February 7 (PDF, 30.71 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE
5:00 p.m., Tuesday, February 7, 2012
The regular meeting of the Public Safety Committee was held at 5:00 p.m. on Tuesday,
February 7, 2012 in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmember Bergwerf, Mayor Cronin and Chair
Bettelli, Administrator Tucker, Fire Chief Graham, Police Chief Buckhannon, Assistant to the
Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland; quorum was present to conduct business.
Invited guests were Richard Turner of Charleston County and Jeff Lansik representing the
Connector Run.
1. Chair Bettelli called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
were duly notified in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to approve the minutes of the regular meeting
of January 12, 2012 as submitted; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Old Business
A. Status of Improvements to the Rental Placard for 911 Calls
Administrator Tucker reported that staff has been reviewing various designs for the placard;
Chief Graham feels that one (1) with the address in a color will meet the need described at the
previous meeting. The Administrator added that the placard is not a WORD document, but a
document that merges files; therefore, the staff does not have much flexibility in the design.
B. Update on Improvements to the IOP Connector
Richard Turner with Charleston County Transportation Development was present to answer
questions Committee members may have related to the proposed bike/pedestrian path on the
IOP Connector. Administrator Tucker repeated the Committee’s concerns relative to main-
taining a ten (10) foot wide center lane for emergency and to eliminating the need to raise the
height of the side railings.
Mr. Turner related that the standards established by the American Association of State Highway
and Transportation Officials (AASHTO) state that to have a multi-use path adjacent to a travel
lane, there must be either a forty-two (42) inch barrier between the travel lane and the multi-use
lane or five (5) foot buffer. Administrator Tucker noted that the side railings on the Connector
are at thirty-two (32) inches for the full length of the bridge. Mr. Turner had two (2) suggestions
to maintain the ten (10) foot center lane; they are to have a two (2) foot buffer and eight (8) foot
shoulder that would not be dedicated as a bike lane or to have a five (5) foot shoulder, four (4)
foot bike path and one (1) foot buffer. Administrator Tucker noted that neither of these two (2)
options has gotten SC DOT approval.
Mayor Cronin indicated that either option could be attained by striping the Connector.
Public Safety Committee
February 7, 2012
Page 2 of 9
Mr. Turner stated that the railing would have to be a minimum of forty-two (42) inches in height if
the shoulder was to be less than five (5) feet wide for the safety of bikers.
Chair Bettelli asked about the width of the bike path on the Ben Sawyer Bridge; Mr. Turner said
it was four (4) feet wide.
The Administrator reported that discussions had taken place at the Real Property Committee
meeting the previous evening relative to a bike path from Breach Inlet to 57
th Avenue and that,
in the Committee’s opinion, it made more sense to improve the bike paths on either side of the
roadway for the length of the island than to impr ove the Connector with the addition of as bike
lane. Additionally, Administrator Tucker expr essed doubt that the City had enough right-of-way
from Breach Inlet to 57
th Avenue for regulation bike paths and that to have bike lanes the full
length of Palm would certainly impact parking for day visitors to the island. She explained that
regulation bike paths are extensions of the road, and Mr. Turner said that regulation bike paths
must be four (4) feet wide.
Mayor Cronin brought out one of the visuals of the traffic and people congestion along Palm
Boulevard in the summer and asked members to visualize the addition of bikers to the mix. He
confirmed that the City has ample right-of-way from 21
st to 41 st Avenues; from 41 st Avenue to
57th Avenues, the pedestrian walk would have to be moved inland and the palm trees in the
right-of-way would have to be removed or relocated.
Councilmember Bergwerf asked where the money would come from if the City decided to
pursue an improvement to the Connector, and Administrator Tucker responded that the
question did not have a good answer at this time. The Administrator repeated a statement
made to Mr. Turner earlier in the day that this subject has “taken on a life of its own;” in
actuality, the City and Charleston County are still in fact-finding mode.
Pursuant to discussions, the Administrator asked the Committee whether they wanted to her to
proceed if the center lane remains ten (10) feet wide and height of the railing does not increase;
the consensus was to move forward.
