September 11 (PDF, 28.32 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE
5:00 p.m., Tuesday, September 11, 2012
The regular meeting of the Public Safety Committee was called to order at 5:00 p.m. on
Tuesday, September 11, 2012 in the City Hall Conf erence Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of
Palms, South Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmember Bergwerf, Mayor Cronin,
Chair Bettelli, Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban, Fire Chief Graham, Police Chief
Buckhannon, City Attorney Halversen and City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to
conduct business. Also in attendance were Mark Schoemaker and Chip Branscom, a
mechanical engineer with Cole+Russell and Mike Weeks, a design engineer with DWG.
1. Chair Bettelli called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Bergwerf moved to approve the minutes of the
regular meeting of August 9, 2012 as submitted; Mayor Cronin seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Old Business
A. Discussion with Mark Shoemaker of Cole+Russell regarding Public Safety
Building
Assistant Dziuban noted that Cole+Russell (C+R) was the design and engineering firm for the
construction of the Public Safety Building that was completed in 2009. Since the City took
possession of the building, there have been on-goi ng and unresolved issues with the structure;
staff from Cole+Russell is present, having spent the day checking on these problems to make
recommendations on resolution.
Mr. Shoemaker noted that he and his associates had spent the past four (4) hours in the Public
Safety Building checking the installations of some of the problem items; in addition, Mr.
Branscom has been studying the drawings and specifications for the building. Mr. Weeks was
instrumental in the design of the building and has also been looking at mechanical issues. Mr.
Shoemaker remarked that some of the issues to be discussed have been going on since the
construction was completed; he said that C+R has been trying to resolve these problems for
three (3) years to no avail. He indicated that he was on-site late in 2011 going through a final
punch-list and warranty items; subsequent to that visit, he stated that several letters, emails and
phone conversations have been exchanged between C+R and Mashburn Construction, the
construction contractor on the building. Accord ing to Mr. Shoemaker, the list of items has gone
from about forty (40) to six or seven (6-7) items, a combination of punch-list and warranty
issues. He explained that punch-list items relate to retainage while warranty items relate to the
one-year (1 yr.) warranty; certain of the warranty issues on the list have been present from the
day the City took possession of the building. He added that some of the warranty items have
been fixed only to re-occur, such as the diesel line leak, and others resulted from repairs that
caused subsequent problems, such as the drinking fountain that leaked and now sticks and
cannot be turned off.
Public Safety Building
September 11, 2012
Page 2 of 5
Two (2) of the primary issues are mechanical and relate to the HVAC on the third floor and odor,
temperature and humidity problems on the second floor. Relative to comfort on the third floor,
C+R and Mashburn identified several areas of air infiltration into the building that contributed to
humid air being introduced into the building that could not be handled by the HVAC system.
Today, the C+R team did not locate any obvious leaks; they believe this problem has been
handled.
Sanyo, the manufacturer of the HVAC system on the third floor, has not been responsive to the
issues that have been occurring, but, after speaking with them earlier today, they have agreed
to come back next week to make sure that the system is operating as it should. Subsequent to
their visit, C+R expects to get a letter from Sanyo saying that the system checked out, or Sanyo
will find a problem and fix it.
If it turns out that there is an issue with the way the system was initially designed, C+R will look
at it and make recommendations. Mr. Shoemaker stated that C+R does believe that the system
as designed was proper and sized appropriately for the building, but acknowledged that a
problem exists.
Relative to the odor on the second floor, today the C+R team did find that a damper was in the
closed position; at one point it was stuck open. Mr. Shoemaker stated that he was unsure
whether it was a warranty item; the damper controls makeup air from the outside for the unit.
No one is certain how long it has been in this closed position; a maintenance man worked on
the unit about a month ago when it was stuck open. This is the same system that is on the
Police Department side of the building, and they are not experiencing these problems; there-
fore, Cole+Russell believes that the system was properly designed. In addition, the team
checked the air handler and found no sign of moisture that could cause an odor.
Mr. Shoemaker said that the fuel line leak is a warranty issue; originally the leak was to the
diesel fuel. Parts of the line have been re-installed twice, but the leaks have re-occurred. In the
fall of 2011, the entire diesel fuel line was reinstalled all the way to the diesel generator; over the
past six (6) months, the leaks have reoccurred, primarily at the joints. He anticipates the entire
line having to be removed and re-installed. Over the past few months, a propane line leak has
occurred in the mechanical room; Chief Graham indicated that this leak was originally reported
to Mashburn two (2) years ago.
