March 15 (PDF, 26.52 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE
5:00 p.m., Thursday, March 15, 2012
The regular meeting of the Public Safety Committee was held at 5:00 p.m., Thursday, March 15,
2012 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmember Bergwerf, Mayor Cronin and Chair Bettelli, City
Administrator Tucker, Fire Chief Graham, Police Chief Buckhannon, Assistant to the
Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland. A quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Chair Bettelli called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
were duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to approve the minutes of the regular meeting
of February 7, 2012 as submitted; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Old Business
A. Update on Connector Run – deferred awaiting Connector Run representative
B. Prioritization of Projects in Excess of $250,000
After each Committee presented his/her priority list, the Committee discussed the merits of each
item and agreed upon the following:
1. Drainage Project at 42
nd -52nd Avenue
2. Disaster Recovery Fund Increase
3. Recreation Ball-field – lighting only
4. Dune Walkover Additions/Replacements
5. Island-wide Beach Access Parking Management System
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to approve the list as stated; Councilmember
Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
A. Update on Connector Run
Kristin Powers, representing the Connector Run, joined the Committee for a progress report on
preparations. Since the last meeting, representatives have met with the Front Beach
businesses impacted by the race and the road closure to discuss how to make the event better
for them and their expectations. The majority of the businesses were excited about the added
celebration post-race, anticipating more people in attendance and staying in the vicinity longer.
The businesses included in the discussions were the Acme Cantina, Banana Cabana, Ben &
Jerry’s, Coconut Joe’s, Huck’s, Luke ‘n Ollie’s, The Sea Biscuit, The Windjammer, Mingo’s, the
Island Mermaid and Splash; each business was offered a free vendor/sponsor space for the
event to sell their food or merchandise. Off-island vendors will be charged a sponsorship fee for
space.
Public Safety Committee
March 15, 2012
Page 2 of 8
The Sea Biscuit expressed concern about the road closure and its effect on access to their
parking lot; the plan was revised to prevent the road closure from blocking access to their lot.
The Connector Committee wanted permission to set up the stage for the band in front of the
Public Safety Building because they think is will create a great appearance. They will place the
snow barricade to prevent any alcohol from being consumed on City property.
The Connector Committee will be purchasing the alcohol from and use the liquor license of the
Acme Cantina, who will also serve. Ms. Powers asked if there would be issues with people
being on the road with alcohol in-hand, assuming the use of the snow fence and barricades.
The Administrator reported that the City has had events in the past where adult beverages were
served, and, as long as there were no incidents and no alcoholic beverages were carried from
the enclosed area, the City did not issue any tickets. Ms. Powers said that their plan was to bar-
ricade the property on which the event is taking place so that people are funneled to one (1) exit
with a checkpoint where there would be trash receptacles and signs indicating that say “NO
ALCOHOL BEYOND THIS POINT.”
Chief Buckhannon noted that the situation in the past was held on a City-owned road, and this
event is on a state-owned road. Administrator Tucker remarked that the event had been
granted the road closure from DOT, and she did not remember there being any stipulations.
Ms. Powers stated that the organizers were more than willing to hire a private security firm to
monitor the exits and check identifications. Chief Buckhannon indicated that it was the respon-
sibility of the alcohol servers to ensure that t he people they serve alcohol to are of legal age.
Persons who are outside of the confined area of the event and who are in possession of alcohol
will be ticketed.
The marketing efforts are going to be ramped up more than what has happened in the past, and
the Isle of Palms will be featured in all of it. Copies of all advertising will be sent to the City to
ensure that the City is satisfied with its content.
Administrator Tucker asked about the sound amplification at the stage; Ms. Powers explained
that they typically use two (2) speakers, one (1) on either side of the stage. Ms. Powers said
that she would check the City’s noise ordinance to make sure that they stay within acceptable
ranges. Ms. Powers offered to send letters to surrounding residents offering them free tickets to
the event; the Administrator agreed that notification was always helpful.
As to a source of power, Ms. Powers said they could bring in a generator.
