March 20 (PDF, 93.63 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
WAYS and MEANS COMMITTEE
5:45 p.m., Tuesday, March 20, 2012
The regular meeting of the Ways and Means Committee was held at 5:45 p.m., March 20, 2012
in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulev ard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina. Present
for the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf, Bettelli, Buckhannon, Carroll, Loftus, Stone,
Thomas and Ward, Mayor Cronin, City Administrator Tucker, City Attorney Halversen, Assistant
to the Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland. A quorum was present to conduct
business.
1. Mayor Cronin called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
were duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Stone moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of February 21, 2012 as submitted; Councilmember Bettelli seconded and
the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments - None
4. Financial Statements – Treasurer Suggs
A. February Financial Statements
Being two-thirds ( ⅔) through the fiscal year, the target is sixty-seven percent (67%); General
Fund expenditures are at fifty-eight percent (58%) overall for the City’s departments, while
General Fund revenues are at fifty-five percent (55%) of budget. General Fund revenues
continue to be low due to the collection issues Charleston County is experiencing relative to
property taxes. Since the end of February, the City has received an additional six hundred fifty
thousand ($650,000) in property which that takes property taxes receipts to seventy percent
(70%) of budget. Cash on-hand has improved to thirty-one percent (31%) of annual General
Fund expenses.
B. Tourism Schedules
Municipal Accommodations Fees continue to trend ahead of FY11; collections year-to-date are
eleven percent (11%) greater than the same period in FY11.
State Accommodation Taxes and the Charlest on County Accommodations Tax Pass Through
have had no activity since the past meeting.
Hospitality Taxes are also ahead of FY11. Treas urer Suggs recalled that Councilmember Ward
had inquired about the large difference between in January collections in 2011 and 2012; she
researched to numbers and found that, in 2012, two (2) payees paid who had been delinquent.
February collections also show a significant increase over the same month in 2011; checking
the detail, the Treasurer found that one payee caught up on delinquent taxes and penalties
totaling ten thousand dollars ($10,000).
Treasurer Suggs stated that the City collects penalties, but not interest on late payments.
Ways and Means Committee
March 20, 2012
Page 2 of 16
C. Projects Status
1. Beach Restoration
For the next meeting, the contract to Baker Infrastructure Group for two hundred thousand five
hundred dollars ($250,500) the 2012 Shoal Management Project will be added to the top section
of the schedule. Payments were made to Coastal Science and Engineering relative to the
current project.
2. Dredging
The change orders going before the Committee have been added to the top section of the
schedule and reflect a reduction to the contingency and an addition to the construction costs.
Recent payments reflect the cost to remove pilings, the second application to Marcol and
contracted services from GEL.
3. 53
rd to 57th Avenue Drainage
Treasurer Suggs reported that Charleston County has accepted the documentation the City
provided for spending related to CTC grants; the only anticipated activity for this project is the
cost of relocating the line for the construction of the pool for The Villages. Pursuant to a request
from the Mayor, this schedule will not be put before the Committee until those expenditures
have been paid.
5. Old Business
Prioritization of Projects Greater than $250,000
Included in meeting packets were the results of this exercise from each Committee and the
resulting compilation of those lists. Administrator Tucker noted that this is the first time that two
(2) committees have duplicated efforts; she did report that all committees appear to want to pro-
ceed with replacing the ball-field lights which impacts the Capital Budgets.
The final priority list for projects greater than a quarter million dollars ($250,000) is as follows:
1. Drainage Project at 42
nd to 52nd Avenue
2. Increase Disaster Recovery Fund
3. Recreation Ball-field – lights only
4. Bicycle and Pedestrian Infrastructure Additions
5. Island-wide Parking System
5. Underground Wiring Projects
Councilmember Loftus asked to review the funds that would be available should the City have a
natural disaster imminently. Administrator Tucker explained that, in part, the purpose of the
Disaster Recovery Fund is to allow for cash flow immediately after the event or storm
preparations. This is a time when all revenues stop and the flow from FEMA and insurance
Ways and Means Committee
March 20, 2012
Page 3 of 16
proceeds have not started, but this is the time that the City’s residents need the City’s people
infrastructure the most. At a time like this, the City could utilize other sources of money on the
understanding that the money would be paid back.