Mr. Shoemaker remarked that some “mysterious” elec trical issues with light fixture ballasts in
the Training Room exist; originally there were two (2) light fixtures, but today there are five (5)
that do not work on one (1) side of the room. Mashburn contends that improper light bulbs were
put into those fixtures and that, since someone else has worked on them, the warranty is no
longer applicable. An electrician has commented that there may be a problem with the
grounding system and maybe the neutral wiring of the system; C+R is trying to find someone to
come to check out the electrical grounding in the building.
By way of background, Mr. Shoemaker stated that Mr. Branscom had been tasked with studying
drawings, specifications and shop drawings, as well as conferring with DWG; in addition, C+R
has hired an electrical engineer who may have recommendations on how to best check out this
Public Safety Committee
September 11, 2012
Page 3 of 6
issue. C+R expects to make a recommendation to the City in the next couple of weeks
regarding the electrical issues.
Mr. Shoemaker indicated that problems exist with the lighting for the ground for the fixtures for
the flag poles; this issue was on the punch-list, and C+R has been unsuccessful in getting
Mashburn to do anything about this issue.
The water fountain should be a simple fix; Mashburn simply needs to get someone to do the
work.
The four-fold doors – the large apparatus bay doors – have had rusting issues from the time
they were installed. Mr. Shoemaker has been trying to locate someone who can take samples
of the paint; he suspects that the doors were never painted properly, unlike the doors at Fire
Station 2 that look as if they were just painted even though they are older. The rusting initially
appeared around the window jams at the trim; when he initially looked at them in December, he
questioned that a finish coat was ever applied to them. After speaking with the door
manufacturer and reviewing shop drawings, the windows were to have been painted and then
caulked; the manufacturer is suggesting that the lack of caulk has contributed to the rusting.
Since rust is occurring on other parts of the doors, Mr. Shoemaker indicated that he is not sure
that the lack of caulk is the answer, but a contri-buting factor. Mashburn has finally come to
caulk between the jams and the exterior wall – another item that goes back to the original
punch-list; they did a very poor job and have agreed to re-do it.
In an email today, Mr. Shoemaker related that Mashburn is prepared to remove all of the rust,
down to the bare metal, re-prime and caulk the windows. Mashburn stated in the same email
that they will do that work once they are released of all final retainage on the job, which is out of
the question. In an August letter to Mashburn, C+R listed six to eight (6-8) items that they need
to complete, the windows being only one (1).
Another punch-list item is the overhead sectional doors at the police garage where there was
water infiltration when it rains; C+R determined that the doors had not been properly adjusted to
seal tightly. In the past two (2) years, Advanced Door has been out a number of times for
maintenance or warranty issues with the doors; the real issue is that the rollers for the doors
come off the tracks. In recent months, the technician working on the doors indicated that the
doors are not heavy-duty doors; when Chief Graham reported that to Mr. Shoemaker, he
checked the specifications and shop drawings that were approved and submitted by Mashburn
indicate that the overhead sectional doors for both Police and Fire were supposed to have
double hinges with the roller extending through them both. Mr. Shoemaker recalled that heavier
hardware was not put on the doors because they were not set up as heavy duty doors; Mr.
Shoemaker has concluded that, when the double hinges are placed on the doors, the styles on
the edges need to be wider on the door panels and the panels on the doors are sized for single
hinges.
Referring again to the letter to Mashburn in August, Mr. Shoemaker had indicated that the doors
provided do not meet the specifications and do not meet the approved shop drawings making
the issue contractual not punch-list. To-date, Mashburn has chosen to ignore the matter.
Public Safety Committee
September 11, 2012
Page 4 of 6
Mr. Shoemaker informed the Committee that he anticipates another letter from C+R to
Mashburn after the review of Sanyo’s inspections and a testing of the paint on the bay doors.
Assistant Dziuban confirmed the Mayor’s query that the City continues to hold retainage of
roughly fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000).
Assistant Dziuban summarized the discussion as follows:
• Scrutiny of the Sanyo report that will indi cate that a problem was found and corrected or
that recommendations will be made to address a design problem;
• Repair the damper on the second floor;
• Confirm that temperature control settings are working properly;
• Address issues with thermostats on third floor;
• Return of Mashburn to re-do the fuel line for leaks;
• Return of C+R personnel to look at the electrical issues with the building; and
• Return of Mashburn to address four-fold doors, overhead sectional doors and water
cooler.
Councilmember Bergwerf questioned whether the retainage was sufficient to pay for the repairs
if the City has to hire someone to do the work; the response was negative.
