March 20 (PDF, 14.19 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MINUTES OF THE ISLE OF PALMS
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
March 20, 2013
The Isle of Palms Planning Commission met in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207
Palm Boulevard on March 20, 2013 at 4:30 p.m. Members attending included Bev
Ballow, Richard Ferencz, Ron Denton, Patrick Harrington, Penny Lewis, Noel Scott and
Don Smith; the Director of Planning Douglas Kerr was present as well. The press had
been notified of the meeting and the agenda for the meeting was posted in City Hall and
the Building Department to comply with the Freedom of Information Act.
Chairman Noel Scott called the meeting to order.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Mr. Scott explained that the first item on the agenda was the approval of the February
13, 2013 minutes. Mr. Denton made a motion to approve the minutes as submitted and
Mr. Ferencz seconded the motion. The motion was unanimously approved.
DISCUSSION OF TREE ORDINANCE
Mr. Kerr explained that a redlined draft of amendments had been distributed in the
packets and experts from Clemson were available to discuss the changes being
considered. He explained that the changes in the amendment included: exempting
palm trees that are transplanted or replaced from permitting, exempting invasive pest
species of trees from permitting, and allowing the removal of trees that are causing
structural damage to the enclosed, habitable area of a building when the damage
cannot be remedied without removing the tree.
Mr. Scott asked the representatives from Clemson, Harry Crissy and Mark Arena, to join
the group and answer questions. Mr. Kerr asked if they believed it was proper to
exempt invasive species and if the “Invasive Plant Pest Species of South Carolina,”
published by Clemson, was the proper reference. Mr. Arena answered yes to both
questions. He stated that it was his belief that not all invasive species were harmful, but
that the “pest” species were all harmful and the City should not require an owner to
keep them.
Ms. Ballow explained that the City’s code gave no protection to pine trees and asked for
their opinion on this exemption. Mr. Arena answered that he believed that large pine
trees do offer ecological benefits and they should be given some level of protection.
The group generally discussed the fact that there are relatively few pine trees over 24
inches in diameter left on the island. It was discussed that after Hugo many pine trees
snapped and caused damage, but that there was extensive damage from all other
species as well.
Planning Commission Minutes
March 20, 2013
Page 2
Mr. Kerr asked Mr. Arena what suggestions he would make regarding trees causing
structural damage to people’s homes. Mr. Arena stated that he believed that
communities should allow owners to remove trees that are causing hardships to
owners, but that there is always a challenge of determining what level of hardship
should qualify for the removal of a tree. He explained that in situations where an owner
is required to annually prune roots from a tree that is causing damage, the tree will
ultimately die and in the end the result is the same as if the tree was allowed to be
removed initially.
The group thanked Mr. Arena and Mr. Crissy for joining and agreed to go through the
draft amendment. The first point of discussion was the amendment to exempt palm
trees that are transplanted or otherwise replaced from permitting. The group agreed
that they supported this amendment. Mr. Ferencz explained that he felt that the
ordinance should clarify that the City recognizes the fact that a palm tree is not
technically a tree, but that the ordinance still regulates their removal. He explained that
this fact is acknowledged in discussions, but that the code is silent on the issue and it
would be clearer if the code acknowledged the distinction. The group agreed that this
clarification should be made.
The next point of discussion was the exemption of invasive pest species of trees from
permitting. The group agreed that they supported this amendment and that they
supported the code referencing the list published by Clemson as the guiding document.
The next point of discussion was granting permission for trees causing damage to
property. Mr. Kerr explained that the draft included several triggers for permitting that
he would like to discuss individually. He explained that as the ordinance is drafted there
would have to be some level of physical damage to a structure and not just the
“potential” for damage for a permit to be issued. He made an example of a large oak
tree being only 24 inches from the foundation of a house, but no perceivable damage
occurring and asked if the group supported the notion of requiring the owner to keep
this tree until some perceivable damage occurred. The group discussed the difficulty of
accurately predicting when a tree could cause damage and the opportunity for abuse if
the trigger is based on a prediction. The group agreed that the trigger for removal
should be some level of damage and not the potential for damage.
The next point of discussion was which structures would have to sustain damage before
a tree removal permit could be issued. He explained that as currently drafted, the
amendment would only cover the enclosed, habitable area of buildings. Under this
language, damage to a porch, deck, parking slab, shed or pool would not qualify for tree
removal.
Planning Commission Minutes
March 20, 2013
Page 3
Mr. Smith explained that he felt that language should be broadened to include any
enclosed space of the principle building, including porches. The group agreed.
Mr. Harrington explained that he had believed that pools and possibly other accessory
structures should also be included. Ms. Ballow explained that she felt that items like
pools were luxury items and that burden should be on an owner to manage the conflict
between a pool and a tree without the removal of the tree. The group generally
discussed whether it would be appropriate to allow the removal of trees damaging
pools, but not allow the removal of trees damaging other accessory structures.
After a lengthy discussion, Mr. Kerr proposed keeping the amendment as drafted and
resuming the discussion of accessory structures at the next meeting to give time for
consideration. The group agreed.
Mr. Ferencz explained that he would like to revisit the issue of pine trees being
exempted regardless of size and asked that the group consider the recommendation of
Mr. Arena of protecting large pine trees. Mr. Denton explained that he doubted that the
island had too many pine trees as large as 24 inches in diameter, which is the size Mr.
Arena referenced. Ms. Ballow explained that she supported the idea of protecting larger
pine trees, as they provide habitat and enhance the ecology of the island. The group
generally agreed that wanted to extend protection to include pine trees over 24 inches
in diameter.
Mr. Kerr explained that he would have the amendment put into ordinance form and have
it on the next agenda for consideration.
REVIEW OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN
Mr. Kerr explained that the first section of the Comprehensive Plan to be reviewed was
the population element and he distributed a draft of changes to the section that included
changes based on the 2010 Census. He explained that the 2010 Census data did not
show any alarming changes, but that there were some notable trends that the plan
should note. He explained that the year round population is shown to have fallen a bit
from 2000 to 2010 even though the number of housing units had increased. He also
explained that the numbers appeared to show a large increase in the number of long
term rentals, but the difference was so large it appeared to be due more to a change in
the method of collecting or reporting data than a real change.
Mr. Denton stated that he found it interesting that for the first time, the City has more
dwelling units than people.
Planning Commission Minutes
March 20, 2013
Page 4
Mr. Smith stated that he felt that the Vision Statement was overly optimistic and was
silent on the fact that the City faces challenges such as erosion and seasonal
congestion.
Ms. Lewis stated that she had reviewed documents from other coastal communities and
noticed that several of them, including Nag’s Head, North Carolina, included a mission
statement as well as a vision statement and that the mission statement might include
some of the challenges the communities face. The group generally liked the idea of
adding a mission statement to the plan.
Mr. Scott stated that the history made note of fairly insignificant issues including the fact
that the Sea Pines Company initiated the process of developing Wild Dunes. He
explained that the group was only involved for a few months and it is probably not
noteworthy. The group agreed.
Mr. Kerr explained that he would work on confirming the data from the 2010 Census
and clean up these sections for review at the next meeting and suggested that the
group also look at the economic section at the next meeting. The group agreed.
ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 6:45 p.m.
Respectfully submitted, Noel Scott, Chairman.
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.