February 9 (PDF, 73.09 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE
4:00 p.m., Thursday, February 9, 2012
The regular meeting of the Public Works Committee was held at 4:00 p.m. on Thursday,
February 9, 2012 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Carroll and Loftus, City Administrator
Tucker, Director Pitts and Clerk Copeland; Chair Buckhannon’s absence was excused. A
quorum was present to conduct business. Also present was Dave Stevens of Civil Site
Environmental.
1. With the absence of the Chair, Vice Chair Loftus called the meeting to order and
acknowledged that the press and public had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance
with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Carroll moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of January 4, 2012 as submitted; Vice Chair Loftus seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizen’s Comments – None
4. Department Reports for January 2012 – Director Pitts
A. Maintenance Reports
B. Trash Collection Tracking Reports
Director Pitts reported that more in-house work than outdoor had taken place in January; he has
worked on re-structuring the monthly reports to make them more easily understood while the
staff were working on inside projects around the City.
Garbage was up for the month. On the report, the Director suggested that five (5) years of
information were sufficient, but Vice Chair Loftus would like to see annual totals added to each
column.
Director Pitts explained that the move to paper bags or plastic containers for yard debris meant
that more debris went to Bees Ferry and less to 4B. He added that most debris haulers
measure in cubic yards; however, Bees Ferry measures real debris because the trucks go
across a scale yielding a truck weight and tare weight, yielding more accurate data. When
using the cubic yard measure, the use of a seventeen (17) yard truck means seventeen (17)
cubic yards of debris despite the fact that debris has a lot of air. Treasurer Suggs computed
that the thirty-two (32) loads of debris that went to Bees Ferry in January in seventeen (17) yard
trucks weighed on average two and seven one hundredths (2.07) tons; Director Pitts has,
therefore, redesigned the report to display in tonnage. For the future, the Director foresees
eighty to ninety (80-90) percent of all debris going to Bees Ferry; that will drive fuel costs up, but
he anticipates a savings in Contracted Services for the use of 4B.
For future reporting, Vice Chair Loftus asked that any special circumstances or events that
affect the amount of debris be noted in the margins of the report.
Public Works Committee
February 9, 2012
Page 2 of 8
Expenses remain on target to be less than or meet the budget for the year.
5. Old Business
A. Update on Drainage Projects
1. Discussion of Easement 53
rd to 57th Avenue Drainage
Administrator Tucker announced that the construction expense related to that project is officially
over, and the project savings will go back into the fund for future projects.
The Administrator explained that, when this project was designed, the City took the water to an
outfall on Wild Dunes’ property; therefore, the City had to get easements from both Lowe Wild
Dunes Investors and the Wild Dunes Community Association. The language was clear that,
should an occasion arise when conflicts arose over their future construction, the City would
move the line at the City’s expense or give th em permission to move the line at the City’s
expense. Plans are underway to build a pool over one (1) on the drainage lines, and they have
indicated that they will undertake to move the line at the City’s expense subject to Mr. Stevens’
inspections and oversight to ensure the integrity of the City’s line is maintained. The expense
will fall into this fiscal year since they intend to complete construction by the end of July.
Mr. Stevens related that one (1) good outcome from the relocation of the line is that the City will
be granted a permanent easement which means that any future relocation will be at their
expense.
According to Administrator Tucker, the estimated cost is thirty-thousand dollars ($30,000) which
she thinks is low. Mr. Stevens anticipates having the plans in a week to ten (10) days from
which he can work up the costs.
2. Update on Reimbursement for 21
st Avenue Drainage from NPDES
The Administrator announced that the City had received the fifty-five hundred dollar ($5,500)
reimbursement from Charleston County for the 21
st Avenue drainage, which proves that the
system works.
MOTION: Vice Chair Loftus moved to re-order the agenda to discuss item 6E;
Councilmember Carroll seconded and the motion PASSD UNANIMOUSLY.
6. E. Consideration of Contracts in Excess of $10,000
Recommendation for Award of Sole Source Contract to Civil Site Environmental
(CSE) for Design, Bidding and Construction Oversight of 42
nd to 52nd Avenue
Drainage
Administrator Tucker reminded the Committee that the FY12 budget includes funds to begin the
next phase of drainage, i.e. the design and engineering from 46
th to 52nd Avenues, now referred
to as 42nd to 52nd Avenue, in the amount of eighty-six thousand dollars ($86,000). Mr. Stevens
Public Works Committee
February 9, 2012
Page 3 of 8
has expanded the scope to 42 nd Avenue for his proposal until the engineering can be done to
more specifically confirm the scope.
