January 12 (PDF, 27.27 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE
3:00 p.m., Thursday, January 12, 2012
The regular meeting of the Public Safety Commi ttee was held at 3:00 p.m., Thursday, January
12, 2012 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf and Bettelli, Mayor Cronin,
Administrator Tucker, Chief Graham, Captain Caldwell, Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban,
City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Past Chair Bettelli called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and
public had been duly notified in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Election of Chair and Vice Chair
Councilmember Bergwerf nominated Councilmember Bettelli as Chair for 2012; Mayor Cronin
seconded and the vote was unanimous in support of Councilmember Bettelli.
Mayor Cronin nominated Councilmember Bergwerf as Vice Chair; Chair Bettelli seconded and
the vote was unanimous in support of Councilmember Bergwerf.
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to re-order the agenda to place Item 5B next
and Mayor Cronin moved to add an item to New Business, Modifications on the
Connector; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motions PASSED UNANI-
MOUSLY.
5.B. Old Business/Discussion of Amenities Offered at Connector Run
Administrator Tucker explained that discussion had taken place at a recent Connector Run
committee meeting and feedback from participants indicated that people were becoming bored
with the event, so the committee membership had suggested offering a beer garden at the end
of the event. Kristin Powers and Jeff Lansink were attending the meeting today to get a feel
from this committee about the possibilities of making the idea a reality. In the Administrator’s
opinion, areas of concern were competing with island businesses and the proximity of alcohol to
children that are participating; she did indicate that this type of activity is commonplace for this
type of event.
Mr. Lansink stated that the impetus for the beer garden is to increase the number of participants
in the event; participation has decreased by fifty per cent (50%) over the last four (4) years. He
indicated that many sponsors were eager to sign on, but their involvement is based on participa-
tion. According to Mr. Lansink, many runners parti cipate as a form of entertainment rather than
a competition; they come for the amenities or the celebration after the event and the beauty of
the course. Kristin Powers is the Director of Development for Windwood Farm Home for
Children and is on Race Board; she was brought on last year to determine the cause for the
steady decline when most regional races were ex periencing increases in participation. Ms.
Powers indicated that she has been talking with sponsors to determine what their needs are to
be included in the event, as well as a board member who has been talking with local businesses
about what they want to see from the event. For additional input, she has talked with
participants and with officials of other local events to determine what components are different;
those components varied from amenities, contest elements, cash prizes and a more exciting
celebration at the end of the event.
Public Safety Committee
January 12, 2012
Page 2 of 8
In the Strategic Plan developed by the board, the race wants to draw one thousand (1,000) par-
ticipants in 2012 and three thousand (3,000) participants in 2014. Local businesses were very
much on-board with increased visitors to the island.
Mr. Lansink related that they had spoken with the Windjammer about partnering in the event; a
beer garden will not interfere with their business since they do not open until the event is over.
The board member who spoke with the Acme Cantina and The Sea Biscuit Café related that
these businesses thought that more participants in the race would mean more traffic for their
restaurants.
In Mr. Lansink’s opinion, the fenced parking in the small City lot adjacent to the Public Safety
Building was a perfect location that lends itself to compliance with several of the rules and regu-
lations of serving alcohol.
Councilmember Bergwerf asked what the hours of the beer garden would be; Ms. Powers
responded that it would begin when the race is over, around 9 a.m. and run until 11 a.m.
Ms. Powers commented that, in addition to the fenced location, the race committee would install
“snow” fencing to camouflage the area where alcohol is served, and they would hire trained
servers to work behind the bar and a private secu rity firm to be responsible for identification
checks. The security firm would carry all of the insurance and liability.
Ms. Powers interprets the beer garden as bridging the gap between the race event and lunch,
making it more realistic that participants will go to island restaurants for a meal.
When asked by the Mayor who would be dispensing the beer, Ms. Powers said that tip-trained
volunteers would be brought in for that purpose. She anticipates having the beer donated, but
including the cost of the beer garden in the event registration fee.
Ms. Powers has experience with acquiring liquor licenses and explained the process to the
Public Safety Committee members. She related sitting before a committee detailing the security
for the event, the type of barriers being used, the number of restrooms, etc. Once this group is
comfortable with the plan, the application would be submitted to the state for the permit. The
race, as a 501(c)3 entity, will hold the permit, the board of the race would be liable and the
background checks will be done on all of the board members for the race. Ms. Powers stated
that, in the two (2) years she has been in Charleston, she has been responsible for some twelve
(12) events.
