July 11 (PDF, 32.51 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE
5:00 p.m., Wednesday, July 11, 2012
The regular meeting of the Public Safety Committee was held at 5:00 p.m. on Wednesday, July
11, 2012 in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmember Bergwerf, Mayor Cronin, Chair Bettelli, City
Administrator Tucker, Fire Chief Graham, Police Chief Buckhannon, Assistant to the
Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Chair Bettelli called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to approve the minutes of the regular meeting
of June 12, 2012 as submitted; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments
Barb Gobien, 5 Fifty-first Avenue, displayed an enlarged photograph (Exhibit A) of a vehicle
parking on her street with all four (4) tires on the roadway and asked whether this vehicle was
legally parked. She questioned that an emergency vehicle could pass this parked vehicle since
the road is only eighteen (18) feet wide.
Chief Buckhannon stated, “In the state of South Carolina, vehicles are to park off the road
where practicable; if it is not practicable to pull off the road because of an obstruction, a vehicle
is allowed to park along the edge of the road, on the side of the road or in the road as long as
there is a sight distance of greater than two hundred (200) feet on either side so that cars can
see from the approach and there is sufficient width for cars to pass in the opposite direction.”
Councilmember Bergwerf countered that this was not the rule in her neighborhood; Chief
Buckhannon noted that, on 8
th Avenue between Ocean and Carolina, there is not two hundred
(200) feet from the middle of the road to the end of the road.
Councilmember Bergwerf stated that, if there is two hundred (200) feet of visibility, one can park
in the middle of the street and not be ticketed; Administrator Tucker added that would be true
unless the street is posted indicating otherwise.
Chair Bettelli interrupted the discussion because it was outside the realm of Citizens’
Comments.
Chief Buckhannon read the statute into the minutes as follows:
No person shall stop, park or leave standing a vehicle whether attended or unattended upon the
roadway outside a business or residential district when it is practicable to stop, park or leave the
vehicle off the roadway. An unobstructed wi dth of the highway opposite a standing vehicle
must be left for the free passage of the other ve hicles and a clear view of a stopped vehicle must
be available from a distance of two hundred ( 200) feet in each direction upon the highway.
Public Safety Committee
July 11, 2012
Page 2 of 8
Chief Buckhannon summarized that in one sentence the statute tells you to park off the
roadway, but in the next sentence it says one can park on the road if the sight distance exists.
Administrator Tucker expressed the opinion that Ms. Gobien’s photograph might be useful in
Chief Buckhannon’s training of officers and asked that she email a copy to him for that purpose.
4. Old Business
A. Update on Wayfinding Signs with Stantec Presentation
Chair Bettelli welcomed Jerry Regenbogen, Rick Reiff and Marie Langlois from Stantec and
asked that they come forward to begin their presentation; Mr. Reiff distributed the handouts that
duplicated the visuals that would be discussed. Mr. Regenbogen recalled the initial meeting of
May 16
th where the issues and concerns of the City were presented; since that meeting, Mr.
Reiff and Ms. Langlois spent the Saturday of Memorial Day weekend riding with a patrol officer
to see “first-hand” the traffic and parking issues of the island. Based on the information
gathered, Stantec defined the mission of its project to be “getting visitors quickly and seamlessly
to available parking in the municipal lots and the Charleston County Park.” Mr. Regenbogen
reported that a lot of signage, or signage clutter, exists in the area of the Connector and Palm
Boulevard, the heart of their project. He pointed out that, when there are areas of concentrated
signage, the individual signs lose their impact and people lose the ability to respond quickly.
The goal of their project was to create effective wayfinding signs to provide access for drivers
and pedestrians.
Components of a successful way finding system are
• Understanding the types of users, i.e. drivers, pedestrians and cyclists;
• Understanding the user experiences;
• Understanding the ultimate destinations; and
• Clear and concise signage.
The criteria used in developing the signs include the incorporation of color, text sizes – from
guidelines based on the speed of the vehicles, and uniform symbols easily identified.
According to Mr. Regenbogen, the purpose of today’s presentation is to share their process with
the Committee, to determine what the wayfinding package should be, to look at the existing
conditions which have a major impact on the placement of signs, to look at proposed
alternatives, and, ultimately, to provide Stantec personnel with the City‘s recommendation or
selection of the alternatives offered.
