March 6 (PDF, 82.55 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
ACCOMMODATIONS TAX ADVISORY COMMITTEE
11:00 a.m., Wednesday, March 6, 2013
The regular meeting of the Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee was held at 11:00 a.m.
on Wednesday, March 6, 2013 in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of
Palms, South Carolina. Attending the meeting were Committee members Burgis, Covington,
Kruesi, Miller, Nelson and Russell, Chair Ferencz, City Administrator Tucker, City Treasurer
Suggs, Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present
to conduct business.
1. Chair Ferencz called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Ms. Kruesi moved to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of
February 9, 2013 as written; Mr. Nelson seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Financial Statement – Treasurer Suggs
Treasurer Suggs stated that the financial statement for review was through January 31, 2013.
At that time, the ATAX fund had a cash balance exceeding one million three hundred thousand
dollars ($1,300,000), and more than one million dollars ($1,000,000) was invested with the
Local Government Investment Pool with the balance in BB&T. The only revenue received was
the small amount of interest. Expenditures are tracking normally; the final invoices for the
Holiday Street Festival/Tree Lighting have put that expenditure line over by twenty dollars
($20.00).
MOTION: Mr. Nelson moved to approve the overage of $20.15 for the Front
Beach Tree Lighting; Chair Ferencz seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
Ms. Kruesi asked Recreation Director Page what the Summer Arts event would be; the Director
indicated that the event is as yet undefined. For the FY14 budget, the event has been renamed
a cultural arts event, because summer did not seem to be the right time for this event. Last
year, the event was a comedienne, but the attendance was not sufficient to warrant continuing.
A cultural arts event can be anything and anytime during the year.
A quick review of the revenue and expense projection for FY13 has not changed since the last
meeting; according to the Treasurer, the schedule does show the early payoff the capital leases
that was actually outside the budget and creates a deficit of approximately eighty thousand
dollars ($80,000). The FY14 budget has not included lease principal or interest payments.
Treasurer Suggs reported that the City did receive the quarterly payment from the state for the
quarter ended December 31, 2013 late in February; she then distributed the schedule entitled
Distribution of Funds Received. Continuing, the Treasurer stated that the gross payment from
the state was in excess of two hundred eighty-three thousand dollars ($283,000.00), which is a
ATAX Committee
March 6, 2013
Page 2 of 9
two percent (2%) decrease from FY12, but the payment for the quarter ended December 2011
included a prior year correction of approximately eighty thousand dollars ($80,000).
Considering that fact, the December 2012 pay ment was considerably higher than December
2011. When Treasurer Suggs researched the information received from the state which is by
taxpayer, she saw that four (4) internet-based reservation companies had paid large amount of
money, approximately thirty-sev en thousand dollars ($37,000). The problem is that these
numbers do not correlate to the amounts reported by the County with Municipal
Accommodations Taxes; the County’s numbers are much smaller. The City has, therefore,
decided not to recognize this difference as revenue until such time as they can be verified; the
money could well belong to another municipality.
Administrator Tucker related that she and the Mayor had met with the Director of the
Department of Revenue and a member of his staff about the problems the City is having as it
tries to reconcile accommodations taxes from the state to those received from the County. In
addition to describing the problems, they offered some possible solutions.
Ms. Russell sought confirmation that the fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000) for a potential off-
season event was available for an event on which the ad hoc committee is working, but
Treasurer Suggs said that money has been used for the tree lighting. Administrator Tucker
explained that there is money in the FY14 budget for another Christmas-themed street festival;
if the ATAX Committee wants another event, money will have to be added to the budget.
Chair Ferencz remarked that, since City Council had not approved fifteen thousand dollars
($15,000) for Spoleto, the money will not be spent; Administrator explained that sponsorship of
an event had not been approved, but an advertisement was approved as was the cost for
camera-ready art for an advertisement – those expenditures will come from the money assigned
to the Spoleto Festival. The Chair suggested that the remaining balance in that account could
pay for an event in this year; the Administrator reminded the Committee that they have the
ability to do a project out of the fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) under Unexpended
Projects/Miscellaneous.