Mayor Cronin listed money sources as the following:
• $2.2 million Unassigned funds at the end of FY12
• $2.5 million General Funds
• $300,000 Beach Maintenance
• $500,000 Ball-field lights
• $1.3 million Capital Projects
• $2 million Unallocated Tourism funds
• $1 million Unassigned, unallocated marina funds
The Mayor added that FEMA reimburses funds that have been spent, but the City has to have
an officially-recognized storm event, not a glancing blow like Irene was to Folly Beach.
Councilmember Ward sought a clarification on the term “unallocated tourism funds;” the Mayor
stated that these funds had not been assigned to a specific purpose. Councilmember Ward
then noted that the Mayor was referring to fund balances.
From experiences he had during Hurricane Hugo, Councilmember Ward said that he did not
think the City could have too much money in the Disaster Recovery Fund; he indicated that in
taking the CPI into consideration, the City should have thirty-four hundred thousand dollars
($3,400,000) at a minimum.
With the budget workshop looming on the horizon, Mayor Cronin asked Treasurer Suggs to roll
forward the forecasted FY12 balances into the fund balance schedule to have for the workshop.
Councilmember Stone stated that he has a problem with the prioritization list because he did not
look forward to the citizens’ seeing that a drainage project that would affect possibly one
hundred (100) residents took precedence over a parking management plan, or ball-field lights
as more important than parking. From a citizen’s point of view, he thought parking should be
THE priority.
Councilmember Bergwerf noted that the City had money in-hand for the ball-field lights,
whereas the City does not even have a plan relative to parking.
Councilmember Bettelli commented that all six (6) items were a priority to him, but the north end
of the island is one (1) of the few remaining areas of the island that has drainage issues.
Mayor Cronin suggested that the list remain intact as priorities for the City without numbering
them in any way.
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to adopt the list as stated as
priorities for the City; Councilmember Stone seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
Ways and Means Committee
March 20, 2012
Page 4 of 16
5. New Business
A. Recommendation from the Public Works Committee for the award of a sole
source contract in the amount of $43,290 to PermaTrak for materials for the
replacement of the public restrooms beach access
Assistant Dziuban circulated photos of the existing dune walkover for the Committee to
understand the need for replacement. The Assistant recounted that eighty thousand dollars
($80,000) had been included in the FY12 budget for the replacement of a dune walkover; after
assessing the dune walkovers on the island, Directors Pitts and Kerr recommended the replace-
ment of the dune walkover behind the Front Beach public restrooms. The decision then
became what material should be used, and staff returned with a recommendation for
PermaTrak, a concrete-based product that looks like wood. The material was selected for being
low maintenance and estimated life of between forty and fifty (40-50) years. She indicated that,
although OCRM is sympathetic with the City’s product selection, they are going to require a
permit to ensure that the work does not alter the primary dune in any way. The staff is recom-
mending that the product be purchased now under the FY12 budget, and then re-budgeting the
balance to accomplish the labor in FY13 after the receipt of the permit. If the permit is issued
quickly, the project would be completed under the FY12 budget.
Mayor Cronin asked if there was a possibility that the City would acquire the material but not be
issued a permit; Administrator Tucker stated that Director Kerr had met with the OCRM
representative at the site and had been assured that the permit would come through.
The Administrator informed the Committee that this is a sole source award because this is the
only vendor in the region who carries the materials.
In addition, the Administrator said that she has learned that, with the permit situation, the
possibility exists that OCRM will plus or minus t he City on the length or height of the walkover in
the permit; therefore, she was possibly asking for lower than the forty-three thousand dollars
($43,000) quoted here or for no more than seven thousand dollars ($7,000) more than stated.
Councilmember Carroll asked whether the material carried a guarantee; the life quoted is an
estimate, not a warranty. He, then, asked where the materials would be stored; Assistant
Dziuban responded that the vendor had agreed to store until time for construction.
