January 4 (PDF, 77.35 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
ACCOMMODATIONS TAX ADVISORY COMMITTEE
11:00 a.m., Wednesday, January 4, 2012
The regular meeting of the Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee was held at 11:00
a.m. on Wednesday, January 4, 2012 in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm
Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Caroli na. Attending the meeting were Committee
members Jim Covington, Frances Russell, Ma rgaret Miller, Davi d Nelson and Sandy
Ferencz, Administrator Tucker, Treasurer Suggs, Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban
and Clerk Copeland. The absences of Malc olm Burgis and Mary Alice Kruesi were
excused; a quorum was present to conduct business.
1. In the absence of a chair, Administrato r Tucker called the meeting to order and
acknowledged that the pre ss and public had been duly not ified of the meeting in
accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Election of Chair and Vice Chair
Opening the nominations for Chair, Mr. Nelson submitted Sandy Ferencz for considera-
tion, and Ms. Miller seconded the nomination. Ms. Ferencz was unanimously elected
Chair.
Upon assuming her role as Chair, Ms. Fe rencz nominated Malcolm Burgis as Vice
Chair; Mr. Nelson seconded the nomination and the vote was unanimous in support of
Mr. Burgis.
3. Approval of Previ ous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Mr. Nelson moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of October 4, 2011 as subm itted; Mr. Covington seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
4. Citizen’s Comments
Primarily for the new members of the Co mmittee, Administrato r Tucker introduced
Councilmember Jimmy Carroll, who has served on the ATAX Committee and was sworn
in as a member of City Council the previous evening. Perrin Lawson of the Charleston
Visitors Bureau was introduced, as well as Recreation Director Page, Finance Officer
Debbie Suggs, Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban and Clerk Copeland.
5. Financial Statement – Treasurer Suggs
In an attempt to avail the newly appointed me mbers of the best s ource for information
on the ATAX rules, regulations and links to state law, Tr easurer Suggs provided the
Committee members with a copy of the home page for the Tourism Expenditure Review
Committee, as well as her email address and direct phone line.
Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee
January 4, 2012
Page 2 of 8
The financial statement for discussion covers the fiscal year through December 31,
2011, or six (6) months of the fiscal year. The balance sheet shows that cash at BB&T
exceeds six hundred seventy-fi ve thousand dollars ($675,000) and cash invested with
the Local Government Investment Pool (LGIP ) exceeds six hundred forty-five thousand
dollars ($645,000); Treasurer Suggs informed the Committee that the LGIP is admin-
istered by the State Treasurer’s Office. As a municipal government, the City is limited to
the type of investments it c an make; with the investment pool , the City can maximize its
investments and be assu red of investing in those things that ar e allowed under state
law. In addition, the interest is slightly higher than what the City can receive locally, and
the money is available to the City with twenty-four (24) hours’ notice.
The thirty-eight thousand dollars ($38,000) refe rred to as “amounts due to other funds”
is money due to the General Fund from the most recent payment to the City from the
state.
Also noted on the Balance Sheet are the interest rates the Cit y is currently receiving on
investments with BB&T and LGIP.
On the Revenue Statement are the interest received from both BB&T and the LGIP and
the funds from the state for the quarter ending September 2011. The Treasurer
explained that the amount that the City receives in State ATAX funds equals two
percent (2%) of accommodations revenue generated on the Isle of Palms less an
amount the state withholds to distribute to municipalit ies that do not generate
accommodations revenue and less a percentage that the state re tains. In addition, the
state withholds an additional amount from the September quarter in order to let the year
play out to be trued-up at the end of the fiscal year.
Of the balance paid to the City, the first tw enty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) paid to
the City annually goes into th e General Fund, as well as five percent (5%) of the
remainder. Sixty-five percent (65%) of that balance goes into the ATAX fund that this
Committee oversees with the remaining thirty percent (30%) paid to the Charleston
Visitors Bureau (CVB) and referred to as t he Tourism Promotion funds. The CVB uses
this amount along with funds from other local governments to promote the general area.
The specific figures attributed to the Sept ember 2011 payment are shown in the first
column of the spreadsheet entitled “SC A ccommodations Tax – Distribution of Funds
Received.” Treasurer Suggs remarked that the September quarter is typically the
highest grossing quarter for the City.