Mr. Lansink stated that the entertainment for the event will also be amped up to create more
excitement. Since this is the twentieth year of the Connector Run, the celebration should be
bigger.
Chair Bettelli noted that the City’s ordinances do not allow for the consumption of alcohol on
City property except the marina and Morgan Creek Grill.
Chief Graham stated that streets have been clos ed in the past to eliminate using City-owned
property.
Public Safety Committee
January 12, 2012
Page 3 of 8
Councilmember Bergwerf said that she would like to see the island’s bars and restaurants
drawn in as sponsors or hosts of the event. Mr. Lansink voiced concern that the Windjammer
was too far from the end of the race, but the Mayor envisioned their setting up a tent thereby
eliminating the need for participants to go to their location.
Ms. Powers indicated that, if the restaurants were going to participate, the race committee
needed to know sooner rather than later. With the goal of increasing participation, an eight (8)
month advertising campaign was planned, and they needed to know what they were marketing.
Mayor Cronin endorsed holding the after-race beer garden on J.C. Long Boulevard as long as
local businesses were involved and is much easier for the City. For licensing purposes, Ms.
Powers stated that official barricades would have to be created on J.C. Long with “snow
fencing.”
Councilmember Bergwerf thought that the local businesses would be “thrilled” to participate
since the event is October 6
th.
Ms. Powers summarized the report to the race board as the beer garden has been approved for
J.C. Long Boulevard; Councilmember Bergwerf stated that the approval was based on the
involvement of the island’s businesses.
3. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Bergwerf moved to approve the minutes of the
regular meeting of November 10, 2011 as submitted; Chair Bettelli seconded and
the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
4. Citizens’ Comments – None
5. Old Business
A. Report on Status of Mutual Aid Agreements between IOP and Sullivan’s Island
and Mount Pleasant
Captain Caldwell reported that the rewritten versions had been forwarded to Sullivan’s Island
and Mount Pleasant to go before their Public Safety Committees and Councils.
B. Discussed earlier
C. Discussion of Changes to the Rental Placard for 911 Calls
Chair Bettelli stated that this discussion centers on the placard that must be displayed in short-
term rental properties and the prominence of the property’s address. Chief Graham related a
tragic event that prompted this request where a visitor to the island had an emergency and was
unable to provide the 911 operator with the address. The Committee agreed to an administra-
tive change to enlarge the print for the address and to print in a contrasting color to draw the
renter’s attention. A copy of the existing placard is attached to the meeting minutes.
Public Safety Committee
January 12, 2012
Page 4 of 8
The discussion transitioned to how many residenc es on the island do not have house numbers
or numbers on mailboxes and how many of the markers on the beach have been buried by the
changing coastline or are not visible from the beach. Mayor Cronin suggested a campaign in
the spring to get numbers of houses; Chief Graham reported that the Fire Department personnel
are tasked every spring to ensure that the street markers are in place on the beach. An alert to
residents about house numbers could be included in the City’s website, the Wild Dunes
Community Association newsletter, the rental company newletters and on water bills.
The Committee agreed to keep this subject on the agenda for the near future.
D. Award of Contracts in Excess of $10,000 – None
6. New Business
Modifications on the Connector
Administrator Tucker explained that the City had alerted Charleston County and the biking com-
munity that the addition of barrier between the walking and biking public, similar to that of the
Ravenel Bridge, would be a good change. Councilman Schweers agreed that it was a
worthwhile project and pushed for County funding for a study; the results of that study were
presented in a meeting the previous afternoon with Mayor Cronin, Captain Caldwell,
Councilman Schweers, Curt Taylor, Charleston County Deputy Administrator, Jim Armstrong of
the Charleston County Transportation Sales Tax and CTC Programs and Administrator Tucker.
The study generated three (3) alternatives and t hey are depicted on the drawings that have
been distributed. (A set of illustrations are attached to the historical record of this meeting.)
Alternate 1 – This is the option that has the solid barrier which the City staff prefers on
the Breach Inlet side. To accomplish this walking/bike path, the bridge is reconfigured with two
twelve (12) foot vehicle lanes, a seven (7) foot center lane and a ten (10) foot breakdown lane
on the marina side of the Connector. A study to determine whether the bridge could support the
additional weight has not been done. The Administrator reported that to designate an area for
bike and pedestrian traffic requires that the outside rail be raised. The construction cost for this
option is $3,476,153.15
Alternate 2 – In this alternate, each side has a five (5) foot shoulder, a four (4) foot bike
lane, three (3) foot buffer, twelve (12) foot vehicular lanes and a six (6) foot center lane.