Councilmember Bergwerf asked what the incentive was to buy now, and, according to Director
Kerr, the materials would not be purchased until the permit was issued.
Director Kerr reported that the survey and design have been completed; he has a second
meeting with OCRM on Wednesday to determine at what elevation above the dune is going to
be required. The City has been told that the permit will take six (6) weeks, which will put the
City into the season so that the construction would be delayed until after.
Councilmember Buckhannon indicated that he did not see the need to act now when nothing
would happen until after the season.
Ways and Means Committee
March 20, 2012
Page 5 of 16
Administrator Tucker explained that, between the time the item was placed on the Public Works
Committee’s agenda and this meeting, the City has had multiple meetings with OCRM and
learned different things. Originally the hope was that the work could be done more as a main-
tenance issue, despite the fact that the new walkover will be wider.
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to defer action until the next meeting;
Councilmember Stone seconded.
Councilmember Thomas questioned the award as sole source; Administrator Tucker replied that
this was a sole source due to its longevity and low maintenance which is important for this
particular path. Mayor Cronin stated that the material appears to be a good product for the
application.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
B. Recommendation from the Real Property Committee for change orders for
Marcol Dredging (approximately $29,500 from contingency)
1. Dredging 12 hours at $500/hour for hard material near Intracoastal Court
2. Dredging 12 hours at $500/hour for hard material behind the fuel dock
3. Dredging 25 hours at $500/hour for hard material behind Tidal Wave dock
4. Dredging 10 hours at $500/hour for hard material near restaurant dock
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to approve the change orders as
detailed above; Councilmember Buckhannon seconded.
Administrator Tucker had an aerial view of the marina that pointed out the areas affected by the
change orders; she noted that the dredging contract had a caveat that, if the contractor encoun-
tered hard material that required him to stay in an area for a protracted amount of time to effect
the goal, the City will be notified and the work in those areas would be at a rate of five hundred
dollars ($500) per hour. The Administrator recalled that when dredging was done last, the
desired depth had been eight (8) feet, and the contractor did not get too close to the bulkhead
for fear of its failing. The silting from the 41
st Avenue easement has accumulated under the
dock near IntraCoastal Court to the point that the dock sits on land at dry dock; the City has
produce a waiver of liability that the property owner has signed and executed.
Councilmember Carroll voiced his understanding that the need to dredge at IntraCoastal Court
is due to the silting from the 41
st Avenue easement and that the dredging will go to a depth of
twelve (12) feet. Administrator Tucker confirmed his understanding and clarified that the depth
will be determined by the contractor’s ability to access the area without coming into close
proximity to the SCE&G cable. Councilmember Carroll then asked what was to keep the next
dock owner from claiming that he/she needed dredging also from silting; the Administrator
explained that the City had authorized an engineering study that confirmed the problem was the
result of drainage from the easement. Mayor Cronin added that the 41
st Avenue easement
serves one- third ( ⅓) of the island. Councilmember Carroll queried what was to prevent others
on the island who have docks near an easement to make the same claim; the Administrator
Ways and Means Committee
March 20, 2012
Page 6 of 16
stated that, in that case, the City would authorize another study to make the final determination
about the owner’s claim.
Councilmember Stone explained that the engineer had recommended that the City limit its
expense by defining a specific period of time for the work to be accomplished rather than a
dollar amount.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
D. Recommendation from the Real Property Committee to award a sole source
contract to Low Country Marine due to dredging timing in the amount of $24,400
from the Marina Fund for the removal, construction and installation of a new
floating dock for Tidal Wave Water Sports
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to approve the award to Low Country Marina
as stated above; Councilmember Stone seconded.
Mayor Cronin reminded the Committee that Administrator Tucker had alluded to this action at
the February meeting. The Administrator recalled that twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000)
had been included in the FY12 budget for the design, engineering and permitting of new docks
for Tidal Wave; the Committee recommended using those funds for the dock replacement rather
than spending more of the project contingency. The Administrator indicated that this is being
issued as a sole source due to the time requirements to have a contractor available.
