March 7 (PDF, 34.5 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE
4:00 p.m., Wednesday, March 7, 2012
The regular meeting of the Public Works Committee was held at 4:00 p.m. on Wednesday,
March 7, 2012 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Carroll and Loftus, Chair Buckhannon,
Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban, Director Pitts and City Clerk Copeland; also present
were Building Director Kerr and landscape architect Kelly Messier. A quorum was present to
conduct business.
1. Chair Buckhannon called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and
public had been duly notified in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of February 9, 2012 as submitted; Councilmember Carroll seconded and
the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments
Bev Ballow, 3009 Waterway Boulevard, stated that she and other residents wanted the
Committee to discuss a plan for placing recycling bins on the beach.
4. Department Reports for February 2012 – Director Pitts
A. Maintenance Reports
Priorities for February had been the right-of-way landscaping and tree trimming; in addition,
sand shell was delivered and spread on the inland side of Palm Boulevard from 21
st to 41 st
Avenues.
Vehicle maintenance was a bit high for the month as a result of the purchase of six (6) tires at
the end of the month. The Director pointed out that he is still within budget year-to-date.
B. Trash Collection Tracking Reports
Garbage collection for the month was similar to the same period last year. The Director noted
that he had dropped the oldest two (2) years’ data from the report, and it now displays historical
data for a five (5) year period.
Director Pitts reported that a correction needed to be made to the January 2012 debris
collection; four (4) additional loads went to 4B for a total of five (5).
The departmental reports are attached to the historical record of the meeting.
5. Old Business
A. Discussion on Recycle Bins
Public Works Committee
March 7, 2012
Page 2 of 10
Chair Buckhannon indicated that this item relates to residents who leave the recycle bins in the
right-of-way; he asked Director Pitts whether he had seen a change in the number of people
who do this. The Director responded that he did not perceive this to be a widespread problem
and that the introduction of the ninety-five (95) gallon single-stream barrels could lead to a
County-wide ordinance pertaining to leaving the barrels in the right-of-way.
The Chair reported having researched the Charleston County website to determine whether
they had any ordinances related to the times that recycle bins were to be placed for pickup and
removed afterward, but had been unable to locate anything. He suggested contacting
Charleston County about the issues.
Councilmember Carroll referred to Ms. Ballow’s request for recycling bins on the beach on the
island is a part of single-stream recycling. Director Pitts explained that the problem with
recycling bins on the beach is that it would be a labor-intensive project for the City to ensure that
everything in the bin was truly recyclable. Assistant Dziuban added that Charleston County will
not accept the materials unless everything is recyclable; there can be no stray diapers or food
waste, for instance. Therefore, the City would be tasked with sorting through the beach
recycling bins before the bins were emptied by Charleston County.
Councilmember Loftus inquired about a research source to learn how other beach communities
deal with recycling on the beach; Assistant Dziuban commented that she had fielded a query
from Myrtle Beach today on that subject.
Chair Buckhannon said that this was a subject that the Committee would continue to study.
Councilmember Loftus clarified that he saw the topi c as twofold, i.e. recycling on the island and
recycling on the beach. He also reminded the Committee that the subject had been placed on
the agenda in January to address one (1) particular resident who uses his recycling bin to
prevent people from parking in the right-of-way at his resident on Palm Boulevard.
Councilmember Loftus noted that the police have spoken with the resident, but he has not been
persuaded to roll the bin onto his property, and citizens do not understand why the problem
cannot be resolved.
B. Prioritization of Projects Greater than $250,000
The Committee was quick to agree that the first priority was the 42
nd to 52 nd Avenue drainage
project and that the second would be bike paths from Breach Inlet to 57 th Avenue. Discussion
on the bike path involved approaching the issue in phases, making a formal request to
Charleston County and including the engineering for the project in the budget.
As a result of further dialogue, the Committee reached a consensus on the third priority as
segregating and supporting the replacement of the li ghts at the Recreation ball fields from the
reconfiguration of the ball fields. The fourth selection was any phase of the under-grounding of
power lines as preparation for severe storm events; Chair Buckhannon commented that the City
would finance along with the SCE&G Non-standard Service Funds. The fifth priority was
increase of the Disaster Recovery Fund.
