January 17 (PDF, 25.11 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
WAYS and MEANS COMMITTEE
5:45 p.m., Tuesday, January 17, 2012
The regular meeting of the Ways and Means Committee was held at 5:45 p.m., Tuesday,
January 15, 2012 in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf, Bettelli, Buckhannon, Carroll,
Loftus, Stone, Thomas and Ward, Mayor Cronin, City Administrator Tucker, City Treasurer
Suggs, Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland. A quorum was present
to conduct business.
1. Mayor Cronin called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Election of Chair and Vice Chair
Mayor Cronin opened the floor for the election of Committee Chair; Councilmember Bergwerf
nominated Mayor Cronin as Chair for 2012; Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the vote was
unanimous for the Mayor.
Councilmember Carroll nominated Councilmember Ward as Vice Chair; Councilmember
Buckhannon seconded and the vote was unanimous for Councilmember Ward.
3. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of November 15, 2011 as submitted; Councilmember Bettelli seconded
and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
4. Citizens’ Comments – None
Mayor Cronin recognized Sandy Ferencz as the newly elected Chair of the Accommodations
Tax Advisory Committee, who was in the audience for the meeting.
5. Review of Proposed Forest Trail Wastewater Treatment Plant Replacement by
George Gross, General Manager, Isle of Palms Water and Sewer Commission, and
Mark Yodice, Thomas and Hutton
Mayor Cronin introduced Mr. Gross, Mr. Yodice and Lindy Cummins, Environmental Department
Manager with Thomas and Hutton. Mr. Gross stated that he and the consultants were present
to inform the City of future plans for the IOP Water and Sewer Commission. Mr. Yodice pro-
ceeded to explain that the treatment plant currently in place had been purchased used and been
in operation for more than thirty (30) years, and maintenance costs have continued to escalate.
The replacement will be the latest technology; the modular design will allow for future increased
capacity, should the need arise, and the exceptional treatment capability will allow the plant to
more easily meet future permit limits.
The next move is for the IOP Water and Sewer Commission to take the plan before the Board of
Zoning Appeals for a Special Exception for height. Director Kerr explained that new zoning
criteria were established for this type of facility seven to eight (7-8) years ago, and a Special
Exception had to be granted to exceed a height of thirty (30) feet.
Ways and Means Committee
January 17, 2012
Page 2 of 7
In addition, permits must be obtained from DHEC and OCRM before construction can begin.
When asked what other municipalities in the area used the new technology, Mr. Yodice stated
that the same type of plant planned for Isle of Palms is in Fripp Island and Savannah, as well as
several in Atlanta.
Mr. Cummins distributed conceptual drawings of the facility for the Committee to review.
Councilmember Carroll questioned that the structure was not designed to be elevated; Mr.
Yodice explained that elevation was not required because the electrical equipment was located
above the second level.
The construction cost is estimated to be six million one hundred thousand dollars ($6,100,000),
and an eighteen (18) month construction period is expected to being in 2013. Ten percent
(10%) of the construction costs will come from the Water and Sewer Commission and the
balance from revenue bonds.
Mayor Cronin reminded the Committee that the City would be required to sign off on the
revenue bonds.
Mr. Yodice referred to the water treatment plant in Wild Dunes as being similar to the existing
plant on 41
st Avenue. Councilmember Loftus asked what the life expectancy of the Wild Dunes
plant was, and Mr. Yodice responded that it should last another twelve to fifteen (12-15) years
because it was newer and had received better routine maintenance than the plant on 41 st
Avenue. On the same topic, Councilmember Buckhannon asked if the Commission could
abandon the Wild Dunes plant and add capacity to 41
st Avenue in the future; Mr. Yodice said it
could be done with the addition of modular sections.
Councilmember Stone asked if the new construction would require a rate increase; Mr. Gross
stated that the most recent rate increase had been to accumulate the ten percent (10%) needed
for this project. Another rate increase of five percent (5%) for sewer customers is predicted to
follow in 2014; based on average residential usage of four thousand (4,000) gallons monthly,
the increased expense to individual residences will be twenty-two dollars ($22) per month.