Councilmember Stone remarked that, by replacing t he docks in the existing footprint, no permit
is required, and no design and engineering are necessary.
For the short period of time that the Tidal Wave dock is out of use, the marina manager has
offered an alternate location from which the business can operate.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Before moving to a review of the City’s FY13 operating budgets, Administrator Tucker offered
pictures of the completed walkway and pad at the City compactor that was approved recently.
D. Review of FY 2012-2013 Operating Budgets
Mayor Cronin distributed a schedule for the personnel and personnel-related expenses for the
City from 2010 through the FY13 budget estimates. The schedule shows a steady upward trend
of seven point four percent (7.4%) with individual wage increases of less than three percent
(3%); this increase represents three hundred thousand dollars ($300,000) from 2007 to 2013
projected. These increases have been covered through property tax revenue increases, which
the Mayor does not expect to see in the future. He expressed the opinion that the City will need
to find other sources of revenue to support its employees in the future.
Ways and Means Committee
March 20, 2012
Page 7 of 16
Councilmember Ward noticed that Workers Compensation insurance has doubled in the time
frame covered and asked for an explanation. Treasurer Suggs offered that in FY11 the City
was the recipient of some favorable credits from its carrier; the figures for FY12 and FY13 are
estimates based on fifty percent (50%) of the favorable credits; she does not expect the actual
to be the budgeted amount. Administrator Tucker commented that one bad accident affects the
City’s experience rating for three (3) years. Mayor Cronin stated that he had researched further
into the history and found that the expense in 2008 was one hundred fifty-two thousand dollars
($152,000) and in 2009, one hundred thirty-two thousand dollars ($132,000). Mayor Cronin
attributes the lower actual figures to the training and safety requirements placed on the City’s
personnel.
Initiating the budget discussions, Administrator Tucker recounted the budget changes that
affect every City department as follows:
• Three percent (3%) merit pool;
• Six percent (6%) increase to health insurance effective January 1, 2013;
• Charleston County radio user fees increasing from twenty-five dollars ($25) per radio per
month to thirty eight fifty ($38.50) per radio per month;
• Fuel costs at four dollars and a quarter ($4.25) per gallon; and
• Retirement for regular personnel going from nine point five three five percent (9.535%)
to ten point six (10.6%) and for public safety personnel going from eleven point seven six
five percent (11.765%) to twelve point three percent (12.3%).
Mayor and Council
Group Health $30,623
When City moved to state health plan, who would participate was unknown; reduced to actual.
Memberships and dues 50
New organization of state-wide mayors; first year
Telephone and cable 1,100
Reduced based on actual
Insurance 2,116
Premium adjustments
Overall, the Mayor and Council FY13 operating budget is reduced by twenty-three percent
(23%).
General Government
Debt Service – Principal 416,000
Based on actual
Debt Service – Interest 326,612
Based on actual
Ways and Means Committee
March 20, 2012
Page 8 of 16
Bank service charges 35,000
Estimate of fees related to accepting cr edit/debit cards; may be able to pass on to users
Dues and memberships 4,380
Based on actual
Electricity and gas 4,200
Reduced based on actual
Telephone and cable 8,619
Reduced based on actual
Water and sewer 2,500
Reduced based on actual
Maintenance and service contracts 21,885
Detailed in attached schedule, based on actual
Cleaning and sanitary supplies 2,000
Reduced based on actual
Advertising 7,500
Reduced based on actual; cushion for required Post and Courier ads
Insurance 18,657
Detailed in attached schedule
Employee Training 14,200
Reduced based on actual
Professional Services 31,210
Reduced based on actual; detailed in attached schedule
Overall the General Government FY13 budget has a two percent (2%) increase over FY12.
Councilmember Loftus asked if the line for “printing and office supplies” could be reduced
because usage trends closer to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) annually; the Administrator
agreed to research.
Councilmember Loftus commented that money was budgeted for software training in FY12 and
again in FY13; he wanted to know what was being planned. Administrator Tucker explained
that this year the task has been assigned to someone in the Building Department to locate a
trainer who will come to the island to provide the training.