Mr. Turner reported that Charleston County will be re-surfacing Palm Boulevard from 41
st to 57th
Avenues; the contract will be signed within the month. He indicated that the County is commit-
ted to improvements, such as shoulder widening, when re-surfacing takes place. He fell short of
committing to the construction of a bike path, but said he would look into the possibility.
Mr. Turner also stated that the DOT requirement for a sidewalk next to a road is that a five (5)
foot offset exist from the travel-way or from the edge of the painted line.
According to Mr. Turner, whenever a resurfacing plan is developed, the staff is charged with
what type of improvements can be accomplished at the same time to improve safety.
When asked whether the pavement could be a continuation of road, Mr. Turner indicated that
the City could face issues related to the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) in that there
would not be a change in the texture of the surface to serve as a detectable warning surface.
Public Safety Committee
February 7, 2012
Page 3 of 9
C. Update on Connector Run
Mr. Lansik reported that dialogues had taken place with both Acme Cantina and The Sea Biscuit
before the Connector Run staff learned that the City would be willing to close J.C. Long
Boulevard for a couple of hours after the run for celebration. Mr. Lansik related that their staff is
working with island businesses on the logistics to determine the best way to work together.
Mayor Cronin asked if they had determined how they would distribute the beer; Mr. Lansik
stated that whatever business has access to the cheapest beer to allow the most money to go
to the cause of child abuse prevention.
Mr. Lansik noted that the Cooper River Bridge Run will be the end of March, and they want to
have their promotional information available to draw as many of those participants back to the
area for the Connector Run.
Administrator Tucker remarked that, although Island Time does not sell food, they should not be
left out of the discussions because they will be seriously impacted by the road closing.
Mr. Lansik expects to have more to report at the March meeting.
5. New Business
A. Discussion of Annual Transportation Sales Tax Funding and CTC Requests
Administrator Tucker noted that this request come s to the City every year; this Committee,
along with the Public Works Committee, compiles a prioritized list of three (3) projects that meet
the funding requirements. The Administrator reminded the Committee that the County had been
very generous with funding over several years that has provided for the completion of the 53
rd to
57th Avenue Drainage Project, as well as funding for the Waterway Boulevard bike path, the 41 st
Avenue and 13 th and 14 th Avenue intersection studies, bike path improvements, 21 st and 34 th
Avenue re-surfacing and the Lauden and Sparrow drainage projects. (On side note, the
Administrator reported that the City has a new funding source, i.e. NPDES funds.)
Re-surfacing should not be a consideration because the only projects that would be considered
are roads that are currently dirt roads; the type s of projects that are considered are bike paths,
drainage and new surfaces. Last year the City submitted the engineering for the 44
th to 52 nd
Avenue Drainage, surfacing of Cassina Avenue and a multi-use path from 41 st to 57 th Avenue.
In addition, the Administrator informed the Committee that Cassina will not be paved, but will
rceive a new surface of some type of rock that will not produce the white residue that gets onto
Palm Boulevard. In 2011 the City’s top priority did not receive any funding.
Administrator Tucker announced that the engineering/design for 42
nd to 52 nd Avenue drainage
will come before Ways and Means and City Council in February; the sole source contract to
Civil Site Environmental (CSE) is for one hundred sixty-nine thousand dollars ($169,000)
spanning two (2) fiscal years and carries the project through construction oversight.
Public Safety Committee
February 7, 2012
Page 4 of 9
Mayor Cronin proposed that the next phase of drainage be the top priority for 2012; he noted
that it had taken several years to accumulate the funds to accomplish the 53
rd to 57 th Avenue
project.
Mr. Turner explained that ten and a half million dollars ($10,500,000) is made available to
distribute through Transportation Sales Taxes (TST) each year to fund projects for local paving
of dirt to asphalt roads, drainage improvements, intersection improvements, bike and pedestrian
facilities, as well as public works improvements and resurfacing. Specific amounts of money
are allocated to each area with four million dollars ($4,000,000) for resurfacing.