5. OId Business
A. Update on 2013 Spoleto Advertising
Assistant Dziuban recalled that the deadline for the advertisement is April 5, 2013; Council
approved six thousand dollars ($6,000) – three thousand dollars ($3,000) for the full page ad
and three thousand dollars ($3,000) for camera-ready art. Having waived the twenty percent
(20%) to guarantee the ad space, Spoleto has reserved the City’s page. Ms. Russell provided
Assistant Dziuban with the names of several vendors capable of doing the work; she vetted
them in terms of meeting the City’s timeline and who had IOP business licenses. A vendor with
a very good portfolio has been selected; the quote was only five hundred dollars ($500). There
may be additional expense related to the actual image; the City has three (3) options about
which photograph is used; they are:
• If the City has a photograph that is of the right resolution and suits the need, the City
can provide it at no cost;
ATAX Committee
March 6, 2013
Page 3 of 9
• They have a stock ad the City can use for ninety-five dollars ($95), but Administrator
Tucker insists that the ad must portray the Isle of Palms, not just look like the Isle of
Palms;
• If they have to send a photographer the island to take a photograph, the charge will be
one hundred fifty dollars ($150).
The City has selected a company; they have been given their instructions; and they have one
month to complete the work.
When questioned about the cost, Assistant Dziuban said that all of the proposals were in the
same price range; the vendor selected was not the low bid, but the second low bid. The
Assistant voiced her impression that the vendor was hopeful of additional work in the future
based on their success with this project.
Chair Ferencz has suggested that a photo from the Recreation Department’s contest might be
suitable.
B. Update from Ad Hoc Committee
Ms. Russell stated that the Committee had met the previous week to discuss and explore
possible events to be held on the island that would put “heads in beds” in the off-season. Their
“out of the box” ideas are
• A Shag Weekend – Myrtle Beach has a very successful event; this event would use
venues around the island – The Windjammer, Rec Center; seek support from Charleston
Shag Club; in the November to February time frame.
• Kite Boarding event – potential national exposure in September or October.
• Expansion of Tree Lighting with lighting displays throughout the island, a trolley to
transport visitors around and potentially add fireworks.
• Cycling weekend – research for future years.
Chair Ferencz noted that the light displays had been presented to City Council in the FY13
budget, but Council cut them. She suggested that, by attaching them to the street festival, they
might be positively received. Administrator Tucker voiced her opinion that Council liked the idea
of the lights, but was opposed to spending the money.
Ms. Russell reported that Mr. Covington had proposed contacting local businesses to sponsor
individual lighting displays like is done at the James Island County Park. Chair Ferencz thought
that, initially, the businesses should be those from the island before branching out; she said she
would love to see displays from one end of the island to the other.
Ms. Kruesi thought that transitioning the tree lighting/street festival into the evening would put
people in the City’s restaurants and, possibly, into beds on the island.
Chair Ferencz asked Director Page for her opinion of using the money for the cultural arts event
to expand the tree lighting/street festival into the evening rather than planning another event.
ATAX Committee
March 6, 2013
Page 4 of 9
The Director stated that the current plan for the 2013 street festival was to mimic the 2012
event; it would be tweaked, but not necessarily added to – but she was not opposed to adding
to the event. She explained that, with the Recreation staff of seven (7) individuals, it would be
difficult to hold too large an event; she added that she had volunteers and Exchange Club
members who helped out in 2012. Director Page said that she would support anything the
Committee wanted to do to enhance the Recreation Department’s program and work with them
for the success of the event.
Administrator Tucker cautioned that the City has to be mindful of the allocation of resources; a
multi-day event would draw from every department, but then still be operational the next day.
Ms. Kruesi asked what the City would like to achieve with an expanded street festival; the
Administrator responded that she would like to im prove the revenues for the off-season in terms
of “heads in beds” and people spending money in island businesses.
With that in mind, Ms. Kruesi thought that the street festival would have to move into the
evening, and she would recommend the light displays or fireworks to encourage dinner and
advertise that rates are lower in the winter. Ms. Russell suggested using ATAX money to adver-
tise to get people here and to stay overnight to enjoy the festival, have dinner and be a part of
an evening activity. Ms. Russell added that the camera-ready art being developed would be
generic to be used for advertising at other times.