For the benefit of the newest member of the Committee, the Administrator explained that the
City has historically worked with CSE on projects that require interaction with the systems in
Wild Dunes because, based on work Mr. Stevens has done there, he has a strong familiarity
with their infrastructure, has developed a strong level of trust as a result of that, and the City can
count on Mr. Stevens to work with the various entities within Wild Dunes successfully. For
these reasons the City has historically not sought bids for the drainage projects, but chosen to
award sole source contract. CSE’s quote for the engineering, bidding and construction
oversight is one hundred sixty-nine thousand dollars ($169,000) that would span more than one
(1) fiscal year. The Administrator confirmed to Vice Chair Loftus that no money has been spent
from the FY12 budget for this project.
Mr. Stevens indicated that the surveying needed to be done for him to determine the best route
to the 41
st Avenue outfall. He voiced confidence that the present budget would be sufficient for
any work completed by June 30, 2012.
The Administrator foreshadowed that the amount on money allocated to this project in the FY13
Capital Budget will need to be increased.
MOTION: Councilmember Carroll moved to recommend to Ways and Means
the award of a sole source contract to Civil Site Environmental for the engi-
neering, bidding and construction oversight for the 42
nd to 52 nd Avenue
Drainage project in the amount of $169,000; Vice Chair Loftus seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
5. B. Update on Paving Near Compactor in Municipal Lot
Vice Chair Loftus questioned this item being on the agenda when the Real Property Committee
had voted to award a contract for the paving; Administrator Tucker explained that this
Committee had discussed the issue before and was familiar with the issue. The Administrator
reported that the Real Property Committee had moved to authorize the expenditure of thirty-nine
hundred dollars ($3,900) to put in a concrete path and pad to facilitate getting the large cans to
the compactor and to decrease the possibility of a trip hazard. The action will go forward to
Ways and Means, and, if this Committee does not concur or has any questions, they can be
addressed at this meeting.
C. Discussion of Recycle Bins
Since Chair Buckhannon stated that he had wanted to do further research on the subject, Vice
Chair Loftus recommended postponing any discussion to the March meeting.
Director Pitts reported that he has spoken with Hal Crawford with Charleston County Recycling
who was inquiring about the number of single-family residences on the island relative to
delivering the ninety-five (95) gallon containers for single-stream recycling; the Director quoted
thirty-five hundred (3,500) residences. Vice Chair Loftus asked if there would be a charge to the
Public Works Committee
February 9, 2012
Page 4 of 8
City if additional containers were needed; the Administrator stated that the City had not been
told to expect a charge.
The Vice Chair related that studies have shown that, once single-stream recycling takes hold, it
becomes two-thirds ( ⅔) of the total waste from a residence; with that said, he suggested that
residents will not need or want the seventy-five (75) gallon roll-out carts the City now provides,
but would prefer the smaller ones. He is of the opinion that this should be considered as the
City prepares the FY13 budgets.
6. New Business
A. Review of Capital Budget for FY 2012-2013 and Long Range Capital Plan
Administrator Tucker explained that each department has a long-range plan for capital
replacements, and these are the items that have come up in FY13 for replacement. During the
process at staff level, some things are deemed to be in good shape, therefore, are deferred to
an out-year; some things may need to be replaced sooner than anticipated; and, at times, things
that will lead to a more efficient operation become new requests. The City has been vigilant
about planning for replacements to avoid getting in to situations where something fails and the
City is forced to buy or situations where large sums of money are being spent to maintain some-
thing that should be taken out of service when the resources should be directed to buying new.
The first three (3) items on the Public Works FY13 Capital Budget represent equipment leases
the City entered into; the City will own the equipment once the leases are paid in full. For the
City, capital leases allow for steady expenses over time for large expensive rolling stock.
Replace privacy fence along 13th Ave or Building Dept side 5,000
This item has been deferred before; if City is succ essful in reconfiguring the parking, this money
may be necessary to work on the fencing.
Replace staff computers (3 computers/4 yr aver life = approx .75/year) 1,350
Director Pitts’ computer is due to be replaced; hi s computer is linked to tracking the fuel system.
Replace pressure washer for cleaning trucks 7,500
Used weekly and 7 years old; used by other departments as well; is working
Special Projects
Design engineering & construction 46 th-52nd Ave drainage project 66,000
Administrator believes number needs to be adjuste d; will consult with D. Stevens to determine
what the amount needs to be.
Mobi Mat material to stabilize sand beach accesses 25,000
Plastic fiber at beach accesses; easily re-posit ioned; stable surface to drive over; long-lasting
product.