Administrator Tucker said she understood that a ranking system had been established for
awarding funding for projects and inquired if ther e was anything a local government could do to
improve a project’s ranking. Mr. Turner said he was not involved in the objective criteria, but the
price tag for the project was one aspect of the objective criteria.
For a priority two project, Mayor Cronin suggest ed an improvement to the bike path coming off
the Connector to the Palm Boulevard intersection. Chair Bettelli explained to Mr. Turner that the
bike path ends as cyclists leave the Connecto r and they are sharing the road with vehicular
traffic. Mr. Turner thought a multi-use path similar to the one on the other side on the Connector
that would tie into the sidewalk might be a good solution. The Mayor stated that the City did not
know how much money to request because this was the first time the subject had been
broached; therefore the Mayor inquired about a proposal for the engineering on a multi-use
path. Mr. Turner said that the City could request that Charleston County do the engineering; he
indicated that they would look at the project and determine a cost that would include
engineering and construction.
By way of clarification, Administrator Tucker repeated that, as the second priority, the request
would be for a multi-use path from the foot of the bridge to Palm Boulevard, and the City would
be willing for its property to be used.
B. Review of FY13 Capital Budget and Long-range Capital Plans for the Fire and
Police Departments
Based on an assignment given at Ways and Means, staff has segregated expenses relative to
consolidated dispatch as part of the budgeting process. Other than the new budget, the
majority of the items on these two (2) budgets are roll-forwards from prior years.
Fire Department
The Administrator pointed out that two (2) capital leases for the fire trucks would be paid off in
FY13. Of the recurring purchases for air packs and cylinders, bunker gear, and fire hose and
appliances, the cost for bunker gear has increased.
Responding to Mayor Cronin’s question about the decrease to air packs expense in FY16, Chief
Graham explained that the old air packs are being replaced in quantities of four (4), and she
does not anticipate having to replace four (4) air packs each year once all of the old ones have
been replaced.
Public Safety Committee
February 7, 2012
Page 5 of 9
The mobile repeaters are a re-budget item; the Chief added that the number of repeaters has
been reduced from three to two (3 to 2) due to the new radio system. The reason the repeaters
have not been purchased is a hold up in the FCC license, which is not yet available.
The FY13 purchase of safety harnesses will provi de a harness for every member of the Depart-
ment.
A new item for the budget is the Porta-count machine for SCBA mask fit testing; Chief Graham
explained that face masks are required to be air tight, and this piece of equipment will ensure
that the City meets the OSHA requirements. In response to the Mayor’s question about a less
expensive tester, Chief Graham said that she would defer another item in order to get this
equipment. As to the frequency of use, the Chief explained that the masks must be tested
within ten (10) days of hiring a new firefighter, as well as annually for all personnel.
The jet ski to be replaced has been in service for three (3), going on four (4) years. The Chief
reported that experience has taught her that the jet skis are not reliable after four (4) years.
The truck being replaced will cause a “shuffle down” in fleet vehicles that will results in the
removal of a 2001 truck with very high mileage.
The items listed under Facility Maintenance will ultimately be in the Operating Budget, but
appear here due to the dollar amounts. These items are included each year.
Chief Graham pointed out that replacing the stair chair and the RAD-57 meter were deferred to
FY14.
Administrator Tucker foreshadowed that, at the Ways and Means Committee meeting, she and
the Treasurer would be proposing that the threshold for capital items be raised to two thousand
dollars ($2,000) from one thousand dollars ($1,000). Such an action would simplify record
keeping for the Treasurer.
Police Department
Like the Fire Department, the majority of items have come about as part of the regular rotation
of capital items.
The replacement of the VHS in-car camera systems will be complete with the purchases in
FY13 of digital cameras.
Two (2) new items have been added to the Police budget; they are portable drivers’ license
scanners for integration with the court syst em and the equipment to enable the automatic
upload of patrol videos. In budgeting last year, the replacement of the court software was
included for sixteen thousand dollars ($16,000). The seventy-five hundred dollars ($7,500)
included here is the DL scanners of the court software expense to make the system whole. The
automatic upload of patrol videos makes for less handling of the videos of traffic stops; the
officers can drive into the police garage, and the server will wirelessly upload the
Public Safety Committee
February 7, 2012
Page 6 of 9
videos from the digital in-car cameras. The Chief assured the Mayor that the information would
be admissible in court.