Chief Buckhannon asked if they had considered setting up the band in the parking lot of the
CPA’s office, next to the Sea Biscuit, closer to the vendors and beer sales; if they did that, the
noise would be pointed toward the beach and some of the sound would be absorbed by the
vendors, lessening the possibility that people would complain about the noise and people would
be in a more confined area. Ms. Powers explained that they had decided against that layout
because the owners of the Sea Biscuit wanted the business from the event, but did not want to
be caught up in the frenzy of it.
Public Safety Committee
March 15, 2012
Page 3 of 8
Responding to Mayor Cronin’s inquiry, Ms. Powers said the band would be performing until
around 10:30 a.m.; the Connector Committee wants to be winding down by 11:00 a.m. to be
gone by noon.
Ms. Powers indicated that they are hoping to have one thousand (1,000) participants in the
Connector Run; plans are in the works to coordinate with island realtors to offer specials for
rentals encouraging runners to stay on the island and make the event a destination run.
5. New Business
A. Discussion of Charges to Committee from Joint Meeting
1. Line of Sight Clearance at Intersections
Chair Bettelli referred to the new “NO PARKIN G HERE TO CORNER” signs that have been
installed along Palm Boulevard; he said he thought that they were a great first step toward
making the island safer.
The Chair asked if there was a way to make the exit from the shopping area on the ocean-side
of Palm at 14
th Avenue a “right turn only;” he told the Committee of seeing drivers exiting the lot
and crossing four (4) lanes of traffic to gain access to the Connector. Administrator Tucker said
that the City had corresponded with the owner of the shopping center in the past with that
request, but would do so again.
Another safety concern from the Chair was the height of the shrubs as one exits left from the
Red & White parking lot. Chief Buckhannon said that the shrubbery had been brought to the
owner’s attention in the past as well; Mayor Cronin suggested opening up a dialogue again.
Mayor Cronin reported seeing the white chalk lines drawn on both side of Palm Boulevard. Chief
Graham pointed out that in areas where a fire hydrant is in the middle of a block, the chalk lines
goes right up to the hydrant rather than ending at the required distance from the hydrant. As it
is, someone would park there, be ticketed and argue that they were just following the implied
parking area defined by the white line. Chief Buckhannon said he had spoken to Director Page
about the hydrants and the parking limitations.
When the Mayor suggested that the City re-locate some of the signs, Chief Buckhannon stated
that the Highway Department had not followed their normal sign placement when these signs
were installed – the signs are supposed to be a set distance from the edge of the road, and
some are too close to the edge. The Chief said that the errors had been brought to their atten-
tion to be corrected. Administrator Tucker remarked that she, too, has witnessed the communi-
cation breakdown between the group that gives the assignment and the group that executes the
assignment.
Chief Buckhannon said that signs could be placed beside the hydrants saying NO PARKING
WITHIN 15 FEET OF HYDRANT, but everyone agreed that the City has enough signs.
Public Safety Committee
March 15, 2012
Page 4 of 8
B. Parking Control Systems and Enforcement
Councilmember Bergwerf recounted dialogue at the Joint Meeting as to legalities of parking
restrictions on the island; she voiced caution with moving forward until the legal aspects are
resolved. The Committee agreed that the City’s Attorney should be tasked with answering that
question for the City before more time and money are invested in it.
Councilmember Bergwerf stated that she wished she had asked for a show of hands from City
Councilmembers indicating their support for a park ing pass plan. Mayor Cronin indicated that,
until money is attributed to the cost of a pass plan, many Councilmembers will be noncommittal.
Mayor Cronin commented that restricting parking in the neighborhoods and pay-to-park are two
(2) separate initiatives that overlap. To eliminate parking in the neighborhoods will require more
signage, a great deal of control and a pass system.
Councilmember Bergwerf voiced her vision of the residents’ pass being like the Wild Dunes
stickers allowing residents to park anywhere at any time, except, of course, Front Beach. The
Mayor commented that the Wild Dunes system r equires two (2) people are on duty twenty-four
(24) hours a day, seven (7) days a week.
