June 12 (PDF, 15.02 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MINUTES OF THE ISLE OF PALMS
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
June 12, 2013
The Isle of Palms Planning Commission met in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207
Palm Boulevard on June 12, 2013 at 4:30 p.m. Members attending included Bev
Ballow, Ron Denton, Richard Ferencz, Penny Lewis, Noel Scott and Don Smith. The
Director of Planning Douglas Kerr was present as well. Patrick Harrington was absent.
The press had been notified of the meeting, and the agenda for the meeting was posted
in City Hall and the Building Department to comply with the Freedom of Information Act.
Chairman Noel Scott called the meeting to order.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Mr. Scott explained that the first item on the agenda was the approval of the May 8,
2013 minutes. Mr. Smith made a motion to approve the minutes as written, and Mr.
Ferencz seconded the motion. The vote was unanimous in favor of the motion.
DISCUSSION OF TREE ORDINANCE
Mr. Scott explained that, at the last meeting, the group held off on deliberating the issue
of protecting pine trees until the group could consult with an arborist. Mr. Kerr explained
that he had contacted Mark Arena with Clemson who was unavailable to attend in
person or participate by phone. Mr. Kerr stated that he did discuss the issue of
protecting smaller pine trees with Mr. Arena, and his impression was that Mr. Arena did
not give a clear recommendation either way on the issue.
Ms. Ballow explained that she had also discussed the issue with a tree expert and other
people in the community, and she has concluded that the issue is very emotional and
not scientific. To include a recommendation of protecting loblolly pine trees might be too
controversial or unnecessary. She stated that she would support eliminating protection
for loblolly pine trees from the recommendation at this time. She made a motion to
amend the recommendation to eliminate protection for pine trees, and Mr. Denton
seconded the motion. The vote was unanimous in favor of the motion.
Mr. Kerr explained this settled the last unresolved issue; therefore, the recommendation
would be forwarded to the City Attorney for drafting into ordinance form and onto City
Council for their consideration.
DISCUSSION OF SIGN ORDINANCE - VEHICLE SIGNS
Mr. Kerr explained that the existing Code prohibits someone from displaying a vehicle
with sign in a way that indicates that the primary purpose of the vehicle with a sign is to
attract the attention of the public rather than to serve the business of the owner. He
explained that there is no differentiation between cars with signs being displayed in
Planning Commission minutes
June 12, 2013
Page 2
the commercial areas or the residential areas; recently this code caused a business
owner aggravation who was displaying his signed vehicle in front of his place of
business. He stated that the business owner went before City Council, which had in
turn directed the City Attorney to research the issue. The City Attorney had created a
draft ordinance that would allow vehicle signs to be displayed on the premises of a
business.
Mr. Smith stated that some of the verbiage in the draft ordinance appeared to be
clarifying the existing code and some of it appeared to be a departure from the current
code. Mr. Kerr explained that, for discussion purposes, the draft could be broken into
three parts as follows: the first part being to clarify the existing vehicle sign standards,
the second part is a change that would allow businesses to display their vehicle signs,
and the third part would be to allow owners of home occupations to display their vehicle
signs at their homes.
Mr. Smith stated that, as he understood the second part of the change, it would be
giving the on-island businesses an advantage that they do not currently have and this
does not bother him.
Mr. Ferencz explained that, as he read the second part of the changes, it would allow a
business owner the opportunity to display vehicle signs with no limits on the size or
number of signs, which he thought was probably too broad.
Mr. Denton explained that he, generally, did not have an issue with the display of the
sign at the old Red and White that began this discussion; he thought the existing code
was too strict. He explained that he would have an issue if the vehicles could not move.
Mr. Smith asked what the impetus was for the change to the home occupation section.