A market that the Administrator believes to be untapped is young families whose children are
not yet in school that could enjoy the island in September and spring; Ms. Miller added that the
home-schooling families likely another untapped market.
If the Committee were to proceed with the concept of a shag weekend, Mr. Covington indicated
that he would contact the Charleston Shag Club to find out if they would sponsor with the help of
the ATAX Committee; he said they would do the work and the ATAX Committee would assist
with funding. Ms. Russell questioned that it would be appropriate to contact an island business,
possible Newton Farms, about sponsoring the event; the Administrator said that she did not see
any problem with doing that. Director Page suggested that the shag weekend coincide with the
street festival, and the bands would be part of the entertainment at the festival. Ms. Russell said
the ad hoc committee would be working with the Recreation Department on coordinating the two
(2) events.
6. New Business
A. FY14 Operating, Capital, Long-range Plan and Estimated Reserve
Requirements
Administrator Tucker stated that she thought the ideas presented were really good, and she
thanked Ms. Russell for her assistance in finding a vendor for the camera-ready art.
State Accommodation Tax Fund Revenues
ATAX Committee
March 6, 2013
Page 5 of 9
State ATAX Revenue $ 945,000
Increased over FY13 based on historical trend
State ATAX Promo 436,000
Paid to CVB by state statute
Interest Income 2,441
Annualized YTD actual
State ATAX Transfers Out
To island-wide Beach Maintenance Fund (50,000)
Add to reserve for long-term beach management
To island-wide Beach Maintenance Fund (49,646)
Ongoing monitoring entire coastline
To General Fund for PT Firefighters (10,000)
Approx. 30 hrs/weekend for 26 we ekends, April through September
To marina debt service (178,157)
⅓ of total marina debt service
State ATAX Expenditures - Highlights
General Government
Advertising 8,000
Reorder new, larger maps; camera-ready art for ads (if not completed in FY13)
Ms. Kruesi questioned this expenditure since so many have mapping capabilities with their cell
phones. Administrator Tucker stated that the City gets a lot of requests for maps for visitors to
get the feel of where they are in relation to other locations on the island; Director Page indicated
that they many requests for City maps at the Re creation Center as well. Only the City maps
show the locations of beach accesses and handicapped accesses.
Professional Services 40,500
Wayfinding signs & parking management plan Phases III and IV
Capital outlay 35,000
Replace 2 message boards, possibly with computerized models
The message boards generated a good bit of discussion, including the fact that Council did not
approve them last year, the amount of time that Recreation staff spends changing the existing
boards and that new signs would be in the motif of the wayfinding signs.
MOTION: Mr. Covington moved to remove the electronic message boards from
the ATAX budget and moved to an alternate budget within the City; Ms. Russell
seconded and the motion PASSED with dissenting votes from Mr. Burgis, Ms.
Miller and Mr. Nelson.
Mr. Covington asked if it would be feasible to change the image on the t-shirts annually and to
hold a contest for elementary school children to submit drawings from which a winner would be
selected to adorn the t-shirts for that year. The Administrator said that is feasible, but she ques-
tioned that the City had staff to accomplish it. This type of contest is best when handled by a
ATAX Committee
March 6, 2013
Page 6 of 9
group of people who take the initiative to get it through the selection process; the City staff
would then supervise the printing.
Administrator Tucker explained that the t-shirt give-away came into existence with the initiation
of the City’s website; visitors go to the website and bring the free t-shirt page to City Hall where
they exchange their name, address and email address for a free t-shirt. The t-shirt is not a
promotion geared to locals, but to out-of-town visitors to wear when they get home and to use
the website address printed on the shirts. Assistant Dziuban reiterated the fact the City
captures its visitors’ email addresses.
Police Department
Non-capital tools 9,500
Scheduled annual replacement of body armor; 19 body-worn digital cameras
These cameras will be worn on the body and capture everything the police officer is doing when
out of his/her vehicle. The cameras will be useful to capture acts of offenders, as well as officer
safety; they will also be useful when the City receives any type of complaint since the camera
will capture both audio and video.
