February 6 (PDF, 32.81 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
REAL PROPERTY COMMITTEE
5:00 p.m., Monday, February 6, 2012
The regular meeting of the Real Property Committee was held at 5:00 p.m. on Monday,
February 6, 2012 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Buckhannon and Stone, Chair Loftus,
Administrator Tucker, Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban and Clerk Copeland; a quorum
was present to conduct business. Invited guests for the meeting were Steven Traynum and
Haiqing Liu Kaczkowski of Coastal Science and Engineering (CSE) and Public Works Director
Pitts.
1. Chair Loftus called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
were duly notified in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Stone moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of January 6, 2012 and the Special Meeting of January 30, 2012 as
submitted; Councilmember Buckhannon seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Comments from Marina Tenants – No marina tenants attended the meeting.
5. Old Business
A. Update on Beach Restoration Shoal Management Project by Steven
Traynum of Coastal Science and Engineering
Mr. Traynum’s handout is attached to the historical record of the meeting.
Administrator Tucker related that, while in the process of developing the bid documents for the
Shoal Management Project, Mr. Traynum had met with her to inform her of dynamics that were
developing in the project area, and the Administrator wanted everyone to be aware of those
dynamics because it may influence the timing of future projects.
In the presentation, Mr. Traynum reviewed the conditions prior to and after the 2008 renou-
rishment project and described the process of erosion that occurs when a shoal attaches to the
shoreline. Following an animated visual forecasting the movement of a shoal landward, Mr.
Traynum explained that the shoal will be very close to the beach in a couple of years causing
the area behind it to build out and the areas beside it to erode creating the need for another
project.
Administrator Tucker inquired about the level of interest CSE has gotten from potential bidders
on the 2012 Shoal Management Project; he responded that four (4) sets of plans had been sent
out and others have said they will come to City Hall to review them. The mandatory pre-bid
meeting will be Thursday, February 9.
Real Property Committee
February 6, 2012
Page 2 of 8
The presentation was summarized as follows:
• Project is designed in anticipation of landward migration and attachment of an offshore
shoal over the next 2-3 years;
• Sand will be moved from attachment site to adjacent site;
• Single project is not a long-term solution, rather part of a maintenance strategy; and
• Further migration may be required once the shoal approaches the beach.
Administrator Tucker emphasized the need to inform the public that the 2012 project will not
cause what beach erosion occurs with the next shoal attachment in two to three (2-3) years.
Assuming CSE’s predictions are correct, another project will be required in a couple of years to
prevent beach conditions from deteriorating to 2008 conditions. A primary focus to the public
needs to be that the City is being proactive to prevent conditions on the beach from getting as
severe as before the 2008 project when beachfront homes were jeopardized.
According to the Administrator, an issue that the City needs to be concerned about is that no
source of funds has been identified for a renourishment project beyond the 2012 project; staff
anticipates the remaining funds from the 2008 project to be exhausted with the current task.
Mr. Traynum added that each subsequent monitoring – the next one in June or July 2012 – will
provide data for refining the predictions of the movement of the shoal attachment.
Councilmember Stone commented that a renourishment project on the north end of the island
would be funded primarily by Wild Dunes residents; he doubted that the City could garner funds
from Charleston County or the State.
Administrator Tucker expressed the opinion that this future project should be foreshadowed at
the upcoming annual meeting of the Wild Dunes Community Association (WDCA); they need to
be aware that funds are available for the current project, but funds must be assembled for any
future project.
Mr. Traynum will be making a similar presentation to the WDCA annual meeting; Dave Kynoski,
the association manager, sent Mr. Traynum the following questions to be answered:
• What amount of sand is in the project area?
• What is the configuration of the current shoal?
• What is the project?
• What are the expectations from the project?
As an aside, the Administrator informed the Committee that the bid documents do not allow for
work over Easter weekend; Mr. Traynum added that no work will be allowed on Sundays and
hours are restricted on Saturdays.
Chair Loftus asked if the project two or three (2-3) years hence would be similar in scope and
cost to the 2012 project; Mr. Traynum replied that, if the shoal sand is accessible with land-
based equipment, the project would probably be larger. He added that the larger the project,
the longer it tends to last, because it tends to fix the cause more; he noted that any project
should be designed for the protection of the structures and the habitat.
Real Property Committee
February 6, 2012
Page 3 of 8
When Administrator Tucker asked Mr. Traynum whether DHEC had issued the permit, Mr.