The Administrator added that tuition reimbursement is also in the line for “employee training,”
and one (1) employee postponed his/her classes.
Ways and Means Committee
March 20, 2012
Page 9 of 16
Police Department
Wages 1,232.781
Reorganization in the department upon the retirement of Lt Wright lessened impact of merit
pool on wages and overtime
Memberships and dues 1,500
Based on actual
Electricity and gas 22,000
Based on actual; FY11 actual reflected billing error by SCE&G
Telephone and cable 42,804
Increase primarily due to Charleston County radio user fees increase
Water and sewer 4,500
Based on actual
Maintenance and service contracts 47,521
Based on actual, detailed in attached schedules
Cleaning and sanitary supplies 1,750
Decreased based on actual
Rents and leases 2,400
Decreased based on actual
Employee training 8.980
Decreased based on actual
Professional services 5,500
Decreased based on actual
Overall the Police Department budget is flat for FY13 with no increase or decrease.
Fire Department
Printing and office supplies 6,500
Decreased based on actual
Meetings and seminars 1,000
Decreased based on actual
Electricity and gas 42,000
See Police Department
Telephone and cable 39,996
Increased primarily due to Charleston County radio user fee increase
Water and sewer 8,500
Decreased based on actual
Ways and Means Committee
March 20, 2012
Page 10 of 16
Maintenance and service contracts 42,046
Based on actual, detailed in attached schedules; impacted by move to Consolidated Dispatch
and items out of warranty
Uniforms 24,500
Increased based on actual
Cleaning and sanitary supplies 3,000
Reduced based on actual
Medical and lab supplies 15,000
Reduced based on actual
Rents and leases 3,500
Increased based on actual
Employee training 12,500
Reduced based on actual
Miscellaneous and contingency 6,000
Reduced based on actual
Overall, the Fire Department budget increases two percent (2%) from FY12.
Councilmember Loftus commented that, based on year-to-date actuals, the vehicle mainte-
nance line could possibly be an opportunity to reduce the budget; the Administrator agreed to
review with the Treasurer and Chief Graham. Councilmember Buckhannon recounted that the
exposure to the elements when the department was operating out of trailers adversely impacted
vehicle maintenance in the past.
Councilmember Carroll asked clarification on “volunteer fire points;” Administrator Tucker
explained that, when volunteers serve, they a ccrue points for being active – they are an
incentive to be active volunteers. The points translate to financial awards.
Public Works
Wages and salaries 457,713
Includes the addition of one (1) mid-level person whose responsibility would be to provide
facilities maintenance on the City’s buildings
Responding to Mayor Cronin’s query, Councilmember Buckhannon reported that the Public
Works had not supported the addition of this position. Assistant Dziuban stated that no motion
had come from the Committee to remove the position from the FY13 budget.
MOTION: Councilmember Ward moved to remove the facilities maintenance
position from the FY13 Public Works Operating Budget; Councilmember
Buckhannon seconded.
Ways and Means Committee
March 20, 2012
Page 11 of 16
Mayor Cronin noted that the Public Works Department had eliminated a position in FY12; he
recommended that the departments should begin to track the expenses in both time and money
to maintain the City’s facilities for better understanding of the cost effectiveness.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Memberships and dues 450
Increased based on actual
Telephone and cable 8,881
Increased primarily due to Charleston County radio users fees
Non-capital tools and equipment 1,500
Decreased based on actual
Uniforms 7,425
Purchase of replacement t-shirts and hoodies
Medical and lab supplies 3,250
Increased for replacement safety gloves and glasses
Professional services 1,000
Decreased based on actual
Temporary labor 169,335
Increased based on actual
Contracted services 12,500
Decreased based on fewer trips to 4B
Garbage cart procurement 7,600
Based on purchase of 75 gallon carts
The Public Works FY13 operating budget increases overall by six percent (6%) over FY12
budget.