When the Mayor asked about the permitting cycle, Mr. Yodice said he expected permitting to
take eight to ten (8-10) months. Mr. Gross stated that he anticipated coming back before the
Committee about mid-year with the financing package details.
6. Financial Statement – Treasurer Suggs
A. December Financial Statement
Treasurer Suggs reported that the financial statement before the Committee at this meeting is
reflective of activity for one-half (½) of the fiscal year. General Fund revenue is at twenty-three
(23%) of budget, and the revenue stream with the most impact is Property Taxes which are
down from the same period in FY11. The reason for the reduction is assumed to be attributable
to the fact that Charleston County had problems with its new computer program that delayed the
distribution of tax bills which would delay payments.
Ways and Means Committee
January 17, 2012
Page 3 of 7
Councilmember Buckhannon asked if staff knew how many challenges or appeals were filed
with the County from the City. The Mayor responded that the number was unknown, and
Councilmember Stone added that tax payments were due and payable despite the existence of
a challenge or appeal.
Revenues from business licenses , rental licenses and building permits are all running ahead of
FY11; these revenue streams are typically indica tive of the general economic activity on the
island from the Treasurer’s viewpoint.
Treasurer Suggs drew attention to the asterisk at the bottom left of the page and stated that the
City had received unbudgeted revenue in the form of a premium refund from the previous health
insurance provider in the amount of one hundred thirty-nine thousand dollars ($139,000). She
deferred to Administrator Tucker, who has served on the board, for further explanation.
Administrator Tucker repeated for the benefit of new members of the Committee that, until July,
the City was part of a health insurance pool known as the South Carolina Local Government
Assurance Group (SCLGAG). As health care costs continued to rise, SCLGAG knew that they
needed to dissolve before becoming insolvent, and the participants in the pool voted to approve
the action. Since July 1, 2011, SCLGAG has been pay ing the run-out of claims liabilities; in this
initial distribution a total of five million dollars ($5,000,000) went back to participants in the pool.
The next board meeting is in April and details on the final payout should be available.
All departments are below the fifty percent (50%) target for General Fund expenditures; in total,
the City is at forty-three percent (43%) of annual budgeted expenditures.
Through the end of December, the City had a combined total of one million two hundred sixty-
nine thousand dollars ($1,269,000) deposited in BB&T and the South Carolina Local
Government Investment Pool (LGIP). The cash on hand represents fifteen percent (15%) of
General Fund annual expenditures.
Responding to Councilmember Ward’s questions on debt service, Mayor Cronin reminded him
that the City’s annual debt service by fund can be located on one (1) of the last schedules in the
annual budget.
B. Tourism
State ATAX – No change since the last meeting; the second quarterly payment should be
received any day.
Municipal Accommodation Fee – Receipts in J anuary for December were thirty-one thousand
dollars ($31,000); revenues year-to-date are nine percent (9%) greater than FY11.
Charleston County Pass-through – The City has not received a payment in FY12.
Hospitality Tax – Receipts were down in December compared to FY11; two (2) taxpayers are
delinquent, and efforts are being made to collect. Year-to-date the City is down eight percent
(8%) from FY11.
Administrator Tucker commented that one (1) particular taxpayer prefers to pay the late fees to
paying his hospitality taxes timely.
Ways and Means Committee
January 17, 2012
Page 4 of 7
C. Projects Status
1. Beach Restoration – Payments since the last meeting were to Coastal Science and
Engineering (CSE) for post-project monitoring and permitting for the remedial restor-
ation project.
Mayor Cronin reported that the bid package for the remedial project is being readied, and he
hopes to award a contract at the February Council meeting, which will mean that the work will
be done before the season. The Mayor remarked that the City has not received the permit from
the Corps of Engineers.