Public Works Committee
March 7, 2012
Page 3 of 10
C. Discussion of Ingress/Egress of Public Works Site
Although this project falls under the purview of the Real Property Committee, the topic is being
brought to this Committee as a result of the reconfiguration of the ingress/egress to the Public
Works site. Kelly Messier, the landscape architect hired by the City, is present to respond to
any questions or concerns about her recommendations for the site; Assistant Dziuban stated
that staff had asked Ms. Messier to investigate a change to the ingress/egress in hopes of
eliminating the trucks entering the site from Palm Boulevard. The conceptual drawings were
displayed to the Committee for review; the drawings show an angled entrance to Public Works
further down 13
th Avenue that circles to the present ingress. Assistant Dziuban explained that
the turn radius of the City’s large emergency vehicles has been taken into consideration and this
configuration is workable for all.
Councilmember Loftus asked whether the Public Works site was expanding; Director Pitts
explained that the site was expanding into th e area previously filled by the dog kennel and
police garage. The area to the rear is not expanding, and a natural buffer would exist between
the Public Works site and the properties behind it.
Responding to Councilmember Loftus’ questions about the type of surface for the driveway, the
Director said that it could be either asphalt or concrete, whichever was more feasible.
Councilmember Carroll asked if the entrance fr om Palm Boulevard would be eliminated, and
Assistant Dziuban answered that Ms. Messier had advised that people parking in the lot created
at the corner of 13
th Avenue and Palm Boulevard should have an exit without having to perform
a three-point turn in the confines of the lot to exit as they entered. Councilmember Loftus
countered that turning onto Palm Boulevard for visitors unfamiliar with the island would be a
safety hazard. In addition, the Palm Boulev ard entrance would provide an emergency entrance
for access to the fuel station at the Public Works site when necessary.
Councilmember Loftus noted that the costs for the project have not been discussed; Assistant
Dziuban stated that the project budget would be present to the Real Property Committee at their
meeting of March 13
th.
Before moving forward to New Business, Chair Buckhannon asked about the status of the pad
being constructed at the compactor. Director Pitts responded that the gravel had been
excavated and the concrete was to be poured on Friday; he has advised Front Beach busi-
nesses to use the J.C. Long entrance until Sunday. Carolina Waste will empty the compactor
on Thursday before the concrete is poured.
6. New Business
A. Review of Operating Budget for FY 2012-2013
Assistant Dziuban indicated that there are only a few changes to the Public Works operating
budget; they are bolded to be easily identifiable. Universally, the City’s operating budgets have
a three percent (3%) merit pool, which affects the FICA, retirement and workers’ compensation
lines as well. In addition, as foreshadowed last year, the addition of a Facilities Maintenance
Public Works Committee
March 7, 2012
Page 4 of 10
position is included in the Fy13 operating budget. Assistant Dziuban explained that five (5) of
the City’s properties – City Hall, Public Works, the Public Safety Building, Fire Station 2 and the
public restrooms – do not have anyone to perform r egular or proactive maintenance. The City’s
current practice for maintenance on these buildings is to address problems when seen or
identified to call a vendor to perform the needed service; at times, members of another
department are called upon to assist with minor maintenance issues.
Other increases include:
Memberships and dues 450
An increase of $50 to reflect actual expense.
Uniforms 7,425
In the past the City has purchased hoodies for the full-time employees; this has not been done for
three (3) years. The Director stated that they deserve the protection from the weather and for
safety purposes.
Medical and lab supplies 3,250
An increase of $250 for the replacement of safety gloves and glasses.
Temporary Labor 169,335
The increase is based on current usage of temporary workers, i.e. 6 temps for 4 days and 7
temps for 1 day.
Garbage cart procurement 7,600
Increase of $10 per barrel
Councilmember Loftus complimented Director Pitts by stating that the Public Works Department
had “performed better than any department in the City” based on the run rate for the past five
(5) years; he thanked the Director for the “exceptional work” he has done.
The Councilmember said that he could not support any increase in personnel because he did
not want to create a situation where taxes had to be increased. He stated that the only way he
would support the Facilities Maintenance position would be if another position in the City was
eliminated.
Councilmember Carroll asked Director Pitts if he thought this was a need for the City, and he
also asked for input from the department heads on the need. The Director responded that the
City now responds reactively, and he does see the benefit of someone who would have a
monthly checklist for each building. He commented that the replacement of the windows in City
Hall could have been avoided if the City had someone who checked the window sills routinely;
he added that he and the Building Department are called upon to handle issues related to the
public restrooms.
Councilmember Loftus continued with a question about the budget projection for overtime since
actual expenses through seven (7) months of the year have totaled twenty-five hundred
seventy-six dollars ($2,576). In his opinion, the budget should more nearly reflect the actual
expense incurred.
Public Works Committee
March 7, 2012
Page 5 of 10
Another issue for Councilmember Loftus was how the “electricity and gas” line item could be
less than half of the FY11 expense through seven (7) months of the fiscal year. Director Pitts
said that he thought that the difference was related to an audit that SCE&G had done of the
streetlights on the island, which the City is double-checking.