Mayor Cronin questioned the purchase of six (6) patrol vehicles in one (1) year with no pur-
chases the following year and inquired about a way to level out the expense. Chief Buckhannon
explained that, in 2007, the Department had a dded two (2) new positions and the Livability
officer thereby adding three (3) vehicles to the normal rotation of three (3). Chief Buckhannon
also called the Committee’s attention to replacem ent of four wheel drive vehicles that are
scheduled for replacement next year
When asked about the mileage of the vehicles, the Chief reported that one (1) has more than
one hundred twenty thousand (120,000) miles, one has more than one hundred ten thousand
(110,000) miles and the remaining four (4) have more than ninety thousand (90,000) miles on
them.
The Administrator said that staff would study the budget to determine if they could find a way to
level out expenditures.
Mayor Cronin then asked pointed to the replacement of radios in FY16 and FY17 for nearly
seven hundred fifty thousand dollars ($750,000). Chief Graham explained that the replace-
ments were in anticipation of Phase 2 compliance relative to narrow banding and FCC in 2017.
The Mayor expressed the opinion that the City should begin to set aside money for an obligation
of that dollar amount. Administrator Tucker remarked that this radio replacement was not a
requirement of Charleston County, but of the FCC. Chief Graham commented that the City may
need to reduce the number of radios due to the cost of the radios themselves and the increased
monthly fees to Charleston County which may be as much as fifty dollars ($50.00) per month.
Consolidated Dispatch
Administrator Tucker explained that the purpose for this budget was to put forth the types of
expenses the City will have as it prepares for and moves to consolidated dispatch; certain items
have been taken from the capital budgets and placed here to segregate transition expenses.
Since the vehicle computers being purchased in FY13 are part of a grant that Charleston
County got; when they are replaced in FY17, there may not be a grant. For that reason, staff
believes that the replacement cost will be closer to forty-five thousand dollars ($45,000) than to
the twenty thousand dollars ($20,000) indicated in FY13.
Since the City is probably eighteen (18) months away from the actual move to consolidate
dispatch, these numbers are preliminary. Administrator Tucker stated that a retreat is being
planned for the Consolidated Dispatch Board, of which Chief Buckhannon is a member, plus
other members of the public safety community who will be impacted. The City anticipates
getting more concrete information from that retreat.
Chief Graham noted that the eight (8) vehicle computers in FY13 are a re-budget from FY12.
These computers will have pre-plans, a mapping capability, pre-incident surveys, hydrant
Public Safety Committee
February 7, 2012
Page 7 of 9
locations, etc. Chief Graham realized that the computers will require air cards for internet
access which will be additional monthly expense.
Other items included in the consolidated dispatch budget are a station alerting system man-
dated by Charleston County, increased software expense for the software the City now uses,
the re-numbering of helmets and vehicles, and a centralized accountability system, which keeps
track of who is where in an event.
In generating this budget, the Administrator contacted Folly Beach to learn exactly what had
happened to cause them to back out of consolidated dispatch; contact was made to ensure that
the City’s transition to consolidated dispatch was successful by learning from another’s
mistakes. The fact that they did not maintain a presence in their old dispatch center and some-
one monitoring that phone line was unfortunate for them; residents are accustomed to a certain
level of local non-emergency service. Administrator Tucker, therefore, was proposing that, in
the transition period and for one (1) full beach season, the City maintain the expense of staffing
around-the-clock, twenty-four seven (24/7), the dispatch center to monitor what is going on at
the County level and intervene if and when a call goes awry.
Answering Councilmember Bergwerf’s question, Administrator Tucker stated that Charleston
County has scheduled the Isle of Palms to join consolidated dispatch on July 1, 2013. Both
Chief Buckhannon and Chief Graham agree that to join in the middle of a beach season would
be a big mistake, so the City is proposing a move after the beach season.