Traynum reported that he had spoken with their office earlier in the day and been told that the
biological monitoring would not be required and that the paperwork has been passed up the
chain of command. He hopes to have the permit by the time the bids are opened Friday,
February 17.
B. Update on Marina Dredging
The Administrator reported that the pilings have been removed; per Assistant Dziuban, they are
not stored on-site because the boat could not get access to the boat ramp to deposit them as
instructed by the marina manager. The pilings remain the property of the City, but are being
stored, for the time being and at no cost to the City, in McClellanville at the offices of the
company that removed them.
Chair Loftus expressed concern that the pilings were not on-site as the Committee had directed.
The City has received the bill for removing them for three thousand dollars ($3,000) as quoted;
there was no charge for the relocation.
Councilmember Stone suggested that the pilings be returned to the marina for storage on-site
as soon as the dredging has been accomplished.
Assistant Dziuban stated that the contract states that the project must be complete by April 10.
C. Project Worksheet for Activities Related to 1207 and 1301 Palm Boulevard
Recounting actions taken at Ways and Means, Administrator Tucker noted that fifty-five hundred
dollars ($5,500) had been approved for the project from the Tree Fund, but no action had been
taken on the balance estimated to complete the project. Staff wanted to have a more accurate
estimate based on the plans from the landscape architect before seeking additional funding.
The staff has another planning meeting scheduled for February 7.
Chair Loftus asked about the square footage of 1301 Palm Boulevard; the Administrator indi-
cated that she did not know. Chair Loftus expr essed concern over the cost estimates because
they are three times (3x) the costs of improvements to the United Methodist Church’s (UMC)
property when the UMC property appears to be three times (3x) the size of the City’s.
Administrator Tucker repeated comments from the Ways and Means meeting that costs would
not be known until the landscape architect had completed her design relative to parking and
traffic flow suggestions from staff. The Administrator remarked that staff wanted to accomplish
the goals for the least amount of money.
D. Update on Paving Near Front Beach Compactor in Municipal Lot
The Administrator informed the Committee that the Public Works Committee was also dis-
cussing this issue; members of both committees expressed a desire to view the area in ques-
tion, and staff was asked to learn how other businesses are dealing with the issue.
Real Property Committee
February 6, 2012
Page 4 of 8
In talking with other Front Beach restaurants, staff learned that businesses, other than Coconut
Joe’s are having problems maneuvering to the compactor; some restaurants are using the
yellow wagons and are reporting problems getting through the parking lot surface.
Director Pitts got additional estimates for the concrete pad proposed at a previous meeting; the
lowest bid came in at thirty-nine hundred dollars ($3,900). The cost can be covered in the FY12
Front Beach maintenance budget from Municipal Accommodations Fees; the balance in that
line is approximately forty-seven thousand dollars ($47,000).
Chair Loftus asked when the lot had last been resurfaced; the Administrator said that the past
resurfacing was done with the completion of the Public Safety Building. The previous surface
was gravel and dirt, but different from what is there now.
With the flooding problems that the island experiences, Chair Loftus expressed reluctance at
adding another impervious surface. He reported that he had visited the location and could ima-
gine the problems that the restaurants are having; he thought that the surface was entirely
wrong for hauling heavy volumes of garbage through. The Chair asked about scraping off the
existing surface and replacing it with hard-packed gravel/shell similar to the other parking lot;
that would keep the surface natural and would be more cost effective.
Director Pitts indicated that shell sand required on-going maintenance; replacing it annually
would cost approximately one thousand dollars ($1,000).
The thirty-nine hundred dollar ($3,900) bid calls for three thousand (3,000) psi fiber re-enforced
concrete six (6) inches thick with control joints.
Relative to the issues the restaurants reported, the Banana Cabana uses a yellow wagon and
reports difficulty, and Huck’s uses the yello w wagon and gets major reports from employees
about pulling it through the lot due to the depth and unevenness of the surface material.
The Chair expressed no difficulty understanding the problems, but he wanted to find a more
cost effective solution that does not require concrete. He queried whether black top would be
less expensive; Director Pitts said he had gotte n quotes for black top at fifty-five hundred and
fifty-nine hundred dollars seventy-five dollars ($5,500 and 5,975).
Director Pitts repeated that any type of rock surface would require future maintenance and
expressed the opinion that the fiber re-enforced concrete was the cheapest solution.
Administrator Tucker stated that she and Director Pitts were in agreement that the thirty-nine
hundred dollar ($3,900) re-enforced concrete would save the City money in maintenance and,
since the City has not been put on notice of a problem, in potential expenses related to an
injury.