The Committee thanked Mr. Shoemaker, Mr. Branscom and Mr. Weeks for their time and efforts
on behalf of the City.
MOTION: Councilmember Bergwerf moved to re-order the Agenda to hold the
Executive Session next; Mayor Cronin seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
7. Executive Session to receive legal advice on contractual matters
MOTION: Councilmember Bergwerf moved to go into Executive Session at
5:37 p.m.; Mayor Cronin seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
The Committee returned to regular session at 5:56 p.m.; Chair Bettelli stated that the Committee
had not taken any action or a vote during the Executive Session.
Chair Bettelli asked the Attorney Halversen to be prepared to brief City Council on the con-
tractual issues discussed in an Executive Session.
4. Old Business , continued
B. Update on “NO PARKING” delineation on Avenues between 42
nd and 57th
Chief Buckhannon stated that SCDOT had approved the placement of “NO PARKING HERE
TO CORNER” signs on the avenues between 42 nd and 57 th Avenues; he was not told when to
expect the signs to be installed.
Public Safety Committee
September 11, 2012
Page 5 of 6
5. New Business
Consideration of “No Parking on Pavement” Ordinance
Assistant Dziuban noted that, pursuant to a request from the Committee, Attorney Halversen
has prepared an ordinance prohibiting parking on the pavement.
Chair Bettelli asked if the ordinance was for 42
nd to 57th Avenue; Chief Buckhannon replied that
the ordinance would address parking on the pavement island-wide. He also commented that,
assuming that the ordinance is adopted, the City will still have to get SCDOT approval for the
new signage.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to recommend approval of the ordinance for
“NO PARKING ON PAVEMENT;” Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
6. Highlights of Departmental Reports
Fire Department – Chief Graham
During the month of August, Chief Graham reported that the Department had been involved in
several multiple jurisdictional responses to water calls. In addition, there had been a rash of
jelly fish and stingray stings. The Chief stated that personnel had responded to one hundred
thirty-seven (137) calls; ninety (90) of them were EMS calls. A total of nineteen (19) fire inspec-
tions were done in the month. Chief Graham stated that the young man who had jumped from
the balcony of Coconut Joe’s in August and who was resuscitated twice by IOP personnel has
returned to work.
Police Department – Chief Buckhannon
The Chief reported that Police officers had initiated the “Neighborhood Block Meet & Greets” on
August 23
rd; through these gatherings, the department plans to introduce the officers to island
residents and to familiarize residents with crime trends in their neighborhoods and on the island
in general. Officers have been going door-to-door to introduce themselves and the program to
residents; four (4) more meetings are scheduled in September. When it gets dark earlier, the
officers will hold the gatherings at the homeowners meetings in Wild Dunes, at the Exchange
Club and at a Keenagers meeting; Chief Buckhannon stated that the gatherings are receiving
positive feedback from residents.
In August dispatchers received forty-three hundred sixty-six (4,366) calls; of that number, thirty-
two hundred thirty-three (3,233) were for the Police Department. For the month, two hundred
ninety-two (292) traffic stops were made and eighty-one (81) tickets were issued. On the
livability front, seventeen (17) noise complaints were received with four (4) citations being
written.
Public Safety Committee
September 11, 2012
Page 6 of 6
Referring to an incident where several golf carts were ticketed, Chief Buckhannon reported that
an event, which was unknown to the department, took place that drew residents to Front Beach
- several driving golf carts. The tickets that were written that day have been voided.
In addition, Chief Buckhannon repeated that new legislation will go into effect in September that
will allow golf carts to be driven farther from t heir home base, but golf carts are still not allowed
on state roadways, meaning they are not allowed to be driven on most of Palm Boulevard or on
sidewalks.
Mayor Cronin stated that he wanted to do something to make citizens aware of the good work
the Fire and Police personnel are doing; he specifically referred to the incidents where Fire
Department personnel have saved lives and the work officers have done relative to auto break-
ins. Assistant Dziuban stated that she would generate a press release and try to get it printed in
The Island Eye.
8. Miscellaneous Business
Connector Run – 8:00 a.m., Saturday, October 6. Chief Buckhannon reminded the Committee
of the after-run event that will required that Pavilion and J.C. Long remain closed until noon.
Fire Prevention Parade – 4:30 p.m., Wednesday, October 10.
Next Meeting Date: 4:00 p.m., Thursday, October 4, 2012 in the Conference Room
9. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Bergwerf moved to adjourn the meeting at 6:37
p.m.; Chair Bettelli seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.