Mr. Covington questioned police officers taking cameras into private homes; Administrator
Tucker explained that an officer only enters a residence when invited by the inhabitant or when
there are exigent circumstances in plain view from the door.
Professional Services 100,000
⅓ provision for implementation of beach access parking solutions
Fire Department – all leases paid off in FY13
Capital Outlay 66,000
Mobile repeater (re-budget), Yamaha jet ski, beach patrol ATV, replace Ford F150
Public Works – all leases paid off in FY13
Miscellaneous & contingency 11,600
Pooper-scoopers, pooper-scooper stations, beach trash barrels
Capital outlay 158,000
Re-budget dune walkover at Front Beach restrooms; 25% of garbage packer
The funds for the garbage packer are one (1) piece of the City’s initiative to purchase capital
assets and to avoid indebtedness.
Chair Ferencz questioned that the dune walkover at Front Beach had been budgeted in FY13
for eighty-five thousand dollars ($85,000) and was now ten thousand dollars ($10,000) higher.
Administrator Tucker explained that the dune walkover budget had been revised based on the
bids received for the dune walkover currently being replaced; prices have spiked because
resources are being sent to the area hurt by Hurricane Sandy.
ATAX Committee
March 6, 2013
Page 7 of 9
Recreation Department
Special Activities 48,000
Beach Run, Connector Run, Street Festival , music event, Easter Egg Hunt, sand sculpting,
cultural arts event
Public Restrooms/Front Beach Area
Cleaning and Sanitary Supplies 5,800
Increased based on actual
Insurance 2,800
Property, liability and flood with a 5% rate increase
Mr. Covington asked to go on record as being opposed to the body-worn digital cameras for
police officers.
MOTION: Ms. Kruesi moved to add the cost of a minimum of 4 Christmas light
displays in General Government under Capital Outlay ; Mr. Burgis seconded and
the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
The budget as presented shows a deficit of one hundred fourteen thousand dollars ($114,000)
to funded from cumulative surpluses from prior y ears; typically the year ends differently than
predicted in the budget – with a need to draw from the fund balance less than anticipated or with
a surplus.
Chair Ferencz reminded the Committee that the deficit would be thirty-five thousand dollars
($35,000) less than shown since they had removed the message boards from the ATAX budget.
At this juncture, Administrator Tucker directed attention to the schedule headed Estimated
Reserve Requirements. The Administrator explained that this schedule takes the expenses from
the capital plan for the Fire and Public Works Departments and defines the amount to be saved
each year in order to replace capital assets in the year they are scheduled to be replaced. If an
asset is scheduled to be replaced, but still has useful life, the purchase can be delayed because
the money is on–hand when needed.
Option 1 is a pure method of spreading the replacement cost of each vehicle over the years
remaining until the scheduled purchase; this method creates huge peaks and valleys in cash
on-hand. Option 2 is the result of manipulating the amounts to have a more level savings
amount each year while still having the amount nec essary to purchase the vehicle when its due;
for budgeting purposes, Option 2 is preferable and reflected in budgets.
Not reflected in this schedule is the potential for huge increases in the cost of equipment [the
Treasurer has used an inflation rate of two percent (2%)]; also not included is the sale of surplus
property; and it does not take into account the interest earned on the savings account.
On the subject of beach restoration and monitoring, Ms. Russell voiced concern about the
erosion of Breach Inlet; Administrator Tucker assured her that the City monitors the entire seven
(7) mile shoreline. The consultants are confident that Breach Inlet will heal itself as it has
ATAX Committee
March 6, 2013
Page 8 of 9
historically, but they do not know how long that healing will take. The next regular monitoring
will be in July 2013, and, from that, the engineers will learn if something out of the ordinary is
happening.
The final page of the capital budgets represents the City’s bonded indebtedness; Administrator
Tucker informed the Committee that staff has initiated dialogue with bond counsel regarding the
potential of refinancing some of the City’s bonds since interest rates are so favorable right now.