Replace/repair/add dune walkovers (5 woode n walkovers, approx. 53 accesses) 80,000
Currently deciding best use of funds for FY12, likely to be path from Front Beach restrooms;
looking at different materials to use, such as concrete and epay wood, used at 21
st Avenue, and
the PermaTrak concrete boardwalk syst em for ease in maintenance and longevity.
Vice Chair Loftus asked whether the Director had looked at engineered woods where polymers
are driven into wood; Director Pitts stated that the only drawback was that the plastic get hot.
Public Works Committee
February 9, 2012
Page 5 of 8
Vice Chair Loftus inquired about particular beach accesses where the Mobi mat needs to be
replaced; Director Pitts remarked that the Mobi mat at 42
nd Avenue beach access has begun to
fray and a risk exists for someone to be cut. Mobi mat is also installed at 9th Avenue.
Facility Maintenance
Garbage cart replacement (approximately 100 cans per year) 7,600
Vice Chair Loftus reminded Director Pitts to look into buying smaller roll-out carts.
Drainage contingency 25,000
Annual placeholder for unplann ed items throughout the year
Repeat drainage work based on 5-year maintenance schedule 88,150
Eadie’s contract for ditch maintenance; in Year 2 of current 5-year contract
Contingency for right-of-way maintenance 3,000
For example, sand shell along rights-of-way along Palm Boulevard
These items will be rolled into other budgets as the process evolves.
B. Prioritization of Projects Greater than $250,000
The Administrator explained that this is an exer cise done every couple of years; the list
represents items that have either been in long-range plans to do by department or come up as
possible ideas of things needed by the City. It is not a closed list – any member of any
committee could add to it. The goal is to consider, globally, what the Committee thinks should
be the top five (5) priorities for the City to narrow the focus for staff on the direction the decision-
making body is leaning. When this exercise was last undertaken, a couple of items were
removed that have been added back for the sake of information and discussion for the new
members of Council; the items are the public safety beachfront outpost and the 41
st Avenue
roundabout. Projects that have been completed also appear as a sign that the list is not just a
wish-list; projects from the list do get accomplished. Staff will take each Committee’s top five (5)
to produce a priority list to be presented at Ways and Means.
Vice Chair Loftus remarked that he did not understand why the beachfront outpost or the 41
st
Avenue roundabout had been added back to the list; the City does not need or have an
economic justification for either item. Administrator Tucker noted that they could be removed
again.
C. Discussion of Annual Transportation Sales Tax Funding and CTC Requests
Administrator Tucker explained that each year C harleston County sends the City a request for a
prioritization of projects to be funded through the Transportation Sales Tax Fund (TST) and the
Charleston County Transportation Committee (CTC) “C” Fund. Both the Public Safety Commit-
tee and the Public Works Committee provide input because these sources of money can pay for
drainage improvements to sidewalks and bike paths to paving roads that are not already paved.
Funding for re-surfacing does come from these sources, but the County has a computer
program that prioritizes county-wide paving projects. In the past, projects on the island that
have been paid by these funds are the 53
rd to 57th Avenue Drainage, drainage at Sparrow Drive
and Lauden, Waterway Boulevard bike path, the 41 st Avenue and 13 th and 14 th Avenue
intersection studies, bike path improvements, and 21st and 34th Avenue re-surfacing.
Public Works Committee
February 9, 2012
Page 6 of 8
Councilmember Carroll asked where he could go to learn which roads on the island fall under
the City’s jurisdiction; he was directed to Director Pitts.
Last year’s requests were for the 46
th to 52nd Avenue Drainage, paving of Cassina and a multi-
use path from 41st to 57th Avenue; the City was not awarded any money in 2011. Cassina Drive
will receive a new rock surface that should not produce the white residue on Palm Boulevard.
The Public Safety Committee had made their first priority the 42
nd to 52nd Drainage project and
the continuation of the bike path from the foot of the Connector to the Palm Boulevard inter-
section to shift cyclists off of the roadway.
Councilmember Carroll expressed his agreement wi th Vice Chair Loftus’ suggestion at the
February meeting that the City needed to focus on getting regulation bike paths from Breach
Inlet to 57
th Avenue. Vice Chair Loftus indicated that the Real Property Committee had a similar
discussion at their meeting, but he agreed that the continuation of the drainage project should
be the first priority. He voiced the opinion that a bike path guiding cyclists onto the island was
useless if they did not have anywhere to go and “would create a huge traffic problem for
residents.” He stressed the need to build the infrastructure for bikes to allow cyclists to
maneuver safely on the island before any upgr ades like the Palm Boulevard intersection;
therefore, Vice Chair Loftus suggested that regulation bike paths the length of the island be
submitted as Priority #2. Councilmember Carroll concurred.