Mr. Covington asked whether th e City was required to pay t hese funds to the CVB; the
Treasurer responded that the Cit y was required, under state la w, to use this specific
percentage to promote tour ism and, since the City does not have its own tourism
promotion organization, the CVB serves that need.
Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee
January 4, 2012
Page 3 of 8
Administrator Tucker added that, in the past, the City had participated with the expense
of the Mount Pleasant Visitor’s Center, so the funds went to maintain that center which
was staffed by CVB personnel.
Mr. Covington followed up by a sking at what point the City could justify having its own
tourism promotion organization; the Administrator replied th at the current amount could
conceivably justify it. On the other hand, the CVB has the people infrastructure in place,
has the national and internationa l media contacts, etc. which would be difficult for the
City to match on its own. Administrato r Tucker added that the City’s having its own
tourism promotion organization “was not outs ide the realm of possibility in the future,”
but “the CVB does give excellent service to the City.” The CVB is required to provide
the City with a copy of their annual audit and to tell the City what it is getting for its
funding. In addition, the Administrator receiv es a weekly electronic communication that
tells what the week’s level of tourism ac tivity for the entire Charleston area; this
communique also reports on the kinds of promotional events and promotional
opportunities that are taking place in the area along with what targeting has been done.
The end of the report is a listing of positive press and accolades received by the entities
that make up the CVB, such as the City’s Best Restored Beach Award. The CVB is cur-
rently working on a better data base to bette r track occupancy in the vacation rental
market.
Mr. Covington asked what perce ntage of the total CVB budget came from the Isle of
Palms; Mr. Lawson reported t hat IOP contributes approxim ately four hundred thousand
dollars ($400,000) of an elev en million dollar ($11,000,000) annual budget; he stated
that the CVB interprets the local government participation as an investment to leverage
an eleven million dollar ($11, 000,000) organization. Administrator Tucker stated
participating local governments include the citi es of Charleston and North Charleston,
Isle of Palms, Kiawah, Mount Pleasant and Seabrook.
Before moving to expenditures from the AT AX fund, Treasurer Su ggs commented that
the “Distribution” spreadsheet also indicates trends in accommodations funding over
several years.
The Treasurer stated that she reviews expenditures at each meeting, keying in on those
expenditures that have occurred in the last quarter. For the Front Beach restrooms, the
cleaning service is paid eight y-nine dollars ($89) per day to maintain the restrooms as
many hours as the restrooms ar e open to the public. Since these restrooms are for the
visitors to the island, one hundred percent ( 100%) of the costs associated with them,
from supplies to electricity, are paid fr om State ATAX funds. Schupp Enterprises has
contracted with the City to empty the trash barrels on the beach from end to end and at
Front Beach, as well as to fill holes that are dug on the beach. State ATAX funds pay
for t-shirts given to visitors who have checked the City’s website and come to City Hall;
Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee
January 3, 2012
Page 4 of 8
it is a very popular promoti on and allows the City to capture visitor information in
database for a visitors’ newsletter. In addi tion ATAX funds pay for the irrigation at
Breach Inlet, an annual contribution to the Sp oleto Festival, as well as support for
events on the island such as the Lowcountry Blues Bash, the Isle of Palms Beach Run,
the annual Connector Run and July 4 th Fireworks. In rece nt years and with full
Committee support, the ATAX funds simply act a sponsor for the event and any
revenues generated by the Beach Run are given to the Recreation Department Building
Fund.
Mr. Covington asked why the Beach Run was hel d in July when the island is full of
visitors already rather than May or October when tourists are fe w. Director Page
responded that, at one time, the Beach Run had been held in October – close to the
Connector Run – and people tended to confuse the two (2) events. By having the
Beach Run in July, many island tourists choose to participate and return year after year
in July to be a part of the Beach Run. T he date is not written in stone, but the timing
has worked well in recent years. Based on his experience, Mr. Covington pointed out
that rental properties are ty pically booked solidly from Memorial Day until school starts
in the fall, but the rental pr operties are empty the rest of the year. He suggested that
the City could generate more accommodations taxes if, for exampl e, the Beach Run
were in late March or April.