The Chair summarized the discussion to this point as tasking the City Attorney with researching
the legality of a pass system.
Councilmember Bergwerf expressed the fact that she does not favor the pass system, but she
wants to give relief to the neighborhoods. For visitors from off-island, she believes that they will
find the pass system to be very unfriendly.
Chair Bettelli stated that he understands the parking plan and pay-to-park as two (2) separate
issues. The added signage affecting line-of-sight is a major step in a parking plan; a pay-to-
park plan is going to cost a lot of money and no one has calculated what that number might be.
Mayor Cronin added that pay-to-park is going to cost more than most people realize in the way
of people and enforcement.
Administrator Tucker related that staff has devised a demonstration project related to parking to
be brought before the Committee for consideration. The primary issue is that many of the
complaints from residents are about those who come to the island and cause a problem, i.e. act
inappropriately, leave their trash, block driveway s, etc. The concept was “to staff up” with
Beach Service Officers and to assign them to wo rk in specific areas, for instance two (2) BSOs
for 1
st to 5 th Avenues from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. and two (2) BSOs for 6 th to 10 th Avenues for the
same period; the idea being that they are there to act preventatively, to provide information
about other areas for parking and to ticket offenders. Through this process, the City does some
intense management of the crowds coming to the island already. To do this initiative the City
would need to increase the number of BSOs substantially, equipping them with radios, and
providing them uniforms and transportation; sinc e four-wheel type vehicles are not allowed on
Palm Boulevard, some number of small trucks would be required. If the demonstration project
did not prove to be successful, the equipment and uniforms could go into inventory to be used at
a later time.
Public Safety Committee
March 15, 2012
Page 5 of 8
From a staff-level viewpoint, the Administrator explained that part of the problem with parking is
that the sworn officers, from Memorial Day to Labor Day, are tasked with the most serious type
of crimes that tie them up so that parking enforcement falls to a lower priority; therefore, parking
enforcement is, likely, not getting the level of attention that our residents want it to get – and
perhaps, rightly so. Using BSOs in this manner will put the focus on parking and the issues
related to parking that our residents are focused on; in addition, this project would give the resi-
dents someone to go to when they see problems happening. This demonstration project can be
done relatively easily; it does not have the impact of changing lifestyles for the entire island,
unlike the parking passes; and it could improve the parking situation to an extent that passes
are no longer considered necessary. Staff has delayed generating a budget until the project
gets a not from this Committee and Council.
Having heard the idea earlier in the day, Mayor Cronin commented that he had thought the
service could be done Tuesday through Sunday.
The Administrator remarked that the idea was an outgrowth of how people react with a law
enforcement presence – they tend to act better and react to having someone to go to talk to.
Councilmember Bergwerf said that the idea was interesting, but it was not a solution to the
“crush” of parking. Chair Bettelli said that he could see the double-parked truck adding to the
problems.
Mayor Cronin thought that it might be useful in the area of Breach to 10
th Avenue with spaces
designated for the vehicle to be parked.
Chief Buckhannon explained that currently the City hires four (4) BSOs; one (1) is on the beach
and three (3) are dedicated to the Front Beach Area. Typically they are directing traffic from 11
a.m. to 3 p.m. to keep traffic moving.
The Committee agreed for the staff to establish a budget for a demonstration project between
Breach and 10
th Avenue.
B. Review of FY13 Operating Budget for the Fire and Police Departments
As in other committees, Administrator Tucker covered the budgetary issues that are global to all
departments, i.e. a three percent (3%) merit pool, six percent (6%) increase to the health
insurance, fuel estimated at four dollars and a quarter ($4.25) per gallon, an increase to the
retirement for public safety employees from eleven point seven six five percent (11.765%) to
twelve point three percent (12.3%) and for regular employees from nine point five three five
percent (9.535%) to ten point six percent (10.6%).
Fire Department
Line items that were reduced based on actual experience are printing and office supplies,
meetings and seminars, water and sewer, cl eaning and sanitary supplies, medical and lab
supplies, employee training and miscellaneous and contingency.