The Councilmember also was questioning why the “maintenance and contracts” expense was
again nearly five thousand dollars ($5,000) when less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) had
been spent in FY 11 and only six hundred dollars ($600) had been spent year-to-date in FY12.
Director Pitts reported that the software for the fueling system had not been renewed because it
is outdated, and the City budgeted for a new fuel system in FY12. Assistant Dziuban stated that
the composition of that line item be available for the next meeting.
Councilmember Loftus reminded the Director that he had mentioned that, with single-stream
recycling, he anticipates residents of the island wanting smaller rollout carts; therefore, he
wanted the price for smaller carts as well. Director Pitts indicated that he did not anticipate
much savings on the forty (40) gallon carts over the ninety (90) gallon carts.
Councilmember Carroll voiced curiosity about the budget of four thousand dollars ($4,000) with
only eight hundred dollars ($800) being spent year-to-date. The Director explained that another
sign order in this budget cycle would probabl y not exceed one thousand dollars ($1,000); he
added that most expensive part of sign replacement was the poles; the caps and tees are
twelve dollars ($12) each. Director Pitts indicated that he reuses the caps, tees and poles
whenever possible, but he has to be able to replace when vandals attack. The dollar amount is
a placeholder for the worst scenario.
Director Pitts explained that the number of truck loads has been halved by going to Bees Ferry
over 4B resulting in a cost savings to “contracted services.” He expressed the desire to
measure the savings from going to Bees Ferry in comparison to the service costs of going to
4B.
B. Discussion of Charges to Committee from Joint Meeting
1. Island-wide Signage
Chair Buckhannon initiated the discussion noting that the City Administrator had received a
response from SCDOT about the recommendations he had made relative to parking signage
overhead and on the roadway; Assistant Dziuban said that she had not seen the communi-
cation, therefore, could not respond to its content. Based on his understanding, the Chair said
that DOT was not the holdup; DOT has given the City the guidelines to decide what it can do
within that framework. Whatever the City deci des to do relative to this signage will still have to
be approved by SCDOT before any action can be taken. The Committee agreed that the City
should proceed with these, seemingly, simple signage solutions to direct visitors to the commer-
cial district for parking as soon as they arrive on the island.
Councilmember Loftus inquired about whether t he City had gotten any feedback from residents
on the “No Parking Here to Corner” signs that have been put up on Palm; Assistant Dziuban
indicated that the City has not gotten any reaction from citizens to her knowledge.
Public Works Committee
March 7, 2012
Page 6 of 10
Since it rained most of the previous weekend, Director Pitts thought the City might get input
after the coming weekend when spring break begins. Councilmember Loftus thought that
members of City Council would be interested in knowing how the new signs are being received.
Councilmember Loftus expressed his understanding of the charge to the Committee relative to
signage as one of making recommendations to Council for a component of a parking program.
The recent new signs could be considered as Step 1, and Step 2 should be signage to take
parking out of the neighborhoods. He expressed a desire to eliminate parking on Charleston,
Carolina and the finger streets and to force parking to the public lots. He suggested studying
the impact of the new restrictions on parking on Palm and the elimination of parking in the
neighborhoods for a year; in his opinion, these policies were more acceptable than rushing to a
pay-to-park system. The Councilmember thought the new signage should be used in conjunct-
tion with residential parking stickers that restrict the vehicle to a specific address.
Chair Buckhannon noted that the rights-of-way are only ten (10) feet wide making it very difficult
for vehicles to park safely.
Councilmember Carroll repeated his opinion that the City needs professional advice on the
parking issue.
When the topic of parking on Ocean Boulevard was introduced, Councilmember Loftus voiced
his opinion that parking should exist on Ocean Boulev ard to the extent of a specific number of
parallel parking spaces on the ocean-side should be created to meet the requirements of the
Beach Management Plan. This action would take the cars off Carolina and Charleston.
According to Director Kerr, the parking mandates of the Beach Management Plan are met in the
commercial district and a mile in either direction. The Plan would require six (6) spaces at each
of the beach accesses at 2
nd, 3rd and 4th Avenues on Ocean Boulevard, and the City would allow
only stickered residents’ vehicles to park on the avenues.