Mr. Covington asked whether the City had cons idered New Year’s Eve fireworks as a
way to tip the scales in the Isle of Palms’ fa vor over Folly Beach or Myrtle Beach. As
budget preparations ar e about to begin, the Administra tor stated that the staff had
discussed the possibility of inco rporating fireworks with t he tree lighting ceremony in
December to kick-off the holiday season to benefit the island’s businesses, but they
would have to be funded. Discussions had also taken place about expanding the
lighting on the island for the holidays to the marina, for exam ple, to draw people to the
island during the holiday season.
Other expenses paid through AT AX funds are the on-going moni toring of the beach,
reserving funds for future beach renour ishment projects and a one-third ( ⅓) of the
marina debt. Additional events funded thr ough ATAX are the Sand Sculpting Contest
and Piccolo Spoleto Goes to the Beach/State Production.
The City will purchase one patrol vehicle and a Public Works pickup truck, as well as
four (4) sets of body armor for the Poli ce Department and a Z-track mower for the
Recreation Department. At the request of Council, t he 2009 Mack garbage truck was
paid off early and one-third ( ⅓) of that was paid from AT AX. Eighty thousand dollars
($80,000) has been set aside to repair or re place dune walkovers, and the purchase of
one (1) radio repeater is included in the ATAX budget. State law allows the City to fund
Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee
January 3, 2012
Page 5 of 8
one-third (⅓) of Public Works equipment leases and one-quarter (¼) of lease payments
for fire trucks; the municipal leases the City has transfer ownership of the equipment to
the City at the end of the lease. On page 6 of the expense statement are the lease
payments from the ATAX budget for the ladder truck, pum per/ladder truck, two (2)
garbage packers, the Caterpillar and the 2010 pumper on page 7. The purchase of a
new boat for the Fire Department was parti ally funded through ATAX funds. For the
Fire Department, State ATAX funded a the rmal imaging camera and anti-exposure
suits, as well as add itional personnel during the summer months. All expenses related
to the City’s website are f unded from ATAX money. Other items funded include the
Easter egg hunt, the beach trash cans, the annual tree lighting and the pooper-scooper
dispensers and supplies. One-third ( ⅓) of the cost of design and permitting for the
upcoming marina dredging project will come from ATAX money. The design and half of
the construction costs related to the pr oposed parking nodes on Ocean Boulevard was
to come from ATAX; that project has been put on-hold indefinitely. In addition, the
Committee approved a one-time c ontribution of fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000) for a
study at Patriots Point. Each year the Co mmittee has an amount of money that can be
used at its discretion and with the approval of City Council for events, projects or
programs that it believes w ill increase tourism on the isla nd; the balance remaining in
that budget line item is just short of fifty-three thousand dollars ($53,000).
Administrator Tucker spoke again regarding holding the fireworks display at another
time of year since the Isle of Palms is typically full of visitors already on July 4
th with
both vacation renters and day-only visitors. Staff discussed holding the fireworks
display at another time in lieu of the July 4the event.
When Mr. Covington asked about the parki ng nodes, the Administrator reported that,
although the funds will likely not be spent on nodes , staff is considering using a portion
of those funds to pay for improved signage related to parking – su ch an action would
require Council approval.
In conclusion, Treasurer Suggs review ed the schedule headed “Revenue and Expense
Projection for the Year Ending 6/30/12;” she explai ned that this schedule takes into
consideration estimated annual revenue, in terest and sale of assets, less budgeted
expenditures and other expend itures approved by the Co mmittee to arrive at an
estimated year-end balance with the surplus/def icit from the previo us year considered
as well.
Administrator Tucker added that the City is required by law to turnover ATAX funds
every two (2) years; therefore, the City has subscribed the poli cy that the first cash in is
the first cash spent. That policy has served t he City well in its reporting to the state; the
state does not allow for the City to continue to amass ATAX funds year after year.
Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee
January 4, 2011
Page 6 of 8
MOTION: Mr. Nelson moved to approve the financial statements as
presented; Ms. Russell seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
6. Old Business – None
7. New Business
Primarily for the benefit of the new memb ers of the Committee, Administrator Tucker
offered a couple of ideas to keep in mind when they are reviewing new applications that
include the following:
• The purpose for the investment of ATAX funds is “to generate tourism heads in
beds;” this is something that the entity requesting ATAX funds must justify in their
application.