Public Safety Committee
March 15, 2012
Page 6 of 8
Increases in the Department are as follows:
Electricity and Gas $42,000
The budget in FY12 dealt with a billing error by SCE&G that has been corrected
.
Telephone and Cable 39,996
The Charleston County radio user fee in creases January 2013 from $25/radio/month to
$38.50/radio/month
Maintenance and Service Contracts 42,046
Detailed in budget documents attached
U n i f o r m s 2 4 , 5 0 0
Rents and Leases 3,500
Based on actual usage for the copier equipment
Overall the Fire Department FY13 budget has a two percent (2%) increase over FY12.
Police Department
Administrator Tucker explained that the salaries and wages line does include the merit pool, but
the line does not show a significant increase as a result of the reorganization that occurred in
the Department with the retirement of Lieutenant Wright; in addition, the department has had
military time issues included in the FY12 budget.
Lines with decreases based on actual experience are water and sewer, cleaning and sanitary
supplies, rents and leases, and professional services.
Areas of the budget experiencing an increase are as follows:
Memberships and Dues $ 1,500
Based on actual expenses.
Electricity and Gas 28,000
Same explanation as Fire Department
Telephone and Cable 42,804
Based on the Charleston County radio user fee increase
Maintenance and Service Contracts 47,521
Detailed in budget documents attached
Overall the FY13 Police Department budget is flat with no increase or decrease from FY12.
C. Consideration of Award of Contracts in Excess of $10,000 – None
Public Safety Committee
March 15, 2012
Page 7 of 8
6. Highlights of Departmental Reports
Fire Department
Personnel from the department assisted with the search of the Francis Marion National Forest
for a missing female on February 17
th. On February 19 th, they responded to a report of a boat
leaking diesel fuel at a dock behind Morgan Pl ace Drive; they placed absorbent booms in the
water to contain the leak.
Mayor Cronin interrupted the report to inquire whether the City had an ordinance prohibiting
people from living on their boat. Chief Buckhannon responded that the prohibition comes in
DHEC regulations. Administrator Tucker voiced her opinion that there is an ordinance against
live-aboards in the City code and agreed to research.
In February, personnel responded to thirty-four (34) total calls, thirteen (13) were EMS calls. A
Fire Inspector has been hired and will start to work in March.
The IOP Fire Department hosted the Charleston Area Training Officers Meeting.
The Chiefs were involved in several meetings about the transition to the Charleston County
Consolidated Dispatch system.
Police Department
During the month of February, the Department had no significant calls. Dispatchers received a
total of forty-two hundred six (4,206) calls in the month; thirty-five hundred sixty (3,560) were for
the Police Department. Officers made three hundred sixty (360) traffic stops that resulted in
seventy-six (76) tickets being issued. There were eight (8) noise complaints for the month, and
four (4) warnings were issued.
Chair Bettelli asked whether the Department was fully staffed; Chief Buckhannon responded
that the Department was down two (2) officers, and he is in the process of hiring both officers
and BSOs.
The Committee praised the Chief for the Department’s annual report; he indicated that it has
been added to the City’s website.
7. Executive Session – not needed
8. Miscellaneous Business
Administrator Tucker announced that “Army Wives” will be filming beginning on Wednesday,
assuming the weather is good; the areas of the island impacted are the Front Beach parking lot,
around the Windjammer and the 500 block of Ocean Boulevard.
Public Safety Committee
March 15, 2012
Page 8 of 8
Chief Graham noted that the Carolina Children’s Charity is holding their annual telethon on the
weekend of March 25
th; she asked that Fire Department personnel be allowed to collect on the
weekend of March 17th-18th for a couple of hours a day. Chair Bettelli recounted that collections
were taken the weekend before the official event last year and had been very successful. The
Committee was very supportive of the Chief’s request.
Next Meeting Date: 5 p.m., Thursday, April 12, 2012 in the Conference Room.
9. Adjourn
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to adjourn the meeting at 5:40 p.m.;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.