Mr. Kerr explained that, while Council was discussing the issue of vehicle signs in the
commercial area, a Councilmember voiced concern that employees of businesses not
based in the home could park vehicles with signs, but that owners of businesses that
are based in a home cannot park vehicles with signs. Mr. Ferencz voiced his
understanding that, if he had a home occupancy employed his neighbor and both had a
truck, his neighbor could park the vehicle in the yard, but he could not park the vehicle
in the yard because he owns the business. Mr. Kerr answered that this was correct.
Mr. Smith stated that he wanted to have votes on each of the three parts, and he made
a motion to accept the editorial changes in defining vehicle signs. Mr. Scott seconded
the motion, and the vote was unanimous in favor of the motion.
Ms. Lewis made a motion to recommend approval of the change that would allow
vehicle signs that are on the premises of the business establishment it serves.
Planning Commission minutes
June 12, 2013
Page 3
Mr. Scott asked if the Simons seafood truck would be affected should the group not
accept this language. Mr. Kerr answered yes, if, after the public vetting of this issue, it
is decided not to allow commercial vehicles, the Simons Seafood truck would have to be
moved or modified. Mr. Smith explained that there was no other space on the site; he
felt that the language just voted on would allow this truck to remain. Ms. Lewis
explained that one of her primary objections in this issue is that it appears to be unfairly
administered since there are real estate agents with brightly colored vehicles that are
being allowed to leave their vehicles while this particular vehicle is being forced to
move. Mr. Kerr explained that, if the will of the group is to keep the language, some
additional enforcement will be necessary.
Ms. Lewis restated her motion to recommend approval of the language that would allow
business owners to have onsite vehicle signs; Mr. Denton seconded. The vote was four
to two in favor of the motion with Mr. Ferencz and Mr. Smith voting against the motion.
The group moved on to discuss signage at a home occupation. Mr. Kerr stated that the
only rationale that he could think of for the code not allowing a business owner to
display a vehicle sign, but allowing an employee to display a vehicle sign, is that there
would be very little incentive for an employee to aggressively market the business within
his/her neighborhood, but there would be an incentive for a business owner to
aggressively market his/her business within the neighborhood.
Mr. Denton explained that he understood the purpose of the limitation to be to keep
home-based businesses very discrete and that this change could change the nature of
these operations.
Mr. Scott explained that, if he lived next to the owner of the large seafood truck, he
probably would not want that truck to be parked next to his home.
Ms. Ballow explained that she did not see a real need to change the code. She felt that
most of today’s businesses were office work that did not need to attract attention.
Mr. Smith made a motion to reject this portion of the amendment and Ms. Ballow
seconded the motion. The vote was five to one with Ms. Lewis voting against the
motion.
Planning Commission minutes
June 12, 2013
Page 4
REVIEW OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN - CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT
Mr. Scott explained that the next item on the agenda was the review of the Cultural
Resources element of the Comprehensive Plan. Ms. Ballow stated that she felt the
offerings at the Recreation Department should be highlighted, and the group generally
agreed. Mr. Kerr explained that the section currently includes a mention of the
Lowcountry Blues Bash, which he believes is no longer held on the island. Mr. Smith
noted that the last sentence of the first paragraph under Events ends in the word
“commemorate” and is poorly worded and should be edited. The group agreed with the
suggested revisions.
MISCELLANEOUNS BUSINESS - BEACH TRAFFIC
Mr. Scott explained that he had asked for the issue of traffic to be put on the agenda for
the group to talk about the Memorial Day weekend traffic. He expressed the opinion
that there should be some traffic control exercises implemented on these busy
weekends that would simulate a hurricane evacuation or the letting out of a major
sporting event. He explained that more officers directing traffic and possibly reversing
of some traffic lanes might be in order. Mr. Kerr explained that he knew that the Police
Department was implementing some changes in managing traffic as a result of that
weekend, but he was not clear on the details. He suggested that, between now and the
next meeting, he pass along the details of the Police Department changes and see if
any more discussion is necessary. The group agreed with this suggestion.
ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 6:20 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Noel Scott, Chairman.
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.