Councilmember Buckhannon noted that any action needed to be done soon because the SEWE
Wildlife Expo was next week and that event has historically been the unofficial start of the tourist
season.
Real Property Committee
February 6, 2012
Page 5 of 8
MOTION: Councilmember Stone moved to approve $3,900 from Municipal
Accommodations Fees for the concrete pad and path to the Front Beach
compactor; Councilmember Buckhannon seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
6. New Business
A. Review of Capital Budgets for FY2012-2013 and Long Range Capital Plan
Administrator Tucker indicated that the review of capital budgets was the first step in the annual
budget process; she reminded the members that capital budgets are prepared primarily on the
basis of items that are expected to come up because of their position in the capital equipment
rotation cycle.
Front Beach Area, including Public Restrooms, Parking Meters and Parking Lots
Replace/refurbish benches, trash receptacles, information kiosks $2,000
Normal replacement
Facility Maintenance – normal replacement/refurbishment
Replace street signs, parking signs, poles (approximately 75) 2,500
Maintain public restrooms, plumbing, electrical, etc. 7,500
Parking kiosk and ticketing device maintenance 7,500
ER callbox maintenance 1,650
Annual parking lot maintenance (fill material, grading) 1,000
Maintain irrigation system for parking lo ts & Front Beach green space 2,500
Maintain electrical systems, landscape lighting, etc. 2,500
Resurface (patching) City-owned portion of Ocean Blvd. 5,000
Sidewalk & brick repair on City-owned po rtion of Ocean Blvd. 5,000
Resod and refurbish green spaces 5,000
Chair Loftus questioned that the resodding and refurbishing of green spaces was in the FY12
budget; Administrator Tucker explained that items listed under “Facility Maintenance” are place-
holders to have money available when the job is required to be done.
In addition, the Chair inquired about the frequency of use of the ER callbox; in this age of cell
phones, he suggested that the callbox was no longer needed. The Administrator replied that
the Police Department should have information on its usage and she would follow-up.
Beach Restoration and Monitoring
The Administrator commented that this budget foreshadows the future project referred to earlier
in the meeting for which there is not identified source of funding. Resonding to the Chair’s
question as to why it is included in the FY13 budget, Administrator Tucker explained that the
City could not enter into a project without money and assembling the money would have to
occur in FY!3 for a project in FY13 or FY14. In addition, the need to assemble funding becomes
a part of the work plan for the year by its inclusion in the budget.
Real Property Committee
February 6, 2012
Page 6 of 8
Councilmember Stone envisioned being in a budget preparation meeting this time next year,
FY13, with a project looming in FY14; the money would need to be in place for a project to
occur. The Administrator concurred; the City could not seek any type of contract – engineering
or anything else – without having the money in the bank to pay for the contract.
Sand fencing and escarpment removal as necessary 2,500
Potential Post-project requirements for FY Shoal Mgmt Project 100,000
Potential focused erosion project in FY13 (funding not identified) 600,000
Ongoing monitoring of shoreline (3 yr contract = $160,702) 61,410
Additional reserve for future beach restoration projects 100,000
Councilmember Stone asked the source of funding for the three (3) year monitoring contract;
Administrator Tucker stated that this monitoring contract was paid in full by the City and
encompassed the entire beach front.
Isle of Palms Marina
According to the Administrator, the items included for FY13 were re-budgeted from FY12.
Design & permitting of new watersports/waverunner docks 25,000
Design & permitting for new docks (permit process take s up to 1 year) 50,000
Improve newer docks on Intercoast al Waterway 75,000
Chair Loftus stated that, from being at the marina last week and looking at the City docks on the
Intercoastal Waterway, he did not see the ne ed for improvements to them. Councilmember
Stone asked if this was to extend the finger piers.
The Administrator was unsure of the reasoning behind this line item and said she would look
into it for the March meeting when operating budgets are presented.
Councilmember Stone digressed and asked whether all marina tenants were current with their
obligations to the City; Administrator Tucker reported that one (1) tenant is past due with
January rent.
Councilmember Stone expressed the opinion that t he tenant is “holding the City’s money” and
that the tenant needs to be held responsible for the lease they negotiated to avoid this situation.
When asked what the next step would be, the Administrator said she would send a default
notice as outlined in the lease, and the tenant would have a prescribed number of days in which
to respond. Administrator Tucker said that one (1) reason this action has not been taken is that
the tenant will respond by bringing a check to make them current.