Another issue that plagued Folly Beach was resident education. The Administrator envisions a
piece of educational literature being mailed to every residence in the City explaining what is
going to happen, what the differences are going to be and the changes residents can expect.
In addition, there will be on-going charges for software and information upgrades that will be
made at the County level; the Dispatch B oard is having discussions about information
mechanisms that need to be part of the county system that are not now part of it. Chief
Buckhannon stated that the records management component is in the City’s budget now; the
City pays for a product called Interpol that is used for report writing and dispatching. Ultimately
all participants in consolidated dispatch may have the same records management system.
Chief Graham indicated that the East Cooper public safety officials are wanting to transition to
consolidated dispatch as a group.
When the Mayor asked how calls to the livability line would be handled, Chief Buckhannon said
there would be no difference, i.e. when a call comes in on that line and the livability officer is not
on duty, it automatically rings into dispatch after the third ring. Administrator Tucker said that
this was the type of call that makes maintaining a staff presence on the island during the transi-
tion important.
On the subject of public education, Chief Buckhannon reported that the dispatch center has
produced video tapes and pamphlets that explain the process when a call is made to the center;
they explain that the call initially is responded to by a call-taker who then transfers it to a
dispatcher who is sending an officer to the scene while the caller continues to answer questions.
Public Safety Committee
February 7, 2012
Page 8 of 9
Citizens need to understand that someone is coming to their aid while the dispatcher continues
to gather information.
Chief Buckhannon commented that Charleston County will over-hire before the City’s
dispatchers move to the call center; therefore, if the City decides to maintain its dispatch center,
employees will be in a position to stay on the island. The Mayor countered that he did not want
to be responsible for that dispatcher not having a position at the County in a couple of years
when the City finds that it no longer needs an island presence.
C. Prioritization of Projects in Excess of $250,000
Administrator Tucker noted that this list was last reviewed two (2) years ago; she believes it to
be a good exercise to help the staff understand what t he policy-setting body’s priorities are. No
decisions are expected at this meeting, but the Committee will be asked at the March meeting to
generate a list of its top five (5) projects. Once staff has the priority list from each Committee,
they will be compiled into a single priority list for the Ways and Means Committee meeting. The
last is different from its last review; additions have been made based on input from department
managers and a couple of items that had been removed have been added back for
consideration by this seated Council, for example the 41
st Avenue roundabout and the
beachfront outpost.
D. Consideration of Contracts in excess of $10,000 – None
6. Highlights of Departmental Reports
Fire Department
For the month of January, Chief Graham reported that personnel had responded to thirty-five
(35) calls, twenty (20) of which were EMS calls. One full-time firefighter has been hired; he is a
recent graduate of the Fire Academy which he attended at his own expense. The Chief will be
interviewing three (3) candidates for the Fire Inspector position on Wednesday; she informed
the Committee that she expects to have the position filled in four to six (4-6) weeks.
Police Department
Chief Buckhannon reported that one (1) incident of a fraudulent vacation rental occurred in
January; he anticipates the problem to get worse as the season nears. Officers investigating a
couple of burglaries at the Sea Cabins were able to develop a suspect and charged someone;
some of the property was recovered and some was found to be damaged. For the month,
dispatchers responded to thirty-seven hundred fifty -eight (3,758) calls, and thirty-one hundred
twenty (3,120) were for the Police Department. Ninety-seven (97) citations were written from
the three hundred fifteen (315) traffic stops. The two (2) officers that completed the academy in
November should be released from field training next week; interviews are beginning to fill the
one (1) vacancy in the department. In January, five (5) noise complaints were made, and one
(1) citation was written.
7. Executive Session – not needed
Public Safety Committee
February 7, 2012
Page 9 of 9
8. Miscellaneous Business
Chair Bettelli reminded the Committee that the MS Challenge Walk will be Sunday, March 4.
The next meeting was scheduled for 5 p.m., Thursday, March 15 in the Conference Room.
9. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Bergwerf moved to adjourn the meeting at 6:43
p.m.; Mayor Cronin seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.