Councilmember Loftus indicated that staff is l ooking into any cost-savings that would be
obtained by purchasing smaller roll-out carts; he is of the opinion that, when single-stream
recycling begins, residents will no longer need or want the larger roll-out carts because they will
be recycling more.
When asked, Director Pitts stated the County indica tes, unofficially, that single-stream recycling
will begin on the island in June.
Building Department
Administrator Tucker remarked that changes to the Building Department FY13 are primarily
reductions to costs from relocating to City Hall.
Ways and Means Committee
March 20, 2012
Page 12 of 16
Electricity and gas 4,200
Reduced based on actual
Telephone and cable 5,040
Reduced based on actual
Water and sewer 2,500
Reduced based on actual
Maintenance and service contracts 5,406
Reduced based on actual
Professional services 7,000
Reduced based on actual
Overall, the Building Department FY13 operating budget decreases by one percent (1%) from
FY12.
Recreation Department
Vehicle maintenance 2,000
Reduced based on actual
Electricity and gas 36,000
Reduced based on actual
Telephone and cable 11,526
Reduced based on actual
Water and sewer 4,300
Reduced based on actual
Non-capital tools and equipment 1,500
Reduced based on actual
Special events/activities 20,500
Increased to include videographer for video postings to City website
Summer camps 14,000
Increased based on actual
The FY13 operating budget for the Recreation Department includes a one percent (1%)
increase as presented.
Judicial and Legal
Part-time wages 18,000
Reduced because City has one (1) judge for municipal and livability courts
Printing and office supplies 4,000
Reduced based on actual
Ways and Means Committee
March 20, 2012
Page 13 of 16
Memberships and dues 200
Reduced based on actual
Maintenance and service contracts 4,000
Reduced based on actual
Employee training 2,000
Reduced because Judge Molony will not be requ ired to attend training required of Judge Harper
Professional services 48,000
Increased based on actual
The Judicial and Legal operating budget has been reduced by four percent (4%) from the FY12
budget.
Parking Meter Department
Bank service charges 1,000
New item; bank charges for processing coin s and currency; previously done in-house by
employee
This budget increases two percent (2%) from FY12 operating budget.
The total FY13 departmental operating budgets have a one percent (1%) increase over FY12.
Municipal Accommodations Fee Fund Expenditures
Front Beach Area
Telephone and cable 1,500
Includes service to call boxes
Administrator Tucker recounted the discussion at the Real Property Committee to remove this
item from the budget due to the infrequency of use and to account for the fact that everyone has
a cell phone.
Councilmember Buckhannon commented that the process to replace the call boxes is in the
budget along with the service contracts and the air cards; the Committee believes that the
infrequency of use and costs associated with the ca ll boxes are sufficient reasons to eliminate
these costs from the budget.
Councilmember Ward asked if the data on the number of calls placed from the call boxes was
available and whether the call boxes had actually been used in an emergency to save someone.
Chief Buckhannon stated that he did not have the number of calls at the meeting, but he did
have that information. The call boxes exist only for emergencies and only dial 911; there have
been instances of an emergency at the beach and the call boxes have been used. Each call
box uses cell phone technology; the cost is thirty collars ($30) per month for the three (3) boxes
and five hundred twenty-five or five hundred fifty dollars ($525-550) per box for annual
maintenance. The Chief recalled that the boxes are used two to four (2-4) times a month.
Ways and Means Committee
March 20, 2012
Page 14 of 16
Councilmember Ward said that, if the boxes are used to find one (1) child or to save one (1) life,
then they are needed.
Mayor Cronin suggested that the Public Safety Committee continue this discussion at their April
meeting.
Administrator Tucker noted that, at the Personnel Committee, the recommendation had been
made to add the holiday gathering to the General Government budget in the amount of ten
thousand dollars ($10,000); it will appear in the version of the budget distributed next month.
The Real Property Committee asked staff to resear ch the possibility of reducing the line item for
“Miscellaneous and Contingency.”