Councilmember Carroll asked if there was a “drop-dead” date that would force the work to be
delayed a year. Administrator Tucker answered that such a date was more driven by environ-
mental aspects of the permit than tourism; she recounted that the 2008 project had been done
in June, but the City had to employ round-the-clock turtle monitoring. To perform the work in
March would avoid the peak turtle-nesting season.
Treasurer Suggs pointed out that she had added the cost of the shoal management project to
the top of the schedule.
2. 53
rd to 57 th Avenue Drainage Project – No expenses have been attributed to this
project since the last meeting. Administrator Tucker noted that the Public Works
Committee had directed her to have Civil Site Environmental develop a proposal for
the engineering design of the next phase of the drainage from 46
th to 52nd Avenues.
3. Marina Dredging – Since the last meeting, General Engineering has been paid for
preparation of the contract documents.
Mayor Cronin announced that the City was in receipt of the Corps of Engineers’ permit for
dredging, and work may begin by the end of the month.
7. Old Business
Consideration of Extension of Audit Engagement with Greene, Finney, Horton,
LLP through 2011
The Mayor stated that the City had engaged this firm for the past seven (7) years, and they
have given a proposal for one (1) year, three (3 ) year and five (5) year engagements. The City
is not allowed to enter into a five (5) year agreement by state law; the Committee will decide on
one (1), three (3) or four (4) term extensions. Mayor Cronin pointed out that Greene, Finney,
Horton “have worked extremely well with us the la st few years, they know our system, they
know our people and are not as burdensome on the staff.”
Administrator Tucker indicated that, for the four (4) year term, the Committee can simply elimin-
ate Year Five (5) in that proposal.
Ways and Means Committee
January 17, 2012
Page 5 of 7
The Administrator explained that, in 2004, the City had entered into a competitive bid process,
and City Council had made its determination bas ed primarily on other municipal auditing
experience in the state of South Carolina, whic h means that they already know all of the
regulations and they have experience in gover nmental accounting and experience in municipal
accounting. At that time, the City received pricing from six (6) firms, and Greene, Finney,
Horton was in the middle of the pack; bid prices ranged from sixty-four thousand dollars
($64,000) to ninety-seven thousand dollars ($97,000) for four (4) years. This firm was selected
by Council based on the fact that they had more municipal accounting experience than any of
the other firms that submitted bids. Administrator Tucker noted that neither the City’s code nor
state law requires the competitive bidding proce ss for accounting services; the City can extend
an existing engagement or select a new firm. Greene, Finney, Horton now has an office in the
area and has more municipal contracts than w hen they entered into the original engagement
with the City. The Administrator added that the City has been very happy with their services
and that they are extremely responsive to the needs of the staff – over and above the annual
audit. Based on this information, staff recommends moving forward with a four (4) year
extension.
MOTION: Councilmember Stone moved to extend the audit engagement for a
period of four (4) years; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded.
Councilmember Ward asked whether Greene, Finney, Horton submitted their peer review to the
City, and Treasurer Suggs responded that they do. He asked whether they received an
unqualified opinion every year; again the Treasurer responded that they do. He added that few
firms in the state do this type of auditing and that it is very specialized and very technical.
The Committee was informed that this firm now performs the audit for Mount Pleasant and for
CARTA.
Councilmember Stone asked if this proposal was in-line with previous ones and he was assured
that it is.
Councilmember Loftus sought confirmation that t he four (4) year stipulation had been discussed
with the accounting firm; Administrator Tucker replied that she had spoken with them by phone
earlier in the day.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
8. New Business
A. Recommendations from the Real Property Committee
1. Approval of $5,500 from the Tree Fund for landscaping trees for 1301 Palm
Administrator Tucker referred the Committee to the revised estimate on this effort that she had
sent electronically earlier in the day.