Naming the five (5) foot lanes as shoulders, rather than pedestrian paths, eliminates the require-
ment for raised side rails. The group considered this option affordable and do-able; the cost of
this option is $150,424.88. The problem with this alternate is that the bike path ends beside
Public Works, and bikers would have to share the road as they do now. At this point, the Mayor
questioned that the City could afford this project in terms of both real estate and money.
Alternate 3 – This illustration shows eight (8) foot multi-use paths on each side of the
bridge, five (5) foot breakdown lanes, twelve (12) foot vehicular lanes and a four (4) foot center
lane. This option requires the raised side rails. To have the multi-use path on one (1) side of
the bridge would cost $2,229,497.81; to have the multi-use path on both sides of the bridge
would cost $4,220,492.81.
Public Safety Committee
January 12, 2012
Page 5 of 8
Further modifications to the Connector have not been discussed previously in this Committee,
by City Council or with the community. The question is does this Committee want to pursue any
of the alternates presented.
Chair Bettelli asked whether the existence of a designated bike lane mean that bikers are
required to be in that lane. Captain Caldwell responded that use of the lane is not required by
state law.
Mayor Cronin commented that more bikers and pedestrians will want to traverse the Connector;
a designated bike lane keeps the walkers out of the way, but also tells the walkers to stay in the
shoulder.
Administrator Tucker noted that the tragedy on the James Island Connector was discussed at
the alternates meeting and it is being closed to bikers and pedestrians. Since the James Island
Connector is considered a limited access intersta te highway, those restrictions can be imposed;
the IOP Connector has a different designation that allows for bikers and walkers. The Mayor
indicated that the IOP Connector was constructed with the wide shoulders to accommodate
bikers.
Another topic that seemed to surprise the County attendees is that the speed limit on the
Connector is fifty-five (55) miles per hour; it wa s agreed that bikers and pedestrians would feel
safer if the speed limit were to be lowered.
Referencing Alternate 2, Chief Graham asked if the five (5) foot shoulder was a minimum width;
she expressed concern in having a center lane less than ten (10) feet wide. She noted that
sometimes the center lane is the only way an emergency vehicle can get through, and, if the
shoulder could be reduced to three (3) feet on each side, the center lane could be kept at ten
(10) feet.
Administrator Tucker recalled that a regulation about the width of the shoulder determines
whether the increased height of the rail is required; the regulation concerns the width of the
buffer between the bikers and the bridge rail. The shoulder would not be designated, but its
purpose would be a walking lane. According to the Administrator, the lanes would be delineated
by a surface referred to as “profile thermo,” which produces a rumbling noise to a driver when
passed over.
Captain Caldwell related that, if the shoulder were to be designated as a pedestrian walking
area, the rail must be raised and Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) guidelines must also be
followed.
Captain Caldwell confirmed Chair Bettelli’s statement that a new addition to state law will not
allow a bike path on one (1) side only.
Mayor Cronin indicated agreement that maintaining the ten (10) foot center lane was more
important than getting the correct widths on the biking or pedestrian paths/shoulder.
Public Safety Committee
January 12, 2012
Page 6 of 8
Summarizing the discussion, Administrator Tucker stated that, if the ten (10) foot center lane
could not be maintained and the side rails had to be heightened, the City was not interested in
modifying the Connector. The Administrator assured the Committee that she would get a
resolution to those two (2) concerns.
The discussion continued with problems associat ed with bikers being dumped into vehicular
traffic as they leave the Connector and travel towa rd the intersection with Palm Boulevard.
Mayor Cronin suggested a turn into Memory Park so that bikers could avoid the intersection
completely. For bikers going onto the Connector, the state would need to build a bike path;
Administrator Tucker said she had been led to believe that the right-of-way is very narrow
accessing the Connector.
Mayor Cronin remarked that he had related the fact at the meeting with County representatives
that, last year, the City responded to twenty-five (25) accidents on the Connector and one
hundred nine- teen (119) traffic stops with tickets being issued.