Front Beach Public Restrooms and Area Maintenance
Water and sewer 14,000
Increased based on actual
Maintenance and service contracts 10,000
Increased based on actual
Beach Restoration Fund
Administrator Tucker stressed the fact that six hundred thousand dollars ($600,000) is included
in the budget for a potential focused erosion project in FY13, or possibly 2014, which has no
source of funding at this time. Based on information from the engineers, the City is at a point
where it must gather the stakeholders to begin assembling money for such a project.
Councilmember Carroll queried about the use of two point two million dollars ($2,200,000) of
unallocated tourism funds toward this project should the beach experience an expected
emergency shoal attachment; the Administrator confirmed his understanding.
Councilmember Ward asked who was included in the term “stakeholders;” Administrator Tucker
said that the stakeholders would vary based on where the project actually occurs, but,
considering where the shoal is attaching, they would be the members of the Wild Dunes
Community Association, the individual condominiums and homes that border the location where
the shoal attaches, and Wild Dunes resort.
The Administrator further clarified the project as one (1) with the goal of avoiding a repeat of the
situation the City experienced in 2007 when it had to choose between coming up with money
quickly or cleaning houses and condos off the beach.
As a point of information, the Mayor remarked that the Isle of Palms is one (1) of only a few
municipalities in Charleston County that collects only three percent (3%) in accommodations
taxes; Charleston County gets two percent (2%) and the City gets one percent (1%). The City
of Charleston and the City of North Charleston get four percent (4%); Hilton Head has
Ways and Means Committee
March 20, 2012
Page 15 of 16
established a Beach Preservation Fund getting two percent (2%) of their accommodations
taxes, and the county keeps nothing.
Marina Fund
Administrator Tucker recalled that the Committee had questioned legal fees associated with the
marina and were told that legal fees related to the marina and its tenants are paid from this line.
Councilmember Loftus reminded the Administrator that she was to clarify why advertising
appears under “General and Administrative” and “Marina Operation;” she responded that
advertising is a provision in the leases and would have the detail for the budget workshop.
Marina Operations
Insurance 77,753
Administrator Tucker explained that dock insurance is very expensive because it is a high-risk
item and, based on the value of the docks, the City is under-insured. The City is gradually
increasing the insured value.
Councilmember Stone asked whether the Administrator could provide the percentage of the
value that is insured; she indicated that she would have that for the Real Property Committee
meeting.
Having concluded the review of the operating budgets for FY13, Mayor Cronin set the Budget
Workshop as part of the April 17
th Ways and Means Committee meeting.
7. Miscellaneous Business
Upcoming Possible Lease Negotiations
Administrator Tucker reported that, at the Real Property Committee, a lengthy discussion took
place related to requests from the Marina Outpost and Marina Joint Ventures for consideration
of amending the lease agreements; the Committee will work with the City Attorney for the
changes. Both entities have suffered with the downturn in the economy; one (1) consideration
they are requesting is some financial relief. Other issues of less import to the City were also
identified; one (1) possibility is to have two (2) amendments – one that would address these
lower priority issues and a second addressing the financial aspects of the lease. The tenant has
assured the Committee that financial responsibilities incurred to this point will be honored.
The Administrator pointed out that, when the leases were written, the City wanted to ensure that
it would profit as profits at the marina improved , but the leases do not have provisions for the
opposite situation occurring.
The Administrator reminded the Committee that the City has worked with another tenant at the
marina for lease relief in the past; to renegotiate with this tenant would be consistent with
previous actions.
Ways and Means Committee
March 20, 2012
Page 16 of 16
Mayor Cronin urged the members of the Ways and Means Committee to read the minutes of the
Real Property Committee and to get copies of the leases in question. If anyone has questions
or concerns, he asked that they be directed to members of the Committee.
Next Meeting Date: 5:45 p.m., Tuesday, April 17, 2012
8. Executive Session to receive legal advice related to a potential claim arising out of City
lease agreement
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to go into Executive Session for the
reason stated at 7:50 p.m.; Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the motion
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
The Committee returned to regular session at 8:20 p.m., and Mayor Cronin announced that the
Committee had taken no action and no vote while in Executive Session.
9. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to adjourn at 8:21 p.m.;
Councilmember Buckhannon seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.