The Administrator added that two (2) tenants are past due in sending the City their annual gross
receipts reports, on which additional rent payments are calculated, and she said that the tenants
have been reminded that they are past due. The Committee agreed that these tenants should
be sent default notices as well.
Real Property Committee
February 6, 2012
Page 7 of 8
B. Prioritization of Projects Greater than $250,000
Administrator Tucker recalled that this list was last reviewed in 2009 and, at the March meeting,
staff wants the Committee to establish its top five (5) projects as a way of providing direction to
staff for things to get done.
Chair Loftus questioned that green space acquisitions and a roundabout at 41
st Avenue were on
the list. Since the roundabout would require th e City to condemn land, cost between eleven
hundred thousand and thirteen hundred thousand dollars ($1,100,000 and $1,300,000) and the
new configuration is working well, he did not understand why it had been added back to the
schedule.
The Administrator explained that the primary reasons for adding items back to the list are the
new composition of Council and to show the type of projects that are considered.
Chair Loftus suggested that the only way a 41
st Avenue roundabout should be discussed in the
future would be when the intersection is not functioning property, and, as for the green space
acquisitions, he opined that citizens of the island would question the decision –making process
of City Council to see it being considered.
Assistant Dziuban stated that members should feel free to add projects to the list, for example,
Director Pitts’ suggestion for the replacement of the Front Beach restrooms.
Administrator Tucker stated that the priority list from each committee would be compiled for a
single priority list to be announced at the March Ways and Means Committee meeting.
Chair Loftus referred to discussion at the Public Works Committee meeting in January about the
need for more and improved bike lanes on the island. He asked if a conflict existed between the
City’s request for a bike lane on the Connector and the Committee’s expression of the need for
improvements to bike lanes from Breach Inlet to 57
th Avenue.
The Administrator explained that, other than inquiries made by the City, part of the initiative for a
bike lane on the Connector is coming from a biking organization that is pushing Charleston
County and other entities for more bike paths throughout the County; the biking organization
specifically referred to the IOP Connector as being in need of a bike lane. When the various
configurations for a Connector bike lane were reviewed by the Public Safety Committee, certain
questions came up that needed resolution before the Committee would be prepared to take a
recommendation to City Council. Those concerns were the need to maintain the ten (10) foot
wide center lane to accommodate emergency vehicles and a desire not to raise the height of the
side railings; Richard Turner from Charleston County is in discussions with Dickie Schweers and
SC DOT for a response to the Committee’s concerns
On the subject of bike lanes from Breach Inlet to 57
th Avenue, the topic has not been discussed
by the full Council; as stated, bike lanes were discussed in the January Public Works meeting
and have been advocated by another member of Counc il. In addition, the City Administrator
has not made any approaches to funding agencies relative to that. Based on those statements,
the Administrator noted that the two (2) projects could be competing for the same dollar.
Real Property Committee
February 6, 2012
Page 8 of 8
Chair Loftus commented that opening up to bike traffic without the proper infrastructure on the
island to handle it “would be a recipe for disaster.” The Chair believes that a serious public
safety problem exists on the island already with the number of bikers on the road, and to invite
more bikers without the necessary infrastructure is “putting the cart before the horse.”
The Chair asked what could be done with Green Space money “for the betterment of the
island.” Administrator Tucker responded that the City has not taken any steps relative to the
Green Space money since being told not to pursue the acquisition of the property located at
3206 Palm Boulevard. Chair Loftus added that the project did not have public support, and, if
the City cannot find a way to use the funds, he is of the opinion that Charleston County will find
a way to take the funds away from the City. He suggested that the “full weight of the City (be
placed) behind one or two (1 or 2) ideas” that are acceptable to the County.
Councilmember Stone stated a desire to have som eone from the County who is all-knowing
about the Green Space funds to address Council and to answer questions. He indicated that
Council, in general, does not understand what the acceptable uses of Green Space funds are.
The Administrator said she could arrange such a presentation and urged him, in the interim, to
go to the County’s Greenbelt website because it contains excellent information.
Administrator Tucker confirmed the Chair notion that the City has a finite amount of Green
Space funds and that they are not going to increase.
C. Consideration of Award of Contracts in Excess of $10,000 – None
7. Miscellaneous Business
Marina Rents Report – discussed earlier in the meeting
Next Meeting Date: 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, March 13, 2012, City Hall Conference Room
8. Executive Session – not needed
9. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Buckhannon moved to adjourn the meeting at 6:23
p.m.; Councilmember Stone seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.