Mr. Reiff reviewed the existing signage conditions which were depicted on page one of their
handout and their recommendations for the future; each numbered circle represented an
existing sign. Each numbered sign was pictured on the subsequent pages with Stantec’s
recommendation for that sign in the future.
Public Safety Committee
July 11, 2012
Page 3 of 8
As a driver exits the Connector onto the island, a driver encounters six (6) sign posts in a space
of approximately three hundred (300) feet, and some of those posts carry multiple messages
creating a flood of information for drivers. The goal for that area is to simplify some signs, to
relocate other signs and to remove others completely, making the approach more direct for
drivers coming to the island.
Another issue they addressed is that no signage pres ently directs drivers to turn right onto Palm
Boulevard for an alternative route to the municipal lots via J.C. Long. For those unfamiliar with
the island, Stantec thought it was important to alert visitors to an alternative; by directing
vehicles on the alternate route, the through movement of traffic can be improved as well.
Mr. Reiff directed the Committee’s attention to Sign 17 as an example of sign clutter – one (1)
post with four (4) different messages for drivers; this sign is an example of what Stantec is trying
to clean up and make simpler for visitors to the island.
With these issues in mind, Page 4 of the handout displays the proposed changes to sign
placement; it shows existing signs that will re main, directional pavement markings, and large
and small vehicular directional signs. In addition to the signage, pavement markings at the
Connector and Palm and on Palm at J.C. Long will direct drivers to public parking.
Mayor Cronin asked if the City could place signage further up onto the Connector bridge; Mr.
Reiff reported that, in casual discussions with Mark Nesbitt of SCDOT, SCDOT was not inclined
to approve signs on the bridge structure. Administrator Tucker added that
SCDOT also was not in favor of pavement markings, so she suggested that Stantec use bridge
signage as leverage to get approval for pavement markings for parking further on the bridge.
Marie Langlois reviewed the specific sign designs Stantec has developed for the island; they are
a seven foot by seven foot (7 ft. x 7 ft.) sandbl asted wood signs with white recessed lettering
and a seven foot by seven foot (7 ft. x 7 ft.) powder-coated metal signs with white paneled, vinyl
lettering. In addition, Stantec has developed smaller directional signage, following each style,
specific to parking. Ms. Langlois informed the Committee that they were proposing three (3) of
the large signs, three (3) directional pavement markings and twelve (12) smaller directional
signs. The sandblasted signs have a ten (10) year life span before refurbishing is needed; the
metal signs have a life of seven (7) years before needing to be repainted. Fifteen (15) total
signs, three (3) large and twelve (12) smaller sandblasted wood signs cost eighteen thousand
four hundred dollars ($18,400); the same number of metal signs cost twenty-two thousand three
hundred dollars ($22,300).
Since the sandblasted signs have a longer life and are less expensive, the Committee selected
the sandblasted wood signs with the green and yellow color scheme and design presented in
the metal signs.
Assistant Dziuban asked if the removal of existing signage was included in the pricing; Ms.
Langlois said that removal was not a part of their quote.
Public Safety Committee
July 11, 2012
Page 4 of 8
Mr. Regenbogen informed the Committee that SCDOT has “strongly suggested” that the only
way they will allow the stylized signage is for the City to commit to a plan for the entire island so
that they know that the City is going to impl ement the use of this signage island-wide. Ms.
Langlois and Mr. Regenbogen acknowledged that this would be a phased program and that
SCDOT only requires a commitment relative to vehicular signage.
Assistant Dziuban asked whether the pavement markings were included in the sign pricing and
was told that they are included.
Mr. Regenbogen reminded the Committee the SCDOT does not like the pavement markings,
but, knowing the City’s stand on them, the Stantec staff will work to have them approved. Mr.
Reiff stated that he has concluded that DOT does not think pavement markings have the same
visual impact; there is also the issue pavement markings not been seen when traffic backs up
on top of them. In addition, there is the matter that pavements markings are not approved in the
federal guide book.
Mayor Cronin suggested that Stantec take the approach that the pavement markings would be a
demonstration project for SCDOT for a couple or three (2-3) years like the 41
st Avenue project a
couple of years ago.