• The role of the ATAX Committee is advisor y; any decision for the use of funds is
subject to Council approval. Council may increase or reduce an ATAX decision,
or Council may override a Committee decision to reject an application.
The City’s budget process begins in February with Capital Budgets; this Committee will
first see the ATAX budget in Ap ril. Certain exp enditures are attributed to ATAX funds
on the basis that the City would not need the added service or the type of equipment
were it not for the level of t ourism the City has, for example the additional staffing in the
Fire Department over the summer and the number of beach services officers.
In addition, Administrator Tucker cauti oned the members of the Committee about
electronic communications; a violation of the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) would
occur should a majority of the members engage in dialogue via emai l; in addition,
emails are subject to subpoena. Any su ch communication bet ween a majority of
members is considered to be a meeting that was not properly noticed to the general
public; therefore, it would not meet tr ansparency standards. The safest way to
communicate to the committee as a whole is via the City staff; they can disseminate
ideas, concepts, opinions, etc. with all of the Committee without risking violating any
regulations.
Ms. Russell asked whether a me mber of ATAX could email a member of City Council;
the Administrator responded that such a communication would be okay.
Chair Ferencz related going to the City’s website in search of the ATAX October
meeting minutes only to find that they were not available; she questioned whether City
Council had seen those unapproved Committee mi nutes. Assistant Dziuban explained
that Council does have access to the Committ ee’ minutes, but Council takes no action
on ATAX committee minutes. Council would only approve, disapprove or alter any
Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee
January 4, 2011
Page 7 of 8
decisions for funding that the ATAX committee has made in its meeting. Minutes are
only put on the City’s website after they have been approved by the Committee that
generated them.
Chair Ferencz noted that, if there was a seri ous error in the minutes, the Committee is
not aware of it and cannot correct for a period of ninety (90) days. Once that error gets
corrected, the Chair asked wh ether the corrected minutes we re again submitted to City
Council.
Administrator Tucker commented that, if the ATAX Committee took an action to approve
an application for funding or the ATAX budget, the item w ould appear on the Ways and
Means agenda and, then, City Council agenda. As seen from the number of staff
members attending ATAX meetings, staff always works to convey the sentiment of the
ATAX Committee to Council. In the past, a member of ATAX woul d attend the Ways
and Means meeting to answer any questions t hat Committee might have; that practice
could be re-initiated. In addition, the Ad ministrator said the ATAX Committee can hold
special meetings when the need arises, or the Committee could meet more frequently;
the meetings used to be held monthly, but there were many months when the
Committee did not have any business before it.
Chair Ferencz noted that the Committee does not receive a draft budget until its April
meeting and inquired if the ATAX budget went before Ways and Means in April, as well.
Administrator Tucker ex plained that Ways and Means will see the draft budget before
the ATAX Committee; when Ways and Means meets in April, they will be made aware
of the Committee’s approval/disapproval of or changes to the budget.
Since the budget process will be new to several on the Committee, the Chair asked that
Committee members receive the draft ATAX budget in March to give them time to study
and be ready to discuss in April.
In addition, Chair Ferencz aske d for staff to plan an ori entation session of the new
members of the Committee.
Assistant Dziuban encouraged members of the Committee to direct any questions on
the budget to staff before the April meeting; to do so would mean that the staff would be
better prepared at the meeting as well.
Administrator Tucker informed the Committee that the City’s budget is posted to the
website and added that she and the Treasurer consider t he annual budget to be their
work plan for the year.
Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee
January 4, 2012
Page 8 of 8
Prior to adjourning the meeting, Chair Fere ncz thanked the new members for agreeing
to serve on the ATAX Committ ee; she added that the task ma y seem difficult at times,
but it is always worthwhile.
One final question from Chair Ferencz wa s how the agenda was generated. According
to the Administrator, staff produces a dr aft agenda that is forwarded to the Chair for
approval. The Chair has the op portunity at this time to change or add to the agenda;
Administrator Tucker emphasized that the Committee Chair sets the meeting agenda.
8. Miscellaneous Business
Next Meeting Date: 11 a.m. , Wednesday, April 4, 2012
9. Adjourn
MOTION: Mr. Nelson moved to adj ourn the meeting at 12:10 p.m.; Ms.
Russell seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.