject deliverables have been
completed and will be provided.
Kate Swinford addressed the committee by going over review items reiterating
Lochmueller's method of progress as well as answering questions received regarding
levels of service criteria and generation of base traffic data. Ms. Swinford reminded the
committee that Lochmueller's analysis was completed independently of outside input and
stated there was no significant variation between prior study efforts and their study efforts
with respect to previously considered alternatives. According to Ms. Swinford,
Lochmueller has not been involved in any meetings with SCDOT nor have they ever
coordinated with SCDOT in regards to the respective project. Not only did Lochmueller
evaluate previous ideas, but also brought new ideas to the table to provide for
consideration regarding Alternatives 2, 3 and 4. Ms. Swinford went on to explain that
levels-of-service is one method used among a three-pronged approach analyzing the
effectiveness of a certain approach with the remaining two prongs being queue and
volume-to-capacity ratio. Queue length speaks to the resulting number of cars waiting to
make their turn to enter the corridor based upon the configuration, while volume-to-
capacity ratio speaks to the lane capacity.
Ms. Swinford stated that all hourly volumes used as a basis for this independent analysis
and provided scenarios were collected in March of 2023, and both hourly volumes and
daily volumes are taken into consideration with the main bulk of analysis being based
upon hourly volumes. The 30th highest traffic volume day recorded was specifically
utilized to ensure the research conducted by Lochmueller responsibly reflected peak
conditions without overestimating or underestimating traffic volumes. Using a singular
growth rate, Lochmueller developed a model depicting the future scenario at the year
2045 which they explain would be the "worst case scenario" compared to years prior.
Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory
Committee
Meeting Minutes
6/12/2024 Page | 3
4. New Business
a. Presentation of Findings for Downstream Intersection Impacts
Michelle Romine presented the Downstream Impacts by first building upon Kate
Swinford's statements stating that Lochmueller has provided some excerpts of traffic
volumes to show the hourly volumes used in the analysis. All traffic volumes were
provided as part of the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review
Advisory Committee meeting on March 27th, 2024 as well as within the corridor, an
Alternatives Analysis Memorandum which was submitted on May 3rd, 2024.
Ms. Romine explains that her focus for the presentation will be west of Section 9, which is
known as the Squire Pope area. The morning peak hour consists of approximately 2,800
vehicles traveling in the eastbound direction which includes 159 left turns, 2,620 through
vehicles, and two right turning vehicles. In the evening, just west of Section 9 at Squire
Pope, there are approximately 3,000 vehicles traveling in the westbound direction which
includes 2,687 through vehicles, 2 northbound left turns, and 341 southbound right turns.
Ms. Romine reiterated that these are the 2023 traffic volumes used in the analysis.
Lochmueller took these volumes and raised them by their determined growth rate of
0.56% which brings morning peak hour volume to approximately 3,150 vehicles traveling
eastbound and evening peak hour volume to 3,400 vehicles traveling westbound, these
volumes were then used for the 2045 scenarios with Squire Pope being an excerpt of one
intersection out of the many provided by Lochmueller.
Ms. Romine went on to present their Task 4 Scope of Findings. There were previously 4
alternatives considered between Moss Creek Drive and Gum Tree Road, and after review
of the findings and discussion with SCDOT, Lochmueller was directed by the Town of
Hilton Head Island to pursue Alternative 1 SCDOT Modified Recommended Preferred
with additional modifications to provide a single eastbound left turn lane, and a single
southbound right turn lane at U.S. 278 and Squire Pope. Lochmueller is in the process of
determining what impacts this alternative might have, as well as evaluating what, if any,
improvements need to be made. The analysis presented now includes the entire study
area including intersections near Indigo Run, traveling all the way down to the Sea Pines
Circle. The Visum Model, which is a simulation tool used to accurately replicate vehicles
and their interactions within complex traffic streams, travel time runs for the Modified
Alternative 1, as well as the SCDOT Alternative, match the numbers of the "No-Build"
scenario previously presented by Lochmueller. Ms. Romine presented the Synchro
results for the first time for the Modified Alternative 1 to serve as a comparison which
Lochmueller expected to be less pronounced than the original Visum Model, as it is noted
that Visum provides a more accurate representation. The values from these models
presented in the table included the use of an Adaptive Traffic Signal System along U.S.
278 along the Modified 1 Alternative Traffic System.
Under the 2045 "No-Build" scenario, it is expected that it would take approximately 26.3
minutes to travel eastbound along Hilton Parkway between Moss Creek and Indigo Run
Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory
Committee
Meeting Minutes
6/12/2024 Page | 4
during the AM peak hour. Using the Visum Model, it is expected that this travel time
would be reduced to 10.5 minutes under the Modified Alternative 1. Under the same 2045
"No-Build" scenario, it is expected that is would take 25.7 minutes in the evening peak
hour to travel westbound along Hilton Parkway between Moss Creek and Indigo Run. It is
now expected that the travel time would be reduced to 10.3 minutes under the Modified
Alternative 1 Scenario, and these are expected to be the final travel times, assuming no
changes along U.S. 278 east of Gum Tree or along the Cross Island Parkway. However,
as Lochmueller proceeds through mitigation strategies, the values are subject to changes
that may reflect potential improvements. Ms. Romine displayed and narrated a simulated
video presentation to help visualize the 2045 Modified Alternative 1 Scenario displaying
both AM and PM peak hours as well as specific locations where queuing issues are being
addressed.
