May 8 (PDF, 11.79 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MINUTES OF THE ISLE OF PALMS
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
May 8, 2013
The Isle of Palms Planning Commission met in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207
Palm Boulevard on May 8, 2013 at 4:30 p.m. Members attending included Bev Ballow,
Ron Denton, Richard Ferencz, Patrick Harrington, Penny Lewis, Noel Scott and Don
Smith. The Director of Planning Douglas Kerr was present as well. The press had
been notified of the meeting and the agenda for the meeting was posted in City Hall and
the Building Department to comply with the Freedom of Information Act.
Chairman Noel Scott called the meeting to order.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Mr. Scott explained that the first item on the agenda was the approval of the April 10,
2013 minutes. Ms. Ballow explained that the minutes state that she supported a change
to protect pine trees larger than 16 inches and she does not believe that she stipulated
a dimension. Penny Lewis made a motion to approve the minutes with the amendment
and Mr. Ferencz seconded the motion. The vote was unanimous in favor of the motion.
DISCUSSION OF TREE ORDINANCE
Mr. Scott explained that at the last meeting the group held off on deliberating three
issues, because three members were not present and he did not feel comfortable
changing things that had been previously agreed to by the entire group. The three
items were: should the protection of pine trees be applied to trees smaller than 24
inches in diameter, should a tree damaging accessory structures, including pools, be
allowed to be removed and should trees that have the potential to damage a structures
be allowed to be removed.
Mr. Scott asked for discussion of the first question, should the group recommend
protecting pine trees smaller than 24 inches. Ms. Ballow stated that she had spent the
last few months investigating pine trees on the island and she had measured many of
the large pine trees on the island and she did not find one that was larger than 16
inches in diameter. Additionally, she had spent time researching pine trees and she
feels that they provide a valuable benefit to the City in terms of providing a natural
habitat to various species. Based on her research she proposed protecting pine trees
12 inches and larger.
Mr. Harrington explained that he was comfortable recommending that 24 inch pine trees
be protected based on the input of the Clemson arborist who met with the Commission,
but he was unsure about going smaller than what the arborist suggested. He asked if
the group could consult with the arborist again on this issue.
Planning Commission minutes
May 8, 2013
Page 2
Mr. Scott explained that he felt that this issue had been lingering with the Planning
Commission for several months and he would prefer to come to some conclusions at
this meeting.
Mr. Smith explained that he also had concerns about making a recommendation to
protect smaller pine trees, but that it may be useful to consult an arborist on the issue.
Mr. Harrington suggested that the group delay a decision on this issue for one more
month to give the group the opportunity to consult with an arborist at the next meeting.
After some discussion, the group agreed to delay one month on this issue.
The next issue for discussion was whether or not to allow the removal of trees that are
damaging accessory structures. Mr. Kerr explained that as the amendment is currently
written, a tree causing damage to a pool or any other accessory structures could not be
removed. Mr. Kerr explained that from previous discussions, he felt that the primary
issue of concern was damage to pools. He explained that a compromise on the issue
may be to amend the language to specify the amendment does not apply to damage to
accessory structures other than pools, but allow trees damaging pools to be removed.
After general discussion, the group agreed to amend the recommendation to allow a
tree damaging a pool to be removed, but not trees damaging other accessory
structures.
The final issue for discussion on the tree amendment was the trigger for when a tree
could be removed. Mr. Kerr explained that as the amendment was currently drafted a
house would have to sustain damage before a tree removal permit could be issued. He
explained that the reason for this language was that if the trigger was “potential
damage” that this created potential for abuse as it is prediction and less clear.
Mr. Denton stated that he felt that in situations where future damage to a home was
clear and eminent, he supported an owner being able to remove the tree. Mr. Kerr
explained that he was surprised to hear the arborist from Clemson explain that he was
trained to make determinations of when a tree will cause damage. Ms. Ballow made a
motion to amend the recommendation to allow trees to be removed when the tree is
causing structural damage or in situations when a certified arborist determines that
damage is eminent and the damage cannot be remedied without removing the tree.
The motion to amend the recommendation was seconded and unanimously approved.
REVIEW OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN- NATURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT
Mr. Scott explained that the next item on the agenda was the review of the Natural
Resources element of the Comprehensive Plan. Mr. Kerr explained that he had
distributed his proposed amendments to the section. He explained that he added a
Planning Commission minutes
May 8, 2013
Page 3
statement to the initial characteristics section that summarized the issue of erosion and
he added a strategy that stated that efforts to minimize the impact of erosion should be
supported.
Mr. Scott explained that he believed it would be worthwhile to mention the City’s by the
Blue Wave certification as a clean beach. The group generally agreed that this would
be a good addition.
The group discussed the wording of the statement regarding erosion on the island and
agreed to reword the statement to read: “the beaches on the Isle of Palms are generally
accreting, but the shoreline has cyclical erosional episodes.”
Ms. Ballow explained that the statement that loggerhead sea turtle visits have declined
over the years should be deleted and the sentence stating that turtles return to the
same site every two years should be deleted. The group asked Ms. Ballow to edit the
paragraph regarding loggerheads for the next meeting, which she agreed to do.
The group agreed to review Cultural Resources element at the next meeting.
ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 6:00 p.m.
Respectfully submitted, Noel Scott, Chairman.
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.