The City would see significant savings if the refinancing is accomplished; the City may have to
pay down some of the bonds in order to refinance which would affect fund balances.
MOTION: Mr. Nelson moved to approve the FY14 ATAX budget with the removal
of the message boards and the addition of holiday light displays; Ms. Russell
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
B. Review of 2013 CVB Marketing
Perrin Lawson of the CVB distributed copies of the FY 2012-2013 Marketing Programs to
members of the ATAX Committee; Mr. Lawson reviewed the CVB’s initiatives that will relate to
the Isle of Palms. He stated that everything the CVB is doing now is multi-platform advertising
with companies like Meredith Publications. The target audience is college-educated individuals
and families with a household income of eighty thousand dollars ($80,000) or more; he stated
that the real area of opportunity is the major metropolitan areas east of the Mississippi and
particularly the northeast corridor where non-stop air service can be established. A full page ad
in Southern Living in January specifically about booking your Charleston area beach vacation
early; in coordination, a special landing page was created on Charlestonareabeaches.com
website with a lot of different packages. This website is constantly being tweaked with new
editorial and content, which is true of all other websites of the CVB. The CVB continues to work
closely with Trip Adviser, the largest travel site in the world; the CVB is sponsoring pages for the
area and local municipalities – a page exists specifically for the Isle of Palms.
Meredith Publications has purchased Family Fun magazine from Disney and are in the process
of acquiring Time, Inc., which will be People magazine, Southern Living, Parents magazine and
many others; this is good for the CVB which has developed a strong relationship with Meredith
via the Family Circle Cup. The CVB has a six (6) month promotion running in Family Fun, and
Charleston was on the cover in February.
Mr. Lawson reported that Jet Blue, with its non-stop service to JFK, an international hub which
did not previously have any flights to or from Charleston, Charleston now becomes a destination
for international guests. Jet Blue has added a flight from Boston on Saturdays only based on
the response to pre-sales.
The CVB has generated a great deal of marketing initiatives relative to having won the
CondeNast Traveler Award for the second year in a row primarily due to the warmth and
friendliness of the residents; the next step is to maintain the level of travel satisfaction to
continue to win. Presently Charleston is in the running to host the Travel Specialists Summit,
which is a group of approximately one hundred fifty (150) of the world’s best travel experts
coming together in the fall of 2013.
ATAX Committee
March 6, 2013
Page 9 of 9
Mr. Covington asked why the CVB was not involved with television advertising in the Northeast;
Mr. Lawson responded that it will happen in the future. Presently, the CVB is doing half of a
million dollars ($500,000) in advertising with Jet Blue as a cooperative effort; they are doing a lot
of print with The Boston Globe and The New York Post – the CVB is funding the effort and Jet
Blue is directing how it is used.
C. Status of Live Oak Park
Chair Ferencz stated that this issue was on the agenda to learn whether there were any funding
implications for the ATAX fund.
Administrator Tucker stated that the property was purchased by the City using Greenbelt funds;
the grant agreement requires a public process to ensure that the public was aware that the
property is public and to get input on utilization, which is very restrictive due to the type of funds
that were used to acquire it. At the public hearing, input was that the City might want to
consider a name change and suggestions to limb it up and to leave it as it is. Signage is
required indicating that the property is public and that it was purchased with Greenbelt funds.
The Administrator explained that a name for the park had to be included in the grant application,
and, since there are many live oaks on the property, staff thought it was an appropriate name.
Assistant Dziuban added that, according to the grant agreement, the City has three (3) options
for the park; they are
• Put up a sign and do nothing else;
• Put up a sign and limb it up; and
• Put up a sign and make it a passive park, which is defined in the agreement as a few
unpaved trails, picnic tables, etc.
There were only a few residents at the Public Hearing, and no one spoke on the passive park
option. No decision or direction was made.
7. Miscellaneous Business
Date of Next Meeting: 11:00 a.m., Wednesday, May 1, 2013
8. Adjourn
MOTION: Mr. Burgis moved to adjourn the meeting at 12:57 p.m.; Mr. Nelson
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.