Ways & Means Committee
January 17, 2012
Page 6 of 7
A basic drawing of the property at 1301 Palm Boulevard was displayed as a visual aid for the
discussion. The Administrator reported that the RPB for demolition has been advertised and the
bid opening is set for 10 a.m. on Friday, January 27
th.
As the building demolition has drawn near, staff has become concerned that, once the building
comes down, there will be no buffer for the Public Works Department and its apparatus. Staff
knew that they would need to mobilize immediately not only to secure Public Works, but also to
eliminate an eyesore in the middle of town.
The staff also considered that the entrance to Public Works from Palm Boulevard is not well-
placed and that this might be a good time to study the site and better plan for ingress/egress
and parking. A landscape architect has been hired to look at both 1301 and 1207 Palm to
develop a plan for making the properties more attractive and more usable.
As the thought processes developed, staff realized that there may not be sufficient budgets to
accomplish the goals that they were seeking, and work began on more realistic cost estimates.
When presented to Real Property, they took the two actions that are detailed on the agenda, i.e.
(1) to use fifty-five hundred dollars ($5,500) budgeted from the Tree Fund for beautification in
the form of a vegetative buffer along the fence and (2) the approval of thirty-four thousand one
hundred seventy dollars ($34,170) from the Capital Projects fund to the budget for 1301 Palm
Boulevard. These two (2) actions are reflective of the first column on the estimates, which
represents a very rough estimate of the cost to transform 1301 Palm Boulevard into a surface
for parking that is similar to overflow parking at the County Park.
Councilmember Stone justified the use of Tree Fund money as a valid use because the purpose
for which those funds are to be used is beautification, and this certainly will be a beautification
project, and the balance in the Tree Fund is approximately forty-six thousand dollars ($46,000).
The five thousand dollars ($5,000) for paving is for the ingress from 13
th Avenue and an overlay
from the ingress to the remaining parking spaces on either side.
Gravel was inadvertently omitted from the original estimates and has been added here in
Options 1 for a new total of thirty-five thousand seven hundred thirty-three dollars ($35,733).
The Real Property Committee also asked staff to look at the overflow parking surface at the
First United Methodist Church and to include costs estimates reflecting that change. Option 2
contains the rough estimates for using that type of surface and totals thirty-two thousand seven
hundred fifteen dollars ($32,715).
In telephone calls to vendors to compile these revised numbers, staff remains concerned that
the estimates are too low and have concluded that an actual plan is needed before getting an
approval for funding from the Committee. Some activities must move forward however, i.e. the
demolition and the temporary fencing to secure the Public Works’ area.
MOTION: Councilmember Bergwerf moved to approve $5,500 from the Tree
Fund for beautification; Councilmember Buckhannon seconded and the motion
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Ways and Means Committee
January 17, 2012
Page 7 of 7
Councilmember Buckhannon repeated comments from the Real Property Committee supporting
the graveled surface similar to Methodist Church parking in that the City would not have to deal
with an irrigation system with broken sprinkler heads and a well pump. He reported that the
Methodist Church had spent a total of seventeen thousand dollars ($17,000) for the gravel, the
trees and the fencing.
Councilmember Carroll asked whether staff had spoken with the property owners behind the
Public Works’ property about the change in ingre ss/egress; the Administrator replied that any
reconfiguration did not include moving further down 13
th Avenue.
Responding to Councilmember Stone’s query, the Administrator stated that the fifty-five hundred
dollars ($5,500) was intended entirely for 1301 Palm Boulevard.
B. FY13 Budget Calendar
Mayor Cronin announced that the annual budgeting process will begin next month with a goal of
approval in April; he noted that the annual budget must be approved by July 1, 2012 by state
law.
MOTION: Councilmember Stone moved to adopt the FY13 Budget Calendar as
submitted; Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
9. Miscellaneous Budget
Next Meeting Date: 5:45 p.m., Tuesday, February 21, 2012
10. Executive Session – not needed
11. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to adjourn the meeting at 7:15 p.m.;
Councilmember Stone seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.