Chair Bettelli recommended delaying any further discussion until the Administrator has gotten
the answers to the questions the Committee posed.
7. Highlights of Departmental Reports
Fire Department – Chief Graham
November 2011 – During the months, the Department responded to several potentially serious
fires; in each case, the incidents were quickly controlled by the resident or crew. Personnel
responded to forty-three (43) total calls, twenty-seven (27) of which were EMS calls. A total of
twelve (12) fire inspections were performed, and no violations were found to exist. Primary
expenses for vehicle maintenance were a starter replacement and rear brakes replacement.
The new radio tower on 41
st Avenue was placed in service in November, personnel immediately
noticed improved coverage. Chief Graham foreshadowed an increase in the radio user fee to
thirty-eight dollars ($38) per month in January 2013.
December 2011 – During the month, personnel res ponded to forty-one (41) calls; twenty-five
(25) were EMS calls. The Fire Department responded to nine hundred seventy-seven (977)
total calls in 2011, which is up nine (9) from 2010. Five (5) fire inspections were performed in
December, and one (1) violation was found. The most significant vehicle maintenance expense
was the replacement of the on-board battery charger to the 1999 rescue truck.
Chair Bettelli asked that the percentage of budget expended to-date for vehicle maintenance
report be added to future reports; the Chief indicated that the Department is saving on fuel and
staff hours by having repairs made by a certified technician on-island.
Police Department – Captain Caldwell
November 2011 – Captain Caldwell reported on an incident of November 29
th that led to
locating a quantity of handguns with live ammunition and other items of suspicion; the City noti-
fied the local Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms (ATF) office to assist with determining the legality
Public Safety Committee
January 12, 2012
Page 7 of 8
of the seized weapons. A coordination of efforts between the IOP Police Department, ATF
Charleston, the West Virginia State Patrol, ATF West Virginia and federal prosecutors resulted
in the subject being extradited to West Virginia for federal prosecution.
Mayor Cronin asked why the person would have been on the island; Captain Caldwell indicated
that he had said he was here to recruit, and the wife had a homemade badge similar by those
worn be members of the “sovereign citizen” movement. This group is reported to have been
involved in the bombing of the federal building in Oklahoma City.
Continuing with the report, dispatchers answered thirty-four hundred eleven (3,411) calls in the
month; twenty-seven hundred eighty-seven (2,787) were for the Police Department. Officers
made three hundred four (304) traffic stops and issued ninety-seven (97) tickets. During the
month, thirteen (13) noise complaints were filed with one (1) citation being issued.
December 2011 – Dispatchers responded to thir ty-four hundred twenty-seven (3,427) calls;
twenty-seven hundred seventy-five (2,775) were for the Police Department. Three hundred two
(302) traffic stops yielded seventy-nine (79) tickets.
Mayor Cronin referred to page 9 and noted that arrests in 2011 were just shy of four hundred
(400), but, in 2010, arrests totaled four hundred seventy-eight (478). He reported going back
several years and noted that arrests were down si gnificantly – in one (1) year, arrests exceeded
six hundred (600). He questioned whether, statistically, offenses were being accounted for in
the same manner as six or eight (6 or 8) ago; Captain Caldwell said there had been no change.
Chair Bettelli queried whether the island’s trend reflected a national trend, and the Captain
responded that crimes against persons were down nationally, but property crimes remain
relatively steady with some spikes based on the state of the economy. The Captain explained
that the City has more community service in pl ace, as well as crime prevention programs, and
City has established a reputation as having zero-tolerance for underage possession of alcohol.
Councilmember Bergwerf asked whether a call initiated under one (1) classification (noise), but
the results in another classification (underage dr inking), is listed under both classifications or
only the resulting problem. Captain Caldwell replied that the call is listed in both categories.
8. Executive Session – not needed
9. Miscellaneous Business
Chief Graham commented that, in the wake of Fire Inspector Anderson’s resignation, she had
reviewed the job description for the position and found that a class indicated as a requirement
has been replaced by another. She asked whether the correction could be administrative or the
corrected job description had to be approved by this Committee then Personnel; the consensus
of the Committee was for an administrative correction.
Next Meeting Date: 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, February 7, 2012.
Chair Bettelli reminded the Committee of the MS Challenge Walk on Sunday, March 4.
Public Safety Committee
January 12, 2012
Page 8 of 8
10. Adjourn
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to adjourn the meeting at 4:47 p.m.;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.