Assistant Dziuban noted that Stantec’s scope of work, as originally conceived, was fairly small,
focusing on the downtown area; if SCDOT will require a larger scale plan to permit the
specialized signs, the City must consider expanding the scope of work for Stantec. Mr.
Regenbogen offered to compile a proposal with a scope of services and related fees;
Administrator Tucker recommended that Stantec approach the proposal an amendment to the
existing scope of services to include these activities.
Mr. Regenbogen stated that the permitting process could proceed once City Council approves
the sign package; permitting typically takes a month. The new signage is expected to be in
place before the start of the next tourist season
B. Continued Discussion on Beach Access Parking
The discussion continued from earlier in the meeting about parking in the roadway. Chair
Bettelli wanted to know what the City needed to do to get people to park off of the roadway and
to standardize enforcement over the island. Chief Buckhannon explained that the City would
have to pass an ordinance stating how the City wants people to park, and then to have the
proper signage in place indicating what is acceptable parking.
Administrator Tucker cautioned that DOT would have to concur that the City’s decision-making
was valid in passing a parking ordinance. Chief Buckhannon noted that this situation also
brings up the impediments to parking in the right s-of-way that prevent people from getting out of
the roadway.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to have a “No Parking on Pavement” statute
generated and to request authorization from DOT to place necessary signage;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Public Safety Committee
July 11, 2012
Page 5 of 8
Councilmember Bergwerf expressed frustration in the fact that the methods for managing
parking that have been discussed have all met wi th roadblocks from SCDOT; she suggested
that the City find out from Charleston County what has been spent in the past five (5) years to
maintain the island’s road as a basis for the City’s considering taking over the island’s roads.
Chair Bettelli said that one (1) storm on the measure of Hurricane Hugo that could to wash out a
lot of island roads would devastate the City; he stated that the “what ifs” are his biggest concern.
Councilmember Bergwerf suggested that, in ten (10) years, if every day is like July 4
th, then
people will not want to own a home here or to pay eight to ten thousand dollars ($8,000-10,000)
a week to rent one. She thought residents would support a tax increase for a fund to maintain
the roads if the City could control parking; she recommended putting the issue before the resi-
dents in a referendum. In her opinion, owning the roads would give the City the flexibility it
wants to control parking.
Administrator Tucker indicated that, if Council were to embrace the idea, the City would need to
engage transportation experts to put together a package of credible estimates of the cost to own
the roads.
Mayor Cronin said he and the Administrator would talk to some people to determine if the
proposal is worthwhile.
Administrator Tucker cautioned that recent maintenance costs to Charleston County for island
road maintenance would be misleading because many different things impact road
maintenance. She recalled that when Mount Pleasant got into the “road business,” they hired a
traffic engineer and a staff of maintenance people; these are the types of costs the City will have
to consider. Assistant Dziuban commented that the cost to the island would be significant with
no infrastructure of people or equipment. The Administrator questioned that the City could
afford to insure the roads.
When residents voice dissatisfaction that they cannot see that progress is being made on
parking management, Administrator Tucker encouraged the Committee members to cite the
impact of the white chalk line on Palm Boulevar d, to look at the changes brought about by the
“NO PARKING HERE TO CORNER” signs, to point to the increased enforcement, and to note
the hiring of a consultant to drive visitors to the municipal parking lots.
5. New Business
A. Consideration of Revision of Parking Enforcement Officer Job Description
to Beach Services Officer
B. Consideration of Revision of Patrol Sergeant Job Description
Assistant Dziuban explained that these changes are the result of work the Administrator did to
get the funding from Charleston County for the added Beach Services Officers this summer;
from reading the existing job description, she learned that the job description was not in line with
Public Safety Committee
July 11, 2012
Page 6 of 8
the job being done. The Personnel Committee asked for a change in language relative to
training and had unanimously approved the changes.
The only change to the Patrol Sergeant’s job description was the addition of the sentence
“Supervises overall field training process for police recruits.”
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to approve the revised job descriptions;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
C. Consideration of South Carolina HEART Drill on January 4-6, 2013
Chief Graham explained that this will not be an event, but be a training activity of the National
Guard and the South Carolina Fire Marshall’s office. IOP personnel will participate as well.