Chair Buckhannon inquired of Director Kerr the number of parking spaces required to be in
compliance with the Beach Management Plan with parking eliminated on Carolina, Charleston
and the avenues; Director Kerr said that basically the number was zero (0) because the Plan is
met through 5
th Avenue. Beyond that, the Plan calls for six (6) spaces per beach access path
for an eighth (1/8) of a mile in either direction or twenty-five (25) for a half (½) mile in either
direction; therefore, six (6) spaces at each of 2
nd, 3rd and 4th Avenues will suffice. The Director
informed the Committee that a standard, parallel parking space is required to be twenty (20) feet
long.
Director Kerr also indicated that the parking battle that must be won is not with the Beach
Management Plan, but with SCDOT. He recounted that, early in the Planning Commission’s
deliberations on parking, a representative of DOT attended a meeting and made it very clear
that the City could change from perpendicular to parallel parking if the action was in the name of
safety. But to make that change to eliminate or reduce parking would be allowed. A member of
the Commission at that time was an attorney who researched the issue and, in his legal opinion,
the City could fight that interpretation in court and prevail due to the language in the state
Public Works Committee
March 7, 2012
Page 7 of 10
statute. According to Director Kerr, the highway department has been very clear that the City
cannot eliminate parking spaces that now exist.
The previous dialogue caused Councilmember Carro ll to repeat the need for professional assis-
tance – someone who knows the nuances of SC DOT.
Councilmember Loftus remembered the legal opinion being that Isle of Palms, as a community,
has the right to make the determinations on how to manage parking. He voiced the opinion that
the City should be in a position to tell DOT what will be done rather than ask their permission.
Councilmember Carroll was in favor of going from perpendicular parking on the numbered
streets to parallel parking for safety reasons and no parking on Charleston and Carolina.
Assistant Dziuban commented that the parking on the numbered streets today is primarily
parallel. Director Kerr described parking on those streets as a “free-for-all,” in that, if it fits, it is
parked.
Councilmember Loftus suggested that parking be addressed street by street with no parking on
Charleston and Carolina; he recommended squeezing the parking availability forcing people to
the municipal lots and giving relief to the island’s residents.
Director Kerr noted that Carolina is far enough from the beach accesses that it is not included in
the Beach Management Plan, but SC DOT will be a problem.
Councilmember Loftus remarked that the residential parking decals would be important to
implement resident only parking on Carolina and Charleston; he would like to see the program
in place by April 2013. Director Kerr commented that tying the parking changes to a decal
system complicate matters for the City; Assist ant Dziuban noted that the parking decals will
require more enforcement from the Police Depa rtment. Primarily parking enforcement is done
by the Beach Services Officers in the summe r months because patrol officers are too busy
responding to emergency calls, and, of course, any system is not effective if not enforced.
Director Kerr suggested getting agreements from the residents of Charleston and Carolina that
no parking, including the residents, is better than parking yet having the problems continue
would avoid the decal system and streamline the suggestion a great deal. The issue then
becomes one of completing the paperwork for DOT and signage.
Philosophically, Councilmember Loftus summed up the discussion as the Committee desirous
of restricting parking in the neighborhoods with a means of managing it and addressing public
parking on the streets and avenue on a street-by-street basis.
B. Path at Citadel Beach Club
Director Kerr explained that the Planning Commission’s goal was finding available space that
would not be offensive to the property owners where cars could go to satisfy the Beach
Management Plan in exchange for eliminating vehicles elsewhere. The situation is that 47
th and
48th Avenues are private roads; twenty-five (25) spaces exist at 42nd Avenue; at 56th Avenue,
Public Works Committee
March 7, 2012
Page 8 of 10
vehicles are accommodated on the Palm Boulevard right-of-way. The concept was to allow
cars on Palm Boulevard adjacent to the Citadel Beach Club’s fence on the right-of-way and to
give them access to the beach with a walkway along the edge of the Citadel’s property. To do
this would likely entail the installation of a new fence on their property and a corral directing
people to the beach which would allow approximately twenty (20) vehicles in that section of
Palm Boulevard. If this could be accomplished, three (3) areas of parking would exist at the
northern end of the island and parking could be eliminated at the finger streets.
The Director stated that the Citadel would need to grant the City an easement.
Councilmember Loftus noted that the Citadel has a private beach, and he did not envision them
opening it up to visitors.
Director Pitts commented that the residents of 48
th Avenue have serious flooding issues, but
they will not be included in the newest phase of drainage infrastructure because the road is
private. Therefore, the opportunity of inclusion in the drainage may be the enticement for them
to deed the road to the City which the City could then include in a parking management plan.
Director Pitts’ suggestion provides the Committee with a fallback option assuming that the
Citadel Beach Club is not receptive to granting an easement.