Administrator Tucker noted that Richard Turner with Charleston County Transportation Develop-
ment had attended the Public Safety Committee meeting and had informed them that the resur-
facing of Palm Boulevard from 41
st to 57 th Avenue was in the plan for 2012. He shared that,
when resurfacing occurs, the County has committed to extend the pavement, where possible,
so that there are paths; this appears to be one (1) way that Charleston County is trying to be
responsive to the biking community. That being the case, Mr. Turner said they would look at
trying to do that section of road as part of the resurfacing assuming there is enough right-of-
way.
The Administrator repeated her understanding that this Committee’s priority list was the
drainage continuation as Number 1, bike lanes from Breach Inlet to 57
th Avenue as Number 2
and the bike path from the end of the Connector to the Palm Boulevard intersection as Number
3. The Committee agreed.
D. Report on Meeting with Charleston County on NPDES Funds
Administrator Tucker recounted that the City had signed an intergovernmental agreement with
Charleston County to manage the National Pollut ant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES)
program for the City; in 2011 the City had asked Charleston County for an accounting of the
stormwater fees that residents have been paying for the past few years. The City knew that the
County was following through with their responsibilities related to compliance – had they not, the
EPA would have been knocking on the City’s door, but the City did not know how much money
had been collected for the City or how that money had been spent. At the meeting, the County
provided the City with a great deal of information that demonstrated that they are complying with
the public education component of the stormwater program. In addition, they brought the five
Public Works Committee
February 9, 2012
Page 7 of 8
(5) year plan they have developed to use the money which includes some charge-back
expenses for County staff running the program and identifies revenues that have been collected
and how they would be used for drainage. The Administrator expressed satisfaction at learning
that an accountant has been assigned to the stormwater division whom she can call with
questions relevant to the Isle of Palms. For the current year, the County has budgeted fifteen
thousand dollars ($15,000) to spend on projects on the island; this is the fund from which the
fifty-five hundred dollars ($5,500) was reimbursed to the City for 21
st Avenue. In addition, a
portion of the Cassina Avenue endeavor will come from these funds as well as repairs to the
drainage collapse at 3604 Hartnett. Going forward, the City can identify NPDES projects that it
wants to have done under this program; therefore, the City has a new source of funds for
drainage and drainage-related projects. The fund balance at the end of June is projected to be
one hundred sixty-seven thousand one hundred fifty-nine dollars ($167,159).
In response to Vice Chair Loftus’ question, Administrator Tucker confirmed that the Eadie’s
contract would be eligible for NPDES funds, freeing up money to go towards the capital costs
associated with the 42
nd to 52nd Avenue drainage. The Vice Chair asked whether the City could
use the entire balance or whether there were limitations; the Administrator indicated that the
County has fund balance requirements and enough money must remain to do the operational
components of the program for the City. This information provides flexibility to identify other
drainage projects to do or to earmark existing expenses the City now pays for from Capital
Projects or the General Fund.
Councilmember Carroll asked for clarification on the City’s position on open-versus-piped
ditches. Administrator Tucker answered that most engineers say that an open ditch functions
far better than a piped ditch, but there are circumstances where it is necessary to pipe a ditch or
pressure is placed by surrounding residents that a ditch is piped. Some ditches on the Isle of
Palms are actually governed by the Corps of Engi neers because the type of plant life growing in
them makes them wetlands, which cannot be piped unless the City was willing to establish
another wetland area elsewhere to mitigate the loss.
Director Pitts added that, in a fifteen or twenty (15 or 20) year storm, open ditches act as
retention ponds because they hold more volume than a fifteen (15) inch pipe. The ditch running
behind properties on Hartnett was piped in the late 1990s as a result of pressure from the
property owners.
Administrator Tucker summarized that the County is taking care of the City’s money and the
City can tell the County how it wants some of the money spent.
7. Miscellaneous Business
Director Pitts announced that the annual Household Hazardous Waste Collection would be held
on Saturday, April 21, 2012 and the Recreation Center is being considered as the site.
Vice Chair Loftus related that he had been asked through the Exchange Club to find programs
where students from Wando High School can volunteer to fulfill their obligation; Director Pitts
said they could assist with transferring material s from cars to the containers. The Vice Chair
agreed to communicate that suggestion to the Exchange Club.
Public Works Committee
February 9, 2012
Page 8 of 8
Next Meeting Date: 4 p.m., Wednesday, March 7, 2012 in the Conference Room .
8. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Carroll moved to adjourn the meeting at 6:33 p.m.;
Vice Chair Loftus seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.