Mayor Cronin stressed the need to inform island residents since helicopters will be landing at
the Recreation Center.
D. Approval of ATAX Request for Purchase of Rescue Sleds in the amount of
$3,014.13
Assistant Dziuban reported that the ATAX Committee had met earlier in the day and unani-
mously approved this funding request and noted that, in addition to the rescue sleds, the Fire
Department will be purchasing two (2) VHF handhel d radios with microphone speakers. Chief
Graham explained that this item was not included in the FY13 budget because the Department
had not been able to test one; she then described how the sled will make water rescues more
efficient and safer for both the rescuer and the person in the water.
MOTION: Councilmember Bergwerf moved to approve the purchase of the
rescue sled and radios; Mayor Cronin seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
E. Consideration of Award of Contracts in Excess of $10,000 – None
6. Highlights of Departmental Reports
Fire Department – Chief Graham
When the pool façade of the Palms Hotel collapsed on June 14
th, Fire Department personnel
secured the area; personnel also rescued two (2) people trapped in an elevator at the
condominiums on Palmetto Drive on June 23
rd. In the month of June, personnel responded to
one hundred thirteen (113) calls; sixty (60) were EMS calls. Sixteen (16) fire inspections were
done in the month where nine (9) violations were found and corrected. Chief Graham attached
several letters of thanks to the Department; the Committee decided that these letters should be
shared with all of Council and asked that they be included in Council packets.
Public Safety Committee
July 11, 2012
Page 7 of 8
Police Department – Chief Buckhannon
Responding to a complaint, officers entered a residence and found an underage party taking
place; twelve (12) subjects were charged with Underage Possession of Alcohol. While in the
residence, officers observed two (2) street signs, and a subject was charged with Petit Larceny.
A traffic stop on a golf cart resulted in the operator being placed under arrest for Driving Under
Suspension. (Chief Buckhannon took this opportunity to report a change in the state golf cart
laws in October that will allow golf carts to travel on any road with a speed limit of 35 mph as
well as a greater distance they can travel.) Telecommmunicators took fifty-two hundred nine
(5,209) total calls in June; forty-one hundred nine (4,109) were for the Police Department.
Three hundred forty-eight (348) traffic stops generated ninety-four (94) tickets. The majority of
arrests in June were for the underage possession of alcohol. Nine (9) noise complaints were
made in June, and one (1) citation was issued.
7. Executive Session – not needed
8. Miscellaneous Business
Chair Bettelli informed the Committee that attendees of the Municipal Association Annual
Meeting had been told of a recent Supreme Court decision that prohibits an addition to an
agenda once that agenda has been posted and printed. This situation seldom occurs at City
Council or Committee meetings, so the ruling is not expected to be an issue.
A. Follow-up on Disaster Expo
Chair Bettelli thanked the all of the City personnel who worked to make the Disaster Expo a
successful event; he stated that there had been a good turnout. Assistant Dziuban added that,
in the follow-up of the 2010 Expo, staff had questioned how many residents the event reached
in a significant way; therefore, this year, a st aff member was assigned the task of talking to
residents to get their general impression of the event. Residents of the islands voiced interest in
learning about what they needed to do to prepare, what they wanted to take, how to prepare
their children to evacuate and what the evacuation routes are; they were pleased with the level
of information provided at the Expo.
B. Holiday Traffic Counts
Chief Buckhannon directed attention to the graph of Memorial Day weekend traffic counts that
indicated a total of nineteen thousand four hundred twenty-six (19,426) vehicles incoming to the
island and a total of nineteen thousand four hundred seventy (19,470) vehicles outgoing from
the island. In the Chief’s opinion, the significance is that the volume has continued to increase a
little each year since 2005; he noted that rain was forecasted for two (2) days of the holiday
weekend this year. Additionally, the Chief had offered a graph of incoming and outgoing traffic
for the month of May from 2005 through 2012. The graphs for the months of June from 2005 to
date show a similar trend. Chief Buckhannon had similar information for the Committee for July
4
th from 2006 to 2011.
Next Meeting Date: 5 p.m., Thursday, August 9, 2012 in the City Hall Conference Room.
Public Safety Committee
July 11, 2012
Page 8 of 8
9. Adjourn
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to adjourn at 7:25 p.m.; Councilmember
Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.