3. Obstructions in the Right-of-Way
Assistant Dziuban reflected on the fact that this topic has been on the table for quite some time;
many of the obstructions in the rights-of-way are old and expensive. The rights-of-way are
state-owned, and the state says that the rights-of-way cannot be obstructed, but the state does
not have an enforcement mechanism in place or t hey choose not to use it. The City could pass
legislation to increase its ability to enforce the obstructions, but past Councils have not wanted
to take said action because it would be most unpopular.
Chair Buckhannon stated his opinion that a prime area of concern is Palm Boulevard between
21
st and 41st Avenue. People appreciate the depth of the right-of-way on the inland side of Palm
Boulevard, but fail to recognize that the same amount of right-of-way exists on the ocean-side.
He pointed out that a quasi-ditch exists on the ocean-side and suggested that piping the ditch
would open up Palm to a visually deeper right-of-way.
Councilmember Carroll commented that the effects of new signage and the possibility of parking
in the area of the Citadel Beach Club could make significant enough changes to make the
obstructions in the rights-of-way a non-issue.
Councilmember Loftus expressed the opinion that the City had to be vigilant about allowing no
more encroachments into the right-of-way. Director Kerr explained that there is no mechanism
in the City Code for enforcement; ordinances were introduced several years back, but were not
adopted. The Director noted that the City Attorney has given an opinion on the subject stating
that a traffic officer could write a five dollar ($5) ticket for blocking the right-of-way.
Public Works Committee
March 7, 2012
Page 9 of 10
Councilmember Loftus believes that the City must have the force of law to enforce its
regulations; therefore, he would like for City Council to consider an ordinance empowering
enforcement. Staff posed the question about the legality of an ordinance that would only
enforce against new encroachments and did not enforce against all encroachments.
Director Kerr explained that, at the present time, all encroachments into the DOT right-of-way
are reported to DOT, and they deal with the most egregious violations.
In concluding the discussion, Chair Buckhannon asked that the earlier ordinance be brought
back to Council for review and charged Director Pitts with resolving the issues related to the
quasi-ditch; Director Pitts stated that the piping of that ditch will require SCDOT approval.
C. Consideration of Contracts in Excess of $10,000
Consideration of Award of Contract to PermaTrak in the amount of $43,290 for
Materials for Replacement of Public Restrooms Beach Access
Assistant Dziuban reminded the Committee that eighty thousand dollars ($80,000) has been
included in the FY12 budget for repair or replacement of dune walkovers; after evaluating the
walkovers on the island, Directors Kerr and Pitts agreed that the walkover behind the public
restroom is most in need of replacement. The existing walkway is pine, but the recommend-
dation from staff is to replace it with PermaTrak, which is a concrete material that is environ-
mentally friendly and requires a minimum of maintenance. This walkover is the most trafficked
on the island.
Chair Buckhannon asked whether the PermaTrak would be for the deck or for the system;
Director Pitts responded that the entire system would be PermaTrak.
Councilmember Loftus asked how many walkovers are on the island; Director Pitts answered
that there are four (4). The Councilmember followed up by asking if Director Pitts intended to
use PermaTrak to replace all of them or was the material being considered for this walkover due
to the volume of use; the Director said that the latter was true. He further questioned whether
the PermaTrak had been approved by the regulatory agencies; Director Kerr said that it had
been approved from a materials standpoint, but staff is working through the elevation over the
dunes with OCRM. Director Pitts explained that the issue with OCRM is the primary dune issue.
When asked if the product had a longer lifespan, Director Kerr stated that the product was
actually concrete; Director Pitts described it as a “Lincoln log” concrete. The projected lifespan
is forty to fifty (40-50) years; the City currently gets four (4) years from pine.
Other areas with close proximity to the City th at have used this material are in Hilton Head,
Nashville and Myrtle Beach.
MOTION: Chair Buckhannon moved to recommend to Ways and Means the
award of a contract in the amount of $43,290 to PermaTrak for materials for the
replacement of the public restrooms beach access; Councilmember Carroll
seconded.
Public Works Committee
March 7, 2012
Page 10 of 10
Although the labor costs for this endeavor are currently unknown, staff is confident that the
walk-over can be replaced using the PermaTrak under budget.
Councilmember Loftus expressed reluctance in approving this product because it is not in
widespread use.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
7. Miscellaneous Business
Councilmember Carroll asked if the catch basis at 35
th Avenue and Hartnett has been replaced;
Director Pitts said that Charleston County has not yet completed the work.
Next Meeting Date: 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, April 10, 2012 in City Hall Conference Room.
8. Adjourn
MOTION: Chair Buckhannon moved to adjourn the meeting at 6:30 p.m.;
Councilmember Carroll seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.