Ms. Romine elaborated further by displaying results based upon the operating conditions
expected from this scenario provided by Visum, with the operating conditions for each
intersection being included in the Appedix of the presentation for reference. The results
presented for key intersections of note were provided as follows: The intersections
between Squire Pope and Gum Tree are expected to operate acceptably overall during
the AM and PM peak hours. Each signalized intersection is expected to have an LOS-D
or better, which is the target LOS for an intersection overall, and the inidivual approaches
are expected to operate with an LOS-E or better, which Ms. Romine notes is typically
considered acceptable during peak hours concerning some of the side street approaches.
Ms. Romine states that Lochmueller is considering any additional improvements that can
be made, including reconfiguring intersections and turn lanes to improve efficiency,
addition of lanes to improve capacity, and most certainly looking to improve the Sea
Pines roundabout, which is performing the least efficiently out of all the performance
studies conducted. Mr. Advocaat had questions regarding traffic volumes and breakdown
lanes which Ms. Romine addressed. Mr. Walczak had additional questions regarding
emergency lanes, which were also addressed by Lochmueller as well as Shawn Colin,
Assistant Town Manager. There was a lengthy discussion by the Committee regarding
the option of a Southern Bypass which Lochmueller, Shawn Colin and Mayor Perry
addressed in detail.
b. Consideration of a Resolution to Accept the Findings of the William Hilton Parkway
Gateway Corridor Independent End to End Analysis
On February 21st, 2023 Town Council authorized the creation and appointment of the
William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee.
Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager, went over the resolution which created the
Committee stating the resolution required the Committee to secure a consultant to adopt
a scope of work to recommend to Town Council. On May 12th, 2023 the Committee
recommended an agreed upon scope of work, and on June 6th, 2023 Town Council
unanimously adopted a resolution approving the scope of work and request for
qualifications. On August 28th the Committee unanimously recommended the Town
negotiate a contract with Lochmueller group, and on October 12th, 2023 the Town
Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory
Committee
Meeting Minutes
6/12/2024 Page | 5
executed the contract with Lochmueller tp preform the independent analysis. Since then,
the Town has held ten public meetings spanning from November 3rd, 2023 to June 12th,
2024 to review the consultants findings and recommendations for the William Hilton
Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent End-to-End Analysis as well as to receive public
input. As of today, the consultant has presented technical reports and deliverables as
outlined in the contract.
Shawn Colin requested consideration from the Committee to accept the findings and
recommendations of the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent End-to-
End Analysis delivered by the consultant. Secondarily, Mr. Colin asks that the Committee
authorize the Town Manager to use the findings and recommendations for future planning
purposes. Mayor Perry called for a motion, Mr. Warner made the motion to approve.
Mayor Perry passed the gavel to Mr. Warner and seconded the motion. The motion failed
with a vote of 2-2. Mr. Advocaat asked that the record reflect that he is not in favor of this
motion.
5. Appearance by Citizens:
Mayor Perry opened up the floor for public comment.
Christopher Cliff made comments regarding the letter from SCDOT as well as completion
percentages.
Jack Alderman, Chairman of the Housing Action Committee, stated that the development of
the roadways is a key component to the island's growth and economic vitality, and he was
disappointed to hear some of the same issues being discussed that were resolved early on in
the process.
Kris Ruffner commented that she is from Chicago and has experienced some of the worst
traffic delays. Further, Ms. Ruffner explained that further development will increase induced
demand and will not solve the issue, "if you build it, they will come."
Frank Babel, former member of the original Gateway Corridor Committee, made comments
regarding the need for development of the roadways and mentioned the frequency of
accidents. Mr. Babel stated the roadway does not work as it stands now, and that the traffic
has affected the businesses on the island.
Gerald Devito commented stating he believes Alternative #1 is the only viable option and
mentioned that the cross-sections would address various issues.
Tammy Becker, Member of Council, thanked Lochmueller for their review of the Southern
Bypass option. Ms. Becker then clarified that she does not remember Council ever being
further consulted regarding the Bypass which Lochmueller addressed.
Greg Whitaker stated that the simulation displayed at this afternoon's meeting was very
beneficial and requested that Lochmueller display it at the next Town Council meeting where
these alternatives will be discussed. Mr. Whitaker also suggested that Lochmueller discuss
why reversible lanes were considered but dismissed, and that they shed some light on the
Southern Bypass option.
Gray Smith noted that the amount of lanes are not the issue in his opinion, but how free
flowing the traffic is through the corridor. Mr. Smith also stated that he believes voting on the
findings is premature at this point.
Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory
Committee
Meeting Minutes
6/12/2024 Page | 6
Richard Busy explained that he believes the Southern Bypass should have received the same
evaluation efforts as the other alternatives presented by Lochmueller.
Kathleen Redman stated she believes two lanes in each direction would suffice and she does
not think we need six lanes.
Carol Vuxxer made comment stating she agrees with Ms. Redman regarding the two lane
bridge as opposed to six. Ms. Vuxxer also noted that she is against taking any Stoney property
to complete this project.
6. Adjournment
The meeting was declared adjourned at 4:00 PM.
APPROVED: August 14th, 2024.
The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website
at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.